No More Learning

complained immediately
our Bryan, and Edward Fox, master William Paget
Tholouse, journey till had reparation for the wrongs Francis together readily promising his assist
protesting proceed “he would not
his (after)
being
sent Orleans and
and
done his person and dignity; that the peo ple were satisfied concerning certain scandalous rumours, which heard were scattered abroad
ance. And because our king had many agents about this time employed Italy, namely doctor Ra. Croke, man excellent the
the prejudice cardinal Woolsey and him Greek tongue) Padua; Hierome Ghi
self. But our king his Letter Oct. 22nd answered, That must not expected from him, præstare, quicquid vel vulgi temeritas ef
nucci, bishop Worcester, and Gregory Ca salis, Rome; doctor Stokesley Venice, Thomas Cranmer (afterwards abp Canter
future, vel quorundam nimiun fortasse scrupulo bury) Andreas and Johannes Casalis, and Pre
alone
was revoked the ments. Stokesley writ Letter dated June subjects acknowledge. ' Adding have concurred, had not the Pope contradicted.
anxia sedulitas designare soleat. As for videllus,
had enough while some laboured reconcile, and sometimes make use their various advertise
the jus legati pretended
king answered, “That
expired, not only
Pope's late Inhibition, but particularly the 13,) that had gotten the Opinions the interposition his own regal authority, which University Bononia; and that more would
violated, our times conceived, was again
did
it
heto
.
bybyit
to he in to I to
byI toall erbe(ato
of
he he
to
it as he
of
so
to to
it
as
ofto
of toof to
at to by it it,in So he
be
be so he a
as to19 to
sa to &
to
his totoaheattoinhe
of
he or to
to he
if
as
he he in all to ofor
no
toin by be he
of
as by so onof of
it ofhe
he
by toitis at at
in
as de
it,
he
he
to to of sit
so inof a
in all as It of toheat ofaat bebybya
: of
as
as it
(a to he he to in of to
a athetobeofheto
to in to hebe to of
do of so
;
to
the
ofat
dein
as
sir
in
ill :in he
it
so
of
in
toso
it soit;
of
of
as
a
to
ina he ofto in toin
341] STATE TRIALs, 19 Henry VIII. 152s-Divorce of Catharine of Arragon. [342
Croke said, the pope and emperor threatened jesty does only aim The reason why that subscribed favour the king's Cause. gave this for Answer, was, that certain
He writes also that the emperor's ambassador place, from whence have information Padua, challenged one frier Thomas, for fa designs and contrivances the Cesarians,
the
vouring the king's cause, and told him, this have certain intelligence and undoubted know
conclusion should take effect, many greatest princes Christendom should herited, taken illegitimate; accounting
the ledge, that this proposal was started, and dis promoted the Cesarians; but what their aim and design herein should be, dare not those well the emperor, the king Por certainly affirm, and therefore leave that
tugal. Notwithstanding which, had gotten wholly your highnesses great prudence and 80 principal mens hands good while since, consideration. And though told his holiness, and had obtained more, which yet their that could not venture write your ma means were burnt. By Letter also Crokes, jesty herein, yet was unwilling keep this Aug. 24, appears, that the emperor laboured from your majestics knowledge, that may with the State Venice, oppose the king appear, that care industry wanting
me execute your majesties commands, promote your services. have done which have been able with one Ancona, with sometimes small reward them when they whom have great intimacy. As which
his demand. Furthermore protested hone would take money (lawyers only excepted) for delivering their Opinions, though forced
had done. Which particular Dr. Stokesley (in refer the common letters. May God Dispatch Sept. 23, 1530) did confirm saying preserve your majesties health. Rome Sept. 18, was their manner both Padua and Bononia 1530. Your most excellent majesties most
refuse money with these words, Quod Spi obedient servant, GR roof CASA Lis. ”
rieu Sancto gratis accepimus, gratis libenter How this Letter was believed accepted impertimur. Moreover Croke Letter, yet, doth not appear me; that although Aug. 31, 1530, said, Caesar minis, precibus, pre Melancthon said have concurred some tio, sacerdotiis, partun territat nostros, par such opinion, effect followed thereof. For
tin confirmat suos certifying our king fur find, that this very time, king Henry, ther, that Andreas Casalis and Prevideolus did jealous the queen's, (as our Historians* reveal his highness secrets to the Cesarians: say) Woolsey’s procuring Bulls against him,
conclusion find that many would have given set forth this Proclamation, Sept. 19.
their opinion favour the Divorce, they “The king's highness streightly chargeth
durst. So that though the king's agents did
now and then differ some points, they
yet agreed that most the Learned Men
those parts would have favoured the king the purchase from the court Rome elsewhere, point his Divorce, had not the pope and em nor use and put execution, divulge pub peror oppugned Croke adds further, that the
emperor got some hands Mantua for money, but they were the meaner sort. Whereas doctors that place had freely subscribed his highness part. Now, Gregory Casalis
seemed among his highness agents, this time, the most industrious, solicited the
Pope continually our king's behalf, not neg lecting also the Cesarians, whom gave, and from whom received that intelligence,
made advantage all. By which dan gerous and suspected wisdom yet prevailed
far, that length had authority,
seems, write this following Dispatch, which
have caused faithfully transcribed out the original.
lish any thing heretofore within this year pass ed, purchased, purchased hereafter, containing matter prejudicial the high au thority, jurisdiction and prerogative royal
this his said realm, the let, hindrance, impeachment his graces noble and virtu ous intended purposes the premisses; upon
pain incurring his highness indignation, and imprisonment, and farther punishment their
bodies, for their doing, the dreadful example
Declaration the House Thus did the king begin
Romish yoke; which was much animated the concurrence his subjects Parlia
“Most serene and most powerful lord, and ment, both spiritual and temporal, who (as
my most gracious sovereign, whom health appears our records) July this year under and happiness, and the most humble acknow their hands and seals sent Declaration the
ledgments my duty and affection. Some Pope. The tenor whereof this;
days agoe the Pope private offered me “To the most holy lord, our lord and father this Proposal, thing which made Christ Clement, the Divine providence
much account, that your majesty might have the seventh pope that name, we wish and Dispensation have two wives; pray for perpetual felicity our Lord Jesus
whom answered, that was very un Christ, with humility throwing our selves willing take upon me write your his feet. Most blessed father, although the majesty know your majesties pleasure Cause concerning the Marriage the most in herein, because that did not know whether vincible prince our sovereign lord the king this proposal would satisfie your conscience, England and France, defender the faith, and the ease and quiet whereof, was what your ma lord Ireland, does for sundry great, and
and commandeth, that manner person
what estate, degree, condition soever they purchase attempt
his graces pleasure, other. ”
Lords
shake off the
the
_* Pope.
of
of or of
by ofto
to
I
to
of
of
oror or to
is toto I
of at
it of to
orin
it of
is I I
a ofIso as on29 toita in in all he &
toItoof as
to of at
in
I
a it or
to
inall in in by to or heof
II I
as
in
of
Ito : 30in
a
he on all
it.
of
asof
in ofin of a toheofin ina
toI of to be
to so as he
on to
as
of
he all toto
as it
a& ; he of heat inif &
byofbeofif in
he
by he he
all of be is no by tosooforinof, atno
of todoto I byofor toorI
in in to be a he ofat
I inisofall or Y Iof
at.
of no or
to to so of
to
into of in allall to of or
in a
I.
343] STATE TRIALS, 19 IIesty VIII. 152s. Proceedings relating to the [344
weighty reasons of itself, require and demand and powerful adversaries, till withstood
your holinesses assistance, that it may be brought to that speedy end and determination,
and opposed their des? partly his sword,
partly pen, other times com mands and authority, supporting that power
the church from whence obtain those mighty ad now finds himself only
which we with so great and earnest desires
have wished, and with so very great, though and authority
very vain expectations have long looked for from your holiness: we could not nevertheless
prevail with our selves to keep silence herein any longer, especially since our kingdom and
the affairs thereof suffer so much, and are
brought into so great danger through the un
justice of the cause it self, approved of by the riage, nor will that possible, unless your Opinions of the most Learned Men every holiness will your authority, pronounce the
same Sentence concerning his former Marri age, which many Learned Men have already delivered. But your holiness, whom we
seasonable delay of Sentence herein : so that
since his majesty our head, and by consequence
the life of us all, and we in his words, as sub
ject members, by a just union annexed to the
head, have with great earnestness prayed your for virtues, scated npon the throne his holiness, but prayed in vain, we are by the ancestors, right undoubted and unquestion greatness of our grief, forced separately and able, who would entail lasting peace, and unin distinctly by these our Letters, most humbly to terrupted tranquillity realms, leaves intreat your speedy determination hereof. Be son succeed him from lawful and true Mar
where, and determined by the Decrees of the
most famous Universities in the world, and
esteemed and judged most righteous by
persons either England, France, Italy, justly call our Father, shall refusing com who are most eminent for their learning, might ply herein, esteem cast-aways, and resolve
confirm that Sentence which has
determination this Cause piece jus we beg your holiness, without delay, farther tice done that king and kingdom, which loss time, assist these his majesty's most upon many several accounts have deserved just and reasonable desires, we most earnestly well the Apostolical See; although entrea intreat confirmation the judgment these
ties you herein seem not necessary, however we make them, persons overborn with troubles, who indulge their grief, and fre
most Learned Men, humbly imploring, that for the sake that mutual love, and that paternal affection which your pastoral office requires you
Quently pour forth repeated and unnecessary shew us, not shut your bowels pity
prayers. But since your holiness not
and compassion against us, your most dutiful, most loving, most obedient sons. The Case his most sacred majesty, the case all,
continued requests the best princes, must bear part, the grief arising herefrom, and
that which might expected from your pater the injury suffered hereby does equally affect us,
prevailed upon, either
Cause, the remembrance
you have always found,
the justice the
others are enabled
vantages from which
excluded. What answer can be made hereto
we see not, and yet we see that from hence flood miseries flowing upon the com monwealth, and sort deluge calamities overwhelming us, from the disputes about Suc cession, which will soon overtake us, never
settled without infinite slaughter and effusion blood. We now have king most eminent
far prevail, that your holiness, though body entreated nay, though some opposed
should with your own voice and authority,
leave construction
committed
orphans; we can make no other but that the care ourselves our own hands, and that we
universally
been pronounced just, especially when your we may never driven these extremities,
are left seek our remedy elsewhere. But that
the good services
the earnest and since the head cannot suffer but the members
mal love and affection alone, our grief the who bear our proportion majesties af
remembrance of our miseries and calamities flictions; the remedy which, must pro encreased that immense degree, that ceed wholly from your holiness's power overspreads the whole body the realm, and duty necessarily arising from your paternal gives voice complaint each member authority and affection: Which remedy, your
forcing them both their words, and holiness shall refuse delay grant, our con their letters, lay before your holiness this dition will indeed herein be more miserable, that their insupportable grievance. For how great long we have fruitlessly and vain sought
misfortune that what our own two Uni redress, but will not wholly desperate,
versities, the University Paris, well since possible find relief some other way.
many other France, what almost men Desperate remedies indeed are not without ex learning, knowledge and integrity, both tremity applied; but that sick, will home and abroad have determined and affirmed any means get rid his distemper; the
true, and the truth which they are rea change our miseries there some comfort, defend and support both their discour when we cannot obtain perfect relief, yet we ses and writings; yet cannot confirmation may change our condition for that which less
this universally acknowledged truth ob afflicting and more tolerable. That your holi tained from the holy apostolical see that ness would pleased take these things into prince, whose support and assistance that your most serious consideration, we again and see still keeps and preserves authority, which again beseech you, for our lord Jesus Christ's bas been shakon and undermined many, sake, whose vicar earth you stile yourself,
by so
bybe of
allas is
or
on
us to at toof of of asbeon ofhe
its
is ain of a
by
be
beit
ofso by his toto by
so
to
a
to of
by
to
is be so
dyto to be
a
it,
a ofso
it, so
of
by of
or of by
as
ifit of to is
aof tohis of so
in
it,
to
to
is
to
of
of
it,as
by to ofto at ofas in of it do be
no
all
is he
in
by
in
to
do is it
to or be
to beit,if aisof
is in if so it
of
to a
be of
of bysoaofto istoaofbe
to
a of us
by
of is up all
to
his a
is,
as his
of if of bybyhe
of of is us
of or
to he
his
in
sol STATE TRIALs, 19 Hoso, viii. 1828–Divorce of calarine of Arragon. (310
and that you would now conform your actions two grievous offences, ingratitude to his high to that title by pronouncing your sentence to ness, and denial of justice. We do acknow the glory and praise of God, and thereby giv ledge that your king has deserved that your ing your testimony and sanction to that truth Letter mentions, nay, even much mure, that which has been examined, approved, and after the remembrance his many meritorious ac much deliberation confirmed by the most Learn tions towards the Apostolical See, will not only ed Men of all nations. In the mean time we live fresh our memories, but be traitsuitted
will beseech God, whom we infallibly know to down late posterity. We cannot but own be truth, that he would vouchsafe so to inform likewise, that not only with respect our and direct your holiness's deliberations, herein, office and character the Church, but also that having by your holiness's authority, a con our own private person, we owe much firmation of what is just, righteous and true, highness's affection, we shall scarce ever
Shrewsbury, Hen. Essex, Edw. Derby, H. Worcester, Tho. Rutland, Hen. Cumberland, Robert Sussex, Geo. Huntington, G. of Kil dare. —Bishops; Robert Cicestrens. Joh. Car liolens. Joh. Lincoln, Rich. Menevensis—Ba rons; Hen. Montague, G. Rochford, W. Wes ton, E. Abergavenny, J. Audley, Hen. Scroope,
we may therein rest sauisfied, and be free from able sufficiently recompence. As what the trouble of seeking to attain this end by other relates the controversy concerning the Mar means. (Signed) Archbishops; T. Cardinalis riage between his highness and queen Cathe Ebor, Willielmus Can. —Dukes; Tho. Norfolk, rine, we have been far from disappointing Char. Suffolk. -Marquesses; T. Dorset, H. the king's expectation therein denying him Exeter. —Earls; W. Arundel, Jo. Oxenford, justice, that we have even lain under the cen H. Northumberland, Rauf. Westmeriand, Geo.
Latimer, Edw. Stourton, Jo. Fitzwarren, Jo.
Semers, Jo. Lumley, W. Mountjoy, Chris.
Coniers, Hen. Daubeny, T. Darcy, T. Mon
tegle, W. Sandys, Jo. Husey, Andr. Windsor. —
Abbots; Jo. of Westminster, Jo. of Bury St.
Edmund, Rich. Glaston, Will. Gloucester, Tho. both your kingdom, and upon the spot
Jo. of Peterburgh, Jo. of Ramsey, Jo. of Croy we were able, we satisfied his highness's de land, Ro. of Thorney, Ro of Selby, W. abbot sires. But when the queen began suspect
of Bardney, W. abbot of St. Benet de Hulmo, them partial judges, and the account Tho. ab. of St. John by Colchester, Jo. ab. of some grievances she had imposed her the Hyde, Clem. ab. of Evesham, Ric, ab. of said legates, had appealed from them the
of Abendon, Hugh of Reading, Edw. of York, examine into the matter; whereby, far
Malmsbury, Ric. ab. of Winchelcomb, Rob.
ab. St Crucis de Waltham, Jo, ab. of Circes
ter, Hen. abbot of Teuxbury. —Knights and
Doctors in parliament; W. Fitz-William, Hen.
Guildford, Steph. Gardiner, Jo. Gage, W. For although we could not this Cause deny
Kingston, Bryan Tuke, Rich. Sacheverell. Rich. the queen Commission Appeal, yet seek
Sampson, Edw. Lee, Rich. Woolman, Jo. Bettat. ”
“To our Venerable Brethren the archbishops and bishops, and to our beloved sons the abbots, noblemen, dukes, marquisses, earls,
barons, knights and doctors assembled toge
ther in Parliament in England : Clement VII.
Pope. Venerable brothers and beloved sons,
health be to you, and apostolical benediction
There are many expressions in your Letter,
bearing date July 13, which we received some
days ago, which we could not have thought vote the Cardinals was concluded, that well of, did we not wholly impute them to the Commission Appeal this Cause could great duty and tender affection which you bear not
sure the other party, and have been thought partial, and too much inclined favour his majesty's desires herein. But give more undeniable proof our constant affection your king, will necessary mention what has some time since passed When first, about three years since, majesty's ambassadors laid this Cause before us, rather seeking redress herein from our affection and kindness his
tice, we committed the determination
our beloved sons, Thomas abp. York our le gate England, cardinal Sancae Caecilia, and
Laurence Campejus, cardinal Sanctae Mariae transtiberim our legate later who were
Apostolical Tribunal, and had her part ap
pointed proctors prosecute the said Appeal
his
Tho. Dacres, Tho. La-Ware, W. Dacre, Tho.
Barkley, Hen. Morley, Geo. Cobham, Rich. highness, than from the rigorous course jus
to our most dear son in Christ your king. We
shall therefore without taking these things
amiss, sedately answer your Letter, that you cases we ought proceed with the greatest may thereby learn with how little reason you caution, ought we more especially
have complained of us, and that your private that which concerns the majesties kings and
duty and affection to your king, ought not to queens, which we see the eyes
extend so far, as to justify your excusing us of Christian world placed. Since which law
Rome, even then our great inclination his majesty's service was sufficiently evidenced.
ing rather that this controversy might finish the agreeable methods peace and con cord, than course law, we framed seve
ral delays granting our Commission Ap
peal the said Cause, under pretence that
this being cause the highest nature, must
therefore brought before the Consistory.
After this we held frequent consultation with our most venerable brethren their Eminences
the Cardinals, whereby this affair was still far ther put off; till length the unanimous
refused. was therefore appointed examined, heard, and the said Consistory,
finally determined. For
the
on
so
all
bea inby a
in of it
in
of
of
all
of to do
as be to as a
in totoby to to\
bybe a ed at
us be of in by
to asin toto
be
to It at
in it
of
of
to
beof to
of
in ofin de :
by of on to
onone,of tobyso
to
noall of of to
in all to of asto of to be in .
it his so asin to
to
347] STATE TRIALS, 19 HENRY VIII. 152S. –Proceedings relating to [348
ful proctor has appeared the king's part, set forth bis majesty's pretensions either writing, word mouth, from whence
that this Cause could not yet receive de termination. Since must be decided accord
demand that we should rashly, and without due consideration, determine any thing herein
his highness, yet ing what alledged, and witnesses executing Judgment we must necessarily much oved; not according favour and affection. more regard him, ‘by whom Kings reign and
confirm our au Decrees many Universities: which words thority, truth concerning the former Marri seem not proceed from your usual pru age, which many Learned Men the
dence and modesty; since we see not with kingdom agreed upon we are truly willing
what reason you can desire, that we should cause the greatest moment give Sentence,
though none entreated nay, though some
opposed it; when the other side alledged stroy that authority, would we should the great scandal and offence that Chris judicially give sentence contrary the usual tians would take, Sentence Divorce methods and due course law any thing, from Marriage which has continued many though might appear never plain and years, which was contracted Dispensation manifest us. As for what you mention from the Holy See, the request his most the end your Letter, that unless we grant excellent majesty Henry and the most Ca your request herein, you shall imagine that the tholick king Ferdinand; from whence the care yourselves remitted into your own queen has had many children born, and still hands, and that you are left liberty seek has daughter living; contrary the opinion remedy herein elsewhere; this resolution
several doctors (which you urge also your neither worthy your prudence, nor becoming behalf) and those very learned and grave men, your Christianity; and we therefore our and who confirm their judgment both the fatherly love, exhort you abstain from any laws God, and arguments taken not only such rash attempt: though would no from the Latins, but likewise derived from the fault the physician, the patient weary of Jewish law Notwithstanding which, we his distemper, should rashly and unadvisedly kept ourselves unbiassed, inclined favour venture upon measures destructive his health; neither side, but hear both, looking this we indeed never denyed you such remedies most extraordinary Cause, not only concern might with safety given, and with advantage the whole Christian world, but also belong received “for who weak, and am not weak,
who offended, and burn not? ' write not
these things shame you, but my beloved
sons warn you. We cannot imagine that his majesty, whose account you write, can ap prove your writing this manner; for we know, and are fully acquainted with his ho
those men, alledging reasons for their De nour and integrity, that we are assured
posterity. As for the opinions Learned Men, and the Decrees Universities
which you mention, few
our notice, shewn your ambassadors, nor
them have come not proper form
the name the king exhibited, and those were but bare opinions
terminations, nor supporting them any authority from Scripture, the Canons, which herein ought only prevail. Wherefore,
would not accept any thing that unjust, although were offered him; and although your intercession cases great power
his majesty's favour, itself, nor agreeable
thing neither righteous your wisdom. For
although we owe much
reason why this deferring Princes decree Justice;’ and further, the determination, which you duty good Father, take care that by
There therefore our sentence complain, should
complaint herein seems the more strange, children: besides, we should not only
because his majesty's ambassadors several our own, but also his highness's conscience, by
places, particularly Bononia, did request and solicit this delay Sentence from us, contrary the inclination and demand the queen's proc tors herein. Since therefore we have ways occasioned these delays, hindred this Cause from being determined, after mature examina tion, and due consideration all the circum stances we see not on what reasons these your complaints are grounded; unless you will venture say, that the services which his ma
jesty has shewn us, and the Apostolical See, are
such, that the Cause should be, determined
his favour, without regard had either right justice; for that must the meaning your words, when you say that Sentence ought
given us, though nobody entreated nay, though some opposed this case, which has been adjudged just the Learn England, France and Italy, and the
ascribed us, and your over fondness, not too much indulge
. .
ties, which you fear impending over your kingdom, sure were much more feared,
such hasty and inconsiderate Sentence, which thus unduly given, would dan gerous example, greatly dainage the whole Christian
As for that
deluge
calami
we should rashly hasten that Sentence which ought calmly proceed the strait way jus tice and reason, thereby violating both our own duty, and departing from the rules justice through too great favour and affection your king; you cannot with more earnest desires wish his majesty son, than we do, and that not only his highness, but Christian princes
had sons like great king, the inheritors not only their realms, but such princely vir
o:
tues, but we are not we can give children. that we were unwilling
the stead God, that. As what you say,
gratify his highness things wherein we are able our authority, but then our ability cannot extend those things which will de
to
to by
aton at a
it of
to
of
byto
of
its to if in
or
no us inof
7,
it,
by byit
to to orus on
it
on
to
of
to to
of
ofallis
by
in
be ofof
of
all
to
allin
to in
of
I is
to of a to ed it,to or all ofa a usinbe
is is
to
.
of
so
to
by
of
of is atbeno
byonbyonso tono by
of
isso oftosoa he
;
of
of it to
by is a by
of
ifan
of a
of
so
to of it,
or by
in
of in
to
itinto
to it
all if itin; is a
in of Iisbe is in
do
is
todo
of asIitisat
is
by
of beofby
it is
I to he as
a
be of to
of
to
the
in
hi\
in in
as in a
of all so in to if
to
of
to all
in
to
to to
in
to of
its
so
to
349] STATE TRIALS, 19 HENRY VIII. 152s. —Divorce of Catharine of Arragon. [350
and prevalence with us, yet is our love and as yet, but that his own Universities of Oxford and
fection to his highness such, as to need neither Cambridge could have sufficiently decided the the entreaty nor solicitation of any persons point, but that he might the more amply satisfy whatever, to influence or quicken and himself and the world. ” Whereupon Bryan we never remember that his highness has ever Tuke was commanded take out, and read the yet made his request us, and received Determinations the Universities Paris, denial, where could granted with safety Orleans, Angiers, Bourges Berry, and Tho our own, and the honour the Apostolical louse France, and Bononia and Padua,
See, we shall always shew him the same re Italy, who
gard and good will. Lastly, the present Cause, we shall give hindrance delay
decision, that when ready for Exami
nation, and all the circumstances have were exhibited. The perusing which yet been heard, shall brought speedy de (the day being far spent) was referred fur termination, and final conclusion; being ear ther time. As also the Resolution of our two
nestly desirous free your king and queen, Universities (brought after the rest our king)
and our ownselves from this most troublesome affair. But this we must desire his highness,
which because Sanders calls sort surrepti tious, shall relate out some Original pieces which have seen.
To the University Oxford, the bishop Lincoln was employed, where, neither easily, nor general vote, there past this Decree,
and your goodness, that you would not re
quire more from us, reason his majesty's
great deservings us, than we can without of
fending God perform and then you may as
sure yourselves the good offices which April 1530.
can expected from us, considering the person and office we bear, and the justice we are in
dispensably bound administer. Given St. Peter's, Rome, under the Seal the Fiso
“We John Cotisford, commissary the University Oxford, the authority, and with the consent of the whole venerable Con vocation, declare, determine and adjudge,
-*
agreed declaring the Marriage After which, above hundred
several doctors, (whereof Dr. Cran-
unlawful.
Books
mer was one) confirming the same Opinion,
erman, Sept. 27, 1530, Pontificat. ”
The Chancellor's Speech
specting
The former proceedings king Henry, being the Question lately propounded his
advertised the Pope, made him fear defection our king. Insomuch, that
total most excellent majesty the king, which shall
Rome
the 7th year our that the major part the doctors, masters, well regents non-regents faculties the Commons re this famous University, have agreed and
given their consent and assent, that the De the Divorce. termination, Resolution, and final Answer
they studied nothing more than how
him his ancient devotion some arguments
whereof have been formerly mentioned. To and accounted the Determination, Resolution, the furthering which intention also did and final Answer this whole University, and not little conduce, that had taken some therefore that may lawful for the com distaste against the emperor: who, being desired missary and the proctors affix the common
retain
the major part them, esteemed
received some satisfaction the affair of the the University, the bishop Lincoln. As Divorce, had not his Parliament, this time, for the University Cambridge, find Stephen as above-said, concurred the setting Gardiner, and Edward Fox were employed; the regal authority ecclesiastical affairs. To where, notwithstanding the king's Letters, and whom therefore thought communicate the diligence used their part, not few what his agents Italy and other places had difficulties did occur. Insomuch that was done, concerning that much controverted first denyed, then the voices both sides were point the lawfulness Marriage. Where brought even, and last, (some absenting upon, the parliament yet sitting, the lord chan themselves) was agreed, that the question cellor, accompanied with Dr. Stokesley bishop should disputed delegates, and that of London, and divers other lords spiritual and
temporal, came into the Lower-House, 31st
March 1531, and told them “That they could not ignorant, how the king, having narried
two parts three should determine it; which
his brother's wife, was and therefore had sent
Fo Christendom, versities
troubled conscience, the most learned Uni resolved that
accordingly was done favour the king, by the vice-chancelior, and the two proctors,
ten doctors, and fifteen others, whose names are extant the same Record. Which averseness, more than foreign Universities,
oint: and namely had employed the bishop
present, purpose. Not, there for this
the Pope scrupulosity
England, conscience,
the
more than will
given the doctors and bachelors the faculty divinity, chosen for that purpose,
appoint certain judges determine dif seal the University the Decree, which
ferences betwixt him and the duke Ferrara, shall made
concerning Modena and Reggio, chose such termination. ”
pursuance their said De
sentenced on the duke's behalf; which in Which Copy, though blurred (upon what oc
censed the Pope that fell from the em casion know not, for not probable
peror. For which reason also probable, should intended the king that manner)
that our king might have closed with him, and was dispatcht the day following, the Act
whether should attributed
power their particular
it of in
be of it
ofby
do of
all
in
in to
to ofso he in it
to be
;
his
fit to in to
to he
:
of to
is as of to
in
all
up so it
to at a
of
be
byat on
to
of
of
in
of
a or of
it; toa as
of ofas of
at in as
to
in
it
ofby of33as
inhe
of of
in
itoff at is
of of
to
beI beof
or be
by byIIin
of
it
in
of inof to
to
its
isa beofso beof in
of
to
to all; by be no beto
it to be of
or to in
in
in 28
isto
I ita
is to
in a
to of
of be to all
to of a
on
I of in as
-ofit a
in to of
J|
in
us
by of
to a
of sir
all by
of
4,
of
it
so
it
351] STATE TRIALS, 19 HENRY VIII. 152S. –Proceedings relating to the [352
determine; though, on this occasion, I can do should question And, whereas for quieting no less, that repeat some arguments drawn (in the king's conscience, you would have me put favour of the Divorce) out of our Records. 1. the business eight lords; that which say, The place in Leviticus, chap. xviii. vers. 16. pray God send his grace quiet consci ‘Thou shalt not uncover the nakedness of thy ence. As for answer your message; pray
brother's wife. ' 2, Basil's Opinion, tending this way, where saith, “that shall excommunicated that marrieth his wife's sister. ’
Because two Epistles, transcribed out the Pope's Registers, and sent into England
Dr. Stokesly (whereof one was Gregory, the
other Innocent the 3rd) profess, that the Pope cannot dispense against the law God,
the particular case being then Marriage.
That granting the Pope can dispence, urgen
tissima causa, with that which erjure divino, against you, since his grace having used (which yet divines for the most part deny) there means clear his own, and subjects insatis was occasion here, since the peace betwixt factions, concerning the lawfulness his Mar England and Spain, which was taken the riage, you yet continue refractory that vio ground the Breve) stood firm and intire. lent manner, you not only refuse the general Lastly, that the Jews themselves (for our Determinations Universities, and Learned agents consulted with them also) did not hold Men; but contrary the laws the land, the law marrying the brother's wife, (Deut. and the royal dignity, have cited high 25. ) necessary this time, but did often ness appear the Court Rome; neither
pati discalceationem. All which being ma have those many admonitions you have re turely considered the Lower-House, made ceived concerning the danger and consequences them detest the Marriage, our IIistorians Jereof, been able divert you from your pur have Whereupon the king thought also poses, reduce you reason and your duty.
prorogue the parliament, the intent that Of which therefore his highness sensible, every man repairing hone, might satisfy his that hath forborn late see your grace,
neighbour these passages; not omitting, to receive your tokens, giving you
gether,
cause these foreign Determinations, ther, repair either manner
published this year, the Estainsteed, the Monastery print shews. Notwith for, since you were known
fur Oking, Bisham;
printed and Book yet extant
his brother far was the king from remit prince Arthur, you cannot his lawful wife. ” his gentle behaviour the To which the virtuous and sorrowful queen queen, that, had not forborn come her replied little more than this “That what bed, neither could his outward favour towards place soever she removed, nothing could re
standing which, ting any thing
her, her fashions towards him, have argued move her from being the king's wife. ” And any diminution love; those wonted cere here the king bid her final farewel: for, from monies which they sustained the dignity this time, being July the 14th, find not the their place, and civilities which might imply king ever saw her more.
mutual respect, continuing firmly either side. The Pope's Leiter persuade the King take
Which our historians amplify far, that they say sore lamented his chance, and made
manner mirth pastime was wont do; without yet that they can thought
his Wife again.
And now queen Catherine her proctor Rome, assisted with the advice and power the imperialists, negotiated puissantly with the
speak improbably, when we consider both how Pope; that, notwithstanding our king's in dear this liberty cost him, and how much en dignation for her prosecuting him this
dangered the Succession. However, that manner, she urged still the Appeal, beseeching might both prevail himself the occasion, and the Pope cite the king, himself proctor,
also satisfy the doubts had raised, not his appear. But the Pope thought own alone, but subjects breasts, sent gently thus exhort our king
rather take again the fol
queen Catherine some lords his council, his wife Catherine; which wishing them acquaint her with these Deter lowing Letter
minations (which also find had been shewed
the Pope,) and together demand her CLEMENT VII. Pope. quieting the king's conscience, and ending this “To our most dear son
business, whether she would rather refer herself and apostolical benediction.
the Judgment four spiritual, and four tem tender affection towards you, for the sake of
poral lords this kingdom, stand her both your honour here, and your salvation Appeal. To which the sad queen answered, hereafter, should glad find false, has “That her father, before consented her been reported us, and many hands con second marriage, had taken the advige firined, concerning your highness, that although doctors, and clerks, whose opinion she believed not only before, but since the Controversy has rather than any others; and that, the Pope been depending about the lawfulness the having confirmed she wondered that any Marriage Contract between yourself, and our
you tell the king, am his lawful wife, and will abide, till the court Rome determine the contrary. ” But our king, who alledged
his proceedings were according the law
God (which therefore said should more
insisted on, than any other authority) sent other messengers, exhorting her still con form herself; among whom one spake this effect: “Madam, you cannot ignorant how much you have provoked the king's displeasure
did
#.
Christ, &c. health What our
it,
of
of
of
for
to to
he
totono
a of
be
he
to or
all
to
to
toto as
fit
as
erof 4,
of by
we to
to : to
be
a toofto to his
in
ofby to ofof of
to
to to he or be
3, of
by in by to
I by is
be to a
of in
in to to ofat
his
all toto fit
be
I I of so
to
ofso he in
I he of
he
St.
in
fitor
ofof so
of
in of
of
as so behe on
to as
is a do
of he
in it
he
so
to
to
or
byin
t
or or
to he or
to
is, I
to
or
to
of
he to toheby:betoof of
it. as
no
in to
to
as
of Iit.
353] STATE TRIALS, 19 Henry VIII. 1528. —Dizorce of Catharine of Arragon. [354
most dear daughter in Christ, the most excellent
Catherine queen of England; you entertained
the said Catherine in your palace, and lived
with her as your queen and wife, as it was fit bad they are represented
ting you should do; yet now of late you have that you yourself would take such care, your not only removed her from your person and singular wisdom, that nobody may this thing court, but have banished her from the city, the have occasion speak your highness, usual place of her residence, and sent her to whose virtues have other your actions another place, taking in her room publicly to been conspicuous. For any catholic
your bed and conversation, a certain lady Anne,
us; and farther,
his great grief, any heretic his mighty joy,
with whom you cohabit, and to whom you shew
that conjugal love and affection, which is only
due to your wife, the said queen. Which whom you married, the daughter king, the
thing, most dear son, if it be true, and you
would lay aside carnal affections, and give
yourself leisure to think, we doubt not but that,
although we were silent herein, you would soon
perceive upon how many several accounts it is
unworthy your highness, either as it is a great sation, but also contrary contempt of our Judgment and Sentence, which
you thus refuse to stay for, as it is a publick
bition; he cannot but
this judgment the best
one that little regards the authority the Church, and nothing values the public peace, than which we are satisfied nothing can far ther from your highness's will and intention; insomuch that should any one your kingdom dare this which reported your high ness, we surely know that you would far from approving, that you would most surely
scandal to the Church, or as it is a manifest
kings, that
violation of the public peace; which things are contrary the principles virtuous and religious prince, we have always esteem
your highness, that though they have daily
more and more been confirmed unto us, yet we have found great difficulty believe them, things wholly repugnant your nature, and
see what measures will most proper for
take. We wish, dear son, that these things were false,
we have said, least not
should hear that you have now removed afar off from your bed and presence, your queen
aunt the emperor, and king the Romans, after she had lived with you more than twenty years, and had several children you; that you have openly taken another woman your
ed, not only without our licence and dispen
our express prohi some measure make
your usage. For what punish Wherefore, my son, we most
well defended the power the sword, and trious your highness, are looked upon
the strength argument, our most holy faith marks and patterns whereto others may direct and the catholic Church Surely the public their aim, and whereby they may form their Peace and tranquillity have prince our practice. Nor ought your highness neglect age, been more carefully preserved than you, the common safety, and overlook the peace and who piously undertoo! , war for the Church, tranquillity Christendom, which the best gloriously prosecuted and length for the princes have never failed pay, duty sake public peace and quiet desisted from bound, regard. Nor ought you, my son,
from whence your highness has been justly offer this injury the most serene princes, the esteemed the arbiter peace and common emperor and the king the Romans, the said concord among Christian princes; wherefore quéen Catherine's nephews, who have never when we hear these strange things concerning given you offence, thus proceeding before you, raiseth both our admiration, and en your Cause determined, thereby disturbing creaseth our grief, that this one action yours, that universal peace among Christian Princes,
true, should cast blemish upon the wherein alone our safety from the Turks con
glory your former life and behaviour. Where sists; lest you give occasion much scandal
perfectly contrary
can more unnatural your integrity,
you, less agreeable certainly believe that your knowledge
one hand, both your informed herein, ought your practice
your ambassadors, inplore such, not give occasion scandalous re
letters and
our assistance determining your Cause, and ports; especially these dangerous times, on the other, your actions judge and which abound with heresies, and other most decide your ownself? contemn the au grievous calamities, lest what you do, should thority the Church such proceeding, grow precedent and example for others; for how unlike the actions him, who has the actions princes, especially those illus
the Church, and great danger, the Christian world, and provoke the Almighty by matter this weight with neglect, we far, change the great blessings has
tore we could not but enquire into the truth hereof more carefully, and ought not pass
were willing send you this kind admonition,
long poured down upon you into bitterness and affliction. We therefore of our tender
loving and affectionate father, before we
are forced deal with you the severer love and affection exhort you, and our pa
methods impartial judge. The high dig your majesty, your most deserving ser vices us, and our most tender love and af
ternal duty, warn you, my son, that the sake that kind indulgence and favour which we have always shewn, and shall continue ever shew you, unless you hinder us, that, these things true, that tarnish your former repu.
fection you, makes choose act towards
you, with respect and gentleness the per
son kind parent, and long lay aside our tation piety and glory, you yourself would office Judge, till your Letters we shall amend them affectionately taking again
Vol.
rightly
i. a
to
of anto
ofit
2 A
asoas to
of so
of as a
toof
a
as ofbe
it
of
be
so
byus
ofbe by
as
to is
a
as it. of of to
do
to
.
he
to as be is to sous
all
is it
in by by
in
of
if ityofa it
byso
to
as
ed
to of
so a byToto
to in
to
of to a
to of soso
in
of
to as
forof
as to
is
to
byof it,
by
so of
of
is
of
toto
to
to toifof oras
of byto
ofit,a by to
to
at no
of ofa
or
to
all
on
to
as
of
by in in
to
or
to
be
if hein in so to so beof to of
so
of
in to
allill be
in
asof bya in
of of
at
35. 5]
STATE TRIAs. S. , 19 HENRY VIII. 1528. -Proceedings relating to the [356
yourself your queen Catherine, by giving her any man had much married two sisters,
the honour and respect due to a queen, and the first were carnally known. But for the bro the tenderness and affection due to wife : and ther marry the brother's wife was abhorred
by removing the said lady Anne from your among nations, that never heard any
bed and conversation, so long at least till your Christian did but himself; and therefore o Cause shall be determined, and we have given wished them to believe that his conscience was
Sentence herein. Which, although it be no troubled. ” -
more than your duty, and what will greatly While these things thus passed, king Henry conduce to your honour, and advance your commands his agents Rome, (the bishop glory; yet we shall take as a great mark of Worcester and Gregory Casalis) present your highness's respect and good will towards
us. For as our most earnest desire is always
to preserve in you your good esteem of us, and
your customary duty and affection to the apos Rome, offer disputation for the same. To tolical See, which in your regard and your second this again, king Henry Jan. 1532, actions, you have never failed to shew : so we sends William Bennet, doctor law, Rome. cannot without the greatest grief betake our with instructions this purpose. But because
selves to the sharper remedies of Justice; to which the indignity offered to our own person herein, which we can willingly pass by, could
never prompt us, nor indeed can any thing
force us to but the honour Almighty ther about February, Edward Karne, doctor God, the advancement the public good, and law, his excusator; and remonstrate,
the salvation your immortal soul, our that his grace not bound law appear
Nuntio with you has orders more fully ac But the Pope making difficulty
admit this the Consistory,
whether ought heard
time being spent herein, the queen's agents re quire the Pope proceed the principal Cause. the meanwhile our king, sir Francis Bryan, importunes Francis intercede
But the Pope had good Answer thereunto; for him with the Pope who, thereupon by for the people for the most part exclaimed Letter, dated March 16, insorins his holiness, against the match (as our Historians relate) that the request the king England just, the king would have found perchance some dif. and ought relieve him. Or else they two ficulty appease their scruples, when otherwise (being une mesme chose, and who have well
could have satisfied his own. The queen deserved him) shall forced seek such wanted not yet those who defended her Cause other remedies, shall not please him,’ &c. publickly, both Books and Sermons (of whom To enforce this most earnest Letter, Francis the chief were Thomas Abel, her chaplain, and sends Gabriel Grammont, bishop Tarbe,
quaint your highness. Given Peter's
excusator, was disputed
under the Seal the 9th year
the Fisherman, Jan. 25, 1532, our Pontificat. ”
the House Commons peti
no? But much
unto the Pope the Opinion divers famous lawyers, favour his Cause; procuring also
learned inen from parts Italy, come
was found, that, the continual intercession the queen and emperor, the Pope intended
shortly cite the king appear Rome, ei
ther person proxy; dispatches thi
moved,
tion the King take his Wife again.
-
`-- Temse, the Lower House Parliament, who committed for maintaining the papal authority,
motioned that they should Petition the king and that another priest (being put prison take his queen again; which being advertised the abp. Canterbury for favouring Luther)
our king, sent for Thomas Audley, the after had appealed the king tanquam Do
John Fisher, bishop Rochester) and privately
discourse, (especially women) though not suf ing continually urged
ficiently either clear objections, re proceed against the king, and hearing besides, move king from his affection Mrs. Anne first, the Prohibition Annates above men Bolen. Among which must not forget one tioned, and afterwards that certain priest was
Speaker the House, and told him this ef. fect: That marvelled any among them should meddle businesses which could not
properly determined there. As for this par ticular, that concerned his soul much, that many times wished the Marriage had been
good, but since the Doctors the Universities had generally declared unlawful, could
minum Supremum, was set liberty, proceeds" Citation; and calling Consistory, July
commits the hearing the Cause Paulus de Capisucci, dean the Ruota, and appoints the month October 1532, for the king's appear ance, protesting alioqui procedetur, &c. the mean time, writes our king, certifying him what was done, yet omitting the Clause
less than abstain from her company. Which alloqui procedetur, intreating him further therefore he wished them take the true send proctor; making also this overture
reason, without inputing any wanton ap our agents, that will content that the petite since, being the one and fortieth process shall England, except only the year his age, night justly presumed such final decision, which, because there question
motions were not quick him. All which,
that tirey might the better under-tand, had
informed himself all parts Christendom,
concerning stratoge Marriages; and that, saving cites our king again, his proctors, finally
lately cardinal, Pope, yet,
made
the papal authority and the law divine, he will reserve himself. The term prefixed for our king's appearance being expired, Capisucci
Spain and Portugal, could never find that his orators. To all which Edward Karne all
the who be the Imperialists
in
of:
| is
he
be
it toto of
I all
of
or
is to in
to toso at to so of to to to
in
it
in of
of
of
so
it
inofofit, of
in
all
of
no to
no
he toto “
in
he
It in
as he
to St to
i.
inhehe toin
as to
of it
of
be
so to at
of he or toas
do
of to “ ofit
inhe of as of to to by byto allof sir
so
a he he toin to
of of of In he be to to in all tohe itso
be detoisor-so
or oftoofto be at
be to a by be ; to as
all
In
so is by o
to to of
8,
by to
to
of if
ata byofhe
to
of in or in he of of to to in
-
357] STATE TRIALS, 19 HENRY VIII. 1528–Divorce of Catharine of Arragon. [338
swered publickly, Nov. 14, 1532, That the Pro
ceeding was undue, both as the question con
cerning his Excusation was not decided, and
that he could not get a copy of the Citation;
and finally as it was not congruous to the Breve
c Rome, that he could not expect justice, where the king's Clandestine Marriage much fore, unless they desisted, he declared, that he longer hidden, the new queen being quick with
must appeal from thence to the able men in child that resolved shortly, both pub
sent to the king concerning this business. Be
sides, that the emperor was so powerful in chosen this place. Neither, indeed, could
4 some indifferent universities. And that, if this were refused, he protested then a nullity in
that they did. But the Pope, little regarding
lish his Marriage, and require his Clergy
proceed Sentence concerning the Divorce.
His parliament, the mean time, favouring this, goes Bononia shortly after, meet the his intentions, that they made Act against
emperor, according agreement made Appeals Rome, the little displeasure good while since betwixt them; promising our queen Catharine, who found thereby how dan agents yet, that notwithstanding the queen's gerous would (in point our law) in proctor's solicitation, nothing moment should sist hers. Howsoever, find she had many
done this Cause, till the emperor were de openly favoured her Cause, without that our
parted. —Our king finding could obtain
satisfaction from the Pope hastens the League with Francis, formerly projected, conclu
king thought Sentence
punish them.
Divorce pronounced against Queen Catharine,
sion and the rather, that heard this meet ing betwixt the Pope and the emperor would shortly follow.
Queen Catharine was now Ampthil Bedfordshire; and because conce fied the The king finding that the emperor, who king acquaint her with the causes this second Marriage, sent again some grave persons prepare her thereunto, wishing her together submit. But she persisting still, Cranmer, abp. Canterbury, cited her ap pear Dunstable, being six miles off. Where
Whereunto conduced much, that Warhanu, abp. Canterbury, being lately lead, Thomas
Cranmer (an able person) much favoured
our Historians say, and lately the king's business Italy, and
the nobility, employed this present
Germany, was, though absent,
seemed while desist from the eager prose cution his aunt's cause, was now more vehe ment than ever; sends Instructions his agents Rome, protest his name, that was not bound either his own person,
proctor, appear there, urging this
for deciding this business, appointed Court held and with him came the bi shops London, Winchester, (being Stephen
purpose, the Determination ~ties, and particularly
some universi Orleans and Paris.
permitted doctor Gardiner) Bath, Lincoln, and many great himself) divers motions clerks. Their first proceeding (as Sanders hath the Pope, the principal whereof our Re was citation our king put away his
cords find these. First, that seeing the wife Catharine, protesting otherwise that they Opinion lawyers, and the Council Nice, would censure him. But the Records which
the matter ought decided partibus; have seen, mention only that Cranmer de and that the laws England the determi manded and obtained leave the king de nation concerning the Succession) cannot termine the matter, since caused much doubt elsewhere made; would please his holi among the common people, and fears great ness that the abp. Canterbury taking him inconveniences matter of Succession. The
two eminent bishops abbots, the whole Court being now held, and the queen suum clergy his province, should decide the same. mon'd days together, without yet that she But this being dislik'd the pope, Bennet appeared, the archbishop having first pro secondly propos'd, whether would refer the nounced her contumacious, proceeds Sen
Notwithstanding which, Bennet make (as
Tho. More, the bishop
Cause might heard England, and that
the queen refused the Sentence, she should “In the name God, Amen We Thomas have the benefit her Appeal before three divine permission archbishop Canterbury,
judges, one England, one France, and the primate England, and legate the third from the Pope who also should discuss apostolical see, certain cause enquiry the matter some indifferent place. But the and concerning the validity the Marriage Pope allowed not this, saying, “Since saw contracted and consummated between the the king would needs conserve his authority, most potent and most illustrious prince, our
determination London,
nominate the king, and emperor name another, and
tence, which also caused publickly rend the chapel our Lady the priory Dunstable, before two notaries, and then
soon
let the queen
the French king the third, and the abp.
Canterbury the fourth. But this, also being
rejected, Bennet came, seems, the last de as he had advised with his council. gree the Instructions, which was, that the
would likewise via ordinaria. '
conserve his, and proceed
sovereign lord Henry the grace God king England and France, defender the
faith, and lord Ireland, and the most serene princess Catharine, daughter his most catho
now his best expedient
Our king thought
stand the decision his own clergy
sent the king, desiring further know his
mind concerning his second Marriage,
The Tenor Sentence was this.
to he
of to byhe
of of I his ;
be in
to inof beto be
it of
of
be orbeto
sir of it to
of
if
: of
of
of
of of:
into to be
of to he it
an
in
of
all
; of
fit
to be in he
as
8, by
the he
to
he
to
by
for to
or noaall
of
by he
or or in
of in
he he of
as
of by
of
it)
of
be to
to to
of a inin it
init orofbe of
by hein
to an
to
let
in to to a
in of in
(it by
of
to
at ofa to to to
to
oftoin aoftoattoon:of
15 toitsoto
aofof to he to
it
I no of
of of be ofof of as to to to of to to
I a in o/to
at
by
at
so
359] STATE TRIALS, 19 HENRy VIII. 1528. -Proceedings relating to the [360
lick majesty, Ferdinand king of Spain, &c. of dence, strength and validity, which the glorious metuory; we proceeding according to said Cause we have fully and clearly informed law and justice in the said Cause, which has ourselves, we find, and with undeniable evi been brought judicially before us in virtue of dence and plainness, see, that the Marriage our office, and which for some time has lain contracted and consummated, aforesaid, under examination, as it still being not yet between the said most illustrious prince king finally determined and decided, having first seen Henry and the most serene lady Catharine, all the Articles and Pleas which have been ex was and null and invalid, and that was con
hibited and set forth her part, together with tracted and consummated contrary the law
the Answers made thereto, and given the part the said most illustrious and powerful prince Henry having likewise seen, and dili gently inspected the Informations and Deposi
tions many noblemen and other witnesses
unsuspected veracity exhibited the said Cause;
having also seen, and like manner carefully
considered not only the Censures and Decrees
the most famous Universities almost the whole
Christian world, but likewise the Opinions and Determinations both of the most eminent divines
God. Therefore we Thomas, archbishop,
primate and legate aforesaid, having first called
upon the name Christ for direction herein, and having God altogether before our eyes,
pronounce sentence, and declare for the nul lity and invalidity the said Marriage, decree ing that the said pretended Marriage always was, and still null and invalid, that was contracted and consummated contrary the will and law God, that no force obligation, but that always wanted, and still
and civilians, also the Resolutions and Con wants the strength and sanction law, and clusions the clergy both provinces Eng therefore we sentence, decree and declare, that land convocation assembled, and many other not lawful for the said most illustrious and wholesome instructions and doctrines which powerful prince Henry
and the said most have been given and laid before concern serene lady Catharine, remain the said ing the said Marriage. Having farther seen, pretended Marriage; and we separate and
land, and the said Ferdinand glorious me said pretended Marriage facto and not mory, late king Spain, having besides seen, jure, and that they separated and divorced, and most carefully weighed and every are absolutely free from Marriage Bond, the Acts, Debates, Letters, Processes, Instru with regard the foresaid pretended Mar ments, Writs, Arguments, and other things riage, we pronounce, decree and declare by which have passed, and been transacted the this our definitive Sentence, and final Decree, said Cause any time, which thus seen which we now give, and the tenor these and inspected, our most exact care examin presents publish. May 23, 1533. ”
and with like diligence inspected the Trea divorce from each other the said most illus ties and Leagues peace and amity this trious and most powerful king Henry and account, entered upon, and concluded between the said most illustrious lady Cathorine,
Henry immortal same, late king Eng much they contracted and consuminated the
ing, and our most mature deliberation weigh The king hereupon (according the Decree
ing them, hath been used, reserving here the last parliament) commands strictly Ca
whatsoever right ought re tharine should no more called queen, but served. Furthermore the said most illustrious princess dowager, and widow prince Arthur.
and most powerful prince king Henry the
forementioned Cause, proper proctor
having appeared before us, but the said most
serene lady Catharine contempt absenting And now the news the archbishop of herself, (whose absence may the divine pre Canterbury's Sentence, and open Marriage sence always attend) and with the advice mistress Anne Bolen, being come the Pope's
most eminent skill divinity, whom cerning the Book our king had composed have consulted the premises, we have found against the Pope's authority (which also more
the most learned the law, and persons ears, and together with Information cou
our duty proceed
and definitive Sentence which accordingly we
give our final Decree than any thing else offended him) the whole the said Cause, college cardinals, especially such were for this manner. Be the emperor, became humble suppliants the
cause acts, warrants, deductions, propo Pope, that would proceed rigorously against
sitions, exhibitions, allegations, proofs and con our king; which also the Pope accorded, though
fessions, articles drawn up, answers wit not that peremptory and publick manner nesses, depositions, informations, instruments, was afterwards done; for find that this Sen arguments, letters, writs, censures, determina tence was not definitive the principal Cause, tions professors, opinions, councils, asser (as the imperials desired, and Sanders mistakes tions, affirmations, treaties and leagues but only declarative the point At peace, processes and other matters the said temptats, (as they call that king Henry Cause above-mentioned before laid, (the Cause yet depending) had divorced himself had, done, exhibited, and respectively produced,
also from the same and sundry other reasons, causes and considerations, manifold arguments,
and various kinds proof the greatest evi
without the leave and authority the Pope. Therefore was declared that all his actions
The
King proceeded against vigorously Rome.
herein were subject nullity, and himself excommunication, unless restored things
into
as of at de as or do
as
of
it ofof in
as is
in of of by 7,of
in us
be
of
to atof
in ofby as 8;
of
of ininbyin
of of in of
do to in
in us by in
of
in
of
of
8, byinin in us
of on
of
in on
his
to
all
all
of
in
is,
in
of we of ofof
it) of it of is
in
ithe do
as
is 8,
of
to soit a
it) in it of to 8, heininIan bebyallde
it
of
of do is of toto ofas
as in of to it is
all
all us
to
of
is
of
of to of 8, toit in in
of
361] STATE TRIALS, 19 HENRY VIII. 1528. -Divorce of Catharine of Arragon. [362
integrum, for which time was allowed him till the command taught, that the
end of September following. These proceed council above the pope, and that hath
ings being reserved, and the censures thus sus pended, argued that the Pope was willing be
any other foreign bishop. Lastly, send into
fore he went any farther to see the success of
Germany, confederate with the king Po land, John king Hungary; the dukes Saxony, Bavaria, the landtgrave Hess, &c.
his interview with Francis, which was accele
rated by this means. —This while, our king be
ing confident, that either by the Pope's good
permission, or his proper authority, he should
be able to justify a Cause which so many Uni things being resolved on, for final Answer, versities had sentenced on his side, proceeds to desired the bishop Paris certify Francis, the coronation of his new queen, which also That the pope would supersede from execut was performed with much solemnity. —The ing his Sentence, until had indifferent judges
ol more authority England God's law than
Pope was often solicited by Francis in the be sent, who might hear the business, would half of our king, that at least the time of de also supersede from the execution what claring the Censures against him might be pro was deliberated withdrawing his obe_l rogued. But the Pope answering only, that dience from the Roman see. But the bishop, though the term prefixed for fulmination were who thought this alone not enough reduce now past, yet he would omit further process things into good terms, made offer nego till he came to Rome. Our agents not con ciate the business Rome; which our king tent herewith, proceed in their Instructions, gladly accepted, assuring hum withal, that
and Edmund Bonner, as I find by an Original soon had obtained what was demanded, of his to our king, getting audience of the would send sufficient power and authority Pope, Nov. 7, in respectful terms, and under confirm much was accorded on his
likewise the Hanse-Teutonick towns, being Lubeck, Dantsick, Noremburgh, &c. These
protestation that his majesty intended no con part, having entire confidence his discre tempt of the see apostolick or holy church, inti tion and sufficiency, ever since his two years mated to him king Henry's ‘Appeal to the next employment ambassador this kingdom. General Council lawfully asseumbled,' exhibiting Whereupon the bishop, though Christmas also the authentick Instruments thereof (made holydays, and extream winter, posted
before the bishop of Winchester;) at which Rome: where came before any thing was the Pope being much incensed, said, “he would done, more than what formerly past; and here refer it to the Consistory. ’ Which being held obtaining public audience the Consistory, Nov. 10, he answered Bonner, “That, con
cerning the king's Appeal he rejected
being unlawful, and against Constitution
Pope Pius. For the Council, would pro would be the whole church. Which cure belonging his authority, and not vailed, that they prefixt day for receiving
king Henry's. For the Original Instru our king confirmation thereof. Insomuch, ments, which Bonner required back, “he de that courier was dispatched our king Henry, nied them,' and dismissed him; desiring desiring his Answer, within the time limited.
Francis only, that would persuade our king But the term being expired, and Answer to conform himself his ancient devotion and brought, the pope resolved proceed ful
obedience the Roman Church. ” Shortly af mination the Sentence which being adver
ter which, being the 12th Nov. 1533, the tised Bellay, repaired the pope and
Pope returned. find moreover that the abp. cardinals, (then sitting full Consistory) de Canterbury this time suspecting the Pope siring them stay while, being probable
would proceed against him,
our king made his Appeal also
which desired our agents
Pope. The success whereof yet doth not ap pear our Records.
The Pope's Sentence against the King set Dunkirk.
About this time the Pope's Sentence against the king was openly set Dunkirk Flan ders; that prevent further inconveniences,
the king (as our Records shew) advised with his Council, Dec. First, To inform his subjects
his Appeal the Council General, and the justice thereof. Secondly, Of the Unlawful ness the dowager's Appeal Rome, and the
that the courier, either through cross winds, other accidents long journies, might de tained concluding his speech, that the king England had years together been pa tient, they might attend six days; which space only desired them give him, for the re
the advice the Council:
intimate the
late statute against which said statute was
(for that purpose) set upon every church certain cardinals. By reason whereof the door England, also his majesty's said Pro Sentence was precipitated, that, what ac vocation, Appeal, whereof transumpts also cording their usual forms could not done were scnt into Flanders. Thirdly, To less than three Consistories, was now dis
eloquently declared our king's Message, re
resenting both what had obtained our ing, and shewing withal how advantageous
ceiving being put
our king's Answer; this proposition the question, the plurality
voices carried rather, that
against our king, and the this mean time, news came
Rome, that the king had printed and published the Book written against the Pope's authority, (which yet was untrue, for came not forth
afterwards, though was not yet kept
close, but copy was now come the Pope's hands) and that there was comedy repre sented court, the little defamation
pre ! .
of
beor to
it, as
to
in of
so to
in
in
till
he tohe as
be
ifbe ofsotoofor
to
so of
asto it, be
toheso
3,to
no a
it
in ;
it to to to
in in
in in
toa
by
to
to
of to he of
to 2.
at I
up at
to by to
of a he
in
up
to
at of
it, ofas
he
of
to
2,
heof;toa asasifis
toat of a he of
a of a to to it
into to as as to soit heantoin
to
in he a
at do of in he
of be
it
to six
a he
as
no
of
itto ashehelofno
an
to to
he
-
*
363] STATE TRIALS, 19 Henry VIII. 152s. -Proceedings relating to [364
patched one: and final determina Henry against the said queen Catharine, upon tion the Marriage with queen Catharine was the invalidity the said marriage, have pronounced good, and king Henry commanded been and judged unlawful and unjust; and
accept her for his wife, and case refusal the said king from henceforth for ever hold Censures were fulminated against him. But his peace, and not heard any court two days the six were not past, when the hereafter speak touching the invalidity courier arrived with ample commission and au the said matrimony: like we also here thority from our king, conclude and confirin will and charge him hold his peace, and
all that the bishop had agreed his name. put him perpetual silence herein; willing Which was this, (as the writer the Concilio moreover and adjudging the said king Henry Tridentino hath that king Henry was con condemned, and presently here we do tent accept the Judgment that court, upon condemn him the expences the said queen condition that the suspected and imperial car Catharine's behalf here our court, expended
dinals should not intervene, and that indiffe and employed
traversing the aforesaid cause,
which expences we reserve limited and taxed, we shall
rent persons should sent Cambray informed the merits the Cause
authority further for his proctors appear that court. At which, the more wise and tem.
the valuation
ourselves
giving
perate cardinals were astonished, that they our Consistory, 25th March 1534. Blosius.
became humble suppliants the pope, that would advise how things might repaired;
whereupon the business was again discussed.
But remedies being judged either late,
impossible, the Sentence stood, and the empe
ror was made the executor The bishop
now returning toward France, met (as find
our Records) Edward Karne and William Re and bloodshed this realm) was enacted, vet, who were employed our king for solicit that the king's Marriage with the lady Catha
ing important they rine, ocarnally
this business. But un wife and known his brother
derstood the bishop, that the first Marriage prince Arthur (as was lawfully proved before
was pronounced good, and the issue legi timate, they judged lost labour proceed,
and advertised our king.
The Sentence was this effect.
“That Pope Clement the seventh with the consent of his other brethren the cardinals as
sembled together the consistory, sitting there the throne justice calling upon the name Christ, and having God only before his eyes,
Thomas, abp. Canterbury) contrary
and the matrimony with queen Anne shall be taken for firm and good and the issue thence procreate accounted lawful; the inheritance
the crown belong the same, manner following, viz. First the eldest son begotten
the king queen Anne, and the heirs the said son lawfully begotten, and for default such heir then the second son, &c. and
England, and shall bound and obstrict issue, the right heirs the king's
-
be held void and she styled more queen, but Dowager prince Arthur,
doth pronounce, define, aud declare the
cause and causes between his dear daughter queen Anne decease without issue male, then
Catharine queen England appealing the
see apostolique, and his beloved son Henry the 8th, king England, concerning the validity
the crown to descend the son and heir of the king's body lawfully begotten, and the heirs of the said son lawfully begotten, and for default
such issue, the second son like manner, &c. And for default sons, that then the the Consistory Court the said Pope Clement; crown shall belong the issue female the
and invalidity the matrimony heretofore con tracted between them, and yet depending
that the said matrimony always hath and still king queen Anne; and first the first be doth, stand firm and canonical, and that the gotten the princess Elizabeth, and the heirs issue proceeding, which shall proceed the her body lawfully begotten. And for de same, standeth and shall stand law full and le fault such issue then the second daughter gitimate and that the aforesaid Henry, king like sort, &c. And for default all such
judge meet hereafter. We pronounce, Rome our Apostolical palace publicly
The King's Marriage with Catharine made void Act Parliament.
tool the matrimonial society and cohabitation was ordained that this Act shall pro
with the said lady Catharine his lawful wife claimed before May next throughout the king and queen, hold and maintain her with such dom.