No More Learning

The rest of the goods im-
ported in the Champion were disposed of in January. 2 The
complete cargoes of the schooners Lynn, Britannia and
Adventure, all from Falmouth, were sold a few weeks
later. * As the result of their enterprise, the Marblehead
1 Mass. Spy, Dec. 16, 1774.
'Salem Gas. , Dec. 23. 1774; Essex Gas. , Jan. 3, 1775: Bos. Gas:. ,
Jan. 23.
*Moss. Spy, Feb. 9, 1775.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-19 01:37 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/mdp. 39015011480665 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 48o THE COLONIAL MERCHANTS: 1763-1776
committee of inspection derived profits amounting to ? 120,
which they turned over to Boston. 1 Meantime, the Salem
Committee were disposing of importations from Bristol,
London, Falmouth, Jamaica and Dominica. Their method
of sale was indicated by their advertisement that: "Each
invoice will be put up at the sterling cost and charges, one
per cent advance, and half per cent each bidder. " z Their
contribution to Boston, as a result of the sales, amounted
to ? 109 9s. 5d. 8 In the same period the Plymouth com-
mittee of inspection made profits for Boston amounting to
? 31 58. 6/2. "
After February 1 few vessels arrived in Massachusetts
ports as compared with former and better days. When they
did come, the cargoes were almost invariably re-shipped
without breaking bulk. 5 One instance of defiance occurred
at Falmouth in March, when a small sloop arrived from
Bristol with rigging, sails and stores for a vessel which
Thomas Coulson was in the process of building. The com-
mittee of inspection resolved that the materials should be
returned by the same vessel; but Coulson would conform
to their demands only in part. He brought on his head the
condemnation of the Cumberland County convention, which
shortly after assembled at Falmouth; and as Coulson con-
tinued obdurate, the committee of inspection published him
as a violator of the Association. *
Few efforts were made to violate the regulation for the
non-exportation of sheep. In December, Captain Hamilton
1Bos. Gas. , Mch. 13, 1775.
? Mow. Spy, Jan. 5, 1775-
1 Essex Gas. , Apr. 11, 1775.
4 Bos. Gas. , Mch. 27, 1775.
? E. g. , a cargo of molasses arriving at Vlarblehead from Dominica
on March 2; Essex Journ. , Mch. 15, 1775.
? 4 Am. Arch. , vol. ii, pp. 3>>-313; Bos. Eve. Post, Apr. 3, 1775-
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-19 01:37 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/mdp. 39015011480665 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? IN THE COMMERCIAL PROVINCES 481
at Salem planned to send thirty sheep to Jamaica; but when
the committee of inspection explained that he would be
violating the Association, he readily desisted. 1 The com-
mittee later stopped another consignment. The regulations
concerning non-consumption were harder to administer,
because of the practical difficulty of distinguishing between
goods which might properly be bought and those which
could not. The committee at Newburyport met this diffi-
culty by requiring shopkeepers to produce a certificate from
some committee of inspection, testifying that the wares
offered for sale had been imported before December I or,
if later, that they had been disposed of according to Ar-
ticle x. 2 The provincial congress simplified the situation
for the future by passing a sweeping resolution forbidding
the sale, after October 10, 1775, of goods which fell under
the ban of the non-importation regulation, even if the goods
were unsold stock remaining from the period prior to De-
cember 1. 8
The most frequent infractions of the non-consumption
regulation occurred with reference to the article of tea. An
example of the vigilance of the committees of inspection
was afforded by the prompt apprehension of Thomas Lilly,
of Marblehead, for the purchase of a pound and a quarter
of tea from Simon Tufts, a Boston dealer, after March 1,
1775. When Lilly had burnt the tea in the presence of a
large crowd, and had signed a confession, which read in
part: " I do now in this publick manner ask their pardon,
and do solemnly promise I will not in future be guilty of a
like offence," the Marblehead committee announced that he
might "be justly entitled to the esteem and employ of all
1 Essex Gas. , Dec. 13, 1774.
1 Essex Journ. , Dec. 28, 1774.
14 Am. Arch. , vol. i, pp. 998-999. This resolution was repealed on
Sept. 30, 1775, however, before it became effective. Ibid. , vol. iii, p. 1445.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-19 01:37 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/mdp. 39015011480665 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 482
THE COLONIAL MERCHANTS: 1763-1776
persons as heretofore. " The Boston committee examined
into Tufts' action and secured from him a statement, made
under oath before a justice of the peace, that the tea had
been sold to Lilly by the clerk without the knowledge or
consent of himself and that in the future his conduct should
not be open to misconstruction. 1 Some difficulty arose from
the practice of peddlers and petty chapmen going through
the country towns and selling teas and other East India
goods which, there was reason to suspect, had been im-
ported after December t. On February 15, 1775, the pro-
vincial congress urged the committees of inspection to pre-
vent such sales, and recommended to the inhabitants not to
trade with peddlers for any article whatever. 2
Some effort was made by the provincial congress to stim-
ulate local industry, although it hardly went beyond an ex-
hortation to the people to form societies for the purpose of
promoting manufacturing and agriculture. A number of
articles were named, whose production should be encour-
aged -- such as nails, steel, tin-plates, buttons, paper, glass
and hosiery, gunlocks, saltpetre and gunpowder. A few
months later, the provincial congress asked every family in
the province to save rags in order that a paper mill erected
at Milton might have a sufficient supply. The people were
also asked to refrain from killing sheep except in cases of
dire necessity. 8 Local manufacturers made some progress
if one may judge from the advertising columns of the
Massachusetts Spy in January, 1775. Fish-hooks, made at
Cornish, were offered for sale by Lee & Jones. Enoch
Brown advertised sagathies, duroys, camblets, calamancoes
and shalloons of Massachusetts-make, and decanters, cruets
1 Essex Gos. , Mch. 28, 1775, and Bos. Gas. . Apr. 3; also 4 Am. Arch. ,
vol. ii, p. 234.
1Ibid. , vol. i, pp. 1339-1340.
* Ibid. , vol. i, pp. 1001-1002, 1334; vol. ii, p. 1514; vol. iii, p. 329.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-19 01:37 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/mdp. 39015011480665 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? IN THE COMMERCIAL PROVINCES 483
and other glassware imported from Philadelphia. Boston-
made buttons could be purchased from John Clarke.
Tendencies toward a greater frugality were to be found
in other respects as well. The Marblehead committee of
inspection voted unanimously that " the meeting of the in-
habitants of this town in parties at houses of entertainment,
for the purposes of dancing, feasting, &c. , is expressly
against the Association," and that future offenders should
be held up to public notice. 1 The regulation with reference
to simplicity in mourning seems to have been well ob-
served,2 although the committee of inspection at Newbury-
port felt it necessary to declare that: " If any should . . .
go into a contrary practice, they may well expect that their
friends and neighbours will manifest their disapprobation
. . . by declining to attend the funeral. " *
In New Hampshire the enforcement of the Association
depended in large degree on the faithfulness and energy of
the Committee of "Forty-Five" at Portsmouth, the only
port of entry. This committee proved equal to its respon-
sibilities. Before news of the adoption of the Association
reached Portsmouth, Captain Pearne, a merchant, had com-
missioned a brig to proceed to Madeira for a cargo of
wine; but before the vessel sailed the provisions of the
Association were learned and the merchant agreed to send
her to the West Indies instead. 4 The committee also
stopped Captain Olivers who was on the point of exporting
fifty sheep to the West Indies; and he was forced to dis-
pose of them otherwise at some loss to himself. 5 On De-
cember 2 Governor Wentworth wrote that most people
1 Essex Gas. , Jan. 17, 1775; also Salem Gas. . Jan. 20.
* Mass. Spy, Nov. 24, 1774.
1 Essex Journ. , Dec. 28, 1774.
*AT. H. Gas. , Nov. 18, 1774.
4 4 Am. Arch. , vol. i, p. 1013; N. H. Gas. , Nov. 18, 1774.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-19 01:37 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/mdp. 39015011480665 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
?
484 THE COLONIAL MERCHANTS: 1763-1776
accepted the regulations of Congress "as matters of obe-
dience, not of considerate examination, whereon they may
exercise their own judgment. " 1 When sixty pounds of
dutied tea was found in possession of a shopkeeper on Jan-
uary 18, the culprit exhibited the better part of valor by
burning it in the presence of a large crowd. 2 On February
10 the committee recommended that all who furnished
accommodations for cards and billiards should discontinue
their unjustifiable proceedings at once. * So energetic was
the committee that the conservatives endeavored to set on
foot an association in opposition to the Continental Asso-
ciation; but the movement came to nought. 4
In the towns outside of Portsmouth, the greatest diffi-
culty was experienced in dealing with country peddlers and
chapmen. These men were accused of contravening the
non-importation and non-consumption regulations and also
of "tempting women, girls and boys with their unneces-
sary fineries. " The town of Exeter voted to permit no
itinerant traders to sell wares there. 8 A town meeting at
Epsom established the same regulation "upon no less
penalty than receiving a new suit agreeable to the modern
mode and a forfeiture of their goods. " * The committees at
Kingstown, New Market and Brentwood announced that
the provincial law prohibiting peddling would now be
rigidly enforced. 7 When a provincial convention met on
January 25, they endorsed this last method as the most
effective way of coping with the difficulty. 8 The conven-
1 4 Am. Arch. , vol. i, p. 1013.
1 N. H. Gas. , Jan. 27, 1775.
* Ibid. , Feb. 10, 1775; also 4 Am. Arch. , vol. i, p. 1223.
4 Ibid. , vol. ii, p. 251; also N. H. Gas. , Mch. 31, 1775.
1 Ibid. , Jan. 6, 1775; also 4 Am. Arch. , vol. i, pp. 1105-1106.
? Ibid. , vol. i, p. 1105; also N. H. Gas. , Jan. 20, 1775.
1 Ibid. , Jan. 13, 1775-
1Ibid. , Feb. 3, 1775; also 4 Am. Arch. , vol. i, p. 1182.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-19 01:37 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/mdp. 39015011480665 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? IN THE COMMERCIAL PROVINCES 485
tion also issued an address to the inhabitants in behalf of
the Association and, among other things, recommended the
immediate and total disuse of tea whether dutied or smug-
gled. The people were also urged to promote home manu-
factures and shun all forms of extravagance. It was not
until the provincial congress met in May that the subject
of local production received further attention. Then linen
and woolen manufactures were mentioned as being partic-
ularly worthy of encouragement, and farmers were enjoined
to kill no lambs before the first of August following. 1
The non-importation regulation appears to have been
well enforced in Rhode Island. Several vessels intending
for the African coast were actually laid up at Newport be-
cause they could not be gotten ready to depart by Decem-
ber 1. 2 The Newport committee remitted to Boston the
sum of ? 5 15s. 3d. sterling as the profits of sales of im-
portations prior to February 1, 1775. 8 Late in January,
the committee at Providence auctioned off a quantity of
merchandise, valued at ? 1200 sterling, imported from
Liverpool by way of New York, and derived a profit of
? 16 6s. 1d. for the relief of Boston. 4 Particular attention
was given in Rhode Island to the regulations for the non-
exportation of sheep. In November, 1774, the Providence
committee exhorted obedience to these regulations; a few
days later they sent to Boston, as a gift, one hundred and
thirty-six sheep that had originally been intended for ex-
portation to the West Indies but which the town had bought
instead. 8 Until late in February, Newport would not even
1 4 Am. Arch. , vol. ii, p. 651.
1 Pa. Journ. , Feb. 8, 1775; also 4 Am. Arch. , vol. i, pp. 1098-1099.
14M. H. S. Colls. , vol. iv, p. 265.
4 Bos. Eve. Post, Feb. 20, 1775; Essex Gas. , Mch. 7,
? 4 M. H. S. Colls. , vol. iv, p. 154.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-19 01:37 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/mdp. 39015011480665 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 486 THE COLONIAL MERCHANTS: 1763-1776
permit the shipment of sheep to associated provinces; then,
the Salem committee succeeded in pointing out the error
of this interpretation of the Association. 1
Providence facilitated the enforcement of the non-con-
sumption regulation by requiring all dealers to show a
certificate that the goods offered for sale conformed in
every way to the specifications of the Association. 2 On
March 2, 1775, the day after the total disuse of tea became
effective, the event was celebrated at Providence by a bon-
fire of three hundred pounds of tea that had been collected
from the inhabitants. 8 The situation in Rhode Island may
be summarized in the language of the Newport committee
to their Philadelphia brethren: "so far as we can learn,
the Association hath been strictly adhered to by the mer-
chants in this colony . . . " 4 Apparently little was done
to encourage manufacturing or to foster the simple life.
However, the graduating class at Rhode Island College in-
duced the college authorities to abandon the public com-
mencement exercises as out of harmony with Article viii. "
The chief problem in Connecticut was not that of non-
importation (for her imports came largely by way of Mas-
sachusetts and New York), but that of non-consumption.
The Norwich committee required all dealers to comply with
the regulation, which was rapidly becoming popular, of
vouching for the character of new stock by displaying cer-
tificates from whence the merchandise came. 3 An early
tendency was observable for prices to rise, due to the fact
1 Pickering Papers (M. H. S. Mss. ), vol. xxxiii, p. 122; vol. xxxix,
p. 100.
1R. I. Col. Recs. , vol. vii, pp. 285-287.
*4 Am. Arch. , vol. ii, p. 15.
4 Pa. Journ. , Feb. 8, 1775; also 4 Am. Arch. , vol. i, p. 1099.
1 Ibid. , vol. ii, pp. 93S-93&
? Conn. (Ja*. . Dec. 30. 1774.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-19 01:37 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/mdp. 39015011480665 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? IN THE COMMERCIAL PROVINCES 487
that the importers had sold to the Connecticut retailers at
an advance and the former could not easily be reached be-
cause of their residence in other provinces. On January 25,
1775, a joint meeting of committees of inspection of Hart-
ford County resolved that, even if the importers violated
the Association, the retailers should not be excused, and
that no better rule could be fixed regarding prices than Ar-
ticle ix of the Association. 1 A few days later the com-
mittee of inspection at Farmington in the same county ob-
tained from James Percival, a local dealer, a written con-
fession of his guilt in violating this regulation and a
promise to deposit his surplus profit with the committee for
use of the Boston unfortunate. 5 The same action with re-
spect to prices was taken by the counties of New Haven.
Fairfield and Litchfield. All these counties also directed
attention to the importance of improving sheep, raising flax
and encouraging manufactures. *
As Connecticut possessed no commercial metropolis,
special effort was made in that province to standardize the
practice of trying persons accused of transgressing the
Association in the several small river and coast towns. The
movement was set on foot, it would appear, at the meeting
of the committees of inspection of Hartford County on
January 25. In executing the Association, it was there
agreed that proceedings against an accused should be con-
ducted in an "open, candid and deliberate manner:" that
formal summons should be served upon him. containing the
nature of the charge, with an invitation to defend himself
before the committee at some time not sooner than six days
later; that witnesses and other evidence should be " openly,
fairly and fully heard;" and that no conviction should be
1 Conn. Cour. , Jan. 30, 1775.
1 Ibid. , Feb. 13, 1775.
'Ibid. , Feb.