No More Learning

That Nashe was engaged one
way or another in the anti-Martinist crusade is certain. We have his own
word for it. (McKerrow's Nashe, vol. I, p. 270. ) But it is as yet impos-
sible to say anything definite as to the extent and nature of his contributions
to the controversy. All that can be done here is to record, for what they are
worth, a personal impression that Martins Months Minde and An Almond for
a Parrat are by the same hand and that not the hand of Pasquill, and a
suspicion that Bancroft may have lent his pen as well as his countenance to
the making of these lampoong.
iv. Modern Works.
Allnatt, W. H. The Marprelate Press, 1588-89. Bibliographica, vol. II,
p. 172. 1896.
Arber, Edward. An Introductory Sketch to the Martin Marprelate Con-
troversy. English Scholar's Library. 1895. Reprints, with introductions
and notes, of Diotrephes, Demonstration of Discipline, The Epistle,
Admonition to the People of England.
Bond, R. W. The Complete Works of John Lyly. 3 vols. Oxford, 1902.
Brook, B. The Lives of the Puritans. 3 vols. 1813.
Dexter, H. M. The Congregationalism of the last three hundred years, as
seen in its Literature, with special reference to certain recondite, neglected
or disputed passages. New York, 1880.
Disraeli, Isaac. Quarrels of Authors. 1814.
Frere, W. H. The English Church in the reigns of Elizabeth and James I.
Vol. v of W. R. W. Stephens and W. Hunt's History of the English
Church. 1904.
Grieve, Alex. J. The Aequity of an humble supplication by John Penry,
with introduction, etc. Congregational Historical Society. 1905.
Grosart, A. B. The works of T. Nashe. 1883.
The works of G. Harvey. The Huth Library. 1884.
Lee, Sidney. The Last Years of Elizabeth, in The Cambridge Modern
History, vol. III, chap. X. Cambridge, 1904. Also in the D. of N. B. on
Penry, Throckmorton, Udall, Waldegrave.
Maskell, W. History of the Martin Marprelate Controversy. 1845. Also see
Christian Remembrancer, vol. ix, Martin Marprelate, 1845.
McKerrow, R. B. The Works of Thomas Nashe. 5 vols. 1904-1910.
Neal, D. The History of the Puritans. 3 vols. 1837.
Petheram, John. Reprints with introductions, etc. of The Epistle, The
Epitome, Hay any worke for Cooper, Pappe with a Hatchet, An Almond
for a Parrat, An Admonition to the People of England, and Plaine
Percevall. Puritan Discipline Tracts 1842-6. (Republished, 1860. ]


## p. 545 (#567) ############################################

Chapter XVII
545
Pierce, William. The Date of the second Marprelate Tract. Journal of the
Northamptonshire Nat. Hist. Soc. , vol. XIII, No. 103, Sept. 1905. The
Marprelate Tracts. Trans. of the Congregational Hist. Soc. , vol. II,
No. 2, May 1905.
Powicke, F. J. Henry Barrowe, Separatist. 1900.
Saintsbury, G. Elizabethan and Jacobean Pamphlets. (Pocket Library of
Eng. Lit. ) 1892.
Strype, John. Annals of the Reformation. 4 vols. Oxford, 1824.
Life of John Whitgift. 3 vols. Oxford, 1822.
Waddington, John. John Penry the Pilgrim Martyr. 1854.
Wilson, John Dover. A Date in the Marprelate controversy. The Library,
Oct. 1907.
Both in writing the chapter and in compiling this bibliography the author
has been assisted by suggestions ungrudgingly offered by the Rev. William
Pierce of Northampton, who is preparing an edition of the Marprelate
tracts.
6
[The concluding phases of the Greene, Harvey and Nashe controversy
(see ante, pp. 395 ff. ) may be read, by those who care to follow the various
stages of a scurrilous and somewhat wearisome personal squabble, in the
Huth library edition of the works of Greene (ed. Grosart), the Huth library
edition of the works of Harvey (ed. Grosart) and the excellent edition of the
works of Nashe now in course of publication (ed. McKerrow).
The extant copies of Greene's Quip for an upstart Courtier (licensed 20
July 1592) do not contain the offensive passage which annoyed Gabriel Harvey
(see Nashe's Strange Newes, referred to below).
In Pierce Penilesse His Supplication to the Divell (entered in the
Stationers' register 8 August 1592), Nashe virulently attacked the Harveys,
and (in some of the issues of the same pamphlet during 1592) spoke some-
what scurvily of Green's Groats-worth of Wit as 'a scald trivial lying
pamphlet:
Greene died 3 September 1592, and Gabriel Harvey published in the same
year Foure Letters, and certaine Sonnets: Especially touching Robert
Greene, and other parties, by him abused: But incidentally of divers ex-
cellent persons, and some matters of note. To all courteous mindes that will
voutchsafe the reading. (Epistle Dedicatorie dated 16 September, licensed
4 December. ) The adjective applied on the title-page to the readers, and at
the head of the Dedication, would seem to have been forgotten dur the
writing of the Letters, the author of Pierce Pennylesse being stigmatised
as 'the Divels Oratour by profession and his Dammes Poet by practise,'
while the mildest terms applied to Greene are 'A rakehell: A makeshift:
A scribling foole'; and John Harvey's Welcome to Robert Greene (a sonnet
put in the mouth of Gabriel's physician brother who had died in July 1592)
begins with the lines :
Come, fellow Greene, come to thy gaping grave:
Bid Vanity and Foolery farewell:
Thou over-long hast plaid the madbrain'd knave:
And over-loud hast rung the bawdy bell.
Vermine to vermine must repaire at last . . .
These hungry wormes thinke longe for their repast.
Henry Chettle, the editor of Greene's Groats-worth of Wit, in his Kind-
Hart's Dreame (licensed December 1592) introduces the spirit of Greene, who
asks Nashe to remember his wrongs. Nashe, in his preface to Greene's Mena-
phon (1589), headed ‘To the Gentlemen Students of Both Universities,' had
35
E. L. III.


## p. 546 (#568) ############################################

546
Bibliography
6
spoken appreciatively of Gabriel Harvey as a Latin poet; and, as we have seen,
he had not scrupled to speak contemptuously of one of Greene's pamphlets.
But he was more than willing to take sides in a controversy, and, on 12 January
1592/3, a pamphlet was entered in the Stationers' register entitled The Apo-
logie of Pierce Pennylesse or strange newes of the intercepting certen letters,
and a convoy of verses as they were goinge to victuall the Lowe Cuntries.
The first six words of the entry are omitted from the title-page of the extant
editions. “Gabriel, and not onely Gabriel, but Gabrielissime Gabriel, no
Angell but Angelos, id est, Nuntius' is called upon to 'Behold, here stands
he that will make it good, on thy foure Letters bodie, that thou art a filthy
vaine foole' and the author proceeds to make good his boast, so far as words
can accomplish his will. Harvey's reply was Pierces Supererogation or A
New Prayse of the Old Asse. A Preparative to certaine larger Discourses,
intituled Nashes S. Fame (1593), and so the miserable game went on. For
a time, Nashe wearied, or he found other work for his pen. He appears in
pleasanter guise in the preface to his Christs Teares over Jerusalem Wher.
unto is annexed, a comparative admonition to London, (entered 8 September
1593), in which he avows his laudable desire “to be at peace with all men,
and make submissive amends where I have most displeased. Not basely
feare-blasted or constraintively over-ruled, but purely pacifycatorie suppliant,
for reconciliation and pardon doe I sue to the principallest of them, gainst
whom I profest utter enmity. Even of Maister Doctor Harvey, I hartily
desire the like. ' True to his quarrelsome and selfish nature, Gabriel Harvey
rejected the proffered olive-branch, stating, in A New Letter of Notable
Contents (dated 16 September 1593), bis unwillingness to be coosened with
the legerdemaine of a jugling convert. . . what say you, to a Spring of rankest
Villany in February: and a Harvest of ripest Divinity in May? ' His offered
hand being refused, Nashe set to work to compose a fresh preface to
Christs Teares (1594) 'wheras I thought to make my foe a bridge of golde,
or faire words, to flie by, he hath used it as a high way to invade me. . . . Hence-
forth, with the forenamed Machiavel, for an unrefutable principle I will hold
it, that he is utterly undone which seekes by new good turnes to roote out
old grudges. . . . Was never whore of Babylon so betrapt with abhominations
as his stile (like the dog-house in the fields) is pestred with stinking filth'
and so on and so on. Not content with this, Nashe published in 1596 ‘Have
with you to Saffron-Walden, or, Gabriell Harveys Hunt is up. Containing
a full answere to the eldest sonne of the Halter-maker. Or, Nashe his
Confutation of the sinfull Doctor. The Mott or Posie, instead of Omne tulit
punctum: Pacis fiducia nunquam. As much to say, as I sayd I would speake
with him. Here, at last, the reader gains some reward for turning over
reams of sheer vituperation. The Epistle Dedicatorie to the 'speciall super-
visor of all excrementall superſluities for Trinitie Colledge in Cambridge,
in other words, to the college barber, is a delightful piece of fooling. The rest
of the pamphlet is an admirable example of Nashe's force as a satirist, and
is, perhaps, the best of contemporary lampoons.
Harvey's reply, The Trimming of Thomas Nashe, Gentleman, by the
high-tituled patron Don Richardo de Medico campo, Barber Chirurgion to
Trinitie Colledge in Cambridge, was published in the following year and
ended the controversy, for, before the close of the century, 'all Nashe's bookes
and Dr Harvey's bookes' were ordered, by those in authority, to 'be taken,
whersoever they may be, and that none of the same bookes be ever printed
hereafter. : A. R. W. ]


## p. 547 (#569) ############################################

Chapter XVIII
547
CHAPTER XVIII
OF THE LAWS OF ECCLESIASTICAL POLITY
(Bibliography by George A. Brown. ]
EDITIONS OF THE POLITY.
First four books printed by Windet, J. (no date), entered at Stationers' Hall,
29 Jan. 1592-3.
Book v published by Windet in 1597. Ed. Spencer, J. 1604(? ), 1611.
Sixth and eighth books 'published according to the most authentique copies,'
1648, 1651.
Seventh book, in Gauden's 1662 ed. of Hooker's works.
See Lee, S. , in D. of N. B. for a discussion as to the genuineness of Books
VI, VII and vill. Book vi, apparently, 'has no right to its place in Hooker's
treatise. '
The E. P. and other works with life by Izaak Walton, and Strype's inter-
polations: to which are pow added the 'Christian's Letter' and Dr Covel's
*Just and temperate defence. With an introduction, a life by Cart-
wright, T. and notes by Hanbury, B. 3 vols. 1830.
Ed. Keble, J. 4 vols. Oxford, 1836. Keble's ed. is the best in its later form,
3 vols. , ed. Church, R. W. and Paget, F. , Oxford, 1883-8.
Book 1. Ed. Church. R. W. Oxford, 1876.
Book v. Ed. Bayne, R. 1902.
OTHER WRITINGS.
A learned Discourse of Justification, Workes, and how the foundation of
Faith is overthrowne. Ed. Jackson, H. 1612, 1613.
A learned Sermon of the nature of Pride. Oxford, 1612.
The Answere to a Supplication preferred by Mr. Travers to the H. H. Lords
of the Privie Counsell. Oxford, 1612.
A Remedy against Sorrow and Fear. Oxford, 1612.
A Learned and comfortable Sermon of the certaintie and perpetuitie of faith
in the Elect. Oxford, 1612.
LIVES.
Fuller, T. History of the Worthies of England. Ed. Nichols, E. D. Vol. 1.
1811.
Church History. Ed. Brewer, J. S. Vol. v. 177, 178, 183-235. 1845.
Ganden, J. In his 1662 ed. of the Polity.
Hook, W. F. Ecclesiastical Biography. 1850.
Hurst, J. F. Literature of Theology. 1884.
Prince, J. Danmonii Orientales Illustres: Or, The Worthies of Devon, p. 393.
1701.
Walton, Izaak. Life. First published, 1665. Then added to the various eds.
of the Polity and included in all eds. of Walton's Lives.
Wood, A. à. Athenae Oxonienses. 1848.
Wordsworth, C. Ecclesiastical Biography. 1810.
GENERAL CRITICISM AND ALLUSIONS.
Bernard, N. Olavi Trabales. 1661.
Cambridge Modern History. Vol. IIl.
35-2


## p. 548 (#570) ############################################

548
Bibliography
Collier, J. Ecclesiastical History of Great Britain. Ed. Lathbury, T. Vols.
III, 36; VII, 159, 160, 250. 1825.
Dale, A. W. W. History of English Congregationalism. 1907.
Davidson, J. Bibliotheca Devoniensis. 1852.
Figgis, J. N. The Theory of the Divine Right of Kings. 1892. See also
article in Guardian, 11 October 1905, entitled Hoadly and the Bangorian
Controversy.
Hallam, H. Constitutional History of England. Vol. 1, 214. 1854.
Introduction to the Literature of Europe. 1854.
Hunt, J. Religious Thought in England from the Reformation. 3 vols.
1870-3.
Landor, W. S. Imaginary Conversations. Vol. 11. Ed. C. G. Crump. 1891.
Maurice, J. F. D. Modern Philosophy. 1862.
Neal, D. History of the Puritans. Vol. 1. 446. 1822.
Nichols, J. B. Literary Anecdotes. 1813.
Paget, F. An Introduction to the 5th Book. 1899.
Pepys' Diary. Ed. Wheatley, H. B. Vols. 11, 61, 84; VI, 273, 325, 326. 1903.
Rémusat, C. F. M. de. Histoire de la Philosophie en Angleterre. Paris, 1875.
Ruskin, J. Modern Painters. Vol. 11, 128. 1869.
Sandys, E. Europae Speculum. 1629. Sandys being Hooker's pupil, this
work exhibits many interesting points of contact with Hooker's writings.
Stephen, Sir J. F. Horae Sabbaticae. Vol. 1. 1892.
LITERATURE OF THE CONTROVERSY.
(See also bibliography to the chapter on the Marprelate controversy. )
The Book of Discipline (Latin). 1574.
Browne, R. A treatise of Reformation without tarying for anie. 1582.
Rptd, 1903.