In 1867, as
consequence
of a similar operation, there was a strike of 20,000 men at Preston.
Marx - Capital-Volume-I
215, 319, 320.
In this work, Malthus finally discovers, with the help of Sismondi, the beautiful Trinity of capitalistic production: over-production, over-population, over-consumption -- three very delicate monsters, indeed.
Cf.
F.
Engels, --Umrisse zu einer Kritik der Nationalo?
konomie,?
l.
c.
, p, 107, et seq.
18 Harriet Martineau, --A Manchester Strike,? 1832, p. 101.
19 Even in the cotton famine of 1863 we find, in a pamphlet of the operative cotton-spinners of Blackburn, fierce denunciations of overwork, which, in consequence of the Factory Acts, of course only affected adult male labourers. --The adult operatives at this mill have been asked to work from 12 to 13 hours per day, while there are hundreds who are compelled to be idle who would willingly work partial time, in order to maintain their families and save their brethren from a premature grave through
? ? 489 Chapter 25
being overworked. . . . We,? it goes on to say, --would ask if the practice of working overtime by a number of hands, is likely to create a good feeling between masters and servants. Those who are worked overtime feel the injustice equally with those who are condemned to forced idleness. There is in the district almost sufficient work to give to all partial employment if fairly distributed. We are only asking what is right in requesting the masters generally to pursue a system of short hours, particularly until a better state of things begins to dawn upon us, rather than to work a portion of the hands overtime, while others, for want of work, are compelled to exist upon charity. ? (--Reports of Insp. of Fact. , Oct. 31, 1863,? p. 8. ) The author of the --Essay on Trade and Commerce? grasps the effect of a relative surplus population on the employed labourers with his usual unerring bourgeois instinct. --Another cause of idleness in this kingdom is the want of a sufficient number of labouring hands . . . . Whenever from an extraordinary demand for manufactures, labour grows scarce, the labourers feel their own consequence, and will make their masters feel it likewise -- it is amazing; but so depraved are the dispositions of these people, that in such cases a set of workmen have combined to distress the employer by idling a whole day together. ? (--Essay, &c. ,? pp. 27, 28. ) The fellows in fact were hankering after a rise in wages.
20 Economist, Jan. 21. 1860.
21 Whilst during the last six months of 1866, 80-90,000 working people in London were thrown out of work, the Factory Report for that same half year says: --It does not appear absolutely true to say that demand will always produce supply just at the moment when it is needed. It has not done so with labour, for much machinery has been idle last year for want of hands. ? (--Rep. of Insp. of Fact. , 31st Oct. , 1866,? p. 81. )
22 Opening address to the Sanitary Conference, Birmingham, January 15th, 1875, by J. Chamberlain, Mayor of the town, now (1883) President of the Board of Trade.
23 781 towns given in the census for 1861 for England and Wales --contained 10,960,998 inhabitants, while the villages and country parishes contained 9,105,226. In 1851, 580 towns were distinguished, and the population in them and in the surrounding country was nearly equal. But while in the subsequent ten years the population in the villages and the country increased half a million, the population in the 580 towns increased by a million and a half (1,554,067). The increase of the population of the country parishes is 6. 5 per cent. , and of the towns 17. 3 per cent. The difference in the rates of increase is due to the migration from country to town. Three-fourths of the total increase of population has taken place in the towns. ? (--Census. &c. ,? pp. 11 and 12. )
24 --Poverty seems favourable to generation. ? (A. Smith. ) This is even a specially wise arrangement of God, according to the gallant and witty Abbe? Galiani --Iddio af che gli uomini che esercitano mestieri di prima utiliti nascono abbondantemente. ? (Galiani, l. c. , p. 78. ) [God ordains that men who carry on trades of primary utility are born in abundance] --Misery up to the extreme point of famine and pestilence, instead of checking, tends to increase population. ? (S. Laing, --National Distress,? 1844, p. 69. ) After Laing has illustrated this by statistics, he continues: --If the people were all in easy circumstances, the world would soon be depopulated. ?
25 --De jour en jour il devient donc plus clair que les rapports de production dans lesquels se meut la bourgeoisie n'ont pas un caracte`re un, un catacte`re simple, mais un caracte`re de duplicite? ; que dans les me^mes rapports dans lesquels se produit la richesse, la mise? re se produit aussi; que dans les me^mes rapports dans lesquels il y a de? veloppement des forces productives, il y a une force productive de re? pression; que ces rapports ne produisent la richesse bourgeoise, c'est-a`-dire la richesse de la classe bourgeoise, qu'en ane? antissant continuellement la richesse des membres inte? grants de cette classe et en produisant un prole? tariat toujours croissant. ? [From day to day it thus becomes clearer that the production relations in which the bourgeoisie moves have not a simple, uniform character, but a dual character; that in the selfsame relations in which wealth is produced, poverty is produced also; that in
? ? 490 Chapter 25
the selfsame relations in which there is a development of productive forces, there is also a force producing repression; that there relations produce bourgeois wealth, i. e. , the wealth of the bourgeois class, only by continually annihilating the wealth of the individual members of this class and by producing an evergrowing proletariat] (Karl Marx: --Mise`re de la Philosophie,? p. 116. )
26 G. Ortes: --Delia Economia Nazionale libri sei, 1777,? in Custodi, Parte Moderna, t. xxi, pp. 6, 9, 22, 25, etc. Ortes says, l. c. , p. 32: --In luoco di progettar sistemi inutili per la felicita` de'popoli, mi limitero` a investigate la region delta loro infelicita`. ? [Instead of projecting useless systems for achieving the happiness of people, I shall limit myself to investigating the reasons for their unhappiness]
27 --A Dissertation on the Poor Laws. By a Well-wisher of Mankind. (The Rev. J. Townsend) 1786,? republished Lond. 1817, pp. 15, 39, 41. This --delicate? parson, from whose work just quoted, as well as from his --Journey through Spain,? Malthus often copies whole pages, himself borrowed the greater part of his doctrine from Sir James Steuart, whom he however alters in the borrowing. E. g. , when Steuart says: --Here, in slavery, was a forcible method of making mankind diligent,? [for the non- workers] . . . --Men were then forced to work? [i. e. ,to work gratis for others], --because they were slaves of others; men are now forced to work? [i. e. , to work gratis for non-workers] --because they are the slaves of their necessities,? he does not thence conclude, like the fat holder of benefices, that the wage labourer must always go fasting. He wishes, on the contrary, to increase their wants and to make the increasing number of their wants a stimulus to their labour for the --more delicate. ?
28 Storch, l. c. , t. iii, p. 223.
29 Sismondi, l. c. , pp. 79, 80, 85.
30 Destutt de Tracy, l. c. , p. 231: --Les nations pauvres, c'est la` ou` le peuple est a` son aise; et les nations riches, c'est la` ou` il est ordinairement pauvre. ? [The poor nations are those where the people are comfortably off; and the rich nationss, those where the people are generally poor]
31 --Tenth Report of the Commissioners of H. M. Inland Revenue. ? Lond. , 1866. p. 38.
32 lbidem.
33 These figures are sufficient for comparison, but, taken absolutely, are false, since, perhaps, ? 100,000,000 of income are annually not declared. The complaints of the Inland Revenue Commissioners of systematic fraud, especially on the part of the commercial and industrial classes, are repeated in each of their reports. So e. g. , --A Joint-stock company returns ? 6,000 as assessable profits, the surveyor raises the amount to ? 88,000, and upon that sum duty is ultimately paid. Another company which returns ? 190,000 is finally compelled to admit that the true return should be ? 250,000. ? (Ibid. , p, 42. )
34 --Census, &c. ,? l. c. , p. 29. John Bright's assertion that 150 landlords own half of England, and 12 half the Scotch soil, has never been refuted.
35 --Fourth Report, &c. , of Inland Revenue. ? Lond. , 1860, p. 17.
36 hese are the net incomes after certain legally authorised abatements.
37 At this moment, March, 1867, the Indian and Chinese market is again overstocked by the consignments of the British cotton manufacturers. In 1866 a reduction in wages of 5 per cent. took place amongst the cotton operatives.
In 1867, as consequence of a similar operation, there was a strike of 20,000 men at Preston. [Added in the 4th German edition. -- That was the prelude to the crisis which broke out immediately afterwards. -- F. E. ]
38 --Census, &c. ,? l. c. , P. 11.
39 Gladstone in the House of Commons, Feb. 13th, 1843. Times, Feb. 14th, 1843 -- --It is one of the most melancholy features in the social state of this country that we see, beyond the possibility of
? ? 491 Chapter 25
denial, that while there is at this moment a decrease in the consuming powers of the people, an increase of the pressure of privations and distress; there is at the same time a constant accumulation of wealth in the upper classes, an increase of the luxuriousness of their habits, and of their means of enjoyment. ? (Hansard, 13th Feb. )
40 Gladstone in the House of Commons, April 16th, 1863. Morning Star, April 17th.
41 See the official accounts in the Blue book: --Miscellaneous Statistics of the United Kingdom,? Part vi. , London, 1866, pp. 260-273, passim. Instead of the statistics of orphan asylums, &c. , the declamations of the ministerial journals in recommending dowries for the Royal children might also serve. The greater dearness of the means of subsistence is never forgotten there.
42 Gladstone, House of Commons, 7th April, 1864. -- --The Hansard version runs: ? Again, and yet more at large -- what is human life, but, in the majority of cases, a struggle for existence. ' The continual crying contradictions in Gladstone's Budget speeches of 1863 and 1864 were characterised by an English writer by the following quotation from Boileau:
--Voila` l'homme en effet. Il va du blanc au noir,
Il condamne au matin ses sentiments du soir.
Importun a` tout autre, a` soi-me^me incommode,
Il change a` tout moment d'esprit comme de mode. ?
[Such is the man: he goes from black to white. / He condemns in the morning what he felt in the evening. / A nuisance to everyone else, and an inconvenience to himself, / he changes his way of thinking as easily as he changes his way of dressing]
(--The Theory of Exchanges, &c. ,? London, 1864, p. 135. )
43 H. Fawcett, l. c. , pp. 67-82. As to the increasing dependence of labourers on the retail shopkeepers, this is the consequence of the frequent oscillations and interruptions of their employment.
44 Wales here is always included in England.
45 A peculiar light is thrown on the advance made since the time of Adam Smith, by the fact that by him the word --workhouse? is still occasionally used as synonymous with --manufactory? ; e. g. , the opening of his chapter on the division of labour; --those employed in every different branch of the work can often be collected into the same workhouse. ?
46 --Public Health. Sixth Report, 1864,? p. 13. 47 l. c. , p. 17.
48 l. c. , p. 13.
49 l. c. , Appendix, p. 232.
50 l. c. , pp. 232, 233.
51 l. c. , pp. 14, 15.
52 --In no particular have the rights of persons been so avowedly and shamefully sacrificed to the rights of property as in regard to the lodging of the labouring class. Every large town may be looked upon as a place of human sacrifice, a shrine where thousands pass yearly through the fire as offerings to the moloch of avarice,? S. Laing, l. c. , p. 150.
53 --Public Health, Eighth Report. 1866. ? p. 14, note.
54 . c. , p. 89. With reference to the children in these colonies, Dr. Hunter says: --People are not now alive to tell us how children were brought up before this age of dense agglomerations of poor began, and he would be a rash prophet who should tell us what future behaviour is to be expected from the present growth of children, who, under circumstances probably never before paralleled in this country, are now completing their education for future practice, as 'dangerous classes' by sitting up half the night with persons of every age, half naked, drunken, obscene, and quarrelsome. ? (l. c. , p. 56. )
? ? 492
55 l. c. , p. 62.
56 --Report of the Officer of Health of St. Martins-in-the-Fields, 1865.
57 Public Health, Eighth Report, 1866,? p. 91.
Chapter 25
? 58 l. c. , p. 88.
59 l. c. , p. 88.
60 l. c. , p. 89.
61 l. c. , p. 55 and 56.
62 l. c. , p. 149.
63 l. c. , p. 50.
64
? ? ? ? COLLECTING AGENTS LIST (BRADFORD)
Houses
? ? ? ? ? ? Vulcan Street, No. 122
? ? ? ? 1 Room
? ? ? Lumiev Street, No. 13
? ? ? ? 1 Room
? ? ? Bower Street, No. 41
? ? ? ? ? ? 1 Room
? ? ? Portland Street. No. 112
? ? 1 Room
? ? ? Hardy Street, No. 17
? ? ? ? ? ? 1 Room
? ? ? North Street, No. 18
? ? ? ? 1 Room
? ? ? North Street, No. 17
? ?
18 Harriet Martineau, --A Manchester Strike,? 1832, p. 101.
19 Even in the cotton famine of 1863 we find, in a pamphlet of the operative cotton-spinners of Blackburn, fierce denunciations of overwork, which, in consequence of the Factory Acts, of course only affected adult male labourers. --The adult operatives at this mill have been asked to work from 12 to 13 hours per day, while there are hundreds who are compelled to be idle who would willingly work partial time, in order to maintain their families and save their brethren from a premature grave through
? ? 489 Chapter 25
being overworked. . . . We,? it goes on to say, --would ask if the practice of working overtime by a number of hands, is likely to create a good feeling between masters and servants. Those who are worked overtime feel the injustice equally with those who are condemned to forced idleness. There is in the district almost sufficient work to give to all partial employment if fairly distributed. We are only asking what is right in requesting the masters generally to pursue a system of short hours, particularly until a better state of things begins to dawn upon us, rather than to work a portion of the hands overtime, while others, for want of work, are compelled to exist upon charity. ? (--Reports of Insp. of Fact. , Oct. 31, 1863,? p. 8. ) The author of the --Essay on Trade and Commerce? grasps the effect of a relative surplus population on the employed labourers with his usual unerring bourgeois instinct. --Another cause of idleness in this kingdom is the want of a sufficient number of labouring hands . . . . Whenever from an extraordinary demand for manufactures, labour grows scarce, the labourers feel their own consequence, and will make their masters feel it likewise -- it is amazing; but so depraved are the dispositions of these people, that in such cases a set of workmen have combined to distress the employer by idling a whole day together. ? (--Essay, &c. ,? pp. 27, 28. ) The fellows in fact were hankering after a rise in wages.
20 Economist, Jan. 21. 1860.
21 Whilst during the last six months of 1866, 80-90,000 working people in London were thrown out of work, the Factory Report for that same half year says: --It does not appear absolutely true to say that demand will always produce supply just at the moment when it is needed. It has not done so with labour, for much machinery has been idle last year for want of hands. ? (--Rep. of Insp. of Fact. , 31st Oct. , 1866,? p. 81. )
22 Opening address to the Sanitary Conference, Birmingham, January 15th, 1875, by J. Chamberlain, Mayor of the town, now (1883) President of the Board of Trade.
23 781 towns given in the census for 1861 for England and Wales --contained 10,960,998 inhabitants, while the villages and country parishes contained 9,105,226. In 1851, 580 towns were distinguished, and the population in them and in the surrounding country was nearly equal. But while in the subsequent ten years the population in the villages and the country increased half a million, the population in the 580 towns increased by a million and a half (1,554,067). The increase of the population of the country parishes is 6. 5 per cent. , and of the towns 17. 3 per cent. The difference in the rates of increase is due to the migration from country to town. Three-fourths of the total increase of population has taken place in the towns. ? (--Census. &c. ,? pp. 11 and 12. )
24 --Poverty seems favourable to generation. ? (A. Smith. ) This is even a specially wise arrangement of God, according to the gallant and witty Abbe? Galiani --Iddio af che gli uomini che esercitano mestieri di prima utiliti nascono abbondantemente. ? (Galiani, l. c. , p. 78. ) [God ordains that men who carry on trades of primary utility are born in abundance] --Misery up to the extreme point of famine and pestilence, instead of checking, tends to increase population. ? (S. Laing, --National Distress,? 1844, p. 69. ) After Laing has illustrated this by statistics, he continues: --If the people were all in easy circumstances, the world would soon be depopulated. ?
25 --De jour en jour il devient donc plus clair que les rapports de production dans lesquels se meut la bourgeoisie n'ont pas un caracte`re un, un catacte`re simple, mais un caracte`re de duplicite? ; que dans les me^mes rapports dans lesquels se produit la richesse, la mise? re se produit aussi; que dans les me^mes rapports dans lesquels il y a de? veloppement des forces productives, il y a une force productive de re? pression; que ces rapports ne produisent la richesse bourgeoise, c'est-a`-dire la richesse de la classe bourgeoise, qu'en ane? antissant continuellement la richesse des membres inte? grants de cette classe et en produisant un prole? tariat toujours croissant. ? [From day to day it thus becomes clearer that the production relations in which the bourgeoisie moves have not a simple, uniform character, but a dual character; that in the selfsame relations in which wealth is produced, poverty is produced also; that in
? ? 490 Chapter 25
the selfsame relations in which there is a development of productive forces, there is also a force producing repression; that there relations produce bourgeois wealth, i. e. , the wealth of the bourgeois class, only by continually annihilating the wealth of the individual members of this class and by producing an evergrowing proletariat] (Karl Marx: --Mise`re de la Philosophie,? p. 116. )
26 G. Ortes: --Delia Economia Nazionale libri sei, 1777,? in Custodi, Parte Moderna, t. xxi, pp. 6, 9, 22, 25, etc. Ortes says, l. c. , p. 32: --In luoco di progettar sistemi inutili per la felicita` de'popoli, mi limitero` a investigate la region delta loro infelicita`. ? [Instead of projecting useless systems for achieving the happiness of people, I shall limit myself to investigating the reasons for their unhappiness]
27 --A Dissertation on the Poor Laws. By a Well-wisher of Mankind. (The Rev. J. Townsend) 1786,? republished Lond. 1817, pp. 15, 39, 41. This --delicate? parson, from whose work just quoted, as well as from his --Journey through Spain,? Malthus often copies whole pages, himself borrowed the greater part of his doctrine from Sir James Steuart, whom he however alters in the borrowing. E. g. , when Steuart says: --Here, in slavery, was a forcible method of making mankind diligent,? [for the non- workers] . . . --Men were then forced to work? [i. e. ,to work gratis for others], --because they were slaves of others; men are now forced to work? [i. e. , to work gratis for non-workers] --because they are the slaves of their necessities,? he does not thence conclude, like the fat holder of benefices, that the wage labourer must always go fasting. He wishes, on the contrary, to increase their wants and to make the increasing number of their wants a stimulus to their labour for the --more delicate. ?
28 Storch, l. c. , t. iii, p. 223.
29 Sismondi, l. c. , pp. 79, 80, 85.
30 Destutt de Tracy, l. c. , p. 231: --Les nations pauvres, c'est la` ou` le peuple est a` son aise; et les nations riches, c'est la` ou` il est ordinairement pauvre. ? [The poor nations are those where the people are comfortably off; and the rich nationss, those where the people are generally poor]
31 --Tenth Report of the Commissioners of H. M. Inland Revenue. ? Lond. , 1866. p. 38.
32 lbidem.
33 These figures are sufficient for comparison, but, taken absolutely, are false, since, perhaps, ? 100,000,000 of income are annually not declared. The complaints of the Inland Revenue Commissioners of systematic fraud, especially on the part of the commercial and industrial classes, are repeated in each of their reports. So e. g. , --A Joint-stock company returns ? 6,000 as assessable profits, the surveyor raises the amount to ? 88,000, and upon that sum duty is ultimately paid. Another company which returns ? 190,000 is finally compelled to admit that the true return should be ? 250,000. ? (Ibid. , p, 42. )
34 --Census, &c. ,? l. c. , p. 29. John Bright's assertion that 150 landlords own half of England, and 12 half the Scotch soil, has never been refuted.
35 --Fourth Report, &c. , of Inland Revenue. ? Lond. , 1860, p. 17.
36 hese are the net incomes after certain legally authorised abatements.
37 At this moment, March, 1867, the Indian and Chinese market is again overstocked by the consignments of the British cotton manufacturers. In 1866 a reduction in wages of 5 per cent. took place amongst the cotton operatives.
In 1867, as consequence of a similar operation, there was a strike of 20,000 men at Preston. [Added in the 4th German edition. -- That was the prelude to the crisis which broke out immediately afterwards. -- F. E. ]
38 --Census, &c. ,? l. c. , P. 11.
39 Gladstone in the House of Commons, Feb. 13th, 1843. Times, Feb. 14th, 1843 -- --It is one of the most melancholy features in the social state of this country that we see, beyond the possibility of
? ? 491 Chapter 25
denial, that while there is at this moment a decrease in the consuming powers of the people, an increase of the pressure of privations and distress; there is at the same time a constant accumulation of wealth in the upper classes, an increase of the luxuriousness of their habits, and of their means of enjoyment. ? (Hansard, 13th Feb. )
40 Gladstone in the House of Commons, April 16th, 1863. Morning Star, April 17th.
41 See the official accounts in the Blue book: --Miscellaneous Statistics of the United Kingdom,? Part vi. , London, 1866, pp. 260-273, passim. Instead of the statistics of orphan asylums, &c. , the declamations of the ministerial journals in recommending dowries for the Royal children might also serve. The greater dearness of the means of subsistence is never forgotten there.
42 Gladstone, House of Commons, 7th April, 1864. -- --The Hansard version runs: ? Again, and yet more at large -- what is human life, but, in the majority of cases, a struggle for existence. ' The continual crying contradictions in Gladstone's Budget speeches of 1863 and 1864 were characterised by an English writer by the following quotation from Boileau:
--Voila` l'homme en effet. Il va du blanc au noir,
Il condamne au matin ses sentiments du soir.
Importun a` tout autre, a` soi-me^me incommode,
Il change a` tout moment d'esprit comme de mode. ?
[Such is the man: he goes from black to white. / He condemns in the morning what he felt in the evening. / A nuisance to everyone else, and an inconvenience to himself, / he changes his way of thinking as easily as he changes his way of dressing]
(--The Theory of Exchanges, &c. ,? London, 1864, p. 135. )
43 H. Fawcett, l. c. , pp. 67-82. As to the increasing dependence of labourers on the retail shopkeepers, this is the consequence of the frequent oscillations and interruptions of their employment.
44 Wales here is always included in England.
45 A peculiar light is thrown on the advance made since the time of Adam Smith, by the fact that by him the word --workhouse? is still occasionally used as synonymous with --manufactory? ; e. g. , the opening of his chapter on the division of labour; --those employed in every different branch of the work can often be collected into the same workhouse. ?
46 --Public Health. Sixth Report, 1864,? p. 13. 47 l. c. , p. 17.
48 l. c. , p. 13.
49 l. c. , Appendix, p. 232.
50 l. c. , pp. 232, 233.
51 l. c. , pp. 14, 15.
52 --In no particular have the rights of persons been so avowedly and shamefully sacrificed to the rights of property as in regard to the lodging of the labouring class. Every large town may be looked upon as a place of human sacrifice, a shrine where thousands pass yearly through the fire as offerings to the moloch of avarice,? S. Laing, l. c. , p. 150.
53 --Public Health, Eighth Report. 1866. ? p. 14, note.
54 . c. , p. 89. With reference to the children in these colonies, Dr. Hunter says: --People are not now alive to tell us how children were brought up before this age of dense agglomerations of poor began, and he would be a rash prophet who should tell us what future behaviour is to be expected from the present growth of children, who, under circumstances probably never before paralleled in this country, are now completing their education for future practice, as 'dangerous classes' by sitting up half the night with persons of every age, half naked, drunken, obscene, and quarrelsome. ? (l. c. , p. 56. )
? ? 492
55 l. c. , p. 62.
56 --Report of the Officer of Health of St. Martins-in-the-Fields, 1865.
57 Public Health, Eighth Report, 1866,? p. 91.
Chapter 25
? 58 l. c. , p. 88.
59 l. c. , p. 88.
60 l. c. , p. 89.
61 l. c. , p. 55 and 56.
62 l. c. , p. 149.
63 l. c. , p. 50.
64
? ? ? ? COLLECTING AGENTS LIST (BRADFORD)
Houses
? ? ? ? ? ? Vulcan Street, No. 122
? ? ? ? 1 Room
? ? ? Lumiev Street, No. 13
? ? ? ? 1 Room
? ? ? Bower Street, No. 41
? ? ? ? ? ? 1 Room
? ? ? Portland Street. No. 112
? ? 1 Room
? ? ? Hardy Street, No. 17
? ? ? ? ? ? 1 Room
? ? ? North Street, No. 18
? ? ? ? 1 Room
? ? ? North Street, No. 17
? ?
