A clergy-
Acted superbly by Miss Irene Rooke and
man's young wife, who wants to widen her Mr.
Acted superbly by Miss Irene Rooke and
man's young wife, who wants to widen her Mr.
Athenaeum - London - 1912a
”
* love attains therein to perfect utter-
Dust and ashes, dead and done with, Venice spent
what Venice earned.
ance,
As Hope,
are now useless as presentments of
Fear, Joy and Grief,-though ampler stretch and
The soul, doubtless, is immortal-where a soul can passion
be discerned.
Once all was perfume-now, the flower is dead.
They seek and find in novel rhythm, fresh phrase, --
Galuppi's music is not less“ dust and
Were equally existent in far days
than the life of which it was once Gluck, Haydn, Mozart. Nor was Handel
ashes
Handel is represented as superseded by of Music's dim beginning-even so,
Truth was at full within thee long ago!
a concomitant:-
Stanza xiii.
even supreme in his own day :-
“ Dust and ashes ! ” So you creak it.
By no means ! Buononcini's work is theme In ‘Fifine at the Fair,' stanza xcii. ,
in you come with your cold music till I creep Geminiani-of whom Avison was a pupil
For tit laudation of the impartial few.
speaking of Schumann's 'Carnival,' the
through every nerve.
poet says :-
But this barrenness to the modern ear --and Dr. Pepusch are also mentioned.
only emphasizes the recognition in stanzas Though the music of Avison's day is
The stuff that 's made
vü. and viii. that in its own day Galuppi's
“ all alive once more,
it is as
the
To furnish man with thought and feeling is
purveyed
“ plaintive and commiserating music
figured worthies of a wax-work show. "
Substantially the same from age to age with change
served a useful purpose. It arrested, As representing “to-day's music-manu- Of the outside only for successive feasters.
though perhaps but momentarily, the facture," the reader'is referred to
The forms, the themes one without its
frivolity of ball, mask, and carnival. It Brahms, Wagner, Dvorak, Liszt. ”
counterpart
not only told them something” which Browning, however, has only sarcasm
Ages ago.
raised the question “Must we die ? " but for those who, contemptuously recognizing
refused to desist till its warning was the transience of all other music, imagine Nor do these passages touch the limit
heeded. So I interpret the line already that the creations of their own idol will of his appreciation of music's permanence.
quoted :-
last for all time. So, anyway, I interpret Witness Don Juan apostrophizing Schu-
Hark, the dominant's persistence till it must be
the line
Fifine,' and
answered to!
>
:
scope
66
no
in stanza
Since fatal Wagner fixed it fast for us. declaring that his thought
mann
Xc. of
## p. 543 (#413) ############################################
No. 4411, May 11, 1912
THE ATHENÆUM
543
one-
instead
by delicate colouring and restrained realistic
Of words, sought sounds, and saved for ever, in the touches. The suite was originally written
Dramatic Gossip.
same,
in the form of a piano duet.
Truth that escapes prose,-nay, puts poetry to THE 'Ring' is to be performed in its Mr. Maurice Baring on having produced at
It is pleasant to be able to congratulate
shame.
entirety at the Bristol Festival, which will
last a really good play. Technically con-
(Italics mine. )
take place October 23rd-26th, and un-
sidered, The Double Game' is far and
satisfactory as this concert performance
Of music that conserves the assurance, thou as
well
may appear to those who have opportunities away the most satisfactory stage work he
Here is none of that
of hearing the work with stage action, it discursiveness or lack of decision which
Wast certain of the same! thou, master of the
will be without doubt welcome to many
spell,
marred his earlier experiments. This is a
Mad'st moonbeams marble, didst record what lovers of music in the West. Wagner carefully planned, well-made play, with a
other men
himself, already in 1852, gave portions of plot that marches boldly forward and never
Feel only to forget!
his early operas on a concert platform, and loses itself in side issues. Grimly undeviating
(Italics Browning's: they occur in a pre- Richter and Mottl followed the composer's is its story of the Russian girl revolutionary,
vious use of the word. )
and by such means they prepared the way herself from shame and despair; clear and
It would, of course, show a strange mis- for the later music-dramas.
intelligible stand out the personalities of
conception of the function of poetry to
WAGNER was a prolific letter. writer, and the devoted heroine, the traitor and his
estimate the service it renders to an art
among other signs that the centenary of suspicious rival.
by the number of implements mentioned, his birth is not far off, a complete uniform But Mr. Baring's drama is something more
Yet a musician cannot but be interested edition of his letters, under the editorship of than a neat piece of mechanism. It handles
to observe that in a comparatively short Carl Fr. Glasenapp, is being published by unsensationally material which might seem
& Härtel. Seventeen | instinct with sensationalism. It is upon the
poem like ‘Charles Avison? Browning Messrs. Breitkopf
alludes to no fewer than five musical volumes are announced, but letters have still mental and emotional states of his trio of
“forms”-such as Sonata, Fugue, Suite-
to be collected from the Wahnfried archives, leading characters and their mutual re-
and others from various parts of the world ; actions that he fastens his and our attention,
nine instruments, and fifteen composers !
in the editing of these Paul Hans von not on the melodrama of their circumstances.
CLEMENT ANTROBUS HARRIS. Wolzogen will co-operate.
Similarly natural and unexaggerated is
The eight days?
festival which was to
his treatment of the background of his
take place at Salzburg has, for various tragedy. What strikes us, and what he
reasons, been postponed until next year.
means us to be struck with, is the unim-
passioned, almost apathetic mood in which
Musical Gossip.
VERDI's complete correspondence will the heroine's middle-class boarding-house
shortly be published. Madame Marla Car, associates receive news of revolutionary
events and discuss their consequences.
At the second of the series of concerts rara, his heir, has placed all the material
which Mr. Donald F. Tovey is giving Scherillo.
at the disposal of the editor, Signor Mr. Baring knows his modern Russia, and
at the Æolian Hall, the programme was
his contrast between the girl's enthusiasm
entirely devoted to his music. A
The report has been spread so often that and the calm acceptance of facts by the
composer programme is seldom successful. Arrigo Boito's ‘Nerone was about to be majority is obviously intentional.
Mr. Tovey is an accomplished musician, produced that one really began to wonder
Where the author still seems at fault is
and what he writes shows thorough ac.
whether it was
even written.
It is now in his reliance on rhetoric and in his in-
quaintance with the technique of his art. definitely stated that it will be given at ability to individualize his creations briefly
There were three works in his programme-
La Scala during the season 1912–13.
and economically. His men and women
a pianoforte trio, quartet, and quintet- In the current quarterly issue of The cannot explain themselves, except in long
but it was only in the last that he really Antiquary Mr. W. H. Grattan Flood gives speeches, and when, as in the case of his
created interest. In the first movement he an interesting account of Sebastian Westcott, subordinate figures, this resource is not
has bold and ably developed themes; in the an organist of St. Paul's who is not even available, he fails to differentiate them
second, though somewhat lengthy, are both named in so careful a compilation one from another, and a comment made
character and charm; while the Finale is J. E. West's Cathedral Organists'; yet, by one of them might just as well come
clever and spirited.
as Mr. Flood shows, he must have been a from any of half a dozen others. Still, in
MR. BALFOUR GARDINER gave his last person of prominenco in musical circles, and this new play the three protagonists emerge
as Master of the Children he is of real definitely enough, though at the expense of
concert at Queen's Hall on the 1st inst. importance in the early history of the drama. the rest, and it is to their representatives,
There many, interesting, numbers; The first known reference to him by name therefore, at the Kingsway that all the
but the most striking was Von Holst's
Oriental Suite, - Beni-Mora,' especially the
occurs in February, 1551/2, in the_House- opportunities of acting fall. Mr. Claude
Finale, in which realism plays a prominent hold Expenses of the Princess , Elizabeth King's
staccato manner suits the part of the
during her Residence in Hatfield. He pro- spy admirably ; Mr. Harcourt Williams's
part, yet as a means, not an end. The com-
poser furnished a brief outline of the pro-
bably died in 1584.
trick of explosiveness is telling in the
jealous rival's tirades; and Miss Ernita
gramme to which he worked; but even
Lascelles as the heroine shows nervous
without that help, one could feel atmosphere,
intensity without ever being betrayed into
colour, and skill in the music. A second Special Concert, 3. 30, Royal Albert Hall.
violence that is inartistic.
series of these interesting concerts is
announced to take place in the spring of
* THE NEW SIN,' Mr. Macdonald Hastings's
next year.
clever play which has fired the popular
imagination, has been put into the evening
MADAME CARREÑO gave
a pianoforte Mina Rode and Fred Helwig's Violin and Vocal Recital, 8. 15,
bill at the Criterion, and gives every sign of
recital at Queen's Hall on Tuesday afternoon. Meta Diestel's Song Recital, 8. 30, Steinway Hall.
justifying its promotion. Dialogue so witty
Her rendering of Beethoven's Waldstein'
and thoughtful, scenes and characters so
Sonata was tame; of brio in the first move-
Ernst von Lengyel's Pianoforte Recital, 3, Bechstein Hall. unconventional as are to be found in this
ment there was virtually no trace; while
piece, deserved a wider recognition than
in Chopin's Nocturne, Op. 48, and Fantaisie- Vivian Goswell's Vocal Recital, 8. 15, Bechstein Hall.
Tamini's Vocal Recital, 8. 18, Queen's Hall.
could be secured at matinée performances,
Polonaise, Op. 61, the playing, if technically
and
the enthusiasm of last Monday
fine, was almost soulless-a curious absence
night's Criterion audience suggests that such
of qualities which have won for the pianist
Mr. and Mrs. Dennis Drew's Vocal Kecital, 9. 30, Bechstein
acknowledgment will be fully accorded. The
so high and well-deserved a reputation.
Donald Tovey's Chopin Recital, 8. 30, Æolian Hall.
cast is virtually the same as that which was
SEÑOR CASALS gave an orchestral concert
engaged at the Royalty, except that Mr.
Grainger
Kerr's Vocal Recital, 8. 15, Æolian Hall.
Of his fine
Hallard now takes the hero's part. This is
at Queen's Hall last Saturday.
playing of Bach's 'Cello Suite in c, the only
as much as to say that the play is brilliantly
Adila, Hortense, and Jelly von Aráoyi's Chamber Concert, 3,
acted.
criticism we offer is that
of the
soft passages are not heard_to the best
WHEN a new author makes a success in
advantage in so large a hall. But there was
the theatre, commissions are apt to rain
May Mukle's 'Cello Recital, 8. Bechstein Hall.
a novelty in the programme an orchestral
upon him and the playwright becomes in
suite, 'Ma Mère l'Oie,' by Maurice Ravel.
as
were
PERFORMANCES NEXT WEEK.
Bus.
National Sunday League Concert, 7, Queen's Hall.
Mon. -Bar. Royal Opera, Covent Garden.
Mox. -SAT. London Opera House, Kingaway.
Mon. Auriol Jones's Pianoforte Recital, 3. 15, Eolian Hall.
Grace Thynne's Violin Recital, 3. 15, Bridgewater House.
William Murdoch's Pianoforte Recital, 3. 30, Bechstein Hall,
Bessie Mark's Vocal Recital, 8. 15, Bechstein Hall.
Æolian Hall.
Handel Society, 8. 30, Queen's Hall.
TUES. Titanic Disaster Fund, Matinée, Royal Opera, Covent Garden.
Gregory Hart's Concert, 3, Queen's Hall.
Nathan Fryer's Pianoforte Recital, 3 15, Æolian Hall,
Evelyn Dawkin's Pianoforte Recital, 8, Polinn Hall.
WED. F. S. Kelly's Orchestral concert. 3, Queen's Hall.
Vera Bianca's Vocal Recital, 8. 15, Æolian Hall.
Smallwood Metcalfe's Choir, 8. 10, Queen's Hall.
Hall.
111115
some
THURS. Twelve o'clock Chamber Concert, Æolian Hall.
Pablo Casals's Recital, 3, Queen's Hall.
Yvonne Astruc'. Violin Recital, 3. 15, Bechstein Hall
Armida Sepatra's Violin Recital, 8. 15, Bechstein Hall.
Sonia Darbell's Vocal Recital, 8. 30, Æolian Hall,
FRI.
Æolian Hall.
Marian Jay's Orchestral Concert, 8, Queen's Hall.
St. Petersburg String Quartet, 3, Bechstein Hall.
Gwendolen Logan's song Recitals, 3. 30 and 8. 45, Steinway Hall.
Montague F. Phillips's Orchestral Concert, 8. 15, Queen's Hall.
Beatrice Dunn and Clive Carey's Folk Song Recital, 8. 30,
IIIIII
too much of a hurry to satisfy managerial
Each of the five movements is of short
impatience. We surmise this is what has
compass, and the quaint music is enhanced
happened in the case of 'Love and What
Rolian Hall.
Mary LAW and Norman Wilks's Violin and Pianoforte
Recital, 3. Bechstein Hall,
Mitnitzki's Violin Recital, 3, Æolian Hall.
Mozart Society, 3, Portman Rooms,
Sat.
## p. 544 (#414) ############################################
544
No. 4411, May 11, 1912
THE A THENÆUM
BELL'S
BOOKS.
>>
The very
NAPOLEON
>>
Then ? ' which Mr. Cyril Maude has staged slips quietly away. The piquancy of the
MESSRS.
at the Playhouse, or it may be an earlier play, apart from the beauty of much of its
effort than "The New Sin. It certainly | language, consists in the contrast between
has not the compactness of plot and the the fiery rhetoric of the opening scene and
compelling interest of story that are that the subdued tone of that which follows.
work's great recommendations.
A clergy-
Acted superbly by Miss Irene Rooke and
man's young wife, who wants to widen her Mr. Milton Rosmer in the two chief parts, To be completed in 6 vols, demy 8vo, 108. Bl. net oach.
experience and invites kisses from an officer
* Miles Dixon' thoroughly deserved its
Vol. IIL. JUST PUBLISHED.
sho cares nothing about, is the character for enthusiastic reception.
Vols. I. and II. previously Published.
whom attention is chiefly solicited ; while
a bishop of the “human and “broad.
· The Younger Generation' is of a much THE CORRESPONDENCE OF
minded" type, provides the comic relief. lighter texture, but this gay little comedy is
As its title would
JONATHAN SWIFT.
The talks between the bishop and the quite in the movement.
rebellious girl. wife are amusing, but the suggest, it deals with the topic which
Edited by F. ELRINGTON BALL, Litt. D.
business of osculation would have been many of our more thoughtful playwrights
better omitted. Mr. Maude proves the most
have found fascinating—the revolt of pre-
With an Introduction by the Right Rev. the BISHOP OF
OSSORY.
genial of bishops, and his daughter Margery ences of age. Mr. Houghton's manipulation edition to the whole correspondence, both to and from
genial of bishops, and his daughter Margery sent-day youth against the restraining influ.
“For the first time we have the beginning of a complete
plays the heroine with an agreeable lightness of this theme pictures three children of a
of touch.
well - meaning
Nonconformist protesting best texts, and annotated with extreme elaboration
A STAGE fairy-tale, constructed out of the against their father's narrow notions, and
Swift's letters have
been often, but never well, edited
before this. . . . We congratulate Mr. Ball on an arduous
fortunes, legendary or historical, of the insisting on shaping their lives to suit their task faithfully executed, with a sure mastery of its
Rothschild family, sounds odd at first. own wishes. The humours of the piece are
bewildering complexity. "--Times.
Such is the fare in Carl Rössler's comedy of sometimes almost farcical in their extrava-
- The Five Frankforters' which Mr. Basil gance, but the author has the knack of JUST PUBLISHED. Medium 8vo, 108. Bd. net.
Hood has adapted for the Lyric Theatre. individualizing every one of his characters,
Artifice is of the play's essence.
and in addition he has high spirits and
PITT
costumes--of 1822_would seem to have had manages to keep his theme constantly in
their quaintness exaggerated. The dis evidence. The interpretation was satis.
tinctions drawn between the four famous fying, Mr. Stanley Drewitt's performance AND
banker-sons who attend in procession to pay in the part of the harassed father perhaps
homage to their unpretending mother on standing out from the acting of the rest.
Essays and Letters.
her birthday are patently accentuated in Mr. Houghton, it should be remarked, relies
By Dr. J. HOLLAND ROSE.
the direction of caricature. Fantastic is the on the new convention of the “ fourth wall. ”
Reader in Modern History, University of Cambridge.
atmosphere of the principality which bold
Baron Samuel proposes to annex by marry: Rede Lecture next June at Cambridge, and
PROF. GILBERT MURRAY is to give the "This book in reality forms the third volume of Dr.
Holland Rose's Life of Pitt. ' In it new and important
ing his daughter to its reigning, duke, and has chosen as his subject “The Chorus in
light is thrown on many points which arise both in
farcical is the behaviour of his Jowish
• William Pitt and National Revival' and ' William Pitt
Greek Tragedy. '
brothers at Court. Even the courtship of drama, the chorus, is in modern productions
The oldest part of Greek and the Great War. ' Taken together these three
volumes may be regarded as the standard bio-
pretty Rachel and that cousin David whose
the chief stumbling-block. Uncertain how
graphy of tho patriotic statesman whose untiring
attractiveness the family overlooks has the
exertions brought about the Union between
old-fashioned formality of a minuet, though not represent the views of the
to treat it, we are at least sure that it does England and Ireland. . . . One of the most important
' ideal
historical works which has appeared since the commence-
it serves to balk the ambitions of finance. spectator," as was formerly declared. Rather,
ment of the present century. " -Outlook.
Yet the sentiment, picturesqueness, and it seems to suggest Mrs. Grundy, and, like
humour of the piece make a thoroughly an up-to-date Censor, doubts concerning BY THE SAME AUTHOR.
successful appeal, especially as a cast includ.
ing Miss Henrietta Watson, Mr. C. M.
propriety in the wrong place.
THE
Lowne, Mr. Louis Calvert, Miss Gladys
Guy, and Mr. Henry Ainley furnishes acting Received.
TO CORRESPONDENTS. -F. G. S. -S. M. -M. C. -S. B. -
LIFE OF WILLIAM PITT
which is just in the right vein, and throws
H. H. -Many thanks.
Vol. 1. -WILLIAM PITT AND NATIONAL
into relief the idyllic qualities of the story.
No notice can be taken of anonymous communications.
REVIVAL
Miss HORNIMAN's company from Man- We cannot undertake to reply to inquiries concerning the Vol. II. -WILLIAM PITT AND THE GREAT
. chester is now on a visit to London to re-
appearance of reviews of books,
WAR
We do not undertake to give the value of books, china,
mind us that the repertory theatre still
pictures, &c.
Medium 8vo, with Photogravure Plates, 168. net each.
thrives in the provinces, and that there is
plenty of good acting in other than West-
“We may, specially recommend to our readers the
interesting chapters in which Dr. Holland Rose re-tells, in
End theatres. Her season at the Coronet
INDEX TO ADVERTISERS.
the light of much new evidence, the story of how this Union
began with revivals of Mr. Galsworthy's
(of Great Britain and Ireland) was brought about and the
motives that underlay it. "-Times.
Silver Box' and Mr. Bernard Shaw's
- Widowers' Houses,' both of them works
AUTHORS' AGENTS
which have contributed to the development
BELL & SONS
HANDBOOKS OF ENGLISH
of the drama of ideas, and both of them
BLACKWOOD & SONS
BOOKBINDING
pieces which, by reason of the balance each
LITERATURE.
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
of the playwrights preserves between his
CATALOGUES
Crown 8vo, 38. Bd. net each.
various characters, enable the company to EDUCATIONAL
show its all-round merit. It was not till
NEW VOLUME JUST PUBLISHED.
ENO'S FRUIT SALT
Wednesday night that Miss Horniman
EVERETT & Co. . .
THE AGE OF ALFRED
offered any novelties. Then came
two
at once—' Miles Dixon,' a two-act play by FARMER
(A. D. 664-1154).
Mr. Gilbert Cannan, and succeeding this, HUTCHINSON & Co.
By F. J. SNELL, M. A.
Mr. Stanley Houghton's comedy in three INSURANCE COMPANIES
acts, “The Younger Generation. '
522 POEMS BY ROBERT BROWNING.
The scene of Mr. Cannan's miniature
LECTURES . .
Illustrated and Decorated by BYAM SHAW. With
drama is a lonely farm in the Lake district,
520, 522
an Introduction by RICHARD GARNETT, LL. D. C. B.
and the hero who gives it its title is a wild
MAGAZINES, &c. . .
4th Edition. 38. 6d. net.
vagabond with the imagination of a poet,
MISCELLANEOUS. .
NOTES AND QUERIES .
whom a farmer's handsome wife drives from
A BROWNING TREASURE BOOK.
OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS
Extracts from Browning, Selected and Arranged by
her side after she has temporarily surrendered
A. M. WARBURTON. Wide fcap. 8vo, 28. 6d. net; or
PAUL & Co.
to the magic of his lawless tongue. Years
in stamped sheepskin, 88. Bd. net.
PROVIDENT INSTITUTIONS
later, when she is a widow, and her boy, who
SALES BY AUCTION
is obviously Miles's son, wishes to go, as
618 HANDBOOK TO ROBERT
SANDS & Co.
did Miles himself, into the wide world, the
BROWNING'S WORKS.
SHIPPING
once gay and reckless ne'er-do-well calls at
SIMPKIN, MARSHALL & Co. . .
By Mrs. SUTHERLAND ORR. 11th Edition, with a
the farm, grey-haired and reduced to the
Bibliography. Fcap. 8vo, 68.
SITUATIONS VACANT
trade of a travelling huckster ; still eloquent, SITUATIONS WANTED
but no longer confident, he dissuades the SOCIETIES . .
G. BELL & SONS, LTD. ,
lad from his proposed adventure, and then TYPE-WRITERS, &c.
Portugal Street, London, W. C.
6
.
PAGE
518
544
548
520
519
518
517
547
547
517
520
545
547
EXHIBITIONS
JACK
517
MACMILLAN & Co.
520
518
546
522
521
517
.
. .
. .
547
547
521
517
518
517
518
## p. 555 (#415) ############################################
No. 4412, May 18, 1912
THE ATHENÆUM
555
555
556
ANGLO - AXERICAN MEMORIES
EGYPTIAN LITERATURE
557558
668
559565
566
567
BRITISH NEW
& Textbook on
568-571
AND
671---574
WEEK. .
674-675
575-576
576
an
1780-1908,' catalogued the series of club flicting statements; and not less modest
SATURDAY, MAY 18, 1912. publications which are the best certificate are the disclaimer of original critical con-
extant of the historical spirit in Scotland. tribution, and the warm homage to Sir
CONTENTS.
The old history-makers were thus not Archibald Dunbar, Mr. Anderson, and the
PAGE neglected-far from it. Nevertheless, there work of Sir Archibald Lawrie, whose
THE EARLY CHRONICLES RELATING TO SCOTLAND
was room for some such co-ordinating name by some slip must have fallen out of
558 study as Sir Herbert Maxwell has under the mention of his book in the Preface.
THEORY AND PRACTICE (The Kingdom of God; Lon.
don's Underworld). .
* love attains therein to perfect utter-
Dust and ashes, dead and done with, Venice spent
what Venice earned.
ance,
As Hope,
are now useless as presentments of
Fear, Joy and Grief,-though ampler stretch and
The soul, doubtless, is immortal-where a soul can passion
be discerned.
Once all was perfume-now, the flower is dead.
They seek and find in novel rhythm, fresh phrase, --
Galuppi's music is not less“ dust and
Were equally existent in far days
than the life of which it was once Gluck, Haydn, Mozart. Nor was Handel
ashes
Handel is represented as superseded by of Music's dim beginning-even so,
Truth was at full within thee long ago!
a concomitant:-
Stanza xiii.
even supreme in his own day :-
“ Dust and ashes ! ” So you creak it.
By no means ! Buononcini's work is theme In ‘Fifine at the Fair,' stanza xcii. ,
in you come with your cold music till I creep Geminiani-of whom Avison was a pupil
For tit laudation of the impartial few.
speaking of Schumann's 'Carnival,' the
through every nerve.
poet says :-
But this barrenness to the modern ear --and Dr. Pepusch are also mentioned.
only emphasizes the recognition in stanzas Though the music of Avison's day is
The stuff that 's made
vü. and viii. that in its own day Galuppi's
“ all alive once more,
it is as
the
To furnish man with thought and feeling is
purveyed
“ plaintive and commiserating music
figured worthies of a wax-work show. "
Substantially the same from age to age with change
served a useful purpose. It arrested, As representing “to-day's music-manu- Of the outside only for successive feasters.
though perhaps but momentarily, the facture," the reader'is referred to
The forms, the themes one without its
frivolity of ball, mask, and carnival. It Brahms, Wagner, Dvorak, Liszt. ”
counterpart
not only told them something” which Browning, however, has only sarcasm
Ages ago.
raised the question “Must we die ? " but for those who, contemptuously recognizing
refused to desist till its warning was the transience of all other music, imagine Nor do these passages touch the limit
heeded. So I interpret the line already that the creations of their own idol will of his appreciation of music's permanence.
quoted :-
last for all time. So, anyway, I interpret Witness Don Juan apostrophizing Schu-
Hark, the dominant's persistence till it must be
the line
Fifine,' and
answered to!
>
:
scope
66
no
in stanza
Since fatal Wagner fixed it fast for us. declaring that his thought
mann
Xc. of
## p. 543 (#413) ############################################
No. 4411, May 11, 1912
THE ATHENÆUM
543
one-
instead
by delicate colouring and restrained realistic
Of words, sought sounds, and saved for ever, in the touches. The suite was originally written
Dramatic Gossip.
same,
in the form of a piano duet.
Truth that escapes prose,-nay, puts poetry to THE 'Ring' is to be performed in its Mr. Maurice Baring on having produced at
It is pleasant to be able to congratulate
shame.
entirety at the Bristol Festival, which will
last a really good play. Technically con-
(Italics mine. )
take place October 23rd-26th, and un-
sidered, The Double Game' is far and
satisfactory as this concert performance
Of music that conserves the assurance, thou as
well
may appear to those who have opportunities away the most satisfactory stage work he
Here is none of that
of hearing the work with stage action, it discursiveness or lack of decision which
Wast certain of the same! thou, master of the
will be without doubt welcome to many
spell,
marred his earlier experiments. This is a
Mad'st moonbeams marble, didst record what lovers of music in the West. Wagner carefully planned, well-made play, with a
other men
himself, already in 1852, gave portions of plot that marches boldly forward and never
Feel only to forget!
his early operas on a concert platform, and loses itself in side issues. Grimly undeviating
(Italics Browning's: they occur in a pre- Richter and Mottl followed the composer's is its story of the Russian girl revolutionary,
vious use of the word. )
and by such means they prepared the way herself from shame and despair; clear and
It would, of course, show a strange mis- for the later music-dramas.
intelligible stand out the personalities of
conception of the function of poetry to
WAGNER was a prolific letter. writer, and the devoted heroine, the traitor and his
estimate the service it renders to an art
among other signs that the centenary of suspicious rival.
by the number of implements mentioned, his birth is not far off, a complete uniform But Mr. Baring's drama is something more
Yet a musician cannot but be interested edition of his letters, under the editorship of than a neat piece of mechanism. It handles
to observe that in a comparatively short Carl Fr. Glasenapp, is being published by unsensationally material which might seem
& Härtel. Seventeen | instinct with sensationalism. It is upon the
poem like ‘Charles Avison? Browning Messrs. Breitkopf
alludes to no fewer than five musical volumes are announced, but letters have still mental and emotional states of his trio of
“forms”-such as Sonata, Fugue, Suite-
to be collected from the Wahnfried archives, leading characters and their mutual re-
and others from various parts of the world ; actions that he fastens his and our attention,
nine instruments, and fifteen composers !
in the editing of these Paul Hans von not on the melodrama of their circumstances.
CLEMENT ANTROBUS HARRIS. Wolzogen will co-operate.
Similarly natural and unexaggerated is
The eight days?
festival which was to
his treatment of the background of his
take place at Salzburg has, for various tragedy. What strikes us, and what he
reasons, been postponed until next year.
means us to be struck with, is the unim-
passioned, almost apathetic mood in which
Musical Gossip.
VERDI's complete correspondence will the heroine's middle-class boarding-house
shortly be published. Madame Marla Car, associates receive news of revolutionary
events and discuss their consequences.
At the second of the series of concerts rara, his heir, has placed all the material
which Mr. Donald F. Tovey is giving Scherillo.
at the disposal of the editor, Signor Mr. Baring knows his modern Russia, and
at the Æolian Hall, the programme was
his contrast between the girl's enthusiasm
entirely devoted to his music. A
The report has been spread so often that and the calm acceptance of facts by the
composer programme is seldom successful. Arrigo Boito's ‘Nerone was about to be majority is obviously intentional.
Mr. Tovey is an accomplished musician, produced that one really began to wonder
Where the author still seems at fault is
and what he writes shows thorough ac.
whether it was
even written.
It is now in his reliance on rhetoric and in his in-
quaintance with the technique of his art. definitely stated that it will be given at ability to individualize his creations briefly
There were three works in his programme-
La Scala during the season 1912–13.
and economically. His men and women
a pianoforte trio, quartet, and quintet- In the current quarterly issue of The cannot explain themselves, except in long
but it was only in the last that he really Antiquary Mr. W. H. Grattan Flood gives speeches, and when, as in the case of his
created interest. In the first movement he an interesting account of Sebastian Westcott, subordinate figures, this resource is not
has bold and ably developed themes; in the an organist of St. Paul's who is not even available, he fails to differentiate them
second, though somewhat lengthy, are both named in so careful a compilation one from another, and a comment made
character and charm; while the Finale is J. E. West's Cathedral Organists'; yet, by one of them might just as well come
clever and spirited.
as Mr. Flood shows, he must have been a from any of half a dozen others. Still, in
MR. BALFOUR GARDINER gave his last person of prominenco in musical circles, and this new play the three protagonists emerge
as Master of the Children he is of real definitely enough, though at the expense of
concert at Queen's Hall on the 1st inst. importance in the early history of the drama. the rest, and it is to their representatives,
There many, interesting, numbers; The first known reference to him by name therefore, at the Kingsway that all the
but the most striking was Von Holst's
Oriental Suite, - Beni-Mora,' especially the
occurs in February, 1551/2, in the_House- opportunities of acting fall. Mr. Claude
Finale, in which realism plays a prominent hold Expenses of the Princess , Elizabeth King's
staccato manner suits the part of the
during her Residence in Hatfield. He pro- spy admirably ; Mr. Harcourt Williams's
part, yet as a means, not an end. The com-
poser furnished a brief outline of the pro-
bably died in 1584.
trick of explosiveness is telling in the
jealous rival's tirades; and Miss Ernita
gramme to which he worked; but even
Lascelles as the heroine shows nervous
without that help, one could feel atmosphere,
intensity without ever being betrayed into
colour, and skill in the music. A second Special Concert, 3. 30, Royal Albert Hall.
violence that is inartistic.
series of these interesting concerts is
announced to take place in the spring of
* THE NEW SIN,' Mr. Macdonald Hastings's
next year.
clever play which has fired the popular
imagination, has been put into the evening
MADAME CARREÑO gave
a pianoforte Mina Rode and Fred Helwig's Violin and Vocal Recital, 8. 15,
bill at the Criterion, and gives every sign of
recital at Queen's Hall on Tuesday afternoon. Meta Diestel's Song Recital, 8. 30, Steinway Hall.
justifying its promotion. Dialogue so witty
Her rendering of Beethoven's Waldstein'
and thoughtful, scenes and characters so
Sonata was tame; of brio in the first move-
Ernst von Lengyel's Pianoforte Recital, 3, Bechstein Hall. unconventional as are to be found in this
ment there was virtually no trace; while
piece, deserved a wider recognition than
in Chopin's Nocturne, Op. 48, and Fantaisie- Vivian Goswell's Vocal Recital, 8. 15, Bechstein Hall.
Tamini's Vocal Recital, 8. 18, Queen's Hall.
could be secured at matinée performances,
Polonaise, Op. 61, the playing, if technically
and
the enthusiasm of last Monday
fine, was almost soulless-a curious absence
night's Criterion audience suggests that such
of qualities which have won for the pianist
Mr. and Mrs. Dennis Drew's Vocal Kecital, 9. 30, Bechstein
acknowledgment will be fully accorded. The
so high and well-deserved a reputation.
Donald Tovey's Chopin Recital, 8. 30, Æolian Hall.
cast is virtually the same as that which was
SEÑOR CASALS gave an orchestral concert
engaged at the Royalty, except that Mr.
Grainger
Kerr's Vocal Recital, 8. 15, Æolian Hall.
Of his fine
Hallard now takes the hero's part. This is
at Queen's Hall last Saturday.
playing of Bach's 'Cello Suite in c, the only
as much as to say that the play is brilliantly
Adila, Hortense, and Jelly von Aráoyi's Chamber Concert, 3,
acted.
criticism we offer is that
of the
soft passages are not heard_to the best
WHEN a new author makes a success in
advantage in so large a hall. But there was
the theatre, commissions are apt to rain
May Mukle's 'Cello Recital, 8. Bechstein Hall.
a novelty in the programme an orchestral
upon him and the playwright becomes in
suite, 'Ma Mère l'Oie,' by Maurice Ravel.
as
were
PERFORMANCES NEXT WEEK.
Bus.
National Sunday League Concert, 7, Queen's Hall.
Mon. -Bar. Royal Opera, Covent Garden.
Mox. -SAT. London Opera House, Kingaway.
Mon. Auriol Jones's Pianoforte Recital, 3. 15, Eolian Hall.
Grace Thynne's Violin Recital, 3. 15, Bridgewater House.
William Murdoch's Pianoforte Recital, 3. 30, Bechstein Hall,
Bessie Mark's Vocal Recital, 8. 15, Bechstein Hall.
Æolian Hall.
Handel Society, 8. 30, Queen's Hall.
TUES. Titanic Disaster Fund, Matinée, Royal Opera, Covent Garden.
Gregory Hart's Concert, 3, Queen's Hall.
Nathan Fryer's Pianoforte Recital, 3 15, Æolian Hall,
Evelyn Dawkin's Pianoforte Recital, 8, Polinn Hall.
WED. F. S. Kelly's Orchestral concert. 3, Queen's Hall.
Vera Bianca's Vocal Recital, 8. 15, Æolian Hall.
Smallwood Metcalfe's Choir, 8. 10, Queen's Hall.
Hall.
111115
some
THURS. Twelve o'clock Chamber Concert, Æolian Hall.
Pablo Casals's Recital, 3, Queen's Hall.
Yvonne Astruc'. Violin Recital, 3. 15, Bechstein Hall
Armida Sepatra's Violin Recital, 8. 15, Bechstein Hall.
Sonia Darbell's Vocal Recital, 8. 30, Æolian Hall,
FRI.
Æolian Hall.
Marian Jay's Orchestral Concert, 8, Queen's Hall.
St. Petersburg String Quartet, 3, Bechstein Hall.
Gwendolen Logan's song Recitals, 3. 30 and 8. 45, Steinway Hall.
Montague F. Phillips's Orchestral Concert, 8. 15, Queen's Hall.
Beatrice Dunn and Clive Carey's Folk Song Recital, 8. 30,
IIIIII
too much of a hurry to satisfy managerial
Each of the five movements is of short
impatience. We surmise this is what has
compass, and the quaint music is enhanced
happened in the case of 'Love and What
Rolian Hall.
Mary LAW and Norman Wilks's Violin and Pianoforte
Recital, 3. Bechstein Hall,
Mitnitzki's Violin Recital, 3, Æolian Hall.
Mozart Society, 3, Portman Rooms,
Sat.
## p. 544 (#414) ############################################
544
No. 4411, May 11, 1912
THE A THENÆUM
BELL'S
BOOKS.
>>
The very
NAPOLEON
>>
Then ? ' which Mr. Cyril Maude has staged slips quietly away. The piquancy of the
MESSRS.
at the Playhouse, or it may be an earlier play, apart from the beauty of much of its
effort than "The New Sin. It certainly | language, consists in the contrast between
has not the compactness of plot and the the fiery rhetoric of the opening scene and
compelling interest of story that are that the subdued tone of that which follows.
work's great recommendations.
A clergy-
Acted superbly by Miss Irene Rooke and
man's young wife, who wants to widen her Mr. Milton Rosmer in the two chief parts, To be completed in 6 vols, demy 8vo, 108. Bl. net oach.
experience and invites kisses from an officer
* Miles Dixon' thoroughly deserved its
Vol. IIL. JUST PUBLISHED.
sho cares nothing about, is the character for enthusiastic reception.
Vols. I. and II. previously Published.
whom attention is chiefly solicited ; while
a bishop of the “human and “broad.
· The Younger Generation' is of a much THE CORRESPONDENCE OF
minded" type, provides the comic relief. lighter texture, but this gay little comedy is
As its title would
JONATHAN SWIFT.
The talks between the bishop and the quite in the movement.
rebellious girl. wife are amusing, but the suggest, it deals with the topic which
Edited by F. ELRINGTON BALL, Litt. D.
business of osculation would have been many of our more thoughtful playwrights
better omitted. Mr. Maude proves the most
have found fascinating—the revolt of pre-
With an Introduction by the Right Rev. the BISHOP OF
OSSORY.
genial of bishops, and his daughter Margery ences of age. Mr. Houghton's manipulation edition to the whole correspondence, both to and from
genial of bishops, and his daughter Margery sent-day youth against the restraining influ.
“For the first time we have the beginning of a complete
plays the heroine with an agreeable lightness of this theme pictures three children of a
of touch.
well - meaning
Nonconformist protesting best texts, and annotated with extreme elaboration
A STAGE fairy-tale, constructed out of the against their father's narrow notions, and
Swift's letters have
been often, but never well, edited
before this. . . . We congratulate Mr. Ball on an arduous
fortunes, legendary or historical, of the insisting on shaping their lives to suit their task faithfully executed, with a sure mastery of its
Rothschild family, sounds odd at first. own wishes. The humours of the piece are
bewildering complexity. "--Times.
Such is the fare in Carl Rössler's comedy of sometimes almost farcical in their extrava-
- The Five Frankforters' which Mr. Basil gance, but the author has the knack of JUST PUBLISHED. Medium 8vo, 108. Bd. net.
Hood has adapted for the Lyric Theatre. individualizing every one of his characters,
Artifice is of the play's essence.
and in addition he has high spirits and
PITT
costumes--of 1822_would seem to have had manages to keep his theme constantly in
their quaintness exaggerated. The dis evidence. The interpretation was satis.
tinctions drawn between the four famous fying, Mr. Stanley Drewitt's performance AND
banker-sons who attend in procession to pay in the part of the harassed father perhaps
homage to their unpretending mother on standing out from the acting of the rest.
Essays and Letters.
her birthday are patently accentuated in Mr. Houghton, it should be remarked, relies
By Dr. J. HOLLAND ROSE.
the direction of caricature. Fantastic is the on the new convention of the “ fourth wall. ”
Reader in Modern History, University of Cambridge.
atmosphere of the principality which bold
Baron Samuel proposes to annex by marry: Rede Lecture next June at Cambridge, and
PROF. GILBERT MURRAY is to give the "This book in reality forms the third volume of Dr.
Holland Rose's Life of Pitt. ' In it new and important
ing his daughter to its reigning, duke, and has chosen as his subject “The Chorus in
light is thrown on many points which arise both in
farcical is the behaviour of his Jowish
• William Pitt and National Revival' and ' William Pitt
Greek Tragedy. '
brothers at Court. Even the courtship of drama, the chorus, is in modern productions
The oldest part of Greek and the Great War. ' Taken together these three
volumes may be regarded as the standard bio-
pretty Rachel and that cousin David whose
the chief stumbling-block. Uncertain how
graphy of tho patriotic statesman whose untiring
attractiveness the family overlooks has the
exertions brought about the Union between
old-fashioned formality of a minuet, though not represent the views of the
to treat it, we are at least sure that it does England and Ireland. . . . One of the most important
' ideal
historical works which has appeared since the commence-
it serves to balk the ambitions of finance. spectator," as was formerly declared. Rather,
ment of the present century. " -Outlook.
Yet the sentiment, picturesqueness, and it seems to suggest Mrs. Grundy, and, like
humour of the piece make a thoroughly an up-to-date Censor, doubts concerning BY THE SAME AUTHOR.
successful appeal, especially as a cast includ.
ing Miss Henrietta Watson, Mr. C. M.
propriety in the wrong place.
THE
Lowne, Mr. Louis Calvert, Miss Gladys
Guy, and Mr. Henry Ainley furnishes acting Received.
TO CORRESPONDENTS. -F. G. S. -S. M. -M. C. -S. B. -
LIFE OF WILLIAM PITT
which is just in the right vein, and throws
H. H. -Many thanks.
Vol. 1. -WILLIAM PITT AND NATIONAL
into relief the idyllic qualities of the story.
No notice can be taken of anonymous communications.
REVIVAL
Miss HORNIMAN's company from Man- We cannot undertake to reply to inquiries concerning the Vol. II. -WILLIAM PITT AND THE GREAT
. chester is now on a visit to London to re-
appearance of reviews of books,
WAR
We do not undertake to give the value of books, china,
mind us that the repertory theatre still
pictures, &c.
Medium 8vo, with Photogravure Plates, 168. net each.
thrives in the provinces, and that there is
plenty of good acting in other than West-
“We may, specially recommend to our readers the
interesting chapters in which Dr. Holland Rose re-tells, in
End theatres. Her season at the Coronet
INDEX TO ADVERTISERS.
the light of much new evidence, the story of how this Union
began with revivals of Mr. Galsworthy's
(of Great Britain and Ireland) was brought about and the
motives that underlay it. "-Times.
Silver Box' and Mr. Bernard Shaw's
- Widowers' Houses,' both of them works
AUTHORS' AGENTS
which have contributed to the development
BELL & SONS
HANDBOOKS OF ENGLISH
of the drama of ideas, and both of them
BLACKWOOD & SONS
BOOKBINDING
pieces which, by reason of the balance each
LITERATURE.
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
of the playwrights preserves between his
CATALOGUES
Crown 8vo, 38. Bd. net each.
various characters, enable the company to EDUCATIONAL
show its all-round merit. It was not till
NEW VOLUME JUST PUBLISHED.
ENO'S FRUIT SALT
Wednesday night that Miss Horniman
EVERETT & Co. . .
THE AGE OF ALFRED
offered any novelties. Then came
two
at once—' Miles Dixon,' a two-act play by FARMER
(A. D. 664-1154).
Mr. Gilbert Cannan, and succeeding this, HUTCHINSON & Co.
By F. J. SNELL, M. A.
Mr. Stanley Houghton's comedy in three INSURANCE COMPANIES
acts, “The Younger Generation. '
522 POEMS BY ROBERT BROWNING.
The scene of Mr. Cannan's miniature
LECTURES . .
Illustrated and Decorated by BYAM SHAW. With
drama is a lonely farm in the Lake district,
520, 522
an Introduction by RICHARD GARNETT, LL. D. C. B.
and the hero who gives it its title is a wild
MAGAZINES, &c. . .
4th Edition. 38. 6d. net.
vagabond with the imagination of a poet,
MISCELLANEOUS. .
NOTES AND QUERIES .
whom a farmer's handsome wife drives from
A BROWNING TREASURE BOOK.
OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS
Extracts from Browning, Selected and Arranged by
her side after she has temporarily surrendered
A. M. WARBURTON. Wide fcap. 8vo, 28. 6d. net; or
PAUL & Co.
to the magic of his lawless tongue. Years
in stamped sheepskin, 88. Bd. net.
PROVIDENT INSTITUTIONS
later, when she is a widow, and her boy, who
SALES BY AUCTION
is obviously Miles's son, wishes to go, as
618 HANDBOOK TO ROBERT
SANDS & Co.
did Miles himself, into the wide world, the
BROWNING'S WORKS.
SHIPPING
once gay and reckless ne'er-do-well calls at
SIMPKIN, MARSHALL & Co. . .
By Mrs. SUTHERLAND ORR. 11th Edition, with a
the farm, grey-haired and reduced to the
Bibliography. Fcap. 8vo, 68.
SITUATIONS VACANT
trade of a travelling huckster ; still eloquent, SITUATIONS WANTED
but no longer confident, he dissuades the SOCIETIES . .
G. BELL & SONS, LTD. ,
lad from his proposed adventure, and then TYPE-WRITERS, &c.
Portugal Street, London, W. C.
6
.
PAGE
518
544
548
520
519
518
517
547
547
517
520
545
547
EXHIBITIONS
JACK
517
MACMILLAN & Co.
520
518
546
522
521
517
.
. .
. .
547
547
521
517
518
517
518
## p. 555 (#415) ############################################
No. 4412, May 18, 1912
THE ATHENÆUM
555
555
556
ANGLO - AXERICAN MEMORIES
EGYPTIAN LITERATURE
557558
668
559565
566
567
BRITISH NEW
& Textbook on
568-571
AND
671---574
WEEK. .
674-675
575-576
576
an
1780-1908,' catalogued the series of club flicting statements; and not less modest
SATURDAY, MAY 18, 1912. publications which are the best certificate are the disclaimer of original critical con-
extant of the historical spirit in Scotland. tribution, and the warm homage to Sir
CONTENTS.
The old history-makers were thus not Archibald Dunbar, Mr. Anderson, and the
PAGE neglected-far from it. Nevertheless, there work of Sir Archibald Lawrie, whose
THE EARLY CHRONICLES RELATING TO SCOTLAND
was room for some such co-ordinating name by some slip must have fallen out of
558 study as Sir Herbert Maxwell has under the mention of his book in the Preface.
THEORY AND PRACTICE (The Kingdom of God; Lon.
don's Underworld). .
