The Five
Skandhas
and the Unconditioned Dharmas 81
H.
H.
Abhidharmakosabhasyam-Vol-1-Vasubandhu-Poussin-Pruden-1991
?
VASUl-sAfOliU
? Abhidharmakosabhasyam Volume I
? Abhidharmakosabhasyam
of Vasubandhu
Volume I
Translated into French by Louis de La Vallee Poussin
English Version by Leo M. Pruden
ASIAN HUMANITIES PRESS [An imprint of Jain Publishing Company]
Web Site -- www. jainpub. com
? ASIAN HUMANITIES PRESS
Asian Humanities Press offers to the specialist and the general reader alike the best in new translations of major works and significant original contributions to enhance our understanding of Asian religions, cultures and thought.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
V asubandhu.
[AbhidharmakoSabhasya. English]
AbhidharmakoSabhasyam / [translated] by Louis de La Vallee Poussin; English
translation by Leo M. Pruden. -- Berkeley, Calif. : Asian Humanities Press, 1988- 1990.
4 v. ; 23 cm.
Translation of: Abhidharmako? abhasya. Includes bibliographies.
ISBN 0-89581-913-9 (set).
1. Vasubandhu. Abhidharmakosa.
2. Abhidharma.
I. La Vallee Poussin,
87-71231 AACR 2 MARC
Louis de, 1869-1938. BQ2682. E5P78 1988 294. 3'824? del 9
II. Title.
Copyright (R) 1991 by Asian Humanities Press. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the written permission of Asian Humanities Press except for brief passages quoted in a review.
? CONTENTS
A Brief Biography of Louis de La Valine Poussin xv Translator's Preface xxi
The Abhidharma:
The Origins, Growth and Development of a Literary Tradition
by Leo M. Pruden
1. Origin and Growth of Abhidharma xxx 2. Abhidhamma as "higher dhamma" xxxi 3. Abhidhamma alone xxxiii 4. Abhidhamma-kathd xxxv 5. Traditional Explanations of Abhidhamma xxxvi 6. Abhidharma in the Mahdvibhasd xxxvi 7. The Abhidhamma Pitaka xxxvii 8. The Mdtika xxxviii 9. Mdtika and Abhidharma xxxix
10. Abhidharma in the Agamas: the Religion of the Agamas xl 11. The Agamas and the Nikdyas xli 12. Abhidharmic Tendencies in Extant Agamas:
Numerical Categories, Samyuktas, and Vibhangas xlii
13. Sarvastivadin Agamas xliii
14. Samathadeva's Commentary xlv
15. Sarvastivadin Abhidharma Literature xlvi
16. Origin of the Abhidharma xlvi
17. The Second Period of Early Sarvastivadin Literature xlix 18. TheJnanaprasthdna li 19. The Vibhdsds lii 20. Development of the Literature After the Vibhdsds liii
21. The Abhidharma-hrdaya liii 22. The Abhidharmakosabhasyam liv 23. Sanskrit Remains of the Abhidharma lv
? 24. The Sanskrit Kosabhdsyam lvi 25. Translations of the Abhidharmakosabhdsyam lvii 26. Commentaries on the Abhidharmakosabhdsyam lvii 27. The Tibetan Kosabhdsyam lviii 28. Translations of the Kosabhdsyam and the F^/y/rf lix 29. Indexes to the Kosabhdsyam lix Footnotes lxii
Abhidharmakosabhasyam of Vasubandhu
by Louis de La Vallee Poussin
Introduction 1 I. Bibliography of the Kosa 7 A. Additions to the Bibliography, by Hurbert Durt 12
II. The Date of Vasubandhu. The Former Vasubandhu 13 III. The Seven Ginonical Treatises of the Abhidharma 17 A. TheJndnaprasthdna 17
B. The Prakarana of Vasumitra 20 C The Vijfidkdya 21 D. The Dharmaskandha 23 E. The Prajndptisdstra 24 F. The Dhdtukdya 27 G. The SamgUiparyaya 28
IV. Some Masters of the Vibhasa 28 A. Vasumitra 28 B. Ghosaka and the Abhidharmamrtasdstra 31 C Buddhadeva 32 D. Dharmabrdta 32 E. The Bhadanta Dharmatrdta 33
V. Some Schools of the Vibhasa 35 A. Ddastdnitkas and Sautrantikas 35 B. Vibhajyavadins 38 C Yogdcdrins 41
VI. The $ariputrdbhidharma 42 VIII. The Abhidharmasdra 44 Footnotes 49
? Chapter One: The Dhdtus
General Introduction
A. Homage to the Buddha
1. The Three Qualities of a Buddha B. Definition of Abhidharma
1. Absolute Sense of the Word
2. Conventional Sense of the Word C Definition of Abhidharmakosa
D. Purpose of the Abhidharma E. Authors of the Abhidharma
I. The Division of the Dharmas A. The Defiled Dharmas
B. The Undefiled Dharmas
C TheUnconditionedDharmas
1. Discussion of the Two Types of Disjunaion
2. Is Disjunaion Single or Multiple? D. ConditionedDharmas
1. Synonyms of "Conditioned" 2. Synonyms of "Defiled"
II. The Five Skandhas, the Twelve Ayatanas, and the Eighteen Dhdtus
A. RupaSkandha 1. Visible Matter 2. Sound
3. Taste
4. Odor
5. Tangible Things
B. The Relationship between the Five Consciousnesses
and the Five Visayas G Avijnaptirupa
D. TheFourPrimaryElements
E. The Definition of "Rupa"
F. The Ten Ayatanas and the Ten Dhdtus
G. The Vedand, Samjnd, and Samskdra Skandhas
55 55 55 56 56 56 57 57 58
58
59
59
59
59
59
61
61
62
63 63 64 65 66 66 66
66
67 68 70
72 72
? H. The Vijnana Skandha and the Mana Ayatana 14 I. The Seven Dhatus 74 J. The Manodhatu and the Eighteen Dhatus 75
The Threefold Classification of the Dharmas 16
A. The Threefold Classification of the Dharmas 16
B. The Nature of the Eighteen Dhatus 1(S
G The Definition of "Skandha," "Ayatana" and "Dhatu" 11
D. Their Provisional Existence 79
E. The Reason for the Threefold Classification 80
F. Distinctions between Vedana and Samjna 81
G. The Five Skandhas and the Unconditioned Dharmas 81
H. The Order of the Five Skandhas 82
I. The Order of the Ayatanas and Dhatus,
with Reference to the Six Indriyas 83
Some Problems Raised by the Threefold Classification 85
A. The Rupa Ayatana and the Dharma Ayatana 85
B. Inclusion in Other Skandhas, Ayatanas, and Dhatus 86
C The Eighty-four Thousand Dharmaskandhas 86
D. E.
F.
The Dimension of a Dharmaskandha 86 The Characteristics of the Skandhas and the
Threefold Classification 87 Vijnanadhdtu and Akasadhdtu 88
Classification of the Dharmas in the Eighteen Dhatus 90 A. Visible and Invisible Dharmas 90 B. Resistant and Non-Resistant Dharmas 90 C. Good, Bad, and Morally Neutral Dharmas 90 D. The Eighteen Dhatus and the Three Realms ? ? E. Pure and Impure Dhatus 95 F. Vitarka and Vicara 96 G. Vitarka, Vicara, and the Five Sense Consciousnesses 97
H. Discussions
1. How many Dhatus Serve as an Object? 98 2. How many are Non-Appropriated
to Living Beings? 98
? I. Primary and Derived Elements 99 J. Discussion
1. Can the Atoms be Accumulated? 101
2. How many of the Dhatus Cut or are Cut?
Burn or are Burned? Weight or are Weight? 102
3. How many of the Dhatus are vipdka?
Accumulations? Outflowings? 103
4. How many of the Dhatus are Real Substances? 105
5. How many of the Dhatus are Momentary? 105
K. Possession of a Dhatu versus a Vijndnadhatu 106 L. Internal and External Elements 107 M. Sabhdga and Tatsabhdga 108
N. HowaretheDhatusAbandoned? Ill O. How many of the Dhatus are "View? " 113
VI. Subsidiary Discussions 118
A. Are Visible Things Seen by One or Two Eyes? 118
B. Do the Indriyas and the Visayas Touch? 119
C. The Dimension of the Organs and their Visayas 122
D. Atoms within the Organs 123
E. Are Atoms Sabhdga or Tatsabhdga} 123
F. Time and the Support of the Consciousnesses 124
G. Why are the Organs, and not the Object,
the Support of the Consciousness? 125
H. How are the Different Consciousnesses Named? 125
I. The Body, the Organ of Sight, Visible Things,
and the Consciousness, and their Relationship
to the Different Bhumis 126
J. Which Dhatu is Discerned by Which Consciousness? 129
K. How many of the Dhatus are Eternal? 130
L. How many of the Dhatus are Indriyas? 130 131
? Chapter Two: The Indriyas
The Indriyas 153 A. Definition 153 1. Objection 155 B. General Explanation 155
The Twenty-two Indriyas 158
A. A Different Definition 159
B. The Organs of Sensation 160 1. The Saint 162
C Pure and Impure Indriyas 163
D.
The Five Skandhas and the Unconditioned Dharmas 81
H. The Order of the Five Skandhas 82
I. The Order of the Ayatanas and Dhatus,
with Reference to the Six Indriyas 83
Some Problems Raised by the Threefold Classification 85
A. The Rupa Ayatana and the Dharma Ayatana 85
B. Inclusion in Other Skandhas, Ayatanas, and Dhatus 86
C The Eighty-four Thousand Dharmaskandhas 86
D. E.
F.
The Dimension of a Dharmaskandha 86 The Characteristics of the Skandhas and the
Threefold Classification 87 Vijnanadhdtu and Akasadhdtu 88
Classification of the Dharmas in the Eighteen Dhatus 90 A. Visible and Invisible Dharmas 90 B. Resistant and Non-Resistant Dharmas 90 C. Good, Bad, and Morally Neutral Dharmas 90 D. The Eighteen Dhatus and the Three Realms ? ? E. Pure and Impure Dhatus 95 F. Vitarka and Vicara 96 G. Vitarka, Vicara, and the Five Sense Consciousnesses 97
H. Discussions
1. How many Dhatus Serve as an Object? 98 2. How many are Non-Appropriated
to Living Beings? 98
? I. Primary and Derived Elements 99 J. Discussion
1. Can the Atoms be Accumulated? 101
2. How many of the Dhatus Cut or are Cut?
Burn or are Burned? Weight or are Weight? 102
3. How many of the Dhatus are vipdka?
Accumulations? Outflowings? 103
4. How many of the Dhatus are Real Substances? 105
5. How many of the Dhatus are Momentary? 105
K. Possession of a Dhatu versus a Vijndnadhatu 106 L. Internal and External Elements 107 M. Sabhdga and Tatsabhdga 108
N. HowaretheDhatusAbandoned? Ill O. How many of the Dhatus are "View? " 113
VI. Subsidiary Discussions 118
A. Are Visible Things Seen by One or Two Eyes? 118
B. Do the Indriyas and the Visayas Touch? 119
C. The Dimension of the Organs and their Visayas 122
D. Atoms within the Organs 123
E. Are Atoms Sabhdga or Tatsabhdga} 123
F. Time and the Support of the Consciousnesses 124
G. Why are the Organs, and not the Object,
the Support of the Consciousness? 125
H. How are the Different Consciousnesses Named? 125
I. The Body, the Organ of Sight, Visible Things,
and the Consciousness, and their Relationship
to the Different Bhumis 126
J. Which Dhatu is Discerned by Which Consciousness? 129
K. How many of the Dhatus are Eternal? 130
L. How many of the Dhatus are Indriyas? 130 131
? Chapter Two: The Indriyas
The Indriyas 153 A. Definition 153 1. Objection 155 B. General Explanation 155
The Twenty-two Indriyas 158
A. A Different Definition 159
B. The Organs of Sensation 160 1. The Saint 162
C Pure and Impure Indriyas 163
D. Vipdka and Non-Vipdka Indriyas 165 Discussion: Prolonging and Shortening Life 166 Discussion: Jivita and Ayus 167
E. How Many Indriyas have Retribution 171
F. Their Moral Nature 171
G. The Indriyas id the Three Dhatus 172
H. Abandoning the Indriyas 173
I. How Many Indriyas are initially possessed
in each Dhatu? 174
J. How Many Indriyas perish at Death 176
K. Indriyas and the Stages of the Religious Life 177 1. The Quality of Arhat 179
L. Possessing the Indriyas 180
M. The Smallest Number of Indriyas 183
N. TheLargestNumberofIndriyas 183 Discussion: The Atom 184
The Mental States 188
A. Definition 189
B. The Mahdbhumikas 189
C The Kusakmahabhumikadharmas 190 Discussion: Prasrabdhi 191 Discussion: Equanimity 192 D. The Klesamahabhumikadharmas 193 1. A Different List 194
? 2. Is a Mahabhumika also Klesamahdbhwnikal 194 E. The Akusalamahabhumikadharmas 195 F. The Parittaklesikadharmas 196
G. The Number of Mental States that can Arise Together 196 H. Differences between Mental States 200 1. Disrespect versus Absence of Fear 200 2. Affection versus Respect 201
3. Vitarka versus Vkara 202
4. PrideversusPride-Intoxication 204 I. Synonyms 205
IV. Dharmas not Associated with the Mind 206
A. Definition 206
B. PraptiandAprapti 206
C TheTimePeriods 212
D. How is Prapti Abandoned? 213
E. Types of Aprapti 215
F. How does Aprapti Perish? 217
Discussion: Prapti and Anuprapti 217
G. Genre (Sabhdgatd) 219
H. The Dharma of Non-Consciousness 221 1. The Absorption of Non-Consciousness 223
I. The Absoption of Extinction 225
J. The Differences between the Two Absorptions 229 Discussion: How is a Mind produced after Absorption? 230
Discussion: Do the Two Absorptions exist as Real Substantial Entities? 232
K. The Vital Organ 233
Discussion: Warmth, Consciousness, and Life 233 Discussion: How does Death take place? 235 Discussion: Premature Death 235
L. Characteristics of Conditioned Dharmas 238 1. Primary and Secondary Characteristics 239 2. Arising 247
M. Words,Phrases,andandPhonemes 250 1. Voice 251
? N. Other Dharmas not Associated with the Mind 254
V. The Six Causes 254
A. General Comments 255
B. Reason for Existence 255
C Coexistent Cause 257
Discussion: The Sautrantikas Criticize the
Doctrine of Coexistent Causes 260
D. Similar Casuses 262 1. Definition 262 2. Objections 264 3. Similar Causes and the Path 267
E. Causes through Association 272
F. Universal Causes 273
G. Retributive Causes 274 1. Definition 275
2. Skandhas as Results 275
3. AyatanasasResults 276
H. The Time Periods 277
I. Causes and their Results 278 Discussion: Disconnection 280 Discussion: Are Unconditional Things Real Entities? 280 Discussion: Is Extinction or Nirvana Real? 281
J. The Five Results 286 1. Their Characteristics 288 2. The Time Periods 291
K. A Different List of Results 295
L. How Many Causes produce the Different Dharmas} 295
VI. The Four Conditions 296 A. General Comments 296 B. Equal and Immediately Antecedent Conditions 297 C Objects as Conditions 302 D. Predominating Conditions 303 E. The Time Periods 304 F. How Many Conditions Cause the Different Dharmas? 305
? Footnotes
326
Discussion: The Impossibility of a Single Cause 306
G. The Relationship between the Primary Elements
and Derived Matter 308
H. The Arising of Mind and Mental States 310 1. The Twelve Minds and the Three Dhatus 310 2. The Twenty Minds and the Three Dhatus 314 3. Acts of Attention 323
I. The Number of Mental States Acquired in
the Twelve Minds 323
? A Brief Biography of Louis de La Vallee Poussin
X-rfOuis de La Vallee Poussin, born in Li? ge on the 1st of January, 1869, was of French origin through his father's side of the family. His grandfather, Etienne- Pierre-Re'my de La Vallee Poussin, took part in the last Napoleonic campaigns and in 1832 was one of a group of French officers charged, under the direction of Marshall Girard, with the organization of the Belgian army at the request of King Leopold I. He married Marie-Therese de Cauwer in Namur, with whom he had four sons. The second, Gustave, was born in La Rochelle in 1829 and died in Paris in 1910; he married Pauline de Monge de Franeau, who was born in Liege in 1845. The eldest of the four children born of this marriage was Louis de La Vallee Poussin.
Orphaned from his mother at the age of 7, Louis, as well as his two brothers and his sister, were raised in Liege by his maternal grandparents. He was an outstanding student at the College Saint-Servain, in Liege, and in 1884 he entered the University of Liege where, four years later, he received the docteur en philosophie et lettres. His reading of Charles Lyall's Asiatic Studies awakened in him a desire to pursue Oriental studies, and it was at Louvain, under the direction of Charles de Harlez and Philippe Colinet, that he learned the elements of Sanskrit, Pali, and Avestan. He then went to Paris where he enrolled, from 1890 to 1893, at the Sorbonne and in the courses of Sylvain Levi at the Ecole pratique des Hautes-Etudes.
In 1892 he published a timid essay, a translation of Buddhist tales, in collaboration with Godefroy de Blonay. But as early as this same year there appeared in Museon an academic study, Le Bodhicaryavatdra de fantideva, a first indication of his tendency to research "the Saint and Sanctity in Buddhism" which marks all of his work; a first stage in this enormous task of investigating this theme pursued throughout the various Buddhist schools and the canons of scriptures.
In 1893-1894, he studied Buddhist Sanskrit and Sanskrit poetical meter "at the feet" of the great Orientalist H. Kern.
At the beginning of his activities as a Sanskrist, Louis de La Vallee Poussin was attracted by the curious and still unexplored doctrines of Tantrism. His Note sur le Pancakrama (1894) as well as his edition of this text (1896), "an authoritative summary of the nihilistic doctrines of Nagarjuna" and Une pratique des Tantras (1897) prepared the way for his first great work which is already the work of a master: Bouddhisme, Etudes et Materiaux, published by the Royal Academy of
? xvi A Brief Biography of Louis de La Vallee Poussin
Belgium (1898). This is a capital work which studies, with the method of an accomplished scholar, the relationship between Indian asceticism and the left- handed rituals. In spite of the tact and finesse with which he treated this topic, the subject let loose the righteous indignation of the great Rapson who, in a long review article, protested with severity against this exposure of "the Tantric infection". This English scholar, imbued with the theories current in his period-- theories which have not yet completely disappeared--would consider that Buddhism is only a pure philosophic system, whose only true literature are the words of the Buddha, and he openly manifested his dislike for such a subject of study as Tantrism. His criticism must have been cruelly felt by the young scholar since he did not hesitate to justify himself publically. He showed in fact, in his Tantras, that for Rapson Buddhism is only the doctrine preached by Sakyamuni, whereas for him Buddhism is the general state of beliefs which have condensed around the name of the Buddha. The Tantras are the inheritors of all the forms of Indian religions and their study is necessary to that which de La Vallee Poussin called Buddhism.
One would have thought that after this lively reaction against formalism, his works on the manifestations of popular Buddhism would have continued to occupy a large place in the activity of the young master, but he did nothing more with respect to Tantrism, with the exception of a study published in 1901, The Four Classes of Buddhist Tantras, the documents of this type, a new and living sphere of study, no longer formed the object of his publications. Following upon this excursion into the Indian jungle if badly viewed by traditionalist scholars, Louis de La Vall6e Poussin returned to monastic Buddhism, never to leave it.
It was then, in full possession of Tibetan, he did not hesitate--at more than forty years of age--to also learn Chinese. He continued the editing of enormous scholastic texts: Prajndkdramati, Santideva's commentary on the Bodhicarydvatdra (1901-1905, 605 pages) of which he published the annotated translation; an edition of the Tibetan translation of the Mddhyamakdvatdra of Candraklrti (1907-1912, 427 pages); and the Mulamddhyamakakdrikd of Nagarjuna with the commentary of CandrakBrti (1903-1913,658 pages). Taking refuge in Gimbridge during the war of 1914, he edited the Mahdniddesa (in collaboration with E. J. Thomas) and the third chapter of the Abhidharmakosa of Vasubandhu (1914-1918, 368 pages).
In mentioning these voluminous editions which come to a total of hundreds of pages, we do not pretend to evaluate his work in terms of its weight. But these figures are eloquent for anyone who has edited with the same scruples as has Louis de La Vallee Poussin, if not with the same mastery, only several pages of
? A Brief Biography of Louis de La Vallee Poussin xvii
Sanskrit text for which one must always have recourse to the Tibetan and Chinese versions. These enormous works would suffise to fill several lives and yet how much research has sprung out of his work, and how much has been enriched by it! Such are the over fifty articles in Hastings' Dictionary of Religion and Ethics, his studies on the doctrine of Karman (La negation de Vame et la doctrine de VActe, 1902), on the concatenation of the Twelve Causes (La theorie des Douze Causes, 1913), on the Three Bodies (The three bodies of a Buddha, 1906; Note sur les Corps du Buddha, 1913); and his constructions of the theory of Nirvana. All of the presentations of dogma that he developed, and by the approval that they received as well as by the reactions that they generated, have brought about the progress of Buddhist exegetical and philosophical studies up to the point where we find it today, that is, based on texts scrupulously established and patiently collated.
In the course of his long career filled with immense labor, the curiosity of Louis de La Vallee Pousin was brought to bear on all of the forms of Buddhism and on the principal aspects of Indian civilization, but the subject to which he returned most spontaneously in conversation and in his writings was Buddhist philosophy, or more precisely Buddhist scholasticism. Whereas Western phi- losophy is always more or less systematic, Indian scholasticism strives less to combine and to construct, than to set up an evaluation of the mind and of the universe by defining, enumerating, and classifying concepts. Louis de La Vallee Poussin found in this a field of study conforming to his spontaneous and to his well considered aspirations, for never was there a mind less systematic. This charaaeristic manifested itself not only in his choice of subjeas but in his research and in the manner in which he presented the results of this research.
? Abhidharmakosabhasyam Volume I
? Abhidharmakosabhasyam
of Vasubandhu
Volume I
Translated into French by Louis de La Vallee Poussin
English Version by Leo M. Pruden
ASIAN HUMANITIES PRESS [An imprint of Jain Publishing Company]
Web Site -- www. jainpub. com
? ASIAN HUMANITIES PRESS
Asian Humanities Press offers to the specialist and the general reader alike the best in new translations of major works and significant original contributions to enhance our understanding of Asian religions, cultures and thought.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
V asubandhu.
[AbhidharmakoSabhasya. English]
AbhidharmakoSabhasyam / [translated] by Louis de La Vallee Poussin; English
translation by Leo M. Pruden. -- Berkeley, Calif. : Asian Humanities Press, 1988- 1990.
4 v. ; 23 cm.
Translation of: Abhidharmako? abhasya. Includes bibliographies.
ISBN 0-89581-913-9 (set).
1. Vasubandhu. Abhidharmakosa.
2. Abhidharma.
I. La Vallee Poussin,
87-71231 AACR 2 MARC
Louis de, 1869-1938. BQ2682. E5P78 1988 294. 3'824? del 9
II. Title.
Copyright (R) 1991 by Asian Humanities Press. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the written permission of Asian Humanities Press except for brief passages quoted in a review.
? CONTENTS
A Brief Biography of Louis de La Valine Poussin xv Translator's Preface xxi
The Abhidharma:
The Origins, Growth and Development of a Literary Tradition
by Leo M. Pruden
1. Origin and Growth of Abhidharma xxx 2. Abhidhamma as "higher dhamma" xxxi 3. Abhidhamma alone xxxiii 4. Abhidhamma-kathd xxxv 5. Traditional Explanations of Abhidhamma xxxvi 6. Abhidharma in the Mahdvibhasd xxxvi 7. The Abhidhamma Pitaka xxxvii 8. The Mdtika xxxviii 9. Mdtika and Abhidharma xxxix
10. Abhidharma in the Agamas: the Religion of the Agamas xl 11. The Agamas and the Nikdyas xli 12. Abhidharmic Tendencies in Extant Agamas:
Numerical Categories, Samyuktas, and Vibhangas xlii
13. Sarvastivadin Agamas xliii
14. Samathadeva's Commentary xlv
15. Sarvastivadin Abhidharma Literature xlvi
16. Origin of the Abhidharma xlvi
17. The Second Period of Early Sarvastivadin Literature xlix 18. TheJnanaprasthdna li 19. The Vibhdsds lii 20. Development of the Literature After the Vibhdsds liii
21. The Abhidharma-hrdaya liii 22. The Abhidharmakosabhasyam liv 23. Sanskrit Remains of the Abhidharma lv
? 24. The Sanskrit Kosabhdsyam lvi 25. Translations of the Abhidharmakosabhdsyam lvii 26. Commentaries on the Abhidharmakosabhdsyam lvii 27. The Tibetan Kosabhdsyam lviii 28. Translations of the Kosabhdsyam and the F^/y/rf lix 29. Indexes to the Kosabhdsyam lix Footnotes lxii
Abhidharmakosabhasyam of Vasubandhu
by Louis de La Vallee Poussin
Introduction 1 I. Bibliography of the Kosa 7 A. Additions to the Bibliography, by Hurbert Durt 12
II. The Date of Vasubandhu. The Former Vasubandhu 13 III. The Seven Ginonical Treatises of the Abhidharma 17 A. TheJndnaprasthdna 17
B. The Prakarana of Vasumitra 20 C The Vijfidkdya 21 D. The Dharmaskandha 23 E. The Prajndptisdstra 24 F. The Dhdtukdya 27 G. The SamgUiparyaya 28
IV. Some Masters of the Vibhasa 28 A. Vasumitra 28 B. Ghosaka and the Abhidharmamrtasdstra 31 C Buddhadeva 32 D. Dharmabrdta 32 E. The Bhadanta Dharmatrdta 33
V. Some Schools of the Vibhasa 35 A. Ddastdnitkas and Sautrantikas 35 B. Vibhajyavadins 38 C Yogdcdrins 41
VI. The $ariputrdbhidharma 42 VIII. The Abhidharmasdra 44 Footnotes 49
? Chapter One: The Dhdtus
General Introduction
A. Homage to the Buddha
1. The Three Qualities of a Buddha B. Definition of Abhidharma
1. Absolute Sense of the Word
2. Conventional Sense of the Word C Definition of Abhidharmakosa
D. Purpose of the Abhidharma E. Authors of the Abhidharma
I. The Division of the Dharmas A. The Defiled Dharmas
B. The Undefiled Dharmas
C TheUnconditionedDharmas
1. Discussion of the Two Types of Disjunaion
2. Is Disjunaion Single or Multiple? D. ConditionedDharmas
1. Synonyms of "Conditioned" 2. Synonyms of "Defiled"
II. The Five Skandhas, the Twelve Ayatanas, and the Eighteen Dhdtus
A. RupaSkandha 1. Visible Matter 2. Sound
3. Taste
4. Odor
5. Tangible Things
B. The Relationship between the Five Consciousnesses
and the Five Visayas G Avijnaptirupa
D. TheFourPrimaryElements
E. The Definition of "Rupa"
F. The Ten Ayatanas and the Ten Dhdtus
G. The Vedand, Samjnd, and Samskdra Skandhas
55 55 55 56 56 56 57 57 58
58
59
59
59
59
59
61
61
62
63 63 64 65 66 66 66
66
67 68 70
72 72
? H. The Vijnana Skandha and the Mana Ayatana 14 I. The Seven Dhatus 74 J. The Manodhatu and the Eighteen Dhatus 75
The Threefold Classification of the Dharmas 16
A. The Threefold Classification of the Dharmas 16
B. The Nature of the Eighteen Dhatus 1(S
G The Definition of "Skandha," "Ayatana" and "Dhatu" 11
D. Their Provisional Existence 79
E. The Reason for the Threefold Classification 80
F. Distinctions between Vedana and Samjna 81
G. The Five Skandhas and the Unconditioned Dharmas 81
H. The Order of the Five Skandhas 82
I. The Order of the Ayatanas and Dhatus,
with Reference to the Six Indriyas 83
Some Problems Raised by the Threefold Classification 85
A. The Rupa Ayatana and the Dharma Ayatana 85
B. Inclusion in Other Skandhas, Ayatanas, and Dhatus 86
C The Eighty-four Thousand Dharmaskandhas 86
D. E.
F.
The Dimension of a Dharmaskandha 86 The Characteristics of the Skandhas and the
Threefold Classification 87 Vijnanadhdtu and Akasadhdtu 88
Classification of the Dharmas in the Eighteen Dhatus 90 A. Visible and Invisible Dharmas 90 B. Resistant and Non-Resistant Dharmas 90 C. Good, Bad, and Morally Neutral Dharmas 90 D. The Eighteen Dhatus and the Three Realms ? ? E. Pure and Impure Dhatus 95 F. Vitarka and Vicara 96 G. Vitarka, Vicara, and the Five Sense Consciousnesses 97
H. Discussions
1. How many Dhatus Serve as an Object? 98 2. How many are Non-Appropriated
to Living Beings? 98
? I. Primary and Derived Elements 99 J. Discussion
1. Can the Atoms be Accumulated? 101
2. How many of the Dhatus Cut or are Cut?
Burn or are Burned? Weight or are Weight? 102
3. How many of the Dhatus are vipdka?
Accumulations? Outflowings? 103
4. How many of the Dhatus are Real Substances? 105
5. How many of the Dhatus are Momentary? 105
K. Possession of a Dhatu versus a Vijndnadhatu 106 L. Internal and External Elements 107 M. Sabhdga and Tatsabhdga 108
N. HowaretheDhatusAbandoned? Ill O. How many of the Dhatus are "View? " 113
VI. Subsidiary Discussions 118
A. Are Visible Things Seen by One or Two Eyes? 118
B. Do the Indriyas and the Visayas Touch? 119
C. The Dimension of the Organs and their Visayas 122
D. Atoms within the Organs 123
E. Are Atoms Sabhdga or Tatsabhdga} 123
F. Time and the Support of the Consciousnesses 124
G. Why are the Organs, and not the Object,
the Support of the Consciousness? 125
H. How are the Different Consciousnesses Named? 125
I. The Body, the Organ of Sight, Visible Things,
and the Consciousness, and their Relationship
to the Different Bhumis 126
J. Which Dhatu is Discerned by Which Consciousness? 129
K. How many of the Dhatus are Eternal? 130
L. How many of the Dhatus are Indriyas? 130 131
? Chapter Two: The Indriyas
The Indriyas 153 A. Definition 153 1. Objection 155 B. General Explanation 155
The Twenty-two Indriyas 158
A. A Different Definition 159
B. The Organs of Sensation 160 1. The Saint 162
C Pure and Impure Indriyas 163
D.
The Five Skandhas and the Unconditioned Dharmas 81
H. The Order of the Five Skandhas 82
I. The Order of the Ayatanas and Dhatus,
with Reference to the Six Indriyas 83
Some Problems Raised by the Threefold Classification 85
A. The Rupa Ayatana and the Dharma Ayatana 85
B. Inclusion in Other Skandhas, Ayatanas, and Dhatus 86
C The Eighty-four Thousand Dharmaskandhas 86
D. E.
F.
The Dimension of a Dharmaskandha 86 The Characteristics of the Skandhas and the
Threefold Classification 87 Vijnanadhdtu and Akasadhdtu 88
Classification of the Dharmas in the Eighteen Dhatus 90 A. Visible and Invisible Dharmas 90 B. Resistant and Non-Resistant Dharmas 90 C. Good, Bad, and Morally Neutral Dharmas 90 D. The Eighteen Dhatus and the Three Realms ? ? E. Pure and Impure Dhatus 95 F. Vitarka and Vicara 96 G. Vitarka, Vicara, and the Five Sense Consciousnesses 97
H. Discussions
1. How many Dhatus Serve as an Object? 98 2. How many are Non-Appropriated
to Living Beings? 98
? I. Primary and Derived Elements 99 J. Discussion
1. Can the Atoms be Accumulated? 101
2. How many of the Dhatus Cut or are Cut?
Burn or are Burned? Weight or are Weight? 102
3. How many of the Dhatus are vipdka?
Accumulations? Outflowings? 103
4. How many of the Dhatus are Real Substances? 105
5. How many of the Dhatus are Momentary? 105
K. Possession of a Dhatu versus a Vijndnadhatu 106 L. Internal and External Elements 107 M. Sabhdga and Tatsabhdga 108
N. HowaretheDhatusAbandoned? Ill O. How many of the Dhatus are "View? " 113
VI. Subsidiary Discussions 118
A. Are Visible Things Seen by One or Two Eyes? 118
B. Do the Indriyas and the Visayas Touch? 119
C. The Dimension of the Organs and their Visayas 122
D. Atoms within the Organs 123
E. Are Atoms Sabhdga or Tatsabhdga} 123
F. Time and the Support of the Consciousnesses 124
G. Why are the Organs, and not the Object,
the Support of the Consciousness? 125
H. How are the Different Consciousnesses Named? 125
I. The Body, the Organ of Sight, Visible Things,
and the Consciousness, and their Relationship
to the Different Bhumis 126
J. Which Dhatu is Discerned by Which Consciousness? 129
K. How many of the Dhatus are Eternal? 130
L. How many of the Dhatus are Indriyas? 130 131
? Chapter Two: The Indriyas
The Indriyas 153 A. Definition 153 1. Objection 155 B. General Explanation 155
The Twenty-two Indriyas 158
A. A Different Definition 159
B. The Organs of Sensation 160 1. The Saint 162
C Pure and Impure Indriyas 163
D. Vipdka and Non-Vipdka Indriyas 165 Discussion: Prolonging and Shortening Life 166 Discussion: Jivita and Ayus 167
E. How Many Indriyas have Retribution 171
F. Their Moral Nature 171
G. The Indriyas id the Three Dhatus 172
H. Abandoning the Indriyas 173
I. How Many Indriyas are initially possessed
in each Dhatu? 174
J. How Many Indriyas perish at Death 176
K. Indriyas and the Stages of the Religious Life 177 1. The Quality of Arhat 179
L. Possessing the Indriyas 180
M. The Smallest Number of Indriyas 183
N. TheLargestNumberofIndriyas 183 Discussion: The Atom 184
The Mental States 188
A. Definition 189
B. The Mahdbhumikas 189
C The Kusakmahabhumikadharmas 190 Discussion: Prasrabdhi 191 Discussion: Equanimity 192 D. The Klesamahabhumikadharmas 193 1. A Different List 194
? 2. Is a Mahabhumika also Klesamahdbhwnikal 194 E. The Akusalamahabhumikadharmas 195 F. The Parittaklesikadharmas 196
G. The Number of Mental States that can Arise Together 196 H. Differences between Mental States 200 1. Disrespect versus Absence of Fear 200 2. Affection versus Respect 201
3. Vitarka versus Vkara 202
4. PrideversusPride-Intoxication 204 I. Synonyms 205
IV. Dharmas not Associated with the Mind 206
A. Definition 206
B. PraptiandAprapti 206
C TheTimePeriods 212
D. How is Prapti Abandoned? 213
E. Types of Aprapti 215
F. How does Aprapti Perish? 217
Discussion: Prapti and Anuprapti 217
G. Genre (Sabhdgatd) 219
H. The Dharma of Non-Consciousness 221 1. The Absorption of Non-Consciousness 223
I. The Absoption of Extinction 225
J. The Differences between the Two Absorptions 229 Discussion: How is a Mind produced after Absorption? 230
Discussion: Do the Two Absorptions exist as Real Substantial Entities? 232
K. The Vital Organ 233
Discussion: Warmth, Consciousness, and Life 233 Discussion: How does Death take place? 235 Discussion: Premature Death 235
L. Characteristics of Conditioned Dharmas 238 1. Primary and Secondary Characteristics 239 2. Arising 247
M. Words,Phrases,andandPhonemes 250 1. Voice 251
? N. Other Dharmas not Associated with the Mind 254
V. The Six Causes 254
A. General Comments 255
B. Reason for Existence 255
C Coexistent Cause 257
Discussion: The Sautrantikas Criticize the
Doctrine of Coexistent Causes 260
D. Similar Casuses 262 1. Definition 262 2. Objections 264 3. Similar Causes and the Path 267
E. Causes through Association 272
F. Universal Causes 273
G. Retributive Causes 274 1. Definition 275
2. Skandhas as Results 275
3. AyatanasasResults 276
H. The Time Periods 277
I. Causes and their Results 278 Discussion: Disconnection 280 Discussion: Are Unconditional Things Real Entities? 280 Discussion: Is Extinction or Nirvana Real? 281
J. The Five Results 286 1. Their Characteristics 288 2. The Time Periods 291
K. A Different List of Results 295
L. How Many Causes produce the Different Dharmas} 295
VI. The Four Conditions 296 A. General Comments 296 B. Equal and Immediately Antecedent Conditions 297 C Objects as Conditions 302 D. Predominating Conditions 303 E. The Time Periods 304 F. How Many Conditions Cause the Different Dharmas? 305
? Footnotes
326
Discussion: The Impossibility of a Single Cause 306
G. The Relationship between the Primary Elements
and Derived Matter 308
H. The Arising of Mind and Mental States 310 1. The Twelve Minds and the Three Dhatus 310 2. The Twenty Minds and the Three Dhatus 314 3. Acts of Attention 323
I. The Number of Mental States Acquired in
the Twelve Minds 323
? A Brief Biography of Louis de La Vallee Poussin
X-rfOuis de La Vallee Poussin, born in Li? ge on the 1st of January, 1869, was of French origin through his father's side of the family. His grandfather, Etienne- Pierre-Re'my de La Vallee Poussin, took part in the last Napoleonic campaigns and in 1832 was one of a group of French officers charged, under the direction of Marshall Girard, with the organization of the Belgian army at the request of King Leopold I. He married Marie-Therese de Cauwer in Namur, with whom he had four sons. The second, Gustave, was born in La Rochelle in 1829 and died in Paris in 1910; he married Pauline de Monge de Franeau, who was born in Liege in 1845. The eldest of the four children born of this marriage was Louis de La Vallee Poussin.
Orphaned from his mother at the age of 7, Louis, as well as his two brothers and his sister, were raised in Liege by his maternal grandparents. He was an outstanding student at the College Saint-Servain, in Liege, and in 1884 he entered the University of Liege where, four years later, he received the docteur en philosophie et lettres. His reading of Charles Lyall's Asiatic Studies awakened in him a desire to pursue Oriental studies, and it was at Louvain, under the direction of Charles de Harlez and Philippe Colinet, that he learned the elements of Sanskrit, Pali, and Avestan. He then went to Paris where he enrolled, from 1890 to 1893, at the Sorbonne and in the courses of Sylvain Levi at the Ecole pratique des Hautes-Etudes.
In 1892 he published a timid essay, a translation of Buddhist tales, in collaboration with Godefroy de Blonay. But as early as this same year there appeared in Museon an academic study, Le Bodhicaryavatdra de fantideva, a first indication of his tendency to research "the Saint and Sanctity in Buddhism" which marks all of his work; a first stage in this enormous task of investigating this theme pursued throughout the various Buddhist schools and the canons of scriptures.
In 1893-1894, he studied Buddhist Sanskrit and Sanskrit poetical meter "at the feet" of the great Orientalist H. Kern.
At the beginning of his activities as a Sanskrist, Louis de La Vallee Poussin was attracted by the curious and still unexplored doctrines of Tantrism. His Note sur le Pancakrama (1894) as well as his edition of this text (1896), "an authoritative summary of the nihilistic doctrines of Nagarjuna" and Une pratique des Tantras (1897) prepared the way for his first great work which is already the work of a master: Bouddhisme, Etudes et Materiaux, published by the Royal Academy of
? xvi A Brief Biography of Louis de La Vallee Poussin
Belgium (1898). This is a capital work which studies, with the method of an accomplished scholar, the relationship between Indian asceticism and the left- handed rituals. In spite of the tact and finesse with which he treated this topic, the subject let loose the righteous indignation of the great Rapson who, in a long review article, protested with severity against this exposure of "the Tantric infection". This English scholar, imbued with the theories current in his period-- theories which have not yet completely disappeared--would consider that Buddhism is only a pure philosophic system, whose only true literature are the words of the Buddha, and he openly manifested his dislike for such a subject of study as Tantrism. His criticism must have been cruelly felt by the young scholar since he did not hesitate to justify himself publically. He showed in fact, in his Tantras, that for Rapson Buddhism is only the doctrine preached by Sakyamuni, whereas for him Buddhism is the general state of beliefs which have condensed around the name of the Buddha. The Tantras are the inheritors of all the forms of Indian religions and their study is necessary to that which de La Vallee Poussin called Buddhism.
One would have thought that after this lively reaction against formalism, his works on the manifestations of popular Buddhism would have continued to occupy a large place in the activity of the young master, but he did nothing more with respect to Tantrism, with the exception of a study published in 1901, The Four Classes of Buddhist Tantras, the documents of this type, a new and living sphere of study, no longer formed the object of his publications. Following upon this excursion into the Indian jungle if badly viewed by traditionalist scholars, Louis de La Vall6e Poussin returned to monastic Buddhism, never to leave it.
It was then, in full possession of Tibetan, he did not hesitate--at more than forty years of age--to also learn Chinese. He continued the editing of enormous scholastic texts: Prajndkdramati, Santideva's commentary on the Bodhicarydvatdra (1901-1905, 605 pages) of which he published the annotated translation; an edition of the Tibetan translation of the Mddhyamakdvatdra of Candraklrti (1907-1912, 427 pages); and the Mulamddhyamakakdrikd of Nagarjuna with the commentary of CandrakBrti (1903-1913,658 pages). Taking refuge in Gimbridge during the war of 1914, he edited the Mahdniddesa (in collaboration with E. J. Thomas) and the third chapter of the Abhidharmakosa of Vasubandhu (1914-1918, 368 pages).
In mentioning these voluminous editions which come to a total of hundreds of pages, we do not pretend to evaluate his work in terms of its weight. But these figures are eloquent for anyone who has edited with the same scruples as has Louis de La Vallee Poussin, if not with the same mastery, only several pages of
? A Brief Biography of Louis de La Vallee Poussin xvii
Sanskrit text for which one must always have recourse to the Tibetan and Chinese versions. These enormous works would suffise to fill several lives and yet how much research has sprung out of his work, and how much has been enriched by it! Such are the over fifty articles in Hastings' Dictionary of Religion and Ethics, his studies on the doctrine of Karman (La negation de Vame et la doctrine de VActe, 1902), on the concatenation of the Twelve Causes (La theorie des Douze Causes, 1913), on the Three Bodies (The three bodies of a Buddha, 1906; Note sur les Corps du Buddha, 1913); and his constructions of the theory of Nirvana. All of the presentations of dogma that he developed, and by the approval that they received as well as by the reactions that they generated, have brought about the progress of Buddhist exegetical and philosophical studies up to the point where we find it today, that is, based on texts scrupulously established and patiently collated.
In the course of his long career filled with immense labor, the curiosity of Louis de La Vallee Pousin was brought to bear on all of the forms of Buddhism and on the principal aspects of Indian civilization, but the subject to which he returned most spontaneously in conversation and in his writings was Buddhist philosophy, or more precisely Buddhist scholasticism. Whereas Western phi- losophy is always more or less systematic, Indian scholasticism strives less to combine and to construct, than to set up an evaluation of the mind and of the universe by defining, enumerating, and classifying concepts. Louis de La Vallee Poussin found in this a field of study conforming to his spontaneous and to his well considered aspirations, for never was there a mind less systematic. This charaaeristic manifested itself not only in his choice of subjeas but in his research and in the manner in which he presented the results of this research.
