No More Learning

Whether by giving a different direction to the public
mind, and offering a new hope of relief, the proposed con-
vention of the states would have prevented these alarming
occurrences, it is impossible to determine. The despair
of aid from state legislation may have stimulated the peo-
ple to violence; but it is rather to be believed that the
popular feelings were too much excited, the suffering too
great and extensive, to have waited the issue of so slow a
process. The rebellious temper of the populace rendered
a vigorous exertion of the powers of government neces-
sary; and it cannot be doubted, that this necessity had
much influence in inducing the states to consent to the es-
tablishment of the federal constitution.
The prostration of commerce, the poverty and anarchy
of the country, the hopeless prospect before them, com-
pelled the people to feel the want of that which Hamilton
was the first to indicate as the only resource--" a more
perfect union. " New-York had been the earliest to pro-
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 372
THE LIFE OF
pose a convention of the states. After longer experience,
Massachusetts had declared her conviction of its necessity;
to which Virginia, eminently jealous of her state sove-
reignty, was impelled by peculiar circumstances at last to
assent.
Her geographical position rendered it extremely difficult
to establish an efficient, and at the same time an indepen-
dent revenue system. This difficulty had early suggested
the importance of forming a compact with Maryland, as
to the jurisdiction of their confluent waters; and in De-
cember, seventeen hundred and seventy-seven, commis-
sioners were appointed by Virginia for this object. The
subject was resumed in seventeen hundred and eighty-four,
and a similar commission created. Nothing having been
effected by them, new commissioners were chosen in the
succeeding year, who met the deputies of Maryland at
Mount Vernon. There they agreed upon an act regula-
ting the commercial intercourse through the Potomac and
Chesapeake, and defining the jurisdiction of each state.
But at the moment of framing this compact, they deemed
it necessary to extend its provisions so as to authorize the
establishment of a naval force to protect these estuaries,
and the formation of a mutual tariff. This compact, by
the articles of the confederation, required the previous
consent of congress. To obviate that difficulty, these de-
puties recommended to their respective states the appoint-
ment of other commissioners with enlarged powers, to
whose proceedings the permission of congress was to be
solicited.
On the thirteenth of January, seventeen hundred and
eighty-six, resolutions passed the legislature of Virginia for
a uniformity of duties between the two states, and that
commissioners should be chosen to meet annually, if re-
quired, to regulate their mutual commercial interests.
They were instructed particularly to provide, that foreign
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON.
373
gold should pass at the same rate in both states, and that
the same amount of damages should be charged on pro-
tested bills of exchange. A few days after, the house of
delegates passed a resolution, directing the projected ar-
rangement to be communicated to all the other states, who
were invited to send deputies to a general meeting for the
precise purpose " of considering how far a uniform system
of taxation in their commercial intercourse and regula-
tions might be necessary to their common interest and
permanent harmony; and to report an act relative to this
great object, which, when ratified, would enable the United
States, in congress assembled, effectually to provide for the
same. " Thus it will be seen that Virginia merely con-
templated a commercial arrangement, falling far short of
the policy which New-York and Massachusetts had pre-
viously embraced.
Her reluctance in granting, and her repeals of the im-
post ;* her hostility to a federal judiciary; her jealousy as
to the Mississippi;--all leave little room for doubt, that the
project of a continental convention to frame a constitution,
would at an earlier period have been feebly sustained by
her. Washington's circular letter had produced no action
on her part, and her councils were swayed by penmen who
looked upon an invigoration of the union with jealousy,
because the suggestion had emanated from the army, and
who, speculating in their closets on the dangers of con-
ferring power, had not considered how much greater were
the evils of usurpation, even from "necessity," than those
* In a letter from R. H. Lee, he states his apprehensions of alterations m
the articles of the confederation, that he had " ever been opposed to the five
per cent. impost," that he never could agree that congress " shall dictate the
mode of taxation, or that the collection shall in any manner be subject to
congressional control. " He was opposed to the power of regulating trade. --
Life, v. 2, pp. 62, 71.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 374
THE LIFE OF
of a large constitutional authority. * Yet the precedence
of that state in this important measure- has been claimed
without hesitation, and generally received as a part of
American history. It is time that this error, with many
others, should be corrected.
Soon after this project was first agitated, Hamilton,
whose mind had long laboured with the great design of a
national constitution, determined to bring about the co-
operation of New-York. It was a part of his plan, that
the state legislature should definitively adopt or reject the
revenue system of seventeen hundred and eighty-three, and
in case of its rejection, should appoint commissioners to
attend the commercial convention. "Hamilton," Troup
relates, "had no idea that the legislature could be prevail-
ed on to adopt the system as recommended by congress,
neither had he any partiality for a commercial convention,
otherwise than as a stepping stone to a general conven-
tion, to form a general constitution. In pursuance of
his plan, the late Mr. Duer, the late Colonel Malcom, and
myself, were sent to the state legislature as part of the
* In a letter of Madison to R. II. Lee, he observes, "/ have not yet found
leisure to scan the project of a continental convention with so close an eye
as to have made up any observations worthy of being mentioned to you. In
general, I hold it for a maxim, that the union of the states is essential for their
safety against foreign danger and internal contention, and that the perpetui-
ty and efficacy of the present system cannot be confided in. The question
therefore is, in what mode and at what moment the experiment for supplying
the defects ought to be made. The answer to this question cannot be made
without a knowledge, greater than I possess, of the temper and views of the
different states. Virginia seems, I think, to have excellent dispositions to-
wards the confederacy, but her assent or dissent to such a proposition, would
probably depend much upon the chance of having no opponent capable of
rousing the jealousies and prejudices of the assembly against innovations,
particularly such as will derogate from their own power and importance.
Should a view of the other states present no objections against the experi-
ment, individually, I would wish none to be presupposed here. "--2 Life of
R. H. Lee, p. 220. Dec. 25, 1784.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON.
375
city delegation, and we were to make every possible effort
to accomplish Hamilton's objects.
"Duer was a man of commanding eloquence. We
went to the legislature, and pressed totis viribus the grant
of the impost agreeably to the requisition of congress. We
failed in obtaining it . The resolutions of Virginia were
communicated by Governor Clinton, on the fourteenth of
March, seventeen hundred and eighty-six. We went all
our strength in the appointment of commissioners to attend
the commercial convention, in which we were successful.
The commissioners were instructed to report their pro-
ceedings to the next legislature: Hamilton was appointed
one of them. Thus it was, that he was the principal
instrument to turn this state to a course of policy that
saved our country from incalculable mischiefs, if not from
total ruin. "
While this subject was in agitation in other states, Gov-
ernor Bowdoin was using all his influence to incite the
people of Massachusetts to the promotion of their true in-
terests. In a special message, he urged upon the legisla-
ture the protection of manufactures, stating that the looms
were idle, in consequence of excessive importations. On
a subsequent occasion, after descanting upon the impor-
tance of conferring the necessary powers upon congress,
he placed before them the serious inquiry, " Shall the union
cease to exist V and as soon as he received the circular
of Virginia, he recommended the appointment of commis-
sioners to the commercial convention, which the legislature
approved. New-Je/sey, Delaware, and Pennsylvania co-
operated in the measure. "The delegates appointed by
New-York were Hamilton, Duane, Robert R. Livingston,
Robert C. Livingston, Benson, and Gansevoort. Ganse-
voort declined the appointment. Duane was prevented
attending by indisposition, Robert R. Livingston by bu-
siness. Hamilton and Benson (then attorney-general of
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 37G
THE LIFE OF
the state) proceeded to Annapolis, where they met the
other commissioners. " After a short interview, "a com-
mittee was appointed to prepare an address to the states,
which was reported and agreed to,--the whole in the
course of three or four days, and we separated. The draft
was by Hamilton, although not formally one of the com-
mittee. "*
In the draft as originally framed, Hamilton had exhibit-
ed frankly and at large the condition of the states, and
the necessity of an efficient government. But it was
thought,f from the sentiments of some of the delegates, and
the lukewarmness exhibited by the non-attendance of so
many states, that his statements were too explicit, and he re-
duced the address to the form in which it now appears, sign-
ed by Governor Dickinson, as chairman of the meeting.
"To the honourable the legislatures of Virginia, Delaware,
Pennsylvania, and New-York.
"The commissioners from the said states respectively
assembled at Annapolis, humbly beg leave to report, That
pursuant to their several appointments, they met at Anna-
polis, in the state of Maryland, on the eleventh day of
September, instant, and having proceeded to a communi-
cation of their powers, they found that the states of New-
York, Pennsylvania, and Virginia, had in substance, and
nearly in the same terms, authorized their respective com-
missioners to meet such commissioners as were or might
be appointed by the other states in the union, at such time
and place as should be agreed upon by the said commis-
sioners, to take into consideration the trade and commerce
? Memoir published by Judge Benson.
t The governor, Edmund Randolph, objected to the report as first framed.
Madison then observed to Hamilton, "You had better yield to this man, for
otherwise all Virginia will be against you. "
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON.
377
of the United States, to consider how far an uniform system
in their commercial intercourse and regulations might be
necessary to their common interest and permanent harmo-
ny, and to report to the several states such an act relative
to this great object, as, when unanimously ratified by them,
would enable the United States in congress assembled
effectually to provide for the same.
"That the state of Delaware had given similar powers
to their commissioners; with this difference only, that the
act to be framed in virtue of these powers, is required to
be reported 'to the United States in congress assembled,
to be agreed to by them, and confirmed by the legislature
of every state. '
"That the state of New-Jersey had enlarged the object
of their appointment, empowering their commissioners 'to
consider how far an uniform system in their commercial
regulations, and other important matters, might be neces-
sary to the common interest and permanent harmony of
the several states; and to report such an act on the subject,
as, when ratified by them, would enable the United States
in congress assembled effectually to provide for the exi-
gencies of the union. '
"That appointments of commissioners have also been
made by the states of New-Hampshire, Massachusetts,
Rhode Island, and North Carolina, none of whom, how-
ever, have attended. But that no information has been
received by your commissioners of any appointment hav-
ing been made by the states of Connecticut, Maryland,
South Carolina, or Georgia. That the express terms of
the powers to your commissioners supposing a deputation
from all the states, and having for their object the trade and
commerce of the United States, your commissioners did
not conceive it advisable to proceed to the business of their
mission under the circumstance of so partial and defective
a representation.
48
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 378 TI1E LIFE OF
"Deeply impressed, however, with the magnitude and
importance of the object confided to them on this occasion,
your commissioners cannot forbear to indulge an expres-
sion of their earnest and unanimous wish that speedy meas-
ures may be taken to effect a general meeting of the states
in a future convention for the same, and such other pur-
poses, as the situation of public affairs may be found to
require.
"If in expressing this wish, or intimating any other senti-
ment, your commissioners should seem to exceed the strict
bounds of their appointment, they entertain a full confi-
dence that a conduct dictated by an anxiety for the wel-
fare of the United States will not fail to receive a favour-
able construction. In this persuasion, your commissioners
submit an opinion that the idea of extending the powers
of their deputies to other objects than those of commerce,
which had been adopted by the state of New-Jersey, was
an improvement on the original plan, and will deserve to
be incorporated into that of a future convention. They
are the more naturally led to this conclusion, as, in the
course of their reflections on the subject, they have been
induced to think that the power of regulating trade is of
such comprehensive extent, and will enter so far into the
general system of the federal government, that to give it
efficacy, and to obviate questions and doubts concerning
its precise nature and limits, may require a correspondent
adjustment of other parts of the federal system. That
there are important defects in the system of the federal
government, is acknowledged by the acts of all those states
which have concurred in the present meeting; that the
defects, upon a closer examination, may be found greater
and more numerous than even these acts imply, is at
least so far probable, from the embarrassments which
characterize the present state of our national affairs
foreign and domestic, as may reasonably be supposed
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 379
to merit a deliberate and candid discussion in some
mode which will unite the sentiments and councils of all
the states.
"In the choice of the mode, your commissioners are of
the opinion that a convention of deputies from the differ-
ent states for the special and sole purpose of entering into
this investigation, and digesting a plan of supplying such
defects as may be discovered to exist, will be entitled to a
preference, from considerations which will occur without
being particularized. Your commissioners decline an enu-
meration of those national circumstances on which their
opinion respecting the propriety of a future convention
with those enlarged powers is founded, as it would be an
intrusion of facts and observations, most of which have
been frequently the subject of public discussion, and none
of which can have escaped the penetration of those to
whom they would in this instance be addressed.
"They are, however, of a nature so serious, as, in the view
of your commissioners, to render the situation of the Uni-
ted States delicate and critical, calling for an exertion of
the united virtue and wisdom of all the members of the
confederacy. Under this impression, your commissioners
with the most respectful deference beg leave to suggest
their unanimous conviction, that it may effectually tend to
advance the interests of the union, if the states by which
they have been respectively delegated would concur them-
selves, and use their endeavours to procure the concur-
rence of the other states, in the appointment of commis-
sioners to meet at Philadelphia on the second Monday in
May next, to take into consideration the situation of the
United States, to devise such further provisions as shall
appear to them necessary to render the constitution of the
federal government adequate to the exigencies of the union,
and to report such an act for that purpose to the United
States in congress assembled, as, when agreed to by them
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 380
THE LIFE OF
and afterwards confirmed by the legislature of every state,
will effectually provide for the same.
"Though your commissioners could not with propriety
address these observations and sentiments to any but the
states they have the honour to represent, they have nev-
ertheless concluded, from motives of respect, to transmit
copies of this report to the United States in congress as-
sembled, and to the executives of the other states.
"Annapolis, September 14th, 1786. "'
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON.
381
CHAPTER XXII.
[1786. ]
It has been seen that the conferring on congress the
power of levying a national impost, was the great dividing
question on which the two parties that existed in America
were arrayed. By the friends of a general and enlarged
policy, or, as they were then styled, of "continental poli-
tics," this measure was regarded as one involving the fate
of the country, for without such a power it was obvious
that the confederation, feeble and inadequate as it had
proved, could not be longer preserved. Its opponents
were those who had coalesced, either from disappointment
in not having acquired an influence in the general councils,
from a desire to retain powers in the states that might be
wielded for the gratification of their ambition, from an un-
defined or pretended apprehension of the dangers to their lib-
erties which might result from so large a confidence as the
control of the national funds, and in certain states from a
calculation of the partial benefits to be derived from peculiar
circumstances of more extensive territory, favourable posi-
tion, and natural advantages. These lent themselves to the
most absurd suspicions, deprecated any advance towards
this great object as an approach to a gulf in which every
vestige of liberty would be merged, and appealing to each
narrow passion, the offspring of inconsiderateness, igno-
rance, or pride, gratified their vanity, and increased their
influence, by being esteemed the zealous watchmen of lib-
erty, and especial guardians of state rights. This party
was the proper growth of the articles of confederation.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 382
THE LIFE OF
It had acquired a complete ascendency throughout the
country, thus affording another proof that false principles,
while they hasten decay in the system into which they en-
ter,. give a noxious vitality to the parasitic plants which
nourish in the progress of its corruption.
That ascendency was inconsistent with the preservation
of the union; nor should we know from its effects at this
time that the union existed, but that the pageantry of a
congress was still kept up. The members chosen to meet
in November, seventeen hundred and eighty-five, did not
assemble until February, seventeen hundred and eighty-six.
Their first deliberations related to the finances. The re-
port of a committee showed that the requisitions for the
four preceding years a little exceeded seven millions of
dollars; that the total receipts were rather more than one-
third of this sum, of which less than one-tenth had been
collected within the last fourteen months; that the means
for discharging the interest on the foreign debt would have
been inadequate, but for the unappropriated residue of the
Dutch loan; that further loans could not be obtained;
that the emission of bills of credit was hopeless; that the
only remaining resource was the public lands--but public
securities being receivable for them, they could only aid
in reducing the public debt; and that, after the maturest
consideration, they were unable to devise any other than
the revenue system of seventeen hundred and eighty-three.
It then proceeded to state, that seven states had complied
with it in part; that Pennsylvania and Delaware had only
granted it provisionally, and that Rhode Island, New-York,
Maryland, and Georgia, had not decided in favour of any
part of a system " so long since and so repeatedly presented
for their adoption.
" It closed with the following impres-
sive appeal:--" The committee observe with great concern
that the security of the navigation and commerce of the
citizens of these states from the Barbary powers; the pro-
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON.
383
tection of the frontier inhabitants from the savages; the
immediate establishment of military magazines in different
parts of the union, rendered indispensable by the principles
of public safety; the maintenance of the federal govern-
ment at home, and the support of the public servants
abroad;--each and all depend upon the contributions of the
states under the annual requisitions of congress. The
moneys essentially necessary for these important objects will
so far exceed the sums formerly collected from the states
by taxes, that no hope can be indulged of being able from
that source to make any remittances for the discharge of
foreign engagements.
"Thus circumstanced, after the most solemn deliberation,
and under the fullest conviction that the public embarrass-
ments are such as above represented, and that they are
daily increasing, the committee are of opinion that it has
become the duty of congress to declare most explicitly,
that the crisis has arrived when the people of these United
States, by whose will and for whose benefit the federal
government was instituted, must decide whether they will
support their rank as a nation by maintaining the public
faith at home and abroad, or whether, for want of timely
exertion in establishing a general revenue, and thereby
giving strength to the confederacy, they will hazard, not
only the existence of the union, but of those great and in-
valuable privileges for which they have so arduously and
so honourably contended. "
This strong language was followed by resolutions, in
which, to efface the erroneous impressions produced by
Jefferson's scheme of counterbalancing deficiencies, and
"in order that congress may remain wholly acquitted from
every imputation of a want of attention to the interests
and welfare of those whom they represent," they declare--
First, that the requisitions of seventeen hundred and
eighty-four and eighty-five, cannot be considered as the
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 384 THE LIFE OF
establishment of a system of general revenue in opposition
to that recommended in seventeen hundred and eighty-
three; second, they recommend to the delinquent states
an accession to that system in all its parts; and last, pro-
claim, that whilst congress are denied the means of satis-
fying those engagements which they have constitutionally
entered into for the common benefit of the union, they
hold it their duty to warn their constituents that the most
fatal evils will inevitably flow from a breach of public
faith pledged by solemn contract, and a violation of those
principles of justice which are the only solid basis of the
honour and prosperity of nations. "*
Although Pennsylvania and Delaware had not complied
strictly with the system of seventeen hundred and eighty-
three, it became apparent that the non-concurrence of
New-York was the only serious obstacle to its establishment.
Under these circumstances, the public attention in that
state was wholly devoted to this subject
A strong memorial to the legislature from the pen of
Hamilton was widely circulated. It stated, "that the
community had seen with peculiar regret the delay which
had hitherto attended the adoption of the revenue system;
that the anxiety which they had all along felt from mo-
tives of a more general nature, is at the present juncture
increased by this particular consideration, that the state of
New-York now stands almost alone, in a non-compliance with
a measure in which the sentiments and wishes of the union
at large appear to unite, and by a further delay may ren-
der itself responsible for consequences too serious not to
affect every considerate man; that all the considerations
important to a state, all the motives of public honour, faith,
reputation, interest, and safety, conspire to urge a compli-
* R. King was chairman of this committee, and it is to be presumed was
the author of this important document.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON.
383
ance with that measure--that government without reve-
nue cannot subsist--that the mode provided in the con-
federation for supplying the treasury of the United States
has in experiment been found inadequate--that any objec-
tion to it as a measure not warranted by the confederation
is refuted by the thirteenth article, which provides that
alterations may be made, if agreed to by congress and
confirmed by the legislatures of each state; and the con-
duct of this state itself in adopting the proposed change
of the eighth article is a precedent in which we find the
principle reduced to practice, and affords a complete an-
swer to every pretence of the revenue system being un-
constitutional. That as to danger in vesting the United
States with these funds, your memorialists consider their
interests and liberties as not less safe in the hands of their
fellow-citizens delegated to represent them for one year in
congress, than in the hands of their fellow-citizens dele-
gated to represent them for one, or four years, in the sen-
ate and assembly of this state"--" That government implies
trust, and every government must be trusted so far as it is
necessary to enable it to attain the ends for which it is in-
stituted, without which must result insult and oppression
from abroad, confusion and convulsion at home. "
The public men throughout the state took an open stand
on this question; the newspapers were filled with discus-
sions of its merits,* and the elections turned solely on this
point.
The head of the opposition was the governor, whose in-
fluence, after an administration of nine years, had become
almost irresistible. In the southern district, though opposed
by the commercial members of the community, whose
* The most noticed of the writings against the grant of the impost, were
a series of numbers Rigncd " Rough Hewer," of which the author was Abra-
ham Yates, a member of the legislature and a zealous partisan of Clinton.
49'
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 386
THE LIFE OF
hopes had centred upon Hamilton; Clinton was supported
by a combination of interests--by the most violent of the
whigs, and the most violent of the tories, who had become
zealous whigs. In the interior of the state his ascendency
was limited only by the opposition of a few intelligent men
on the eastern borders of the Hudson, guided by Chancel-
lor Livingston, and by the active and unceasing exertions
of General Schuyler in the northern and western districts,
where he was yet recollected as their most energetic pro-
tector and enlightened friend.
To judge merely from the official communications of
Clinton, the inference would be drawn, that though not a
zealous champion, he was a decided friend to the federal
system; but the measures which marked the policy of the
state, and which were directed by him, indicated very dif-
ferent purposes.
In pursuance of the recommendation of congress, New-
York, on the nineteenth of March, seventeen hundred and
eighty-one, passed an act which, after granting the duties
to that body, provided, "that they should be levied and
collected in such manner and form, and under such pains,
penalties, and regulations, and by such officers, as con-
gress should from time to time make, order, direct, and
appoint. "
Soon, however, after the indications of peace, the policy
of the state changed. The act of seventeen hundred and
eighty-one was repealed,- and on the fifteenth March,
seventeen hundred and eighty-three, a law was enacted
granting the duties; but departing from the principles
which had prompted this measure at its inception, and
which prevailed during a period of danger, directed them
to be collected by the officers and under the authority of the
state. This law, combined with other circumstances, in-
duced congress to recommend the system that was adopted
on the eighteenth of March, seventeen hundred and eighty-
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON.
387
three, which yielded the appointment of the revenue offi-
cers to the states, but rendered them amenable to, and
removable by, the United States* alone.
Early in the year seventeen hundred and eighty-four, a
motion was made in the legislature of New-York, urging
the abolition of the officers of superintendent of finance
and of continental receiver, which was followed by the
acts establishing a customhouse and a revenue system.
The immense and improvident speculations made on the
return of peace, poured into the coffers of that state a
large revenue. This was subsequently increased by the
navigation acts of other states, which rendered New-York
the entrepot of the whole region east of the Delaware, and
presented to her tempting prospects of future wealth.
Blinded by these adventitious circumstances to the supe-
rior advantages to be derived from the general prosperity
of the whole union, the idea of state aggrandizement
engrossed the thoughts of Clinton, who, had the desire
of establishing a separate government ever conflicted in
his mind with a more comprehensive patriotism, would
have regarded this as the great source of influence and
power.
To whatever cause it may be attributed, it became the
settled policy of New-York to defeat the proposition for a
national revenue. A measure conforming with the recom-
mendation of congress was proposed in the legislature in
seventeen hundred and eighty-four, and failed. It was
* In a letter to Hamilton, Schuyler remarks, May 4th, 1783: "Although
our legislature seems still inclined to confer powers on congress adequate to
the proper discharge of the great duties of the sovereign council of these
states, yet I perceive with pain that some, chagrined at disappointment, are
already attempting to inculcate a contrary principle, and I fear it will gain
too deep a root to be eradicated, until such confusion prevails as will make
men deeply feel the necessity of not retaining so much sovereignty in the
states individually. "
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 388
THE LIFE OF
again brought forward in seventeen hundred and eighty-
five, and again failed by two votes in the senate.
At the close of the session of seventeen hundred and
eighty-six, in which the exertions of Schuyler to induce
the grant were most conspicuous, a law was enacted giv-
ing the revenue to congress, but reserving to the state "the
sole power of levying and collecting" the duties; the con-
ferring of which power on congress, was an indispensable
and express condition of the acts of some of the other
states. Instead of making the collectors amenable, and
removable by congress, it subjected them to the exclusive
jurisdiction of the state courts.
It also rendered the duties payable in the bills of credit
of the state, and thus so entirely contravened the plan of
seventeen hundred and eighty-three, as to be equivalent to its'
rejection. This enactment was defended by the argument
that congress, being a single body, and consequently without
checks, would be apt to misapply the money arisingfrom it.
All hope had, in the mean time, centred in this question;
and palsied for the want of resources, congress is seen de-
bating Indian treaties, consulting measures to suppress their
hostilities, discussing the inquiry whether a member could,
without permission from that body or from his state with-
draw from his seat, and suspending all action, waiting the
decision of New-York. *
* The confederation required nine states to form a quorum for every es-
sential purpose. Each state had one vote--no state could be represented by
less than two members. The withdrawal therefore of a member could sus-
pend its functions, and yet New-York, Maryland, and Virginia, affirmed the
absolute right to withdraw, and New-Hampshire, Rhode Island, Connecti-
cut, and Georgia were divided. For the right--William Grayson, John
Haring, Harrison, Henry, Hindman, Houston, Livermorc, Miller, Mitchell,
James Monroe, Melancton Smith; against it--Bayard, Bloodworth, Dane, ,
Few, N. Gorham, Hornblower, Dl. Huger, William Samuel Johnston, Ru-
fus King, Lee, Long, Manning, Parker, Petit, Charles Pinckney, Sedg-
virk, Symmes, White.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON.
389
Perceiving that no benefit could be derived from the
law recently passed by this state; that if acceded to, the
acts of twelve adopting states (for Rhode Island had
meanwhile concurred) would, by their conditions, which
required the concurrence of all the states, become void;
that the provision which rendered the duties payable in
bills of credit was most pernicious, as it would, on the same
principle, admit all the paper money of the other states at
various rates of depreciation, thus reducing the revenue,
producing an inequality in the public burdens, and deter-
ring the states averse from paper money from engaging in
the measure--congress treated it as a nullity.
Feeling deeply their humiliating condition in being una-
ble to meet the claims of foreigners who had advanced
money to prosecute the war, and to discharge the inter-
est on the foreign debt without new loans in Europe,
and thereby compounding it, they passed a resolution
requesting Governor Clinton to convene the legislature
for the purpose of submitting this subject again to its
consideration. To this application, involving such mo-
mentous consequences, Clinton replied by letter, stating
that "he entertained the highest deference and respect for
the authority of congress, and that it would afford him the
greatest pleasure to have it in his power to comply with
their recommendations, but that he had not the power to
convene the legislature before the time fixed by law for
their stated meeting, except upon 'extraordinary occasions'
and as the present business had already been particularly
laid before them, and so recently as at their last session
received their determination, it cannot come within that
description. "
Soon after receiving this communication, congress then
sitting at New-York, adopted a series of resolutions, de-
claring that the act of New-York was not a compliance
with the general plan. "That the present critical and em-
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 390
TIIE LIFE OF
barrassed state of the finances was such as to'require that
the system of impost should be carried into immediate
effect; that they consider this 'an occasion sufficiently im-
portant and extraordinary' for the convening of the legisla-
ture, and 'earnestly' recommend that it should be 'immedi-
ately' called. " Clinton was immovable. This earnest and
solemn appeal of the confederacy was disregarded, and the
hope of establishing a general revenue was almost aban-
doned.
While the dignity of the nation was thus prostrated be-
fore the executive of a single state, difficulties, the conse-
quences of recent example, were pending with several
others. New-Jersey, wearied with fruitless efforts to in-
culcate the benefits of a national system, and jealous of the
commercial prosperity of New-York, early in this year
had resorted to decisive measures. She passed a resolution
(reciting as a reason for it the delinquency of other states)
by which she refused a compliance with the requisition of
congress for her quota, " until all the states in the union
had complied with the revenue system of seventeen hun-
dred and eighty-three, or until states having peculiar com-
mercial advantages should forbear a system of partial le-
gislation. " This formidable decision alarmed the nation,
and demanded the immediate attention of congress, who
sent a deputation to remonstrate with that state. After an
able address from each of the delegates, showing the ne-
cessity of union to the general happiness of all its mem-
bers, but especially to the smaller states, the legislature
rescinded their resolution, but declared that the requisition
had no binding force.
Pennsylvania claimed a set-off against part of her quota-
and a committee was appointed to confer with her legisla-
ture. A similar claim was, after much debate, conceded
to South Carolina. Another committee was directed to
repair to Connecticut, New-Jersey, and North Carolina,
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON.
391
and an address was made to New-Hampshire and Mary-
land, urging upon them a full and immediate compliance
with the last requisition. Was this a government?
These obstacles indicated the necessity of an adjustment
of accounts with the several states, and an ordinance was
framed for that purpose. Another ordinance before re-
commended was passed, of much prospective importance.
It was for the establishment of a mint; the standard of
gold and silver, and the money of account in a decimal ra-
tio, having been previously fixed.
While congress were thus engaged, the insurrection of
Massachusetts broke upon them. After much delay, they,
in secret session, made a report strongly indicative of their
feebleness and their fears. Having stated that unless speedy
and effectual measures were taken to suppress the designs
of the insurgents, they will possess themselves of the arse-
nal at Springfield, subvert the government, and not only
reduce that commonwealth to a state of anarchy and con-
fusion, but probably involve the United States in the ca-
lamity of a civil war; it declared their obligations to
restore the authority of the state, and to protect the public
property, and that for these purposes a body of troops
should be immediately raised, but that the causes of raising
them ought not to be publicly assigned, and that they had,
in a separate report, on the intelligence from the western
country, recommended the augmentation of the troops in
the service of the United States. By this report a legion-
ary corps was ordered to be enlisted for three years, prin-
cipally in New-England.
Thus did an emergency, which every government should
have been empowered to meet, drive congress to a usurpa-
tion upon a false pretext; for where is to be found the
authority in the articles of the confederation to raise a
military force for such a purpose, and what was there to pre-
vent an increase of its number, and its permanent existence 1
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 392
THE LIFE OF
The only security against this usurpation of power was
the want of means; but this want involved the very dan-
ger, for, while acting upon the necessity of the measure,
congress declared," that in the present embarrassments of
the federal finances, they would not hazurd the perilous
step of putting arms into the hands of men, whose fidelity
must in some degree depend on the faithful payment of
their wages, had they not the fullest confidence, from au-
thentic and respectable information, in the most liberal
exertions of the money-holders in the state of Massachu-
setts and the other states, in filling the loans authorized"
for that purpose.
The suppression of the insurrection by her own militia,
leaves it only a subject for speculation what would have
been the consequences of an invasion, by the confederacy,
of so populous, so warlike, and then so jealous a state.
The friends of the union in New-York had in the mean
time determined to make another and a final effort. The
popularity of Hamilton, it was hoped, might have influence;
and while General Schuyler was brought forward as a can-
didate for the senate, Hamilton was put in nomination for
the assembly. His election was earnestly opposed--op-
posed by the men whose cupidity he had exposed in seven-
teen hundred and eighty-four, and who, identified with the
state policy of Clinton, as leaders of the democratic party,
regarded him as a formidable adversary to their narrow
and selfish politics. But serious apprehensions had seized
the community as to the future. They saw in the discords
and the weakness of the confederacy the fulfilment of all
his prophecies, and they looked to him as their last hope
of changing the vicious direction which had been given to
the councils of the state. He was elected. *
* On the eve of this election a letter was received by him from a tory mer-
chant, asking his influence to obtain legislative relief. In his reply he states,
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 393
The legislature opened its session in January, seventeen
hundred and eighty-seven, at the city of New-York. The
speech from the governor, after alluding to the annual ap-
pointment of state officers, from which so large a share of
his influence was derived, adverted to the requisitions for
the service of the year, and stated his confidence that the
dispositions of the legislature being truly federal, would in-
duce a speedy compliance with a measure so essential to
the national support and credit. The representatives were
informed of the resolutions of congress, expressing their
sense of the act granting the impost, and requesting an im-
mediate call of the legislature, whereby the revenue system
of seventeen hundred and eighty-three would be brought
to their view--" a subject which had been repeatedly sub-
mitted to them, and must be well understood. "
The correspondence which had recently passed on that
subject was laid before them, with a declaration, " that a
regard to their excellent constitution, and an anxiety to
preserve unimpaired the right of free deliberation in mat-
ters not stipulated by the confederation, had restrained
him from convening them at an earlier period. " The ad-
"that he would not be understood to declare any opinion concerning the prin-
ciples of the bill;" and remarks, " I make this observation from that spirit of
candour which I hope will always direct my conduct. I am aware that I have
been represented as an enemy to the wishes of what you call your corps. If
by this is meant that I do not feel as much as any man not immediately in-
terested for the distresses of those merchants who have been in a great meas-
ure the victims of the revolution, the supposition does not do justice either to
my head or my heart. But if it means that I have always viewed the mode
of relieving them as a matter of peculiar delicacy and difficulty, it is well
founded.
"I should have thought it unnecessary to enter into this explanation, were it
not that I am held up as a candidate at the ensuing election, and would not
wish that the step I have taken in respect to your letter should be considered
as implying more than it does, for I would never wish to conciliate at the ex-
pense of candour; on the other hand, I confide in your liberality not to infer
more than I intend from the explanation I have given you. "
50
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 394
THE LIFE OF
justment of the territorial controversies with Massachusetts
and Pennsylvania was mentioned, and the speech concluded
by calling the attention of the legislature to local topics.
The address in reply to the speech was referred to a com-
mittee, of which Hamilton was a member, and was reported
by him. It was a mere echo of the speech on all subjects,
except as to the request of congress to convene the legis-
lature, which was passed by in silence. On being reported
to the house, a motion was made by the speaker to amend
it, by expressing their approbation of the governor's con-
duct in not convening the legislature at an earlier period
than that fixed by law; he at the same time disclaiming
all hostility to the impost. This motion produced the effect
which had been sought to be avoided, and called up a long
and vehement debate. While the friends of the union
expressed in general terms a dissent from the views of the
governor, feeling themselves in a minority, they sedulously
endeavoured to prevent all discussion of this topic, seeing
that it had been thrown in as an apple of discord; but the
friends of the governor, who were guided with an adroit
and subtle policy, seized upon this occasion to kindle an
excitement, and to rouse all the hostile feelings of the
states rights party.
The speaker then proposed to withdraw the motion, but
it was insisted that it could not be withdrawn. That no
}11 consequences could arise from a decision; that it was
only a question whether there was such a pressing neces-
sity as to authorize the governor to convene the legisla-
ture. That if the doctrine that the governor was bound
to comply with a requisition of congress on this subject
was sustained, it was impossible to tell where it would end.
That congress might, by repeated requisitions, perhaps once
a month, tease and weary the legislature into a compliance
with their measures; an apprehension not exaggerated,
for such had been the practice of the former government.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 03:42 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275492 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON.