"
College Composition and Communication 47 (1996): 325-41.
College Composition and Communication 47 (1996): 325-41.
The Public Work of Rhetoric_nodrm
Libanius, "Oration 11," 31.
33. For Libanius's financial circumstances, see his own extensive Autobiography and
Norman, General Introduction. On Libanius's school, see Cribiore, School of Libanius, 111-73.
34. Homer, Iliad, "Book 8," 231-50. (Fagles translates the key term as "cable. ")
35. Libanius, "Oration 11," 34-36.
36. See Fishman et al. , "Performing Writing," 224-52, on student performance within
the academic sphere.
37. See Brady, "Review," 70-81, for a review of new books on composition and literature. 38. Scott, "Story of Obama," 22 (emphasis added).
39. See, for example, Aristides' encomium of Rome. Oliver, "Ruling Power," 901-3. See
George, "From Analysis to Design," 11-39, on visual design as argument. 40. Arendt, Human Condition, 199-200.
The Prospects for the Public Work of Rhetoric 295
Works Cited
Ahl, Frederick. "The Art of Safe Criticism in Greece and Rome. " American Journal of Philology 105 (1984): 174-208.
Arendt, Hannah. The Human Condition. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1958. Brady, Laura. "Review: Retelling the Composition-Literature Story. " College English 71
(2008): 70-81.
Brown, Peter. Power and Persuasion in Late Antiquity: Toward a Christian Empire. Madison:
University of Wisconsin Press, 1992.
Brunt, P. A. Roman Imperial Themes. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1990.
Connolly, Jill. "Virile Tongues: Rhetoric and Masculinity. " In A Companion to Roman
Rhetoric, edited by William Dominik and Jon Hall, 83-97. Oxford: Blackwell, 2007. Cribiore, Raffaella. The School of Libanius in Late Antique Antioch. Princeton, N. J. : Prince-
ton University Press, 2007.
Dio Chrysostom. Vol. 1. Translated by J. W. Cohoon. Cambridge, Mass. : Harvard Uni-
versity Press, 1949.
Fishman, Jenn, et al. "Performing Writing, Performing Literacy. " College Composition and
Communication 52 (2005): 224-52.
Foster, John Bellamy. "The Rediscovery of Imperialism. " Monthly Review 54, no. 6 (2002):
1-16.
Foucault, Michel. Fearless Speech. Edited by Joseph Pearson. Los Angeles: Semiotext(e),
2001.
George, Diana. "From Analysis to Design: Visual Communication in the Teaching of
Writing. " College Composition and Communication 54 (2002): 11-39.
Goldhill, Simon. "The Erotic Eye: Visual Stimulation and Cultural Conflict. " In Being
Greek under Rome, 154-94. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001. Gusterson, Hugh. "Up Revisited. " Political and Legal Anthropology Review 20 (1997):
114-19.
Hartnett, Stephen, and Laura Ann Stengrim. Globalization and Empire: The U. S. Invasion
of Iraq, Free Markets, and the Twilight of Democracy. Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama
Press, 2006.
Hauser, Gerard A. Vernacular Voices: The Rhetoric of Publics and Public Spheres. Columbia:
University of South Carolina Press, 1999.
Haussmen, Heath. "Editorial: Ethics Violations Need Real Investigations. " Citizens for
Responsibility and Ethics in Washington. http://www. crewsmostcorrupt. org/node/413
(accessed September 12, 2008).
Homer. The Iliad. Translated by Robert Fagles. New York: Viking, 1990.
Ignatieff, Michael. "The Burden. " New York Times Magazine, January 5, 2003, 22-27, 50,
53-54.
Jarratt, Susan C. "George W. Bush, 'Graduation Speech at West Point. '" Voices of Democ-
racy Project. http://www. voicesofdemocracy. com/ (accessed June 1, 2002).
Kagan, Donald, Gary Schmitt, and Thomas Donnelly. "Rebuilding America's Defenses. Strategy, Forces and Resources for a New Century. " Report of the Project for the New American Century, 2000. http://www. newamericancentury. org/RebuildingAmericas
Defenses. pdf (accessed July 3, 2009).
Konstan, David. The Emotions of the Ancient Greeks: Studies in Aristotle and Classical Lit-
erature. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2006.
Libanius. Autobiography (Oration 1) the Greek Text. Translated by A. F. Norman. New York:
Oxford University Press, 1965.
296 Susan C. Jarratt
------. "Oration 11: The Antiochikos: In Praise of Antioch. " Translated by A. F. Norman. In Antioch as a Centre of Hellenic Culture as Observed by Libanius, 3-65. Liverpool: Liv- erpool University Press, 2000.
Mendelsohn, Daniel. "Theatres of War. " New Yorker, January 12, 2004, 79-84.
Nader, Laura. "Up the Anthropologist--Perspectives Gained from Studying Up. " In Reinventing Anthropology, edited by Dell H. Hymes, 284-311. New York: Pantheon
Books, 1972.
Norman, A. F. General Introduction. In Antioch as a Centre of Hellenic Culture as Observed
by Libanius, xi-xxii. Liverpool: Liverpool University Press, 2000.
Obama, Barack. Dreams from My Father: A Story of Race and Inheritance. New York: Three
Rivers Press, 2004.
Oliver, James H. , trans. "The Ruling Power. A Study of the Roman Empire in the Second
Century after Christ through the Roman Oration of Aelius Aristides. " Transactions of
the American Philological Society 43 (1953): 873-1003.
Pernot, Laurent. Rhetoric in Antiquity. Translated by W. E. Higgins. Washington, D. C. :
Catholic University Press of America, 2005.
Philostratus. Lives of the Sophists. In Philostratus and Eunapius, 2-315. Translated by
Wilmer Cave Wright. Cambridge, Mass. : Harvard University Press, 1921.
Plato. The Republic of Plato. Translated by Francis MacDonald Cornford. New York:
Oxford University Press, 1941.
Poulakos, Takis. Speaking for the Polis: Isocrates' Rhetorical Education. Columbia: Univer-
sity of South Carolina Press, 1997.
Quandahl, Ellen, and Susan C. Jarratt. "'To Recall Him . . . Will Be a Subject of Lamen-
tation': Anna Comnena as Rhetorical Historiographer. " Rhetorica 26 (2008): 301-35. Rose, Peter W. "Cicero and the Rhetoric of Imperialism: Putting the Politics Back into
Political Rhetoric. " Rhetorica 13 (1995): 359-99.
Royster, Jacqueline J. "Disciplinary Landscaping, or Contemporary Challenges in the
History of Rhetoric. " Philosophy and Rhetoric 2 (2003): 148-67.
Scott, Janny. "The Story of Obama, Written by Obama. " New York Times, May 18, 2008. Smith, Neil, and Setha Low. "Introduction: The Imperative of Public Space. " In The Poli-
tics of Public Space, edited by Setha Low and Neil Smith, 1-16. New York: Routledge,
2006.
Suetonius. The Twelve Caesars. Translated by Robert Graves. London: Penguin Books,
1957.
Vitanza, Victor J. Negation, Subjectivity, and the History of Rhetoric. Albany: SUNY Press,
1997.
Wells, Susan. "Rogue Cops and Health Care: What Do We Want from Public Writing.
"
College Composition and Communication 47 (1996): 325-41.
Westrup, J. A. , and F. Ll. Harrison. The New College Encyclopedia of Music. New York: W.
W. Norton, 1976.
Whitmarsh, Tim. Greek Literature and the Roman Empire. The Politics of Imitation. New
York: Oxford University Press, 2004.
------. The Second Sophistic. New York: Oxford University Press, 2005.
Wines, Michael. "Ethics Violations in House Spur Call for Tougher Rules. " New York
Times, December 19, 1988.
Contributors
John M. Ackerman is an associate professor of communication at the University of Colo- rado at Boulder. He directs the Program for Writing and Rhetoric and holds the Ineva Baldwin Chair of Arts and Sciences. He codirects the 2011 Rhetoric Society of America Institute in Boulder and has chaired the Doctoral Consortium of Rhetoric and Compo- sition. His research on disciplinarity, architecture, and everyday life has appeared in various journals and edited collections; an article with Louise Phelps on disciplinary visibility will appear in the sixty-year commemorative issue of College Composition and Communication.
M. Lane Bruner is currently professor of rhetoric and politics in the Department of Com- munication at Georgia State University in Atlanta, Georgia. He is the author of Democ- racy's Debt (2009) and Strategies of Remembrance (2002), and he is a coeditor of Market Democracy in Post-Communist Russia (2005). He has written numerous essays appearing in journals such as the Quarterly Journal of Speech, Rhetoric and Public Affairs, Discourse and Society, and Text and Performance Quarterly. His current research is on political psy- choses, artful resistance, and the aesthetic state.
Ralph Cintron is an associate professor of English studies as well as Latin American and Latino studies at the University of Illinois at Chicago (UIC). He is the author of Angel- stown: Chero Ways, Gang Life, and Rhetorics of the Everyday, which received honorable mention for the Victor Turner prize in ethnographic writing from the American Anthropological Association. He has also been a Rockefeller Foundation fellow; a Ful- bright scholar at the University of Prishtina in Kosova, where he taught political sci- ence; and twice a Great Cities Institute scholar at the College of Urban Planning and Public Administration at UIC. He has been elected to the executive boards of the Col- lege Conference on Composition and Communication and the Rhetoric Society of America. He is currently working on a book tentatively titled "Democracy as Fetish: Rhetoric, Ethnography, and the Expansion of Life" and coediting with Robert Hariman Power, Rhetoric, and Political Culture: The Texture of Political Action.
Celeste M. Condit is a Distinguished Research Professor in the Department of Speech Communication at the University of Georgia. Her work on the social impacts of genet- ics has been supported by the National Institutes of Health's Ethical, Legal and Social Implications (ELSI) Program, and she has been a project PI in the CDC-funded South- ern Center for Communication, Health, and Poverty at the University of Georgia. In addition to approximately a hundred scholarly essays, she has published five books, including The Meanings of the Gene (1999) and, with John Lucaites, Crafting Equality: America's Anglo-African Word (1994). She was elected to the National Communication Association's Distinguished Scholars in 2002.
David J. Coogan is an associate professor of English at Virginia Commonwealth Univer- sity. His work on community literacy, rhetorical theory, and social change has appeared in the journals College Composition and Communication, College English, and Community
298 Contributors
Literacy and in the book Active Voices, edited by Patty Malesh and Sharon Stetson. He is currently finishing a second book, The Prison inside Me: Writing beyond the Bars, the healing story of a writing workshop that began at the Richmond City Jail, followed twelve men into prison, and ended with their return to society.
Ellen Cushman is an associate professor of writing, rhetoric, and American cultures. She is currently finishing a book on the evolution of the Cherokee syllabary, based on four years of ethnohistorical research. She is a citizen of the Cherokee Nation and currently serves as a Sequoyah commissioner. In addition to The Struggle and the Tools (1998) and Literacy: A Critical Sourcebook, edited with Eugene Kintgen, Barry Kroll, and Mike Rose Bedford (2001), her research on literacy studies has included publications in College English, College Composition and Communication, Research in the Teaching of English, Reflections, and Kairos and is forthcoming in Pedagogy and Ethnohistory.
David Fleming is an associate professor of English and director of the Writing Program at the University of Massachusetts Amherst. He is the author of City of Rhetoric: Revital- izing the Public Sphere in Metropolitan America (2008) and On the Hinge of History: Fresh- man Composition and the Long Sixties, 1958-1974 (forthcoming). He is currently at work on a book about rhetorical education: past, present, and future.
Linda Flower is a professor of rhetoric at Carnegie Mellon University and has been co- director of the National Center for the Study of Writing and Literacy at Berkeley and Carnegie Mellon and of the Carnegie Mellon Center for Community Outreach. She is the author of Construction of Negotiated Meaning: A Social Cognitive Theory of Writing (1994) and Community Literacy and the Rhetoric of Public Engagement, which won the 2009 RSA book award.
Diana George is professor of rhetoric and writing at Virginia Tech, where she currently serves as director of composition and the Writing Center. Her work has appeared in a number of collections and journals including College English, College Composition and Communication, and Reflections. She is a past Braddock Award winner and co-author with John Trimbur of the textbook Reading Culture.
Jeffrey T. Grabill is a professor of rhetoric and professional writing and codirector of the Writing in Digital Environments (WIDE) Research Center at Michigan State University. He is the author of Community Literacy Programs and the Politics of Change (2001) and Writing Community Change: Designing Technologies for Citizen Action (2007). His essays have appeared in College Composition and Communication, Technical Communication Quar- terly, Computers and Composition, and English Education.
Erik Green is currently a Ph. D. student in the Department of Education at University of California, Santa Cruz, with a concentration on language, literacy, and culture, and a recipient of the Chancellor's Fellowship. A graduate from Michigan State University, he received a B. A. in English and an M. A. in critical studies in literacy and pedagogy. His research interests include the use of personal narrative in developing identity, queer lit- eracies, and the sponsorship of nondominant discourses.
Gerard A. Hauser is a professor of communication and College Professor of Distinction at the University of Colorado at Boulder. He is editor of Philosophy and Rhetoric. His pub- lications include Introduction to Rhetorical Theory, second edition (2002) and Vernacular Voices: The Rhetoric of Publics and Public Spheres (1999), recipient of the National Com- munication Association's Hochmuth-Nichols Book Award. He is past president of the Rhetoric Society of America and recipient of its George Yoos Distinguished Service
Contributors 299 Award. He is an RSA Fellow and an NCA Distinguished Scholar. His current research
focuses on vernacular rhetoric and rhetorics of resistance.
Susan C. Jarratt is professor of Comparative Literature at the University of California, Irvine and the past coordinator of the University of California, Irvine's Writing Pro- gram. Her research interests include public writing broadly construed, from ancient Greco-Roman rhetoric to contemporary writing, feminism, and critical pedagogy. She is the author of Rereading the Sophists: Classical Rhetoric Refigured and is currently work- ing on a new manuscript, "Chain of Gold," about the Second Sophists.
David A. Jolliffe is professor of English and curriculum and instruction at the Univer- sity of Arkansas at Fayetteville, where he holds the Brown Chair in English Literacy. He is the co-author, with William Covino, of Rhetoric: Concepts, Definitions, Boundaries. His most recent book, with Hephzibah Roskelly, is Everyday Use: Rhetoric at Work in Reading and Writing.
Erik Juergensmeyer is an assistant professor of composition and rhetoric at Fort Lewis College in Durango, Colorado. Beyond his work in action research, argumentation, and assessment, he has recently started a peace and conflict studies program and a commu- nity mediation center that seek to create increased opportunities for restorative justice. His past work appears in Composition Studies, Rhetoric Review, and WPA Journal.
Paula Mathieu is an associate professor of English and director of First-Year Writing at Boston College. Her writing, which focuses on public discourse, economics, homeless- ness, and university-community partnerships, includes a book, Tactics of Hope: The Pub- lic Turn in English Composition, and two coedited collections, Beyond English, Inc. with Claude Hurlbert and David Downing and Writing Places with Tim Lindgren, George Grattan and Staci Shultz, as well as articles in CCCs, Rhetoric Review, and Works and Days.
Carolyn R. Miller is SAS Institute Distinguished Professor of Rhetoric and Technical Communication at North Carolina State University. Her research interests are in digital rhetoric, rhetorical theory, rhetoric of science and technology, and genre studies. Her work has appeared in Argumentation, Argumentation & Advocacy, College English, Config- urations, Journal of Business and Technical Communication, Quarterly Journal of Speech, Rhetorica, and Rhetoric Society Quarterly, as well as in many edited volumes. She has lec- tured and taught in North America, Europe, and South America, and she is a past presi- dent of the Rhetoric Society of America and current editor of Rhetoric Society Quarterly.
Thomas P. Miller teaches courses ranging from first-year composition to graduate semi- nars in the Rhetoric, Composition, and Teaching Program at the University of Arizona, where he is currently associate provost. He received the MLA's Mina Shaughnessy Award for the first volume of his history of college English, The Formation of College English: Rhetoric and Belles Lettres in the British Cultural Provinces. The second volume, The Evolu- tion of College English: Literacy Studies from the Puritans to the Postmoderns, is forthcoming.
Candice Rai is an assistant professor at the University of Washington in Seattle. Her re- search interests center on the relationship between the rhetorical and the material, on public and everyday rhetorics, on urban and spatial theory, on ethnography as a method for studying rhetoric in action, and on community-based pedagogies. Her work has been published in the Michigan Journal of Community Service, Reflections, and the Community Literacy Journal and will soon appear in Ethnography and in Texts of Conse- quence: Composing Rhetorics of Social Activism for the Writing Classroom.
Index
Ackerman, John M. , 11 actor-network theory, 194-95 adversarial relations, 22-26, 29 Aeschines, 28
African Americans, 122. See also "race as genetic"
agency, 193, 197, 200, 205; collective, 230-31; "public rhetorical work," 202; rhetorical, 10, 81, 83, 143, 204, 207, 285; rhetorical agency defined, 147; rhetorical agency of marginalized speakers, 153; rhetorical agency, taking, 145, 147-52. See also specific topics
agonism, 12, 25, 26, 33. See also specific topics
"agonistic pluralism," 41 Ahl, Frederick, 287 Alcidamas, 24
Alinsky, Saul D. , 137
All Quiet on the Western Front (Remarque), 62
Allen, Grant, 260-62
Allen, John, 86
Allen, Richard, 175-76
Alliance of Rhetoric Societies conference,
11
Alliance to Conserve Old Richmond Neighborhoods (ACORN), 158
Anderson, John R. , 217-18
anger, 165
anxiety, 2, 3, 5-7, 9, 114 Appadurai, Arjun, 10 archeological work, 65
Arendt, Hannah, 90, 283
Argument Culture, The (Tannen), 26 "argument is war" metaphor, 25 "argumentative turn," 80 Aristotle, 20, 27, 100, 101
Arnove, Robert, 280
Aspinwall, William, 255 assemblage, 83, 204
assembling a public, community,
group, or other aggregate, 194-201;
and supporting the knowledge work
of others, 201-5
Athenians, ancient, 32
Augusta, Arkansas, 267, 271-72, 276 Augusta Community Literacy Advocacy
Project, 270, 271, 274; analyzing the rhetorical activity of, 276-78; kickoff and the initial year, 274-76; public rhe- torical activity as a teaching opportu- nity, 278-81
Augusta Recovery Initiative, 272-74 Aune, James, 103
autopoiesis, 11
Bacon, Nora, 179
Balkan wars of the 1990s, 108
Barnet, Richard, 10
Barthes, Roland, 213
Be the Change, 79
Becker, Samuel, 4
Benjamin, Walter, 86
Bennett, Lance W. , 80-81
Berlin, James, 6
Bernhardt, Grace, 205
biopower (Foucault), 4
Bitzer, Lloyd, 3, 4, 9-10
Black, Edwin, 3
Blythe, Stuart, 195, 196
body politic, 101
Booth, Wayne, 2, 26, 31, 33
Bowen, Joy Lynn, 274, 276
Boyer, Ernest, 78
Boyte, Harry, 82
Brandt, Deborah, 279-80
"Breaking through the Border," 242-44 bringing-before-the-eyes, 101 Brockmann, Steven, 67
Bruffee, Kenneth, 5
Burchard, Esteban Gonza? lez, 128-29 Burke, Kenneth, 19-20, 25, 29, 39, 232 Bush, George H. W. , 284
Bush, George W. , ix, 63, 71n29, 285, 288 Bush, Robert, 234-35
302 Index
Cahn, Michael, 20-21
Cameron, Colin, 144
Campbell, George, 26-27
Capital Area Community Media Center,
200, 201
capitalism, 58-59, 79, 108, 262
Carnegie Mellon University (CMU) Deci-
sion Makers project, 147
Cato the Elder, 26
Cavanagh, John, 10
Cherokee Nation/Michigan State Univer-
sity (CN/MSU) collaborative, 175-81.
See also praxis of new media
Chicago Rehab Network, 47
Church Hill, Virginia, 157-58, 164 Cicero, 19, 20, 23, 24, 25, 100, 119
cities and towns making rhetorical state-
ments, 268-70
"civic," 76
civic communions, 270, 277
civic engagement, 7, 11, 76-77, 84,
89-91; across education, planning,
and political spheres, 78-80; discourse of, 1; nature of, 76; reframing, 81-82. See also engagement; rhetorical engage- ment
Civic Engagement in Action series, 78 civil rights legislation, 107
classroom, 211-12, 219; reimagining the,
220-25; transformative mediation in
the, 239-40. See also school
Clifford, James, 180
Clinton, Bill, 80
CMU (Carnegie Mellon University) Deci-
sion Makers project, 147
codes, 159, 292-93
Cold War, 107
collective agency. See agency, collective collective identity, 57, 64; "staged," 64 collective identity construction, 58, 60,
63, 67-68
Collier, Steven, 272, 274 color-blindness (race), 128-29 "coming out," 144-45. See also under
learning disabilities
Communism, 107, 108, 114n17 Community Literacy Advocacy Project.
See Augusta Community Literacy Advo-
cacy Project
community media center, 198-202,
206n14
Community Think Tank on Learning Disability, 138-39, 141, 145-48, 152
concealment, rhetorical, 20-23, 27-30, 69 "conduit metaphor" for communication,
35n59
consensus, 57-58, 105, 122-23 Consigny, Scott, 25
consumer ideal of citizenship, 50 Coogan, David, 216-17
cooperation, 24, 31, 33
Corder, Jim, 232, 238
Cornish, Samuel, 249
correspondence theory of truth, 27 counternarrative, 178. See also praxis of
new media
counterpublic deliberation, 152 counterpublic discourses, 61, 260 counterpublic spaces, 253-54, 259;
defined, 253
counterpublic spheres, xi counterpublics, xii, 60-61, 146-47,
160-62, 253, 284. See also specific topics creative economy, 83
critical framing, 182, 186-88
"critical mode" of reception, 32
critical philosophy, 56, 57
critical political communication, 56, 57;
mapping the unspeakable and diag- nosing identity, 62-68; theorizing, 58-60; and theorizing the public work of rhetoric, 60-62
critical rationality, 145, 146 criticism, 194
Crowley, Sharon, 103 Cruikshank, Barbara, 43, 45 cultural economy, 83, 84 Cushman, Ellen, 179
Dawes General Allotment Act of 1887, 177, 178
De Pastino, Todd, 255
Deems, Julia, 236
Delpit, Lisa, 219
democracy, 39-41, 51-52, 76-77; an
anthropology of, 104-7; attribution of a character or ethos to, 105; dissident press and, 249-50; as inclusive deliber- ative process, 47-48; as justice, 48-50; post-Berlin Wall moment, 98, 107-11; preserving it against exclusionary forces, 103; as topos, 43, 102-4, 108,
111, 114; Uptown's "public" and rhetor- ical uses of, 46-47. See also under public sphere trope
"democracy without democrats," 108, 109 Democratic Leadership Council (DLC),
79-80
democratic paradox/paradox of democ-
racy, 40, 41
democratic rhetorics: democratic gover-
nance and, 105-6; institutions of
democracy and, 105 Demosthenes, 22
DeVoss, Danielle Nicole, 179 Diab, Rasha, 222
diagnosis, medical, 140-41
dialogic engagement, 152
difference, 138; without exclusion, social
relations of, 51
Dio (Sophist), 288, 289
Dionysius, 28
disabilities: defined, 138; discourse on,
143, 144. See also learning disabilities disabilities studies, 143-44
dissent, rhetoric of, 251-54, 261; "Hobo"
News and, 254-59
dissident press, 252-54, 258-60, 262-63;
nature of, 249-51. See also dissent dissimulation, 20, 21, 23, 25, 26, 69 dissoi logoi (antithesis/counterstatement),
27, 167
du Gay, Paul, 83-84 Duberman, Martin, 222 Dupont, Leslie, 242
East End Teen Center ("Teen City"), 159-63
economy, new, 80, 82, 83, 89-90
Ede, Lisa, 5
education: civic rhetorical, 215; structural
possibilities of formal, 219-20. See also Augusta Community Literacy Advo- cacy Project; Augusta Recovery Initia- tive; dissent; pedagogies; school
Ehninger, Douglass, 3
Emig, Janet, 212
emotion, 23. See also specific emotions empire, 284-85
empowerment. See learning disabilities energeia (energy), 100-102, 112, 114 engagement, 76; citizen-scholars and
community, 8-12; methodology of--
see assembling a public, community, group, or other aggregate; scholarship of, 11. See also civic engagement; rhetorical engagement
engaging publics. See Cherokee Nation / Michigan State University (CN/MSU) collaborative; praxis of new media
Enlightenment, 29, 99
"entertainment mode" of reception, 32 Entman, Robert M. , 80-81 environmental projects, 195-96 epistemic crisis of rhetoric, 3-8
equal opportunity, 160
essentialism, 57
ethical practice, 183, 188-89
ethos, 34n29, 48, 165, 269, 276; of cities,
268, 269; creating a successful, 252; of democracy, 105; generative, 232; mis- sionary, 236; organizational, 84
expressive moves, 152
fairness, 106
fear. See anxiety
figured discourse, 290-92
Fix Wilson Yard, 52
Fleming, David, 44-45, 222
Flower, Linda, 4-5, 236
Folger, Joseph, 234-35
Foucault, Michael, 57, 65, 286-87 Fraser, Nancy, x
free speech, 284; practice, politics, and
posture, 286-88, 292. See also democracy Freire, Paulo, 137
freshman composition, 220, 222, 224-25 Freshman Composition program, 220 Fukuyama, Francis, 98
Galston, William, 215-16 Gaonkar, Dilip, 2, 5-7, 27 Garsten, Bryan, 33 Geisler, Cheryl, 218 genealogy, 65
generality (composition), 224 generative ethos, 232
genetic medicine: publishing about
race-based medicine in, 122-24. See
also "race as genetic" genomes, 125
gentrification. See democracy Germany, 64-67
Glenn, Cheryl, 249
Index 303
304 Index
"globalization," 10, 11, 82, 254; textual, 6 "globalization project" of rhetoric, 31 Goebbels, Joseph, 71n29
"going public," 7, 271. See also under
learning disabilities
Goodley, Dan, 143
Gorgias, 25
Grabill, Jeffrey T. , 179
Graff, Harvey, 280
Greeks, ancient, 286. See also Athenians;
specific philosophers
Greene, Ronald, 81
group difference, social relations affirm-
ing, 51
Gutmann, Amy, 111, 112
Habermas, Ju? rgen, x-xi, 44-45, 104, 111, 145
Hales, Kathryn, 11
Haplotype Map Project (HapMap), 121,
130; relabeling the, 126-27 Hariman, Robert, 31 Hart-Davidson, Bill, 200
Hauser, Gerard A. , 44-45, 90, 146 Hawhee, Debra, 25
Hayes, John, 4-5
health, public. See assembling a public,
community, group, or other aggregate health disparities, 121, 122. See also "race
as genetic"
hegemonic public, 60-61
Henwood, Doug, 82
Herzog, Don, 29, 30
Hesk, Jon, 32
Hitler, Adolf, 65, 66
"Hobo" News, 254, 260-61, 263; and a
rhetoric of dissent, 254-59 Holocaust, 64-66
homeless persons, dissident journalists
advocating for, 248, 255-57
housing. See Uptown
Housing Affordability Research Consor-
tium, 47
How, James Eads, 255-58
Howe, Craig, 186
Human Genetic Variation Consortium,
121, 122, 125, 127
human relations as adversarial, 22-26, 29
identity. See collective identity; learning disabilities; social identity
identity-asserting statements, 152. See also learning disabilities
Ignatieff, Michael, 284
imitation. See mimesis
immersion, 190, 214, 217, 218. See also
praxis of new media inclusion/exclusion, 103-5, 107, 108, 112,
113
incommensurability, 27. See also specific
topics
indirection, 225
insituatio, 25
instruction, implicit vs. explicit, 217-18 integrity and appearance, 30 intelligence quotient (IQ), 140 International Brotherhood Welfare Asso-
ciation (IBWA), 256, 257 International Network of Street Papers
(INSP), 253, 254
interpretive moves, 152
invention, 100. See also rhetorical inven-
tion
Jackson, Brian, 240
Jenninger, Philip, 65-66 Juergensmeyer, Erik, 240, 242 justice, democracy as, 48-50. See also
social justice
Kant, Immanuel, 69n2, 110-11
Kennedy, George A. , 101, 211
Kent, Ohio, city plans and artifacts, 87-89 cultural economy of, 84-87, 89
Kent State shootings, 86, 87
Kessler, Lauren, 250
King, Andrew, 10
knowledge work, 205
Kosovo, 104, 108, 109, 115n17
Kushner, Tony, 259
labels. See learning disabilities Laclau, Ernesto, 60, 65
language as (or should be) mimetic,
26-33. See also specific topics Lanham, Richard A. , 29, 32-33 Latour, Bruno, 194-95, 205; "thing
theory" and, 199
learning disabilities (LDs), aspects of,
152; damage control and the dilemma of, 141-43; in a deliberative discourse, 144-47; in a disabling discourse,
138-39; going public, 137-39, 141-43, 151; institutionalized, 141; mediatized, 139-40; medicalized, 140-41; represen- tation and identity, 143-44; taking rhetorical agency, 147-53
Lefebvre, Henri, 8
LeFevre, Karen Burke, 232, 238
Leff, Michael, 2
Lenehan, William, 220-21
Libanius, 290-92
liberation ideology, 108
liberties, 106
liminality (composition), 224 listening-rhetoric, 26
literacy, 279-80; autonomous vs. ideologi-
cal models of, 279
literacy campaigns, 280
"literacy climate," 279
literacy liaisons, 274
literacy programs, towns, and cities mak-
ing rhetorical statements, 267-71. See also Augusta Community Literacy Advocacy Project
Little Rock, Arkansas, 268-69 Lloyd-Jones, Richard, 231 local publics, 270
logos, 7, 163, 292
London, Jack, 258
Long, Eleanor, 270-71, 278 Longinus, 23, 28 Lunsford, Andrea, 5 Lyday, Margaret M. , 249
Machiavelli, Niccolo`, 20
Mahr, Bill, 71n30
marginality (of rhetoric), 18, 249-51;
power, control, and, 31; rhetoric's his-
tory of, 31
marginalized groups, xi, 146, 250 marginalized people, 137, 145-47 marginalized speakers, 138, 144, 149,
153
"marketplace," language of the, 27 Martinez, Inez, 223-24
Masses (magazine), 251-53 Maurin, Peter, 264n51 McDermott, R. P. , 143
media, learning disabilities in the,
138-39. See also under teaching rhetoric media center. See community media
center
mediation, 229-32, 244; "Breaking through the Border," 242-44; rediscov- ering the inventive capacities of con- flicted situations, 232-33; "Showdown in Superior! ," 240-42;
mediation, transformative: in the class- room, 239-40; as model for learning from "dissensus," 233-36
mediation center, community, 236-39 medical diagnosis, 140-41
Mehan, Hugh, 143
memory, 86-87. See also public memory Mendelsohn, Daniel, 284
mestiza public, 146-47
Michigan State University. See Cherokee
Nation / Michigan State University
(CN/MSU) collaborative
middle spaces, 159
Miller, Susan, 2
mimesis, 26-33; appearance of, 28 missionary ethos, 236
Mouffe, Chantal, 41, 82-83 Muehlenkamp, Bob, 222
multiliteracies. See pedagogy of multilit-
eracies mythos, 50, 163
9/11. See September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks
"Naming the LD Difference," 138 National Institutes of Health (NIH)
Roundtable on Race, 127-30 nationalism, 109
nation-state, 108, 113
Native Americans. See Cherokee Nation /
Michigan State University (CN/MSU)
collaborative
National Socialism, 64-67 Nazi Germany, 64-67
Obama, Barack, xi, 292-93
observation language, theory-neutral, 27 Ohmann, Richard, 262
oligarchic democracy, 106, 112-14 Olson, Kathryn M. , 67
Ong, Walter, 25
paideia, xvi, 283-92; postmodern, 283, 285, 288, 292
Paley, Julia, 43, 104 parrhe^sia, 286-88, 291, 292
Index 305
306 Index
pathos, 258, 269
Pax Romana, 284, 291
pedagogies: related to praxis of new
media, 182-83. See also school pedagogy of multiliteracies, 183, 186 "Pedagogy of Multiliteracies, A" (New
London Group), 181-82
Peirce, Charles Sanders, 69n3 perspicuity, 26-27
Petraglia, Joseph, 213
Pheasant Run conference, 8-10 Philips, Ben, 176
Philostratus, 288, 289
phronesis, 3, 4, 181
placemaking, 160-61
Plato, 19
plausible deniability, 20
poie^sis, 11, 76, 161, 285
policy studies, 80
"policy turn," 80
political rhetoric, 32
"politics of representation," 143 Poppin, Wayne, 229
postmodern paideia, 283, 285, 288, 292 postmodern rhetoric, 283-84, 292 poststructuralist philosophy, 56, 57 Poulakos, John, 25
poverty, 46, 253-54, 258, 259, 261. See
also homeless persons; Kent practice, 182
praxis of new media, 179-82, 189-90;
critical framing in a, 182, 186-88; overt instruction in a, 182, 185-86; pedago- gies related to, 182-83; premises under- lying, 181; situated practice in a, 182-85; transformed and ethical, 182, 183, 188-89
presidential campaign of 2008, U. S. , 292-93
Procter, David, 269-70
professional work, 205
Progressive Policy Institute (PPI), 80 Pryke, Michael, 83-84
psychoanalytic theorists, 56, 57
public, the, 2, 60, 253; doing rhetoric, 2 public discourse, 161-62. See also specific
topics
"public good," 33, 42, 44, 106, 111-13; determining the, 111-13; idealizing the concept of, 112. See also praxis of new media
public goods, 39, 40, 47, 49-50
public life; "lost geographies" of, 285-86;
the space to work in, 1-3; citizen-schol- ars and community engagement, 8-12; rhetoric's epistemic crisis, 3-8
public memory, 56-68, 71n25, 72n32, 76, 86-90
public sphere, 39, 113, 253; calls to im- prove, 112; consensus and, 105, 122-23; disabilities and, 145; inclusive vs. exclu- sive, 103-4, 112--see also inclusion/ exclusion; participation and, 145-46; vs. private sphere, 60; reticulate, 7; working in, 104. See also specific topics
public sphere theory, 43
public sphere trope, 41; democratic the-
ory, power, and the limits of, 41-46 public work of rhetoric, theorizing the,
60-62
publicity effect, 167-72
publics, constructing, 20-22; publics,
engaging--see Cherokee Nation / Michigan State University (CN/MSU) collaborative; praxis of new media; local, 270
Quintilian, 23-25
race, 157; antiracism and, 128-29; and going live to genetics researchers on the harmful impact of, 124-26; human genetic variation consortium and, 120- 22; NIH Roundtable on Race, 127-30; race-based medicine, publishing data about challenges and costs of, 122-24 recommendations regarding issues of, 131-32; reification of, 124, 125, 127; scorecard regarding "race as genetic," 130-31
racism, 126
rape, gang, 157-58, 160, 162
Reagan, Ronald, 66-67
Reamer, David, 240, 242
Reder, Lynn M. , 217-18
reflexivity, 7-8
Remarque, Erich, 62
resistance: constructive, 144, 145, 147; "is
sending up a signal flare in the dark-
ness," 247, 259. See also dissent resistance strategies, 144
reticulate public sphere, 7, 44, 154n35
revolutions, 104-5
rhetoric: citizen scholars and commu-
nity engagement, 8-12; denial of, 28, 29--see also concealment; self-denial; denying itself, 7, 20-21; epistemic crisis of, 3-8; nature of, 6, 19, 20, 101; "new," 3; opposing impulses within, 19; "out there," 1; primary vs. second- ary, 211; should never deny itself, 7; teaching bad, 260-62. See also specific topics
"Rhetoric and Its Double" (Gaonkar), 5 "rhetoric of anti-rhetoric," 35n64 Rhetorica Ad Herennium, 24, 25
rhetorica docens, 31, 32
rhetorica utens, 31-33
rhetorical activism, 216
"rhetorical age," 9-10
rhetorical agency. See agency
rhetorical consciousness, 6
Rhetorical Education in Amercai (Glenn et
al. ), 249
rhetorical engagement: in the cultural
economy, 89-91; toward a political and
economic reframing of, 80-84 "rhetorical failure," 216 rhetorical invention, 271, 278 rhetorical return, 249
rhetorical scholarship, 216
rhetors, nontraditional, 249. See also dis-
sident press rhetrickery, 26, 31 Rideout, Walter, 220 Right Dimensions, 90-91 rights, 12, 19, 107
Riis, Jacob, 258
Risch, Neil, 119
Rogers, Carl R. , 232 Roman rhetoric, 25 Russwurm, John, 249
Saussure, Ferdinand de, 69n3 Schloemann, Johan, 32
"scholarship of engagement," 11, 78 school, 211-12, 225; emphasis on factual
knowledge, 215-17; failure to promote self-actualization and improve the world, 214; problems with, 212-15; preference for theoretical abstraction, 217-20; virtues of, 215. See also class- room; learning disabilities
Schopenhauer, Arthur, 69n2
secondary rhetoric, 211
self-advocacy, 147
self-aggrandizement, impulse toward, 19 self-denial, 21; impulse toward, 19, 20.
See also under rhetoric
semantics movement of 1940s and 1950s,
248
semiotic theory, 69n3
Sennett, Richard, 82
September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, 63,
79
Serbia, 108-9, 114n17
ServiceNation, 79, 83
Shakespeare, William, 28
Sharer, Wendy B. , 249
Shiller, Helen, 40, 41, 48-50 Shimabukuro, Mira, 222
Shor, Ira, 221
"Showdown in Superior! ," 240-42 "sick" discourses, 57
"signal flare in the darkness," 249 Simon, Herbert A. , 217-18
sincerity, 23-24. See also transparency situated practice, 182-85
situational rhetoric, 251
Sloop, John, 6
Sly, Gloria, 175-76, 177
"social, the," 195
social categories, 137
social change, rhetorical theorists work-
ing for, 119-20
social class, 102
social energy, 9, 100-102, 108, 111
social identity, valid, 144-45, 152. See also
learning disabilities
social justice, 247-49. See also justice social oppression, 144
social structure, 102
socialism, 262
sociology, reflexive, 7-8
sophistic discourse, 289
sophistic rhetoric, 25, 284, 287 sophistic tactics, 292
sophists, 159-63, 166, 172, 288-91; for
social change, 59; On the Sophists
(Alcidamas), 23
sovereignty, 108
Spahiu, Nexmedin, 108-9, 114n17 spontaneity, 23, 24
Sprat, Thomas, 29
Index 307
308 Index
Start on Success (SOS), 138, 141, 147, 148, 152, 153n8
state of exception (Agamben), 109, 114n17
stimulated learning movement, 217 Streitmatter, Rodger, 251
Stuckey, J. Elspeth, 6-7
students participating in public rhetorics,
lessons regarding, 189-90. See also
praxis of new media suspicion, 22-24, 29 Swain, John, 144 symbolic economies, 86
Tannen, Deborah, 26
teachers, 212. See also school teaching rhetoric, 163-67, 287, 292;
authentic/inauthentic learning, 184-88; new media, 179-84; and social justice, 247-49; transmuting values, 9-12, 260-63
Teen City, 160-63
terrorism, 63
theory-neutral observation language, 27 third space, 9
Tocqueville, Alexis de, 113
topoi/topos, 8, 11, 39, 83, 108, 111-12,
236; considerations regarding, 101-2; nature of, 100, 101; postromantic "unteachability," 211; social energies and, 100-102. See also democracy
totalitarianism, 109-10
Toulmin, Stephen, 268
tragic events, public commemoration
and planning in the context of. See civic engagement; Kent; rhetorical engagement
Trajan (emperor), 288
transformed practice, 182, 183, 188-89 transparency, 26-27
transparency thesis, 27
Two Sides of a One Track Mind (Coogan
and Malinoski), 167
universality (education), 224 universities, 79
University of Wisconsin (UW), English
Department at, 220-25; "emergent"
curriculum, 223; Teaching Assistants'
Association, 223 Uptown (Chicago), 40-51 Urban Matters, 216
vernacular pedagogy, 163
violence, 165; of collective identity con-
struction and public memory, 63. See
also specific topics
Virginia Commonwealth University (VCU), 160, 162
Wacquant, Loi? c, 7-8 Wallace, Karl, 4
war, 62-63
"war on terror," 63
Warner, Michael, 146, 253 Weber, Max, 102 Weizsa?
33. For Libanius's financial circumstances, see his own extensive Autobiography and
Norman, General Introduction. On Libanius's school, see Cribiore, School of Libanius, 111-73.
34. Homer, Iliad, "Book 8," 231-50. (Fagles translates the key term as "cable. ")
35. Libanius, "Oration 11," 34-36.
36. See Fishman et al. , "Performing Writing," 224-52, on student performance within
the academic sphere.
37. See Brady, "Review," 70-81, for a review of new books on composition and literature. 38. Scott, "Story of Obama," 22 (emphasis added).
39. See, for example, Aristides' encomium of Rome. Oliver, "Ruling Power," 901-3. See
George, "From Analysis to Design," 11-39, on visual design as argument. 40. Arendt, Human Condition, 199-200.
The Prospects for the Public Work of Rhetoric 295
Works Cited
Ahl, Frederick. "The Art of Safe Criticism in Greece and Rome. " American Journal of Philology 105 (1984): 174-208.
Arendt, Hannah. The Human Condition. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1958. Brady, Laura. "Review: Retelling the Composition-Literature Story. " College English 71
(2008): 70-81.
Brown, Peter. Power and Persuasion in Late Antiquity: Toward a Christian Empire. Madison:
University of Wisconsin Press, 1992.
Brunt, P. A. Roman Imperial Themes. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1990.
Connolly, Jill. "Virile Tongues: Rhetoric and Masculinity. " In A Companion to Roman
Rhetoric, edited by William Dominik and Jon Hall, 83-97. Oxford: Blackwell, 2007. Cribiore, Raffaella. The School of Libanius in Late Antique Antioch. Princeton, N. J. : Prince-
ton University Press, 2007.
Dio Chrysostom. Vol. 1. Translated by J. W. Cohoon. Cambridge, Mass. : Harvard Uni-
versity Press, 1949.
Fishman, Jenn, et al. "Performing Writing, Performing Literacy. " College Composition and
Communication 52 (2005): 224-52.
Foster, John Bellamy. "The Rediscovery of Imperialism. " Monthly Review 54, no. 6 (2002):
1-16.
Foucault, Michel. Fearless Speech. Edited by Joseph Pearson. Los Angeles: Semiotext(e),
2001.
George, Diana. "From Analysis to Design: Visual Communication in the Teaching of
Writing. " College Composition and Communication 54 (2002): 11-39.
Goldhill, Simon. "The Erotic Eye: Visual Stimulation and Cultural Conflict. " In Being
Greek under Rome, 154-94. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001. Gusterson, Hugh. "Up Revisited. " Political and Legal Anthropology Review 20 (1997):
114-19.
Hartnett, Stephen, and Laura Ann Stengrim. Globalization and Empire: The U. S. Invasion
of Iraq, Free Markets, and the Twilight of Democracy. Tuscaloosa: University of Alabama
Press, 2006.
Hauser, Gerard A. Vernacular Voices: The Rhetoric of Publics and Public Spheres. Columbia:
University of South Carolina Press, 1999.
Haussmen, Heath. "Editorial: Ethics Violations Need Real Investigations. " Citizens for
Responsibility and Ethics in Washington. http://www. crewsmostcorrupt. org/node/413
(accessed September 12, 2008).
Homer. The Iliad. Translated by Robert Fagles. New York: Viking, 1990.
Ignatieff, Michael. "The Burden. " New York Times Magazine, January 5, 2003, 22-27, 50,
53-54.
Jarratt, Susan C. "George W. Bush, 'Graduation Speech at West Point. '" Voices of Democ-
racy Project. http://www. voicesofdemocracy. com/ (accessed June 1, 2002).
Kagan, Donald, Gary Schmitt, and Thomas Donnelly. "Rebuilding America's Defenses. Strategy, Forces and Resources for a New Century. " Report of the Project for the New American Century, 2000. http://www. newamericancentury. org/RebuildingAmericas
Defenses. pdf (accessed July 3, 2009).
Konstan, David. The Emotions of the Ancient Greeks: Studies in Aristotle and Classical Lit-
erature. Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2006.
Libanius. Autobiography (Oration 1) the Greek Text. Translated by A. F. Norman. New York:
Oxford University Press, 1965.
296 Susan C. Jarratt
------. "Oration 11: The Antiochikos: In Praise of Antioch. " Translated by A. F. Norman. In Antioch as a Centre of Hellenic Culture as Observed by Libanius, 3-65. Liverpool: Liv- erpool University Press, 2000.
Mendelsohn, Daniel. "Theatres of War. " New Yorker, January 12, 2004, 79-84.
Nader, Laura. "Up the Anthropologist--Perspectives Gained from Studying Up. " In Reinventing Anthropology, edited by Dell H. Hymes, 284-311. New York: Pantheon
Books, 1972.
Norman, A. F. General Introduction. In Antioch as a Centre of Hellenic Culture as Observed
by Libanius, xi-xxii. Liverpool: Liverpool University Press, 2000.
Obama, Barack. Dreams from My Father: A Story of Race and Inheritance. New York: Three
Rivers Press, 2004.
Oliver, James H. , trans. "The Ruling Power. A Study of the Roman Empire in the Second
Century after Christ through the Roman Oration of Aelius Aristides. " Transactions of
the American Philological Society 43 (1953): 873-1003.
Pernot, Laurent. Rhetoric in Antiquity. Translated by W. E. Higgins. Washington, D. C. :
Catholic University Press of America, 2005.
Philostratus. Lives of the Sophists. In Philostratus and Eunapius, 2-315. Translated by
Wilmer Cave Wright. Cambridge, Mass. : Harvard University Press, 1921.
Plato. The Republic of Plato. Translated by Francis MacDonald Cornford. New York:
Oxford University Press, 1941.
Poulakos, Takis. Speaking for the Polis: Isocrates' Rhetorical Education. Columbia: Univer-
sity of South Carolina Press, 1997.
Quandahl, Ellen, and Susan C. Jarratt. "'To Recall Him . . . Will Be a Subject of Lamen-
tation': Anna Comnena as Rhetorical Historiographer. " Rhetorica 26 (2008): 301-35. Rose, Peter W. "Cicero and the Rhetoric of Imperialism: Putting the Politics Back into
Political Rhetoric. " Rhetorica 13 (1995): 359-99.
Royster, Jacqueline J. "Disciplinary Landscaping, or Contemporary Challenges in the
History of Rhetoric. " Philosophy and Rhetoric 2 (2003): 148-67.
Scott, Janny. "The Story of Obama, Written by Obama. " New York Times, May 18, 2008. Smith, Neil, and Setha Low. "Introduction: The Imperative of Public Space. " In The Poli-
tics of Public Space, edited by Setha Low and Neil Smith, 1-16. New York: Routledge,
2006.
Suetonius. The Twelve Caesars. Translated by Robert Graves. London: Penguin Books,
1957.
Vitanza, Victor J. Negation, Subjectivity, and the History of Rhetoric. Albany: SUNY Press,
1997.
Wells, Susan. "Rogue Cops and Health Care: What Do We Want from Public Writing.
"
College Composition and Communication 47 (1996): 325-41.
Westrup, J. A. , and F. Ll. Harrison. The New College Encyclopedia of Music. New York: W.
W. Norton, 1976.
Whitmarsh, Tim. Greek Literature and the Roman Empire. The Politics of Imitation. New
York: Oxford University Press, 2004.
------. The Second Sophistic. New York: Oxford University Press, 2005.
Wines, Michael. "Ethics Violations in House Spur Call for Tougher Rules. " New York
Times, December 19, 1988.
Contributors
John M. Ackerman is an associate professor of communication at the University of Colo- rado at Boulder. He directs the Program for Writing and Rhetoric and holds the Ineva Baldwin Chair of Arts and Sciences. He codirects the 2011 Rhetoric Society of America Institute in Boulder and has chaired the Doctoral Consortium of Rhetoric and Compo- sition. His research on disciplinarity, architecture, and everyday life has appeared in various journals and edited collections; an article with Louise Phelps on disciplinary visibility will appear in the sixty-year commemorative issue of College Composition and Communication.
M. Lane Bruner is currently professor of rhetoric and politics in the Department of Com- munication at Georgia State University in Atlanta, Georgia. He is the author of Democ- racy's Debt (2009) and Strategies of Remembrance (2002), and he is a coeditor of Market Democracy in Post-Communist Russia (2005). He has written numerous essays appearing in journals such as the Quarterly Journal of Speech, Rhetoric and Public Affairs, Discourse and Society, and Text and Performance Quarterly. His current research is on political psy- choses, artful resistance, and the aesthetic state.
Ralph Cintron is an associate professor of English studies as well as Latin American and Latino studies at the University of Illinois at Chicago (UIC). He is the author of Angel- stown: Chero Ways, Gang Life, and Rhetorics of the Everyday, which received honorable mention for the Victor Turner prize in ethnographic writing from the American Anthropological Association. He has also been a Rockefeller Foundation fellow; a Ful- bright scholar at the University of Prishtina in Kosova, where he taught political sci- ence; and twice a Great Cities Institute scholar at the College of Urban Planning and Public Administration at UIC. He has been elected to the executive boards of the Col- lege Conference on Composition and Communication and the Rhetoric Society of America. He is currently working on a book tentatively titled "Democracy as Fetish: Rhetoric, Ethnography, and the Expansion of Life" and coediting with Robert Hariman Power, Rhetoric, and Political Culture: The Texture of Political Action.
Celeste M. Condit is a Distinguished Research Professor in the Department of Speech Communication at the University of Georgia. Her work on the social impacts of genet- ics has been supported by the National Institutes of Health's Ethical, Legal and Social Implications (ELSI) Program, and she has been a project PI in the CDC-funded South- ern Center for Communication, Health, and Poverty at the University of Georgia. In addition to approximately a hundred scholarly essays, she has published five books, including The Meanings of the Gene (1999) and, with John Lucaites, Crafting Equality: America's Anglo-African Word (1994). She was elected to the National Communication Association's Distinguished Scholars in 2002.
David J. Coogan is an associate professor of English at Virginia Commonwealth Univer- sity. His work on community literacy, rhetorical theory, and social change has appeared in the journals College Composition and Communication, College English, and Community
298 Contributors
Literacy and in the book Active Voices, edited by Patty Malesh and Sharon Stetson. He is currently finishing a second book, The Prison inside Me: Writing beyond the Bars, the healing story of a writing workshop that began at the Richmond City Jail, followed twelve men into prison, and ended with their return to society.
Ellen Cushman is an associate professor of writing, rhetoric, and American cultures. She is currently finishing a book on the evolution of the Cherokee syllabary, based on four years of ethnohistorical research. She is a citizen of the Cherokee Nation and currently serves as a Sequoyah commissioner. In addition to The Struggle and the Tools (1998) and Literacy: A Critical Sourcebook, edited with Eugene Kintgen, Barry Kroll, and Mike Rose Bedford (2001), her research on literacy studies has included publications in College English, College Composition and Communication, Research in the Teaching of English, Reflections, and Kairos and is forthcoming in Pedagogy and Ethnohistory.
David Fleming is an associate professor of English and director of the Writing Program at the University of Massachusetts Amherst. He is the author of City of Rhetoric: Revital- izing the Public Sphere in Metropolitan America (2008) and On the Hinge of History: Fresh- man Composition and the Long Sixties, 1958-1974 (forthcoming). He is currently at work on a book about rhetorical education: past, present, and future.
Linda Flower is a professor of rhetoric at Carnegie Mellon University and has been co- director of the National Center for the Study of Writing and Literacy at Berkeley and Carnegie Mellon and of the Carnegie Mellon Center for Community Outreach. She is the author of Construction of Negotiated Meaning: A Social Cognitive Theory of Writing (1994) and Community Literacy and the Rhetoric of Public Engagement, which won the 2009 RSA book award.
Diana George is professor of rhetoric and writing at Virginia Tech, where she currently serves as director of composition and the Writing Center. Her work has appeared in a number of collections and journals including College English, College Composition and Communication, and Reflections. She is a past Braddock Award winner and co-author with John Trimbur of the textbook Reading Culture.
Jeffrey T. Grabill is a professor of rhetoric and professional writing and codirector of the Writing in Digital Environments (WIDE) Research Center at Michigan State University. He is the author of Community Literacy Programs and the Politics of Change (2001) and Writing Community Change: Designing Technologies for Citizen Action (2007). His essays have appeared in College Composition and Communication, Technical Communication Quar- terly, Computers and Composition, and English Education.
Erik Green is currently a Ph. D. student in the Department of Education at University of California, Santa Cruz, with a concentration on language, literacy, and culture, and a recipient of the Chancellor's Fellowship. A graduate from Michigan State University, he received a B. A. in English and an M. A. in critical studies in literacy and pedagogy. His research interests include the use of personal narrative in developing identity, queer lit- eracies, and the sponsorship of nondominant discourses.
Gerard A. Hauser is a professor of communication and College Professor of Distinction at the University of Colorado at Boulder. He is editor of Philosophy and Rhetoric. His pub- lications include Introduction to Rhetorical Theory, second edition (2002) and Vernacular Voices: The Rhetoric of Publics and Public Spheres (1999), recipient of the National Com- munication Association's Hochmuth-Nichols Book Award. He is past president of the Rhetoric Society of America and recipient of its George Yoos Distinguished Service
Contributors 299 Award. He is an RSA Fellow and an NCA Distinguished Scholar. His current research
focuses on vernacular rhetoric and rhetorics of resistance.
Susan C. Jarratt is professor of Comparative Literature at the University of California, Irvine and the past coordinator of the University of California, Irvine's Writing Pro- gram. Her research interests include public writing broadly construed, from ancient Greco-Roman rhetoric to contemporary writing, feminism, and critical pedagogy. She is the author of Rereading the Sophists: Classical Rhetoric Refigured and is currently work- ing on a new manuscript, "Chain of Gold," about the Second Sophists.
David A. Jolliffe is professor of English and curriculum and instruction at the Univer- sity of Arkansas at Fayetteville, where he holds the Brown Chair in English Literacy. He is the co-author, with William Covino, of Rhetoric: Concepts, Definitions, Boundaries. His most recent book, with Hephzibah Roskelly, is Everyday Use: Rhetoric at Work in Reading and Writing.
Erik Juergensmeyer is an assistant professor of composition and rhetoric at Fort Lewis College in Durango, Colorado. Beyond his work in action research, argumentation, and assessment, he has recently started a peace and conflict studies program and a commu- nity mediation center that seek to create increased opportunities for restorative justice. His past work appears in Composition Studies, Rhetoric Review, and WPA Journal.
Paula Mathieu is an associate professor of English and director of First-Year Writing at Boston College. Her writing, which focuses on public discourse, economics, homeless- ness, and university-community partnerships, includes a book, Tactics of Hope: The Pub- lic Turn in English Composition, and two coedited collections, Beyond English, Inc. with Claude Hurlbert and David Downing and Writing Places with Tim Lindgren, George Grattan and Staci Shultz, as well as articles in CCCs, Rhetoric Review, and Works and Days.
Carolyn R. Miller is SAS Institute Distinguished Professor of Rhetoric and Technical Communication at North Carolina State University. Her research interests are in digital rhetoric, rhetorical theory, rhetoric of science and technology, and genre studies. Her work has appeared in Argumentation, Argumentation & Advocacy, College English, Config- urations, Journal of Business and Technical Communication, Quarterly Journal of Speech, Rhetorica, and Rhetoric Society Quarterly, as well as in many edited volumes. She has lec- tured and taught in North America, Europe, and South America, and she is a past presi- dent of the Rhetoric Society of America and current editor of Rhetoric Society Quarterly.
Thomas P. Miller teaches courses ranging from first-year composition to graduate semi- nars in the Rhetoric, Composition, and Teaching Program at the University of Arizona, where he is currently associate provost. He received the MLA's Mina Shaughnessy Award for the first volume of his history of college English, The Formation of College English: Rhetoric and Belles Lettres in the British Cultural Provinces. The second volume, The Evolu- tion of College English: Literacy Studies from the Puritans to the Postmoderns, is forthcoming.
Candice Rai is an assistant professor at the University of Washington in Seattle. Her re- search interests center on the relationship between the rhetorical and the material, on public and everyday rhetorics, on urban and spatial theory, on ethnography as a method for studying rhetoric in action, and on community-based pedagogies. Her work has been published in the Michigan Journal of Community Service, Reflections, and the Community Literacy Journal and will soon appear in Ethnography and in Texts of Conse- quence: Composing Rhetorics of Social Activism for the Writing Classroom.
Index
Ackerman, John M. , 11 actor-network theory, 194-95 adversarial relations, 22-26, 29 Aeschines, 28
African Americans, 122. See also "race as genetic"
agency, 193, 197, 200, 205; collective, 230-31; "public rhetorical work," 202; rhetorical, 10, 81, 83, 143, 204, 207, 285; rhetorical agency defined, 147; rhetorical agency of marginalized speakers, 153; rhetorical agency, taking, 145, 147-52. See also specific topics
agonism, 12, 25, 26, 33. See also specific topics
"agonistic pluralism," 41 Ahl, Frederick, 287 Alcidamas, 24
Alinsky, Saul D. , 137
All Quiet on the Western Front (Remarque), 62
Allen, Grant, 260-62
Allen, John, 86
Allen, Richard, 175-76
Alliance of Rhetoric Societies conference,
11
Alliance to Conserve Old Richmond Neighborhoods (ACORN), 158
Anderson, John R. , 217-18
anger, 165
anxiety, 2, 3, 5-7, 9, 114 Appadurai, Arjun, 10 archeological work, 65
Arendt, Hannah, 90, 283
Argument Culture, The (Tannen), 26 "argument is war" metaphor, 25 "argumentative turn," 80 Aristotle, 20, 27, 100, 101
Arnove, Robert, 280
Aspinwall, William, 255 assemblage, 83, 204
assembling a public, community,
group, or other aggregate, 194-201;
and supporting the knowledge work
of others, 201-5
Athenians, ancient, 32
Augusta, Arkansas, 267, 271-72, 276 Augusta Community Literacy Advocacy
Project, 270, 271, 274; analyzing the rhetorical activity of, 276-78; kickoff and the initial year, 274-76; public rhe- torical activity as a teaching opportu- nity, 278-81
Augusta Recovery Initiative, 272-74 Aune, James, 103
autopoiesis, 11
Bacon, Nora, 179
Balkan wars of the 1990s, 108
Barnet, Richard, 10
Barthes, Roland, 213
Be the Change, 79
Becker, Samuel, 4
Benjamin, Walter, 86
Bennett, Lance W. , 80-81
Berlin, James, 6
Bernhardt, Grace, 205
biopower (Foucault), 4
Bitzer, Lloyd, 3, 4, 9-10
Black, Edwin, 3
Blythe, Stuart, 195, 196
body politic, 101
Booth, Wayne, 2, 26, 31, 33
Bowen, Joy Lynn, 274, 276
Boyer, Ernest, 78
Boyte, Harry, 82
Brandt, Deborah, 279-80
"Breaking through the Border," 242-44 bringing-before-the-eyes, 101 Brockmann, Steven, 67
Bruffee, Kenneth, 5
Burchard, Esteban Gonza? lez, 128-29 Burke, Kenneth, 19-20, 25, 29, 39, 232 Bush, George H. W. , 284
Bush, George W. , ix, 63, 71n29, 285, 288 Bush, Robert, 234-35
302 Index
Cahn, Michael, 20-21
Cameron, Colin, 144
Campbell, George, 26-27
Capital Area Community Media Center,
200, 201
capitalism, 58-59, 79, 108, 262
Carnegie Mellon University (CMU) Deci-
sion Makers project, 147
Cato the Elder, 26
Cavanagh, John, 10
Cherokee Nation/Michigan State Univer-
sity (CN/MSU) collaborative, 175-81.
See also praxis of new media
Chicago Rehab Network, 47
Church Hill, Virginia, 157-58, 164 Cicero, 19, 20, 23, 24, 25, 100, 119
cities and towns making rhetorical state-
ments, 268-70
"civic," 76
civic communions, 270, 277
civic engagement, 7, 11, 76-77, 84,
89-91; across education, planning,
and political spheres, 78-80; discourse of, 1; nature of, 76; reframing, 81-82. See also engagement; rhetorical engage- ment
Civic Engagement in Action series, 78 civil rights legislation, 107
classroom, 211-12, 219; reimagining the,
220-25; transformative mediation in
the, 239-40. See also school
Clifford, James, 180
Clinton, Bill, 80
CMU (Carnegie Mellon University) Deci-
sion Makers project, 147
codes, 159, 292-93
Cold War, 107
collective agency. See agency, collective collective identity, 57, 64; "staged," 64 collective identity construction, 58, 60,
63, 67-68
Collier, Steven, 272, 274 color-blindness (race), 128-29 "coming out," 144-45. See also under
learning disabilities
Communism, 107, 108, 114n17 Community Literacy Advocacy Project.
See Augusta Community Literacy Advo-
cacy Project
community media center, 198-202,
206n14
Community Think Tank on Learning Disability, 138-39, 141, 145-48, 152
concealment, rhetorical, 20-23, 27-30, 69 "conduit metaphor" for communication,
35n59
consensus, 57-58, 105, 122-23 Consigny, Scott, 25
consumer ideal of citizenship, 50 Coogan, David, 216-17
cooperation, 24, 31, 33
Corder, Jim, 232, 238
Cornish, Samuel, 249
correspondence theory of truth, 27 counternarrative, 178. See also praxis of
new media
counterpublic deliberation, 152 counterpublic discourses, 61, 260 counterpublic spaces, 253-54, 259;
defined, 253
counterpublic spheres, xi counterpublics, xii, 60-61, 146-47,
160-62, 253, 284. See also specific topics creative economy, 83
critical framing, 182, 186-88
"critical mode" of reception, 32
critical philosophy, 56, 57
critical political communication, 56, 57;
mapping the unspeakable and diag- nosing identity, 62-68; theorizing, 58-60; and theorizing the public work of rhetoric, 60-62
critical rationality, 145, 146 criticism, 194
Crowley, Sharon, 103 Cruikshank, Barbara, 43, 45 cultural economy, 83, 84 Cushman, Ellen, 179
Dawes General Allotment Act of 1887, 177, 178
De Pastino, Todd, 255
Deems, Julia, 236
Delpit, Lisa, 219
democracy, 39-41, 51-52, 76-77; an
anthropology of, 104-7; attribution of a character or ethos to, 105; dissident press and, 249-50; as inclusive deliber- ative process, 47-48; as justice, 48-50; post-Berlin Wall moment, 98, 107-11; preserving it against exclusionary forces, 103; as topos, 43, 102-4, 108,
111, 114; Uptown's "public" and rhetor- ical uses of, 46-47. See also under public sphere trope
"democracy without democrats," 108, 109 Democratic Leadership Council (DLC),
79-80
democratic paradox/paradox of democ-
racy, 40, 41
democratic rhetorics: democratic gover-
nance and, 105-6; institutions of
democracy and, 105 Demosthenes, 22
DeVoss, Danielle Nicole, 179 Diab, Rasha, 222
diagnosis, medical, 140-41
dialogic engagement, 152
difference, 138; without exclusion, social
relations of, 51
Dio (Sophist), 288, 289
Dionysius, 28
disabilities: defined, 138; discourse on,
143, 144. See also learning disabilities disabilities studies, 143-44
dissent, rhetoric of, 251-54, 261; "Hobo"
News and, 254-59
dissident press, 252-54, 258-60, 262-63;
nature of, 249-51. See also dissent dissimulation, 20, 21, 23, 25, 26, 69 dissoi logoi (antithesis/counterstatement),
27, 167
du Gay, Paul, 83-84 Duberman, Martin, 222 Dupont, Leslie, 242
East End Teen Center ("Teen City"), 159-63
economy, new, 80, 82, 83, 89-90
Ede, Lisa, 5
education: civic rhetorical, 215; structural
possibilities of formal, 219-20. See also Augusta Community Literacy Advo- cacy Project; Augusta Recovery Initia- tive; dissent; pedagogies; school
Ehninger, Douglass, 3
Emig, Janet, 212
emotion, 23. See also specific emotions empire, 284-85
empowerment. See learning disabilities energeia (energy), 100-102, 112, 114 engagement, 76; citizen-scholars and
community, 8-12; methodology of--
see assembling a public, community, group, or other aggregate; scholarship of, 11. See also civic engagement; rhetorical engagement
engaging publics. See Cherokee Nation / Michigan State University (CN/MSU) collaborative; praxis of new media
Enlightenment, 29, 99
"entertainment mode" of reception, 32 Entman, Robert M. , 80-81 environmental projects, 195-96 epistemic crisis of rhetoric, 3-8
equal opportunity, 160
essentialism, 57
ethical practice, 183, 188-89
ethos, 34n29, 48, 165, 269, 276; of cities,
268, 269; creating a successful, 252; of democracy, 105; generative, 232; mis- sionary, 236; organizational, 84
expressive moves, 152
fairness, 106
fear. See anxiety
figured discourse, 290-92
Fix Wilson Yard, 52
Fleming, David, 44-45, 222
Flower, Linda, 4-5, 236
Folger, Joseph, 234-35
Foucault, Michael, 57, 65, 286-87 Fraser, Nancy, x
free speech, 284; practice, politics, and
posture, 286-88, 292. See also democracy Freire, Paulo, 137
freshman composition, 220, 222, 224-25 Freshman Composition program, 220 Fukuyama, Francis, 98
Galston, William, 215-16 Gaonkar, Dilip, 2, 5-7, 27 Garsten, Bryan, 33 Geisler, Cheryl, 218 genealogy, 65
generality (composition), 224 generative ethos, 232
genetic medicine: publishing about
race-based medicine in, 122-24. See
also "race as genetic" genomes, 125
gentrification. See democracy Germany, 64-67
Glenn, Cheryl, 249
Index 303
304 Index
"globalization," 10, 11, 82, 254; textual, 6 "globalization project" of rhetoric, 31 Goebbels, Joseph, 71n29
"going public," 7, 271. See also under
learning disabilities
Goodley, Dan, 143
Gorgias, 25
Grabill, Jeffrey T. , 179
Graff, Harvey, 280
Greeks, ancient, 286. See also Athenians;
specific philosophers
Greene, Ronald, 81
group difference, social relations affirm-
ing, 51
Gutmann, Amy, 111, 112
Habermas, Ju? rgen, x-xi, 44-45, 104, 111, 145
Hales, Kathryn, 11
Haplotype Map Project (HapMap), 121,
130; relabeling the, 126-27 Hariman, Robert, 31 Hart-Davidson, Bill, 200
Hauser, Gerard A. , 44-45, 90, 146 Hawhee, Debra, 25
Hayes, John, 4-5
health, public. See assembling a public,
community, group, or other aggregate health disparities, 121, 122. See also "race
as genetic"
hegemonic public, 60-61
Henwood, Doug, 82
Herzog, Don, 29, 30
Hesk, Jon, 32
Hitler, Adolf, 65, 66
"Hobo" News, 254, 260-61, 263; and a
rhetoric of dissent, 254-59 Holocaust, 64-66
homeless persons, dissident journalists
advocating for, 248, 255-57
housing. See Uptown
Housing Affordability Research Consor-
tium, 47
How, James Eads, 255-58
Howe, Craig, 186
Human Genetic Variation Consortium,
121, 122, 125, 127
human relations as adversarial, 22-26, 29
identity. See collective identity; learning disabilities; social identity
identity-asserting statements, 152. See also learning disabilities
Ignatieff, Michael, 284
imitation. See mimesis
immersion, 190, 214, 217, 218. See also
praxis of new media inclusion/exclusion, 103-5, 107, 108, 112,
113
incommensurability, 27. See also specific
topics
indirection, 225
insituatio, 25
instruction, implicit vs. explicit, 217-18 integrity and appearance, 30 intelligence quotient (IQ), 140 International Brotherhood Welfare Asso-
ciation (IBWA), 256, 257 International Network of Street Papers
(INSP), 253, 254
interpretive moves, 152
invention, 100. See also rhetorical inven-
tion
Jackson, Brian, 240
Jenninger, Philip, 65-66 Juergensmeyer, Erik, 240, 242 justice, democracy as, 48-50. See also
social justice
Kant, Immanuel, 69n2, 110-11
Kennedy, George A. , 101, 211
Kent, Ohio, city plans and artifacts, 87-89 cultural economy of, 84-87, 89
Kent State shootings, 86, 87
Kessler, Lauren, 250
King, Andrew, 10
knowledge work, 205
Kosovo, 104, 108, 109, 115n17
Kushner, Tony, 259
labels. See learning disabilities Laclau, Ernesto, 60, 65
language as (or should be) mimetic,
26-33. See also specific topics Lanham, Richard A. , 29, 32-33 Latour, Bruno, 194-95, 205; "thing
theory" and, 199
learning disabilities (LDs), aspects of,
152; damage control and the dilemma of, 141-43; in a deliberative discourse, 144-47; in a disabling discourse,
138-39; going public, 137-39, 141-43, 151; institutionalized, 141; mediatized, 139-40; medicalized, 140-41; represen- tation and identity, 143-44; taking rhetorical agency, 147-53
Lefebvre, Henri, 8
LeFevre, Karen Burke, 232, 238
Leff, Michael, 2
Lenehan, William, 220-21
Libanius, 290-92
liberation ideology, 108
liberties, 106
liminality (composition), 224 listening-rhetoric, 26
literacy, 279-80; autonomous vs. ideologi-
cal models of, 279
literacy campaigns, 280
"literacy climate," 279
literacy liaisons, 274
literacy programs, towns, and cities mak-
ing rhetorical statements, 267-71. See also Augusta Community Literacy Advocacy Project
Little Rock, Arkansas, 268-69 Lloyd-Jones, Richard, 231 local publics, 270
logos, 7, 163, 292
London, Jack, 258
Long, Eleanor, 270-71, 278 Longinus, 23, 28 Lunsford, Andrea, 5 Lyday, Margaret M. , 249
Machiavelli, Niccolo`, 20
Mahr, Bill, 71n30
marginality (of rhetoric), 18, 249-51;
power, control, and, 31; rhetoric's his-
tory of, 31
marginalized groups, xi, 146, 250 marginalized people, 137, 145-47 marginalized speakers, 138, 144, 149,
153
"marketplace," language of the, 27 Martinez, Inez, 223-24
Masses (magazine), 251-53 Maurin, Peter, 264n51 McDermott, R. P. , 143
media, learning disabilities in the,
138-39. See also under teaching rhetoric media center. See community media
center
mediation, 229-32, 244; "Breaking through the Border," 242-44; rediscov- ering the inventive capacities of con- flicted situations, 232-33; "Showdown in Superior! ," 240-42;
mediation, transformative: in the class- room, 239-40; as model for learning from "dissensus," 233-36
mediation center, community, 236-39 medical diagnosis, 140-41
Mehan, Hugh, 143
memory, 86-87. See also public memory Mendelsohn, Daniel, 284
mestiza public, 146-47
Michigan State University. See Cherokee
Nation / Michigan State University
(CN/MSU) collaborative
middle spaces, 159
Miller, Susan, 2
mimesis, 26-33; appearance of, 28 missionary ethos, 236
Mouffe, Chantal, 41, 82-83 Muehlenkamp, Bob, 222
multiliteracies. See pedagogy of multilit-
eracies mythos, 50, 163
9/11. See September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks
"Naming the LD Difference," 138 National Institutes of Health (NIH)
Roundtable on Race, 127-30 nationalism, 109
nation-state, 108, 113
Native Americans. See Cherokee Nation /
Michigan State University (CN/MSU)
collaborative
National Socialism, 64-67 Nazi Germany, 64-67
Obama, Barack, xi, 292-93
observation language, theory-neutral, 27 Ohmann, Richard, 262
oligarchic democracy, 106, 112-14 Olson, Kathryn M. , 67
Ong, Walter, 25
paideia, xvi, 283-92; postmodern, 283, 285, 288, 292
Paley, Julia, 43, 104 parrhe^sia, 286-88, 291, 292
Index 305
306 Index
pathos, 258, 269
Pax Romana, 284, 291
pedagogies: related to praxis of new
media, 182-83. See also school pedagogy of multiliteracies, 183, 186 "Pedagogy of Multiliteracies, A" (New
London Group), 181-82
Peirce, Charles Sanders, 69n3 perspicuity, 26-27
Petraglia, Joseph, 213
Pheasant Run conference, 8-10 Philips, Ben, 176
Philostratus, 288, 289
phronesis, 3, 4, 181
placemaking, 160-61
Plato, 19
plausible deniability, 20
poie^sis, 11, 76, 161, 285
policy studies, 80
"policy turn," 80
political rhetoric, 32
"politics of representation," 143 Poppin, Wayne, 229
postmodern paideia, 283, 285, 288, 292 postmodern rhetoric, 283-84, 292 poststructuralist philosophy, 56, 57 Poulakos, John, 25
poverty, 46, 253-54, 258, 259, 261. See
also homeless persons; Kent practice, 182
praxis of new media, 179-82, 189-90;
critical framing in a, 182, 186-88; overt instruction in a, 182, 185-86; pedago- gies related to, 182-83; premises under- lying, 181; situated practice in a, 182-85; transformed and ethical, 182, 183, 188-89
presidential campaign of 2008, U. S. , 292-93
Procter, David, 269-70
professional work, 205
Progressive Policy Institute (PPI), 80 Pryke, Michael, 83-84
psychoanalytic theorists, 56, 57
public, the, 2, 60, 253; doing rhetoric, 2 public discourse, 161-62. See also specific
topics
"public good," 33, 42, 44, 106, 111-13; determining the, 111-13; idealizing the concept of, 112. See also praxis of new media
public goods, 39, 40, 47, 49-50
public life; "lost geographies" of, 285-86;
the space to work in, 1-3; citizen-schol- ars and community engagement, 8-12; rhetoric's epistemic crisis, 3-8
public memory, 56-68, 71n25, 72n32, 76, 86-90
public sphere, 39, 113, 253; calls to im- prove, 112; consensus and, 105, 122-23; disabilities and, 145; inclusive vs. exclu- sive, 103-4, 112--see also inclusion/ exclusion; participation and, 145-46; vs. private sphere, 60; reticulate, 7; working in, 104. See also specific topics
public sphere theory, 43
public sphere trope, 41; democratic the-
ory, power, and the limits of, 41-46 public work of rhetoric, theorizing the,
60-62
publicity effect, 167-72
publics, constructing, 20-22; publics,
engaging--see Cherokee Nation / Michigan State University (CN/MSU) collaborative; praxis of new media; local, 270
Quintilian, 23-25
race, 157; antiracism and, 128-29; and going live to genetics researchers on the harmful impact of, 124-26; human genetic variation consortium and, 120- 22; NIH Roundtable on Race, 127-30; race-based medicine, publishing data about challenges and costs of, 122-24 recommendations regarding issues of, 131-32; reification of, 124, 125, 127; scorecard regarding "race as genetic," 130-31
racism, 126
rape, gang, 157-58, 160, 162
Reagan, Ronald, 66-67
Reamer, David, 240, 242
Reder, Lynn M. , 217-18
reflexivity, 7-8
Remarque, Erich, 62
resistance: constructive, 144, 145, 147; "is
sending up a signal flare in the dark-
ness," 247, 259. See also dissent resistance strategies, 144
reticulate public sphere, 7, 44, 154n35
revolutions, 104-5
rhetoric: citizen scholars and commu-
nity engagement, 8-12; denial of, 28, 29--see also concealment; self-denial; denying itself, 7, 20-21; epistemic crisis of, 3-8; nature of, 6, 19, 20, 101; "new," 3; opposing impulses within, 19; "out there," 1; primary vs. second- ary, 211; should never deny itself, 7; teaching bad, 260-62. See also specific topics
"Rhetoric and Its Double" (Gaonkar), 5 "rhetoric of anti-rhetoric," 35n64 Rhetorica Ad Herennium, 24, 25
rhetorica docens, 31, 32
rhetorica utens, 31-33
rhetorical activism, 216
"rhetorical age," 9-10
rhetorical agency. See agency
rhetorical consciousness, 6
Rhetorical Education in Amercai (Glenn et
al. ), 249
rhetorical engagement: in the cultural
economy, 89-91; toward a political and
economic reframing of, 80-84 "rhetorical failure," 216 rhetorical invention, 271, 278 rhetorical return, 249
rhetorical scholarship, 216
rhetors, nontraditional, 249. See also dis-
sident press rhetrickery, 26, 31 Rideout, Walter, 220 Right Dimensions, 90-91 rights, 12, 19, 107
Riis, Jacob, 258
Risch, Neil, 119
Rogers, Carl R. , 232 Roman rhetoric, 25 Russwurm, John, 249
Saussure, Ferdinand de, 69n3 Schloemann, Johan, 32
"scholarship of engagement," 11, 78 school, 211-12, 225; emphasis on factual
knowledge, 215-17; failure to promote self-actualization and improve the world, 214; problems with, 212-15; preference for theoretical abstraction, 217-20; virtues of, 215. See also class- room; learning disabilities
Schopenhauer, Arthur, 69n2
secondary rhetoric, 211
self-advocacy, 147
self-aggrandizement, impulse toward, 19 self-denial, 21; impulse toward, 19, 20.
See also under rhetoric
semantics movement of 1940s and 1950s,
248
semiotic theory, 69n3
Sennett, Richard, 82
September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, 63,
79
Serbia, 108-9, 114n17
ServiceNation, 79, 83
Shakespeare, William, 28
Sharer, Wendy B. , 249
Shiller, Helen, 40, 41, 48-50 Shimabukuro, Mira, 222
Shor, Ira, 221
"Showdown in Superior! ," 240-42 "sick" discourses, 57
"signal flare in the darkness," 249 Simon, Herbert A. , 217-18
sincerity, 23-24. See also transparency situated practice, 182-85
situational rhetoric, 251
Sloop, John, 6
Sly, Gloria, 175-76, 177
"social, the," 195
social categories, 137
social change, rhetorical theorists work-
ing for, 119-20
social class, 102
social energy, 9, 100-102, 108, 111
social identity, valid, 144-45, 152. See also
learning disabilities
social justice, 247-49. See also justice social oppression, 144
social structure, 102
socialism, 262
sociology, reflexive, 7-8
sophistic discourse, 289
sophistic rhetoric, 25, 284, 287 sophistic tactics, 292
sophists, 159-63, 166, 172, 288-91; for
social change, 59; On the Sophists
(Alcidamas), 23
sovereignty, 108
Spahiu, Nexmedin, 108-9, 114n17 spontaneity, 23, 24
Sprat, Thomas, 29
Index 307
308 Index
Start on Success (SOS), 138, 141, 147, 148, 152, 153n8
state of exception (Agamben), 109, 114n17
stimulated learning movement, 217 Streitmatter, Rodger, 251
Stuckey, J. Elspeth, 6-7
students participating in public rhetorics,
lessons regarding, 189-90. See also
praxis of new media suspicion, 22-24, 29 Swain, John, 144 symbolic economies, 86
Tannen, Deborah, 26
teachers, 212. See also school teaching rhetoric, 163-67, 287, 292;
authentic/inauthentic learning, 184-88; new media, 179-84; and social justice, 247-49; transmuting values, 9-12, 260-63
Teen City, 160-63
terrorism, 63
theory-neutral observation language, 27 third space, 9
Tocqueville, Alexis de, 113
topoi/topos, 8, 11, 39, 83, 108, 111-12,
236; considerations regarding, 101-2; nature of, 100, 101; postromantic "unteachability," 211; social energies and, 100-102. See also democracy
totalitarianism, 109-10
Toulmin, Stephen, 268
tragic events, public commemoration
and planning in the context of. See civic engagement; Kent; rhetorical engagement
Trajan (emperor), 288
transformed practice, 182, 183, 188-89 transparency, 26-27
transparency thesis, 27
Two Sides of a One Track Mind (Coogan
and Malinoski), 167
universality (education), 224 universities, 79
University of Wisconsin (UW), English
Department at, 220-25; "emergent"
curriculum, 223; Teaching Assistants'
Association, 223 Uptown (Chicago), 40-51 Urban Matters, 216
vernacular pedagogy, 163
violence, 165; of collective identity con-
struction and public memory, 63. See
also specific topics
Virginia Commonwealth University (VCU), 160, 162
Wacquant, Loi? c, 7-8 Wallace, Karl, 4
war, 62-63
"war on terror," 63
Warner, Michael, 146, 253 Weber, Max, 102 Weizsa?
