"There is no other
appropriation
to the use of congress
than of the eighteen thousand pounds.
than of the eighteen thousand pounds.
Hamilton - 1834 - Life on Hamilton - v1
My visit at Mr.
Fitzhugh's confirmed
my partiality. Betsey is so fond of your family, that she
proposes to form a match between her boy and your girl,
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 398 THE LIFE OF
provided you will engage to make the latter as amiable as
her mother.
Truly, my dear Meade, I often regret that fortune has
cast our residence at such a distance from each other, i It
would be a serious addition to my happiness if we lived
where I could see you every day^) but fate has determined
it otherwise. I am a little hurried, and can only request,
in addition, that you will present me most affectionately to
Mrs. Meade, and believe me to be, with the warmest and
most unalterable friendship,
Yours,
A. Hamilton.
Having completed his business at Philadelphia, he return-
ed to Albany ; took a house in the vicinity of General Schuy-
ler, to which he invited, as an inmate, his friend Colonel
Troup, who had previously studied the law, and with his
aid commenced to prepare himself for the practice of it.
To this dull pursuit, so foreign to all his previous habits,
such was his control of the powers of his intellect, that he
devoted himself with the most unremitting labour. His
retentive memory was tasked to its utmost. His habit
was to read while walking to and fro, and so incessant were
his labours, that his intimates would smile at the idea, that
while prosecuting this study, with the same diligence, he
might almost have marched from one end to the other of
the confederacy. At the ensuing July term of the supreme
court, he obtained a licence to practise.
Such was the knowledge he acquired during this short
period of four months, " that he composed a Manual on the
Practice of the Law," which, says Troup, "served as an
instructive grammar to future students, and became the
ground-work of subsequent enlarged practical treatises. "*
* There are gentlemen, now living, who copied this manual as their guide.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 399
In the preceding autumn congress had recommended to
the several states to levy a separate tax for continental re-
quisitions, and had invested the Superintendent of Finance
with the power of appointing an officer in each state to re-
ceive these taxes; an idea not improbably suggested by
Hamilton's letter of September, 1780, intimating the im-
portance of appointing in each state a "continental super-
intendent. " While engaged in the prosecution of his legal
studies, he received the following letter from Robert Mor-
ris.
ROBERT MORRIS TO HAMILTON.
Office of Finance, Philadelphia, May 2d, 1782.
"SIK,
"Mr. Charles Stuart, late commissary general of issues,
has informed me that you are disposed to quit the military
line, for the purpose of entering into civil life. He, at the
same time, induced me to believe that you would accept the
office of receiver of the continental taxes in the state of New-
York. The intention of this letter is to offer you that ap-
pointment. The duties of the office will appear, in a great
degree, from the publications made by me on this subject.
In addition, it will be necessary that you correspond with
me frequently, and give accurate accounts of whatever
may be passing in your state, which it may be necessary
for this office to be acquainted with. For the trouble of
executing it, I shall allow a fourth per cent, on the monies
you receive. The amount of the quota called for from
New-York for the current year is, as you know, three hun-
dred and seventy-three thousand five hundred and ninety-
eight dollars.
"I make no professions of my confidence and esteem, be-
cause I hope none are necessary; but if they are, my wish
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 400 THE LIFE OF
that you would accept the offer I make, is the strongest
evidence I can give of them. "
Hamilton made the following reply. "I had this day the
honour of receiving your letter of the second instant, and
am much obliged by the mark of your confidence which it
contains, and to Colonel Stuart for his friendly intentions
upon the occasion.
"My military situation has indeed become so negative,
that I have no motives to continue in it, and if my services
could be of importance to the public in any civil line, I
should cheerfully obey its command. But the plan which
I have marked out for myself is the profession of the law,
and I am now engaged in a course of studies for that purpose.
Time is so precious to me, that I could not put myself in
the way of any interruptions, unless for an object of con-
sequence to the public or to myself. The present is not of
this nature. Such are the circumstances of this state, that
the benefit arising from the office you propose, would not,
during the war, yearly exceed one hundred pounds; for
unfortunately, I am persuaded, it will not pay annually into
the continental treasury forty thousand pounds; and on a
peace establishment this will not be, for some time to come,
more than doubled. You will perceive that an engage-
ment of this kind does not correspond with my views, and
does not afford a sufficient inducement to relinquish them.
"I am not the less sensible to the obliging motives which
dictated the offer, and it will be an additional one to the
respect and esteem with which I have the honour to be,
very truly, sir,
"Your most obedient and humble servant. "
On the fourth of June Mr. Morris wrote to him, acknow-
ledging the receipt of this letter, and stating, "I am much
obliged by the friendly sentiments you express for me,
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 401
which, be assured, I shall retain a grateful sense of. I see
with you, that the office I had the pleasure of offering, will
not be equal to what your own abilities will gain in the profes-
sion of the law; but I did intend that the whole sum should
have been paid, although the whole quota of the taxes had
not been collected by the state; consequently, the object
is greater than you supposed, and the business might proba-
bly be effected without more attention than you could spare
from your studies. If so, I should still be happy in your
acceptance, and will leave the matter open until I have an
opportunity of hearing from you upon the subject. "
To which Hamilton gave the following answer:
HAMILTON TO MORRIS.
SIR,
* * * * The explanation which you give of your inten-
tion, in your late offer, makes it an object that will com-
pensate fully for the time that it will deduct from my other
occupations. In accepting it, I have only one scruple,
arising from a doubt whether the service I can render in
the present stateWJf things, will be an equivalent for the
compensation. (The whole system, (if it may be so called,)
of taxation in this state, is radically vicious, burthensome
to the people, and unproductive to governmenfe-^As the
matter now stands, there seems to be little for a continen-
tal receiver to do. The whole business appears to be
thrown into the hands of the county treasurers; nor do I
find that there is any appropriation made of any part of the
taxes collected for continental purposes, or any provision
to authorize payment to the officer you appoint. This,
however, must be made. There is only one way in which
I can imagine a prospect of being materially useful; that
is, in seconding your applications to the state. In popu-
lar assemblies much may sometimes be brought about by
personal discussions, by entering into details, and combat-
vol. i. 51
? ?
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 402 THE LIFE OF
ing objections as they rise. If it should, at any time, be
thought advisable by you to empower me to act in this ca-
pacity, I shall be happy to do every thing that depends
upon me to effectuate your views. I flatter myself, to you,
sir, I need not profess that I suggest this, not from a desire
to augment the importance of office, but to advance the
public interest.
It is of primary moment to me, as soon as possible to
take my station in the law, and on this consideration I am
pressing to qualify myself for admission the next term,
which will be the latter end of July. After this, should you
think an interview necessary, I will wait upon you in Phila-
delphia. In the mean time, I shall be happy to receive your
instructions, and shall direct my attention more particularly
to acquiring whatever information may be useful to my fu-
ture operations. I have read your publications at different
times, but as I have not the papers containing them in my
possession, it will be necessary that their contents should
be comprised in your instructions. A meeting of the legis-
lature is summoned early in the next month, at which, if I
previously receive your orders, it may be possible to put
matters in train. I am truly indebted to you, sir, for the
disposition you have manifested upon this occasion, and I
shall only add an assurance of my endeavours to justify your
confidence.
Alex. Hamilton.
On the second of July following, Mr. Morris writes, en-
closing the warrant of appointment and instructions, to
which he adds the following observations: -- "It gives me
singular pleasure, to find that you have yourself pointed out
one of the principal objects of your appointment. You will
find that it is specified in the enclosure. I must request
you to exert your talents, in forwarding with your legisla-
ture the views of congress. Your former situation in the
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 403
army, the present situation of that very army, your con-
nexions in the state, your perfect knowledge of men and
measures, and the abilities with which heaven has blessed
you, will give you a fine opportunity to forward the public
service, by convincing the legislature of the necessity of co-
pious supplies, and by convincing all who have claims on
the justice of congress, that those claims exist only by that
hard necessity which arises from the negligence of the
states. When to this you shall superadd the conviction,
that what remains of the war being a war of finance, solid
arrangements of finance must necessarily terminate favour-
ably, not only to our hopes, but even to our wishes. Then,
sir, the governments will be disposed to lay, and the people
to bear those burthens which are necessary; and then the
utility of your office, and of the officer, will be as manifest
to others as at present to me. "
On the receipt of this communication, Hamilton wrote
the following letter.
HAMILTON TO ROBERT MORRIS.
"I shall to-morrow morning commence a journey to
Poughkeepsie, where the legislature are assembled, and I
will endeavour, by every step in my power, to second your
views, though I am sorry to add, without very sanguine ex-
pectations. I think it probable the legislature will do some-
thing, but whatever momentary effort they make, till the
entire change of their present system, very little will be
done. To effect this, mountains of prejudice and particu-
lar interest are to be levelled. For my own part, consi-
dering the late serious misfortune to our ally, the spirit of
reformation, of wisdom, and of unanimity, which seems to
have succeeded to that of blunder, perverseness, and dis-
sension in the British government, and the universal reluc-
tance of these states to do what is right, I cannot help view-
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 404 THE LIFE OF
ing our situation as critical, and I feel it the duty of every
citizen to exert his faculties to the utmost to support the
measures, especially those solid arrangements of finance,
on which our safety depends.
"It is not in the spirit of compliment, but of sincerity, I
assure you, that the opinion I entertain of him who presides
in the department, was not one of the smallest motives to
my acceptance of the office, nor will that esteem and con-
fidence which makes me now sensibly feel the obliging ex-
pressions of your letter, fail to have a great share in influ-
encing my future exertions. "
On his arrival at Poughkeepsie, Hamilton addressed a
letter, on the sixteenth July, to Governor Clinton, apprizing
him of his appointment, and requesting the legislature to
vest in him the necessary authority; stating that it was "a
part of his duty, to explain to the legislature, from time to
time, the views of the Superintendent of Finance, in pursu-
ance of the orders of congress, that they may be the better
enabled to judge of the measures most proper to be adopt-
ed for an effectual co-operation, and asking his excellency
to impart his request, to have the honour of a conference
with a committee of the two houses. "
This body had been convened, in an extra session, at the
express instance of a committee of congress, and was open-
ed with a forcible message from the Governor, urging the
importance of a revisal of the tax laws, and calling upon
the legislature to denounce the attempts of the British go-
vernment to make separate treaties with the states, as a
measure inevitably to be attended with ruin and infamy,
and pressing the importance of the most strenuous exer-
tions to expel the enemy from their territory, to which an
answer, prepared by General Schuyler, who was the leader
in the senate, responded in the strongest terms. On the
twentieth July, the senate adopted a series of resolutions,
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 405
declaring their opinion, "that the present system of these
states exposes the cause to a precarious issue; that the
radical source of most of the embarrassments is the want
of sufficient power in congress to effectuate that ready and
perfect co-operation of the different states, on which their
immediate safety and future happiness depends; that ex-
perience had demonstrated the confederation to be defect-
ive in several essential points, particularly in not vesting
the federal government, either with a power of providing
revenue for itself, or with ascertained and productive funds,
secured by a sanction so solemn and general, as would in-
spire the fullest confidence in them, and make them a sub-
stantial basis of credit; and that it is essential to the com-
mon welfare, that there should be, as soon as possible, a
conference of the whole states on the subject, and that it
would be advisable, for this purpose, to propose to congress
to recommend, and to each state to adopt, the measure of
assembling a general convention of the states, specially au-
thorized to revise and amend the confederation, reserving
a right to the respective legislatures to ratify their deter-
minations. "
These resolutions, in which the hand of Hamilton so dis-
tinctly appears, were adopted unanimously,* and within
two days after, a joint committee of both houses was, at his
instance, appointed to report, at the next session, a system
for establishing such funds, within the state, as were best
suited to answer its purposes and those of the United
States, and for the more effectual collection of taxes, -- at
the head of which was General Schuyler, through whose
influence Hamilton was, on the same day, elected a Dele-
gate to congress.
It is interesting, in the progress of this work, to remark,
that to him who had so long laboured to impress on others
* July 22d, 1782.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 400 THE LIFE OF
the importance of a new organization of the government,
and who had so large a share in its formation, adoption,
and exposition, is to be attributed, with the aid of Schuy-
ler, the first action of the state of New-York, towards this
primary object. * In a letter to Mr. Morris, of this date,
Hamilton thus speaks of the result of his exertions:
HAMILTON TO ROBERT MORRIS.
"Poughkeepsie, July 22, 1782.
"SIR,
"Agreeable to my letter to you from Albany, I came to
this place, and had an interview with a committee of the
legislature, in which I urged the several matters contained
in your instructions. I strongly represented the necessity
of solid arrangements of finance, and by way of argument,
pointed out all the defects of the present system. I found
every man convinced that something was wrong, but few
that were willing to recognise the mischief when defined,
and consent to the proper remedy. The quantum of taxes
already imposed is so great, as to make it useless to impose
any others to a considerable amount; a bill has, however,
passed both houses, payable in specie, bank notes, or your
notes, for eighteen thousand pounds.
"It is at present appropriated to your order, but I doubt
whether some subsequent arrangement will not take place
for a different appropriation. The commander-in-chief has
applied for a quantity of forage, which the legislature is de-
vising the means of furnishing, and I fear it will finish by
diverting the eighteen thousand pounds to that purpose. I
have, hitherto, been able to prevent this; but as it is of
indispensable importance to me to leave this place imme-
diately, to prepare for an examination, for which I have
pledged myself the ensuing term, which is at hand, it is
* It is believed to be the first proceeding of any state on this subject. ?
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 407
possible, after I have left it, contrary ideas will prevail.
Efforts have been made to introduce a species of negotiable
certificates, which I have strenuously opposed. It has not
yet taken place, but I am not clear how the matter will
terminate. Should the bill for the eighteen thousand
pounds go out, in its present form, I cannot hope that it
will produce in the treasury above half the sum, -- such are
the vices of our present mode of collection. A bill has
also passed the assembly, for collecting arrearages of taxes,
payable in specie, bank notes, your notes, old continental
emissions at one hundred and twenty-eight for one, and a
species of certificates issued by the state, for the purchase
of horses. This is now before the senate; the arrearages
are very large.
"Both houses have unanimously passed a set of resolu-
tions, to be transmitted to congress and the several states,
proposing a convention of the states, to enlarge the powers
of congress, and vest them with funds. I think this a very
eligible step, though I doubt of the concurrence of the other
states; but I am certain without it, they never will be
brought to co-operate in any reasonable or effectual plan.
Urge reforms or exertions, and the answer constantly is,
what avails it for one state to make them, without the con-
sent of the others? It is in vain to expose the futility of this
reasoning. It is founded on all those passions which have
the strongest influence on the human mind.
"The legislature have also appointed, at my instance, a
committee to devise, in its recess, a more effectual system
of taxation, and to communicate with me on this subject.
A good deal will depend on the success of this attempt.
Convinced of the absurdity of multiplying taxes in the pre-
sent mode, when in effect the payment is voluntary, and
the money received exhausted in the collection, I have la-
boured chiefly to instil the necessity of a change in the
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 408 THE LIFE OF
plan, and though not so rapidly as the exigency of public
affairs requires, truth seems to be making some progress.
"There is no other appropriation to the use of congress
than of the eighteen thousand pounds.
"I shall, as soon as possible, give you a full and just view
of the situation and temper of this state. This cannot be
till after my intended examination; that over, I shall lay
myself out in every way that can promote your views, and
the public good. I am informed, you have an appointment
to make of a commissioner of accounts for this state. Per-
mit me to suggest the expediency of choosing a citizen of
the state, a man who, to the qualifications requisite for the
execution of the office, adds an influence in its affairs. I
need not particularize the reasons for this suggestion. In
my next I will also take the liberty to mention some cha-
racters. I omitted mentioning, that the two houses have
also passed a bill, authorizing congress to adjust the quotas
of the states, on equitable principles, agreeable to your re-
commendation. "
After the adjournment of the legislature, and his admis-
sion to the bar, Hamilton devoted himself assiduously to the
duties which the urgent solicitations of Mr. Morris earnest-
ly pressed.
The pictures which are given in his letters of this period
are of the most gloomy cast. Double sets of officers,
with conflicting powers and duties, clogging their respec-
tive operations; taxes, far beyond the ability of the peo-
ple, to be collected through a medium reduced to the low-
est point, and almost consumed in the process of collection;
while a general system of connivance and fraud pre-
vailed in many of the subordinate departments, which fur-
nished the strongest inducements to check the inquiries,
and prevent the adoption of the suggestions of an officer,
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 409
whose office itself was an object of the most jealous repug-
nance. *
To overcome these difficulties was an herculean task;
but he engaged in it with all his characteristic patience of
investigation. Though the evils were too extensive, and
laid too deep to be reached by any other means than a total
change of system, yet he hoped, by scrutinizing the whole
train of abuses, such data might be obtained as would ena-
ble the office of finance to apply efficient remedies, and gra-
dually to infuse such opinions as would convince the state
of its errors, and induce a radical change of policy.
During the interval of the appointment and meeting of the
committee, he was constantly engaged in extensive corres-
pondences throughout the state; in circulars to the county
treasurers, to ascertain the receipts and expenses of collec-
tion ; in communications with the army contractors, Messrs.
Duer and Sands, to learn the amount of expenditures and
the quantity of specie, and to promote the circulation and
increase the value of the notes of the financier and of the
bank, and in devising means to defer and lighten the de-
mands on the general treasury.
While thus employed in fulfilling the calls of the finan-
cier, he used the estimate which he obtained, (the incom-
pleteness of which he laments,) as a basis for digesting a
new plan of state taxation, which he proposed to submit to
the legislature.
The rule adopted in the confederation, after much angry
discussion, for fixing the quota of each state, had proved a
source of great delay and controversy. The valuation of
land which it prescribed, had been found impracticable, and
congress had been compelled to adhere to the original sys-
tem of requisitions, on the basis of the population, as com-
* From an entry in the diary of Mr. Morris, it appears that as late as the
twenty-ninth of August, 1782, a committee of inquiry, appointed by congress,
questioned his reasons for appointing continental receivers.
vol. i. 52
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 410 THE LIFE OF
puted in seventeen hundred and seventy-five. Each state
took advantage of the inaccuracy of this enumeration, and
found a ready excuse for the deficiency of their supplies in
the incorrectness of the estimate.
To avoid this difficulty, and at the same time to extend
the system of taxation as far as was possible, in order to meet
the demands of the public, Hamilton framed anelaborate bill,
in which, agreeably to a resolution of congress of the prece-
ding February, and to the report of the financier, he proposed
to abolish the method which existed, of taxing by arbitrary
quotas and assessments, -- a source of the greatest injustice
and inequality, -- and substituting for it a system of specific
taxation on lands, distinguished by their character, as mea-
dow or arable; on salt by the bushel; on tobacco by the
pound; on carriages. ; plate; on licenses of various kinds;
on menial servants; on houses; and a rate of specific du-
ties on imports.
The bill embraces a very minute and systematic scheme
to render the assessment and collection easy and secure; and
with a view to prevent the confusion and neglect which had
resulted from the proceeds of the taxes being thrown into
a general mass, he suggested the appropriation of them to
various objects; that upon land, to the support of the inter-
nal government; on carriages, to the judicial establishment;
the house tax to congress, for supplementary funds; the
salt, license, and tobacco tax, for constituting a loan office,
which seems to have been connected with the incorporation
of a bank, of which a portion of the income was to be secu-
red to that office. * The surplus of these taxes, and all
others, to form an aggregate fund for contingencies, to sup-
* A plan for a state bank and state loan office, is found among the papers,
which contemplated one state bank to control the currency ; -- the general
banking to be conducted by private bankers. It is not in Hamilton's hand-
writing, and some features of the plan fender it probable that it was a project
submitted for his consideration, but which he could not have approved.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 411
ply the Federal treasury. A plan of a lottery was also at
this time devised by him, containing many ingenious sug-
gestions, and evincing singular care to prevent frauds, from
which a considerable sum was hoped to be derived in aid
of the finances; -- a mode of taxation which had been pro-
posed by a committee of congress in seventeen hundred and
eighty; but which the enlightened sentiment of the present
age has ceased to approve.
Having obtained a license as an attorney in July, he,
notwithstanding his public duties, continued to prosecute
his legal studies, in order to prepare for admission to the
bar as a counsellor, at the ensuing October term of the Su-
preme Court. A letter to his friend Meade, shows his views
on this subject, and gives a pleasing exhibition of his do-
mestic feelings.
HAMILTON TO MEADE.
Albany, August 27th, 1782.
I thank you, my dear Meade, for your letter of the first
of this month, which you will perceive has travelled much
faster than has been usual with our letters. Our corres-
pondence hitherto has been unfortunate,' nor in fact can
either of us compliment himself on his punctuality; but you
were right in concluding, that however indolence or acci-
dent may interrupt our intercourse, (nothing will interrupt
our friendship. Mine for you is built on the solid basis of
a full conviction that you deserve it, and that it is recipro-
cal, and it is the more firmly fixed, because you have few
competitors. Experience is a continued comment on the
worthlessness of the human race, and the few exceptions
we find, have the greater right to be valued in proportion as
they are rare. \J know few men estimable, -- fewer amia-
ble, and when I meet with one of the last description, it is
not in my power to withhold my affectionjl
You reproach me with not having said enough about our
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 412 TUK LIFE OF
little stranger. When I wrote last, I was not sufficiently
acquainted with him to give you his character. I may now
assure you, that your daughter, when she sees him, will not
consult you about the choice, or will only do it in respect
to the rules of decorum. He is truly a very fine young gen-
tleman, the most agreeable in his conversation and manners
of any I ever knew, nor less remarkable for his intelligence
and sweetness of temper. You are not to imagine, by my
beginning with his mental qualifications, that he is defect-
ive in personal. It is agreed, on all hands, that he is hand-
some; his features are good, his eye is not only sprightly
and expressive, but it is full of benignity. His attitude, in
sitting is, by connoisseurs, esteemed graceful, and he has a
method of waving his hand that announces the future ora-
tor. He stands, however, rather awkwardly, and as his
legs have not all the delicate shmness of his father's, it is
feared he may never excel as much in dancing, which is
probably the only accomplishment in which he will not be
a model. If he has any fault in manners, he laughs too
much. He has now passed his seventh month.
I am glad to find your prospect of being settled ap-
proaches. I am sure you will realize all the happiness you
promise yourself with your amiable partner. I wish fortune
had not cast our lots at such a distance. Mrs. Meade, you,
Betsey, and myself," would make a most affectionate and
most happy partie quarre.
As to myself, I shall sit down in New-York, when it
opens, and the period we are told approaches. No man
looks forward to a peace with more pleasure than I do,
though no man would sacrifice less to it than myself', if I
were not convinced the people sigh for peace. I have been
studying the law for some months, and Ijave lately been
licensed as an attorney. I wish to prepare myself by Octo-
ber for examujation as a counsellor, but some public avoca-
tions may possibly prevent me.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 413
I had almost forgotten to tell you, that I have been pretty
unanimously elected by the legislature of this state, a mem-
ber of congress, to begin to serve in November. I do not
hope to reform the state, although I shall endeavour to do
all the good I can.
Suffer Betsey and me to present our love to Mrs. Meade.
She has a sisterly affection for you. My respects, if you
please, to Mr. and Mrs. Fitzhugh. God bless you.
A. Hamilton.
The committee of the legislature, of which he speaks in
his letter to Mr. Morris, met on the fifteenth of September,
and notwithstanding his labour in devising a system of taxa-
tion, such were his doubts of the tone of the public, that in
a letter written to Mr. Morris on the evening prior to their
meeting, he says, " I am at a loss to know whether I ought
to press the establishment of permanent funds or not, though
unless I receive your instructions, following my own appre-
hensions of what are probably your views, I shall dwell
upon this article. "
On the fifth of October, he writes as follows: "In my
last I informed you that the committee appointed by the
legislature on the subject of taxation were together.
"In spite of my efforts, they have parted without doing
any thing decisive. They have, indeed, agreed on several
matters, and those of importance, but they have not redu-
ced them to the form of a report, which, in fact, leaves
every thing afloat, to be governed by the impressions of the
moment, when the legislature meet.
"The points agreed upon are these: that there shall
be an actual valuation of land, and a tax of so much on the
pound. The great diversity in the quality of land, would
not suffer them to listen to an estimated valuation, or to a
tax by the quantity, agreeable to the idea in your late re-
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 414 THE LIFE OF
port to congress, that there shall be also a tariff of all per-
sonal property, to be also taxed at so much on the pound.
"That there shall be a specific tax on carriages, clocks,
watches, and other similar articles of luxury: That money
at usury shall be taxed at a fixed rate in the pound, exclu-
ding that which is loaned to the public: That houses in
all towns shall be taxed at a certain proportion of the an-
nual rent: That there shall be a poll tax on all single men
from fifteen upwards; and that the collection of the taxes
should be advertised to the lowest bidder, at a fixed rate
per cent. , barring all subordinate expenses.
"Among other things which were rejected, I pressed
hard for an excise on distilled liquors, but all that could be
carried in this article was a license on taverns.
"The committee were pretty generally of opinion, that
the system of funding, for payment of old debts, and for
procuring farther credit was wise and indispensable; but a
majority thought it would be unwise in one state to contri-
bute in this way alone.
"Nothing was decided on the question of taxes, which
the state was able to pay; those who went farthest did not
exceed seventy thousand pounds, of which fifty were for
the use of the United States. "
An interesting correspondence continued between Mor-
ris and Hamilton, in which the various measures for prop-
ping up the credit of the financier, and introducing his notes
into extensive circulation, as a common currency, are dis-
cussed. In one of these, Hamilton speaks of an address of
the public creditors in Albany to those of the whole United
States, as having originated with himself, and containing
ideas which ought to prevail.
The suspension of interest on the loan office certificates
issued at an early stage of the revolution, had produced
great distress and discontent among the holders, the greater
number of whom resided in Philadelphia. After frequent
-\
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 415
consultation, a numerous meeting was convened in that
city, and strong resolutions adopted, urging upon congress
the necessity of granting them immediate relief. On the
appearance of this document, Hamilton conceived the idea
that a powerful influence might be exercised upon the mea-
sures of congress by the co-operation of the creditors in
other states, and with this view a meeting was held at Al-
bany, where General Schuyler presided, at which was pro-
posed a convention of county delegates at Poughkeepsie,
and a state delegation to a general convention at Philadel-
phia, from which he hoped incipient steps might be taken
for the adoption of his favourite measure, -- a re-organiza-
tion of the general government. These resolutions were
accompanied by the following address, urging the establish-
ment of permanent funds.
"TO THE PUBLIC CREDITORS OF THE STATE OF
NEW-YORK. "
The appellation by which we have chosen to address you,
indicates at once the broad and equitable basis upon which
we wish to unite the influence and efforts of those who are
creditors of the public, to obtain that justice, which the ne-
cessities of many, and the rights of all demand. What-
ever distinctions may characterize the different classes of
creditors, either of the United States, or of" this state, --
whatever may be their different degrees of merit as pa-
triots, or their comparative claims upon the gratitude or
generosity of their country, in one circumstance they all
agree, -- they have an equal claim upon the justice and
plighted faith of the public.
Alarmed by the successive violations of public engage-
ments, and by that recent and distressing one, the with-
holding the interest hitherto paid by bills on France, upon
the monies loaned previous to first March, 1778, the public
creditors in this city have thought it necessary to follow
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 410 THE h I IK OF
the example of those of the city of Philadelphia, and to
convene and consult upon the measures proper to be taken
for their own security. They will not dwell upon the
measure alluded to, farther than to observe, that its weight
is most oppressively felt by those whose zeal in the cause
and confidence in their country have been most conspi-
cuous; who in times of danger, have demonstrated their
concern for the common safety, by voluntary deposits, in
some instances of the whole, in others of a large part of
their fortunes in the public funds; and who now, many of
them at least, feel themselves reduced from affluence to
indigence, -- from circumstances of ease and plenty, to
penury and unaffected distress.
They cannot but add, that there are others, not less me-
ritorious, who have perhaps experienced even a worse fate;
those who, having made subsequent loans, have long since
seen the payment of interest cease, and those who, when
the distresses of the army have had no resource but in the
patriotism of individuals, have cheerfully parted with the
fruits of their industry, scarcely reserving a sufficiency for
the subsistence of their own families, without any compen-
sation since, besides the consciousness of having been the
benefactors of their country.
We entertain not so injurious an idea as lo imagine, that
levity or contempt of the obligations of national faith, or
of the dictates of policy, have influenced those infringe-
ments of the public engagements, which have too often
happened. We have been sensible of the necessity which
has, in some cases, produced them; but we apprehend it
to have resulted, not from the want of ability or means,
but from the want of a proper system for the beneficial
application of them. And we conceive it our duty to ac-
quiesce in that necessity, only so far as there appears to
be an unavoidable sacrifice to the urgent calls of particular
conjunctions, followed by effectual endeavours to prevent
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 41T
a continuance or return of the same necessity, or to make
satisfaction in some other way.
Few states have been without their vicissitudes, in which
the strict obligations of good faith have been obliged. to
bend to momentary necessities; but the example of all
wise and happy ones, combine with reason and justice to
establish this truth, that no time ought to be lost in pro-
viding the means of repairing those breaches, and making
compensation for the sufferers.
Unfortunately for us, and for every citizen of the United
States, (for the calamity directly or in its consequences is
general,) the same policy has been too long delayed in this
country; the only expedient in our power for effecting the
object, being still unattempted. We need no arguments to
convince us, that it is not possible for these states, by any
exertions they can make, to pay off at once the principal
of the public debts, and furnish the supplies for the cur-
rent demands of the war, and for the support of civil go-
vernment. We even think it as manifest as experience
and calculation can make it, that our abilities fall greatly
short even of the two latter objects. This, in an infant
country, will not surprise those who know that nations
the most opulent, and in all the vigour of maturity, are
compelled to have recourse to large loans in time of war,
to satisfy the public exigencies.
The quota of the present year has been fixed at eight
millions of dollars, which we are to consider as the sum
requisite for the annual expenditure; and those accustomed
to computations of such a nature, will be convinced that
to make this sum suffice, requires economy and good ma-
nagement. Have we a prospect of raising one third of
this sum within the states? Those who have attended to
the publications of the receipts on the continental account,
will easily answer the question for themselves. If this
vol. i. 53
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 418 THE LIFE OF
must be in the negative, the inquiry then becomes, what
means have we to supply the deficiency?
Admit that there are defects in the system of taxation
in almost every state, and that more judgement and equali-
ty in the manner of laying them, mere energy and econo-
my in the collection, would be more productive to the re-
venue, and less burthensome to the people, still we cannot
imagine that the reformation of these defeets would aug-
ment the product of the taxes in any proportion to the de-
ficiency.
It is plain, therefore, that the principal part of the ba-
lance must be procured upon credit; nor is it less plain,
that this must chiefly be from individuals at home and
abroad. We are assured, that the situation of our allies
will not permit them to make us governmental loans, in
any proportion to our wants, and without this assurance,
we might have inferred it, from a consideration of the im-
mense land and naval establishments which they are
obliged to support in the prosecution of the war, on their
own part.
It may be asked, if such are the necessities of the pub-
lic, how are they to spare any part of their funds for the
payment of old debts? The answer is easy, -- those ne-
cessities can only be supplied by a sound and healthy state
of public credit, and there is only one way to effect the
restoration of this credit, -- the putting the old debts in a
course of redemption,, or at least securing the punctual pay-
ment of the interest, by substantial funds, permanently
pledged for that purpose.
It cannot be expected, that individuals in this country
will hereafter lend to the public, unless they perceive a dis-
position to do justice to its creditors. If, without providing
for those who have already risked their fortunes, securities
should be held out to invite future creditors, a suspicion of
their faithful application would deter every prudent man.
my partiality. Betsey is so fond of your family, that she
proposes to form a match between her boy and your girl,
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 398 THE LIFE OF
provided you will engage to make the latter as amiable as
her mother.
Truly, my dear Meade, I often regret that fortune has
cast our residence at such a distance from each other, i It
would be a serious addition to my happiness if we lived
where I could see you every day^) but fate has determined
it otherwise. I am a little hurried, and can only request,
in addition, that you will present me most affectionately to
Mrs. Meade, and believe me to be, with the warmest and
most unalterable friendship,
Yours,
A. Hamilton.
Having completed his business at Philadelphia, he return-
ed to Albany ; took a house in the vicinity of General Schuy-
ler, to which he invited, as an inmate, his friend Colonel
Troup, who had previously studied the law, and with his
aid commenced to prepare himself for the practice of it.
To this dull pursuit, so foreign to all his previous habits,
such was his control of the powers of his intellect, that he
devoted himself with the most unremitting labour. His
retentive memory was tasked to its utmost. His habit
was to read while walking to and fro, and so incessant were
his labours, that his intimates would smile at the idea, that
while prosecuting this study, with the same diligence, he
might almost have marched from one end to the other of
the confederacy. At the ensuing July term of the supreme
court, he obtained a licence to practise.
Such was the knowledge he acquired during this short
period of four months, " that he composed a Manual on the
Practice of the Law," which, says Troup, "served as an
instructive grammar to future students, and became the
ground-work of subsequent enlarged practical treatises. "*
* There are gentlemen, now living, who copied this manual as their guide.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 399
In the preceding autumn congress had recommended to
the several states to levy a separate tax for continental re-
quisitions, and had invested the Superintendent of Finance
with the power of appointing an officer in each state to re-
ceive these taxes; an idea not improbably suggested by
Hamilton's letter of September, 1780, intimating the im-
portance of appointing in each state a "continental super-
intendent. " While engaged in the prosecution of his legal
studies, he received the following letter from Robert Mor-
ris.
ROBERT MORRIS TO HAMILTON.
Office of Finance, Philadelphia, May 2d, 1782.
"SIK,
"Mr. Charles Stuart, late commissary general of issues,
has informed me that you are disposed to quit the military
line, for the purpose of entering into civil life. He, at the
same time, induced me to believe that you would accept the
office of receiver of the continental taxes in the state of New-
York. The intention of this letter is to offer you that ap-
pointment. The duties of the office will appear, in a great
degree, from the publications made by me on this subject.
In addition, it will be necessary that you correspond with
me frequently, and give accurate accounts of whatever
may be passing in your state, which it may be necessary
for this office to be acquainted with. For the trouble of
executing it, I shall allow a fourth per cent, on the monies
you receive. The amount of the quota called for from
New-York for the current year is, as you know, three hun-
dred and seventy-three thousand five hundred and ninety-
eight dollars.
"I make no professions of my confidence and esteem, be-
cause I hope none are necessary; but if they are, my wish
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 400 THE LIFE OF
that you would accept the offer I make, is the strongest
evidence I can give of them. "
Hamilton made the following reply. "I had this day the
honour of receiving your letter of the second instant, and
am much obliged by the mark of your confidence which it
contains, and to Colonel Stuart for his friendly intentions
upon the occasion.
"My military situation has indeed become so negative,
that I have no motives to continue in it, and if my services
could be of importance to the public in any civil line, I
should cheerfully obey its command. But the plan which
I have marked out for myself is the profession of the law,
and I am now engaged in a course of studies for that purpose.
Time is so precious to me, that I could not put myself in
the way of any interruptions, unless for an object of con-
sequence to the public or to myself. The present is not of
this nature. Such are the circumstances of this state, that
the benefit arising from the office you propose, would not,
during the war, yearly exceed one hundred pounds; for
unfortunately, I am persuaded, it will not pay annually into
the continental treasury forty thousand pounds; and on a
peace establishment this will not be, for some time to come,
more than doubled. You will perceive that an engage-
ment of this kind does not correspond with my views, and
does not afford a sufficient inducement to relinquish them.
"I am not the less sensible to the obliging motives which
dictated the offer, and it will be an additional one to the
respect and esteem with which I have the honour to be,
very truly, sir,
"Your most obedient and humble servant. "
On the fourth of June Mr. Morris wrote to him, acknow-
ledging the receipt of this letter, and stating, "I am much
obliged by the friendly sentiments you express for me,
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 401
which, be assured, I shall retain a grateful sense of. I see
with you, that the office I had the pleasure of offering, will
not be equal to what your own abilities will gain in the profes-
sion of the law; but I did intend that the whole sum should
have been paid, although the whole quota of the taxes had
not been collected by the state; consequently, the object
is greater than you supposed, and the business might proba-
bly be effected without more attention than you could spare
from your studies. If so, I should still be happy in your
acceptance, and will leave the matter open until I have an
opportunity of hearing from you upon the subject. "
To which Hamilton gave the following answer:
HAMILTON TO MORRIS.
SIR,
* * * * The explanation which you give of your inten-
tion, in your late offer, makes it an object that will com-
pensate fully for the time that it will deduct from my other
occupations. In accepting it, I have only one scruple,
arising from a doubt whether the service I can render in
the present stateWJf things, will be an equivalent for the
compensation. (The whole system, (if it may be so called,)
of taxation in this state, is radically vicious, burthensome
to the people, and unproductive to governmenfe-^As the
matter now stands, there seems to be little for a continen-
tal receiver to do. The whole business appears to be
thrown into the hands of the county treasurers; nor do I
find that there is any appropriation made of any part of the
taxes collected for continental purposes, or any provision
to authorize payment to the officer you appoint. This,
however, must be made. There is only one way in which
I can imagine a prospect of being materially useful; that
is, in seconding your applications to the state. In popu-
lar assemblies much may sometimes be brought about by
personal discussions, by entering into details, and combat-
vol. i. 51
? ?
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 402 THE LIFE OF
ing objections as they rise. If it should, at any time, be
thought advisable by you to empower me to act in this ca-
pacity, I shall be happy to do every thing that depends
upon me to effectuate your views. I flatter myself, to you,
sir, I need not profess that I suggest this, not from a desire
to augment the importance of office, but to advance the
public interest.
It is of primary moment to me, as soon as possible to
take my station in the law, and on this consideration I am
pressing to qualify myself for admission the next term,
which will be the latter end of July. After this, should you
think an interview necessary, I will wait upon you in Phila-
delphia. In the mean time, I shall be happy to receive your
instructions, and shall direct my attention more particularly
to acquiring whatever information may be useful to my fu-
ture operations. I have read your publications at different
times, but as I have not the papers containing them in my
possession, it will be necessary that their contents should
be comprised in your instructions. A meeting of the legis-
lature is summoned early in the next month, at which, if I
previously receive your orders, it may be possible to put
matters in train. I am truly indebted to you, sir, for the
disposition you have manifested upon this occasion, and I
shall only add an assurance of my endeavours to justify your
confidence.
Alex. Hamilton.
On the second of July following, Mr. Morris writes, en-
closing the warrant of appointment and instructions, to
which he adds the following observations: -- "It gives me
singular pleasure, to find that you have yourself pointed out
one of the principal objects of your appointment. You will
find that it is specified in the enclosure. I must request
you to exert your talents, in forwarding with your legisla-
ture the views of congress. Your former situation in the
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 403
army, the present situation of that very army, your con-
nexions in the state, your perfect knowledge of men and
measures, and the abilities with which heaven has blessed
you, will give you a fine opportunity to forward the public
service, by convincing the legislature of the necessity of co-
pious supplies, and by convincing all who have claims on
the justice of congress, that those claims exist only by that
hard necessity which arises from the negligence of the
states. When to this you shall superadd the conviction,
that what remains of the war being a war of finance, solid
arrangements of finance must necessarily terminate favour-
ably, not only to our hopes, but even to our wishes. Then,
sir, the governments will be disposed to lay, and the people
to bear those burthens which are necessary; and then the
utility of your office, and of the officer, will be as manifest
to others as at present to me. "
On the receipt of this communication, Hamilton wrote
the following letter.
HAMILTON TO ROBERT MORRIS.
"I shall to-morrow morning commence a journey to
Poughkeepsie, where the legislature are assembled, and I
will endeavour, by every step in my power, to second your
views, though I am sorry to add, without very sanguine ex-
pectations. I think it probable the legislature will do some-
thing, but whatever momentary effort they make, till the
entire change of their present system, very little will be
done. To effect this, mountains of prejudice and particu-
lar interest are to be levelled. For my own part, consi-
dering the late serious misfortune to our ally, the spirit of
reformation, of wisdom, and of unanimity, which seems to
have succeeded to that of blunder, perverseness, and dis-
sension in the British government, and the universal reluc-
tance of these states to do what is right, I cannot help view-
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 404 THE LIFE OF
ing our situation as critical, and I feel it the duty of every
citizen to exert his faculties to the utmost to support the
measures, especially those solid arrangements of finance,
on which our safety depends.
"It is not in the spirit of compliment, but of sincerity, I
assure you, that the opinion I entertain of him who presides
in the department, was not one of the smallest motives to
my acceptance of the office, nor will that esteem and con-
fidence which makes me now sensibly feel the obliging ex-
pressions of your letter, fail to have a great share in influ-
encing my future exertions. "
On his arrival at Poughkeepsie, Hamilton addressed a
letter, on the sixteenth July, to Governor Clinton, apprizing
him of his appointment, and requesting the legislature to
vest in him the necessary authority; stating that it was "a
part of his duty, to explain to the legislature, from time to
time, the views of the Superintendent of Finance, in pursu-
ance of the orders of congress, that they may be the better
enabled to judge of the measures most proper to be adopt-
ed for an effectual co-operation, and asking his excellency
to impart his request, to have the honour of a conference
with a committee of the two houses. "
This body had been convened, in an extra session, at the
express instance of a committee of congress, and was open-
ed with a forcible message from the Governor, urging the
importance of a revisal of the tax laws, and calling upon
the legislature to denounce the attempts of the British go-
vernment to make separate treaties with the states, as a
measure inevitably to be attended with ruin and infamy,
and pressing the importance of the most strenuous exer-
tions to expel the enemy from their territory, to which an
answer, prepared by General Schuyler, who was the leader
in the senate, responded in the strongest terms. On the
twentieth July, the senate adopted a series of resolutions,
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 405
declaring their opinion, "that the present system of these
states exposes the cause to a precarious issue; that the
radical source of most of the embarrassments is the want
of sufficient power in congress to effectuate that ready and
perfect co-operation of the different states, on which their
immediate safety and future happiness depends; that ex-
perience had demonstrated the confederation to be defect-
ive in several essential points, particularly in not vesting
the federal government, either with a power of providing
revenue for itself, or with ascertained and productive funds,
secured by a sanction so solemn and general, as would in-
spire the fullest confidence in them, and make them a sub-
stantial basis of credit; and that it is essential to the com-
mon welfare, that there should be, as soon as possible, a
conference of the whole states on the subject, and that it
would be advisable, for this purpose, to propose to congress
to recommend, and to each state to adopt, the measure of
assembling a general convention of the states, specially au-
thorized to revise and amend the confederation, reserving
a right to the respective legislatures to ratify their deter-
minations. "
These resolutions, in which the hand of Hamilton so dis-
tinctly appears, were adopted unanimously,* and within
two days after, a joint committee of both houses was, at his
instance, appointed to report, at the next session, a system
for establishing such funds, within the state, as were best
suited to answer its purposes and those of the United
States, and for the more effectual collection of taxes, -- at
the head of which was General Schuyler, through whose
influence Hamilton was, on the same day, elected a Dele-
gate to congress.
It is interesting, in the progress of this work, to remark,
that to him who had so long laboured to impress on others
* July 22d, 1782.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 400 THE LIFE OF
the importance of a new organization of the government,
and who had so large a share in its formation, adoption,
and exposition, is to be attributed, with the aid of Schuy-
ler, the first action of the state of New-York, towards this
primary object. * In a letter to Mr. Morris, of this date,
Hamilton thus speaks of the result of his exertions:
HAMILTON TO ROBERT MORRIS.
"Poughkeepsie, July 22, 1782.
"SIR,
"Agreeable to my letter to you from Albany, I came to
this place, and had an interview with a committee of the
legislature, in which I urged the several matters contained
in your instructions. I strongly represented the necessity
of solid arrangements of finance, and by way of argument,
pointed out all the defects of the present system. I found
every man convinced that something was wrong, but few
that were willing to recognise the mischief when defined,
and consent to the proper remedy. The quantum of taxes
already imposed is so great, as to make it useless to impose
any others to a considerable amount; a bill has, however,
passed both houses, payable in specie, bank notes, or your
notes, for eighteen thousand pounds.
"It is at present appropriated to your order, but I doubt
whether some subsequent arrangement will not take place
for a different appropriation. The commander-in-chief has
applied for a quantity of forage, which the legislature is de-
vising the means of furnishing, and I fear it will finish by
diverting the eighteen thousand pounds to that purpose. I
have, hitherto, been able to prevent this; but as it is of
indispensable importance to me to leave this place imme-
diately, to prepare for an examination, for which I have
pledged myself the ensuing term, which is at hand, it is
* It is believed to be the first proceeding of any state on this subject. ?
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 407
possible, after I have left it, contrary ideas will prevail.
Efforts have been made to introduce a species of negotiable
certificates, which I have strenuously opposed. It has not
yet taken place, but I am not clear how the matter will
terminate. Should the bill for the eighteen thousand
pounds go out, in its present form, I cannot hope that it
will produce in the treasury above half the sum, -- such are
the vices of our present mode of collection. A bill has
also passed the assembly, for collecting arrearages of taxes,
payable in specie, bank notes, your notes, old continental
emissions at one hundred and twenty-eight for one, and a
species of certificates issued by the state, for the purchase
of horses. This is now before the senate; the arrearages
are very large.
"Both houses have unanimously passed a set of resolu-
tions, to be transmitted to congress and the several states,
proposing a convention of the states, to enlarge the powers
of congress, and vest them with funds. I think this a very
eligible step, though I doubt of the concurrence of the other
states; but I am certain without it, they never will be
brought to co-operate in any reasonable or effectual plan.
Urge reforms or exertions, and the answer constantly is,
what avails it for one state to make them, without the con-
sent of the others? It is in vain to expose the futility of this
reasoning. It is founded on all those passions which have
the strongest influence on the human mind.
"The legislature have also appointed, at my instance, a
committee to devise, in its recess, a more effectual system
of taxation, and to communicate with me on this subject.
A good deal will depend on the success of this attempt.
Convinced of the absurdity of multiplying taxes in the pre-
sent mode, when in effect the payment is voluntary, and
the money received exhausted in the collection, I have la-
boured chiefly to instil the necessity of a change in the
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 408 THE LIFE OF
plan, and though not so rapidly as the exigency of public
affairs requires, truth seems to be making some progress.
"There is no other appropriation to the use of congress
than of the eighteen thousand pounds.
"I shall, as soon as possible, give you a full and just view
of the situation and temper of this state. This cannot be
till after my intended examination; that over, I shall lay
myself out in every way that can promote your views, and
the public good. I am informed, you have an appointment
to make of a commissioner of accounts for this state. Per-
mit me to suggest the expediency of choosing a citizen of
the state, a man who, to the qualifications requisite for the
execution of the office, adds an influence in its affairs. I
need not particularize the reasons for this suggestion. In
my next I will also take the liberty to mention some cha-
racters. I omitted mentioning, that the two houses have
also passed a bill, authorizing congress to adjust the quotas
of the states, on equitable principles, agreeable to your re-
commendation. "
After the adjournment of the legislature, and his admis-
sion to the bar, Hamilton devoted himself assiduously to the
duties which the urgent solicitations of Mr. Morris earnest-
ly pressed.
The pictures which are given in his letters of this period
are of the most gloomy cast. Double sets of officers,
with conflicting powers and duties, clogging their respec-
tive operations; taxes, far beyond the ability of the peo-
ple, to be collected through a medium reduced to the low-
est point, and almost consumed in the process of collection;
while a general system of connivance and fraud pre-
vailed in many of the subordinate departments, which fur-
nished the strongest inducements to check the inquiries,
and prevent the adoption of the suggestions of an officer,
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 409
whose office itself was an object of the most jealous repug-
nance. *
To overcome these difficulties was an herculean task;
but he engaged in it with all his characteristic patience of
investigation. Though the evils were too extensive, and
laid too deep to be reached by any other means than a total
change of system, yet he hoped, by scrutinizing the whole
train of abuses, such data might be obtained as would ena-
ble the office of finance to apply efficient remedies, and gra-
dually to infuse such opinions as would convince the state
of its errors, and induce a radical change of policy.
During the interval of the appointment and meeting of the
committee, he was constantly engaged in extensive corres-
pondences throughout the state; in circulars to the county
treasurers, to ascertain the receipts and expenses of collec-
tion ; in communications with the army contractors, Messrs.
Duer and Sands, to learn the amount of expenditures and
the quantity of specie, and to promote the circulation and
increase the value of the notes of the financier and of the
bank, and in devising means to defer and lighten the de-
mands on the general treasury.
While thus employed in fulfilling the calls of the finan-
cier, he used the estimate which he obtained, (the incom-
pleteness of which he laments,) as a basis for digesting a
new plan of state taxation, which he proposed to submit to
the legislature.
The rule adopted in the confederation, after much angry
discussion, for fixing the quota of each state, had proved a
source of great delay and controversy. The valuation of
land which it prescribed, had been found impracticable, and
congress had been compelled to adhere to the original sys-
tem of requisitions, on the basis of the population, as com-
* From an entry in the diary of Mr. Morris, it appears that as late as the
twenty-ninth of August, 1782, a committee of inquiry, appointed by congress,
questioned his reasons for appointing continental receivers.
vol. i. 52
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 410 THE LIFE OF
puted in seventeen hundred and seventy-five. Each state
took advantage of the inaccuracy of this enumeration, and
found a ready excuse for the deficiency of their supplies in
the incorrectness of the estimate.
To avoid this difficulty, and at the same time to extend
the system of taxation as far as was possible, in order to meet
the demands of the public, Hamilton framed anelaborate bill,
in which, agreeably to a resolution of congress of the prece-
ding February, and to the report of the financier, he proposed
to abolish the method which existed, of taxing by arbitrary
quotas and assessments, -- a source of the greatest injustice
and inequality, -- and substituting for it a system of specific
taxation on lands, distinguished by their character, as mea-
dow or arable; on salt by the bushel; on tobacco by the
pound; on carriages. ; plate; on licenses of various kinds;
on menial servants; on houses; and a rate of specific du-
ties on imports.
The bill embraces a very minute and systematic scheme
to render the assessment and collection easy and secure; and
with a view to prevent the confusion and neglect which had
resulted from the proceeds of the taxes being thrown into
a general mass, he suggested the appropriation of them to
various objects; that upon land, to the support of the inter-
nal government; on carriages, to the judicial establishment;
the house tax to congress, for supplementary funds; the
salt, license, and tobacco tax, for constituting a loan office,
which seems to have been connected with the incorporation
of a bank, of which a portion of the income was to be secu-
red to that office. * The surplus of these taxes, and all
others, to form an aggregate fund for contingencies, to sup-
* A plan for a state bank and state loan office, is found among the papers,
which contemplated one state bank to control the currency ; -- the general
banking to be conducted by private bankers. It is not in Hamilton's hand-
writing, and some features of the plan fender it probable that it was a project
submitted for his consideration, but which he could not have approved.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 411
ply the Federal treasury. A plan of a lottery was also at
this time devised by him, containing many ingenious sug-
gestions, and evincing singular care to prevent frauds, from
which a considerable sum was hoped to be derived in aid
of the finances; -- a mode of taxation which had been pro-
posed by a committee of congress in seventeen hundred and
eighty; but which the enlightened sentiment of the present
age has ceased to approve.
Having obtained a license as an attorney in July, he,
notwithstanding his public duties, continued to prosecute
his legal studies, in order to prepare for admission to the
bar as a counsellor, at the ensuing October term of the Su-
preme Court. A letter to his friend Meade, shows his views
on this subject, and gives a pleasing exhibition of his do-
mestic feelings.
HAMILTON TO MEADE.
Albany, August 27th, 1782.
I thank you, my dear Meade, for your letter of the first
of this month, which you will perceive has travelled much
faster than has been usual with our letters. Our corres-
pondence hitherto has been unfortunate,' nor in fact can
either of us compliment himself on his punctuality; but you
were right in concluding, that however indolence or acci-
dent may interrupt our intercourse, (nothing will interrupt
our friendship. Mine for you is built on the solid basis of
a full conviction that you deserve it, and that it is recipro-
cal, and it is the more firmly fixed, because you have few
competitors. Experience is a continued comment on the
worthlessness of the human race, and the few exceptions
we find, have the greater right to be valued in proportion as
they are rare. \J know few men estimable, -- fewer amia-
ble, and when I meet with one of the last description, it is
not in my power to withhold my affectionjl
You reproach me with not having said enough about our
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 412 TUK LIFE OF
little stranger. When I wrote last, I was not sufficiently
acquainted with him to give you his character. I may now
assure you, that your daughter, when she sees him, will not
consult you about the choice, or will only do it in respect
to the rules of decorum. He is truly a very fine young gen-
tleman, the most agreeable in his conversation and manners
of any I ever knew, nor less remarkable for his intelligence
and sweetness of temper. You are not to imagine, by my
beginning with his mental qualifications, that he is defect-
ive in personal. It is agreed, on all hands, that he is hand-
some; his features are good, his eye is not only sprightly
and expressive, but it is full of benignity. His attitude, in
sitting is, by connoisseurs, esteemed graceful, and he has a
method of waving his hand that announces the future ora-
tor. He stands, however, rather awkwardly, and as his
legs have not all the delicate shmness of his father's, it is
feared he may never excel as much in dancing, which is
probably the only accomplishment in which he will not be
a model. If he has any fault in manners, he laughs too
much. He has now passed his seventh month.
I am glad to find your prospect of being settled ap-
proaches. I am sure you will realize all the happiness you
promise yourself with your amiable partner. I wish fortune
had not cast our lots at such a distance. Mrs. Meade, you,
Betsey, and myself," would make a most affectionate and
most happy partie quarre.
As to myself, I shall sit down in New-York, when it
opens, and the period we are told approaches. No man
looks forward to a peace with more pleasure than I do,
though no man would sacrifice less to it than myself', if I
were not convinced the people sigh for peace. I have been
studying the law for some months, and Ijave lately been
licensed as an attorney. I wish to prepare myself by Octo-
ber for examujation as a counsellor, but some public avoca-
tions may possibly prevent me.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 413
I had almost forgotten to tell you, that I have been pretty
unanimously elected by the legislature of this state, a mem-
ber of congress, to begin to serve in November. I do not
hope to reform the state, although I shall endeavour to do
all the good I can.
Suffer Betsey and me to present our love to Mrs. Meade.
She has a sisterly affection for you. My respects, if you
please, to Mr. and Mrs. Fitzhugh. God bless you.
A. Hamilton.
The committee of the legislature, of which he speaks in
his letter to Mr. Morris, met on the fifteenth of September,
and notwithstanding his labour in devising a system of taxa-
tion, such were his doubts of the tone of the public, that in
a letter written to Mr. Morris on the evening prior to their
meeting, he says, " I am at a loss to know whether I ought
to press the establishment of permanent funds or not, though
unless I receive your instructions, following my own appre-
hensions of what are probably your views, I shall dwell
upon this article. "
On the fifth of October, he writes as follows: "In my
last I informed you that the committee appointed by the
legislature on the subject of taxation were together.
"In spite of my efforts, they have parted without doing
any thing decisive. They have, indeed, agreed on several
matters, and those of importance, but they have not redu-
ced them to the form of a report, which, in fact, leaves
every thing afloat, to be governed by the impressions of the
moment, when the legislature meet.
"The points agreed upon are these: that there shall
be an actual valuation of land, and a tax of so much on the
pound. The great diversity in the quality of land, would
not suffer them to listen to an estimated valuation, or to a
tax by the quantity, agreeable to the idea in your late re-
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 414 THE LIFE OF
port to congress, that there shall be also a tariff of all per-
sonal property, to be also taxed at so much on the pound.
"That there shall be a specific tax on carriages, clocks,
watches, and other similar articles of luxury: That money
at usury shall be taxed at a fixed rate in the pound, exclu-
ding that which is loaned to the public: That houses in
all towns shall be taxed at a certain proportion of the an-
nual rent: That there shall be a poll tax on all single men
from fifteen upwards; and that the collection of the taxes
should be advertised to the lowest bidder, at a fixed rate
per cent. , barring all subordinate expenses.
"Among other things which were rejected, I pressed
hard for an excise on distilled liquors, but all that could be
carried in this article was a license on taverns.
"The committee were pretty generally of opinion, that
the system of funding, for payment of old debts, and for
procuring farther credit was wise and indispensable; but a
majority thought it would be unwise in one state to contri-
bute in this way alone.
"Nothing was decided on the question of taxes, which
the state was able to pay; those who went farthest did not
exceed seventy thousand pounds, of which fifty were for
the use of the United States. "
An interesting correspondence continued between Mor-
ris and Hamilton, in which the various measures for prop-
ping up the credit of the financier, and introducing his notes
into extensive circulation, as a common currency, are dis-
cussed. In one of these, Hamilton speaks of an address of
the public creditors in Albany to those of the whole United
States, as having originated with himself, and containing
ideas which ought to prevail.
The suspension of interest on the loan office certificates
issued at an early stage of the revolution, had produced
great distress and discontent among the holders, the greater
number of whom resided in Philadelphia. After frequent
-\
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 415
consultation, a numerous meeting was convened in that
city, and strong resolutions adopted, urging upon congress
the necessity of granting them immediate relief. On the
appearance of this document, Hamilton conceived the idea
that a powerful influence might be exercised upon the mea-
sures of congress by the co-operation of the creditors in
other states, and with this view a meeting was held at Al-
bany, where General Schuyler presided, at which was pro-
posed a convention of county delegates at Poughkeepsie,
and a state delegation to a general convention at Philadel-
phia, from which he hoped incipient steps might be taken
for the adoption of his favourite measure, -- a re-organiza-
tion of the general government. These resolutions were
accompanied by the following address, urging the establish-
ment of permanent funds.
"TO THE PUBLIC CREDITORS OF THE STATE OF
NEW-YORK. "
The appellation by which we have chosen to address you,
indicates at once the broad and equitable basis upon which
we wish to unite the influence and efforts of those who are
creditors of the public, to obtain that justice, which the ne-
cessities of many, and the rights of all demand. What-
ever distinctions may characterize the different classes of
creditors, either of the United States, or of" this state, --
whatever may be their different degrees of merit as pa-
triots, or their comparative claims upon the gratitude or
generosity of their country, in one circumstance they all
agree, -- they have an equal claim upon the justice and
plighted faith of the public.
Alarmed by the successive violations of public engage-
ments, and by that recent and distressing one, the with-
holding the interest hitherto paid by bills on France, upon
the monies loaned previous to first March, 1778, the public
creditors in this city have thought it necessary to follow
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 410 THE h I IK OF
the example of those of the city of Philadelphia, and to
convene and consult upon the measures proper to be taken
for their own security. They will not dwell upon the
measure alluded to, farther than to observe, that its weight
is most oppressively felt by those whose zeal in the cause
and confidence in their country have been most conspi-
cuous; who in times of danger, have demonstrated their
concern for the common safety, by voluntary deposits, in
some instances of the whole, in others of a large part of
their fortunes in the public funds; and who now, many of
them at least, feel themselves reduced from affluence to
indigence, -- from circumstances of ease and plenty, to
penury and unaffected distress.
They cannot but add, that there are others, not less me-
ritorious, who have perhaps experienced even a worse fate;
those who, having made subsequent loans, have long since
seen the payment of interest cease, and those who, when
the distresses of the army have had no resource but in the
patriotism of individuals, have cheerfully parted with the
fruits of their industry, scarcely reserving a sufficiency for
the subsistence of their own families, without any compen-
sation since, besides the consciousness of having been the
benefactors of their country.
We entertain not so injurious an idea as lo imagine, that
levity or contempt of the obligations of national faith, or
of the dictates of policy, have influenced those infringe-
ments of the public engagements, which have too often
happened. We have been sensible of the necessity which
has, in some cases, produced them; but we apprehend it
to have resulted, not from the want of ability or means,
but from the want of a proper system for the beneficial
application of them. And we conceive it our duty to ac-
quiesce in that necessity, only so far as there appears to
be an unavoidable sacrifice to the urgent calls of particular
conjunctions, followed by effectual endeavours to prevent
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? HAMILTON. 41T
a continuance or return of the same necessity, or to make
satisfaction in some other way.
Few states have been without their vicissitudes, in which
the strict obligations of good faith have been obliged. to
bend to momentary necessities; but the example of all
wise and happy ones, combine with reason and justice to
establish this truth, that no time ought to be lost in pro-
viding the means of repairing those breaches, and making
compensation for the sufferers.
Unfortunately for us, and for every citizen of the United
States, (for the calamity directly or in its consequences is
general,) the same policy has been too long delayed in this
country; the only expedient in our power for effecting the
object, being still unattempted. We need no arguments to
convince us, that it is not possible for these states, by any
exertions they can make, to pay off at once the principal
of the public debts, and furnish the supplies for the cur-
rent demands of the war, and for the support of civil go-
vernment. We even think it as manifest as experience
and calculation can make it, that our abilities fall greatly
short even of the two latter objects. This, in an infant
country, will not surprise those who know that nations
the most opulent, and in all the vigour of maturity, are
compelled to have recourse to large loans in time of war,
to satisfy the public exigencies.
The quota of the present year has been fixed at eight
millions of dollars, which we are to consider as the sum
requisite for the annual expenditure; and those accustomed
to computations of such a nature, will be convinced that
to make this sum suffice, requires economy and good ma-
nagement. Have we a prospect of raising one third of
this sum within the states? Those who have attended to
the publications of the receipts on the continental account,
will easily answer the question for themselves. If this
vol. i. 53
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2014-08-20 04:06 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/uva. x000275470 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 418 THE LIFE OF
must be in the negative, the inquiry then becomes, what
means have we to supply the deficiency?
Admit that there are defects in the system of taxation
in almost every state, and that more judgement and equali-
ty in the manner of laying them, mere energy and econo-
my in the collection, would be more productive to the re-
venue, and less burthensome to the people, still we cannot
imagine that the reformation of these defeets would aug-
ment the product of the taxes in any proportion to the de-
ficiency.
It is plain, therefore, that the principal part of the ba-
lance must be procured upon credit; nor is it less plain,
that this must chiefly be from individuals at home and
abroad. We are assured, that the situation of our allies
will not permit them to make us governmental loans, in
any proportion to our wants, and without this assurance,
we might have inferred it, from a consideration of the im-
mense land and naval establishments which they are
obliged to support in the prosecution of the war, on their
own part.
It may be asked, if such are the necessities of the pub-
lic, how are they to spare any part of their funds for the
payment of old debts? The answer is easy, -- those ne-
cessities can only be supplied by a sound and healthy state
of public credit, and there is only one way to effect the
restoration of this credit, -- the putting the old debts in a
course of redemption,, or at least securing the punctual pay-
ment of the interest, by substantial funds, permanently
pledged for that purpose.
It cannot be expected, that individuals in this country
will hereafter lend to the public, unless they perceive a dis-
position to do justice to its creditors. If, without providing
for those who have already risked their fortunes, securities
should be held out to invite future creditors, a suspicion of
their faithful application would deter every prudent man.
