conscious intelligence which reflects on and Beauty and Ugliness, and Other Studies in
analyzes life ; and (2) that, among primitive Psychological Æsthetics, 12/6 net.
analyzes life ; and (2) that, among primitive Psychological Æsthetics, 12/6 net.
Athenaeum - London - 1912a
The titles of these
of a bygone civilization. Truly, Job and merged in that of France. The collection is illustrations, however, are rather inaccurate,
Jeremiah are his familiar spirits ; grief his made the more useful by an exhaustive and certain names are misspelt; for instance,
element; tears his garment !
bibliography.
Piazza Guidea (Giudea), the Palazzo Massino
a
>
rescue
we
66
## p. 251 (#197) ############################################
No. 4401, March 2, 1912
THE ATHENÆUM
251
as
6
» which
name
more
upon the
(Massimo), and the monastery of Santo of Thucydides, who is hardly a model for is odd that he should object to Boswell's
Scolastico (Santa Scolastica), Illustration Greek prose, though a storehouse of usages placing an index at the beginning instead
xxiii? is said to represent the Garden of which attract the scholastic expert. Mr. of the end. It seems odd, too, that so
Cardinal Cesi in the said Piazza Giudea, Edwards quotes good authorities for his careless a writer should take it upon him
whereas its interesting remains are still to verdicts, but has surely had enough ex- to abuse other people unscientific.
be seen near the Porta Cavalleggieri, at the perience as a reader and teacher to speak Finally, we note that Mr. Fitzgerald in.
foot of the Monte di Santo Spirito. Lafreri's for himself.
dulges in the parallels which he scorns in
representation of Pasquino, published in
others. In 'Pickwick' and 'Boswellhe
1550 (pl. xxxv), is attributed to the seven- THE title of Mr. Percy Fitzgerald's book, detects curious similarities, and most
teenth century. Dosio's view of the Arco Boswell's Autobiography (Chatto & Windus), curious is the fact that Johnson and Mr.
di Portogallo, engraved about 1569 (pl. prepares us for his view that Boswell's Pickwick were both kissed by young ladies.
xxxvii), is attributed to Cavalieri and the chief aim in his 'Life' of Johnson was to
It is, indeed, prodigious.
period 1550 - 90. The rare and fine plate make a sort of apologia for his own life and
of the Benediction given by Pius iv. actions. His purpose was, we are told,
An Introduction to the Study of Prices. By
from the Loggia of St. Peter's, pub at all hazards to claim the first place in Walter T. Layton. (Macmillan & Co. )-It
lished by Lafreri, when Michelangelo's that chronicle. This ingenious paradox the is rarely that a book which is badly wanted
drum of the cupola (conspicuous in the author recently maintained in The Quarterly is as good as Mr. Laylon's. His competence
engraving) had already reached its full Review, and now, enlarges it in a loosely is in no need of testimony, and marks of
height, is attributed to 1540, the sixth year written book, full of repetitions, devoting care and thought abound throughout, e. g. ,
before the death of Giuliano da Sangallo, eight chapters to motor forces
in the valuable note on p. 54 dealing with
and the seventh before Michelangelo's impelled Boswell to advertise himself and his wheat prices from 1820 to 1875.
appointment as his successor in the director claims to notice. The book will interest
The plan adopted is excellent. The
ship of the works.
and entertain those--and they are probably text lays down plain broad tracks of thought
The text, on the other hand, is remark. many--who know little of Boswell's extra, along which even the beginner in economics
ably free even from slips of the pen.
Such ordinary life, and have not noted, or detected
can travel easily and profitably. These are
we may consider, however, the name of by means of other contemporary evidence, followed by neat and copious appendixes
Ferdinand the Fifth” given to the King the traces of his spite and prejudice. But containing the statistical materials on which
of Naples, Ferrante the First, who visited
much that the author says has been long the judgments are based.
An excellent
Rome in the jubilee year of 1475; and the
known to experts, and his special pleading-chart of average wholesale prices and the
statement that the present “Via Alessan.
we cannot call it anything else-frequently world's gold production follows.
drina,” which joins Trajan's Forum with fails to convince us. Boswell was not a
The book is an exposition of the theory of
those of Augustus and Nerva, derives its
gentleman in his behaviour,, but he was a prices, checked and supplemented by careful
from Pope Alexander VI. (1492–
great artist, with the artist's talent alike inquiries into the way in which they have
1503), since it was laid out only in 1567-70,
for veracious reconstruction and positive varied since 1820. How such changes affect
in consequence of the drainage and sanitaembroidery. Above all, he was, we take it, different classes of the community is carefully
tion of the Pantano, undertaken by Pius V.
a hero-worshipper with that intense_gusto considered. Similar care is devoted to the
and his nephew Cardinal Bonelli.
in life which distinguished Samuel Pepys, question whether periods of rising prices are
Apart from these trifling imperfections, the and we do not believe for a moment that best for trade, wherecn the conclusion is
detection of which needs a microscopic eye,
he intended to make Johnson play second that
Rodocanachi's book will be welcomed by all
fiddle. He was full of himself, like other
“nineteenth-century history shows that national
students of the “ Golden Days of the Renais-
vivid persons who have a special sense of
productivity depends much
sance”-and their number is legion-because, their own significance, and he had many advance of science and discovery, and on the
with the help of its amazing bibliography | scores to pay off, as is pointed out.
training, education, and organization of labour,
concerning known and unknown sources of
But the meaning of his phrases seems
than on the rise or fall of prices. "
information, it will give them a chance of sometimes overdone here, and in the attri. The relation in time between changes in the
learning a great deal more than the book bution of motives, always a dubious business, supply of gold and in the level of prices is
itself can tell.
R. LANCIANI,
this chronicle does not satisfy us. Boswell's considered, and the connexion between
case is not so strange as it is made out. them cautiously, but soundly demonstrated.
Many people find an annoying amount of The book should be read by all who are
THIS WEEK'S BOOKS.
Forster in the Life of Dickens,' and De interested in one of the burning questions
Quincey has left us in his views of his asso. of the day,
An English-Greek Lexicon, by G. M. ciations with the “ Lakers ” a masterpiece
Edwards (Cambridge University Press), is of apparently friendly innuendo.
the work of a sound scholar, and, as its Mr. Fitzgerald needs to go deeper than
PROF. HOPE W. HOGG.
320 pages supply a good grounding in he does if he means to convince. Take
vocabulary, separa ing verse and prose, it the case of Dr. Watson's Chemical Essays The death of Prof. Hope W. Hogg, to
is likely to be adopted for the use of young (pp. 126–7). He does not mention that which reference was made in the last issue
students. Mr. Edwards does not advocate they were introduced by Boswell because of The Atheneum, removes one of the best-
the constant use of the 'English-Greek’ in Johnson was reading them, nor would one known Orientalists in this country. Prof.
composition at school or at the University," gather from his subsequent comments that Hogg held the Chair of Semitic Languages
and in this view he will have
the support of these very · Essays' received a high eulogium and Literatures in the University of Man-
the majority of teache's. But some help from Sir Humphry Davy, that Watson chester, and, in addition to his tutorial
is needed, and a trustworthy selection of “ threw his science Aside for ever when duties, found time to undertake much
words with occasional references to the he was made Professor of Divinity, that he valuable work for the furtherance of Oriental
authors who use them, and some of the wrote very, forcibly”, on equalizing the studies.
paraphrase of the Gradus, should be appre- revenues of bishoprics without giving his own Born in Egypt in 1863, he acquired a
ciated. Additions and corrections will be case as an example, and that he was, in fact, sound knowledge of classical and modern
welcomed, and could be easily, supplied. a prominent figure in eighteenth-century Arabic, and with the help of his wife pre-
Our own experience tends to the belief that thought. Our quotations are from Leslie pared in 1896 a translation of the Arabic
the language of Euripides, simpler than Stephen, who was certainly not prejudiced version of Tatian's 'Diatessaron, with
that of his great riva's of tragedy, is unduly in the Bishop's favour.
introduction and notes. He also undertook
ignored. Thus ovdèv úylis is a convenient Writing concerning the Shakespeare the cataloguing of the Arabic MSS. in the
and idioma ic equivalent for unsound Jubilee at Stratford of 1769, Mr. Fitz- Rylands Library; and his wide acquaint-
which is mentioned in the Introduction. gerald says that Boswell's lament concerning ance with the literature shows itself in an
This feature of the book is more fitted Johnson's absence “ had no foundation. " admirable series of articles on 'Mesopo-
for advanced Grecians than for beginners. He wholly omits the fact, stated by Boswell, tamia, &c. , in the eleventh edition of 'The
It is, in fact, a sketch of great interest, that
that “ Johnson's connection both with Encyclopædia Britannica. '
depending on fine scholarship, and affording Shakspeare and Garrick founded a double As an Assyriologist, too, Prof. Hogg did
an admirable insight into the wonderful claim to his presence. ” He does not tell much useful work, especially in contributing
grace and variety of Greek, while it provides the reader, indeed, that the whole affair valuable summaries of Assyriological and
some of the details which will enable the was Garrick's special show.
other Oriental publications to The Inter-
examinee to solve his difficulties. The As usual, we find our author deprecating preter, and elsewhere. From 1895 to 1903
style of tragedy and Thucydides, of Xeno- the methods of Birkbeck Hill, and his
the methods of Birkbeck Hill, and his he was a member of the editorial staff of
phon, a bad authority for Attic,” and the "superfotation" of parallel passages. For the 'Encyclopædia Biblica,' into the pre-
now 'Hellenica' ascribed to Theopompus our own part, we cherish the illusion that a paration of which he threw himself with his
is briefly sketched. It would have been book requires an index. As Mr. Fitzgerald usual enthusiasm. Of his labours the
well, we think, to emphasize the crabbedness provides nothing of tặe kind himself, it | editors say in the Preface: "To his zeal
9
66
6
>
>
## p. 252 (#198) ############################################
252
No. 4401, March 2, 1912
THE ATHENÆUM
as
« vital
It may
a
6
energy, and scholarship the work has been
some books on the legislative methods of foreign
greatly indebted in every direction. ” Among
LIST OF NEW BOOKS.
countries, but the author expresses a doubt
whether we can derive many useful hints from
the numerous articles which he contributed,
(Notice in these columns does not preclude longer
such sources.
special mention may be made of those on
review. )
Morris (Robert C. ), International Arbitration and
the several Israelite tribes, and an extremely
Procedure, 6/ net.
interesting one on ' Agriculture. '
ENGLISH
New Haven, Yale University Press
London, Frowde
He devoted much time and trouble, also,
Theology.
We commend to all students of politics this
to the superintending of the maps which
Burn (Rev. A. E. ), The Athanasian Creed, 1/ net.
modest and unpretentious book by the counsel
form a special feature of this ‘Encyclopædia,'
Rivingtons
for the U. S. A. in the Venezuelan Arbitration.
and have gained the admiration of all who A short survey of the Quicumque, its history,
Mr. Morris sketches the history of arbitration,
have used and tested them.
old as
which is
authorship, and doctrines, with a brief com-
war itself, and the
Not to mention other work by the late mentary. Dr. Burn rejects Dom Morin's
conditions of its application, showing that,
while almost anything may become a
Prof. Hogg, it may suffice to say that he
recent theories, and adheres to Waterland's
view of an early fifth-century authorship.
issue " upon which no peaceful award is pos-
was a scholar of wide and accurate know.
There is a textual appendix. One of the
sible, the use of international agreement is
ledge, enthusiastic and minute in attention Oxford Church Text-Books.
yet extending beyond disputes which arise out
to detail, sober in judgment, and always Carlyle (A. J. ), The Influence of Christianity upon
of previous treaties or the friction of national
ready to assist in promoting the subjects to
Social and Political Ideas, 1/6 net.
debt-collecting. Not the least valuable part
Mowbray
of this volume is the chapter on the Hague
which he gave an all-too short life.
We are disappointed with this book. Not
Conference. President Taft contributes
be added that he originated and was the that it is bad, but if Mr. Carlyle had taken
“ Foreword. ”
first president of an Oriental Society in more pains with those parts of the subject | Robertson (George Stuart), The Law of Copyright.
Manchester, and had already completed the which are not covered by his ' History of
Oxford, Clarendon Press
Political Theory in the Middle Ages,' it might
In this book the text of the Conventions and
preparation and supervision of the first
have been infinitely better. His treatment is
Statutes is relegated to an appendix. The
number of its Journal.
S. A. C.
clear and simple-too simple, perhaps—for it
body of the work consists of a treatise on
suggests a single stream of Christian thought
copyright law as modified by the Act of 1911,
in relation to political ideas, instead of a
the whole subject being reviewed in a series of
separate system for nearly every one of the
well-arranged chapters. The effect of the statute
•GRAHAME OF CLAVERHOUSE. ' myriad forms of religion with little in
law is stated in clear language, and is discussed,
5, John Street, Adelphi, W. C. , Feb. 24, 1912.
common but the name of Christianity. Nor
criticized, and interpreted, as far as possible, by
does he seem to us to give sufficient prominence
earlier legal decisions. The book has the great
IN The Athenæum of to-day's date your to the distinction between clerk and layman, or
merit of dealing with a dry and complicated
reviewer—when criticizing my biography the doctrine of the State as a pis-aller, if a pis-
theme in a very readable way, and will prove
of Claverhouse-points out that the battle
aller of divine institution, which runs through a
useful to lawyer and layman alike.
of Tippermuir was not won by
“ 300 High-
good deal of Christian thought even in our own
day. His work is one of the Christian Social
Fine Art and Archæology.
landers. ” This misprint of the numbers Union Handbooks.
Cust (Robert H. Hobart), Benvenuto Cellini,
at Tippermuir was discovered before pub- Dallinger (W. H. ), The Creator, and What We 2/6 net.
Methuen
lication, and corrected by an erratum slip May Know of the Method of Creation, ed.
net. Mr. Cust's handbook shows sound judgment,
inserted at p. 256, where the misprint occurs.
C. H. Kelly is clear in style, and fortified by excellent illus-
A cheap edition of a lecture by a Wesleyan trations. One of the Little Books on Art.
I can only conclude that The Athenæum
scholar, who based his religious teaching on a Embalmed Head (The) of Oliver Cromwell in the
must have received an advance copy from refutation of materialism supported by his Possession of the Rev. H. R. Wilkinson, ex-
which the erratum was missing.
well - known researches on micro-organisms. hibited before_the Royal Archæological Insti-
I take it that the reviewer is thinking of
No. 17 of the Fernley Lectures.
tute of Great Britain and Ireland on 5th April,
Lord George Murray when he alludes to
Harrison (Jane Ellen), Themis : a Study of the 1911, with some Notes thereon, 2/6
Social Origins of Greek Religion, 15/ net.
The Institute
“Lord George Gordon shortly before Cul.
Cambridge University Press A reprint of the Proceedings of the Royal
loden. ”
MICHAEL BARRINGTON.
A revision of the views expressed in the Archæological Institute last April, when the
author's Prolegomena to the Study of Greek embalmed skull in question was anatomically
Religion. ' She has been led by the philosophy examined by experts. All the circumstances
of Prof. Bergson and the social psychology of that could be discovered concerning the sur-
THE MAN IN THE IRON MASK. Prof. Émile Durkheim to re-examine her material vival of the relic are related, and there are
in the light of two ideas : (1) That the mystery- illustrations of the head, which is now partly
Llandaff House, Cambridge, Feb. 20. 1912. god and the Olympian express respectively, decayed.
MR. ANDREW LANG, in his letter to you last the one durée, life, and the other the action of Lee (Vernon) and Anstruther-Thomson (C. ),
week on this subject, objects to my identifica.
conscious intelligence which reflects on and Beauty and Ugliness, and Other Studies in
analyzes life ; and (2) that, among primitive Psychological Æsthetics, 12/6 net.
tion of the famous prisoner in the new
John Lane
peoples, religion reflects collective feeling and There appeared in The Contemporary Review
edition of my book "The Man of the Mask. '
collective thinking. This “ group-thinking
some years ago the essay around which this
My candidate is, as he truly says, an ecclesi- group-emotion towards life the author book has grown. Of its conclusions, some
astic, and probably a Jesuit. How then, analyzes in the 'Hymn of the Kouretes,' have been sustained, and others largely modi-
Mr. Lang asks, does he come to be described
recently discovered at Palaikastro. Other fied by the latest psychology and philosophy.
themes, such as magic, mana, initiation cere-
as “a valet” by the French Government !
Though Vernon Lee declares that her æsthetics
monies, carnivals, and Olympic games, cluster
always those of the gallery and the
He then proceeds to bring forward once round the Hymn. On the games Mr. F. M. studio, not of the laboratory," they are none
more the claims of his own candidate in Cornford contributes a chapter, while Prof. the less, but perhaps rather the more, suggestive
The Valet's Tragedy '-who no doubt was
Murray adds an excursus on the ritual forms on that account.
a valet, and so far answers to the description.
preserved in Greek tragedy. The book is well Simla : The Conference of Orientalists, including
documented and illustrated, and should prove Museums and Archæology, held in July,
I should reply that from a hundred other of great interest to scholars.
1911.
Simla, Govt. Central Branch Press
instances of French political prisoners of Johnson (Rev. Theodore), The Visitation of the The Conference, which was attended by
the period we know that they were never
Sick: some Practical Reflections for the Use many distinguished scholars, discussed Oriental
called by their right names, or given their
of the Clergy and Others engaged in Parochial studies, museums, and archæology, their recom-
Visitation, 1/6 net.
George Allen mendations being incorporated in this volume.
right description in official letters; and
A manual intended mainly for the instruc- The foundation was proposed of a Central
that his was a matter of settled and in-
tion of the younger clergy, embodying the Research Institute, which would offer facilities
variable policy. Mr. Lang's objection is normal clerical recommendations and regula- for acquiring advanced knowledge both to
therefore no real objection at all, and recoils, tions. It is more of a guide to religious exhorta. Indians and Europeans. A scheme of admin.
so far as there is any force in it, against his
tion than a practical medical directory.
istration and regulation was drafted, and
the innovation promises well.
own candidate.
Law.
When we have said that the candidate Every Man's Own Lawyer, by a Barrister, 1912,
Poetry and Drama.
was a valet, we have, in fact, said all that
6/8 net.
Crosby Lockwood Cook (Augustus H. ), Psyche, and Other Poems, 3/6
there is to be said for Mr. Lang's theory. In the 1912 revised edition there have been
Bell
In nothing else does his candidate meet the few additional incorporations, except concern. There is a dainty and fanciful exclusiveness
ing the National Insurance and Copyright Laws. about Mr. Cook's poems.
requirements of the case. The real prisoner
He scorns contact
Among other Acts of importance are the Pro- with the rough world, and tunes his lyre in
was apparently a gentleman, a man of
tection of Animals Act and the Perjury and Italian bowers for his own satisfaction. There
culture, a fervent Roman Catholic, and a Swearing Act, both being codified. Other are, however, so many of these travellers in
man of political experience,who was possessed minor Acts are duly noted.
the shadow-world of elegant numbers that we
of some secret of vital importance. Mr. Ilbert (Sir Courtenay), Methods of Legislation : would fain light upon more uncouth stalwarts
Lang's valet in no way answers the descrip-
a Lecture delivered before the University of who do not shrink from actuality.
London on October 25th, 1911, 2/6 net.
tion.
Drew (Bernard), Helen, and Other Poems, 2/6 net.
Hodder & Stoughton
A. O. Fifield
If there is no stronger objection to be The author is concerned not with the inter- Mr. Drew's verse gains in strength and self-
brought against my candidate than this pretation of enacted laws, but with the different confidence. He used to be an apt phraser and
one of Mr. Lang's, I shall begin to be hopeful
methods of making them in civilized countries, a skilful colourist, but he has now developed
that I may have made a contribution of
and the advantages and defects that may resonance and dignity. His command over
be claimed for these methods. Though imagery, always noticeable, has
become
real value towards the solution of the
necessarily sketchy, the survey is of consider- broader, and at the same time more facile.
mystery
ARTHUR S, BARNES, able interest. At the end a list is added of While retaining his preference for classical
99
or
are
## p. 253 (#199) ############################################
No. 4401, MARCH 2, 1912
253
THE ATHENÆUM
2
9
was
subjects, he is more original and far more Rimington (A. Wallace), Colour-Music, the Art Lovett (the late Richard), James Chalmers : his
capable of welding difficult thought into of Mobile Colour, 6/
Hutchinson Autobiography and Letters, 1/ net.
rhythmical form than in Cassandra' and For notice see p. 263.
Prometheus Delivered. '
Religious Tract Society
The eighth edition of the life-story of the
Hands across the Equator.
Bibliography.
admirable missionary who worked among the
New York, the Author Book-Auction Records, Part I.
The author informs us that his verse was
Karslake inhabitants of New Guinea, notice of which
appeared in The Atheneum, July 5, 1902, p. 28.
written “ in hours of leisure after days of severe
Philosophy.
mental toil. ” The residuum of mental energy
Nevill (Capt. H. L. ), Campaigns on the North-West
Balsillie (David), An Examination of Professor
Frontier, 15/ net.
available for verse has produced exiguous
John Murray
results. People who toss off a few lines when
Bergson's Philosophy, 5/ net.
Concerned with the troublesome forays of
they can snatch a moment's respite from more
Williams & Norgate
the natives of the North-West Frontier, the
serious things can hardly expect to produce
For notice see p. 249.
repelling of attacks, reprisals, further inroads,
Schiller (F. C. S. ), Forma! Logic: a Scientific
and so on.
good work.
Such a history is unlikely to appeal
Hebblethwaite (James), Meadow and Bush :
and Social Problem, 10/ net. Macmillan
to others than those interested or engaged in
Book of Verses.
guerilla warfare. For soldiers who may be
Sydney, The Bookfellow
A criticism of formal logic from the formal
The author's attenuated spirituality becomes
point of view. Destructive in its purpose, the
stationed in that district of India it should be
tiresome when prolonged through so many
book is meant to prepare the way for the
invaluable, as it comprises the histories of all
pages.
the expeditions, and offers a suggestive study
He is free from marked lapses in taste
true logic of real reasoning, which starts from
and diction, but his inspiration is not sufficient.
the act of thought, and so does not lose touch
of the evolution of arms and strategy. There
His muse is a pastoral idler and
with Science and practical life. ” In fact, it
are maps and appendixes. We should have
touches
tender stops
forms Prolegomena to any future logic. А
liked to hear something of native customs and
-now with sentimental effusion,
now with plaintive wistfulness. Occasionally
fuller notice will appear in a later issue.
social life.
he strays into the idyllic Elizabethan modes of
Seth (James), English Philosophers, 5/ net. Dent
Russell (George W. E. ), Edward King, Sixtieth
feeling with success.
Prof. Seth, in this concise history of English
Bishop of Lincoln : a Memoir, 7/8 net.
Smith & Elder
Heine and Goethe (Translations from), by Philip
(including Scotch) philosophy, has, in spite of
A biography well worth writing.
G. L. Webb, 2/6 net.
his professed purpose of confining attention
The
A. C. Fifield
It seems impossible for English translators
chiefly to “the epoch-making philosophers,'
author has made excellent use of correspond-
of Heine to avoid the pitfalls of bathos and
happily done justice to the host of lesser names
ence to reveal the generosity, kindliness, and
simplesse.
simplicity of the bishop. The letters, however,
They can transmit his words, but
which the student is usually content to ignore,
never his witchery of spirit. Mr. Webb is
at the cost of making the course of thought
of congratulation after the well-known trial
gauche and limp, but conscientious and free
arbitrary and discontinuous. The volume forms
might have been reduced. With four appendixes
from any trace of insipidity or attitudinizing.
part of the Channels of English Literature.
and a frontispiece.
Southey's Letters, a Selection, edited, with Intro-
The Goethe translations selections from
History and Biography.
duction and Notes, by Maurice H. Fitzgerald,
Faust' and Iphigenia in Tauris '-are less
1/ net.
Frowde
cramped and bolder in rendering.
Besant (Sir Walter), London South of the Thames,
A neat little book on thin paper. Southey's
Middleton (George), Embers, and Other One-Act
30/ net.
A. & C. Black
Plays of Contemporary Life, $1. 35.
This book completes Besant's Survey of
private letters are worth piles of epics,'
Thackeray's dictum half a century ago. Its
New York, Holt; London, Bell & Sons
London, and forms the tenth volume of
These plays lack grip, reality, and distinction,
the whole work. It contains topographical
truth is beyond dispute. His correspondence
and their wording does not ring true to an
descriptions of Southwark and the suburbs
has singular spontaneity and charm, and vivifies
his connexion with such men
English_reader. Certain locutions that are
over the water as far as Eltham, Lee, and
as Coleridge,
odd in English, but became familiar in trans-
Shooter's Hill. The illustrations consist of
Lamb, Landor, Scott, and Shelley. The
lations from Ibsen—" even that,'
selection is excellent. In the World's Classics,
also ” in
reproductions of old drawings and prints
Pocket Edition.
unusual places, &c. -betray the source of the
of places now passed away, as well as repre-
author's inspiration ; but the disciple has
sentations of what still exists.
Thornton (John), The Story of India, 6/
H. J. Drane
produced only a superficial copy of the master.
Cooper (Frederic Taber), Some American Story-
O'Riordan (Conal), (Norreys Connell), Shake-
Tellers, 5/ net.
Grant Richards
The book shows a tendency to obscure
speare's End, and Other Irish Plays, 3/6 net.
Most of these essays originally appeared in
general conceptions with a mass of detail.
Swift
The Bookman, and it seems to us doubtful
In other respects we like it well enough. With-
Cherishing an inveterate prejudice in favour
whether they were worth collecting in book-
out being in any way profound, it should serve
of the Irish drama, we yet do not like these plays.
form. However, Mr. Cooper discusses the
to interest the general reader.
We find 'Shakespeare's End’ forced and in-
qualities and defects of his authors with clear-
Warren (Charles), A History of the American Bar,
16/ net.
Cambridge University Press
effective, in spite of some well-turned verse;
ness, and photographs of the chosen add
and the fine theme of The Piper' is poorly
interest to the book.
A portion of this book is reissued with many
additions.
executed.
It has been compiled from innumer-
An Imaginary Conversation
Fea (Allan), The Real Capt. Cleveland, 8/6 net.
is
able and scattered sources, and is consequently
certainly the best of the three, as it is the least
Martin Secker
ambitious, and on the stage it is pleasant
We fail to see either the necessity or usefulness
an agglomeration of facts flung into book-form
enough. Sincere and honest work cannot
of a biography of_the_buccaneer who figured
rather than a book. The first part is a résumé
make up for the lack of dramatic power, and
in Scott's novel The Pirate'; if any interest
of the legal conditions and administration
the
prevailing in the American colonies ;
we miss the peculiar flavour so keenly that it is
is attached to him, it is purely local. The
an effort to remember that the plays are written
author has made up for his lack of material
second traces the development of the American
by an Irishman about Ireland, and that at
by including a mass of trivial details remotely
Bar from the inauguration of the United States
least two of them have been acted at the
connected with his subject. The numerous
Supreme Court to the opening of the Civil War.
Both overcrowded with
illustrations are uninteresting.
Abbey Theatre.
non-essential
detail.
the book is the prefatory letter to Joseph Fitzgerald (Percy), Boswell's Autobiography, Wesley (Rev. John), The Journal of, enlarged
Conrad.
.
Chatto & Windus
For notice see p. 248.
from Original MSS. , with Notes from Unpub-
Percy (Eliza Duncan), Poems of Faith and Hope,
1/ net.
lished Diaries, Annotations, Maps, and Illus-
C. H. Kelly
Innes (Arthur D. ), England's Industrial Develop:
Rhymed versions of various Anglican doc-
ment: a Historical Survey of Commerce and
trations, edited by Nehemiah Curnock, Stan-
dard Edition, Vol. III.
C. H. Kelly
trines and incidents, delivered with pietistic
Industry, 5/ net.
Rivingtons
and altruistic fervour. They have no poetical
This is not a complete or comprehensive
The third 'volume of an admirable edition ;
merit, nor are some pastoral lyrics in any way
picture of the development of industrialism
its publication has been delayed by the wealth
notable.
in England. It only collects various data, and
of annotation which accompanies it. This
Wattson (Edith E. ), Songs and Sonnets, and a
marshals facts in a skeleton form. Neverthe-
section covers the period from April 16th, 1742,
Little Play, 1/
to October 30th, 1751, and has several illustra-
Christian Commonwealth Co.
less, its presentation, which is unbiased and
tions of interest.
The author is an elocutionist of promise ;
orderly, merits the attention of earnest people
but, when she turns from interpretation to
uninitiated into the intricacies of the labour
Geography and Travel.
creation, she shows
Her nebulous
problem, and desirous of grasping in rough Cruickshank (J. W. and A. M. ), The Smaller
reveries and “strange, sweet spells
outline the events, ideas, and tendencies under
are waifs
Tuscan Towns, 3/6 net. Grant Richards
and strays of verse without the semblance of
lying English industrial history.
Another of the excellent guide-books com-
inspiration. The “ little play is diminutive
Johnson (Dr. ) and Fanny Burney: being the piled on the principle of Grant Allen's recom-
and amateurish.
of a bygone civilization. Truly, Job and merged in that of France. The collection is illustrations, however, are rather inaccurate,
Jeremiah are his familiar spirits ; grief his made the more useful by an exhaustive and certain names are misspelt; for instance,
element; tears his garment !
bibliography.
Piazza Guidea (Giudea), the Palazzo Massino
a
>
rescue
we
66
## p. 251 (#197) ############################################
No. 4401, March 2, 1912
THE ATHENÆUM
251
as
6
» which
name
more
upon the
(Massimo), and the monastery of Santo of Thucydides, who is hardly a model for is odd that he should object to Boswell's
Scolastico (Santa Scolastica), Illustration Greek prose, though a storehouse of usages placing an index at the beginning instead
xxiii? is said to represent the Garden of which attract the scholastic expert. Mr. of the end. It seems odd, too, that so
Cardinal Cesi in the said Piazza Giudea, Edwards quotes good authorities for his careless a writer should take it upon him
whereas its interesting remains are still to verdicts, but has surely had enough ex- to abuse other people unscientific.
be seen near the Porta Cavalleggieri, at the perience as a reader and teacher to speak Finally, we note that Mr. Fitzgerald in.
foot of the Monte di Santo Spirito. Lafreri's for himself.
dulges in the parallels which he scorns in
representation of Pasquino, published in
others. In 'Pickwick' and 'Boswellhe
1550 (pl. xxxv), is attributed to the seven- THE title of Mr. Percy Fitzgerald's book, detects curious similarities, and most
teenth century. Dosio's view of the Arco Boswell's Autobiography (Chatto & Windus), curious is the fact that Johnson and Mr.
di Portogallo, engraved about 1569 (pl. prepares us for his view that Boswell's Pickwick were both kissed by young ladies.
xxxvii), is attributed to Cavalieri and the chief aim in his 'Life' of Johnson was to
It is, indeed, prodigious.
period 1550 - 90. The rare and fine plate make a sort of apologia for his own life and
of the Benediction given by Pius iv. actions. His purpose was, we are told,
An Introduction to the Study of Prices. By
from the Loggia of St. Peter's, pub at all hazards to claim the first place in Walter T. Layton. (Macmillan & Co. )-It
lished by Lafreri, when Michelangelo's that chronicle. This ingenious paradox the is rarely that a book which is badly wanted
drum of the cupola (conspicuous in the author recently maintained in The Quarterly is as good as Mr. Laylon's. His competence
engraving) had already reached its full Review, and now, enlarges it in a loosely is in no need of testimony, and marks of
height, is attributed to 1540, the sixth year written book, full of repetitions, devoting care and thought abound throughout, e. g. ,
before the death of Giuliano da Sangallo, eight chapters to motor forces
in the valuable note on p. 54 dealing with
and the seventh before Michelangelo's impelled Boswell to advertise himself and his wheat prices from 1820 to 1875.
appointment as his successor in the director claims to notice. The book will interest
The plan adopted is excellent. The
ship of the works.
and entertain those--and they are probably text lays down plain broad tracks of thought
The text, on the other hand, is remark. many--who know little of Boswell's extra, along which even the beginner in economics
ably free even from slips of the pen.
Such ordinary life, and have not noted, or detected
can travel easily and profitably. These are
we may consider, however, the name of by means of other contemporary evidence, followed by neat and copious appendixes
Ferdinand the Fifth” given to the King the traces of his spite and prejudice. But containing the statistical materials on which
of Naples, Ferrante the First, who visited
much that the author says has been long the judgments are based.
An excellent
Rome in the jubilee year of 1475; and the
known to experts, and his special pleading-chart of average wholesale prices and the
statement that the present “Via Alessan.
we cannot call it anything else-frequently world's gold production follows.
drina,” which joins Trajan's Forum with fails to convince us. Boswell was not a
The book is an exposition of the theory of
those of Augustus and Nerva, derives its
gentleman in his behaviour,, but he was a prices, checked and supplemented by careful
from Pope Alexander VI. (1492–
great artist, with the artist's talent alike inquiries into the way in which they have
1503), since it was laid out only in 1567-70,
for veracious reconstruction and positive varied since 1820. How such changes affect
in consequence of the drainage and sanitaembroidery. Above all, he was, we take it, different classes of the community is carefully
tion of the Pantano, undertaken by Pius V.
a hero-worshipper with that intense_gusto considered. Similar care is devoted to the
and his nephew Cardinal Bonelli.
in life which distinguished Samuel Pepys, question whether periods of rising prices are
Apart from these trifling imperfections, the and we do not believe for a moment that best for trade, wherecn the conclusion is
detection of which needs a microscopic eye,
he intended to make Johnson play second that
Rodocanachi's book will be welcomed by all
fiddle. He was full of himself, like other
“nineteenth-century history shows that national
students of the “ Golden Days of the Renais-
vivid persons who have a special sense of
productivity depends much
sance”-and their number is legion-because, their own significance, and he had many advance of science and discovery, and on the
with the help of its amazing bibliography | scores to pay off, as is pointed out.
training, education, and organization of labour,
concerning known and unknown sources of
But the meaning of his phrases seems
than on the rise or fall of prices. "
information, it will give them a chance of sometimes overdone here, and in the attri. The relation in time between changes in the
learning a great deal more than the book bution of motives, always a dubious business, supply of gold and in the level of prices is
itself can tell.
R. LANCIANI,
this chronicle does not satisfy us. Boswell's considered, and the connexion between
case is not so strange as it is made out. them cautiously, but soundly demonstrated.
Many people find an annoying amount of The book should be read by all who are
THIS WEEK'S BOOKS.
Forster in the Life of Dickens,' and De interested in one of the burning questions
Quincey has left us in his views of his asso. of the day,
An English-Greek Lexicon, by G. M. ciations with the “ Lakers ” a masterpiece
Edwards (Cambridge University Press), is of apparently friendly innuendo.
the work of a sound scholar, and, as its Mr. Fitzgerald needs to go deeper than
PROF. HOPE W. HOGG.
320 pages supply a good grounding in he does if he means to convince. Take
vocabulary, separa ing verse and prose, it the case of Dr. Watson's Chemical Essays The death of Prof. Hope W. Hogg, to
is likely to be adopted for the use of young (pp. 126–7). He does not mention that which reference was made in the last issue
students. Mr. Edwards does not advocate they were introduced by Boswell because of The Atheneum, removes one of the best-
the constant use of the 'English-Greek’ in Johnson was reading them, nor would one known Orientalists in this country. Prof.
composition at school or at the University," gather from his subsequent comments that Hogg held the Chair of Semitic Languages
and in this view he will have
the support of these very · Essays' received a high eulogium and Literatures in the University of Man-
the majority of teache's. But some help from Sir Humphry Davy, that Watson chester, and, in addition to his tutorial
is needed, and a trustworthy selection of “ threw his science Aside for ever when duties, found time to undertake much
words with occasional references to the he was made Professor of Divinity, that he valuable work for the furtherance of Oriental
authors who use them, and some of the wrote very, forcibly”, on equalizing the studies.
paraphrase of the Gradus, should be appre- revenues of bishoprics without giving his own Born in Egypt in 1863, he acquired a
ciated. Additions and corrections will be case as an example, and that he was, in fact, sound knowledge of classical and modern
welcomed, and could be easily, supplied. a prominent figure in eighteenth-century Arabic, and with the help of his wife pre-
Our own experience tends to the belief that thought. Our quotations are from Leslie pared in 1896 a translation of the Arabic
the language of Euripides, simpler than Stephen, who was certainly not prejudiced version of Tatian's 'Diatessaron, with
that of his great riva's of tragedy, is unduly in the Bishop's favour.
introduction and notes. He also undertook
ignored. Thus ovdèv úylis is a convenient Writing concerning the Shakespeare the cataloguing of the Arabic MSS. in the
and idioma ic equivalent for unsound Jubilee at Stratford of 1769, Mr. Fitz- Rylands Library; and his wide acquaint-
which is mentioned in the Introduction. gerald says that Boswell's lament concerning ance with the literature shows itself in an
This feature of the book is more fitted Johnson's absence “ had no foundation. " admirable series of articles on 'Mesopo-
for advanced Grecians than for beginners. He wholly omits the fact, stated by Boswell, tamia, &c. , in the eleventh edition of 'The
It is, in fact, a sketch of great interest, that
that “ Johnson's connection both with Encyclopædia Britannica. '
depending on fine scholarship, and affording Shakspeare and Garrick founded a double As an Assyriologist, too, Prof. Hogg did
an admirable insight into the wonderful claim to his presence. ” He does not tell much useful work, especially in contributing
grace and variety of Greek, while it provides the reader, indeed, that the whole affair valuable summaries of Assyriological and
some of the details which will enable the was Garrick's special show.
other Oriental publications to The Inter-
examinee to solve his difficulties. The As usual, we find our author deprecating preter, and elsewhere. From 1895 to 1903
style of tragedy and Thucydides, of Xeno- the methods of Birkbeck Hill, and his
the methods of Birkbeck Hill, and his he was a member of the editorial staff of
phon, a bad authority for Attic,” and the "superfotation" of parallel passages. For the 'Encyclopædia Biblica,' into the pre-
now 'Hellenica' ascribed to Theopompus our own part, we cherish the illusion that a paration of which he threw himself with his
is briefly sketched. It would have been book requires an index. As Mr. Fitzgerald usual enthusiasm. Of his labours the
well, we think, to emphasize the crabbedness provides nothing of tặe kind himself, it | editors say in the Preface: "To his zeal
9
66
6
>
>
## p. 252 (#198) ############################################
252
No. 4401, March 2, 1912
THE ATHENÆUM
as
« vital
It may
a
6
energy, and scholarship the work has been
some books on the legislative methods of foreign
greatly indebted in every direction. ” Among
LIST OF NEW BOOKS.
countries, but the author expresses a doubt
whether we can derive many useful hints from
the numerous articles which he contributed,
(Notice in these columns does not preclude longer
such sources.
special mention may be made of those on
review. )
Morris (Robert C. ), International Arbitration and
the several Israelite tribes, and an extremely
Procedure, 6/ net.
interesting one on ' Agriculture. '
ENGLISH
New Haven, Yale University Press
London, Frowde
He devoted much time and trouble, also,
Theology.
We commend to all students of politics this
to the superintending of the maps which
Burn (Rev. A. E. ), The Athanasian Creed, 1/ net.
modest and unpretentious book by the counsel
form a special feature of this ‘Encyclopædia,'
Rivingtons
for the U. S. A. in the Venezuelan Arbitration.
and have gained the admiration of all who A short survey of the Quicumque, its history,
Mr. Morris sketches the history of arbitration,
have used and tested them.
old as
which is
authorship, and doctrines, with a brief com-
war itself, and the
Not to mention other work by the late mentary. Dr. Burn rejects Dom Morin's
conditions of its application, showing that,
while almost anything may become a
Prof. Hogg, it may suffice to say that he
recent theories, and adheres to Waterland's
view of an early fifth-century authorship.
issue " upon which no peaceful award is pos-
was a scholar of wide and accurate know.
There is a textual appendix. One of the
sible, the use of international agreement is
ledge, enthusiastic and minute in attention Oxford Church Text-Books.
yet extending beyond disputes which arise out
to detail, sober in judgment, and always Carlyle (A. J. ), The Influence of Christianity upon
of previous treaties or the friction of national
ready to assist in promoting the subjects to
Social and Political Ideas, 1/6 net.
debt-collecting. Not the least valuable part
Mowbray
of this volume is the chapter on the Hague
which he gave an all-too short life.
We are disappointed with this book. Not
Conference. President Taft contributes
be added that he originated and was the that it is bad, but if Mr. Carlyle had taken
“ Foreword. ”
first president of an Oriental Society in more pains with those parts of the subject | Robertson (George Stuart), The Law of Copyright.
Manchester, and had already completed the which are not covered by his ' History of
Oxford, Clarendon Press
Political Theory in the Middle Ages,' it might
In this book the text of the Conventions and
preparation and supervision of the first
have been infinitely better. His treatment is
Statutes is relegated to an appendix. The
number of its Journal.
S. A. C.
clear and simple-too simple, perhaps—for it
body of the work consists of a treatise on
suggests a single stream of Christian thought
copyright law as modified by the Act of 1911,
in relation to political ideas, instead of a
the whole subject being reviewed in a series of
separate system for nearly every one of the
well-arranged chapters. The effect of the statute
•GRAHAME OF CLAVERHOUSE. ' myriad forms of religion with little in
law is stated in clear language, and is discussed,
5, John Street, Adelphi, W. C. , Feb. 24, 1912.
common but the name of Christianity. Nor
criticized, and interpreted, as far as possible, by
does he seem to us to give sufficient prominence
earlier legal decisions. The book has the great
IN The Athenæum of to-day's date your to the distinction between clerk and layman, or
merit of dealing with a dry and complicated
reviewer—when criticizing my biography the doctrine of the State as a pis-aller, if a pis-
theme in a very readable way, and will prove
of Claverhouse-points out that the battle
aller of divine institution, which runs through a
useful to lawyer and layman alike.
of Tippermuir was not won by
“ 300 High-
good deal of Christian thought even in our own
day. His work is one of the Christian Social
Fine Art and Archæology.
landers. ” This misprint of the numbers Union Handbooks.
Cust (Robert H. Hobart), Benvenuto Cellini,
at Tippermuir was discovered before pub- Dallinger (W. H. ), The Creator, and What We 2/6 net.
Methuen
lication, and corrected by an erratum slip May Know of the Method of Creation, ed.
net. Mr. Cust's handbook shows sound judgment,
inserted at p. 256, where the misprint occurs.
C. H. Kelly is clear in style, and fortified by excellent illus-
A cheap edition of a lecture by a Wesleyan trations. One of the Little Books on Art.
I can only conclude that The Athenæum
scholar, who based his religious teaching on a Embalmed Head (The) of Oliver Cromwell in the
must have received an advance copy from refutation of materialism supported by his Possession of the Rev. H. R. Wilkinson, ex-
which the erratum was missing.
well - known researches on micro-organisms. hibited before_the Royal Archæological Insti-
I take it that the reviewer is thinking of
No. 17 of the Fernley Lectures.
tute of Great Britain and Ireland on 5th April,
Lord George Murray when he alludes to
Harrison (Jane Ellen), Themis : a Study of the 1911, with some Notes thereon, 2/6
Social Origins of Greek Religion, 15/ net.
The Institute
“Lord George Gordon shortly before Cul.
Cambridge University Press A reprint of the Proceedings of the Royal
loden. ”
MICHAEL BARRINGTON.
A revision of the views expressed in the Archæological Institute last April, when the
author's Prolegomena to the Study of Greek embalmed skull in question was anatomically
Religion. ' She has been led by the philosophy examined by experts. All the circumstances
of Prof. Bergson and the social psychology of that could be discovered concerning the sur-
THE MAN IN THE IRON MASK. Prof. Émile Durkheim to re-examine her material vival of the relic are related, and there are
in the light of two ideas : (1) That the mystery- illustrations of the head, which is now partly
Llandaff House, Cambridge, Feb. 20. 1912. god and the Olympian express respectively, decayed.
MR. ANDREW LANG, in his letter to you last the one durée, life, and the other the action of Lee (Vernon) and Anstruther-Thomson (C. ),
week on this subject, objects to my identifica.
conscious intelligence which reflects on and Beauty and Ugliness, and Other Studies in
analyzes life ; and (2) that, among primitive Psychological Æsthetics, 12/6 net.
tion of the famous prisoner in the new
John Lane
peoples, religion reflects collective feeling and There appeared in The Contemporary Review
edition of my book "The Man of the Mask. '
collective thinking. This “ group-thinking
some years ago the essay around which this
My candidate is, as he truly says, an ecclesi- group-emotion towards life the author book has grown. Of its conclusions, some
astic, and probably a Jesuit. How then, analyzes in the 'Hymn of the Kouretes,' have been sustained, and others largely modi-
Mr. Lang asks, does he come to be described
recently discovered at Palaikastro. Other fied by the latest psychology and philosophy.
themes, such as magic, mana, initiation cere-
as “a valet” by the French Government !
Though Vernon Lee declares that her æsthetics
monies, carnivals, and Olympic games, cluster
always those of the gallery and the
He then proceeds to bring forward once round the Hymn. On the games Mr. F. M. studio, not of the laboratory," they are none
more the claims of his own candidate in Cornford contributes a chapter, while Prof. the less, but perhaps rather the more, suggestive
The Valet's Tragedy '-who no doubt was
Murray adds an excursus on the ritual forms on that account.
a valet, and so far answers to the description.
preserved in Greek tragedy. The book is well Simla : The Conference of Orientalists, including
documented and illustrated, and should prove Museums and Archæology, held in July,
I should reply that from a hundred other of great interest to scholars.
1911.
Simla, Govt. Central Branch Press
instances of French political prisoners of Johnson (Rev. Theodore), The Visitation of the The Conference, which was attended by
the period we know that they were never
Sick: some Practical Reflections for the Use many distinguished scholars, discussed Oriental
called by their right names, or given their
of the Clergy and Others engaged in Parochial studies, museums, and archæology, their recom-
Visitation, 1/6 net.
George Allen mendations being incorporated in this volume.
right description in official letters; and
A manual intended mainly for the instruc- The foundation was proposed of a Central
that his was a matter of settled and in-
tion of the younger clergy, embodying the Research Institute, which would offer facilities
variable policy. Mr. Lang's objection is normal clerical recommendations and regula- for acquiring advanced knowledge both to
therefore no real objection at all, and recoils, tions. It is more of a guide to religious exhorta. Indians and Europeans. A scheme of admin.
so far as there is any force in it, against his
tion than a practical medical directory.
istration and regulation was drafted, and
the innovation promises well.
own candidate.
Law.
When we have said that the candidate Every Man's Own Lawyer, by a Barrister, 1912,
Poetry and Drama.
was a valet, we have, in fact, said all that
6/8 net.
Crosby Lockwood Cook (Augustus H. ), Psyche, and Other Poems, 3/6
there is to be said for Mr. Lang's theory. In the 1912 revised edition there have been
Bell
In nothing else does his candidate meet the few additional incorporations, except concern. There is a dainty and fanciful exclusiveness
ing the National Insurance and Copyright Laws. about Mr. Cook's poems.
requirements of the case. The real prisoner
He scorns contact
Among other Acts of importance are the Pro- with the rough world, and tunes his lyre in
was apparently a gentleman, a man of
tection of Animals Act and the Perjury and Italian bowers for his own satisfaction. There
culture, a fervent Roman Catholic, and a Swearing Act, both being codified. Other are, however, so many of these travellers in
man of political experience,who was possessed minor Acts are duly noted.
the shadow-world of elegant numbers that we
of some secret of vital importance. Mr. Ilbert (Sir Courtenay), Methods of Legislation : would fain light upon more uncouth stalwarts
Lang's valet in no way answers the descrip-
a Lecture delivered before the University of who do not shrink from actuality.
London on October 25th, 1911, 2/6 net.
tion.
Drew (Bernard), Helen, and Other Poems, 2/6 net.
Hodder & Stoughton
A. O. Fifield
If there is no stronger objection to be The author is concerned not with the inter- Mr. Drew's verse gains in strength and self-
brought against my candidate than this pretation of enacted laws, but with the different confidence. He used to be an apt phraser and
one of Mr. Lang's, I shall begin to be hopeful
methods of making them in civilized countries, a skilful colourist, but he has now developed
that I may have made a contribution of
and the advantages and defects that may resonance and dignity. His command over
be claimed for these methods. Though imagery, always noticeable, has
become
real value towards the solution of the
necessarily sketchy, the survey is of consider- broader, and at the same time more facile.
mystery
ARTHUR S, BARNES, able interest. At the end a list is added of While retaining his preference for classical
99
or
are
## p. 253 (#199) ############################################
No. 4401, MARCH 2, 1912
253
THE ATHENÆUM
2
9
was
subjects, he is more original and far more Rimington (A. Wallace), Colour-Music, the Art Lovett (the late Richard), James Chalmers : his
capable of welding difficult thought into of Mobile Colour, 6/
Hutchinson Autobiography and Letters, 1/ net.
rhythmical form than in Cassandra' and For notice see p. 263.
Prometheus Delivered. '
Religious Tract Society
The eighth edition of the life-story of the
Hands across the Equator.
Bibliography.
admirable missionary who worked among the
New York, the Author Book-Auction Records, Part I.
The author informs us that his verse was
Karslake inhabitants of New Guinea, notice of which
appeared in The Atheneum, July 5, 1902, p. 28.
written “ in hours of leisure after days of severe
Philosophy.
mental toil. ” The residuum of mental energy
Nevill (Capt. H. L. ), Campaigns on the North-West
Balsillie (David), An Examination of Professor
Frontier, 15/ net.
available for verse has produced exiguous
John Murray
results. People who toss off a few lines when
Bergson's Philosophy, 5/ net.
Concerned with the troublesome forays of
they can snatch a moment's respite from more
Williams & Norgate
the natives of the North-West Frontier, the
serious things can hardly expect to produce
For notice see p. 249.
repelling of attacks, reprisals, further inroads,
Schiller (F. C. S. ), Forma! Logic: a Scientific
and so on.
good work.
Such a history is unlikely to appeal
Hebblethwaite (James), Meadow and Bush :
and Social Problem, 10/ net. Macmillan
to others than those interested or engaged in
Book of Verses.
guerilla warfare. For soldiers who may be
Sydney, The Bookfellow
A criticism of formal logic from the formal
The author's attenuated spirituality becomes
point of view. Destructive in its purpose, the
stationed in that district of India it should be
tiresome when prolonged through so many
book is meant to prepare the way for the
invaluable, as it comprises the histories of all
pages.
the expeditions, and offers a suggestive study
He is free from marked lapses in taste
true logic of real reasoning, which starts from
and diction, but his inspiration is not sufficient.
the act of thought, and so does not lose touch
of the evolution of arms and strategy. There
His muse is a pastoral idler and
with Science and practical life. ” In fact, it
are maps and appendixes. We should have
touches
tender stops
forms Prolegomena to any future logic. А
liked to hear something of native customs and
-now with sentimental effusion,
now with plaintive wistfulness. Occasionally
fuller notice will appear in a later issue.
social life.
he strays into the idyllic Elizabethan modes of
Seth (James), English Philosophers, 5/ net. Dent
Russell (George W. E. ), Edward King, Sixtieth
feeling with success.
Prof. Seth, in this concise history of English
Bishop of Lincoln : a Memoir, 7/8 net.
Smith & Elder
Heine and Goethe (Translations from), by Philip
(including Scotch) philosophy, has, in spite of
A biography well worth writing.
G. L. Webb, 2/6 net.
his professed purpose of confining attention
The
A. C. Fifield
It seems impossible for English translators
chiefly to “the epoch-making philosophers,'
author has made excellent use of correspond-
of Heine to avoid the pitfalls of bathos and
happily done justice to the host of lesser names
ence to reveal the generosity, kindliness, and
simplesse.
simplicity of the bishop. The letters, however,
They can transmit his words, but
which the student is usually content to ignore,
never his witchery of spirit. Mr. Webb is
at the cost of making the course of thought
of congratulation after the well-known trial
gauche and limp, but conscientious and free
arbitrary and discontinuous. The volume forms
might have been reduced. With four appendixes
from any trace of insipidity or attitudinizing.
part of the Channels of English Literature.
and a frontispiece.
Southey's Letters, a Selection, edited, with Intro-
The Goethe translations selections from
History and Biography.
duction and Notes, by Maurice H. Fitzgerald,
Faust' and Iphigenia in Tauris '-are less
1/ net.
Frowde
cramped and bolder in rendering.
Besant (Sir Walter), London South of the Thames,
A neat little book on thin paper. Southey's
Middleton (George), Embers, and Other One-Act
30/ net.
A. & C. Black
Plays of Contemporary Life, $1. 35.
This book completes Besant's Survey of
private letters are worth piles of epics,'
Thackeray's dictum half a century ago. Its
New York, Holt; London, Bell & Sons
London, and forms the tenth volume of
These plays lack grip, reality, and distinction,
the whole work. It contains topographical
truth is beyond dispute. His correspondence
and their wording does not ring true to an
descriptions of Southwark and the suburbs
has singular spontaneity and charm, and vivifies
his connexion with such men
English_reader. Certain locutions that are
over the water as far as Eltham, Lee, and
as Coleridge,
odd in English, but became familiar in trans-
Shooter's Hill. The illustrations consist of
Lamb, Landor, Scott, and Shelley. The
lations from Ibsen—" even that,'
selection is excellent. In the World's Classics,
also ” in
reproductions of old drawings and prints
Pocket Edition.
unusual places, &c. -betray the source of the
of places now passed away, as well as repre-
author's inspiration ; but the disciple has
sentations of what still exists.
Thornton (John), The Story of India, 6/
H. J. Drane
produced only a superficial copy of the master.
Cooper (Frederic Taber), Some American Story-
O'Riordan (Conal), (Norreys Connell), Shake-
Tellers, 5/ net.
Grant Richards
The book shows a tendency to obscure
speare's End, and Other Irish Plays, 3/6 net.
Most of these essays originally appeared in
general conceptions with a mass of detail.
Swift
The Bookman, and it seems to us doubtful
In other respects we like it well enough. With-
Cherishing an inveterate prejudice in favour
whether they were worth collecting in book-
out being in any way profound, it should serve
of the Irish drama, we yet do not like these plays.
form. However, Mr. Cooper discusses the
to interest the general reader.
We find 'Shakespeare's End’ forced and in-
qualities and defects of his authors with clear-
Warren (Charles), A History of the American Bar,
16/ net.
Cambridge University Press
effective, in spite of some well-turned verse;
ness, and photographs of the chosen add
and the fine theme of The Piper' is poorly
interest to the book.
A portion of this book is reissued with many
additions.
executed.
It has been compiled from innumer-
An Imaginary Conversation
Fea (Allan), The Real Capt. Cleveland, 8/6 net.
is
able and scattered sources, and is consequently
certainly the best of the three, as it is the least
Martin Secker
ambitious, and on the stage it is pleasant
We fail to see either the necessity or usefulness
an agglomeration of facts flung into book-form
enough. Sincere and honest work cannot
of a biography of_the_buccaneer who figured
rather than a book. The first part is a résumé
make up for the lack of dramatic power, and
in Scott's novel The Pirate'; if any interest
of the legal conditions and administration
the
prevailing in the American colonies ;
we miss the peculiar flavour so keenly that it is
is attached to him, it is purely local. The
an effort to remember that the plays are written
author has made up for his lack of material
second traces the development of the American
by an Irishman about Ireland, and that at
by including a mass of trivial details remotely
Bar from the inauguration of the United States
least two of them have been acted at the
connected with his subject. The numerous
Supreme Court to the opening of the Civil War.
Both overcrowded with
illustrations are uninteresting.
Abbey Theatre.
non-essential
detail.
the book is the prefatory letter to Joseph Fitzgerald (Percy), Boswell's Autobiography, Wesley (Rev. John), The Journal of, enlarged
Conrad.
.
Chatto & Windus
For notice see p. 248.
from Original MSS. , with Notes from Unpub-
Percy (Eliza Duncan), Poems of Faith and Hope,
1/ net.
lished Diaries, Annotations, Maps, and Illus-
C. H. Kelly
Innes (Arthur D. ), England's Industrial Develop:
Rhymed versions of various Anglican doc-
ment: a Historical Survey of Commerce and
trations, edited by Nehemiah Curnock, Stan-
dard Edition, Vol. III.
C. H. Kelly
trines and incidents, delivered with pietistic
Industry, 5/ net.
Rivingtons
and altruistic fervour. They have no poetical
This is not a complete or comprehensive
The third 'volume of an admirable edition ;
merit, nor are some pastoral lyrics in any way
picture of the development of industrialism
its publication has been delayed by the wealth
notable.
in England. It only collects various data, and
of annotation which accompanies it. This
Wattson (Edith E. ), Songs and Sonnets, and a
marshals facts in a skeleton form. Neverthe-
section covers the period from April 16th, 1742,
Little Play, 1/
to October 30th, 1751, and has several illustra-
Christian Commonwealth Co.
less, its presentation, which is unbiased and
tions of interest.
The author is an elocutionist of promise ;
orderly, merits the attention of earnest people
but, when she turns from interpretation to
uninitiated into the intricacies of the labour
Geography and Travel.
creation, she shows
Her nebulous
problem, and desirous of grasping in rough Cruickshank (J. W. and A. M. ), The Smaller
reveries and “strange, sweet spells
outline the events, ideas, and tendencies under
are waifs
Tuscan Towns, 3/6 net. Grant Richards
and strays of verse without the semblance of
lying English industrial history.
Another of the excellent guide-books com-
inspiration. The “ little play is diminutive
Johnson (Dr. ) and Fanny Burney: being the piled on the principle of Grant Allen's recom-
and amateurish.
