No More Learning

ferner dass nur Gott als Geist die absolute Identita? t beider Prin- zipien, aber nur dadurch und insofern ist, dass und inwiefern beide seiner Perso? nlichkeit unterworfen sind. "
98. This footnote has gathered a good deal of attention. White refers to it in his attempt to adduce evidence for his claim that Schelling is engaging in esotericism (107). More recently, Peter Warnek has argued that the note reflects Schelling's "own thematizing of the movement of the word to re- coil upon the way in which freedom comes to word" (Peter Warnek, "Reading Schelling and Heidegger: The Freedom of Cryptic Dialogue," in Schelling Now, 180). Warnek continues: "Schelling's word of freedom would therefore also have to be the ecstatic movement of freedom bring- ing itself to word; it would be life saying life in the movement of life itself. This is the promise of a 'system of freedom. '" Jason Wirth also makes the following comments on this note:
. . . Schelling expressed the dialogical genesis of everything in the text. The writer composes from a particular perspective and in me- dias res within an unfolding drama still always to be completed. This dialogical demand, this indebtedness to the treatise's subject, does not grant Schelling authority over it. This writing, within a fluid context in which the Wesen can somehow emerge, does not grant Schelling the capacity to render it with sharp determinations.
NOTESTOPAGES66-77 | 169
170 | NOTES TO PAGES 66-77
This dialogical humility knows that this is not a dialogue between equals because there is no parity among the interlocutors. The in- terlocutors are not einerlei, not of the same kind. A model of such an asymmetrical dialogue might be something like attempting to communicate with nature. Or speaking with animals, not as crea- tures to be trained for human use, but as animals per se. A more classical precedent might be Job's dialogue with the whirlwind. It is a dialogue between bodies and their animas, between the light and its concealed, indwelling darkness. It might be thought of as a di- alogue of the fractured Wesen with itself, producing discontinuities without sublimation. (Wirth, The Conspiracy of Life, 159)
99. The German here is "Finalita? t der Ursachen" or "finality of causes. " What is likely meant by this is clarified by Gutmann who translates Finalita? t by "purposiveness," thereby suggesting that Schelling is alluding to Aristo- telian teleology and, thus, the notion of a causa finalis that is the end for the sake of which (hou eneka) something happens.
100. The Latin source appears to be Horace which Schelling freely varies. Here is the original (Odes II. i):
Motum ex Metello consule civicum bellique causas et vitia et modos
ludumque fortunae gravesque principum amicitias et arma
nondum expiatis uncta cruoribus, periculosae plenum opus aleae,
tractas et incedis per ignes suppositos cineri doloso.
[In our translation: You are treating of the civil commotion under the consulship of Metellus, the causes of war, the mistakes, its phases, the game of fortune, the dire friendships among princes and the arms stained with blood--a task full of dangerous risk--and you go forth through fires hidden beneath treacherous ashes. ]
101. The section reads:
76. Let it not be objected that such rational speculations on the mysteries of religion are forbidden. --The word 'mystery', in early Christian times, meant something quite different from what we understand by it now; and the development of revealed truths into truths of reason is absolutely necessary if they are to be of any help to the human race. When they were revealed, of course, they were not yet truths of reason; but they were revealed in order to become such truths. They were, so to speak, the result of the calculation which the mathematics teacher announces in advance, in order to give his pupils some idea of what they are working towards. If the pupils were satisfied with knowing the result in advance, they
would never learn to calculate, and would frustrate the intention with which the good master gave them a guideline to help them with their work. (G. E. Lessing, Philosophical and Theological Writ- ings, trans. H. B. Nisbet [Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 2005], 236)
102. This is an allusion to Herder's philosophy of history and, more specifi- cally, to his theory about the origin and development of Christianity as outlined, for example, in his Ideas for the Philosophy of History of Mankind (Ideen zur Philosophie der Geschichte der Menschheit). In that work, Herder insists that Christianity, just as all religions, including those of the pagan cultures, must be traced back to an original religion [Urrelig- ion] and that the very idea of religion has always been a primary fact of human life. (See 9, V. "Religion Is the Oldest and Holiest Tradition of the Earth," in Johann Gottfried Herder, Ideen zur Philosophie der Geschichte der Menschheit, ed. Martin Bollacher [Frankfurt a. M. : Deutscher Klas- siker Verlag, 1989], 372-379. )
103. This alludes to Goethe's famous bon mot mentioned at the end of Baader's essay "On the Assertion that There Can Be No Wicked Use of Reason. " See that essay in this volume.
104. The essay by Baader noted here is called "On the Analogy between the Drive to Know and to Procreate" (U? ber die Analogie des Erkenntnis- und des Zeugungs-Triebes). See Franz Xaver von Baader, Sa? mmtliche Werke, ed. F. Hoffmann, vol. 1 (Aalen: Scientia Verlag [Reprint], 1963), 39-48.
105. According to Buchheim, this idea was prevalent in theosophic literature and, of course, in Boehme (Buchheim, PU 167, n372-373).
106. This is likely another reference to Schlegel and his Indierbuch (see note 7 above).
SUPPLEMENTARY TEXTS
Introductory Note
1. For an extensive treatment of the relation between Schelling and Boehme, see Robert F. Brown, The Later Philosophy of Schelling: The Influ- ence of Boehme on the Works of 1809-1815 (Lewisburg: Bucknell Univer- sity Press, 1977).
2. For a broad overview of the Pantheism debate, see Frederick Beiser, The Fate of Reason: German Philosophy from Kant to Fichte (Cambridge, Mass. : Harvard UP, 1987).
3. In this respect, see Wirth, The Conspiracy of Life, 65-100.
Boehme
1. Jakob Bo? hme, Sa? mtliche Schriften, ed. Will-Erich Peukert, vol 4 (Stuttgart: Frohmann-Holzboog [Reprint], 1955-1960), 97-111.
Baader
1. Franz Xaver von Baader, Sa? mmtliche Werke, 33-38. 2. "Evil is not a story, it's a power. "
NOTESTOPAGES81-130 | 171
172 | NOTES TO PAGES 81-130
Lessing
1. Gotthold Ephraim Lessing, Werke, ed. Herbert G. Go? pfert, vol. VIII (Mu- nich: Hanser Verlag, 1979), 118-120.
Jacobi
1. The translation follows Friedrich Heinrich Jacobi, U? ber die Lehre des Spi- noza in Briefen an den Herrn Moses Mendelssohn, ed. Marion Lauschke (Hamburg: Felix Meiner Verlag, 2000), 23-36 and Lessing, Werke VIII, 565- 571. As to the former, we have attempted to follow as closely as possible the various forms of emphasis in the text.
2. En-Sof [Heb: "that which has no end/the infinite"] refers to the notion of a hidden or absent God, a deus absconditus, without name and form which is the ground of all beings. The term developed into a central con- cept in the Kabbalistic philosophy of the Middle Ages. (See Go? bel, "En- soph," Lessing, Werke VIII, 751 and Gershom Scholem, Major Trends in Jewish Mysticism [New York: Schocken Books, 1946], 269-273. )
3. salto mortale [literally, "by means of a fatal leap," in which a person turns head over heels in the air, e. g. , somersault].
4. This term comes from section 47 of the Monadology, which reads as fol- lows: "Accordingly, God alone is the primary unity or the original simple substance, of which all the created or derivative monads are products. They originate, so to speak, through continual fulgurations of the divin- ity from moment to moment, limited by the receptivity of the created being, to which it is essential to be limited . . . " See Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, Monadology, ed. and trans. Nicholas Rescher (Pittsburgh: Uni- versity of Pittsburgh Press, 1991), 162.
5. Jacobi likely refers here to a Latin translation of Principes de la nature et de la grace fonde? s en raison.
6. Jacobi is referring to the "Confession of Augsburg" by Melanchthon, Lu- ther, and other theologians that was submitted to the emperor during the Reichstag of Augsburg in 1530. This "Confession" continued to incite fierce disputes between orthodox and reformed Lutherans thereafter. (See Go? bel, "Augsburgische Konfession," Lessing, Werke VII, 739. )
7. Jacobi's salto mortale is paired with a play on Kopf [head, intellect] here. The implication is that one must humble one's intellect before this leap, which has no use for it; a leap which, in other words, represents a subor- dination of reason to faith.
8. The text follows Jacobi, U? ber die Lehre des Spinoza, 166-167. As before, we have attempted to follow closely the various forms of emphasis in the text.
9. Jacobi is referring to Voltaire's tragedy Mahomet or Le fanatisme ou Ma- homet le Prophe`te (1743).
Herder
1. Johann Gottfried Herder, Sa? mtliche Werke, ed. B. Suphan, vol. 16 (Berlin: Weidmann, 1881-1913), 552-560.
Index
Page numbers in italics refer to the supplementary texts and the notes to them.
absolute: accession to, xiii; bond, 59; causality, 11; dualism of good and evil, 74; existence, 59; freedom, 50; and the I, 3, 10, 23; identity, 3, 27, 28, 68 (of light and darkness), 71 (of ground and existence, of good and evil), 148n32; indifference, 68, 76; in the, 168nn93, 95; knowledge, xxvii; necessity, 60, 61; personal- ity, 62; self-realization of, xii, xiii, xiv; self-revelation of, xx; sub- stance, 23; unity, 40, 49; utterly groundless, 52
actuality, 26, 62, 67, 120, 148n32; pos- sibility and, 58, 61, 145n26, 158n60; potency and, 44, 54, 70; potentiality and, 66, 75; and the re- versed god, 54
abstraction, 20, 58, 60
Adorno, Theodor W. (1903-1969),
133n16
Adams, Robert M. , 160n69 Alfonso X, King of Castile
(1221-1284), 167n87
anarchy, xxxiii, 29, 30, 62, 151n40 animal(s): becoming, 40, 100; of Buri-
dan, 48; and consciousness, 133n15; dark principle in, 40; in- stinct, 39, 40, 76; soul of, 124; sur- render to, 101; understanding of, 99; and unity, 40
animality, 39
Antoninus Pius (86-161 C. E. ), 121 Apollodorus of Athens (b. ca. 180
B. C. E. ), 143n22 Aphrodite (Venus), 143n22
Archaeus, 154n52
Arians (Arianism), 39, 157n57 Aristotle (384-322 B. C. E. ), xxxiii,
140n13, 147n32, 155n53
Arius (256-336 C. E. ), 194n57
ataxia, 38
atheism, 19, 83, 136n1
atomic swerve, 48, 159n67 Augustine of Hippo, Saint (354-430),
36-37
autonomy, xvi, xvii, xviii, xix, 142n18
Baader, Franz Xaver (1765-1841), 35, 40, 43, 75, 81-82, 158m57, 171nn103, 104, 171n1
Bayle, Pierre (1647-1706), 154n53, 155n55, 167n86
Beach, Edward, 144n26, 158n60 Beauvoir, Simone de (1908-1986),
xxii, 134n32
becoming, x, 17, 28, 51, 59, 66,
150n36, 152n45; animal, 40, 100;
real, 54, 60
Being, 17, 24, 50, 51, 70, 148n32; ab-
solute causality and, 11; of abso- lute identity, 27, 28; and becoming, 66; in God, 72; ground of, 18; in the ground, 72; human, 53; jointure of, xxv; and mechanistic laws, 120; and non-Being, 35; primal, 21, 143n24; as self, 38; and sin, 55, 56; and translation of, xxxiii, xxxiv; and what does not have, 67; and will, 21, 53, 143n24
beings in the world, xxxii, 11, 18, 20, 23, 25
174 | INDEX
Beiser, Frederick, 171n2 Bernstein, Richard, x, 131n3,
133nn14, 18
Bilfinger, Georg Bernhard
(1693-1750), 112
Blumenberg, Hans (1920-1996), xi,
132n8
Bo? ckh, Philipp August (1785-1867), 41 Boehme, Jacob (1575-1624), 81,
142n18, 147n31, 150n37, 153n50, 157n56, 159n63, 168n92, 171n105, 171n1
body, 13, 31, 67, 96, 109, 154n53; of the animal, 156n55; as appear- ance, 125; concept of, 14; eyes of, 115; internal selfhood of, 38; ma- ternal, 29; part, 18; passions of, xxiii; of previous world, 45; real- ism as, 26; root of cold in, 63; soul and, 14; transparent, 33
bond, 31, 56; of creaturely existence, 55; of forces, 31, 34, 40, 43, 54; of gravity, 30; of principles, 41, 42, 56, 59; of love, 45, 55; of personality, 75
Bowie, Andrew, 158n60 Breazeale, Daniel, 144n25
Brown, Robert F. , 133n15, 171n1 Bruno, Giordano (1548-1600), 14,
140n13
Buchheim, Thomas, xxxv, 135n4,
139n9, 140n13, 143n23, 150nn33, 38, 151n43, 153n50, 154n52, 157n56, 158n59, 166nn81, 84, 167n88, 171n105
Buridan, Jean (ca. 1300-1358), 48, 159n66, 162n71
Cassirer, Ernst (1874-1945), 132n7 categorical imperative, xvii, xxiii, 57 Cato, M. Porcius "the younger" or
"Uticensis" (95-46 B. C. E. ), 57,
166n84
causality, 11, 141n14
centrum, 33, 55, 64, 65, 88, 159n64,
163n75; basis or, 44; and beginning of the creation, 51; dark, 35; and
dark principle, 40; as essence of willing, 47; and God, 72; initial, 42; of nature, 34; of particular wills, 32; revealed, 37; of a yearning, 42
cosmourgos, 144n24 cosmotheoros, 138n6
chaos, xx, 42, 45, 128, 155n53; and
nonrational ground, 145n26, 151n40; offspring of, 65; primor- dial, 152n47; struggle against, 46
conscientiousness, 56-57 consequence: in relation to Spinozan
substance, 12, 16-18, 20, 141n14,
149n32
contingency, xxii, xxv, xxvi, 48-49,
50, 52
contraction, xx, xxi, xxii, xxviii,
xxxiii, 110, 149n32, 150n32 copula, 13, 14, 139n10
creation: accomplished, 91, 92; as
act, 60, 65; actual, 62; and connec- tion, 128; and evil, xxiv, 40, 53, 58; final purpose of, 66-67; first, 42-44, 47, 51, 52, 53, 68; and fury, 89; and God, x, 46, 149n32, 155n53; ground of, 55; hate and love in, 127; and initial ground of nature, 45; and identity, xix; hierarchy of, xxi; and King Alfonso X, 167n86; from nothingness, 40; process of, 31; rationality of, xi; ever-renewed, 11; second, 46; and struggle, xxviii; and the universe, 123; of the world, 90, 110; as yearning of the One, 59-60
creature(s), xvii, xxii, 23, 29, 34, 55, 88, 90-92, 99; and dark principle in, 43; and evil, 42; free will in, 159n67; God and, 146n27; for human use, 170n98; imperfection of, 36-37, 155n53; and nothing- ness, 40; self-will of, 32-33, 42, 47
Crocker, Lester G. , 143n20
d'Holbach, Paul-Henri Thiry (1723-1789), 142n20
darkness, 30, 37, 41, 46, 65-70, 90, 93, 156n55, 170n98; and ground, xx-xxi, 29-33, 62, 151n40, 152n47; and light, xx, 35, 42, 44, 55, 66, 113, 165n78; principle of, 44, 156n55
depths, 45, 47, 56; and ground, 30-32, 34
Derrida, Jacques (1930-2004), 161n70
Descartes, Rene? (1596-1650), 26 Desmond, William, 133n14 determinism, 49, 160nn68, 69 devil, 36, 64, 96, 97, 99
dialectic, xii, xiii, xiv, 14, 63, 64, 69, 75, 76, 84, 149n32
difference, xiv, 15, 169n95; between God and man, 150n32, 169n96; identity and, 47, 148n32; non-, 15; specific, 22
differentiation, xiv; and divine imagi- nation, 18, 149n32; of nature from God, 27; of things from God, 12; of understanding and will, 36
discord, 19, 35, 118; of principles, 41, 54, 56
disease, 18, 34-35, 38, 66 disharmony, 38. See ataxia dissonance, x, xxv, xxviii, 150n32 distemperance, 38, 157n56 Dostoevsky, F. M. (1821-1881),
152n44
drive, xiv, 43, 75, 76, 99, 101, 116,
117-119, 122-123
dualism, 24, 30, 68, 71, 74, 146n27; Kantian, xii
Eliot, T. S. (1888-1965), 165n78 emanation, 18, 25, 40, 73, 146n27 Empedocles (ca. 490-430 B. C. E. ), 10,
138n8
Empiricus, Sextus (2nd Century
C. E. ), 10, 139n8
enthusiasm, 26; conscientiousness
as, 57; excesses of, xv; for the
good, 40, 100, 158n57; virtue as, 58 Epictetus (cc. 55-135), 121
Epicurus (ca. 341-270 B. C. E. ), 48 Erasmus of Rotterdam, Desiderius
(1466-1536), 71
essence: of absolute identity and
gravity, 27, 148n32; of acting indi- vidual, 49-53, 160n70, 165n78; of the body, 154n53; conceptual pri- ority of, 29; of fury, 90; of God, xiv, xix, xxxv, 30, 60, 62; and ground, 151n41, 152n47; of human corrupt- ness, 99; of the human soul, 16, 29, 38, 41, 112; and inner necessity, 49; of intelligible being, 49-50; life-, 87; of the moral world, 14; of nature, 31, 89; and positive and negative philosophy, 144n26; of reason and knowledge, 10; revealing itself in its opposite, 41; of things-in- themselves, 22; of willing, 47; of yearning, 29
estrangement, 25, 146n27 eternity, 66, 87, 88-90, 92-93; and
eternal beginning, 51-53. See
predestination
Euclid of Alexandria (ca. 325-265
B. C. E. ), 58
existence, xi, xxxiv, 29, 43, 65, 67,
109, 116, 125, 166n80; absolute, 59; of beings, 11, 25; cause of, 145n26; creaturely, 63; and essence, xxxiv; and evil, xi, xii, 154n53; and God, xxi, xxii, xxv-xxvi, xxxv, 11, 30, 45, 55, 62, 63, 124, 139n10; and ground, xx, xxv, xxviii, xxxiii, xxxiv, 27, 44, 66, 70, 71, 84, 141n14, 147n32, 149n32, 150nn32, 34; medi- ated, 119; personal, 62, 70, 117; ra- tional, 117-118; of spirit, 122
expansion: and contraction, xx, xxviii, xxxiii, 110, 149n32; of forces, 30
evil: and the absolute, xiii; aroused in creation, 53; fundamental being of, 24, 41, 73; and chaos, 42; and cognition, xiii; as conditio sine qua non, 65; dark principle of, 53; and
INDEX | 175
176 | INDEX
evil (continued)
emanation, 25, 73; end of, 66-68; and finitude, 38; and freedom, ix, xxv, 23, 24, 52; general, 47, 53; ground of, 36, 37, 39; matter and, 25; metaphysical, xi, xxiv, 36; ori- gin of, 26, 36, 42, 63; passions and, 53; as lower degree of perfec- tion, 24; as perversion, xvii, xxii, 35, 38, 44, 54-55, 63, 64; as posi- tive force, xxiii; possibility of, 33-40, 54-58, 62, 165n79; as pri- mal ground, 44; principle of, 36, 53, 64, 65, 155n53; privative no- tion of, xi-xiv, 23-25; as produc- tive, xiii; propensity to, xvi, xviii, 47, 52; radical, x, xv-xix, xxiii, 53, 166n79; reality of, 23, 33, 39-48; and search to become a god, xxvii; self-will and, 34; solicitation to, 41; and spirit, 40, 44, 46; and system, xii, xxix; temptation to, 41; threefold distinction of, xi; and the understanding, 36; unity severable in man and, 33, 42
fatalism, 11, 20, 108, 114
feeling, 11, 12, 19, 21, 22, 29, 55, 75,
122; of having strayed from the centrum, 55; and compulsion, 59; and disease, 35; of eternal begin- ning (of each individual), 51; of freedom, 9, 11, 17, 111, 121; of honor, 121; moral, 75; philoso- phers of, 56; of reality, 125
fever, 56
Fichte, Johann Gottlieb (1762-1814),
3, 10, 20, 22, 29, 50, 53, 59, 136n1, 137n2, 138n6, 161n70; Doctrine of Science, 139n9; Die Grundzu? ge des gegenwa? rtigen Zeitalters, U? ber das Wesen des Gelehrten, Anweisung zum seligen Leben, 151n43; System der Sittenlehre, 166n79
finitude, 38, 40, 109, 168n93 Frank, Manfred, ix, 131n1
freedom: absolute, 50; and the ani- mal, 100; as Being-in-God, 72; as capacity for good and evil, 23; of choice, 61; concept of, 9-10, 17, 21, 23, 48, 162n71; and contin- gency, 49; disease and, 34; and the eternal, 18; within God, 145n27; and idealism, 49-53; and imma- nence, 23-25; as incompatible with system, 9, 138n7; and the "Kantian paradox," xviii; loss of in- itial, 56; and necessity, xix, xxvi, 4, 10, 50, 56, 143n23, 161n70, 163n73; and pantheism, 16-19; and per- sonality, 10; as one and all of phi- losophy, 22; problem of, ix-xxvi; and propensity to evil, xviii, 52; as rule of the intelligent principle over sensual desires, 39; as self- activity, 120; and system, 9-11, 49; as unlimited power, 11; and the will, xvi-xix, 4, 47
Fuhrmans, Horst, 138n7
Gadamer, Hans-Georg (1900-2002), 161n70
Gabler, Christian (1770-1821), 137n5 God: as absolute identity, 71; and
antichrist, 97-98; as author, 142n18; and Babel, 94; as cogni- tion of spiritual light, 56; and col- ors, 92-93; and creation, 46; the devil and, 54, 96; and emanation, 40; as eternal love, 54; existence of, 3, 27, 124, 145n26, 149n32, 152n47; as expansion and contrac- tion, 110; eye of soul and, 115; freedom within, 145n27; free will of, 64, 94-95, 97; as general law, 60; and ground, xxi-xxii, 20, 27-29, 42, 45, 46, 61, 63; God begotten in, 30; hidden, 172n2; homology with human beings, xxvi, xxvii; imma- nence of things in, 11-26, 72, 139n10; inseverability (or indissol- ubility) of principles in, xxiv, 33,
41, 153n51; Kantian autonomy and, xvi-xix, 134n30; Leibniz's concept of, xiv, 154n53, 168n91; as a life, 66-68; as living unity of forces, 59; man in, 72; and matter, 41; as moral being, 60; and nature, 59; and necessity, xxi, xxvi, 61, 168n93; perfection of creation and, 61; and personality, 59, 62, 73; of the philosophers, xiii-xiv, xv, xxvii; point of view of, xiii, xv; and predestination, 52, 165n78; presci- ence of, 52; as primum passivum, 76; as principle of pure form and intelligibility, xx; and privation theory of evil, 36-37; and the pro- claimed word, 32; as real, 47; rep- resentation of, 30-32; self- revelation of, xx, 47, 58, 59, 60, 65; reversed, 54; separation of man from, 33; separation of things from, 31; sin and, 55; as spirit, 47, 59, 71, 86-88, 92, 122; theodicy and, ix-xxix, 58-66; as unity of light and darkness, 32-33; as unity of possibility and actuality, 61
Go? bel, Helmut, 172nn2, 6 Goethe, Johann Wolfgang
(1749-1832), xiii, xviii, 83, 102,
133n13, 171n103 Goeze, Johann Melchior
(1717-1786), 81, 83
golden age, 45, 159n62
Graves, Robert (1895-1985), 147n30 gravity, 125-126, 128; and light,
27-28, 30, 147n32; of the planets,
156n55
ground: ambiguity of, 152n47; as an-
archic, xxv, 29, 62; attractive force of, 46, 66; and becoming of things, 28; beginning-, 107; of the birth of spirit (second principle of dark- ness), 44; and consequence, 17-18; and the dark principle, 31-33, 44, 66; and desire, 43; di- vided, 31; and disease, 34; and ex-
istence, xx, xxv, xxviii, 27, 141n14, 147n32; and essence, 151n41; and/of evil, 36-37, 39, 44, 47, 53, 63; and the fall, 48, 55; force active in, 40; freedom as, 22, 26; and God, xxi-xxii, 20, 27, 28, 42, 45, 61, 63; and the good, 68; and gravity, 27-28, 30; and the ideal principle, 59; and the indivisible remainder, 29; of magia, 85; man as emerging from, 32; meaning of, 134n28, 145n26; of nature, 27, 34, 39, 44, 45, 70; and the non-ground, 69-70; and personality, 75; perversion of relation to existence, xxii; primal, 66; principle of evil and, 64, 65; re- alism and, 26; of selfhood, 70; self- positing and, 51; and self-will, 33-34; and sin, 55; and solicitation, 41, 63; and the understanding, 36; and unity, 45; will of, 42, 45, 47, 59, 63, 66-67; and the yearning, 30, 72
Gutmann, James, xxxiii, 142n18, 151nn39, 40, 165n77, 170n99
Hamann, Johann Georg (1730-1788), 64, 83, 152n44, 167n88
harmony, xxiv, 52, 56, 126; preestab- lished, x, xi
Hayden-Roy, Priscilla, 135n1, 151n39 Hegel, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich
(1770-1831), x, xii-xv, xviii, xxv, 81, 133nn13, 14, 143n24, 146n27, 163n72; Lectures on the Philosophy of Religion, xiii, 133n15; Lectures on the Philosophy of World History, xii, 132n11; Phenomenology of Spirit, 133n12, 138n6, 168n95
Heraclitus (535-475 B. C. E. ), 149n32 Herder, Johann Gottfried
(1744-1803), 82, 83, 84, 171n102 Hermanni, Friedrich, 131nn2, 10,
134nn35, 37, 153n51,
Heidegger, Martin (1889-1976), ix, xi,
xxv-xxvi, xxviii, xxxii, 161n70, 163n75, 165n78; The Metaphysical
INDEX | 177
178 | INDEX
Heidegger (continued)
Foundations of Logic, 132n7, 140n13; Plato's Sophist, 153n49; The Principle of Reason, 132n9; Schelling's Treatise on the Essence of Human Freedom, ix, xxv, 131nn1, 4, 134n36, 137nn1, 6, 162n71
Hesiod (ca. 700 B. C. E. ), 159n52 Horace, or Quintus Horatius Flaccus
(65-27 B. C. E. ), 151n42, 170n100 Horkheimer, Max (1895-1973), 133n16 Hogrebe, Wolfram, 164n76
idealism, ix, 3, 17, 20-23, 26, 49, 59; science and, 137n6; transcenden- tal, 161n70; destruction of, 165n78
identity, xix, 117, 118, 152n47; abso- lute, 27-28, 68, 69, 70, 71, 76, 147n32; as absolute indifference, 68; and difference, 47; empty, 139n10; and essence, xxxiv; of evil, 64; between God and beings, 25; between God and human beings, xxvi, 169n96; the I as, 3; innate, 165n78; law of, 13-17, 50, 140n13; of light and darkness, 32-33, 68, 70; mechanism and spirit, 4; philo- sophy of, 136n1, 168n95; of subjec- tive and objective, 144n24, 161n70
immanence: of things in God, 11-26, 72, 139n10
indifference: of existence and ground, xxii; as form of freedom, 162n71; and God, 24; and the non- ground, xxviii, 68-70, 73, 76; and philosophy of identity, 168n95; point of, 127, 129, 130
individuality, 15, 16, 21, 35, 47, 53 infinity, 62, 107, 159n67 imagination: divine, 18; as origin of
good and evil, 88-90; of peoples, 43; philosophical, xiv; and sin, 54-55; will and, 87
Jacobi, Friedrich Heinrich (1743-1819), 82, 83, 100, 136n1,
138n7, 141n15, 143n21, 161n70,
166nn81, 82
Jacobs, Wilhelm G. , 132n11 Jesus Christ, 51, 68, 98, 157n57 Judas, 51, 164n76
Juvenal (1st-2nd C. E. ), 160n68
Kant, Immanuel (1724-1804), ix, x, xii, xv-xix, xxiii-xxiv, xxvii, xxxii, 4, 22, 49, 53, 58, 83, 134nn26, 30, 138n6, 140n13, 142n19, 145n26, 146n27, 161n70, 166n79; Critique of Pure Reason, 141n16, 147n29; Metaphysical Foundations of Natu- ral Science, 137n4; Religion within the Boundaries of Mere Reason, 160n68
Kepler, Johannes (1571-1630), 37, 155n53, 156n55
Kierkegaard, Soren Aabye (1813-1855), 161n70
Kru?
ll, Philipp, 135n1
La Mettrie, Julien Offray de (1709-1751), 142n20
Laurence, Joseph, 131n3, 134nn24, 34
Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm (1646-1716), x, xi-xii, xiii-xiv, xv, xxv, 14, 16-17, 26, 36, 37, 49, 60, 61, 65, 81, 107, 110-112, 132n7, 140n13, 141n15, 160n69, 172n4; Es- says on Theodicy, 154n53, 156n55, 160n69, 168n91; Opuscules et frag- ments ine? dits, 140n13
Lessing, Ephraim Gotthold (1729-1781), 74, 81, 82-83, 171n101
light: gravity and, 27-28, 30, 147n32; principle of, 33, 150n32
Lo? with, Karl (1897-1973), 133n13 logic, 14, 140n13, 157n55, 161n70; of
the enigma, 28
logos, xiv, xx; and Arianism, 157n57,
159n63; being of God, xxi Long, A. A. , 159n67
love, 55, 60, 62, 64, 65, 68, 75, 95; bond of, 45, 55; divine, 58, 67; eter- nal, 169n96; God as, 54, 61; hate and, 127-130, 138n8; human will and, 63; inner, 125; motility of, 41; as motive passion, 109; natural, 119; and the non-ground, 70; and philosophy, 76; pure, 122-123; and Pygmalion, 21, 143n22; and the spirit, 30, 34, 42, 44; of unity, 97; will of, 42, 47, 59, 70; word of, 45
Lucan, Marcus Annaeus (39-65 C. E. ), 167n84
Lucretius (ca. 99-50 B. C. E. ), 159n67 Luther, Martin (1483-1546), 51,
172n6
malum metaphysicum. See evil Mann, Thomas (1875-1955), 164n76 Marquard, Odo, 131n3, 132n11 matter, xvi, 25, 30, 33, 54, 146n28; dy-
namism of, 137n4; imperfection of, 38, 155n53; inertia of, 37; Kant's dynamic theory of, 137n4; mag- netic, 111; Platonic, 30, 41; primal, 107; and spirit, 112
Maximilian I, King of Bavaria (1756-1825), 137n3
mechanism, 4, 14, 108, 118, 119, 120, 122
Melanchthon, Philipp (1497-1560),
172n6
Melissus of Samos (ca. 5th Century B. C. E. ), 155n55
Michalson, Jr. , Gordon E. , 133nn18, 20, 134n25
modification(s), 73; desire and, 116, 118; of substance, 12, 16, 20, 26, 140n14
Moiso, Francesco, 157n56
monads, 16, 110, 172n4 monotheletes (monotheletism), 39,
157n57
morality, 56-58, 64, 168n93; and radi-
cal evil, xv
mysticism, 81, 121
Nabokov, V. V. (1899-1977), xxxi nature, 18, 21, 22, 24, 42, 64, 71, 108;
anarchy of, 30, 44; -being, 88; blind, 145n26; divine, 61, 158n57; drop-forming principium in, 126; essence of, 31; eternal, 89-90, 92; and European philosophy, 26; and evil, 43; as first (or old) Testa- ment, 72; forces of, 14; and God, 26, 27, 59, 65, 72, 87, 122; and ground, 30, 34, 37, 39, 44, 45-46, 70, 147n32; human, 53, 120, 158n57; as lying beyond absolute identity, 28; -language, 92-93, 95; law(s) of, 60, 123, 125, 127-129, 154n53, 156n55; -life, 88-89; life in, 57; magia of, 96; man and, 161n70; mastery of, xiv, xxvii; mathematics and, 132n7; mechanistic and dy- namic notions of, 20, 21, 142n20; and the moral world, 14; as older revelation, 77; personality and, 59; philosophy of, xx, 4, 10, 21, 27, 31, 84, 136n1, 137n5; science of, 43; and spirit, 4, 85-86; stirring life of the craving as, 86; and the subject, 151n43; and the turba, 91; typology in, 73; the understanding and, 30, 31; and unnature, 101; and the veil of dejection, 62-63; and will, 32, 33, 34
necessity, 11, 19, 50, 51, 164n76; ab- solute, 50, 60, 61; abstract, 60; and contingency, xxvi; of death, 48, 67; divine, xxi, xxv, 57, 168n93; empiri- cal, 49, 50; of evil, 25, 39, 146n28; and freedom, xix, xxvi, 4, 10, 50, 56, 143n23, 161n70; geometric, 43, 59; higher, 49; holy, 56, 129; hypo- thetical, 168n91; inner, 49, 50, 148n32; laws of, 163n73; logical, 58, 15n53; mechanical, 59; meta- physical, 61, 154n53; moral, 61; of sin, 48; unconscious, 58
Neiman, Susan, 133n18, 135n39, 167n86
INDEX | 179
180 | INDEX
Niethammer, Friedrich Immanuel (1766-1848), 3, 137n2
Nietzsche, Friedrich Wilhelm (1844-1900), x, 134n38, 146n27
non-ground [der Ungrund], 68-70, 73, 81, 85, 87, 88
Norman, Judith, xxxv, 131n3, 135n3, 151n39
nothingness, xi, xx, xxi, 16, 40, 69,
125
Oetinger, Friedrich Christoph (1702-1782), 157n56
omnipotence, xi, 11-12, 41, 42, 45, 146n27; of the will, 86, 87, 120, 121
opposition: being and, 66; of good and evil, 24, 25, 38, 44, 46, 58, 71; and ground, 42; indifference and, 69; to love, 65; of nature and spirit, 4; of necessity and freedom, 4; overcoming of, 77, 169n95; and self-will, 64; of sin, 55; of subject and object, 3; and unity, 14
Origen (ca. 182-251 C. E. ), 167n88 Ovid (43 B. C. E. -17 C. E. ), 143n22,
159n62
pandemonism, 25
pantheism, 11-12, 15-17, 19-23, 25,
27, 71; Pantheism debate [Pan- theismusstreit], 82-84, 143n21, 171n2; as immanence of things in God, 139n10
Paracelsus, or Philip Theophrastus Bombast von Hohenheim (1493-1541), 154n52
participation, 23, 67, 146n27 Paterclus, Velleius (ca. 19 B. C. E. -31
C. E. ), 166n84
Peetz, Siegbert, 138n7, 143n21 Pelikan, Jarolslav, 157n57 periphery, 33, 34, 35, 43, 47. See
centrum
personality, 4, 10, 33, 74, 75, 110; ab-
solute, 62; concept of, 38, 73, 142n18; God as, 59-60, 66, 71, 73;
and man, 62; spirit and, 66, 75 Pinkard, Terry, 134n26
Pippin, Robert, 133n19, 134n26,
161n70
Plato (427-347 B. C. E. ), 10, 14, 30, 39,
41, 142n19, 151n39, 153n49, 155n53, 167n88; Theaetetus 153n48; Timaeus, 44, 138n8, 152n45, 166n80
Plotinus (ca. 205-270 C. E. ), 25, 146n28
possibility: and actuality, 61, 158n60; bare, 144n26; concept of, 61; empty, 61; of evil, 33, 36, 40, 54, 58, 62, 169n79; of good and evil, 33, 153n51; of immediate cognition, 76-77; of salvation, 46; of several worlds, 62
potency, 28, 44, 54, 62, 63, 67, 70, 148n32
predeterminism, 160n68 predestination, 52, 165n78 principles: absolute identity of, 71;
in discord, 54, 56; existence and ground, xxii; good and evil, 54; lig- ature of, 56; light and darkness, 32-34, 40-42, 69; and personality, 75; perversion of, 35-36; severabil- ity of, 33; unity of, 40, 41, 66, 68, 70; universal, xxiii
Pygmalion, 21, 143n22 Pythagoras of Samos (582-507
B. C. E. ), 10, 138n8
radical evil. See evil
Raphael or Raffaello (1483-1520),
108
ratio, xiv, xx, 112
realism, 21, 22, 23, 26, 59 reason: absence of, 102; and ani-
mals, 99; authority of, xv, 82-83; and Babel, 95; and choice, 160n69; and contingency, 48; despair of, 24; as essence of spiritual nature, 4; and evil, 25; God and, 92; human, xiv, 122, 157n55; as indif-
ference, 76; and language, 92, 94; non-, 74; nothing is without, xi; practical, 118, 119; as primum pas- sivum, 76; pure, 39, 59, 75, 122; re- nouncing, 11, 26; and revelation, 81-83; as self-activity, 120; -spirit, 97; as striving for unity, 10; subor- dination of, xxiii; system of, 11, 19, 20, 21, 75, 172n7; truths of, 74, 140n13, 170n101; universality of, xvii, xxiii; and unreason, 101
Reinhold, Karl Leonhard (1757-1823), 14
religion, 43, 66, 74, 76, 77, 94-95, 122; mysteries of, 170n101; original re- ligion, 171n102; philosophy of, 145n26
religiosity, 56, 57
revelation: end of, 67; and evil, 44;
evil necessary for, 41; of God, xx-xxi, 18, 29, 47, 54, 58-60, 65, 168n93; and ground, 42, 45, 53; of the ideal, 35; of love, 41; and man, 44; older, 77; periods of, 66; and reason, 81-83, 154n53; of the whole, xxii
Rosen, Stanley, 134n26, 153n49 Rousseau, Jean-Jacques
(1712-1778), 156n77
Sade, Donatien Alphonse Franc? ois de (1740-1814), xvi, xxii-xxiii, 133n21, 134n32
salto mortale, 83, 108, 115, 172nn3, 7
Schelling, Friedrich Wilhelm Joseph (1775-1854): and Kant, 137n4, 145n26, 160n68, 166n79; and Ja- cobi, 138n7, 143n21; and Leibniz, 140n13; and Boehme, 142n18, 147n31, 153n50, 157n56, 171n1; and Baader, 158n57; Ages of the World, xxviii, xxxv, 135n41, 135nn2, 3, 151n39, 164n76; "Aphorisms on Natural Philosophy," 70, 169n96; First Outline of a System of the Phi- losophy of Nature, 134n27; Ideas for
a Philosophy of Nature, 134n27, 137n4; Journal for Speculative Physics, 4, 27, 137n5; Philosophy and Religion, 4, 67, 72, 168n93; Presentation of My System of Philo- sophy, 134n27, 136n1, 147n32, 150n34; System of Transcendental Idealism, 143n23
Schlegel, Friedrich (1772-1829), 11, 20, 23, 57, 71, 138n7, 166n82, 171n106
Scholem, Gershom (1897-1982),
172n2
Schopenhauer, Arthur (1788-1860), x, xxiii-xxiv, 163n73
Schulte, Christoph, 134n35
Schulz, Walter, ix, 131n1
science, 10, 26, 27, 45, 57, 74, 75, 76,
77, 112; faith in, xv; of nature, 43; notion of pertinent to German Idealism, 137n6
selfhood, 48, 54, 55, 67, 75; activated, 63; aroused, 63; dark ground of, 70; and dark principle, 56; of the ideas, 168n93; and personality, 62; as principle of evil, 64
self-will, 43; arousal of, 64; of/in crea- tures, 32, 42, 47; elevation of (as evil), 34; of/in man, 33, 54; misuse of, 55; and selfhood, 33, 55
sin, 34, 54, 55, 102; beginning of, 55; God as cause of, 37; necessity of, 48; original, 53; as renunciation of good, 63; unconsciousness about, 45
Snow, Dale E. , 135n40, 142n18, 144n24, 147n32, 163n76
solicitation: to evil, 4, 63; ground of, 41; toward revelation, 102
soul, 14, 16, 18, 31, 111, 115, 121; of the animal, 124; beautiful, 57; as bond, 31; of M. Cato, 57; essence of, 112; of hate, 64; immortality of, 122; as living identity (of princi- ples), 32; of philosophy, 26; sec- ond, 109; -spirit, 97
INDEX | 181
182 | INDEX
Spinoza, Baruch (1632-1677), xiv, 12, 13, 14-15, 24, 26, 27, 59, 83-84, 107, 108-109, 115, 125, 141nn14, 15, 159n66, 163n72, 172n1; Ethics, 16, 111-114, 122, 140n14, 159n66
Spinozism, 16, 19-21, 61, 71, 106, 110-111, 141n15; and pantheism, 83
spirit: as absolute identity, 70, 71; as activity, 76; astral, 97; birth of, 44; of dissension, 34; eternal, 30, 32, 87; and/of evil, 44, 46, 53, 54, 56, 100, 101, 165n79; and freedom, 43, 96; and/as God, 32-33, 41, 42, 47, 59, 71, 92, 93, 95; good, 54; and ground, 147n32; guardian, 54; -life, 88-89; light of, 46; of love, 34, 42, 44, 45, 68; and matter, 112; nature and, 4; and non-ground, 87; and personality, 59, 75; of pride, 57; realm of, xii; selfhood and/as, 33, 38, 40; and Spinozism, 21; thinking, xxii; and understanding, 122; as unifying, 66; of unity, 95; word of, 87; and will, 85-87; willing of, 10; yearning of, 30
spontaneity, xvii, xix
subject: autonomy of, xvii, 160n68,
161n70; identity with predicate, 13, 14, 17, 139n10, 140n13, 142n17; knowing, 151n43; masculine, xxxv; and object, 3, 161n70
substance, 15, 16, 40, 87, 109, 112, 140n14, 155n55; absolute, 10, 23; infinite, 16, 20, 23; highest, 139n9; simple, 172n4
system: of absolute necessity, 60; complete, 5; creation as, xi; self- definition of, xii; and dissonance, xxv; divine understanding and, 62; of equilibrium of free will, 49, 56, 162n71; and evil, xx; evil as ser- vant of, xii; Fichtean, 4; of forces, 127, 128; freedom and, xxv, 9-11, 49; gap in, 101; Hegelian, xii-xiii; of homogeneous forces, 127; and im-
manence, 72; as abolishing indi- viduality, 15; and pantheism, 11, 19-26, 71; and persistency, 129; and personality, 73; as "negative" and "positive" philosophy, 144n26; of practical reason, 118; as having one principle, 70; rationality of, xii; of reason, 11, 19-26, 74-75; of Spinoza, 109; Spinozism and, 61; of things, 125; true, 77; world-, xi, xx
Tantalus, 35
theodicy, ix-xxix, 58-66
Tilliette, Xaver, 136n1
Tolstoy, L. N. (1828-1910), 163n73 turba, 90-92, 94-96, 98; gentium, 46,
159n63
understanding: absolute, 59; and an- archy, 65; and archetype, 76; birth of, 29-33; and blind necessity, 61; complete, 54; craving and, 86; dark principle and, 40, 41; as dialectical principle, 76; differentiating, 76; divine, 9, 10, 36, 52, 62, 154n53; drive and, 99; geometrical, 59; and ground, 75; human, 62, 114; and in- finite cause, 107; mysterium and, 93; and nothingness, 40; and prin- ciple of evil, 36, 155n53; as princi- ple in God, 36; principle of, 39; and spirit, 122; and will, 28, 86, 88, 155n53; and wisdom, 45; yearning without, 28, 42, 72
unity, xxviii, 9, 32, 56; absolute, 40, 49; in conflict, 41; contingency and, 52; and disharmony, 38; and dispersion, 46; and the dynamic, 21; finite and infinite, 14; first, 74; of forces, 59; of freedom and ne- cessity, 163n73; and God, 65-66, 172n4; inseverable in God, 33, 41, 153n51; with the good, 67; and ground, 31, 40, 45, 66-67; hidden in the ground, 30-31; of ground and existence, xxi, xxii, xxv,
150n32; and the hunger of selfish- ness, 55; with the light, 32; of light and darkness, 32, 33; love of, 97; severable in man, 33, 153n51; of man with God, 12; and multiplicity, 128; in nature, 30; necessary, 49; non-differentiation of, 15; and non- ground, 70; in opposition, 14; of possibility and actuality, 61; rea- son and, 10; and sameness, 17, 139n10; spirit of, 95; subject and predicate, 14; and substance, 109; transcendental, 107; unfathom- able, 28; with the universal will, 34; of the world, 52; and yearning, 28, 72
Vedelius, Nicolaus (1596-1642), 154n53
Veto? , Miklos, 134n24
Voltaire, or Franc? ois-Marie Arouet
(1694-1778), xiv, 172n9
Warnek, Peter, 169n98
Wesen: translation of, xxxiii-xxxv White, Alan, 147n32, 169n98
will: all-powerful, 30; and astral-
craving, 98; and Babel, 95, 96; and being, 123; no other Being than, 21, 143n24; and primal being [Ur- sein], 10, 21; blind, 32, 128; capac- ity to, 48; central, 34; and choice, 160n69; to creation, 65; of crea- tures, 33, 65; as rational desire, 117; divining, 29; as encroachment on God's order, 153n51; of equilib- rium, 111; and the eternal, 18, 86, 95; to do evil, xviii, 42, 54, 58; as fa- culty, 117; free, 49, 56, 95, 96, 109, 114, 157n57, 159n67, 162n71; free- dom of, xvi, 4, 47, 48, 49, 51, 56, 120, 162n72; general, 34, 47, 63; of God, 36, 47, 58, 62, 64, 94, 95, 96,
97, 98, 123, 145n26, 154n53; of the ground, 37, 42, 45, 47, 59, 63, 66, 67; human, 32, 33, 34, 48, 63; infi- nite cause and, 107; as insentient, 86; law of, 117; of love, 42, 47, 59, 65, 70; and magia, 88, 95; as magus, 86; of the many, xvii; mere, 85; nature and, 21, 32, 60; inner omnipotence of, 121; one, 39, 158n57; original, 34, 88; particular, 32, 33, 34, 47; pregnant, 87; primal, 23, 32, 33, 37; to power, xxiii; ra- tional, xxii; to revelation, 60; and selfhood, 33; as self-activity, 120; self-, 32, 33, 34, 42, 43, 54, 55, 64; and Spinoza, 20; as spirit, 85, 86; spirit of, 87; and the turba, 96; and understanding, 28, 32, 36; as the craving's understanding, 86; uni- versal, 32, 33, 34, 63; of wrath, 71; and yearning, 28
Wirth, Jason, xxiii, xxxiii-xxxiv, 131n6, 134nn28, 33, 135n41, 151n39, 153n50, 169n98, 171n3
Wissowatius, Andreas (1608-1678), 14
Wolff, Christian (1679-1754), 111, 141n15
Wolfson, H. A. (1887-1974), 163n72 worldview, 9, 10, 74, 137n6
Xenophanes of Colophon (ca. 570-480 B. C. E. ), 14
yearning: of the One, 28-32, 42, 59, 70, 72, 151n39
Zeno of Elea (ca. 490-430 B. C. E. ), 64 Z? iz? ek, Slavoj, ix, x, xx, xxii, xxv-xxvi,
xxviii, 131nn1, 5, 134nn29, 31,
150n32, 164n76
Zoroaster (ca. 1200 B. C. E. ), 155n55
INDEX | 183
? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? PHILOSOPHY
Philosophical Investigations into
the Essence of Human Freedom F. W. J . S c h e l l i n g
Jeff Love and Johannes Schmidt offer a fresh translation of Schelling's enigmatic and influ- ential masterpiece, widely recognized as an indispensable work of German Idealism. The text is an embarrassment of riches--both wildly adventurous and somberly prescient. Martin Heidegger claimed that it was "one of the deepest works of German and thus also of Western philosophy" and that it utterly undermined Hegel's monumental Science of Logic before the latter had even appeared in print. Schelling carefully investigates the problem of evil by building on Kant's notion of radical evil, while also developing an astonishingly original conception of freedom and personality that exerted an enormous (if subterranean) influence on the later course of European philosophy from Schopenhauer and Kierkegaard through Heidegger to important contemporary theorists like Slavoj Z ? iz ? ek.
This translation of Schelling's notoriously difficult and densely allusive work provides extensive annotations and translations of a series of texts (by Boehme, Baader, Lessing, Jacobi, and Herder), hard to find or previously unavailable in English, whose presence in the Philosophical Investigations is unmistakable and highly significant. This handy study edition of Schelling's masterpiece will prove useful for scholars and students alike.
"The unique combination of the most stringent power of conceptual thinking and of shattering references to our most intimate experiences account for the Philosophical Investigations' almost hypnotic power. It is quite simply, together with Hegel's Phenomenology of Spirit and two or three other works, one of the candidates for the greatest philosophical book ever written. " --Slavoj Z ? iz ? ek
At Clemson University, Jeff Love is Assistant Professor of German and Russian and Johannes Schmidt is Assistant Professor of German.
A volume in the SUNY series in Contemporary Continental Philosophy Dennis J. Schmidt, editor
STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK PRESS www. sunypress. edu
? ? ? ? ? ?