No More Learning

On
this, apparently his only visit to the western capital he anxiously
endeavoured to weaken the power and influence of Paganism, while he
effected reforms both in the social and municipal life of the city. Το
the stern and haughty Diocletian the familiarity of the populace had
been insufferable: Theodosius was liberal with his gifts, attended the
public games and won all hearts by his ready courtesy and genial
humanity. In the autumn of 389 he returned to Milan, and there he
remained during 390—that memorable year in which Church and State
met as opposing powers and a righteous victory lay with the Church.
In fact, he who would write of affairs of state during the last years of the
fourth century must ever go borrowing from the church historians; he
dare not at his peril omit the figure of the counsellor of Emperor after
Emperor, the fearless, tyrannous, passionate and loving bishop of Milan.
Though the conduct of Ambrose may at times be arbitrary and repellent,
the critic in his own despite admits perforce that he was a man worthy
of a sovereign's trust and confidence. The facts of the massacre of
Thessalonica are well known. Popular discontent had been aroused
by the billeting upon the inhabitants of barbarian troops, and resent-
ment sought its opportunity. Botherich, captain of the garrison,
imprisoned a favourite charioteer for gross immorality and refused to
free him at the demand of the citizens. The mob seized the occasion :
disappointed of its pleasure, it murdered Botherich with savage brutality.
The anger of Theodosius was ungovernable, and the repeated prayers
of Ambrose for mercy were of no avail. The court circle had long
been jealous of the bishop's influence and had endeavoured to exclude
him from any interference with state policy. Ambrose knew well that
he no longer enjoyed the full confidence of the Emperor. Theodosius
listened to his ministers who urged an exemplary punishment, and the
order was issued for a ruthless vengeance upon Thessalonica. The
message cancelling the imperial command arrived too late to save the
city. The Emperor had decreed retribution and his officers gave rein
to their passions. Upon the people crowded in the circus the soldiers
poured and an indiscriminate slaughter ensued ; at least 7000 victims
fell before the troops stayed their hand. Ambrose, pleading illness,
withdrew from Milan and refused to meet Theodosius. With his own
hand he wrote a private letter to the Emperor, acknowledging his zeal


## p. 245 (#275) ############################################

391–392]
Valentinian II and Arbogast
245
and love for God, but claiming that for such a crime of headlong passion
there must be profound contrition : as David listened to Nathan, so let
Theodosius hear God's minister ; until repentance he dare not offer
the sacrifice in the Emperor's presence. The letter is the appeal
of undaunted courage to the essential nobility of the character of
Theodosius. The gusts of fury passed and remorse issued in penitence.
With his subjects around him in the Cathedral of Milan the Emperor,
stripped of his royal purple, bowed himself in humility before the offended
majesty of Heaven. Men have sought to heighten the victory of the
Church and fables have clustered round the story, but the dignity of
fact in its simplicity is far more splendid than the ornate fancies of any
legend. Bishop and Emperor had proved each worthy of the other.
In 391 Theodosius returned to Constantinople by way of Thessalonica
and Valentinian was left to rule the West. He did not reach Gaul
till the autumn of 391 ; it was too late. Three years of undisputed
power had left Arbogast without a rival in Gaul. It was not the troops
alone who looked to their unconquered captain with blind admiration
and unquestioning devotion : he was surrounded by a circle of Frankish
fellow-countrymen who owed to him their promotion, while his honourable
character, his generosity and the sheer force of his personality had brought
even the civil authorities to his side. There was one law in Gaul, and
that was the will of Arbogast, there was only one superior whom
Arbogast acknowledged, and he was the Emperor Theodosius who had
given the West into his charge. From the first Valentinian's authority
was flouted : his legislative power was allowed to rust unused, his orders
were disobeyed and his palace became his prison : not even the imperial
purple could protect Harmonius, who was slain by Arbogast's orders at
the Emperor's very feet. Valentinian implored support from Theodosius
and contemplated seeking refuge in the East; he solemnly handed the
haughty Count his dismissal, but Arbogast tore the paper in pieces with
the retort that he would only receive his discharge from the Emperor who
had appointed him. A letter was despatched by Valentinian urging
Ambrose to come to him with all speed to administer the sacrament
of baptism ; clearly he thought his life was threatened. He hailed the
pretext of barbarian disturbances about the Alpine passes and himself
prepared to leave for Italy, but mortification and pride kept him still
in Vienne. The Pagan party considered that at length the influence
of Arbogast might procure for them the restoration of the altar of Victory,
but the disciple of Ambrose refused the ambassadors' request. A few
days later it was known that Valentinian had been strangled. Contem-
poraries could not determine whether he had met his death by violence
or by his own hand (15 May 392). Ambrose seems to have accepted
the latter alternative, and the guilt of Arbogast was never proven ; with
the longed-for rite of baptism so near at hand suicide certainly appears
improbable, but perhaps the strain and stress of those days of waiting
CH. VIII.


## p. 246 (#276) ############################################

246
Eugenius
(393–394
broke down the Emperor's endurance, and the mockery of his position
became too bitter for a son of Valentinian I. His death, it must be
admitted, did not find Arbogast unprepared. He could not declare
himself Emperor, for Christian hatred, Roman pride and Frankish
jealousy barred the way; thus he became the first of a long line of
barbarian king-makers : he overcame the reluctance of Eugenius and
placed him on the throne.
The first sovereign to be at once the nominee and puppet of a barbarian
general was a man of good family; formerly a teacher of rhetoric and later
a high-placed secretary in the imperial service, the friend of Richomer
and Symmachus and a peace-loving civilian—he would not endanger
Arbogast's authority. Himself a Christian, although an associate of
the Pagan aristocrats in Rome, he was unwilling to alienate the sympathies
of either party, and adopted an attitude of impartial tolerance; he
hoped to find safety in half measures. Rome saw a feverish revival of
the old faith with strange processions of oriental deities, while Flavianus,
a leading pagan, was made praetorian praefect. The altar of Victory was
restored, but Eugenius sought to respect Christian prejudices, and the
temples did not recover their confiscated revenues ; these were granted
as a personal gift to the petitioners. But in the fourth century none
save minorities would hear of toleration, and men drew the inference
that he who was no partisan was little better than a traitor. The
orthodox Church in the person of Ambrose withdrew from Eugenius
as from an apostate. The new Emperor naturally recognised Theodosius
and Arcadius as co-Augusti, but in all the transactions between the
western Court and Constantinople the person of Arbogast was discreetly
veiled; his name was not suggested for the consulship, and it was no
Frankish soldier who headed the embassy to Theodosius: the wisdom
of Athens in the person of Rufinus and the purity of Christian bishops
attested the king-maker's innocence, but the ambiguous reply of
Theodosius hardly disguised his real intentions. The nomination of
Eugenius was, it would seem, disregarded in the East, while in West and
East alike diplomacy was but a means for gaining time before the
inevitable arbitrament of war. To secure Gaul during his absence
Arbogast determined to impress the barbarians with a wholesome dread
of the power of Rome; in a winter campaign he devastated the territories
of Bructeri and Chamavi, while Alemanni and Franks were forced to
accept terms of peace whereby they agreed to furnish recruits for the
Roman armies. Thus freed from anxiety in the West, Arbogast and
Eugenius left with large reinforcements for Italy, where it seems that
the new Emperor had been acknowledged from the time of his accession
(spring 393 ? ). In the following year Theodosius marched from
Constantinople (end of May 394); Honorius, who had been created
Augustus in January 393, was left behind with Arcadius in the capital.
The Emperor appointed Timasius as general-in-chief with Stilicho for


## p. 247 (#277) ############################################

394–395]
The Battle on the Frigidus
247
his subordinate; immense preparations had been made for the campaign-
of the Goths alone some 20,000 under the leadership of Saul, Gaïnas
and Bacurius had been enlisted in the army. Arbogast, either through
the claim of kinship or as virtual ruler of the West, could bring into
the field large forces both of Franks and Gauls, but he was outnumbered
by the troops of Theodosius. Eugenius did not leave Milan till
1 August. Flavianus, as augur, declared that victory was assured; he
had himself undertaken the defence of the passes of the Julian Alps,
where he placed gilded statues of Jupiter to declare his devotion to
Paganism. Theodosius overcame all resistance with ease and Flavianus,
discouraged and ashamed, committed suicide. At about an equal
distance between Aemona and Aquileia, on the stream of the Frigidus
(Wipbach), the decisive battle took place. The Western army was
encamped in the plain, awaiting the descent of Theodosius from the
heights; Arbogast had posted Arbitio in ambush with orders to fall
upon the unsuspecting troops as they left the higher ground. The
Goths led the van and were the first to engage the enemy. Despite
their heroic valour, the attack was unsuccessful; Bacurius was slain and
10,000 Goths lost their lives. Eugenius, as he rewarded his soldiers,
considered the victory decisive, and the generals of Theodosius counselled
retreat. Through the hours of the night the Emperor prayed alone
and in the morning (6 September) with the battle-cry of “Where is
the God of Theodosius ? ” he renewed the struggle. Arbitio played the
traitor's part and leaving his hiding-place joined the Eastern army.
But it was no human aid which decided the issue of the day. A
A
tempestuous hurricane swept down upon the enemy: blinded by clouds
of dust, their shields wrenched from their grasp, their missiles carried
back upon themselves, the troops of Eugenius turned in panic flight.
Theodosius had called on God, and Heaven had answered. The moral
effect was overwhelming. Eugenius was surrendered by his own soldiers
and slain ; Arbogast fled into the mountains and two days later fell by
his own hand.
Theodosius did not abuse his victory; he granted a general pardon
-even the usurper's ministers lost only their rank and titles, which
were restored to them in the following year. But the fatigues and
hardships of the war had broken down the Emperor's health ; Honorius
was summoned from Constantinople and was present in Milan at his
father's death (17 January 395).
From the invective of heathen critics and the fattery of court
orators it is no easy task rightly to estimate the character and work
of Theodosius. To the Christians he was naturally first and foremost
the founder of an orthodox State and the scourge of heretics and pagans,
while to the worshippers of the older faith it was precisely his religious
views and the legislation inspired by them which inflamed their furious
resentment. The judgment of both parties on the Emperor's policy
CH. VIII.


## p. 248 (#278) ############################################

248
The Legislation of Theodosius I
as a whole was determined by their religious preconceptions. Rome
at least was his debtor; in the darkest hour after the disaster at
Hadrianople he had not despaired of the Empire, but had proved
himself at once statesman and general. The Goths might have become
to the provinces of the East what the Alemanni had long been to Gaul;
the fact that it was otherwise was primarily due to the diplomacy of
Theodosius. Retrenchment and economy, a breathing space in which
to recover from her utter exhaustion, were a necessity for the Roman
world; a brilliant and meteoric sovereign would have been but an added
peril. To the men of his time the unwearying caution of Theodosius
was a positive and precious virtue. His throne was supported by no
hereditary dynastic sentiment, and he thus consciously and deliberately
made a bid for public favour; he abandoned court tradition and
appealed with the directness of a soldier to the sympathies of his
subjects. In this he was justified: throughout his reign it was only
in the West that usurpers arose, and even they would have been content
to remain his colleagues, had he only consented. But this was not the
only result of his refusal to play the demigod; Valentinian had often
been perforce the tool of his ministers, but Theodosius determined
to gather his own information and to see for himself the abuses from
which the Empire suffered. His legislation is essentially detailed and
practical : the accused must not be haled off forthwith on information
laid against him, but must be given thirty days to put his house in order ;
provision is to be made for the children of the criminal, whether he be
banished or executed, for they are not to suffer for their father's sins,
and some share of the convict's property is to pass to his issue ; men
are not to be ruined by any compulsion to undertake high-priestly
offices, as that of the high-priesthood of the province of Syria which
entailed the holding of costly public games ; provincials should not be
driven to sell corn to the State below its market price, while corn from
sea-coast lands is to be shipped to neighbouring sea-coast towns and
not to distant inland districts, in order that the cost of transport may
not ruin the farmer. Fixed measures in metal and stone must be used
by imperial tax collectors, that extortion may be made more difficult,
while defensores are to be appointed to see to it that through the
connivance of the authorities robbers and highwaymen shall not escape
unpunished. Theodosius himself had superintended the work of clearing
Macedonia from troops of brigands, and he directed that men were to
be permitted to take the law into their own hands if robbed on the
high-roads or in the villages by night, and might slay the offender where
he stood. Examples might be increased at will, but such laws as these
suffice to illustrate the point. In a word, Theodosius knew where the
a ,
shoe pinched, and he did what he could to ease the pain. Even when
claims of Church and State conflicted, he refused to sacrifice justice to
the demands of orthodox intolerance; in one case the tyrannous insistence


## p. 249 (#279) ############################################

“ Theodosius the Great'
249
of Ambrose conquered, and Christian monks who had at Callinicum
destroyed a Jewish synagogue were at last freed from the duty of
making reparation; but even here the stubborn resistance of the
Emperor shews the general principles which governed his administration.
Though naturally merciful, so that contemporaries wondered at his
clemency towards the followers of defeated rivals, yet when seized by
some sudden outburst of passion he could be terrible in his ferocity.
He himself was conscious of his great failing, and when his anger had
passed, men knew that he was the readier to pardon: Praerogativa
ignoscendi erat indignatum fuisse. But with every acknowledgment
made of his weaknesses he served the Empire well; he brought the East
from chaos into order; and even if it be on other grounds, posterity can
hardly dispute the judgment of the Church or deny that the Emperor
has been rightly styled “Theodosius the Great. "
CH, VIII.


## p. 250 (#280) ############################################

250
CHAPTER IX.
THE TEUTONIC MIGRATIONS, 378-412.
。
The enormous force of the onrush made by the Huns upon
the
Ostrogoths had been decisive for the fate of the Visigoths also. A
considerable part of Athanarich's army under their leaders Alavio and
Fritigern had asked for and obtained from the Emperor Valens in the
year 376 land for settlements on the right bank of the Danube. From
that time these Goths were foederati of the Empire, and as such were
obliged to render armed assistance and supply recruits. A demand
for land made by bands of Ostrogoths under Alatheus and Saphrax was
refused; nevertheless these bold Teutons effected the crossing of the
river and followed their kinsmen. Quarrels between Romans and
Goths led to Fritigern's victory of Marcianople, which opened the way
to the Goths as far as Hadrianople. They were pushed back indeed
into the Dobrudscha by Valens' army, and the troops under Richomer
sent from the West by Gratian to assist the Eastern Empire were able
to join the Eastern forces. After this however the success of arms
remained changeable, especially when a section of Huns and Alani had
joined the Goths. Thrace was left exposed to the enemy's raids, which
extended as far as Macedonia. Now it was time for the Emperor to
intervene in person, the more so as Gratian had promised to come
quickly to his assistance. At first the campaign was successful. The
Goths were defeated on the Maritza near Hadrianople, and Valens
advanced towards Philippopolis to effect a junction with Gratian. But
Fritigern hastened southward to cut Valens off from Constantinople.
The Emperor was forced to turn back, and whilst at Hadrianople was
asked by Gratian in a letter delivered by Richomer to postpone the final
attack until his arrival. At a council of war however Valens complied
with his general Sebastian's opinion to strike without delay, as he had
been informed that the enemy numbered but ten thousand. In any case
they would have had to wait a long time for Gratian, who was hurrying
eastward from a remote field of war. After rejecting a very ambiguous
message from Fritigern, Valens led the Romans against the Goths, and
(9 Aug. 378) a battle took place to the north-east of Hadrianople,
probably near Demeranlija. The Goths were fortunate in receiving
a


## p. 251 (#281) ############################################

378]
Sequel to the Battle of Hadrianople
251
timely assistance (from the Ostrogoths and Alani under Alatheus
and Saphrax) after they had already defeated a body of Roman
cavalry, which had attacked them prematurely. The Roman infantry
also met with defeat at the hands of the Goths, and two-thirds of
their army perished. The Emperor himself was killed by an arrow, and
his generals Sebastian and Trajan also lost their lives. When he heard
the news from Richomer, Gratian withdrew to Sirmium, and now the
Eastern Empire lay open to the attacks of the barbarians.
On 10 August the Goths advanced to storm Hadrianople, as
they had been informed that there, in a strongly fortified place, the
Emperor's treasure and the war-chest were kept. But their efforts to
seize the town were in vain. The municipal authorities of Hadrianople
had not even admitted within its walls those Roman soldiers, who
during the night after their defeat had fled there and found shelter
in the suburbs under the ramparts. At ten o'clock in the morning
the long-protracted struggle for the town began. In the midst of
the turmoil three hundred Roman infantry formed a wedge and went
over to the enemy, by whom, strange to say, all were killed. At last a
terrible storm put an end to the fight by bringing the besieged the
much needed supply of water, for want of which they had suffered
the utmost distress. After this the Goths made several fruitless
attempts to take the town by stratagem. When in the course of the
struggle it became evident that many lives were being sacrificed to no
purpose the Goths abandoned the siege from which the prudent Fritigern
had from the beginning tried to dissuade them. Early on 12 August
a council of war was held, in which it was decided to march against
Perinthus on the Propontis, where, according to the report of many
deserters, great treasures were to be found.
When the Goths had left Hadrianople the Roman soldiers gathered
together and during the night one part of them, avoiding the high-roads,
marched by lonely forest-paths to Philippopolis and thence to Sardica,
probably to effect a junction with Gratian; whilst another part conveyed
the well-preserved imperial treasures to Macedonia, where the Emperor,
whose death was as yet unknown, was supposed to be. It will be
observed that at this time the position of the Eastern Empire seemed
hopeless. It could no longer defend itself against those robbing and
plundering barbarians who, now that the battle was won, actually
thought themselves strong enough to advance southward as far as the
Propontis, and on their march could also rely on the assistance of the
Huns and Alani. But here again the Goths had trusted too mạch to their
good fortune. For, though on their arrival in the environs of Perinthus
they encamped before the town, they did not feel strong enough for an
attack, and carried on the war by terrible and systematic devastations
only. In these circumstances it is surprising that they next marched
upon Constantinople itself, the treasures of which greatly excited their
сн. Іх.


## p. 252 (#282) ############################################

252
Gratian's action
[378
а
covetousness. Apparently they hoped to surprise and take the capital
at one blow. This time, however, through fear of hostile attacks they
decided to approach the town in close array. They had almost reached
Constantinople when they encountered a body of Saracens, who had
come out in its defence. It is reported that by a monstrous deed one of
these, a hairy, naked fellow, caused them to turn back. He threw
himself with wild screams on one of the Goths, pierced his throat with a
dagger, and greedily drank the blood which welled forth. For a time
the struggles seem to have continued, but soon the Goths saw that they
were powerless against the large and strongly fortified town and that
they suffered greater loss than they inflicted. They therefore destroyed
their siege engines on the Bosphorus, and bursting forth in single
detachments, moved in a north-westerly direction through Thrace, Moesia
and Illyricum as far as the foot of the Julian Alps, plundering and
devastating the country as they went. Every hand in the Eastern
Empire was paralysed with horror at the unrestrained ferocity of the
barbarians. Only Julius, the magister militum, who held the command
in the province of Asia, had courage enough for a terrible deed, which
shews the boundless hatred felt by the Romans for the Goths, as well as
the cruelty practised in warfare at that time. He announced that on a
certain day all Gothic soldiers in the towns and camps of Asia should
receive their pay; instead of which all of them were at his command cut
down by the Romans. In this manner he freed the provinces of the
.
East from future danger. At the same time this incident shews clearly
the straits to which the Eastern Empire was reduced. There was need
of a clear-headed and determined ruler, if peace was ever to be restored to
the Empire. With regard to this, however, everything depended upon
the decision of Gratian, of whose doings we shall now have to give a
short account.
We know that Gratian had made efforts long before the catastrophes
to come to his uncle's aid against the Goths. From this he was
prevented by a war with the Alemanni. An Aleman from the country
of the Lentienses (afterwards the Linzgau on the Lake of Constance)
who served in the Roman Guard had returned to his country with the
news that Gratian was shortly going to render assistance to his uncle in
the East. This news had induced his tribesmen to make a raid across
the Rhine in February 378. They were at first repulsed by frontier-
troops ; but when it became known that the greater part of the Roman
army had marched for Illyricum they prevailed upon their tribesmen to
join in a big campaign. It was rumoured in Gaul that 40,000 or even
as many as 70,000 Alemanni were on the war-path. Gratian at once
called back those of his cohorts which were already on the way to
Pannonia and put the comes Brittanniae Nannienus in command of his
troops, together with the brave Mallobaudes, king of the Franks. A
battle was fought at Argentaria (near Colmar), in which the Romans,


## p. 253 (#283) ############################################

379–380]
Appointment of Theodosius
253
thanks to the skill of their generals, won a complete victory, and
Priarius, the chieftain of the Lentienses, was killed. Gratian now
attacked the Alemanni, crossed the Rhine and sent the Lentienses flying
to their mountains. There they were completely hemmed in and had to
surrender, promising to supply recruits to the Romans. After this
Gratian marched from Arbor Felix (near St Gallen) eastwards along the
high-road, passing Lauriacum on the way. As we have already seen, he
did not reach Thrace in time, and on hearing of the defeat at Hadrianople
he withdrew to Sirmium. Here, at the beginning of 379, a great political
event took place. It must be mentioned that Theodosius, who had
formerly been the commander-in-chief in Upper Moesia, and had since
been living in a kind of exile in Spain, had been recalled by Gratian and
entrusted with a new command. Before the end of 378 Theodosius had
already given a proof of his ability by the defeat of the Sarmatians, who
appear to have invaded Pannonia. The success was welcome in a time
so disastrous for the Romans. This is most probably one of the reasons
why Gratian (19 Jan. 379) at Sirmium raised him to be Emperor of the
East and enlarged his dominions by adding to them Dacia, Upper
Moesia, Macedonia, Epirus and Achaia, i. e. Eastern Illyricum.
The Visigoths under Fritigern had without doubt been the moving
spirit in the war, although the Ostrogoths had played a valiant part in
it. After Ermanarich had committed suicide, Withimir had become
king of the Ostrogoths. He lost his life fighting against the Alani, and
seems to have been succeeded by his infant son, in whose name the
princes Alatheus and Saphrax reigned supreme. These, as we saw,
joined forces later on with the Visigoths and contributed largely to the
victory at Hadrianople. It appears that for some time after this, both
tribes of the Goths made common cause against the Romans. At first
the two Emperors were successful in some minor campaigns against the
Goths, and while Gratian went westward against the Franks and perhaps
against the Vandals who had made an invasion across the Rhine, Theodosius
succeeded in creating at Thessalonica, a place which he chose as a strong
and sure base for his further operations, a new and efficient army, into
which he admitted a considerable number of Goths. Before the end of
379 he and his forces gained important successes over the enemy, who
found themselves almost entirely confined to Lower Moesia and, owing to
a lack of supplies, were compelled to renew the war in 380. The
Visigoths under Fritigern advanced in a south-westerly direction towards
Macedonia, whilst the Ostrogoths, Alani and Huns went to the north-
west against Pannonia. Theodosius, who hurried to meet the Visigoths,
suffered a severe defeat in an unexpected night-attack. The Goths,
however, did not follow up their victory, but contented themselves with
pillaging Macedonia and Thessaly, whilst the Emperor Theodosius lay
a prey to a protracted illness at Thessalonica. During this period
Macedonia suffered terribly from the barbarians. At last when Gratian,
a
a
CH, Tx.


## p. 254 (#284) ############################################

254
End of the Gothic War
[380—382
whose assistance Theodosius had implored, sent an army under Bauto
and Arbogast, two Frankish generals, the Goths were compelled to
retreat into Lower Moesia. Gratian himself was at the same time forced
to take command of an army again; for his general Vitalianus had been
unable to prevent the Ostrogoths, Alani, and Huns from invading
Pannonia. As this barbarian invasion was a great danger to the
Western Empire, it was highly important for Gratian to make peace
with the enemy before suffering great losses. This he accomplished by
assigning Pannonia and Upper Moesia to the Ostrogoths and their allies
as foederati. This settlement of the barbarians at its eastern frontier
guaranteed the peace of the Western Empire in the immediate future. For
the Eastern Empire also peace seemed now ensured. When Theodosius,
who as an orthodox ruler commanded greater sympathy from his subjects
than his predecessor, the Arian Valens, had recovered from his illness, he
made a triumphal entry into Constantinople (24 Nov. 380), and here
(11 Jan. 381) the Visigoth Athanarich arrived with his followers.
He
had been banished by the Goths whom he had led into Transylvania,
and not desiring to ally himself with Fritigern on account of an old feud,
asked to be admitted into the Empire. He was received with the
greatest honours by Theodosius, but only survived his entrance by a
fortnight. The high honour shewn to Athanarich was evidently intended
to create the impression among the inhabitants of the capital that war
with the Goths was at an end; perhaps it was also hoped to promote
more peaceful feelings among Fritigern's followers. We are also led to
believe that Theodosius soon commenced negotiations with this dreaded
prince, which were brought to a conclusion in 382 by the magister
militum Saturninus. A treaty of peace was concluded at Constantinople
(3 Oct. 382) by which permission was given to Fritigern and all his
Goths to settle as allies in Lower Moesia. They were also to retain
their domestic legislation and the right to elect their own princes. It
was their duty in return to defend the frontier and to furnish troops,
which, however, were to be led by their own chiefs. They obtained the
districts assigned to them free of tribute, and moreover the Romans
agreed to pay them annually a sum of money.
This treaty was, without doubt, at the time a triumph for
Theodosius, and as such it was loudly praised by the Emperor's flatterers.
But on closer examination we shall see that the Romans had only
gained a momentary peace. From the outset it was impossible to
accustom the Goths, proud conquerors of the Roman armies as they
were, to the peaceful occupation of tilling the ground, and, as they had
doubtless been allowed to settle in Moesia in a compact mass, retaining
their domestic government, all efforts to Romanise them could but prove
vain. Besides this the Danube, with the exception of the Dobrudscha,
was stripped of Roman troops, and the ever-increasing number of Goths
who entered the Roman army was naturally a considerable danger to it.


## p. 255 (#285) ############################################

382–388)
The Goths in the Empire
255
a
Moreover the majority of the Goths were Arians, and the rest still
heathens. A year previously, however, Theodosius had not only attacked
heathenism, but had issued a law against heretics, especially Arians. He
had even sent his general Sapor into the East to expel the Arian bishops
from their churches ; only bishops professing the Nicene faith were to
possess the churches. Thus the peace could not possibly be of long
duration
How greatly political questions excited the Goths, and how
passionately their national feeling would sometimes break forth is shewn
by an event which occurred at Constantinople soon after 382. One day
at the royal table two Gothic princes, who were specially honoured by
Theodosius, gave free utterance to their opposed political convictions.
Eriwulf was the leader of the national party among the Goths, which
considered the destruction of the Roman Empire their ultimate object ;
he was an Arian by confession. Fravitta, on the other hand, was the
head of that party which saw their future salvation in a close union with
the Empire. He had married a Roman lady, and had remained a
heathen. The quarrel between the two party-leaders ended by Fravitta
drawing his sword and killing his opponent just outside the palace.
The attempts of Eriwulf's followers to take immediate revenge were met
with armed resistance on the part of the imperial palace-guards. This
incident doubtless helped to strengthen Fravitta's position at the
Emperor's Court, whilst he had made himself impossible to the Goths.
At this time a new danger to the Empire arose from those Goths who
had remained at home and had been conquered by the Huns. As early
as the winter of 384 or 385 they had taken possession of Halmyris (a
town to the south of the estuary of the Danube) which however they left
again, only to return in the autumn of 386 to ask for admission into the
Empire together with other tribes. But the magister militum Promotus,
commander of the troops in Thrace, forbade them to cross the river.
He had the frontier carefully guarded, and met their attack with a ruse,
cleverly conceived and successfully executed, by sending some of his men
to the Ostrogoths under the pretence of betraying the Roman army to
them. In reality however those soldiers of his reported to Promotus the
place and time of the proposed night-attack, and when the barbarians,
led by Odothaeus, crossed the river, the Romans, who were posted on a
large number of anchored boats, made short work of them. This time
the better strategy of the Romans gained a complete victory over the
Goths. To commemorate this victory the Emperor, who subsequently
appeared in person on the battle-field, erected a huge column ornamented
with reliefs in the quarter of the town which is called Taurus.
Meanwhile (25 Aug. 383) Gratian had been killed at Lyons at the
instigation of the usurper Maximus, who had been proclaimed Emperor
by the army in Britain and had found followers in Gaul. At first
Theodosius pretended to accept Maximus for a colleague ; but in 388 he
CB. IX.


## p. 256 (#286) ############################################

256
The Franks
(383–389
a
led his army against him and defeated him at Liscia and Pettau. In the
end the usurper was taken prisoner and killed at Aquileia. Theodosius
now appointed Valentinian II, Gratian's youthful brother, Emperor of
the West, only reserving for himself the co-regency of Italy. He then
sent his experienced general Arbogast into Gaul, where the Teutons
from the right bank of the Rhine had seized the occasion offered by the
quarrel for the throne to extend their power beyond the frontier.
Three chiefs of the Ripuarian Franks, Genobaudes, Marcomir and
Sunno, had indeed crossed the Rhine in the neighbourhood of Cologne
and made a raid upon the Roman territory. When the Roman generals
Nannienus and Quintinus went to meet the raiders at Cologne, one part
of them left the borderland of the province, whilst the others continued
their march into the country, till they were at last beaten back in the
Carbonarian forest (to the east of Tournai). Quintinus now proceeded to
attack the enemy and crossed the Rhine at Novaesium (Neuss). But after
pushing forward for three days into the wild and pathless regions on
the right bank of the Rhine, he was decoyed into an ambush, in which
almost the whole of his army perished. Thus it appeared likely that the
Roman rule in the Rhenish provinces would before long be completely
overthrown; for the generals Carietto and Syrus, whom Maximus had
left behind, found it impossible to put a stop to the barbarian raids.
At this juncture Arbogast was sent by Theodosius to save the West.
His first act was to capture Flavius Victor, the infant son of Maximus, and
to have him put to death. Then he reinforced his army with those
troops which Maximus had left stationed in Gaul, and which together
with their generals Carietto and Syrus were easily won over to his side.
Last of all he turned against his former tribesmen, the Franks, and
demanded from them the restitution of the booty and surrender of the
originators of the war. When these demands were refused, he hesitated
to begin war by himself. He found it difficult to come to a decision, for
the fate of Quintinus' troops was still fresh in his memory. In these
straits he wrote to the Emperor Valentinian II, who seems to have urged
a friendly settlement of the feuds; for in the autumn of 389 Arbogast
had an interview with Marcomir and Sunno. The Franks, possibly
fearing the mighty Theodosius, gave hostages, and a treaty of peace was
concluded which cannot have been unfavourable to the barbarians.
In this way the Western Empire shewed considerable indulgence in
its treatment of the Teutons. The Eastern Empire on the contrary, and
especially the Emperor, was soon directly and indirectly exposed to
serious troubles from the Visigoths. We know that the Goths had
extended their raids as far as Thessalonica. In this large town, the
second in importance in the Balkan peninsula, there existed a certain
amount of ill-feeling against the barbarians, which was greatly increased
by the fact that the highest offices, both civil and military, were chiefly
held by Teutons; moreover the town was garrisoned by Teuton soldiers.


## p. 257 (#287) ############################################

389–392]
The Massacre at Thessalonica
257
The innate pride of Greeks and Romans alike was deeply wounded by
this situation, and a very insignificant occurrence in the year 390 sufficed
to make their hatred burst into flames. It happened in the following
way. Botherich, the commandant of the town, had imprisoned a very
popular charioteer and refused to set him free, when the people clamoured
for his deliverance because of the approaching circus-games. This caused
a rising against the obnoxious barbarian in which he lost his life. At
the time of this incident the Emperor Theodosius was at Milan where he
had frequent intercourse with the influential bishop Ambrose; this was
not without its effect upon him, though in his innermost heart the
Emperor as a secular autocrat could not but be opposed to ecclesiastical
pretensions. Although Theodosius inclined by nature to leniency, or
at any rate made a show of that quality, in this case at least wrath
overcame every human feeling in him, and he resolved to chastise
the town in a way so cruel, that nothing can be put forward in
defence of it. When the people of Thessalonica were assembled in the
circus and absorbed in contemplation of the games soldiers suddenly
broke in and cut down all whom their swords could reach. For three
hours the slaughter went on, till the victims numbered 7000. The
Emperor himself, urged perhaps to mercy by Ambrose, had at the last
hour revoked his order, but it was too late. Probably Theodosius had
been led to this unspeakable cruelty by persons of his intimate acquaint-
ance among whom Rufinus played a prominent part. It seems that
Rufinus had been magister officiorum since 382; in 392 he rose to the
position of Praefectus Praetorio. When the news of this massacre
reached Milan, the Christian population of the town was paralysed with
terror. Ambrose left the town and addressed a letter of the utmost
gravity to Theodosius. He explained to him that his deed called for
penitence and warned him not to attend at church.
The proud
sovereign perceived that he would have to submit to the penitence
imposed on him, and obeyed the bishop's will. He did not leave Milan
till the following year; but before returning to the Eastern capital he
had to sustain a dangerous attack from the Goths in Thrace.
tähvad
In 390 the Visigoths broke the peace to which they had sworn, and
invaded Thrace; Huns and other tribes from beyond the Danube had
thrown in their lot with them. They were commanded by Alaric, a
prince of the Visigoths, belonging to the family of the Balti. This is
the first appearance of Alaric, who was then about twenty years of age,
,
and whose great campaigns subsequently excited such terror throughout
the Roman Empire. But even then the Thracians appear to have been
in great distress: for (1 July 391) Theodosius issued an edict at Aquileia,
by which the inhabitants of the endangered district received permission
to carry arms and to kill anybody found marauding in the open
country. After Theodosius had entered the province, he took great
pains to destroy the bands of marauders, and himself assisted in their
17
6. HDD. H. v0L. 1. CH. IX.


## p. 258 (#288) ############################################

258
Arbogast
[391–392
pursuit. On the Maritza, however, he fell into an ambush and was
completely defeated. Even his life seems to have been in danger, but he
was rescued by his general Promotus. The latter continued the war
against the Goths till the end of 391, though he had apparently fallen
into disfavour at Court. He lost his life in the war, and public opinion
at the capital attributed his death to Rufinus. Stilicho the Vandal now
became commander of the troops in Thrace. He was born about 360,
and had at an early age been attached to an embassy to Persia. After-
wards Theodosius had given him his niece Serena in marriage and
promoted him step by step. He was considered to be one of the ablest
statesmen in the Eastern Empire, and the military command entrusted
to him in 392 was destined to increase the importance of his position.
For he succeeded at length in defeating the enemy, who for so long a
time had been the terror of the Empire. The Goths were surrounded
on the Maritza. But again the Emperor shewed mercy and gave orders
that the enemy should be permitted to go free. Theodosius' policy may
probably be attributed to a certain fear of revenge, and it was doubtless
influenced by Rufinus, who did not wish Stilicho to become too
powerful. Thus a treaty with the vanquished Goths was concluded.
Meanwhile Arbogast had embarked upon a most ambitious course
of politics. His aim was to get rid of the young and irresolute
Valentinian II. Not indeed that he himself wished for the imperial crown,
for he very likely felt its possession to be®undesirable. His idea was to
get Valentinian II out of the way, and then assist to the imperial throne
some one of his ardent devotees, under whose name he himself hoped to
wield the supreme power. For the attainment of this end, his first
requisite was a trustworthy army. He therefore levied a large number
of Teuton troops, in whose loyalty he could place the utmost confidence.
When Valentinian took up his abode in Gaul, the relations between him
and the powerful Frank became more and more strained, till finally the
Emperor from his throne handed to his rival a written order, demanding
that he should resign his post. Arbogast tore the document in pieces
before the eyes of the Emperor, whose days were thenceforth numbered.
On 15 May 392 the youthful sovereign was assassinated at Vienne; but
whether Arbogast was directly responsible for this deed remains uncer-
tain. The way was now clear for the Frank's ambitious plans. A short
time previously the Frank Richomer had recommended to his tribesman
Arbogast the head of the imperial chancery, the magister scriniorum
Eugenius. This Roman, formerly a rhetorician and grammarian, was
the man whom Arbogast intended to raise to the imperial throne.
Eugenius could not but yield to the mighty man's wish. He therefore
sent an embassy to Theodosius in 392 to obtain his recognition. But
Theodosius gave an evasive answer; and as there was every prospect of a
war, Arbogast deemed it necessary to make provision for a safe retreat.
We know that the neighbourhood of the Franks formed a very vulnerable


## p. 259 (#289) ############################################

392–395]
Battle of the Frigidus
259
1
point of the Roman government in Gaul. For this reason in the winter
of 392 Arbogast undertook a campaign against these dangerous
neighbours. He probably hoped at the same time to reinforce his army
with Frankish troops, should he be successful in this war. He pushed
on through Cologne and the country along the river Lippe into the
territory of the Bructeri and Chamavi, after which he turned eastward
against the Ampsivarii, who had joined forces with the Chatti under
Marcomir. Apparently he met with but little resistance, for in the spring
of 393 Eugenius succeeded in concluding treaties with the Franks and
even the Alemanni, on condition that they supplied him with troops.
The ensuing period was spent in preparation for war in both Empires,
Eugenius having been, thanks to Arbogast's influence, recognised as
Emperor in Italy also. Theodosius had reinforced his army more
especially with Teutons; the Visigoths were again commanded by Alaric,
whilst the leaders of the other foederati were Gaïnas, Saul and the
comes domesticorum Bacurius, an Armenian. The meeting of the two
armies took place 5 Sept. 394 on the Frigidus, a tributary of the
Isonza, probably the Hubel. As the Gothic troops formed the vanguard
and opened the attack on the enemy, who were posted very favourably,
they suffered severe losses on the first day of the battle, which greatly
elated the Westerns. On the second day the battle would in all
probability have been decided in favour of Arbogast, had not his
general Arbitrio, who commanded the Frankish troops, gone over to
Theodosius. It is related besides, that a violent storm from the north-
east—the Bora, as it is called—wrought such havoc in the ranks of
Eugenius' army, that it helped Theodosius to gain a complete victory.
Eugenius was taken prisoner and put to death, and Arbogast escaped
into the mountains, where he died by his own hand (8 Sept. ). But whilst
the relations and followers of Eugenius and Arbogast were pardoned,
Alaric waited in vain for the post in the Roman army, which Theodosius
had promised him; and when (17 Jan. 395) Theodosius died at Milan,
still in the prime of life, the Goths were sent home by Stilicho, who had
been second in command during the war. To make matters worse, the
yearly payments which had hitherto been made to the Goths, were now
injudiciously held back. These various causes combined to disturb the
peace between the Romans and Goths, which had so far been tolerably
well preserved, and the Goths once more commenced hostilities.
The time for a general rising seemed to be well chosen. Theodosius,
whose strong hand had endeavoured to maintain the peace within the
Empire, was now no more, and his sons were yet of tender age.
The
late Emperor had been the last to reign over the whole Empire. And
even he, powerless to stay its decline, had been obliged to cede to the
Goths an extensive district within its borders. How important the
Teutonic element had grown can best be understood from the fact that
the Teutons not only furnished the best part of the troops, but also
SH Ix.
17-2


## p. 260 (#290) ############################################

260
Division of the Empire
[395
ever.
commanded the armies and held the highest appointments, both civil and
military. Now that Theodosius was dead, the Empire was divided for
At an age of hardly eighteen years his son Arcadius received the
Empire of the East under the guidance of Rufinus, who had in 394, during
the absence of Theodosius, been entrusted with the regency as well as
with the supreme direction of Arcadius. On 27 April 395, to Rufinus'
great vexation, the young Emperor married Eudoxia, who had been
brought to him by Eutropius, the eunuch of the palace. She was the
daughter of Bauto, the Frank who had played an important part under
Gratian and Valentinian. In the course of the same year Rufinus was most
cruelly slain by the soldiers whom Gaïnas had but recently led back to
Constantinople. After his death Eutropius stood in high favour with
the Emperor. He received the office of High Chamberlain (praepositus
sacri cubiculi) and later on the title patricius. The younger son
Honorius, who was in his eleventh year, received the Western Empire.
Stilicho was appointed his guardian and also regent. He had been
raised to the rank of magister utriusque militiae by Theodosius before his
death, and, as we saw, had married a niece of the Emperor. This
capable man was no doubt better fitted than any other to rule the
Empire in the spirit of Theodosius, and when the Emperor died it was
he who without delay hurried to the Rhine to receive homage for
Honorius from the Teuton tribes, even as far as the Batavi. Apparently
on this journey King Marcomir was delivered into his hands, and was
sent into exile to Tuscany. After this Stilicho immediately returned to
Italy.
Meanwhile the Visigoths had broken loose from Moesia. Those of
their tribesmen who had formerly accompanied Alaric to Transylvania
had joined them and chosen Alaric, whose power at that time, however,
was still limited, as leader in the coming war. This war was fraught
with danger for the Eastern Empire, for it appears that in the early
spring of 395 the whole mass of the Visigoths marched south towards
Constantinople. As before, there could of course be no question
of capturing the city, but the surrounding country was mercilessly
devastated. It is most probable that Rufinus, who paid repeated visits
to the hostile camp, bribed the enemy to retire. Alaric now made his way
along the coast to Macedonia and Thessaly. Near Larissa he encountered
Stilicho, who had left Italy with strong forces. These were the victorious
East-Roman soldiers, whom he was leading home to their own country,
hoping at the same time to win back Illyria for the Western Empire.
This province, though given to Theodosius by Gratian, was said to have
been restored by the former a short time before his death. Apparently
the Goths had first of all tried to gain the valley of the Peneus, the Vale
of Tempe ; but meeting with resistance, they had pushed on across the
eastern slopes of Olympus into Thessaly, where they barricaded them-
selves behind their wagons. Stilicho was on the point of attacking


## p. 261 (#291) ############################################

396–397
Alaric in Greece
261
them when he received a message from Arcadius, ordering him to dismiss
the army of the Eastern Empire, and himself return to Italy. If at
first sight this order seems strange, it is because we have long been
accustomed to see in Stilicho a disinterested statesman and general, who
dedicated his labour and personality to the family of Theodosius. This
disposition of Eastern Illyria, which Theodosius was supposed to have
made shortly before his death, is however very doubtful, and it is certain
that Stilicho had entertained personal ambitions with regard to that
province. Viewed in the light of these circumstances, the order from
Arcadius appears in a very different light, especially if to this is added
the fact that in the same year the Huns had broken through the gates
of the Caucasus at Baku on the Caspian Sea and reached Syria by way of
Armenia. There they laid siege to Antioch and proceeded thence to
Asia Minor. Ravages of every kind marked their way. In this situation
it was an absolute necessity for the welfare of the State that the army
should return to its own country. Stilicho obeyed the order, because, as
has justly been remarked, he was probably uncertain about the future
conduct of the East-Roman troops, a section of whom remained in
Greece under Gerontius' command to cover Thermopylae. Alaric, how-
ever, assisted perhaps by treachery, took possession of this famous pass
without difficulty. After this the Goths marched through Boeotia into
Attica. Here Alaric succeeded in seizing the Piraeus, and forced Athens
to capitulate by cutting off her supplies. It is probable that she escaped
pillage by the payment of a sum of money ; Alaric stayed for a short
time peacefully within her walls. From Athens the march of the Goths
was continued to Eleusis, where they ransacked the temple of Demeter,
and further to Megara, which was quickly taken. Gerontius had left the
entrance to the Peloponnesus undefended, and the Gothic hordes,
meeting with no resistance, broke like a torrent upon Corinth and thence
on Argos and Sparta. Many an ancient work of art must have perished
in this rush, but no mention is made of any systematic and wilful
destruction of the ancient monuments.
It is a curious fact, that after all this the East-Roman government
seems neither to have made war against the Huns, who had invaded
Asia, nor to have lent assistance to the Greeks, when Gerontius had so
utterly failed to do his duty at Thermopylae and the Isthmus. Help
came rather from another quarter, and primarily, it must be owned,
with a different purpose in view. Though Stilicho had returned to
Italy, he had been kept well informed about events in Greece. As he
himself had designs on East-Illyria, to which Epirus and Achaia
belonged, and as Alaric was to all appearances endeavouring to create an
independent sovereignty in these provinces, it was imperative for the
vicegerent of the West to interfere. In 397 he transported an army to
Greece, and, landing on the south side of Corinth, expelled the Goths
from Arcadia and surrounded them at Elis near the Alpheus on the
H. I.


## p. 262 (#292) ############################################

262
Revolt of Gaïnas
(
394-399
plateau of Pholoe. But no decisive battle was fought, for Stilicho was
not sufficiently master of his own troops, and just then the revolt of the
Moorish prince Gildo threatened to become a serious danger to the
Western Empire. Gildo had formerly been praefect of Mauretania and
had subsequently been raised to the office of magister utriusque militiae.
In the year 394 he began his revolt, whereby he intended to secure the
North coast of Africa as a dominion of his own, and in 397 he offered
Africa as a feudal province to the Eastern Empire, hoping thereby to
kindle war between the two Empires. In this predicament Stilicho
avoided a decisive encounter with the Goths. For the second time he
allowed his adversary to escape. He even concluded a treaty with
Alaric, which doubtless contained an alliance against the Eastern
Empire; for in these precarious circumstances the chief of the brave
Goths might possibly prove of great service to Stilicho in his ambitious
private policy. The effect of these conditions on the mutual relations
of the two Empires was soon apparent. At Constantinople Stilicho was
declared an enemy of the State, whilst in the Western Empire the
consulship of Eutropius, who had been nominated for 399 and had
entirely won the favour of Arcadius, was not acknowledged. Before his
death Theodosius had so arranged the division of the Empire that the
cohesion of the whole might for the future be firmly and permanently
secured. Thus the first deep cleft had been made in a union which
was already difficult to maintain. Neither Empire had a permanent
diplomatic representation ; only special embassies were sent from time
to time, so that unfounded suspicions were very likely to arise on
either side.
At this time, while Stilicho was sailing back in haste from Greece to
Italy to prepare for war against Gildo, the Goths made a raid into
Epirus, which they devastated in a terrible manner.