No More Learning

and atomical theories of the universe. The
Mahan (Capt. A. T. ), Naval Strategy compared and
writer ranges himself on the side of the philoso-
contrasted with the Principles and Practice of
phers who credit the movement of material
elements towards unity-the “ free develop-
Military Operations on Land, 16/ net.
Lectures delivered at U. S. Naval War College,
ment” of the Being from unity to plurality,
Newport, R. I. , between 1887 and 1911.
and again from plurality towards unity. Mr.
May (Sir Thomas Erskine), The Constitutional
Wordsworth scrupulously avoids committal to
doctrinaire or didactic conclusions.
History of England since the Accession of George
the Third, edited and continued to 1911 by
Francis Holland, Vols. 1. and II. , 15/ net;
History and Biography.
Vol. III. , by Francis Holland, 12/6 net.
Barclay (Sir Thomas), The Turco-Italian War and
The fourth edition of Sir Erskine May's
its Problems, 5/ net.
inquiry into the constitutional development of
The author discusses the cardinal and sub- English government since the accession of
sidiary problems affecting the balance of power
George III. , from the orthodox Whig position.
in Europe, the possibilities of adjustment, and the
Up to 1860 only revision has been necessary, but
extent of interrelated interests. He also, in view
a third and bulky volume now carries the work
of peace in the near future, estimates on what down to the passing of the Parliament Act in
terms an agreement could be reached. He
1911. For the last fifty years the influence
sketches the history of the war up to the present
and prerogative of the Crown have been almost
time, and pronounces on the illegality of the
stationary, and this supplementary volume
Italian position. More than half of the book is
treats exclusively the progressive advance of
taken up with appendixes.
Parliamentary institutions, party vicissitudes,
Carnegy (Mildred), A Queen's Knight, 7/6 net.
the relation of the State to religion, local
This is one of the numerous biographies
government, civil and military service reforms,
written not so much for the student as the
the self-governing colonies, and the recent con-
circulating library. It presents the career of
stitutional crisis. The distinction of the former
Axel de Fersen, the Swedish nobleman whose
volumes is well maintained, nor can any devia-
chivalrous devotion to Marie Antoinette
tion from the point of view we are wont to
involved him in the events of 1789–93. An
associate with Sir Erskine May be detected.
appreciation of the real importance of the Ryan (Daniel J:), The Civil War Literature of
French Revolution would be of no advantage to
Geography and Travel.
Frazer (J. Nelson), In Foreign Lands: Sketches
of Travel in Three Continents, 7/6 net.
The author is a member of the Indian Educa.
tional Service who has travelled in Asia, Africa,
and the Pacific. In view of the wealth of
literature dealing with india, the first part of
the book seems a. trifle superfluous, but it is
well written, as is the somewhat superficial
'Glimpse of Africa. More interesting are Mr.
Frazer's impressions of Fiji and the effect of
European civilization on its inhabitants.
Gillpatrick (Wallace), Wanderings in Mexico :
Ohio : a Bibliography, with Explanatory and
such a work, and it shows none. Readers who
Historical Notes.
like an easy style and a sentimental love.
A bibliography of the literature of and
interest will be well satisfied.
concerning Ohio during the Civil War, whether
Dunraven (Earl of), The Legacy of Past Years :
books, pamphlets, or published addresses.
a Study of Irish History, Bd. net.
Short critical and explanatory précis of the
New Edition.
writers and their work are supplied. The collector
Espitalier (Albert), Napoleon and King Murat :
has adopted the alphabetical system, and in
à Biography compiled from Hitherto Unknown
symmetry and order his volume of references
and Unpublished Documents, translated by
leaves nothing to be desired, while there is a
J. Lewis May.
complete index.
M. Espitalier obtains much of his documentary Scottish Historical Review, January, 2/6 net.
evidence from such sources as the Archivio
The January number contains some erudite
di Stato at Naples, the Società Napolitana di
and original research, largely upon early
history.
Storia Patria, the Austrian archives, and the
The article on The Old Schools and Universi-
British Record Office. Particular attention is
ties' of Scotland throws up in bold relief their
devoted to Murat's two treaties with Austria,
development and historical continuity. Mr.
which explain much of his conduct in 1814.
A. W. Johnston contributes some suggestive
An appendix, index, and genealogical table
matter on the twelfth-century mythological lays
give substance to the investigation.
of the man of Orkney in collaboration with Ice-
Expedition on the Sacramento and San Joaquin
landers. Dr. Brandl's subversive article on
Rivers in 1817: Diary of Fray Narciso Duran,
The Vision of the Cross of Christ,' which
edited by C. E. Chapman.
attempts to shift the authorship from Cynewulf
One of the publications of the Academy of
to an anonymous Northumbrian of the eighth
Pacific Coast History:
century, is built upon somewhat slender
Hovey (Carl), The Life Story of J. Pierpont
foundations. There are a large number of
Morgan.
interesting reviews.
If it is of any interest to the public to know Sergeant (Philip W. ), My Lady Castlemaine :
how millions are earned, or how they are spent, being a Life of Barbara Villiers, Countess of
such things may be found within the covers of Castlemaine, afterwards Duchess of Cleveland,
this laudatory record. “Mr. Morgan controls 16/ net.
virtually the bulk of the banking resources in A biography pieced together from con-
the country,” says Mr. Hovey, who considers temporary documents and diarists such as
his bero a great patriot. " The author is, Pepys, Evelyn, Cominges, and Grammont.
however, far from discreet in his incense-burn- The whole is worked and amplified into a
ing, and the book may be regarded as a useful consistent narrative, but lacks charm or origin-
the Spirited Chronicle of Adventure in Mexican
Highways and Byways, 7/6 net.
The author is an American journalist who
has travelled widely in Mexico rather than seen
deeply into its life and history. He is more
concerned with his chance adventures on the
road and his casual conversations with strangers
than with the antiquities and economic possi-
bilities which give Mexico its place in the world.
The work in fact, though readable, is of no
particular value.
Hulton (Dr. S. K. ), Among the Eskimos of
Labrador, 16/ net.
A book containing a good deal of interesting
matter, which we propose to notice more fully
in a later issue.
Indian Tribes of the Upper Mississippi Valley
and Region of the Great Lakes, as described by
Nicolas Perrot, French Commandant in the
North-west; Bacqueville de la Potherie, French
Royal Commissioner to Canada ; Morrell
Marston, American Army Officer; and Thomas
Forsyth, U. S. Agent at Fort Armstrong ;
translated, edited, annotated, and with Biblio-
graphy and Index by Emma Helen Blair,
2 vols. , $10 net.
The value of this comprehensive work lies
in its presentation of trustworthy first-hand
material upon aboriginal religion, folk-lore,
organization, social relations, industries, cus-
toms, and observances. The eloquence of
Nicolas Perrot in particular, and the brilliance
of the translation, make the narrative as
absorbing for the interest of its material as for
its treatment. It is written with scrupulous
fairness and tolerance, and as an ethnological
study should be invaluable. An exhaus-
tive analytical index is appended at the end of
the second volume.
Jackson (A. V. Williams), From Constantinople
to the Home of Omar Khayyám: Travels in
Transcaucasia and Northern Persia for Historic
and Literary Research, 15/ net.
Prof. Jackson has his authorities, from Hero-
dotus to Lord Curzon, always in his mind, yet
his narrative is easy and vivid, and he presents
conclusions which a scholar can accept, in a
form which will not repel the ordinary reader.
The illustrations also are excellent. He is less
successful where he tries to give his work a
literary flavour. We could dispense with
quotations, ranging from Isaiah to Aldrich and
Kipling, at the head of every chapter; and the
original compositions in verse, which the
author occasionally throws off, are sincere, but
hardly worth the permanency of print. Though
it be proper
at Omar's tomb" to join
in quaffing
the sparkling cup in his name, and to turn
down the empty glass, what are we to say of
the regret " that some of Omar's admirers in
the Occident do not provide a suitable inscrip-
tion on the spot" ?
Young (Filson), Christopher Columbus and the
New World of his Discovery, with a Note on
the Navigation of Columbus's First Voyage by
the Earl of Dunraven, 7/6 net.
Third Edition.
Sports and Pastimes.
Holder (Charles Frederick), Life in the Open :
Sport with Rod, Gun, Horse, and Hound in
Southern California, 7/6 net.
Mr. Holder, who has written a biography of
Darwin and much instructive matter about


## p. (#67) #################################################

No. 4395, JAN. 20, 1912
67
THE ATHEN ÆUM
99
and “
fishing, now publishes a large volume on Southern
School-Books.
California, which he depicts as the paradise of
Fiction
sportsmen. He deprecates the conception of Pring (! . N. ), Laboratory Exercises in Physical Adams (Evelyn), Tales of Seven Islands, 61
sport as a desperate killing, a plethoric bag Chemistry, 4/ net.
A volume of short stories, reprinted from
or creel," and interweaves almost as much For notice see p. 71.
Good Words and various Australian magazines.
naturalism and botany into the fabric of his
The author uses her knowledge of life in Aus-
narrative as there is sport. His story is told
Science.
tralia and the islands of the Pacific with con-
with a wealth of picturesque detail, and is
happily embroidered
siderable skill, but, despite the local colour,
with many engaging
Armytage (H. ), Darwin and the Bible, 6/ net.
touches. He writes of the country with deep
The author, before making this belated
these mild romances are on the whole not very
successful.
feeling, and supplies many spirited pictures of
attack upon Darwin, read the Origin of Species?
Californian life and scenery.
Towards the
dipped into the ‘Descent of Man. ' Balfour (Ethel), In Time's Storerooms, 6/
close of the book he drifts, almost unconsciously,
The result is not calculated to inflict severe This story suffers from the very defects
back to his old love-angling.
damage upon the Linnean Society. Nor which appear as virtues to a large section of
does the section devoted to the praise of the the novel-reading public-over-emphasis and
Education.
Bible, intermingled as it is with trivialities, exaggeration. The girl who on her twentieth
seem to us likely to make many persons re- birthday is to be told an important secret, the
Thoughts on Education, chosen from the Writings consider their opinions upon either religious or discovery then that her beloved guardian is
of Matthew Arnold by Leonard Huxley, 5/net. biological subjects. The whole book is, in fact, not her father, her obedient acquiescence in the
For review see p. 62.
out of date.
wish of her dead mother that she should offer
Butler (H. J. ), Motor Bodies and Chassis : a Text-
to live with her real parent, his eccentric ways
Sociology.
book dealing with the Complete Car, for the
and the dour sister who plots unscrupulously
Forrest (J. Dorsey), The Development of Western Use of Owners, Students, and others, 8/ net.
on behalf of her dissipated son—these and the
Civilization : a Study in Ethical, Economic,
A textbook of more immediate value to the private lunatic asylum from which the heroine
and Political Evolution, 8/ net.
carriage builder than the engineer, since it is barely escapes belong to the stock-in-trade of
The author carries his investigation of the
the body-work, rather than the chassis of the the popular romancer. We could wish the
social phenomena which influenced the forma-
motor-car, with which Mr. Butler deals. It is
author's talent better employed.
tion of Western civilization into an analysis
natural that the mechanism of a car should
Barclay (Marguerite and Armiger), The Activities
of the development of evolution and its relation
receive closer study than its less important of Lavie Jutt, 6/
to ethical, philosophic, economic, and historical
component parts, but treatment of the various This book is typically American, and has a
values. The scope of his subject is too large
styles of bodies has certainly been inadequate. fine disregard for probabilities and in most
to admit of minute examination into social
The author surveys and defines the varieties
cases possibilities. The first chapter is appro-
forces. His work is therefore prone to incon.
of bodies hitherto invented, and devotes chap- priately named 'Lavie Starts In,' and the
clusiveness and generalization.
ters to body dimensions, designing, drawing, story may be recommended to any one who
Hobhouse (L. T. ), Social Evolution and Political
decorating, illuminating, and other accessories. can appreciate American slang. The authors'
Theory, 6/6 net.
He deals separately with ignition, the cooling
ignorance (real or feigned) of what cannot be
Prof. Éobhouse is never dull, and in this
of the cylinders, and lubrication. The figure done in England is abysmal.
book, which is virtually the text of a course
drawings are clear, in spite of their intricacy.
of lectures delivered last year at Columbia
Eugenics Review, January, 1/ net.
Bazin (René), The Children of Alsace, 6!
A translation of 'Les Oberlés,' in which
University, there are few chapters which should Frith (Julius), Alternating-Current Design, 5/ net. M. Bazin draws a vivid picture of the influence
fail to arouse vivid interest. The book is by
A book the contents of which aim at sug- of a man's love for his native land over all
no means to be regarded as an instrument gesting ideas rather than imparting information other interests. The rendering, on the whole,
merely for the spreading of the author's well- already elaborately dealt with in Mr. Cramp's is well done and pleasant to read, and there is a
known political views, and may be confidently 'Continuous-Current Machine Design,' to which short Preface by Dr. A. S. Rappoport.
recommended to any person desirous of finding this treatise is intended to be a companion.
a scientific basis for his political beliefs.
The book is well furnished with calculations Bower (H. M. ), The Temple of Demos, 6/
Social Conditions in Provincial Towns, First
and diagrams.
This book satirizes under an allegorical
Series : Portsmouth, Worcester, Cambridge, Fry (Agnes), Stars and Constellations : a Little
transparency the political institutions of the
Liverpool, Edinburgh, Oxford, and Leeds, Guide to the Sky.
day. The dreamer of the dream-one amongst
edited by Mrs. Bernard Bosanquet, 1/ net.
This book claims to provide hints for observers
many pilgrims, Log-Rollers, Axe-Grinders,
Seven towns are treated by seven writers in of the heavens with the naked eye. Memory is
White Caps, Black Caps, and a certain Dame
under 100 pages, many of which are devoted assisted by rhymes such as have recently engaged
Eugenes-joins a caravan accompanying an
to details more fitting to guide-books. The the attention of Notes and Queries, a method
envoy from Plutopolis to the Royal Court of
important fact that there is a difference of two generally regarded as obsolete.
Demos. On the journey the author avails
years between the age of leaving school and
himself of every opportunity for a tilt at the
entering the Navy, which lamentably affects
Hutchinson (Woods), We and Our Children.
party system, but there is no indication that the
Portsmouth lads, is, like other matters, put
A series of essays on the care of the coming independent politician is less obnoxious to him,
in so uninteresting a fashion that it will not
generation, especially go far as its home por hint as to how the development of altruism
attract the attention it deserves. C. V.
life is concerned. The elementary teaching in the individual which he urges is to be either
Butler on “Oxford,' and Clara Dorothea Rack-
in such chapters as that on 'The Sweet Tooth fostered or directed.
ham on 'Cambridge,' are more interesting than
or 'Our Ivory Keepers of the Gate? reiterates
the other writers.
truths which every wise mother endeavours to
Cook (W. Victor), Anton of the Alps, 6/
put into practice.
The author is an optimist
The intricacies and vicissitudes of this tale
Philology.
who views even the falling birth-rate, modern
of secret societies are not even made probable
fiction, and the American mother through
by the most opportune deaths, accidents, and
Akerlund (Alfred), The History of the Definite rose-coloured glasses.
discoveries. However, the plots and counter-
Tenses in English, 2/6 net.
Lee (Frederic S. ), Scientific Features of Modern
plots are ingeniously worked out, and the story
An investigation into the periphrastic forms
has plenty of buoyancy.
Medicine, 6/6 net.
of the active tenses and their development from Some of the Columbia University Lectures.
the Old English. The author adopts as his
Eyles (Alfred W. ), The Topmost Rung.
The chief interest of this story lies in a
premise the hypothesis that the present parti- Psychical Research Society, Proceedings, Decem-
ciple construction is the same as that occurring
ber, 1911, 1/ net.
murder mystery. As is usual in this type of
in Old English-morphologically, if not his-
Consists of official lists and Index to Vol. XXV. thing, several innocent persons are suspected.
torically. This disposes of the alternative Thorpe (Sir Edward), A Dictionary of Applied
There are two trials, but the real culprit dies
a natural death. Overwhelmed, no doubt, by
theory of the verbal noun. The author intends Chemistry : Vol. I. A-Che, Řevised and
to formulate in a later essay an opinion of
the prevailing complexity of affairs, the book-
Enlarged Edition, 45/ net.
the functions of the verbal noun through the
binders so mixed up the centre four sections
For notice see p. 71.
various stages of the language. The treatise is
of our copy as to make it practically impossible
typical of the thoroughness of German methods
Whetham (W. C. D. and C. D. ), An Introduction to read them. The author has much to learn;
of scholarship.
to Eugenics, 1/ net.
though his plot is in a conventional way in-
The authors, in their endeavour to open up genious, his style is singularly stilted.
Benton (P. Askell), Kanuri Readings, including the immense field of inquiry in a science still
Facsimiles of MSS. , Transliteration, Interlinear in its infancy, lay greater stress on the methods
For the Defence : a Brief for Lady Carol, 6/
Translation, and Notes ; also a Complete and range of such an inquiry than on any
The publishers tell us that the author of this
English-Kanuri Vocabulary and Partial theoretical deductions to which, as yet, research
book has " a long list of successes to his name,'
Kanuri-English Vocabulary, 6/ net.
has led. The contents include six chapters
and that, as the present book is on some-
A supplementary textbook to 'A Kanuri devoted to the ' History of Eugenics,' two to
what different lines from anything he has
Grammar and African Native Literature in
Racial Qualities,' three on the Methods of
hitherto attempted, he is anxious to publish
Kanuri,' published by the Church Missionary Research, and five on the Construction of
it anonymously. ' We regret that we cannot
Society. It consists of a number of native
Society,' with an appendix and bibliography.
commend this departure from his successful
legends and fables, with literal translations and
The phenomenon of a restricted birth-rate,
style. Frankly, the book is gloomy, and the
vocabulary, and a list of Kanuri prefixes and which has profoundly modified biological
chief figures bore us ; when one wants to get
suffixes. The fables are naive and fanciful.
sociology, gives supreme importance to the
married, the other doesn't, and thus they
The Kanuri are the dominant tribe of Bornu, subject.
fluctuate throughout the book. The central
three-fourths of which are part of the British
Juvenile Books.
incident recalls a recently successful play.
Protectorate of Nigeria.
Dinan (W. ), Monumenta Historica
Fraser (Mrs. Alick), The Minister's Marriage, 6/
Celtica :
Where the Hedgerows End, and Other Fairy Tales,
by Ishbel, 1) net.
The minister in point is Evan Angus, an
Notices of the Celts in the Writings of the A series of fairy stories agreeable enough,. intellectual Apollo, who writes books on such
Greek and Latin Authors from the Tenth
but deficient in dramatic concentration. Each subjects as Antilegomena and Sermocination,
Century B. C. to the Fifth Century A. D. , of the longer tales comprises a number of which, we are told, are anxiously awaited by
arranged Chronologically, with Translations,
vignettes loosely strung together, and when both press and publishers! The number of
Commentary, Indices, and a Glossary of the
they are numerous too kaleidoscopic to be
Celtic Names and Words occurring in these
marriages recorded is extraordinary. Angus
coherent. “ (shbel's method is apparently himself loves at first sight, marries another
Authors, 15/ net.
to piece together the tags and shreds of fairy woman, and after her death loves again, all
Modern Language Review, January, 41 net.
lore into a mosaic.
in the space of about two years.


## p. (#68) #################################################

68
No. 4395, Jan. 20, 1912
THE ATHENÆUM
as
an
66
Fraser (Mrs. Hugh) and Stahlmann (J. I. ), The nent part. A medley of fighting, deeds of the Original Edition of 1629, with Introduction
Satanist, 6/
valour, witchcraft, and love ensue, which and Notes, 6/ net.
An unpleasant tale, which we are unable to should please readers who care more for the Dr. Gray has accomplished an effective
commend, concerning a sect of devil-worshippers tale than the method of its telling.
work in resuscitating Carliell, whose biography
at the beginning of the twentieth century. Spencer (Denton), Old Thane's Mummy, 1/
has never been written before, while his plays
Henry (0. ), Cabbages and Kings, 3/6 net.
The story of an antiquary's daughter who are buried under-in our opinion—a deserved
The work of this finished and subtle author
masquerades
Egyptian mummy
oblivion. 'The Deserving Favourite,' the least
has never received the meed that is its due.
brought to life. She disappears, is found, and
wearisome of those plays, is founded on a
He is one of the few writers of short stories
reunited to her distracted lover; while the
Spanish romantic novel, and Carliell owed much
who have claims on posterity. His power of professor incidentally is burnt in his own home,
of his tepid inspiration to foreign sources. He
conjuring up men and women and stamping The same process is to be observed in Mr.
translated one of Corneille's plays. Like most
them with vital significance in a curiously Spencer's novel as in 'The Mysteries of Udolpho. '
of the dramatists of the seventeenth century
haphazard and semi-abstracted way gives Our imagination is stimulated to eerie pitch who wrote heroic plays, Carliell embroiders his
his individual charm and creative force unity. by the implication of supernatural agencies at
plots round the eternal theme of love and
His confident and at the same time plastic style
is effective for his purpose.
work, only to be promptly disillusioned by the
honour. His volubility and edifying magnilo-
banality of a hoax. The style is a nice blend
quence are inexhaustible. He never deviates
Herbertson (Agnes Grozier), The Ship that came of the Johnsonian and the interjectional.
from the conventional regulations which this
Home in the Dark, 6/
dramatic genre imposed upon him.
A woman living in strained relations with her
Stevens (E. S. ), The Lure.
husband, who is blind, falls in love and runs
This describes two episodes, altogether Le Braz (Anatole), The Night of Fires, and other
Handy Newspaper List, 1912, 6d.
away with another man. The situation is
different in character, in the career of Huntly
interesting, but we decline to believe in the
Goss, adventurer. In the first we find him
Breton Studies, put into English by Frances
M. Gostling, 5/ net.
success of the impersonation practised on the
managing a journal" by the aristocracy, for
blind man.
Introduces the reader to types of Breton
The story, however, is well told,
the aristocracy. ” In the second part of the
book he reappears connected with a fraudulent
peasants and customs.
and the interest sustained throughout.
A good deal of the
Holdsworth (Annie E. ), Dame Verona of the
crocodile-farming business, the situation of
matter is commonplace, and for this we do not
Angels.
which enables the author to give some convin-
conceive the blame rests entirely with the
translator.
This book is a study of temperament to
cing descriptions of Sudanese scenery. Ap.
which pre-natal influence is supposed to supply
parently, the two years' interval between the Morgan (Charlotte E. ), The Rise of the Novel of
the key. A more uncomfortable coterie of episodes had changed him, for he is no longer Manners: a Study of English Prose Fiction
troubled consciences than those which surround
the epigrammatic flâneur, but & scoundrel
between 1600 and 1740, 6/6 net.
the subject of the study it would be difficult to
who will stick at nothing. It says much for The bibliography, containing a list of some
find. They include a dour Calvinist, the lady
the author's writing that we do not regret this five hundred prose narratives printed between
who has been willing to marry him for love
scoundrel's escape from justice.
1600 and 1740, with chronological accessories,
of his illegitimate baby girl, the baby's aunt- Tynan (Katharine), Princess Katharine, 6/
and the index, occupies well-nigh one-half of
a baffled, revengeful woman who draws Verona
For notice see p. 63.
this monograph. It deals with the prose out-
towards the Romanism so hateful to her father Vahey (H. L. ), Camilla Forgetting Herself, 6/
put between the beginning of the seventeenth
--and an extraordinary youth who shares her As the author remarks on the first page,
century and the middle of the eighteenth,
passion for sacrifice.
Camilla never did forget herself, so we can only
adopting a somewhat arbitrary form of classi-
Kelston (Beatrice), A Three-Cornered Duel, 6/ suppose that Mr. Vahey thought it was an at-
fication. Though freshness, colour, and in-
The author's clever and delicate handling tractive title and as good as any other. This
sight are not prominent in this volume, which
of an ingenious plot commends her book. Her book cannot be said to be an improvement on
forms one of the Columbia University Studies
characters are full of the joy of life, and well his previous work. The story is concerned with
in English, its scrupulous and conscientious
portrayed. One only regrets that so small a two perpetual honeymooners who are
workmanship, and its presentation of all the
part is allotted to the deaf housekeeper, Mrs. absurdly happy, and, it may be added, rather
facts that bear upon the subject, deserve bigb
Allgood, whose humble calling and retiring silly. There are two stage uncles introduced
praise.
disposition place her in the background.
to give some semblance of a plot.
New Monthly (The), No. 1, December, 1911, Coro-
Mackenzie (Compton), Carnival, 6/
Yorke (Curtis), Dangerous Dorothy: 61
nation Durbar Number, 6 annas.
For notice see p. 62.
“ Curtis Yorke neither multiplies incident, Old-Lore Miscellany of Orkney, Shetland, Caith-
Mann (Mary E. ), Men and Dreams.
nor unravels motives, nor panders to the ness, and Sutherland, January, 2/6
The talent of Mrs. Mary E. Mann does not sensational. She is no propagandist ; nor is Issued by the Viking Club.
show to its fullest advantage in short stories, she careful about her structure. Her novels-
Oxford and Cambridge Review, January, 2/6 net.
and only perhaps from one of the twenty: the latest one in particular-seem written With the New Year the Review shows aggres-
two in this volume could her_authorship be purely for the sake of dialogue. The characters
sive energy. Sir William Bull sounds the
divined. That one is ‘His First Day at the Sea,' exist merely to talk-to bandy sprightly witti- tattoo in 'The Red Flood'; a “ Believer in the
a wonderful vignette of a school treat burdened cisms and toss sentimental badinage at one Book " writes an alarmist article on the in-
by the addition of an undesired and undesirable another. The plot is huddled away, and serves sidious and destructive advance of Modernism
parent. Four or five of the rest are pervaded the subsidiary purpose of churning out episodes in the Church of England ; Mr. H. S. Shelton
by humorous and sometimes bitter irony, to further the conversations.
takes up an uncompromising position on The
and make distinctly good reading ; but only
Dissipation of Energy,' the theory of which
the story of the school treat has the unique
in doctrinaire form is, he declares, non-existent ;
and pungent flavour which the discerning seek,
General Literature.
and Mr. J. Hudson writes a sardonic poem on
and the dull detest, in the work of Mrs. Mann.
Pillai (T. Ramakrishna), The Dive for Death.
Dublin Review, edited by Wilfrid Ward, No. 300, woman's rights. " Amid this controversial
In spite of its title, this is an entrancing
January, 5/6 net.
turmoil, it is pleasant to light upon gentle dis-
romance, revealing, as it does, the intimate
This number is well diversified, and each
cursive matter here and there on mediæval
byways and scenes of Indian life. The most
article is equipped with sober and careful argu-
modes of Indian thought and feeling. It is
devoid of pretentiousness, and its subtlety is
ment. The editor takes advantage of Mr.
attractive article is that of the Rev. R. L. Gales,
cloaked by a transparent simplicity of style.
Balfour's retirement for a pleasant eulogy, and
who talks with sly urbanity and wit on · Three
The author's characterization is bold and
strings together some reminiscences of Tennyson
Jingle Makers '--Mr. Belloc, Mr. Chesterton,
direct, and his penetration into the Indian
at Freshwater. Mr. R. H. Benson refuses to
and Mr. Kipling.
mind is such that he can evoke an instant
commit himself either to a rationalist or Popham (R. Brooks), Finger-posts to Animal Life,
response from the Western reader by the
psychical conclusion in Phantasms of the 5/ net.
most sparing of effects. This novel is bountiful
Dead,' though he constructs a tentative theory “ The writer has had his nomadic days, and
of incident, crowded with pictorial detail of
of his own. The best things are a number of has had his chats. Hopping and skipping
translations of early Irish religious poetry: about over this little world of ours. . . .
Hindu lore and superstition, but never crudely
This
spectacular. The author has childlike
A somewhat Ultramontane article, entitled quotation from the Foreword gives a fair idea
pleasure in spontaneous and unsophisticated
Anti-Clerical Policy in Portugal,' attempts to of the author's method. His constant and
emotion.
depreciate the administration of the new Portu- unusually awkward flippancy makes it difficult
Prague (Joseph), A Woman of Impulse, 6/
guese Republic.
to realize the animals he talks about. It also
In everyday life a woman of impulse
Gornall (H. K. ), The Ten Talents :
occasionally betrays him, e. g. , in his account
an Uncon-
of a bull in India, into bad taste. We have
ventional Commentary.
may be a somewhat trying person; in the realms
of fiction she lives in a charmed atmosphere.