No More Learning

? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2015-01-02 09:08 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/hvd. 32044085188480 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 124 NOTES.
36-7. ] The youths reply with an insinuation that
their competitors feel less indignation than they
express.
The comparisons which follow, vs. 39--58, are
hardly surpassed in elegance of expression and
aptness of similitude, in any language.
45. dum . dum] "prius dum signified quoad,
sequens usque eo. "--Quint. Inst. Lib. 9. cap. 3.
CARMEN XLI.
Of Atys.
"Atys was a beautiful youth, probably of Greece,
who, forsaking his home and parents, sailed with a
few companions to Phrygia, and having landed,
hurried to the grove consecrated to the great god-
dess Cybele. There struck with superstitious
frenzy, he qualified himself for the service of that
divinity; and snatching the musical instruments
used in her worship, he exhorted his companions
who had followed his example, to ascend to the
temple of Cybele. At this part of the poem, we
follow the new votary of the Phrygian goddess
through all his wild traversing of woods and moun-
tains, till at length, having reached the temple,
Atys and his companions drop asleep, exhausted by
fatigue and mental distraction. Being tranquillized
in some measure by a night's repose, Atys becomes
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2015-01-02 09:08 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/hvd. 32044085188480 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? NOTES.
125
sensible of the misery of his situation, and struck
with horror at his rash deed, he returns to the sea-
shore. There he casts his eyes bathed in tears
over the ocean homeward, and comparing his for-
mer happiness with his present wretched condition,
he pours forth a complaint unrivalled in energy and
pathos. The violent bursts of passion are admira-
bly aided by the irresistible torrent of words, and
by the cadence of a measure powerfully denoting
mental agony and remorse* It is the only speci-
men we have in Latin of the Galliambie measure,
so called because sung by the Galli, the effeminate
votaries of Cybele.
The story of Atys is one of the most mysterious
of the mythological emblems. The fable was ex-
plained by Porphyry; and the emperor Julian after-
wards invented and published an allegory of this
mystic tale. According to them, the voluntary
emasculation of Atys was typical of the revolution
of the sun between the tropics, or the separation
of the human soul from vice and error. " Dunlop.
Ovid (Fasti Lib. 4, vs. 223--244) gives a version
of the story of Atys, quite different from that of
Catullus.
The inscription of this poem is very various in
* Gibbon, however, in a spirit of juster criticism perhaps, speaks
(History, chapter 33) "of the transition of Atys from the wildest
enthusiasm to sober pathetic complaint for his irretrievable loss. "
f
11
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2015-01-02 09:08 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/hvd. 32044085188480 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 126
NOTES.
different editions. De AtHne in Sillig, Attis in Voss,
de Attine furore percito in others. Pansanias and
Lucian write the name Artr^. Some manuscripts
Atthys.
4. vagus animi] A Greek rather than a Latin
construction, by which a word definitely limiting a
general epithet, or proposition is put in the genitive.
--See Matthiae Gr. Gram. sec. 339.
8. citato] mark the change of gender, typanum]
i. q. tympanum in imitation of the rvnavov of the
Greek poets, as well as for the sake of the metre.
An instrument resembling very exactly our tambo-
rine. v. 20. compare Carm. 42. v. 262.
9. typanum) in apposition with tubam, or used
adjectively, the 'trumpet--typanum. ' This instru-
ment occupied the place of the tuba, which were
not used in the mysteries of Cybele. Cybelle]
metri causa. Bentley ad Lucan. Phars. I. 600.
writes Cybebe, and gives this rule, "ut ubique scri-
bendum est, quoties media syllaba protrahitur. "
16. truculenta pelagi] Truculenta has the force of
a substantive and governs the genitive, as is not
uncommonly the case with neuter adjectives as
well in the plural as in the singular.
18. herae] Atys.
21. cymbaMm] an instrument consisting of two
circular plates of brass or steel, or concave with
circular edges, which were held one in each hand,
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2015-01-02 09:08 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/hvd. 32044085188480 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? NOTES. 127
and when struck together, produced a sharp ringing
sound.
22. Tibicen . . Phryx] the Phrygian measure is
celebrated for its exciting and maddening effects
vide Quinct. Lib. I. cap. 10. grave] in opposition to
acute.
43. eum] Referring to somnus v. 42. Pasithea]
the wife of Somnus, quasi TiagiSta 'omnibus benigna. '
71. colt/minibus] 'mountains. '
75. nuntia] 'tidings' neuter plural from nuntium.
78. hinc] Sillig has hunc, " hunc (bc, Attinem) face
ut redeat. "
CARMEN XLII.
The Nuptials of Peleus and Thetis.
This is the longest and most highly wrought of
the poems of Catullus, and may be ranked among
the finest productions of the Latin Muse. It
abounds in strikingly distinct descriptions, and
pathetic and eloquent expressions of passion. The
despairing anguish of the forsaken Ariadne, her
reproaches mingled with love for her betrayer, are
hardly any way inferior to the dying language of
Dido, (Virg. iEneid 4. ) and far superior to the
strained sentiments and tamer expressions of the
same Ariadne in Ovid. (Heroides, Ep. 10. ) The
picture of the sad daughter of Minus standing on
the extreme beach--her hair loosened to the winds,
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2015-01-02 09:08 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/hvd. 32044085188480 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 128 NOTES.
the veil which had hid her hosom, and her woven
girdle, fallen at her feet and tossed unheeded by
the waves, gazing after the vessel that bears away
her false lover, and forgetting all but the despair of
her own abandonment, is worthy of the highest
efforts of the sculptor or the painter. The con-
cluding verses (385 ad fin. ) are in a tone of sad re-
gret, and of severe morality, which the Poets of
Rome seldom attained.
The poem opens with a rapid sketch of the
Argonautic expedition, the surprise of the Pontic
sea nymphs, and the mutual attachment of Peleus
and Thetis. After a hasty congratulation, the Poet
passes to the scene of the nuptials, the thronging
of the Thessalian youth, who deserted the labors
of the field and of the vineyard--the palace and the
festal splendors of Peleus. Among the nuptial
ornaments is a curiously embroidered quilt, the
description of which and the narratives suggested
by it, comprise the longer part of the poem. On
one portion is represented Ariadne deserted by
Theseus on the shore of Naxos ; in connection with
which the Poet relates the causes which led The-
seus to Crete, the love and flight of Ariadne, and
the unhappy forgetfulness which proved the death
of jEgeus. On another part, is represented Bac-
chus enamored and pursuing Ariadne, and the
orgies of his attendants. Returning from this
episode, he introduces the Gods and Demi Gods
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2015-01-02 09:08 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/hvd. 32044085188480 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? NOTES. 129
honoring the nuptials with their presence, and
bringing each his peculiar and appropriate gifts.
During the feast, the Parcae, whose persons and
labors are minutely described, sing a fit epithalami-
um, predicting the future glory of Achilles, the
promised offspring. The poem concludes in a
strain of touching mournfulness, contrasting with
the latter times, the blessedness of those days
when the celestials were wont to honor with their
presence the abodes and the solemn assemblies of
men; and dwells in a few sad lines on the crimes
which had withdrawn from men the friendship and
fellowship of the Gods.
5. Colchis] dative plural, 'the Colchians. '
8. Diva] Minerva. Hor. Lib. I. vol. 7. "intactae
Palladia arces. " quibus] referring to juvenes v. 4.
9. Ipsa] this labor is ascribed to Minerva, by
Seneca, Medea v. 365. and by Claudian de bello
Getico, v. 16.
11. Ilia] sc. carina, imbuit] "imbuere est pro-
prieinchoareetinitiare. " Servius. Amphitriten] 'the
sea,' here the Pontic sea, for Catullus afterwards
mentions the voyage of Theseus as anterior.
14, 15. ] are thus construed by Vossy emersere
aequoreae Nereides e candenti gurgite admirantes
monstrum feri vullus. monstrum feri vullus--the
Argo. To construe Nereides in apposition with feri
vultu3 may seem better to accord with the simple and
natural arrangement usually preferred by Catullus.
11*
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2015-01-02 09:08 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/hvd. 32044085188480 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 130 NOTES.
21. sensit] Voas reads sanxit, from the conjec-
ture of Pontanus. If this were preferred, pater
ipse would of course refer. to Jupiter.
27. suos . . .
concessit amores] Jupiter had loved
Thetis, but was induced to resign her, as the fates
had ordained according to the prediction of Prome-
theus, that the offspring of Thetis should become
greater than his father. Quinct. Lib. 3. cap. 7.
28. Neptunine] patronimic.
29. 30. ] Oceanus and Tethys begot Nereus and
Doris, and they the Nereids, of whom Thetis.
35. Scyros] a distant island, but once subject to
the Thessalians. Phthiotica Tempe] Tempe in
Phhiotis. The word Tempe first used to designate
a small and delightful portion of the valley of the
Peneus, was afterward applied to any spot distin-
guished for its pleasantness.
36. Cranonis . . Larrissea] both towns of Thes-
ealy.
43. Ipsius] 'of Peleus. '
49. purpura] equivalent to hac vestis, v. 50. Hor.
Lib. 2. Od. 18. v. 8.
52. Dia] commonly supposed to be Naxos. Some
however say the small island lying just off the shore
of Crete, a little north-west of Panormus. See Plu-
tarch Vita Thes.
60. Minois] 'daughter of Minos. '
61. bacchantis Eva] "mulieris Bacchi furore cor-
reptae et Evoe Evoe clamantis. " Vulpius. See v. 256.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2015-01-02 09:08 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/hvd. 32044085188480 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? NOTES. 131
75. injusti regis] from the cruel war he waged
and the tribute he imposed on Athens. This Minos
-was a grandson of the Cretan Minos so famed for
the equity of his laws.
83. funera . . nefunera] 'mourned as dead while
living. ' Isocrates speaking of the same event, uses
the expression nsrSovfUrov? art ? <3rru! ;. Encomium
Helenae sec. 13.
96. Golgos] a place in Cyprus, sacred to Venus.
103. frustra] in relation to the desired affection
of Theseus.
104. tacito labello] 'with whispered prayer. ' The
? epithet tacitus is applied usually where the object
of the prayer is impious or improper. Persius Sat.
2, v. 5. "tacita libavit acerra. " compare Horace, Lib.
1. Ep. 16, v. 60. "labra movet metuens audiri," and
in the fourth book of Tibullus, Carm. 5, v. 18.
Here the prayer of Ariadne for the safety of The-
seus might imply that she ceased to mourn for the
loss of her brother.
145. apisci] for adipisd.
150. germanum] the Minotaur.
159. parentis] jEgeus the father of Theseus, as
is evident from the succeeding lines. prisci] 'old'
hence severe to the fancies of hia son.
179. invidit] 'denies. '
179. aquor] from aquus, properly means 'the
surface. '
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2015-01-02 09:08 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/hvd. 32044085188480 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 132 NOTES. '
180. quemne] observe the negative force of ne in
this line, as also in v. 183.
217. Reddite] vocative participle. Theseus was
born in the extreme old age of jEgeus. --Plutarch
Vita Thesei.
227. Itoni] a town of Thessaly, from which the
Athenians are said to have derived the worship of
Minerva.
232. JEtas] 'time. ' so v. 238, commonly a limited
period.
236. ] unquestionably a spurious verse.
239. mandata] subject of liquire understood.
252. paHe ex alia] sc. vestis.
299. ] The only nuptials of mortals which were
honored by the presence of the Gods. --Isocrates,
Evagoras, 6.
301. ldri] a mountain of C'aria, where were many
spots sacred to Apollo and Diana.
308. quercus] erot is understood. Habited in
branches of oak, or perhaps in robes inwoven with
oak leaves. The oak was an oracular tree.
309. Tyro] the daughter of Salmoneus. ora]
'border' Theocritus, Pharmac. vs. 121, 2, speaks of
a wreath of poplar entwined with purple ribbons.
312--314. ] 'The right hand, with the fingers
turned upward, first draws the thread, then with
the thumb reversed whirls the spindle. '
324. ] addressed to Peleus.
325. nato] Achilles.
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2015-01-02 09:08 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/hvd. 32044085188480 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? NOTES. 133
342. ]' Homer everywhere calls him noSag cixi);.
347. terlius hares] Agamemnon. Pelops left his
kingdom to Atreus his son, Atreus to Thyestes his
brother, and Thyestes to Agamemnon his nephew,
the son of Atreus.
382. putrida] 'wasted' by age. variabunt] 'dis-
color. '
402. prim<Bvi] 'yet in early manhood. '
403. innupta . . novercoz] 'a daughter-in-law wid-
owed by the death of her husband. ' Sallust, Bell.
Cat. 15.
404. ] an allusion perhaps to CEdipus.
CARMEN XLII1.
To Hortalus.
Catullus had promised Hortalus a translation or
imitation of the poem of Callimachus, entitled de
Coma Berenices, but had been long delayed in ex-
ecuting this promise, by his grief for the loss of a
tenderly loved brother. He at length sends him the
poem from Callimachus completed, with this poetical
apology for his delay. In many manuscripts this is
found as the introductory portion of the following
poem.
2. Horiale] supposed to be Marcus Hortalus, or
Ortalus the grandson of Hortensius.
14. Daulias] 'the Daulian,' Procne. For the
story of Procne and Itys, see Ovid Metam. Lib.
'
? ? Generated for (University of Chicago) on 2015-01-02 09:08 GMT / http://hdl. handle. net/2027/hvd. 32044085188480 Public Domain, Google-digitized / http://www. hathitrust. org/access_use#pd-google
? 134 NOTES.
6. v. 620, seq. In the Heroides, Ep. 15. v. 154,
he calls her Daulias ales.
16.