No More Learning

It is by carefully con- of Synnövé in marriage, which is
sulting the individual tastes of her pupils granted by her parents. The story has
that « The Good French Governess” re- been called one of Björnson's master-
forms Mrs. Harcourt's family. Tact is pieces; and shows his fine perception of
the secret of the “Good Aunt's success human nature, and his skill in revealing
in her educational experiment. Miss the traits and characteristics of the
Edgeworth teaches boys and girls to de- peasantry of his native country. The
spise self-indulgence and uncontrolled development of the savage beauty of
emotion; and to mistrust appearances. Thorbjörn's character, and the strong
Her model hero is young Mr. Mount- scene at the church door, where he
eagle, the matrimonial prize in Made- becomes reconciled to his former enemy,
moiselle Panache, who, momentarily at- show the marvelous power of the author.
tracted by the beauty of Lady Augusta,
has the sense to perceive her inferiority Rab and His Friends. by Dr. John
, amiable
story by a
Helen Temple.
well-beloved Edinburgh physician, is
one of the choicest of English classics.
Synnövé Solbakken, by Björnstjerne Rab is a sturdy mastiff — "old, gray,
Björnson. This story, which brindled, as big as a little Highland
the first to reveal to the world at large bull ») — with "Shakespearean dewlaps
the genius of the author, was brought shaking as he goes. His friends are
out in 1857, in a Norwegian newspaper, his master and mistress, James Noble,
and
not translated into English the Howgate carrier, “a keen, thin, im-
until 1870, although it had previously patient, black-a-vised little man”; and
appeared in French, German, Spanish, the exquisite old Scotchman, his wife
and Russian. The scene of the narra- Ailie, with her unforgettable face, pale,
tive is laid among the Norwegian hills, serious, lonely, delicate, sweet, with
which are minutely and picturesquely dark gray eyes “full of suffering, full
described. Synnövé, the daughter of a also of the overcoming of it. ” Ailie is
well-to-do farmer, is a pretty and charm- enduring a terrible malady; and her
ing girl, idolized by her parents and
husband wraps
her carefully in his
beloved by all who know her. She loves plaid and brings her in his cart to the
her early friend and schoolmate Thor- hospital, where her dignified patient
björn Granliden, who is generally consid- lovableness through a dangerous opera-
ered a rough and vindictive fellow. He
tion moves even the thoughtless medi-
is the son of worthy parents, but his cal students to tears. She is nursed by
father, by over-severity towards him in her husband. Handy, and clever, and
was
was


## p. 525 (#561) ############################################

SYNOPSES OF NOTED BOOKS
525
was
swift, and patient as any woman, was versation, but frequently the writer in
that horny-handed, snell, peremptory
his own
person addresses the reader
little man;
» while Rab, quiet and obedi- directly. In whatever guise he appears,
ent, but saddened and disquieted by however, we cannot help recognizing the
the uncomprehended trouble, jealously genial personality of Holmes himself.
guards the two. Perhaps no truer, more As he says in the verses subjoined as
convincing dog character exists in lit- epilogue to the series:
erature than that of ugly faithful Rab.
“A Boswell, writing out himself!
The pathos in the simple lives of him-
For though he changes dress and name,
self and his friends is heightened by the
The man beneath is still the same,
tinge of Scotch dialect, as well as by the
Laughing or sad, by fits and starts,
One actor in a dozen parts,
author's wise self-restraint.
The story
And whatsoe'er the mask may be,
springs from his scientific knowledge of The voice assures us, This is he. »
life and disease, like a flower from the
soil. Its essence and charm lie in the
Martian, The, by George Du Maurier,
warm-heartedness and refined sympathy his third and last novel, was pub-
which lift it above science, and vibrate lished posthumously in 1897. The hero
contagiously in every word.
is Barty Josselin, the story of whose
life is told by his friend and companion,
Poet at the Breakfast Table, The, Robert Maurice. The school life of the
by Oliver Wendell Holmes. (The two lads in the Institution F. Brossard,
Poet,' like its predecessors, (The Auto- in Paris, is sketched in detail in Du
crat) and (The Professor,)
first Maurier's inimitable manner, the account
printed as a series of papers in the being largely autobiographic. Barty is
Atlantic Monthly, making its appearance from the start a handsome, high-spirited,
in 1872.
In merit it is somewhat su- mischievous, and gifted fellow, thor-
perior to “The Professor, but hardly oughly practical, yet with traits that
equal to (The Autocrat”; and though have in them a strange idealism. After
containing the familiar Aunt Tabitha,' school, the boys return to England, and
and Homesick in Heaven, has nothing Barty goes into the army, but does not
to be compared with (The Chambered like it, and resigns. Then his eyes give
Nautilus) or (The One-Hoss Shay. ) out; and he travels for a time, and con-
Like the earlier volumes, it consists of sults various physicians, being helped
rambling, discursive talks on many sub- finally by a celebrated German special.
jects, — religion, science, literature, — with ist, Dr. Hasenclover, who assures him
a frequent excursion into the realm of that he will be blind in only one eye.
philosophy. The local flavor is very Before this, he has come to such melan-
strong, as usual with Holmes; and prob- cholic discouragement that he intends
ably the papers will always have a suicide; being saved therefrom by dis-
greater attraction for New-Englanders covering in a dream that he has a kind
than for those to whom the local allus- of guardian spirit, the Martian, a woman
ions are pointless, and the setting alien. soul, who has undergone a series of in-
Nevertheless, the author's sympathies carnations, and is now an inhabitant of
are as wide as humanity itself; and he Mars. She advises him about his eyes,
gives many a hard hit at prejudice and and thereafter, for many years, she con-
intolerance. Moreover he says repeatedly stantly communicates with him and helps
that his chief object in writing is to him, using a kind of shorthand called
meet some need of his fellow-creatures, blaze. She inspires him to write won-
to strike some chord that shall wake a derful books, whereby he becomes
responsive note in some kindred soul. famous author. Against her advice, he
Certainly this wide-reaching human kind- obeys the dictates of his heart by mar-
liness is not the least charm of this de- rying Leah Gibson, a noble Jewess, when
lightful book.
the Martian would have had him choose
The principal persons at the table are Julia Royce, an English belle whom he
the Poet; the Old Master, a scholarly meets in Germany. The marriage is so
philosopher; the Scarabee, a withered happy that the Martian acknowledges
entomologist; the poetic young astrono- her mistake. When Barty's daughter
mer; Scheherazade, a young girl who Martia is born, the Martian becomes
writes stories; and the Lady. All of incarnated in her form; and upon the
these occasionally take part in the con- young girl's death, the strange being
a


## p. 526 (#562) ############################################

526
SYNOPSES OF NOTED BOOKS
a
no
from another world returns to Mars, and opinions, serves Laboulaye as a means
whereupon Barty himself also passes of expressing himself pungently on many
away. The charm of the story lies in points wherein his own country might
the genial description of bohemian friend- well learn of a younger nation.
ship and love, seen retrospectively in The first bewildering change which
the half-light of illusion; and in the greets the metamorphosed physician is
suggestive way in which the odd super- the exceeding comfort of his household
natural element is woven into the nar- arrangements, with the unfamiliar baths
rative.
and heating apparatus; the next is the
affectionate and unrestrained attitude of
Tartuffe, by Molière (Jean Baptiste
his wife and children. A thunderbolt
Poquelin). This most famous com-
falls upon him when he finds his daugh-
edy, once performed under the title
“The Impostor,' was published complete
ter engaged to a man who has not pre-
viously asked his consent, and who makes
in 1669. The principal characters are:
Madame Pernelle; Orgon, her son; his
absolutely no inquiries about a dot. An
wife Elmire, his son, and daughter; and
equal surprise is the career of his son,
a friend, Tartuffe, who stands forth as a
who at sixteen chooses a business, finds
type of the religious hypocrite. The old
an opening, and departs, like a man, for
the Indies.
lady is very devout, but uses plain
words when scolding the grandchildren.
Then in a succession of humorously
Orgon, the husband, on coming home
interesting chapters the author takes his
hears that his wife is ill; but immedi-
hero through the civil world of America
ately inquires about Tartuffe, seeming to
as it was in the sixties; he makes him a
think of else.
volunteer fireman, shows him the inner
This honey-lipped
workings of the free American Press, in-
egoist is chosen by the father as the
itiates him into the bitter knowledge of
proper person to whom he should marry
what it is to be a candidate for office.
his daughter.
But she thinks not so. Those who
And the whole is told with the would be
are forced to marry against their will do
grumbling tone of an old fellow who
not make virtuous wives. The modesty
wants to believe in the superiority of his
of Tartuffe is easily shocked; yet he
adored country in every particular over
this land of savages. ”
would examine closely the material of
the dress of Elmire, to whom he pays
But alas when the sorcery is undone,
court, telling her that to sin in secret is
and the Parisian reawakes in fair Paris,
with an unmistakable French family about
not to sin at all. Elmire risks her repu-
tation a little to unmask the vile deceiver
him, he would fain have remained under
the enchantment. His son is no longer
in the eyes of her husband. Through
self-reliant; his daughter blushes and is
fear of hell, Tartuffe yet rules the hus-
shocked to tears at his suggestion that
band, gets his property by scheming, and
has him arrested as a traitor. At last
she shall marry the man of her heart;
and his wife is indignant that he should
the king acts; and Tartuffe is led off to
prison. This is a striking presentation
suppose his daughter so ill-bred as to have
of the manners and morals of the people
a choice. There is a keen reproach for
and times,
France in the mockery of the finale, which
pictures the doctor in an asylum, where
Paris in America (Paris en Ame- in the estimation of his countrymen, his
rique), by Édouard René Lefebvre strange ideas fit him to be an inmate.
Laboulaye. This satirical romance was
first published in 1863. Through the won-
Las
ast Days of Pompeii, The, by Ed-
derful adventures of a Parisian doctor of ward Bulwer, Lord Lytton. (1834. )
the conventional type, who with his whole The characters and scenes of this story
family is spirited away to America by a are in a great measure suggested by the
sorcerer, Laboulaye sets forth an amus- peculiarities of the buildings which are
ing contrast between many customs and still to be seen at Pompeii. The tale be-
institutions of the New World and those gins a few days before the destruction of
of his own «belle France. The whim- Pompeii, and ends with that event.
sical conceit of this old Frenchman sud- The simple story relates principally to
denly become in appearance and environ- two young people of Grecian origin,
ment an Americ: while retaining his GI cus and lone, who are deeply at-
memory and his hereditary prejudices tached to each other. The former is a


## p. 527 (#563) ############################################

SYNOPSES OF NOTED BOOKS
527
(
handsome young Athenian, impetuous, the book. "The Pearl of Orr's Island)
high-minded and brilliant, while Ione is was not published until 1862, although it
a pure and lofty-minded woman. Ar- was begun ten years before that time.
baces, her guardian, the villain of the
story, under a cloak of sanctity and Minister's Wooing, The, by Harriet
Beecher Stowe. The scene of this
religion, indulges in low and criminal
designs. His character is strongly
interesting story is laid in New Eng-
land, and deals with the habits and
drawn; and his passion for Ione, and the
traditions of the past century. Mary
struggle between him and Glaucus, form
the chief part of the plot. Nydia, the
Scudder, the only daughter of a wid-
owed mother, has been reared in an
blind girl, who pines in unrequited af-
fection for Glaucus, and who saves the
atmosphere of religion and piety. Being
lives of the lovers at the time of the
of a naturally sensitive temperament,
destruction of the city, by conducting
she lives up to their teachings with con-
scientious fervor. She is in love with
them in safety to the sea, is a touching
and beautiful conception. The book, full
her cousin, James Marvyn, but does not
of learning and spirit, is not only a
listen to his protestations, because he
charming
has no religious belief. He goes to sea,
novel, but contains many
be
minute and interesting descriptions of
is shipwrecked, and supposed to
ancient customs; among which, those
drowned; and Mary, in course of time,
feels it to be her duty and pleasure to
relating to the gladiatorial combat, the
become engaged to the venerable Dr.
banquet, the bath, are most noteworthy.
Hopkins, her pastor and spiritual ad-
viser. The wedding-day is set, and
Pearl of Orr's Island, The, by Harriet
Beecher Stowe. This story gives a
only one week distant, when Mary re-
truthful and interesting picture of the
ceives a letter from James Marvyn, tell-
ing of his miraculous escape from death,
people in a Maine fishing hamlet. Mara
Lincoln, the «Pearl, a beautiful girl,
his religious conviction, and change of
has been brought up by her grand-
heart, and his abiding love for her. He
follows the letter in person, and presses
parents, Captain and Mrs. Pennel; her
father having been drowned and her
his suit; but Mary, in spite of her in-
mother having died at her birth. Moses,
clinations, considers it her duty to abide
the hero of the book, shipwrecked and
by her promise to the Doctor. How-
washed ashore upon the island when
ever, through the intervention of Miss
Prissy Diamond, a delightful little dress-
very young, is brought up and cared
for by the Pennels; and bears their
maker, who acquaints Dr. Hopkins with
The result of this is the mutual
the facts of the case, this sacrifice is
attachment of the young people, which
prevented. The good Doctor, at the
is at first more strongly felt by Mara.
cost of his own happiness, relinquishes
The
Moses accepts Mara's devotion as a mat-
Mary, and gives her to James.
to
ter of course, and does not awaken to
central purpose in this story is
the fact that he is in love with her
show the sternness and inflexibility of
until piqued by the attentions bestowed
the New England conscience, which
holds to the Calvinistic doctrines through
upon her by Mr. Adams of Boston.
Then, prompted by jealousy, he pays
all phases of life. The struggle that
marked attention to Sally Kittridge, a
goes on in the heart of Mrs. Marvyn
bright and attractive girl, Mara's dear-
and of Mary, when James is supposed
to be drowned unconverted, is a graphic
est friend; but Sally, always loyal to
Mara, makes Moses realize the true state
delineation of the moral point of view at
of his feelings.
that time. All the characters in the
The descriptions of the picturesque
book are well drawn and have striking
individualities; Madame de Frontignac,
scenery of the island are graphic and
accurate; and the Pennel house, now
Miss Prissy, and Candace, the colored
known as the “Pearl house, and the
servant, being especially worthy of note.
“grotto,” where Moses and Sally are
The story was first published in serial
shut in by the tide, are objects of inter-
form in the Atlantic Monthly in 1859.
est to visitors.
Captain Kittridge, and the quaint say-
in form a
ings of Miss Roxy and Miss Ruey graphic and vivid picture of the political
Toothacre are entertaining features of condition in England during the Western
name.
The spicy sea-warns of Micah Clarke, by A. Conan Doyle,


## p. 528 (#564) ############################################

528
SYNOPSES OF NOTED BOOKS
an
Mr. Verdant
as
prose, the
runs
to
rebellion, when James, Duke of Mon- (Micah Clarke) is a book for old and
mouth, aspired to the throne, and when young; a book which instructs, while it
Englishmen were in arms against Eng- quickens the imagination and stirs the
lishmen. The story tells of the advent- blood.
ures of the young man whose name the
Green, Oxford
book bears, of the many perils which he
encountered on his journey from
Freshman, The Adventures of,
Ha-
by Cuthbert Bede” (Rev. Edward
vant to Taunton to join the standard of
Monmouth, and of the valiant part he
Bradley). Since its publication in 1853–
played in the final struggle, when the
57, this story has taken a certain place
an English humorous classic, com-
King's troops were victorious and hun-
dreds of Protestants, who had escaped
parable in some sort to Kortum's fa-
mous Jobsiad' in German (though one
death on the field, were hanged for trea-
is in
other in doggerel
son.
Through this melancholy but thrilling
verse), but on the whole sui generis.
It narrates the university adventures
narrative
a pretty vein of love-
of an innocent and simple young Eng-
making. The gentle and innocent Pur-
lishman of family and position, brought
itan maid, Mistress Ruth Timewell, who
up in the bosom of an adoring family;
had never heard of Cowley or Waller or
Dryden, and who was accustomed to de-
the pranks his fellow undergraduates
rive enjoyment from such books as the
play on him; the rather severe «course
(Alarm to the Unconverted, Faithful
of training ” they put him through, in
order
Contendings, or Bull's Spirit Cordial,
remove his home-feathers,”
and the result finally achieved. Humor
finds love more potent than theology,
and fun abound in it; and though much
and prefers Reuben Lockarby, a tavern-
of the fun is
keeper's son, to Master John Derrick, a
mere horse-play, and
much of the humor of a kind which a
man of her own faith.
But the climax of Micah Clarke) is
later literary taste finds happily out of
fashion, the book still gives pleasure to
reached in the description of the battle
the whole English undergraduate world,
on the plain in the early morning, in
and to a smaller American contingent.
which one learns what religion meant
in England toward the close of the six-
teenth century. Against the disciplinei Manxman, The, by Hall Caine, is a
present-day romance, the scene of
and well-equipped regiments of the King which is the Isle of Man. It was pub-
are opposed Monmouth's untrained and lished in 1894; and was the most success-
ragged forces, - peasants, armed only ful of the author's novels up to that
with scythes, pikes, and clubs, but with time. Old Iron Christian, Deemster (or
the unfaltering courage of fanaticism in Judge) of the Isle, has two sons,
their hearts and with psalms on their Thomas and Peter. The elder, Thomas,
lips.
marries below him and is disinherited.
Again and again they stand firm while He dies, leaving a son, Philip, who is
the serried ranks of the royal troops are
reared in the Deemster's house. The
hurled against them. They meet death younger, Peter, has an illegitimate son,
with a song, and flinch not. But as the Peter Quilliam, who loves pretty Kate
day advances, out of the fog break the Cregeen, daughter of an innkeeper. The
long lines of the King's cavalry, “wave two lads grow up together as
after wave, rich in scarlet and blue and friends. Peter and Kate
gold, and the scythe-men and pikemen hearts, but her father objects to him be.
of Monmouth are cut to pieces. The cause of his birth and poverty. Pete
duke himself, preferring life with dis- goes off to make his fortune, leaving
grace to honor and death, is seen gal- Kate in Philip's charge. Philip, during
loping in terror from the field. But his absence, wins her love and betrays
even as the leader flies, one of his peas- her. Meanwhile tidings come of Pete's
ant soldiers, whose arm had been par- death. Philip cares for Kate, but feels
tially severed by a ball, sits behind a that she is in the way of his ambition
clump of alder bushes freeing himself to become Deemster. He tells her that
from the useless limb with a broad- they must part; and on the return of
bladed knife, and giving forth the Pete, who was falsely reported dead, she
Lord's Prayer the while, without a pause marries the latter out of pique, hoping
or a quiver in his tone. ”
until the last that Philip will interfere
Sworn
are
Sweet-


## p. 529 (#565) ############################################

SYNOPSES OF NOTED BOOKS
529
name
as
and marry her himself. She has a child
She has a child | White Aprons, ja
romance of Ba-
by her husband, but is tortured by the
con's Rebellion, by Mrs. Maud
thought that it may be Philip's. The Wilder Goodwin, is a story of the strug-
shame of her loveless marriage nearly | gle in Virginia between popular rights
drives her crazy; and on Philip's return and aristocratic privilege a hundred
from abroad she runs away on the very years before the Revolution. The hero,
day that he becomes Deemster, to live Bryan Fairfax, is sent by Bacon to
with him secretly, under an assumed bring to his camp several ladies, adher-
The blow well-nigh crushes Pete ents of his opponent, Governor Berke-
when he returns to the empty house. ley. Among them is Penelope Payne,
He does not suspect that she has joined with whom the young soldier speedily
Philip; whom he tells that, solicitous for falls in love. Bacon sends Penelope to
her health, he has sent her to England. Jamestown to inform Berkeley that if he
To guard her good name he even re- attacks before noon, the women will be
ceives mock letters from her, written placed in front of Bacon's uncompleted
by himself. Philip represents to Pete works. Penelope taunts Bacon with
that she is dead. The husband never cowardice, and tells him that he and his
learns the truth, but leaves the island followers shall be known White
forever, placing the boy in Philip's keep- Aprons. The tide of war turns, Bacon
ing Their guilty union so preys upon dies, and Fairfax is taken prisoner by
the conscience of both Philip and Kate, Berkeley, who becomes an unbearable
however, that the woman at last leaves tyrant. When Fairfax is put on trial
him, and Philip offers what restitution for his life, Penelope, to the surprise of
he can.
He makes a public declaration all, comes forward to testify in his favor,
of his sin, resigns his high office, and and openly confesses her love for him.
takes in his own the hand of the Berkeley in a frenzy of rage condemns
woman he has loved and wronged, that Fairfax to death, but consents to his re-
they may begin life openly together. prieve for three months. Penelope
With this dramatic scene of the confes- straightway sets out for England to seek
sion the story closes.
a pardon from the King. She goes to
the house of her uncle, the historic
Leighton Court, by Henry Kingsley. Samuel Pepys, and there she meets
(1866). This book is an interesting Dryden, Buckingham, and various other
story of English social life at the time wits and beaux. The beauty of her
of the Indian mutiny. Robert, the portrait, painted by Kneller, obtains
younger brother of Sir Harry Poynitz, her an audience with the King; who,
masquerading as a master-of-houp
after a trial of her constancy, grants her
der the name of Hammersley, is en- the pardon, with which she makes all
gaged by Sir Charles Seckerton to take speed home, arriving at the critical mo-
care of his pack. He falls in love with ment when Fairfax is on the scaffold.
Laura Seckerton, and at last tells her The story ends as it begins with the
of his attachment, when she urges him burden of an old song: “Love will find
to leave the country. The next morn-
rn- out the way. ” Though slight in texture,
ing Hammersley's horse is discovered the work is very daintily executed, and
drowned on the sea-shore, and his mas- the spirit of colonial Virginia is well
ter is supposed to have shared the same suggested.
fate. Laura, believing him dead, ac-
cepts the hand of Lord Hatterleigh. Friendships of Women, The, by W. R.
The plot now concerns itself with gam- Alger (1868), is a curious and sug-
bling debts. family quarrels, and in- gestive work the emotional and
trigues social and financial, tale-bearings, affectionate side of woman-nature. The
challenges, and sudden deaths. It moves different chapters consider the friend-
rapidly, however, to a proper ending. ships of mothers and sons, of daughters
The author calls the story «a simple tale and fathers, of sisters and brothers, of
of country life. The character of Hat- wives and husbands, of mothers and
terleigh, with his sterling worth hidden daughters, of women and women. Pla-
under a rather dull and effeminate ex- tonic love is also considered at length.
terior, is very cleverly drawn, as is also The author is less the creator than the
Sir Harry Poynitz, with his life of ap- editor of hi subject. The chief value
parent villainy and final justification. of the work is indeed the vast number
XXX—34
un-
on


## p. 530 (#566) ############################################

530
SYNOPSES OF NOTED BOOKS
women
as
as-
men
Gervis, a brilliant diplomat, marries an
Italian woman, by whom he has two
children, Claud and Geneviève. His
second wife is a Russian, Princess
Omanoff, who has already been twice
married, and has her own cynical views
as to the blessings of matrimony. Mr.
Gervis and the Princess maintain sepa-
rate establishments, but are on friendly
terms. When the story opens, Mr. Ger-
vis, with his son Claud, after a long
residence abroad, has just returned to
England to take possession of a family
estate, lately inherited. From this point
the true story begins. Its complications
arise from the love-affairs of Claud and
his beautiful sister, from certain outlived
episodes in the life of the Princess, and
from the serious effects that spring from
the frivolous cause of the Beachborough
Club's reading-room gossip. Nothing is
out of the common, yet the elements of
disaster and of tragedy are seen to be
potential in the every-day lives of the
every-day characters. The book abounds
in types of character done to the life.
Even the callow clubhouse smokers
have an individuality of their own; and
French dandies, men of letters, gam-
blers, scoundrels, Russian adventurers,
and back-biting ladies of quality, row-
dies, and philosophic speculators on the
cosmos in general, are each and all as
real as the crowd in the street.
note
of historical examples brought together
in illustration of the kind of relationship
in question. It is a summing up of
concrete instances of friendship.
The book had great vogue in its day.
Its readableness and interest have not
been diminished by time.
Wom
Toman in the Nineteenth Century,
by Margaret Fuller Ossoli. (1844. )
A book of special interest from the
remarkable character and intellectual
ability of its author, and from the rep-
resentative position which it holds as an
early prophecy of the now broadly de-
veloped recognition of
pirants for culture, and as applicants
equally with for positions and
privileges in the various fields of hu-
man activity. After actively participat-
ing in the celebrated Brook Farm ex-
periment of idealist socialism, where
she thoroughly wrought out for herself
new-departure convictions in religion,
and having served a literary appren-
ticeship of
a translator from
the German, and as editor for two years
of The Dial, a quarterly organ of New
England Transcendentalism, she brought
out in 1844 her (Summer on the Lakes,
and the next year the Woman in the
Nineteenth Century,' — a considerably
enlarged reproduction of an essay by
her in The Dial of October 1843, where
she had used the title, The Great
Lawsuit; or, Man as Men, Woman as
Women. ) By adding a good deal
the article during a seven weeks' stay
at Fishkill on the Hudson (to November
17, 1844), she made what was in effect
a large pamphlet rather than a book
adequately dealing with her subject, or
at all representing her remarkable pow-
ers as they were shown in her (Papers
Literature and Art. ) To do her
justice, the book, which was her proph-
ecy of a
movement which the
tury is fulfilling, should be taken as
a text, and her later thoughts brought
together under it, to have as nearly
as possible a full indication of what,
under more favorable circumstances, her
genius would have given to the world.
Matrimony, by, W. E. Norris
, (1881. )
is the
story of the fortunes of a county family
named Gervis, the scene being laid
partly in Beachborough, an English
county-town, and partly among an aris-
tocratic half-bohemian set in Paris. Mr.
as
on
cen-
Lady
ady Beauty; OR, CHARMING TO HER
LATEST DAY, by Alan Muir. «It
always is darker,” whispered an old gen-
tleman at my side, when Lady Beauty
leaves the room - always. ” This eulo-
gistic remark is made at a dinner-table,
when the ladies have departed; and the
explanation of it is found in the story
which the old gentleman afterwards
tells, – the story of Lady Beauty's life;
a life so charming, so pure and sweet,
that at fifty-three Lady Beauty's never-
fading loveliness is thus described by
a rejected but faithful lover. Lady
Beauty, or Sophia Campbell, is the one
unworldly member of a worldly family
dwelling in the little English town of
Kettlewell. The teachings of her
mother, Lady Barbara, and the example
of her two older sisters are of no avail.
For seven years she remains faithful to
her absent lover, Percival Brent, and at
the end of that time her loyalty is re-
warded by a happy marriage, -
riage as strongly in contrast with the
-a mar-


## p. 531 (#567) ############################################

SYNOPSES OF NOTED BOOKS
531
AN
alliances formed by her sisters as her complications which spring from the con-
amiability and gentleness are opposed to tact of a nature ruled by crass selfish-
their ambition and cynicism.
ness and vulgar ambition, with nobler
The story is written, so the author and more sensitive spirits. The charac-
says, to encourage women to be charm- ter study is always good, and the novel
ing to their latest day; and the charm entertaining
he describes and urges is that of low-
toned voices, of fitting raiment, of gen- Mutable Many, The, by Robert Barr,
published in 1896. This is one of
tle manners, of lofty aims, of unobtrus-
the many accounts of the struggle be-
ive piety, and the charity which forgets
tween labor and capital. The scene is
and forgives, — all personified in the ideal
London, at the present day. The men
woman, Lady Beauty. Few more de-
in Monkton and Hope's factory strike.
lightful tales of society stand on the
Sartwell, their manager, refuses to com-
library shelf.
promise with them, but discusses the sit-
Mamma
ammon; OR, THE HARDSHIPS OF uation with Marsten, one of their num-
HEIRESS, by Mrs. Catharine Grace ber, who clings to his own order, at the
Gore. (1842. ) Mrs. Gore was the writer same time that he avows his love for
of some seventy novels descriptive of Sartwell's daughter Edna. Sartwell for-
the English aristocracy, books dear to bids him to speak to her. The strike
the hearts of a former generation, but
is crushed, Marsten is dismissed, and
forgotten to-day. Mammon) was pub- becomes secretary to the Labor Union.
lished in 1855, and deals with the for- He sees Edna several times, she becomes
tunes of one John Woolston and his interested in him, and her father sends
family. He marries to displease his her away to school. Marsten visits her
father, is for a time very poor, then in- in the guise of a gardener, offers her his
herits a fortune, and becomes a
<< mill- love, and is refused. Barney Hope, son
ionary,” as Mrs. Gore invariably calls it. of her father's employer, a dilettante art-
Her daughter Janetta is the heiress to ist of lavishly generous impulses, also
whom the book owes its title. Her offers himself to her and is refused.
hardships are those of the princess who Later, he founds a new school of art, be-
feels the crumpled roseleaf under her comes famous, and marries Lady Mary
many mattresses; and the sympathetic Fanshawe. Marsten brings about another
tear is slow to fall over her artificial strike, which is on the eve of success,
Yet, like all Mrs. Gore's books,
and Sartwell about to resign his post.
this had a great vogue, and was well Edna, seeing her father's despair, visits
received even by the critics. Her fig-
Marsten at the Union and proposes to
ures move more or less like automata; marry him if he will end the strike and
and her dialogue keeps the same pace
allow her father to triumph. He declines
whether the interlocutors are comfort-
to sell his honor even at such a price.
ably dining, or are finding their moral The members of the Union, seeing her,
world slipping out from under their feet. accuse Marsten of treachery, depose him
But that her books faithfully reflect the from office, and so maltreat him that he
dull, material, and unideaed life of fash- is taken to the hospital. His successor
ionable London in the second quarter of in office is no match for Sartwell, who
the century, there is no doubt, and it is wins the day. Edna goes to Marsten,
this fidelity that makes them of conse-
and owns at last that she loves him.
quence to the student of manners
Widower, by W. M.
even of morals.
Thackeray. (1860. ) One of the
Katherine S. Macquoid great master's later books, written after
(1871), is a story of English middle- his first visit to America, this simple
class contemporary life. Patty Westropp, story touches, perhaps, a narrower range
the pretty and ambitious daughter of a of emotion than
of his
gardener, inherits a fortune, changes her famous novels; but within its own limits,
name, attends fashionable French it shows the same power of characteriza-
school, and presently emerges from her tion, the same insight into motive, the
chrysalis state a fine lady. Her beauty same intolerance of sham and pharisaism,
and her money enable her to marry an the same tenderness towards the simple
English gentleman of good family; and and the weak, that mark Thackeray's
the chief interest of the story lies in the more elaborate work. Frederic Lovel
woes.
or
Lºvel, the
Patty, by
some
more
a


## p. 532 (#568) ############################################

532
SYNOPSES OF NOTED BOOKS
has married Cecilia Baker, who dies cently elevated to the peerage and soon
eight years later, leaving two children, to be preferred to the ministry. Braj-
the little prig Cecilia, and Popham. don has had, by a wife now long since
Their governess, Elizabeth Prior, wins lost and dead, a child which was stolen
the affection of the doctor, the butler, from bim in its infancy. His secret life-
and the bachelor friend who visits Mr. work has been to find and rehabili.
Lovel and tells the story. Lady Baker's tate that child, and so preserve the
son Clarence, a drunken reprobate, re- family 'name of Brandon. As a result of
veals the fact that Miss Prior was once the robbery, two of Paul's associates are
a ballet-dancer (forced to this toil in captured. He succeeds in liberating
order to support her family). Lady them by means of a daring attack, but
Baker orders her out of the house; is himself wounded and taken prisoner.
Lovell comes home in the midst of the Judge Brandon presides at the trial. At
uproar, and chivalrously offers her his the moment when he is to pronounce the
heart and hand, which she accepts, and death sentence, a scrap of paper is
he ceases to be Lovel the Widower.
passed him revealing the fact that the
Lady Baker, his tyrannical mother-in- condemned is his own son. Appalled at
law, has become immortal.
the disgrace which will tarnish his brill-
iant reputation, he pronounces the death
Paul
ul Clifford, by Bulwer-Lytton. Lord sentence, but a few minutes afterward
Lytton's object in Paul Clifford ? is found dead in his carriage.
The pa-
was to appeal for an amelioration of the per on his person reveals the story, and
British penal legislation, by illustrating Clifford is transported for life. He ef-
to what criminal extremes the ungraded fects his escape, however, and together
severity of the laws was driving men with Lucy, flees to America, where his
who by nature were upright and honest. latter days are passed in probity and un-
To quote from Clifford's well-known de-
ceasing philanthropic labors.
fense when before the judges: “Your
laws are of but two classes: the one Mºdern Régime, The, by H. A. Taine.
criminals
(1891. ) This is the third and con-
them. I have suffered by the one -- cluding part of Taine's (Origins of Con-
I am about to perish by the other. temporary France, of which his An-
Your legislation made cient Régime) and French Revolution
what I am! and it now destroys me, as were the first and second. While based
it has destroyed thousands, for being on the fullest and minutest research,
what it made me. ” The scene of the and giving a striking picture of the new
story is laid in London and the adjoin-| régime following the Revolution, it is
ing country, at a period shortly preced- less impartial than the previous parts of
ing the French Revolution.
Paul, a the work. The indictment of Napoleon
child of unknown parentage, is brought is as bitter as the picture of his almost
up by an old innkeeper among compan- superhuman power is brilliant; and what-
ions of very doubtful character. Arrested ever the Revolution produced is referred
for a theft of which he is innocent, he to mingled crime and madness. Taken
is sentenced to confinement among all together, the three works show Taine
sorts of hardened criminals.
He es-
at his best of originality, boldness, and
capes, and quickly becomes the chief
power as a writer.
of a band of highwaymen. In the midst
of a
Birtha wlessness, he takes Mºrals of Lucius Annæus Seneca,
residence at Bath under the name of The, is title given to
Captain Clifford and falls desperately in twelve essays on ethical subjects attrib-
love with a young heiress. Lucy Brandon, uted to the great Roman Stoic. They
who returns his affection; but realizing are the most interesting and valuable of
the gulf which lies between them, he his numerous works. Representing the
resolutely takes leave of her after con- thought of his whole life, the most fa-
fessing vaguely who and what he is.
are the essays on 'Consolation,'
Shortly after this he robs, partly through addressed to his mother, when he was
revenge, Lord Mauleverer, a suitor for in exile at Corsica; on Providence, «a
the hand of Lucy, and intimate friend golden book," as it is called by Lipsius,
of her uncle and guardian, Sir William the German critic; and on (The Happy
Brandon, a lawyer of great note, re- Life. ) The Stoic doctrines of calmness,
me
career
mous


## p. 533 (#569) ############################################

SYNOPSES OF NOTED BOOKS
533
was
one
forbearance, and strict virtue and just- 40,000 citizens that he found on his re-
ice, receive here their loftiest statement. turn from Europe, a traveled gentleman;
The popularity of these Morals) with and the Boston of three times as large
both pagan and Christian readers led a population, where still his owr house
to their preservation in almost a perfect afforded the most delightful hospitality
condition. To the student of Christian- and social life, among many famous for
ity in its relations with paganism, no good talk and good manners,— this old
other classic writer yields in interest to town is made to seem worthy of its son.
this «divine pagan,” as Lactantius, the The papers recording Mr. Ticknor's
early church father and poet, calls him. visits abroad are crowded with the names
The most striking parallels to the for- of men and women whom the world
mularies of the Christian writers, nota- honors, and who were delighted to know
bly St. Paul, are to be found in his the agreeable American: Byron, Rogers,
later works, especially those on (The Wordsworth, Hunt, Lady Holland, Lady
Happy Life) and on (The Conferring Ashburnham, Lord Lansdowne, Macau-
of Benefits.
lay, Sydney Smith, Jeffrey, Lockhart,
Châteaubriand, Talleyrand, Madame de
Life
ife, Letters, and Journals of George Staël, Goethe, Herder, Thorwaldsen,
Ticknor. (2 vols. , 1876. ) The story Manzoni, Sismondi, and in later years,
of the life of a private gentleman is every man of note in Europe. Of all of
here delightfully told through his jour- these, most interesting friendly glimpses
nals and letters to and from friends; his are given in letters and journals. Mr.
daughter, with excellent taste, having Ticknor's characterizations of these per-
joined the history which these docu- sons are admirable, always judicious and
ments reveal, by the slightest thread of faithful, and often humorous. With his
narrative. The birth of George Tick- strong liking for foreign men and things,
nor in Boston in 1791, his education in he
of the best Americans,
private school and college, his deliberate seeing the faults of his country, but lov-
choice of the life of a man of letters as ing her in spite of them. Happily he
his vocation, his four years of study and lived to see a reunited Union, and to
travel abroad, from the age of twenty- cherish the loftiest hopes for its future.
three to that of twenty-seven, his work The young American who looks for fine
at Harvard as professor of French and standards of intellectual, moral, and
Spanish, his labor upon his History social achievements will find his
of Spanish Literature, his delightful count in a study of the life of this mod-
nome life, a second journey in Europe est, accomplished, genial, hard-working,
in his ripe middle age, and still a third, distinguished private gentleman.
full of profit and delight, when he was
sixty-five, his profound interest in the Daniel Webster, cobyn Henry
Cabot
war for
Lodge. This forms Vol. viii. of
and finally the peaceful closing of his days the American Statesmen) series. Mr.
at the age of seventy-nine, - these are Lodge disclaims all credit for original
the material of the book. But the reader research among MS. records in prepar-
sees picture after picture of a delightful ing this life of Webster; and is content
existence, and is brought into intimate to follow in the footsteps of George
relations with the most cultivated and Ticknor Curtis, to whose elaborate,
agreeable people of the century. George careful, and scholarly biography of the
Ticknor had the happiness to be well great statesman he frankly acknowledges
born; that is, his father and mother were his indebtedness for all the material
well educated, full of ideas and aspira- facts of Webster's life and labors. But
tions, and so easy in circumstances that on these facts he has exercised an inde-
the best advantages awaited the boy. pendent judgment; and this biographical
With his inheritance of charming man-
material he has worked over in his own
ners, a bright intelligence, a kind heart, way, producing an essentially original
and leisure for study, he was certain to study of the life of Webster. In con-
establish friendships among the best. sidering the crises of Webster's life as
The simple, delightful society of the lawyer, orator, senator, statesman, he in
Boston of 18,000 inhabitants, where his a few brief chapters brings the man be-
boyhood was passed; the not less agree- fore us with striking vividnes
able but more sophisticated Boston of tray Webster as a lawyer, his part in
ac-
To por-


## p. 534 (#570) ############################################

534
SYNOPSES OF NOTED BOOKS
seen at
answer
the Dartmouth College Case is recounted; subject in its industrial and ethical ap-
for there his legal talents are
plications, and concludes that the «inde-
their best. The chapter on this case is pendence of foreigners ” which a high
a model of clear and concise statement. tariff is supposed to secure, must be the
Webster as an orator is the subject of result simply and solely of native supe.
another chapter, dealing with his speeches riority, either in energy, or industry, or
in the Massachusetts Convention of 1820, inventiveness, or in natural advantages.
and his Plymouth oration, and their The papers on Criminal Politics,' 'Idle-
effects upon the auditors. His part in ness and Immorality,) (The Duty of Ed-
the tariff debates of 1828 in Congress, ucated Men in a Democracy,) "Who Will
his reply to Hayne, and his struggle Pay the Bills of Socialism ? ) and (The
with Jackson, occupy two chapters, in Real Problem of Democracy, are lay
which Webster's extraordinary powers of sermons of so vigorous an application
reasoning and of oratory are analyzed. that the most easy-going political sinner
Mr. Lodge seems to juage without par- who reads them will not be able to es-
tisanship Webster's Seventh of March cape the pangs of conscience. The final
speech, and the dissensions between him
paper on (The Expenditure of Rich
and his party. He recognizes in Web- Men) is a disquisition on the difficulty
ster, above all, «the preeminent cham- of real sumptuosity in America.
pion and exponent of nationality. ”
Language and the Study of Lan.
guage, by William Dwight Whitney,
Problems of Modern Democracy, by
Edwin Lawrence Godkin.
1867. This work is not only indispens-
(1896. )
able to students of comparative phi-
This collection of eleven political and
lology, but delightful and instructive
economic essays, on subjects connected
with the evolution of the republic, be-
It controverts some of the
reading
positions of Max Müller's Lectures on
longs among the most thoughtful and
the Science of Language,' notably in its
most interesting books of its class — with
to the fundamental question.
Lecky's, Pearson's, Stephen's, Fiske's,
How did language originate ? The
and Lowell's. From the first one, (Aris-
tocratic Opinions of Democracy,' pub-
growth of language is first considered,
with the causes which affect the kind
lished during the last year of the Civil
and the rate of linguistic change; then
War, to the last, «The Expenditure of
Rich Men,' thirty-one years elapse; yet
the separation of languages into dialects;
the comment of time simply emphasizes
then the group of dialects and the family
of more distantly related languages which
the rightness of Mr. Godkin's thinking.
include English; then a review of the
He states the aristocratic objections to
other great families; the relative value
democracy with absolute fairness, con-
and authority of linguistic and of physi-
cedes the weight of many of them, is
cal evidence of race, and the bearing of
even ready to admit that to some degree
language on the ultimate question of the
democracy in America is still on trial.
But he maintains that the right-hand
unity or variety of the human species:
the whole closing with an inquiry into
fallings-off and left-hand defections with
the origin of language, its relation to
which its opponents tax our political
thought, and its value as an element in
theories, are really due to quite other
human progress. Professor Whitney's
causes, - causes inseparable from the con-
theory is that acts and qualities were
ditions of our existence. Thus thought-
the first things named, and that the
fully he considers ethics, manners, liter-
roots of language from which all words
ature, art, and philosophy, public spirit
have sprung – were originally planted
and private virtue; and his conclusion is
by man in striving to imitate natural
that the world's best saints of the last
sounds (the onomatopoetic theory), and
hundred years have come out of the
to utter sounds expressive of excited
Nazareth of democracy,- issuing from
feeling (the interjectional theory); not
the middle and lower classes in Europe,
by means of an innate (creative faculty »
from the plain people in America.
for phonetically expressing his thoughts,
(Popular Government is a review and
which is Max Müller's view.
refutation of much of the doctrine of
Sir Henry Maine, in his volume on that | Earth and Man: The, by Arnold Guyot.
(Some
(1849. ) This fascinating book was
Aspects of the Tariff) deals with the the first word upon its subject, -com.


## p. 535 (#571) ############################################

SYNOPSES OF NOTED BOOKS
535
сол
parative physical geography and its rela-
tion to mankind, - which had ever been
addressed to a popular American audi-
ence. The substance of these pages was
first given in the form of lectures before
the Lowell Institute of Boston. Professor
Guyot contends that geography means
not a mere description of the earth's sur-
face, but an interpretation of the phenom-
ena which it describes; an endeavor to
seize the incessant mutual action of the
different portions of physical nature upon
each other, of inorganic nature upon or-
ganized beings — upon man in particular
- and upon the successive development of
human societies. In a word, says the au-
thor, it must explain the perpetual play
of forces that constitutes what might
be called the life of the globe, its physi-
ology. Understood otherwise, geography
loses its vital principle, and becomes a
mere collection of partial, unmeaning
facts. He then goes on to explain how
the contours of mountains, their position,
their direction, their height, the length
and direction of rivers, the configuration
of coasts, the slope of plateaus, the
neighborhood of islands, and in a word,
all physical conditions, have modified
profoundly the life of man. He explains
in detail the relief of the continents, the
characteristics of the oceans, the gradual
formation of the continents, the effects
of winds, rains, and marine currents on
vegetable and animal life, the causes of
likenesses and of differences, and finally,
the people and the life of the future.
Foretold by their physical condition, the
long waiting of the southern continents
for their evolution has been inevitable;
but the scientist foresees for them a full
development when the industrious and
skillful men of the northern continents
shall join with the men of the tropics to
establish a movement of universal pro-
gress and improvement. Full of knowl-
edge and a lofty spirituality, written
always with clearness and often with
eloquence, (The Earth and Man) is a
book whose charm is perennial.
and the criticisms often just, yet some.
times grossly prejudiced. The volumes
were small in size, but Johnson had
intended to make his sketches much
smaller. They had been ordered by
forty of the best booksellers in London
to be used as prefaces for a uniform
edition of the English poets. Johnson
was peculiarly qualified for the work,
deriving his material largely from per-
sonal recollections. The publishers, it is
said, made $25,000 or $30,000, while the
writer got only $2,000. The MS. of the
work he gave to Boswell, who gives us
certain variorum readings. Johnson
himself thought the life of Cowley the
best, and Macaulay agrees with him.
The account of Pope he wrote
amore; said that it would be a thousand
years before another man appeared who
had Pope's power of versification. In
the sketch of Milton the old Tory spoke
with scorn and indignation of that pa-
triot poet's Roundhead politics, calling
him (an acrimonious, surly Republican »
and brutally insolent,” and poured con-
tempt on his (Lycidas. Such things as
this, with his injustice to Gray, called
down on his head a storm of wrath
from the Whigs; which, however, failed
to ruffle in the least the composure of
the erudite old behemoth. It is amaz-
ing to read the names of the English
poets) in this collection. Who now ever
hears of Rochester, Roscommon, Pom-
fret, Dorset, Stepney, Philips, Walsh,
Smith, King, Sprat, Halifax, Garth,
Hughes, Sheffield, Blackmore, Fenton,
Granville, Tickell, Hammond, Somer-
ville, Broome, Mallet, Duke, Denham,
Lyttleton ?
Lady of Fort St. John, The, by Mary
.