No More Learning

Plutarch's solution to the problem of uncorroborated stories from the "remoter ages" was apparently to recast them and present them to the reader as having taken on "the appear- ance of history. " What are modern historians to make of this approach when evaluating a primary document like Plutarch's Life of Theseus? How would we interpret the information and the anecdotes contained in that biography? As factual? As semifactual? Or as nothing more than tall tales taken from "sandy, waterless deserts full of wild beasts"?
Plutarch's Viewpoint (Part Two)
As alluded to earlier, Plutarch is one of the few authors of primary documents who provides his readers with extensive information about his sources. He frequently credits the authors whose works he has consulted, sometimes referencing them, other times quoting them. Quite often, he will include contradictory material from two (or more) sources, leaving the modern historian with a problem: which of these sources is the more/most credible? Plutarch does not assist us; when he reports differing versions of the same event or story, he generally concludes his report with a sentence like: "Let the reader decide which one of these accounts is the true one. " Plutarch seldom even offers hints--let alone blunt state- ments--about his own assessments of his sources, so the modern historian truly must make the call in these cases.
An exception to the foregoing: Plutarch's Life of Pericles. Plutarch seems to have been a great admirer of the famous fifth-century BCE Athenian leader; even so, Plutarch is honest enough with his readers that he quotes sources hostile to Pericles, but with a twist: unchar- acteristically, he often criticizes these sources and challenges the credibility of their work.
Example: "The [fifth-century BCE] poet Ion . . . says that Pericles had a rather disdainful and arrogant manner of address, and that his pride had in it a good deal of superciliousness and contempt for others . . . But we need not pay much attention to Ion. . . " [Plutarch. Life of Pericles 5; tr. Scott-Kilvert. ]
Example: "[H]ow are we to believe [the fourth-century BCE biographer] Idomeneus's charge that Pericles arranged the assassination of the democratic leader Ephialtes, who was his friend [and political colleague], out of sheer jealousy of his reputation? This is surely a poisonous accusation, which he has concocted from some unknown source, to hurl at a man. . . who possessed a noble disposition and a spirit. . . dedicated to the pursuit of honor . . . " [10]
Example: "[W]e find that even [the fifth-century BCE biographer] Stesimbrotus of Thasos has dared to give currency to the shocking and completely unfounded charge that Pericles seduced his son's wife. This only goes to show how thickly the truth is hedged around with obstacles and how hard it is to track down by historical research. " [13]
Example: "In the ninth month [of the Athenian siege of Samos, an island off the coast of modern Turkey], the Samians surrendered. Pericles demolished their walls, confiscated their fleet, and imposed a heavy fine on them . . . Duris of Samos [a fourth-century BCE historian] magnifies these events into a tragedy and accuses Pericles and the Athenians of great brutal- ity, although there is no word of this in Thucydides, nor Ephorus, nor Aristotle. He certainly does not appear to be telling the truth [when he reports that Pericles countenanced atrocities during the takeover of Samos]. Duris is apt to overstep the limits of the truth . . . and so it seems . . . that in this instance he has drawn a horrifying picture of his country's sufferings simply to blacken the name of Athens. " It is most unusual for Plutarch, in effect, to accuse a source not only of incompetent exaggeration, but outright prevarication. [28]
Livy's Viewpoint
Titus Livius ("Livy," 59 BCE-17 CE) wrote a massive, monumental history of Rome, his Ab Urbe Condita, From the Founding of the City. He began work on it around 27 BCE; it took him over 40 years to complete. His plan: to cover the entirety of Roman history from its beginnings with Romulus (753 BCE) all the way to his own time.
In the preface to Ab Urbe Condita, Livy identifies a problem common to ancient and modern historians alike: the competition. A modern historian who proposes to undertake the writing of an account of nearly any historical period is admonished by editors and col- leagues to be certain that his/her putative work claims a niche or displays an approach here- tofore unfilled by any other historian. Livy must have felt the same kind of pressure to produce something new, different, unique, original. He writes: "Whether I am likely to accomplish anything worthy of the labor, if I record the achievements of the Roman people from the foundation of the city, I do not really know . . . perceiving as I do that the theme is not only old but hackneyed, through the constant succession of new historians [his compet- itors! ], who believe either that in their facts they can produce more authentic information, or that in their style they will prove better than the rude attempts of the ancients. " [Livy. From the Founding of the City 1. 1-2; tr. Foster. ]
Another problem that confronted Livy was the sheer antiquity of the earliest eras that he intended to chronicle. These time periods were poorly attested, shrouded in myth and legend (cf. Plutarch's similar quandary, above). Worse yet, perhaps, Livy fears that his read- ers would be far more interested in recent or contemporary events, and that accounts of the earliest eras of Roman history would not resonate with them. His words: "[M]y subject involves infinite labor, seeing that it must be traced back [over] seven hundred
Preface
xvii
Preface
xviii
years . . . and at the same time, I doubt not that to most readers the earliest origins and the period immediately succeeding them will give little pleasure, for they will be in haste to reach these modern times . . . "[1. 4]. As for the credibility or historicity of the legends and stories pertaining to Rome's beginnings, Livy promises "neither to affirm nor to refute. " Rather, he argues that it is the "privilege of antiquity" to create or promulgate legends that contain a mixture of divine and human actions, "so to add dignity to the beginnings of cities. "
Do historians have the prerogative or the credentials to make value judgments concern- ing the historical periods about which they write? Livy seemed to think so; he took the view that, rather than quibbling over the accuracy of minute details of particular events, students of history ought to focus instead on the bigger picture: "[W]hat life and morals were like; through what men and by what policies, in peace and in war, empire was established and enlarged. Then let [the reader] note how, with the gradual relaxation of discipline, morals first gave way . . . then sank lower and lower, and finally began the downward plunge which has brought us to the present time, when we can endure neither our vices, nor their cure. " [1. 9]. This view--that previous generations were somehow more moral, more values- driven, and more courageous than the present one--is echoed frequently by those who see a similar "downward plunge" in contemporary American life.
The bottom line: Livy believed that the study of history was a "wholesome and profit- able" undertaking, principally because it offers a wide range of examples of human activities and experiences, some praiseworthy, others not. The wise and perceptive student of history can then discern worthy examples to emulate and disreputable examples to avoid.
So how would a modern historian evaluate Livy's Ab Urbe Condita? By his own words, Livy certainly seems to have had a fondness for the "good old days" and a corresponding revulsion for more recent Roman history. Do we then conclude that his descriptions of the earliest times are embellished? Overly favorable, to an extent that they distort the truth? And that his accounts of more recent times are unnecessarily pessimistic? There seems to be no need to be skeptical of the accuracy of Livy's history of Rome. The 40-plus years he spent writing it suggest careful research and a diligent quest for the truth. Beyond that, Livy has always enjoyed the respect and esteem not only of his peers--the first-century CE orator Quintilian compared him favorably to the best of the Greek historians, including Thucydides and Herodotus--but also of later generations, up to the present time.
Tacitus's Viewpoint
The Roman historian Cornelius Tacitus (ca. 55-117 CE) has left us with two notable histori- cal works: Annals, which spans the years 14 to 68 CE, and Histories, covering 69 and 70.
Tacitus provides modern readers with some fairly harsh criticisms of his contemporaries in the history-writing business, nor is their readership spared. In his introduction to the Histories, he notes that many historians have written accounts of the previous 822 years of Roman history, from its founding in 753 BCE up to 69 CE. But he makes a distinction between those who covered the Roman Republic (753-31), characterizing their work as displaying "eloquence and freedom," and those who came later, claiming there were no post-31 BCE historians with abilities similar to their forebears. He acerbically writes that "historical truth was impaired in many ways: first, because [historians] were ignorant of politics; . . . later, because of their passionate desire to flatter; or again, because of their hatred of their masters . . . But while [readers] quickly turn from a historian who curries favor, they [readily] listen to calumny and spite . . . [T]hose [historians] who profess inviolable fidelity to truth must write of no [person] with affection or with hatred. " [Tr. Clifford H. Moore. Tacitus: The Histories. Volume I. LCL, 1937. Page numbers: 3, 5. ]
Unfortunately, Tacitus does not mention these ignorant historians by name, so the modern historian is left to speculate which ones are on the receiving end of his critiques. But this raises another dilemma of document evaluation for the modern historian: If we know that an eminent ancient source (like Tacitus) had a low opinion of a particular con- temporary historian, or a whole group of them, how much influence should the ancient crit- ic's opinions exert in our assessments of those writers, and their documents, whom he criticizes?
Conclusion
The ancient sources have demonstrated that the writing of history is no simple task. Many pitfalls, snares, obstacles, and wrong turns await the historian, especially in the matter of evaluating primary documents. And yet he or she must do exactly that if a complete record of human achievement--and failure--is to be written with care and accuracy.
Preface
xix
This page intentionally left blank
CHRONOLOGY
CHRONOLOGY OF GREEK HISTORY FROM THE TROJAN WAR TO THE SUBJUGATION OF CORINTH, 1200-146 BCE
? ? Ca. 1200-1190 776
734 621
594
Ca. 560-510 Ca. 510
490
480
Ca. 478
The epic battle between the Greeks and the Trojans--the Trojan War-- chronicled later by Homer in the Iliad.
Founding of the ancient Olympic Games, the quadrennial athletic fes- tival that took place at Olympia, in the southwestern corner of the Peloponnesus.
The first Greek colony in Sicily, Naxos, is founded.
The Athenian lawgiver Draco is put in charge of codifying and publish- ing the laws of Athens. He recommends the death penalty for virtually any offense, even the most minor.
The Athenian legislator, poet, politician, and businessman Solon (ca. 640- 560) single-handedly enacts many legal, economic, and social reforms in Athens. He modifies the harsh penalties prescribed by Draco's law codes.
Pisistratus, and later his sons, Hippias and Hipparchus, rule Athens as tyrants.
The shadowy Athenian leader Cleisthenes sponsors a number of initia- tives that lay the foundation for the flowering of the Athenian democ- racy in the fifth century.
The Persians, led by King Darius I, invade Greece. The Greeks, princi- pally under the leadership of the Athenians, prevail at the decisive Battle of Marathon.
The Persians return to Greece, this time under King Xerxes. The Athenian navy, led by Themistocles, defeats the Persians for the second time in 10 years.
The representatives of several hundred Greek polises assemble on the tiny Cycladic island of Delos to form an anti-Persian alliance generally known as the Delian League.
xxi
Chronology
xxii
472
447
444
431-404
Ca. 430
429
417
415-413
406 399
384 371
338
336
336-323
Aeschylus's play Persians is staged. It is the only surviving Greek tragic play based on a historical event, the invasion of Greece led by Xerxes. All other extant tragedies draw their themes from myth and legend.
Construction begins on the Parthenon, the signature building of the Golden Age of Athens and one of the most famous architectural land- marks in the history of the western world.
The famous Athenian leader Pericles (ca. 495-429) is elected strategos (military general) for the first time. He would go on to be elected to this annual office an amazing 14 more times in succession.
The Peloponnesian War, the devastating conflict between Athens and Sparta and their allies, eventually resulting in the occupation and partial destruction of Athens by Sparta.
Sophocles's tragic play Oedipus the King, perhaps the best known and most often revived ancient Greek play, is presented in Athens for the first time.
The death of Pericles, who had contracted the highly contagious and nearly always fatal plague that had swept through Athens in this year and in the previous year.
The ostracism of Hyperbolus, the last known victim of the Athenian practice that enabled the citizens of Athens to exile, via popular vote, a disliked or unscrupulous politician for 10 years. Ostracism votes were outlawed after this year.
The disastrous Sicilian Expedition, in which the Athenians inexplicably try to invade the faraway island of Sicily, in the midst of the Peloponnesian War, and are thoroughly defeated.
The famous playwrights Euripides and Sophocles both die in this year.
The famous Athenian philosopher Socrates is put on trial for impiety and subversion. He is convicted and forced to commit suicide.
The philosopher Aristotle and the orator/lawyer Demosthenes are both born in this year. Ironically, they also both died in the same year, 322.
Battle of Leuctra, between Thebes and Sparta. The Thebans win and thereby end Spartan dominance over Greece, which the Spartans had established after the Peloponnesian War.
Battle of Chaeronea, in which the forces of King Philip of Macedonia defeat the Athenians and Thebans. The nearby town of Chaeronea was the birthplace of Plutarch.
The assassination of King Philip of Macedonia. The Athenian orator Demosthenes attacked King Philip and his policies in three of his most famous speeches, the Philippics (352; 344; 341).
The rule of King Philip's son, Alexander the Great.
331 330 Ca. 280 279
211
146
The founding of the city of Alexandria in Egypt by Alexander the Great, who named it after himself.
The venerable and famous capital city of the Persians, Persepolis, is cap- tured, vandalized, and set ablaze by Alexander the Great and his soldiers.
Completion of the Pharos, the huge 300-foot-tall lighthouse at Alexandria, deemed one of the Seven Wonders of the Ancient World.
Battle of Asculum, in which the Greek mercenary general Pyrrhus is victorious against the Romans but loses some of his best soldiers in the process. The outcome of that battle occasioned his famous state- ment that one more success like that would ruin him; hence, the phrase "Pyrrhic victory. "
Death of the mathematician and physicist Archimedes in Syracuse. He once said that, given a place to stand and a pole long enough, he could move the world.
Subjugation of Corinth by the Romans, the last Greek city to hold out against the inevitable. The Romans annex Greece and turn it into a province called Achaea.
CHRONOLOGY OF ROMAN HISTORY FROM THE FOUNDING OF THE CITY TO THE EDICT OF DIOCLETIAN, 753 BCE-301 CE
BCE Events
753 Romulus founds the city of Rome, and becomes its first king.
753-509 Rome is ruled by a succession of seven kings: Romulus (753-714)
Numa Pompilius (714-671) Tullus Hostilius (671-642) Ancus Martius (642-617) Tarquinius Priscus (617-579) Servius Tullius (579-535) Tarquinius Superbus (535-509)
509 Tarquinius Superbus is removed from power, and with him, the mon- archy. The Roman Republic is founded.
509-27 The span of the Roman Republic, when Rome is governed by elected officials and legislative bodies.
458 The Roman farmer-turned-military dictator Lucius Quinctius Cincinnatus is called to duty to extricate a blockaded Roman army. He
Chronology
? ? xxiii
Chronology
xxiv
Ca. 450 396
366
366
343-341
287
264-241 247 218-201
216
202
184
answers the call, saves the army, and resigns his dictatorship, all within the space of 16 days.
The Twelve Tables are promulgated, the first codification of Roman law.
The general Marcus Furius Camillus captures the important Italian town of Veii, signaling the fact that Rome is becoming a regional power to be reckoned with.
Lucius Sextius is elected consul, the highest political office. He is the first plebeian to hold the office, which had formerly been exclusively reserved for patrician politicians.
The passage of the laws of Licinius and Sextius, which specified, among other things, that no individual could hold more than 300 acres of public pasture land.
The First Samnite War. The Samnites were a warlike people in south- central Italy, against whom the Romans fought this war and two others: the Second Samnite War (328-304) and the Third Samnite War (298-290).
The fifth secession (a massive withdrawal from the city) of the plebeians, a tactic they used against the ruling patrician class in order to gain politi- cal equality.
Four previous secessions are thought to have occurred, in 494, 449, 445, and 342, although the consensus appears to be that only the fifth, in 287, is beyond question a historical fact.
The First Punic War. The Romans win and impose an extremely harsh peace treaty on their defeated enemy, the Carthaginians.
Birth of Hannibal, the intractable Carthaginian leader and implacable enemy of Rome.
The Second Punic War, between Rome and Carthage. The Carthaginians are led by Hannibal, who almost succeeds in capturing the city and destroying the Roman Republic.
The Battle of Cannae, near the Adriatic coast of Italy. The Carthaginians virtually annihilate a 60,000-man Roman army. Future Romans will look back upon this battle as one of their worst military defeats ever.
The decisive Battle of Zama, the only time in the Second Punic War that the Romans defeat the Carthaginians in a major battle. Ironically, the battle occurs not in Italy but in North Africa, not far from the city of Carthage. The Second Punic War officially ends in the next year.
Marcus Porcius Cato (Cato the Elder), one of the most famous--and cantankerous--politicians in Roman history, holds the office of censor, in which he initiates a number of unpopular reforms, including crack- downs on citizens who stole water from the aqueducts, the imposition of significantly higher taxes on luxury goods, and higher rental rates for public lands.
149-146 The Third (and final) Punic War, in which Rome utterly and totally defeats and destroys Carthage.
135-132 A major slave revolt breaks out in Sicily.
133 King Attalus III of Pergamum dies, having willed his entire kingdom to the Roman people. Pergamum subsequently becomes Rome's
first Asian province.
133 Tiberius Sempronius Gracchus takes office as one of the 10 tribunes for the year. He proposes and wins enactment of some highly controversial land reform measures, including the enforcement of the law of Licinius
and Sextius (in 366, above).
133 Some 300 people, including Gracchus, are killed in a riot that breaks out during a political rally. Plutarch states that this was reportedly the first time ever in Roman history in which a civil disturbance resulted in the
death of Roman citizens.
123 The tribunate of Gaius Sempronius Gracchus, the brother of Tiberius (above). Gaius has a legislative program as ambitious and as controversial
as his brother's, and he meets the same fate.
106 The birth of the famous orator/lawyer/statesman Cicero.
100 The birth of Julius Caesar.
90-88 The Italian Social War, a struggle pitting Rome against its Italian allies, who wanted Roman citizenship with its concomitant rights and
freedoms.
73 The Thracian slave Spartacus foments a slave rebellion in southern Italy.
70 Cicero successfully argues his first high-profile court case, a prosecution of the corrupt ex-governor of Sicily, Gaius Verres.
63 The year of Cicero's consulship.
63 The disappointed office seeker Lucius Sergius Catilina ("Catiline") organizes an armed conspiracy whose aim is to overthrow the Roman government by force. Cicero discovers the plan and exposes it in a series
of four famous speeches, in November and December of this year. 59 The year of Julius Caesar's consulship.
58-50 Julius Caesar's governorship in Gaul, unprecedented in terms of its length; most provincial governorships lasted for one or two years, three
at most.
50 Caesar is recalled to Rome by nervous politicians. They want to inter- rogate him about his actions in Gaul and his plans for the future.
49 In one of the most famous episodes in Roman history, Caesar, uttering his memorable words "The die is cast," crosses the Rubicon River in northern Italy with his army intact. This action precipitates a civil
war.
Chronology
xxv
Chronology
xxvi
49-45
44
44
44-31
44-43
43 31
29-19 27
27 BCE-476 CE
A period of civil war following Caesar's crossing of the Rubicon River. Caesar's side eventually prevails. The Battle of Munda in Spain, in 45, is the final and decisive battle of the civil war.
Caesar receives a lifetime dictatorship, the latest in a whole series of nontraditional offices and powers he obtains in the decade of the 40s, up until the Ides of March (see next entry).
The Ides of March conspiracy (March 15) unfolds. The goal of the 60 conspirators: to assassinate Caesar, in hopes of somehow restoring the Roman Republic by his death. Their goal of killing Caesar is fulfilled. Their hope of restoring the Republic is not.
Another bloody civil war. Shortly before his assassination, Caesar had predicted that should anything happen to him, a second civil war would break out, worse than the one fought from 49 to 45. He was correct.
Cicero delivers his Philippics, the final public speeches of his long and dis- tinguished career. There were 14 of them altogether; most were harsh denunciations of one of Cicero's arch-enemies, Mark Antony.
Cicero is hunted down and murdered at the behest of Mark Antony.
The Battle of Actium, the last battle of the civil war. The forces of Octavianus (later Augustus) prevail over those commanded by Mark Antony.
The Roman poet Virgil spends these 10 years writing the Aeneid, the renowned epic poem celebrating the founding of the Roman race.
Octavianus receives two perquisites from the Roman Senate that ensure the end of the Republic and the beginning of the Roman Empire: (1) He is granted lifetime tribunician powers, meaning, in effect, that he personally can override and nullify the decisions made by any other legislative entity, or the proposals of any individual politician. (2) The honorary title Augustus, "the revered one," a word that has divine connotations.
The span of the western Roman Empire.
CE Events
14 The death of Augustus. His reign as emperor lasts over 40 years.
14-68 The reigns of the Julio-Claudian successors of Augustus. Tiberius (14-37)
Caligula (37-41) Claudius (41-54) Nero (54-68)
17 64
69-96
79 80
96-180
97
122
Ca. 212
247 271
284-305 293
301
Two notable literati die in this year: the poet Ovid and the historian Livy.
A terrible fire sweeps through Rome, during which Nero supposedly "fiddles"
as the city goes up in flames. The story of his fiddling is probably apocryphal. The reigns of the Flavian emperors:
Vespasian (69-79) Titus (79-81) Domitian (81-96)
Mount Vesuvius erupts in the summer of 79, burying the cities of Pompeii and Herculaneum, as well as many farms and smaller towns, in volcanic debris.
The Flavian Amphitheater, better known as the Coliseum, is dedicated. The reigns of the so-called Five Good Emperors:
Nerva (96-98)
Trajan (98-117)
Hadrian (117-138) Antoninus Pius (138-161) Marcus Aurelius (161-180)
Frontinus becomes curator aquarum, the official in charge of Rome's magnifi- cent aqueduct system. He later writes a detailed technical manual on the aque- ducts, De Aquis Urbis Romae ("On the Aqueducts of Rome"), the only book of its kind surviving from antiquity.
Work begins on Hadrian's Wall in northern England to obstruct raids from tribes living north of the wall. It eventually extends for about 80 miles and to a height of around 20 feet.
Construction begins on the Baths of Caracalla. These public baths were huge; the main building measured 750 feet by 380 feet. Built at the order of the emperor Caracalla (reigned 211-217), for whom they were named.
Observances are held in Rome to mark 1,000 years of Roman civilization.
Construction begins on the Aurelian Wall, extending for 12 miles around Rome and reaching a height of 60 feet.
The reign of the emperor Diocletian.
The emperor Diocletian establishes a tetrarchy, in which four men would jointly rule the empire.
Publication of the Edict of Diocletian.
Chronology
xxvii
This page intentionally left blank
DOMESTIC LIFE
This page intentionally left blank
1. GROWING UP IN SPARTA WAS NO PICNIC
INTRODUCTION
Life in ancient Sparta undoubtedly differed quite markedly from life in the other Greek polises, as the biographer and essayist Plutarch informs us.
KEEP IN MIND AS YOU READ
1. Plutarch's essay The Ancient Customs of the Spartans, from which the document has been excerpted, is comprised of an annotated list of 42 aspects of Spartan life. Plutarch describes each of the 42 in varying degrees of detail. Some, like the first one, consist of only one sentence: "To each of those who comes in to the public meals, the eldest man says, as he points to the doors, 'Through these no word goes out' " (eerily reminiscent of the code of many modern sports teams: "What is said in the locker room, stays in the locker room. "). Others are lengthier, but none is longer than several hundred words.
2. Plutarch also wrote an essay entitled Sayings of Spartans, which is considerably longer than his essay on the customs of the Spartans but contains many of the short, pithy statements for which the Spartans were famous. He also authored a (much shorter) work called Sayings of Spartan Women.
3. Many of the Spartan customs that Plutarch describes were reportedly initiated or encouraged by the legendary Spartan king Lycurgus, whose dates and even historical authenticity are debated by modern historians. Plutarch wrote a biography of Lycurgus.
Document: Plutarch on Life in Sparta
They learned to read and write for purely practical reasons. But all other forms of education they banned from the country . . . All their education was directed toward prompt obedience to authority, stout endurance of hardship, and victory or death in battle.
? ? ? ? ? 3
Voices of Ancient Greece and Rome
They always went without a shirt, receiving one garment for the entire year, and with unwashed bodies, refraining almost completely from bathing and rubbing down. . .
It was the custom that the younger men should be questioned by the elder as to where they were going and for what, and also that the elder should rebuke the one who did not answer or tried to contrive plausible reasons. And the elder who did not rebuke a younger who did wrong in his presence was liable to the same reprimand as the wrongdoer. And anyone who showed resentment, if he was reprimanded, [found himself in serious trouble] . . .
Moreover, the young men were required not only to respect their own fathers and to be obedient to them, but to have regard for all the older men, to make room for them on the streets, to give up their seats to them, and to keep quiet in their presence. As the result of this custom each man had authority, not as in other states over his own chil- dren, slaves, and property, but also over his neighbor's in like manner as over his own, to the end that the people should, as much as possible, have all things in common, and should take thought for them as for their own . . .
The boys steal whatever they can of their food, learn- ing to make their raids adroitly upon people who are asleep or are careless in watching. The penalty for getting caught is a beating and no food. For the dinner allowed them is meager, so that, through coping with want by their own initiative, they may be compelled to be daring and unscrupulous . . .
The selling of anything was not permitted, but it was their custom to use the neighbors' servants as their own if they needed them and also their dogs and horses, unless the owners required them for their own use. And in the country, if anyone found himself lacking anything and had need of it, he would open an owner's storehouse and take away enough to meet his need, and then replace the seals and leave it . . .
They used to make the Helots [state-owned slaves] drunk and exhibit them to the young as a deterrent from excessive drinking.
It was their custom not to knock on the outer doors, but to call from outside . . .
They did not attend either comedy or tragedy [i. e. , theatrical productions], so that they might not hear anyone speak either in earnest or in jest against the laws.
They reprimanded [a] young man from the gymnasium because he knew well about the road to Pylaea.
One of the noble and blessed privileges that Lycurgus appears to have secured for his fellow citizens was
? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? a beating: Young thieves caught in the act were beaten not because stealing was considered wrong or immoral, but because they were insufficiently stealthy to avoid capture.
give up their seats: Most likely at pub- lic events such as religious festivals or athletic competitions.
gymnasium: A large, open-air public building found in most Greek towns, primarily for the use of athletes. However, philosophical discussions and lectures could also take place in gymnasia. The sacred groves near Athens, where Plato famously taught, was called the Academia (hence our word "aca- demic"), and a gymnasium was eventually constructed on the site. But even in Plato's day, the area was apparently frequented by athletes in training.
Pylaea: This word has an interesting history. It is related to the word for "gate," and it originally referred to meeting places, near gated areas of a city's walls, for the represen- tatives of various leagues and coun- cils. Not surprisingly, whenever large numbers of people congre- gated, the informal topics of con- versation often drifted into the realm of the mundane and even the gossipy. Hence, the word came to be associated with trivial conver- sation, which is what it seems to imply in this context: the young man on "the road to Pylaea" appa- rently referred to his propensity for unfocused conversation, when he should have been concentrating on gymnastic drills and exercises.
without a shirt: Plutarch does not mean they went about unclothed from the waist up, but that they wore no shirt underneath their cloak, the himation, here translated as "garment. "
? ? ? 4
abundance of leisure. In fact it was not permitted them to take up any menial trade at all, and there was no need whatever of making money, which involves a toilsome accumulation, nor of busy activity, because of his having made wealth wholly unenvied and unhonored. The Helots tilled the soil for them, paying a return that was regularly settled in advance. There was a ban against letting for a higher price, so that the Helots might make some profit, and thus be glad to do the work for their masters . . . [Tr. Frank Cole Babbitt. Plutarch's Moralia (237-239). Volume III. LCL, 1931. Page numbers: 429, 431, 439, 441, 443, 445. ]
AFTERMATH
Plutarch was writing in a time (first/second centuries CE) when the Romans had long since subjugated Greece and most of the rest of the Mediterranean world. In his last chapter in "Ancient Customs of the Spartans," he argues that the Spartans remained strong and in- dependent as long as they followed the precepts and laws of Lycurgus, but once they began to neglect those ordinances, "they became much like the rest [of those under Roman rule], and put from them their former glory and freedom of speech, and were reduced to a state of subjection. And now they, like the rest of the Greeks, have come under Roman sway. "
ASK YOURSELF
1. What do you think of the Spartan attitude toward education? Why do you suppose the Spartans "banned from the country" all forms of education except for purely practical forms of reading and writing?
2. What are some of the Spartan customs regarding children and adults, and their interactions and relationships? What are the advantages and disadvantages of these customs?
Growing Up in Sparta Was No Picnic
? ? ? ? ARISTOTLE'S COMMENT ON COMMUNITY PROPERTY
One of the many works of the famous fourth-century BCE philosopher Aristotle is entitled Politics. In this lengthy treatise, he covers a number of important topics, including the nature of the state; the family; slavery; the origin of money; the various kinds of governments and constitutions, including those of Sparta, Crete, and Carthage; citizenship; revolutions; the best kind of state; and the nature and importance of education. On the matter of property held in common, he writes: "Even now there are some states in which the outlines of such a scheme [of commonly-held property] are so far apparent, as to suggest that it is not impossible; in well-ordered states . . . there are some elements of it already existing . . . In these states, each citizen has his own property, but when it comes to the use of this property, each makes a part of it available to his friends, and each devotes still another part to the common enjoyment of all fellow citizens. In Sparta, for example, men use one another's slaves, and one another's horses and dogs, as if they were their own. And they take provisions on a journey, if they happen to be in need, from the farms in the countryside belonging to other citizens. " Aristotle. Politics 2. 5; tr. Barker.
? ? ? ? ? ? 5
Voices of Ancient Greece and Rome
3.