The idea of collecting Ezra Pound's letters to his
Japanese
friends started with her.
Ezra-Pound-Japan-Letters-essays
?
^^^
\i
--
? PS 3531 082 E95
Ezra Pound G Japan : letters G essays / edited by Sanehlde Kodama* 1st ed,
-- Redding Rld@:et CT BookSv cl987<<
:
Black Swan
xvl, 249 p. f [7] p. of plates ; 24cm*
:
ill.
Includes bibliographical references* j(r9054 6ift:Mander $ ? ?
ISBN O-933806-27-2
1. Pound, Ezra, 1885-1972 --
Correspondence* 2* Pound, Ezra, 1885
--Knowledge--Japan* 3* Poets,
1972
American--20th century--Correspondence*
4* Artists--Japan--Correspondence* 5* Japan--Civilization* I* Pound, Ezra, 1885-1972* II* Kodama, Sanehlde, 1932-
19 DEC 90 13795675 NEWCxc 86-14774
//905A
? ^v-P
DATE DUE
1-5-
? ? ;q;a Pound & Japan
? ? zra Pound
LETTERS ^ ESSAYS
edited by Sanehide Kodama
BLACK SWAN BOOKS
? Copyright (C) 1987 The Trustees of the Ezra Pound Literary Property Trust
Copyright (C) 1987 Sanehide Kodama
Copyright (C) 1987 Michael Reck
Copyright (C) 1987 Mary de Rachewiltz
Copyright (C) 1987 Black Swan Books Ltd. AcknowJedgements continue copyright statement. All rights reserved.
This publication has been greatly assisted by a generous ^rant from
Q 2
;<<5
First edition
THK SUNTORY FOUNDATION.
Published by
BLACK SWAN BOOKS Ltd P. O. Box 327
Redding Ridge, CT 06876 U. S. A.
ISBN 0-933806-27-2
? Contents
Frontispiece: painting by Tami Koume ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS / vi NOTEONTHETEXT/ viii
PREFACE / ix
by John Walsh
INTRODUCTION / xiv
by Sanehide Kodama
LETTERS
I Pound's Early Contacts with Japan: 1911-23 / 1
II Pound/KitasonoCorrespondence:1936-66/ 25
III Pound's Post-World War II Contacts with Japan: 1956-68 /
129
ESSAYS IVPound'sContributionstoJapanesePeriodicals:1939-40/ 148
APPENDIX
I Tami Koume, The Art o/^Etherism / 192
II VOUClub/ 200
EzraPound,VOUClub/ 201 KatueKitasono,NotesI 202
VOUPoems/ 204 JamesLaughlin,ModernPoetsofJapanI 207 KatueKitasono,TheVOL/Ciub/ 209
III Michael Reck, Memoirs of a Parody Perry / 211
POSTSCRIPT
Mary de Rachewiltz, In Flace of a Note to Letter 71 I 214
NOTES I 216 ADDENDUM/ 248 ILLUSTRATIONS / 250
? Vi
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
First I should like to thank Mary de Rachewiltz both for what she has done for me and for the publication of this book. The idea of collecting Ezra Pound's letters to his Japanese friends started with her. She introduced me to John Walsh in 1980 and together they provided me with much valuable material for the text and notes. They have read the expanded manuscript, and provided a preface and a postscript for the book. I am also grateful to Mrs. Sakae Hashimoto, widow of Katue Kitasono, and to Yasuo Fujitomi, poet, for their enthusiastic help in Japan.
I wish also to thank the following people for their assistance in many forms: Donald Gallup, Carroll F. Terrell, Jim Generoso, John Solt, Naoki Inagaki, and above all Megumi Nakamura for providing me with information that I needed for the notes; Kenji Aral for his arrangement with the Japan Times, Inc. for permission to reprint Ezra Pound's articles; Michiko Shimizu for typing the greater part of the text; Toru Haga for recommending me to the Suntory Foundation; Akiko Miyake, Motoyuki Yoshida, and the librarians and staff at the Beinecke Library at Yale University for their courteous help and encouragement; and the Trustees of the Suntory Foundation, Osaka, for their generous financial assistance for this publica- tion.
Grateful acknowledgement and thanks are given to the following for permis- sion to include the varied Ezra Pound material: The Ezra Pound Literary Property Trust and New Directions Publishing Corp. ; The Beinecke Rare Book and Manu- script Library, Yale University; Ikuko Atsumi, for a letter from Yone Noguchi's Collected English Letters (Tokyo: Zokei Bijutsu Kyokai, 1975); Koichi Iwasaki, for letters to his father, Ryozo Iwasaki; Yukio Sato, for a letter to the Japanese Ambassa- dor in Rome; Tokutaro Shigehisa, for a letter to Tomoji Okada; Townsman, for the essay "VOU Club"; and Shiro Tsunoda, for his help and for the fragment of the letter addressed to himself. The citations for previously published material by Ezra Pound are as follows: The Cantos (copyright 1934, 1937, 1940, 1948, 1956, 1959, 1962, 1963, 1966, 1968 by Ezra Pound; copyright (C) 1972 by the Estate of Ezra Pound); Selected Letters, 1907-1941, ed. D. D. Paige (copyright 1950 by Ezra Pound; copyright (C) 1971 by New Directions Publishing Corp. ); Ezra Pound Speak- ing, ed. Leonard Doob (copyright (C) 1978 by the Ezra Pound Literary Property Trust). Permission to reprint the articles which first appeared in the papers pub- lished by the Japan Times, Inc. has been granted by Gyo Hani, Chief Editor, The Japan Times, Inc.
Likewise grateful acknowledgement and thanks are extended to the following for permission to include the varied material by Pound's Japanese correspondents. The Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library, Yale University; Lilly Library, Indiana University; Harry Ransom Humanities Research Center, the University of Texas at Austin; Kunio Ito (Koreyo Senda) for letters by his brother, Michio Ito; Koichi Iwasaki, for letters from his father, Ryozo Iwasaki; Masayoshi Kume, for material of his father, Tamijuro Kume; Yoshinobu Mori, for a letter by his father,
? ACKNOWLEDGEMENT VI
Yasotaro Mori; Masao Noguchi, for letters of Yonijiro Noguchi; and Eiichiro Oshi- ma, for a letter by his father, Shotaro Oshima; Townsman for Katue Kitasono's "Notes" and New Directions for the VOU poems and "Modern Poets of Japan. "
Further acknowledgement and thanks are offered to the following for various permissions: Mary de Rachewiltz, James Laughlin and Fosco Maraini, for their own material; Omar Pound, for letters by Dorothy Pound (copyright (C) 1987 by Omar S. Pound); and Michael Reck, for his own material, and that by Ezra Pound and Katue Kitasono included in his Ezra Pound: A Close-Up (NY: McGraw-Hill, 1967). Ac- knowledgement is also made to Basil Bunting, Collected Poems (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1979, copyright (C) 1978 by Basil Bunting), and to Van Wyck Brooks, FenoJIosa and His Circle (NY: E. P. Dutton, 1962).
Finally,myspecialthanksareduetoJohnWalsh. I shouldliketoexpressmy heartfelt appreciation for the encouragement and assistance I received from him in many forms and over a period of many years. --S. K.
? yiii
NOTE ON TEXT
NOTE ON THE TEXT
In rendering the Pound material in typeset format, certain translations have been utilized: underlined words have been placed in italics; double underlined words are indicated by boldface; and triple underlining appears as italic capitals. Words originally in block letters appear in small capitals. Handwritten inserts have been placed in the text where indicated by Pound and appear in italics within angle brackets. Phrases and words in foreign languages, as well as titles, have been italicized. With few exceptions. Pound's original spelling, punctuation and spacing have been retained, and a line-for-line approximation has been attempted. In only a few cases have the letters from Japanese correspondents been corrected to aid clarification; no attempt has been made to regularize Japanese names and terms, as this forms one of the themes of the correspondence. The following manuscript abbreviations (followed by the number of pages of the original) have been used: tl
= typed letter; TLS = typed letter signed; PC = postcard; AL = handwritten letter; and ALS = handwritten letter signed.
In the Notes, citations to the editions of Pound's works as listed in Donald Gallup's Ezra Pound: A Bibliography, 2nd ed. (Charlottesville: University of Vir- ginia Press, 1983) have been placed within brackets.
Two additional references are to be included: Ezra Pound, Plays Modelled on the Noh (1916), ed. Donald Gallup (Toledo: Friends of the University of Toledo Libraries, 1987); and Octavio Paz, Jacques Roubaud, Eduardo Sanguinetti and Charles Tomlinson, Rengo: A Chain of Poems (NY: Braziller, 1971)--with special reference to letter 73: The modern chain poem is a descendant of the Japanese "kusari-renga" ["linked poems"] developed between the Heian (794-1183) and Muromachi (1336-1573) periods.
? PREFACE
On the walls of the Boston Museum of Fine Arts hangs a painting by the American painter William Paxton entitled The New Necklace. In the paint- ing is depicted a young American woman, wrapped in an oriental jacket placed over her long frilled dress; she is seated by an oriental screen, set in front of the Western painting and tapestry on the wall; an encased oriental statuette is on top of the woman's lacquered writing desk-chest. The date of the painting is 1910.
The intermixing of styles in this painting reflects the extent of the current vogue of /aponisme, in a setting most likely proximate to one of the ports of the Yankee clipper trade which flourished between Yokohama and Salem. "Things Japanese" had most definitely entered American fashion by this time, a good fifty years after the American painters La Farge and Whistler had begun their collections of Japanese Ukiyoe [woodblockl prints. Such artistic transport, facilitated by the speed of the Yankee clipper ships, prompted Van Wyck Brooks to remark that "the Far East seemed closer to Salem than to any other American town when Ernest FenoUosa* was born there in 1853" (FenoJJosa and His Circle).
The Museum of Fine Arts in Boston, and the nearby Peabody Museum in Salem, were the recipients of much of the art and artifacts of traditional Japanese culture that were shored up against time, thanks to a determined effort on the part of a group of Boston-based Americans who had travelled to Japan--fortuitously arriving at precisely the critical moment for their enterprise. Ernest FenoUosa and Edward Morse, followed by William Stur- gis Bigelow and Percival Lowell, and later by Henry Adams, John La Farge, and then Lafcadio Hearn--all arrived in Japan within nearly a decade (1878-90], at a time when the traditional culture of Japan was on the brink of being swept away. "P'or twenty years," remarks Van Wyck Brooks, "the most precious works were treated as rubbish. " Masterpieces were paradox- ically more commonly to be found in trash-heaps than in showrooms. With a broad gesture, the Japanese had turned their backs on their past in favor of Western modernity. A year after FenoUosa had arrived in Japan, he had been able to acquire a masterpiece by the painter Ganku from a dealer who had never even heard of the master's name, and he was still able to find in 1884 a fine ceramic head of the Buddha--one of the earliest relics of Tendai sculpture--in an ash barrel where it had been discarded. Along with FenoUosa and Morse, these Americans eagerly took to the task of attempt-
IX
--
? X PREFACE
ing to preserve what they feared to be the last surviving traces of a vanishing civilization. Fenollosa took sculpture and painting as his specialty, while Morse chose pottery. Morse also took lessons in the traditional tea cere- mony, and studied Japanese singing with the No master, Minoru Umewaka, under whom Fenollosa studied as well.
At a time when the Japanese feudal system was in its death-throes and
noble families found it necessary to sell their great collections to stave off
poverty, excellent examples of traditional art--swords, guards, emblems,
lacquer boxes, along with statues, paintings, scrolls and pottery
abounded in a radically devalued market. And Fenollosa and Morse bought
discerningly and extensively, shipping off vast collections to the Museum
of Fine Arts in Boston.
Along with Okakura Kakuzo (who organized the Imperial Art School in
Tokyo), Fenollosa acted as Imperial Commissioner of Fine Art and scoured the countryside in search of cast-off treasures. Ironically, however, most of this treasure was being shipped to America. Morse, well aware of the contradiction, remarked: "It is like the life-blood of Japan seeping from a hidden wound. " But this wound was soon to be staunched; in 1884, further transport of national Japanese treasures (now recognized to be so) began to be discussed by the Japanese government. By 1885, a rebirth of interest in the traditional culture of Japan had begun.
Certainly, the crucial role played by this small group of American Japanophiles had not been forgotten by the Japanese; in the words of Prof. Yaichi Haga, "An American, Ernest Fenollosa, taught us how to admire the unique beauty of our art. " And upon preparing to return to America in
1886, Fenollosa was told by the Emperor: "You have taught my people to know their own art; in going back to your great country, I charge you, teach them also. "
When Ezra Pound in London received his first letter from a Japanese correspondent in 1911 (a year before the publication of FenoUosa's Epochs of Chinese and Japanese Art], he probably was not as yet familiar with the work of Fenollosa. Perhaps he had not yet at that time thought much directly about Japan, even though he was certainly familiar with the art of Whistler. Were he in London at the time, he most probably would have seen the Japanese Exhibition held at Shepherd's Bush in 1910. Perhaps he had even discussed Fenollosa when he met, in October 1913, the American photographer Alvin Langdon Coburn, who had intensively studied the collection of Chinese and Japanese art set up by Fenollosa in the Boston
? PREFACE xi
Museum of Fine Arts. But when towards the end of 1913 he received from Mary Fenollosa the notebooks containing Fenollosa's notes on oriental literature, draft translations of Chinese poetry and Japanese No dramas, along with his essay "The Chinese Written Character as a Medium for Poetry"--with the stipulation that Fenollosa wanted the material treated as literature, not philology--a world opened. In March 1909, Pound had heard Laurence Binyon lecture on "Oriental and European Art," and in the spring of 1911, he had written his haiku-like poem on the Paris Metro (see Sanehide Kodama, American Poetry and Japanese Culture). He had also written in 1913, prior to the receipt of the bulk of Fenollosa material, the Chinese-inspired poems "After Ch'u Yuan," "Fan-Piece for Her Imperial Lord," and "Liu Ch'e. " Most significantly. Pound's "A Few Don'ts by an Imagiste" had already appeared. But what accompanied China in the Fenollosa notebooks was the near-virgin world of Japan--territory which he set about exploring almost immediately. Pound and W. B. Yeats spent much of the winter of 1913 in Stone Cottage immersed in the study and translation of No drama. By January of 1914 Pound was able to send off to Harriet Monroe of Poetry the finished version of Nishikigi. And so began
his lifetime enthrallment.
Ironically, Pound's discovery of Japanese drama coincided with an-
other phase of modern Japan's turning away from its traditional culture. When the Japanese dancer Michio Ito arrived in London in 1914, he knew next to nothing about classical Japanese drama--but, most fortunately, a fellow expatriate, the painter Tami Koume, did. So it was in London, not Tokyo, that Ito learned about his own cultural tradition. (Perhaps the apocryphal story of Ito's visit with Yeats to the London zoo to watch the movements of a caged hawk justifiedly merits being preserved. ) From these seeds, the study of No drama became an enduring passion for Pound.
The importance of the No drama for Pound echoes throughout this correspondence. Seated in the cinema in Rapallo watching the film Mit- souko, Pound is filled with nostalgia, struck by the sound of the singing, and remembering a No performance enacted in Paris by Tami Koume and other Japanese: "You have a treasure like nothing we have in the Occident. " In a later letter of 1957, Pound most succinctly and poignantly remarks: "Hagoronno is a sacrament. " And Pound seriously and fondly hoped that his own play. Women of Trachis (1954), would be translated into Japanese and be staged by a No troupe: "Am convinced the Noh technique is only way of doing it properly, in whatever language. "
It was to preserve this induplicable treasure of the No that Pound went to the extreme of suggesting that the American-occupied island of Guam be
--
? Xii
PREFACE
negotiated with the Japanese in exchange for a set of films of classic No plays--along with their authentic music, "insist," wrote Pound to the Japanese poet Katue Kitasono, "on having 300 Noh plays done properly and recorded on sound film so as to be able to educate such American students as are capable of being cultured. "
Ironic indeed that this was being said by an American at a time when many modern Japanese were in another phase of turning away from their cultural heritage--the avant-garde poet, Katue Kitasono. most certainly included. When in 1952 Michael Reck--who made a pilgrimage to Fenollo- sa's grave above Lake Biwa [cf. Canto LXXXIX)--upon Pound's urging met Kitasono, he discovered that the Japanese poet evidenced no enthusiasm at all at the prospect of attending a No performance--to such an extent that he sent his wife in his place to accompany the young American. And after a short time, she politely excused herself and left the performance, leaving the American to discover the classical world of Japan on his own. There is a certain humor in the fact that Pound in his letters to Kitasono is continually asking questions about Japan's traditional culture--ironic in that Kitasono was not at all as interested in it as was Pound himself. For Kitasono embodied contemporary Japan.
What Kitasono, in turn, presented to Pound was not the past but the new. He introduced Pound to what the young avant-garde was doing as reflected in poems written by members of the VOU Club and published in its magazine. Pound seized upon the potential offered by this poetry washed clean as if by acid--written in halting English translations by these young Japanese, for he saw that they approached the language with fresh eyes, without preconceptions, and used English freely, idiosyncratically and inventively. "All the moss and fuzz that for twenty years we have been trying to scrape off our language--these young men start without it. " He praised this "vortex of poetic alertness" for its immense clarity and rapid-
ity: "The Japanese eye is like those new camera shutters that catch the bullet leaving the gun. . . . They see the crystal set, the chemical laboratory and the pine tree with untrammeled clearness. . . . The Japanese poet has gone from one peak of [thought] to another faster than our slow wits permit us to follow before we have got used to his pace. "
Rather than condescendingly dismissing these poems for their techni- cal flaws, Pound positively saw in them a new beginning and enthusiasti- cally recommended them to Ronald Duncan of Townsman and lames Laughlin of New Directions for publication. While one need not necessarily agree with Pound's generous evaluation of them as "better work than any save those of E. E. Cummings," by seeing them in the manner that Pound
? PREFACE xiii
saw them and for the qualities that he cited, lessons could be learned. Here Japan was making its contemporary contribution to the West.
This collection of letters and essays documents Pound's lifelong in- volvement with the art, literature and culture of japan. Extending from 1911 to 1968, Pound's correspondence with Japanese artists and poets forms a record of a vital cultural interchange from which both East and West gained through the interaction. Included in this volume are letters from the Japanese painter Tami Koume and the dancer Michio Ito dating from Pound's early years in London--when he was at work with W. B. Yeats on translating Japanese No dramas--and his years in Paris during the early 1920's; the correspondence between Pound and the Japanese mod- ernist poet Katue Kitasono (editor of VOU) while Pound was residing in Rapallo (and later from St. Elizabeths); and articles written by Pound which appeared in the Japan Times just prior to the outbreak of World War II, promoting cross-cultural communication and insisting that "diplomacy alone could not do it. " Letters from Mary Fenollosa and various other
Japanese correspondents, along with the pertinent material included in the appendix, further round out the portrait.
Similar to the influence exerted by a previous generation of Americans who had travelled to Japan (Fenollosa, Bigelow, Morse, La Farge and Hearn), EzraPoundfromafaralsomadehiscontributiontothepreservation of the classic Japanese tradition, drawing attention to its masterworks as an essential component of world culture and a crucial means to increase East-West understanding.
--John WaJsh
'For further on Fenollosa, see note to letter 4 on Mary Fenollosa; see also Van Wyck Brooks, Fenollosa and His Circle (NY: E. P. Dutton, 1962).
? XIV
INTRODUCTION
In this book are collected letters exchanged between Ezra Pound and his Japanese friends, ranging between the years 1911 to 1968. These letters are, in most cases, chronologically arranged so that the reader may have an historical overview of Pound's involvement with the art and culture of Japan. The book also includes Pound's contributions to Japanese per- iodicals written shortly before World War II, at a time when he had little outlet elsewhere. Supplementary letters, such as those between Ezra Pound and Mary Fenollosa, Katue Kitasono to Dorothy Pound and Mary de Rache-
wiltz, etc. , which touch on material regarding Japan have also been in- cluded.
In the summer of 1911 Ezra Pound received a completely unexpected letter postmarked from Japan. "Dear Mr. Pound," the letter opened, "As I believe you may not know my work at all, I send you, under a separate cover, my new book of poems called The Pilgrimage. . . . " It was from Yonejiro Noguchi, a Japanese poet who was ten years older than Pound and had been favorably received in England and America. He had published a few books of verse and prose in English in both countries: Seen and Unseen (1897), The American Diary o/a Japanese GirJ (1902] and From the Eastern Sea (1902), and had returned to Japan after spending thirteen years abroad.
In his polite response to Noguchi Pound wrote, "of your country I know almost nothing. " But he also wrote, "1 had, of course, known of you. " One may wonder how much knowledge Pound actually had of Japan when he said, "I know almost nothing. " It can be assumed that by 1911 Pound already had some knowledge of Japanese haiku, as he had regularly been attending T. E. Hulme's meetings at the Cafe Tour d'Eiffel since 1909, where haiku had by then become common knowledge. Basil Hall Chamber- lain's CJassicaJ Poetry of the Japanese (London, 1880) had long been out. One of the members of the group, Joseph Campbell, had written three-line poems such as "The Dawn Whiteness," and Edward Storer had written "Image. " F. S. Flint had translated some haiku into English from Paul-Louis Couchoud's French translations, including a piece by Arakida Takeari, which Pound was later to quote. Actually Pound might already have read Couchoud's and Chamberlain's translations himself.
But haiku was not the only aspect of Japan that Pound was acquainted with by that time. He surely would have known something of Japan's political and social aspects as well: news of the unexpected victory of Japan
? INTRODUCTION XV
over Imperial Russia in 1905 and reports concerning the Baltic Fleet, the battles at Liishun, and the following negotiations at Portsmouth, New
Hampshire, most certainly.
Moreover, Pound's juvenescence had coincided with the period of
/aponisme. Certainly, Japan had been "opened" to the American market for some time. Even Sears, Roebuck and Co. had listed Japanese fans with illustrations in their catalogue of 1902. Lacquer ware, paper napkins, kimo- no, netsuke, wood-block prints, and other objets d'art had been imported through Yamanaka & Co. for domestic usage. French and American pain- ters had been influenced for some time by Japanese art, and in his early essays Pound had already made frequent mention of the connection be- tween Whistler and Hokusai.
But Pound in 1911 was still looking at Japan through the back end of a pair of opera glasses. Pound viewed Japan as a far-away, beautiful country, inhabited by people with a delicate and subtle sensibility, by women pretty, gentle, obedient, and loveable, and by men courageous enough to defeat Imperial Russia. When he received a businesslike letter from Yone Noguchi, therefore.
The idea of collecting Ezra Pound's letters to his Japanese friends started with her. She introduced me to John Walsh in 1980 and together they provided me with much valuable material for the text and notes. They have read the expanded manuscript, and provided a preface and a postscript for the book. I am also grateful to Mrs. Sakae Hashimoto, widow of Katue Kitasono, and to Yasuo Fujitomi, poet, for their enthusiastic help in Japan.
I wish also to thank the following people for their assistance in many forms: Donald Gallup, Carroll F. Terrell, Jim Generoso, John Solt, Naoki Inagaki, and above all Megumi Nakamura for providing me with information that I needed for the notes; Kenji Aral for his arrangement with the Japan Times, Inc. for permission to reprint Ezra Pound's articles; Michiko Shimizu for typing the greater part of the text; Toru Haga for recommending me to the Suntory Foundation; Akiko Miyake, Motoyuki Yoshida, and the librarians and staff at the Beinecke Library at Yale University for their courteous help and encouragement; and the Trustees of the Suntory Foundation, Osaka, for their generous financial assistance for this publica- tion.
Grateful acknowledgement and thanks are given to the following for permis- sion to include the varied Ezra Pound material: The Ezra Pound Literary Property Trust and New Directions Publishing Corp. ; The Beinecke Rare Book and Manu- script Library, Yale University; Ikuko Atsumi, for a letter from Yone Noguchi's Collected English Letters (Tokyo: Zokei Bijutsu Kyokai, 1975); Koichi Iwasaki, for letters to his father, Ryozo Iwasaki; Yukio Sato, for a letter to the Japanese Ambassa- dor in Rome; Tokutaro Shigehisa, for a letter to Tomoji Okada; Townsman, for the essay "VOU Club"; and Shiro Tsunoda, for his help and for the fragment of the letter addressed to himself. The citations for previously published material by Ezra Pound are as follows: The Cantos (copyright 1934, 1937, 1940, 1948, 1956, 1959, 1962, 1963, 1966, 1968 by Ezra Pound; copyright (C) 1972 by the Estate of Ezra Pound); Selected Letters, 1907-1941, ed. D. D. Paige (copyright 1950 by Ezra Pound; copyright (C) 1971 by New Directions Publishing Corp. ); Ezra Pound Speak- ing, ed. Leonard Doob (copyright (C) 1978 by the Ezra Pound Literary Property Trust). Permission to reprint the articles which first appeared in the papers pub- lished by the Japan Times, Inc. has been granted by Gyo Hani, Chief Editor, The Japan Times, Inc.
Likewise grateful acknowledgement and thanks are extended to the following for permission to include the varied material by Pound's Japanese correspondents. The Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library, Yale University; Lilly Library, Indiana University; Harry Ransom Humanities Research Center, the University of Texas at Austin; Kunio Ito (Koreyo Senda) for letters by his brother, Michio Ito; Koichi Iwasaki, for letters from his father, Ryozo Iwasaki; Masayoshi Kume, for material of his father, Tamijuro Kume; Yoshinobu Mori, for a letter by his father,
? ACKNOWLEDGEMENT VI
Yasotaro Mori; Masao Noguchi, for letters of Yonijiro Noguchi; and Eiichiro Oshi- ma, for a letter by his father, Shotaro Oshima; Townsman for Katue Kitasono's "Notes" and New Directions for the VOU poems and "Modern Poets of Japan. "
Further acknowledgement and thanks are offered to the following for various permissions: Mary de Rachewiltz, James Laughlin and Fosco Maraini, for their own material; Omar Pound, for letters by Dorothy Pound (copyright (C) 1987 by Omar S. Pound); and Michael Reck, for his own material, and that by Ezra Pound and Katue Kitasono included in his Ezra Pound: A Close-Up (NY: McGraw-Hill, 1967). Ac- knowledgement is also made to Basil Bunting, Collected Poems (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1979, copyright (C) 1978 by Basil Bunting), and to Van Wyck Brooks, FenoJIosa and His Circle (NY: E. P. Dutton, 1962).
Finally,myspecialthanksareduetoJohnWalsh. I shouldliketoexpressmy heartfelt appreciation for the encouragement and assistance I received from him in many forms and over a period of many years. --S. K.
? yiii
NOTE ON TEXT
NOTE ON THE TEXT
In rendering the Pound material in typeset format, certain translations have been utilized: underlined words have been placed in italics; double underlined words are indicated by boldface; and triple underlining appears as italic capitals. Words originally in block letters appear in small capitals. Handwritten inserts have been placed in the text where indicated by Pound and appear in italics within angle brackets. Phrases and words in foreign languages, as well as titles, have been italicized. With few exceptions. Pound's original spelling, punctuation and spacing have been retained, and a line-for-line approximation has been attempted. In only a few cases have the letters from Japanese correspondents been corrected to aid clarification; no attempt has been made to regularize Japanese names and terms, as this forms one of the themes of the correspondence. The following manuscript abbreviations (followed by the number of pages of the original) have been used: tl
= typed letter; TLS = typed letter signed; PC = postcard; AL = handwritten letter; and ALS = handwritten letter signed.
In the Notes, citations to the editions of Pound's works as listed in Donald Gallup's Ezra Pound: A Bibliography, 2nd ed. (Charlottesville: University of Vir- ginia Press, 1983) have been placed within brackets.
Two additional references are to be included: Ezra Pound, Plays Modelled on the Noh (1916), ed. Donald Gallup (Toledo: Friends of the University of Toledo Libraries, 1987); and Octavio Paz, Jacques Roubaud, Eduardo Sanguinetti and Charles Tomlinson, Rengo: A Chain of Poems (NY: Braziller, 1971)--with special reference to letter 73: The modern chain poem is a descendant of the Japanese "kusari-renga" ["linked poems"] developed between the Heian (794-1183) and Muromachi (1336-1573) periods.
? PREFACE
On the walls of the Boston Museum of Fine Arts hangs a painting by the American painter William Paxton entitled The New Necklace. In the paint- ing is depicted a young American woman, wrapped in an oriental jacket placed over her long frilled dress; she is seated by an oriental screen, set in front of the Western painting and tapestry on the wall; an encased oriental statuette is on top of the woman's lacquered writing desk-chest. The date of the painting is 1910.
The intermixing of styles in this painting reflects the extent of the current vogue of /aponisme, in a setting most likely proximate to one of the ports of the Yankee clipper trade which flourished between Yokohama and Salem. "Things Japanese" had most definitely entered American fashion by this time, a good fifty years after the American painters La Farge and Whistler had begun their collections of Japanese Ukiyoe [woodblockl prints. Such artistic transport, facilitated by the speed of the Yankee clipper ships, prompted Van Wyck Brooks to remark that "the Far East seemed closer to Salem than to any other American town when Ernest FenoUosa* was born there in 1853" (FenoJJosa and His Circle).
The Museum of Fine Arts in Boston, and the nearby Peabody Museum in Salem, were the recipients of much of the art and artifacts of traditional Japanese culture that were shored up against time, thanks to a determined effort on the part of a group of Boston-based Americans who had travelled to Japan--fortuitously arriving at precisely the critical moment for their enterprise. Ernest FenoUosa and Edward Morse, followed by William Stur- gis Bigelow and Percival Lowell, and later by Henry Adams, John La Farge, and then Lafcadio Hearn--all arrived in Japan within nearly a decade (1878-90], at a time when the traditional culture of Japan was on the brink of being swept away. "P'or twenty years," remarks Van Wyck Brooks, "the most precious works were treated as rubbish. " Masterpieces were paradox- ically more commonly to be found in trash-heaps than in showrooms. With a broad gesture, the Japanese had turned their backs on their past in favor of Western modernity. A year after FenoUosa had arrived in Japan, he had been able to acquire a masterpiece by the painter Ganku from a dealer who had never even heard of the master's name, and he was still able to find in 1884 a fine ceramic head of the Buddha--one of the earliest relics of Tendai sculpture--in an ash barrel where it had been discarded. Along with FenoUosa and Morse, these Americans eagerly took to the task of attempt-
IX
--
? X PREFACE
ing to preserve what they feared to be the last surviving traces of a vanishing civilization. Fenollosa took sculpture and painting as his specialty, while Morse chose pottery. Morse also took lessons in the traditional tea cere- mony, and studied Japanese singing with the No master, Minoru Umewaka, under whom Fenollosa studied as well.
At a time when the Japanese feudal system was in its death-throes and
noble families found it necessary to sell their great collections to stave off
poverty, excellent examples of traditional art--swords, guards, emblems,
lacquer boxes, along with statues, paintings, scrolls and pottery
abounded in a radically devalued market. And Fenollosa and Morse bought
discerningly and extensively, shipping off vast collections to the Museum
of Fine Arts in Boston.
Along with Okakura Kakuzo (who organized the Imperial Art School in
Tokyo), Fenollosa acted as Imperial Commissioner of Fine Art and scoured the countryside in search of cast-off treasures. Ironically, however, most of this treasure was being shipped to America. Morse, well aware of the contradiction, remarked: "It is like the life-blood of Japan seeping from a hidden wound. " But this wound was soon to be staunched; in 1884, further transport of national Japanese treasures (now recognized to be so) began to be discussed by the Japanese government. By 1885, a rebirth of interest in the traditional culture of Japan had begun.
Certainly, the crucial role played by this small group of American Japanophiles had not been forgotten by the Japanese; in the words of Prof. Yaichi Haga, "An American, Ernest Fenollosa, taught us how to admire the unique beauty of our art. " And upon preparing to return to America in
1886, Fenollosa was told by the Emperor: "You have taught my people to know their own art; in going back to your great country, I charge you, teach them also. "
When Ezra Pound in London received his first letter from a Japanese correspondent in 1911 (a year before the publication of FenoUosa's Epochs of Chinese and Japanese Art], he probably was not as yet familiar with the work of Fenollosa. Perhaps he had not yet at that time thought much directly about Japan, even though he was certainly familiar with the art of Whistler. Were he in London at the time, he most probably would have seen the Japanese Exhibition held at Shepherd's Bush in 1910. Perhaps he had even discussed Fenollosa when he met, in October 1913, the American photographer Alvin Langdon Coburn, who had intensively studied the collection of Chinese and Japanese art set up by Fenollosa in the Boston
? PREFACE xi
Museum of Fine Arts. But when towards the end of 1913 he received from Mary Fenollosa the notebooks containing Fenollosa's notes on oriental literature, draft translations of Chinese poetry and Japanese No dramas, along with his essay "The Chinese Written Character as a Medium for Poetry"--with the stipulation that Fenollosa wanted the material treated as literature, not philology--a world opened. In March 1909, Pound had heard Laurence Binyon lecture on "Oriental and European Art," and in the spring of 1911, he had written his haiku-like poem on the Paris Metro (see Sanehide Kodama, American Poetry and Japanese Culture). He had also written in 1913, prior to the receipt of the bulk of Fenollosa material, the Chinese-inspired poems "After Ch'u Yuan," "Fan-Piece for Her Imperial Lord," and "Liu Ch'e. " Most significantly. Pound's "A Few Don'ts by an Imagiste" had already appeared. But what accompanied China in the Fenollosa notebooks was the near-virgin world of Japan--territory which he set about exploring almost immediately. Pound and W. B. Yeats spent much of the winter of 1913 in Stone Cottage immersed in the study and translation of No drama. By January of 1914 Pound was able to send off to Harriet Monroe of Poetry the finished version of Nishikigi. And so began
his lifetime enthrallment.
Ironically, Pound's discovery of Japanese drama coincided with an-
other phase of modern Japan's turning away from its traditional culture. When the Japanese dancer Michio Ito arrived in London in 1914, he knew next to nothing about classical Japanese drama--but, most fortunately, a fellow expatriate, the painter Tami Koume, did. So it was in London, not Tokyo, that Ito learned about his own cultural tradition. (Perhaps the apocryphal story of Ito's visit with Yeats to the London zoo to watch the movements of a caged hawk justifiedly merits being preserved. ) From these seeds, the study of No drama became an enduring passion for Pound.
The importance of the No drama for Pound echoes throughout this correspondence. Seated in the cinema in Rapallo watching the film Mit- souko, Pound is filled with nostalgia, struck by the sound of the singing, and remembering a No performance enacted in Paris by Tami Koume and other Japanese: "You have a treasure like nothing we have in the Occident. " In a later letter of 1957, Pound most succinctly and poignantly remarks: "Hagoronno is a sacrament. " And Pound seriously and fondly hoped that his own play. Women of Trachis (1954), would be translated into Japanese and be staged by a No troupe: "Am convinced the Noh technique is only way of doing it properly, in whatever language. "
It was to preserve this induplicable treasure of the No that Pound went to the extreme of suggesting that the American-occupied island of Guam be
--
? Xii
PREFACE
negotiated with the Japanese in exchange for a set of films of classic No plays--along with their authentic music, "insist," wrote Pound to the Japanese poet Katue Kitasono, "on having 300 Noh plays done properly and recorded on sound film so as to be able to educate such American students as are capable of being cultured. "
Ironic indeed that this was being said by an American at a time when many modern Japanese were in another phase of turning away from their cultural heritage--the avant-garde poet, Katue Kitasono. most certainly included. When in 1952 Michael Reck--who made a pilgrimage to Fenollo- sa's grave above Lake Biwa [cf. Canto LXXXIX)--upon Pound's urging met Kitasono, he discovered that the Japanese poet evidenced no enthusiasm at all at the prospect of attending a No performance--to such an extent that he sent his wife in his place to accompany the young American. And after a short time, she politely excused herself and left the performance, leaving the American to discover the classical world of Japan on his own. There is a certain humor in the fact that Pound in his letters to Kitasono is continually asking questions about Japan's traditional culture--ironic in that Kitasono was not at all as interested in it as was Pound himself. For Kitasono embodied contemporary Japan.
What Kitasono, in turn, presented to Pound was not the past but the new. He introduced Pound to what the young avant-garde was doing as reflected in poems written by members of the VOU Club and published in its magazine. Pound seized upon the potential offered by this poetry washed clean as if by acid--written in halting English translations by these young Japanese, for he saw that they approached the language with fresh eyes, without preconceptions, and used English freely, idiosyncratically and inventively. "All the moss and fuzz that for twenty years we have been trying to scrape off our language--these young men start without it. " He praised this "vortex of poetic alertness" for its immense clarity and rapid-
ity: "The Japanese eye is like those new camera shutters that catch the bullet leaving the gun. . . . They see the crystal set, the chemical laboratory and the pine tree with untrammeled clearness. . . . The Japanese poet has gone from one peak of [thought] to another faster than our slow wits permit us to follow before we have got used to his pace. "
Rather than condescendingly dismissing these poems for their techni- cal flaws, Pound positively saw in them a new beginning and enthusiasti- cally recommended them to Ronald Duncan of Townsman and lames Laughlin of New Directions for publication. While one need not necessarily agree with Pound's generous evaluation of them as "better work than any save those of E. E. Cummings," by seeing them in the manner that Pound
? PREFACE xiii
saw them and for the qualities that he cited, lessons could be learned. Here Japan was making its contemporary contribution to the West.
This collection of letters and essays documents Pound's lifelong in- volvement with the art, literature and culture of japan. Extending from 1911 to 1968, Pound's correspondence with Japanese artists and poets forms a record of a vital cultural interchange from which both East and West gained through the interaction. Included in this volume are letters from the Japanese painter Tami Koume and the dancer Michio Ito dating from Pound's early years in London--when he was at work with W. B. Yeats on translating Japanese No dramas--and his years in Paris during the early 1920's; the correspondence between Pound and the Japanese mod- ernist poet Katue Kitasono (editor of VOU) while Pound was residing in Rapallo (and later from St. Elizabeths); and articles written by Pound which appeared in the Japan Times just prior to the outbreak of World War II, promoting cross-cultural communication and insisting that "diplomacy alone could not do it. " Letters from Mary Fenollosa and various other
Japanese correspondents, along with the pertinent material included in the appendix, further round out the portrait.
Similar to the influence exerted by a previous generation of Americans who had travelled to Japan (Fenollosa, Bigelow, Morse, La Farge and Hearn), EzraPoundfromafaralsomadehiscontributiontothepreservation of the classic Japanese tradition, drawing attention to its masterworks as an essential component of world culture and a crucial means to increase East-West understanding.
--John WaJsh
'For further on Fenollosa, see note to letter 4 on Mary Fenollosa; see also Van Wyck Brooks, Fenollosa and His Circle (NY: E. P. Dutton, 1962).
? XIV
INTRODUCTION
In this book are collected letters exchanged between Ezra Pound and his Japanese friends, ranging between the years 1911 to 1968. These letters are, in most cases, chronologically arranged so that the reader may have an historical overview of Pound's involvement with the art and culture of Japan. The book also includes Pound's contributions to Japanese per- iodicals written shortly before World War II, at a time when he had little outlet elsewhere. Supplementary letters, such as those between Ezra Pound and Mary Fenollosa, Katue Kitasono to Dorothy Pound and Mary de Rache-
wiltz, etc. , which touch on material regarding Japan have also been in- cluded.
In the summer of 1911 Ezra Pound received a completely unexpected letter postmarked from Japan. "Dear Mr. Pound," the letter opened, "As I believe you may not know my work at all, I send you, under a separate cover, my new book of poems called The Pilgrimage. . . . " It was from Yonejiro Noguchi, a Japanese poet who was ten years older than Pound and had been favorably received in England and America. He had published a few books of verse and prose in English in both countries: Seen and Unseen (1897), The American Diary o/a Japanese GirJ (1902] and From the Eastern Sea (1902), and had returned to Japan after spending thirteen years abroad.
In his polite response to Noguchi Pound wrote, "of your country I know almost nothing. " But he also wrote, "1 had, of course, known of you. " One may wonder how much knowledge Pound actually had of Japan when he said, "I know almost nothing. " It can be assumed that by 1911 Pound already had some knowledge of Japanese haiku, as he had regularly been attending T. E. Hulme's meetings at the Cafe Tour d'Eiffel since 1909, where haiku had by then become common knowledge. Basil Hall Chamber- lain's CJassicaJ Poetry of the Japanese (London, 1880) had long been out. One of the members of the group, Joseph Campbell, had written three-line poems such as "The Dawn Whiteness," and Edward Storer had written "Image. " F. S. Flint had translated some haiku into English from Paul-Louis Couchoud's French translations, including a piece by Arakida Takeari, which Pound was later to quote. Actually Pound might already have read Couchoud's and Chamberlain's translations himself.
But haiku was not the only aspect of Japan that Pound was acquainted with by that time. He surely would have known something of Japan's political and social aspects as well: news of the unexpected victory of Japan
? INTRODUCTION XV
over Imperial Russia in 1905 and reports concerning the Baltic Fleet, the battles at Liishun, and the following negotiations at Portsmouth, New
Hampshire, most certainly.
Moreover, Pound's juvenescence had coincided with the period of
/aponisme. Certainly, Japan had been "opened" to the American market for some time. Even Sears, Roebuck and Co. had listed Japanese fans with illustrations in their catalogue of 1902. Lacquer ware, paper napkins, kimo- no, netsuke, wood-block prints, and other objets d'art had been imported through Yamanaka & Co. for domestic usage. French and American pain- ters had been influenced for some time by Japanese art, and in his early essays Pound had already made frequent mention of the connection be- tween Whistler and Hokusai.
But Pound in 1911 was still looking at Japan through the back end of a pair of opera glasses. Pound viewed Japan as a far-away, beautiful country, inhabited by people with a delicate and subtle sensibility, by women pretty, gentle, obedient, and loveable, and by men courageous enough to defeat Imperial Russia. When he received a businesslike letter from Yone Noguchi, therefore. Pound must have been surprised, but he does not seem to have changed his basic view of Japan. The image of a dream-like Japan had been so strongly imprinted on his young mind that it could not easily
be changed or removed.
When he wrote "The Encounter," Pound compared the graceful fingers
of a London woman to the "tissue" of a soft and lissome "Japanese paper napkin. " And when he wrote the "Metro" poem suggested by haiku, Pound presented the image of the glimmering petals scattered upon "the wet, black bough" as if painted on soft Japanese paper, to be "superimposed" upon the image of the beautiful faces of women and children in Paris.
By the time Pound met Mary Fenollosa, in 1913--and soon afterwards received the bundle of her late husband's notebooks on the No plays and Japanese interpretations of Chinese classics--his knowledge of Japan had been substantially enhanced. Yet he does not seem even then to have changed his basic image of Japan. Rather, he became more enthusiastic about "beautifying" Japan. While promoting the production of Yeats' At the Hawk's Well, Pound met Michio Ito, Tamijuro Kume and Jisoichi Kayano, and through them became acquainted with the Japanese language, Japanese customs, the No plays, Zen and various other aspects of Japan. He ex- perienced, as it were, some new phases of the realities of Japan, including the awkward English of many Japanese. But still he rarefied and mytholo- gized Japan by translating the No plays and the Chinese classics into beautiful English poetry. Certainly Pound tried to finish the translations as
? xvi INTRODUCTION
"Ernest Fenollosa would have wanted them done. " But in any event the more Pound learned about Japanese realities, the more he emphasized their beauty and positive value.
The same can be said of Canto 49. That is, Pound read the manuscript poems in Japanese and Chinese on the lakes and hills around the River Hisaio-Hsiang in China, and he used the images to create an unworldly lyrical world of "stillness" suggestive of the paradiso terrestre. And again we find that aspect when he began correspondence with Kitasono in 1936. Pound read the "crystal" poems by the members of the VOU Club, and introduced them as the "vortex of poetic alertness" in the Townsman (see Appendix). He urged the publisher James Laughlin to introduce them also in his yearly New Directions AnthoJogy. In his essay "Orientamenti" in Broletto (1938), Pound also introduced Japan favorably as being in a new "cycle," though he was aware of the Japanese invasion of Manchuria.
In 1939 Pound had begun to subscribe to the Japan Times & Mail, and was thus exposed to much more concerning the political, economic and social realities of contemporary Japan. But in 1940 he mythologized the whole history of Japan by writing that all the emperors "were of heaven descended" in Canto 58. (His source was most probably Heinrich Julius Klaproth's translation of Nippon Odai Ichiran. See Pound's letter to Kitaso- no. 3 March 1939. )
When we trace Pound's view of Japan, we come to realize that even though he continued to further his knowledge of Japan throughout his life, his earlier image of Japan as a far-off, dreamlike country persisted; a treas- ure land for the aesthete, a country entangled with pleasant memories of youth. We cannot neglect the basic fact that Pound grew up in the era of Japonisme, and the image of Japan registered in his mind in his early youth as a land of lotus and butterfly was not to be erased from his mind through- out his life. And we must also remember that FenoUosa's impact was so very strong on him that FenoUosa's admiration for Japanese values could only reinforce Pound's idealized image.
\i
--
? PS 3531 082 E95
Ezra Pound G Japan : letters G essays / edited by Sanehlde Kodama* 1st ed,
-- Redding Rld@:et CT BookSv cl987<<
:
Black Swan
xvl, 249 p. f [7] p. of plates ; 24cm*
:
ill.
Includes bibliographical references* j(r9054 6ift:Mander $ ? ?
ISBN O-933806-27-2
1. Pound, Ezra, 1885-1972 --
Correspondence* 2* Pound, Ezra, 1885
--Knowledge--Japan* 3* Poets,
1972
American--20th century--Correspondence*
4* Artists--Japan--Correspondence* 5* Japan--Civilization* I* Pound, Ezra, 1885-1972* II* Kodama, Sanehlde, 1932-
19 DEC 90 13795675 NEWCxc 86-14774
//905A
? ^v-P
DATE DUE
1-5-
? ? ;q;a Pound & Japan
? ? zra Pound
LETTERS ^ ESSAYS
edited by Sanehide Kodama
BLACK SWAN BOOKS
? Copyright (C) 1987 The Trustees of the Ezra Pound Literary Property Trust
Copyright (C) 1987 Sanehide Kodama
Copyright (C) 1987 Michael Reck
Copyright (C) 1987 Mary de Rachewiltz
Copyright (C) 1987 Black Swan Books Ltd. AcknowJedgements continue copyright statement. All rights reserved.
This publication has been greatly assisted by a generous ^rant from
Q 2
;<<5
First edition
THK SUNTORY FOUNDATION.
Published by
BLACK SWAN BOOKS Ltd P. O. Box 327
Redding Ridge, CT 06876 U. S. A.
ISBN 0-933806-27-2
? Contents
Frontispiece: painting by Tami Koume ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS / vi NOTEONTHETEXT/ viii
PREFACE / ix
by John Walsh
INTRODUCTION / xiv
by Sanehide Kodama
LETTERS
I Pound's Early Contacts with Japan: 1911-23 / 1
II Pound/KitasonoCorrespondence:1936-66/ 25
III Pound's Post-World War II Contacts with Japan: 1956-68 /
129
ESSAYS IVPound'sContributionstoJapanesePeriodicals:1939-40/ 148
APPENDIX
I Tami Koume, The Art o/^Etherism / 192
II VOUClub/ 200
EzraPound,VOUClub/ 201 KatueKitasono,NotesI 202
VOUPoems/ 204 JamesLaughlin,ModernPoetsofJapanI 207 KatueKitasono,TheVOL/Ciub/ 209
III Michael Reck, Memoirs of a Parody Perry / 211
POSTSCRIPT
Mary de Rachewiltz, In Flace of a Note to Letter 71 I 214
NOTES I 216 ADDENDUM/ 248 ILLUSTRATIONS / 250
? Vi
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
First I should like to thank Mary de Rachewiltz both for what she has done for me and for the publication of this book. The idea of collecting Ezra Pound's letters to his Japanese friends started with her. She introduced me to John Walsh in 1980 and together they provided me with much valuable material for the text and notes. They have read the expanded manuscript, and provided a preface and a postscript for the book. I am also grateful to Mrs. Sakae Hashimoto, widow of Katue Kitasono, and to Yasuo Fujitomi, poet, for their enthusiastic help in Japan.
I wish also to thank the following people for their assistance in many forms: Donald Gallup, Carroll F. Terrell, Jim Generoso, John Solt, Naoki Inagaki, and above all Megumi Nakamura for providing me with information that I needed for the notes; Kenji Aral for his arrangement with the Japan Times, Inc. for permission to reprint Ezra Pound's articles; Michiko Shimizu for typing the greater part of the text; Toru Haga for recommending me to the Suntory Foundation; Akiko Miyake, Motoyuki Yoshida, and the librarians and staff at the Beinecke Library at Yale University for their courteous help and encouragement; and the Trustees of the Suntory Foundation, Osaka, for their generous financial assistance for this publica- tion.
Grateful acknowledgement and thanks are given to the following for permis- sion to include the varied Ezra Pound material: The Ezra Pound Literary Property Trust and New Directions Publishing Corp. ; The Beinecke Rare Book and Manu- script Library, Yale University; Ikuko Atsumi, for a letter from Yone Noguchi's Collected English Letters (Tokyo: Zokei Bijutsu Kyokai, 1975); Koichi Iwasaki, for letters to his father, Ryozo Iwasaki; Yukio Sato, for a letter to the Japanese Ambassa- dor in Rome; Tokutaro Shigehisa, for a letter to Tomoji Okada; Townsman, for the essay "VOU Club"; and Shiro Tsunoda, for his help and for the fragment of the letter addressed to himself. The citations for previously published material by Ezra Pound are as follows: The Cantos (copyright 1934, 1937, 1940, 1948, 1956, 1959, 1962, 1963, 1966, 1968 by Ezra Pound; copyright (C) 1972 by the Estate of Ezra Pound); Selected Letters, 1907-1941, ed. D. D. Paige (copyright 1950 by Ezra Pound; copyright (C) 1971 by New Directions Publishing Corp. ); Ezra Pound Speak- ing, ed. Leonard Doob (copyright (C) 1978 by the Ezra Pound Literary Property Trust). Permission to reprint the articles which first appeared in the papers pub- lished by the Japan Times, Inc. has been granted by Gyo Hani, Chief Editor, The Japan Times, Inc.
Likewise grateful acknowledgement and thanks are extended to the following for permission to include the varied material by Pound's Japanese correspondents. The Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library, Yale University; Lilly Library, Indiana University; Harry Ransom Humanities Research Center, the University of Texas at Austin; Kunio Ito (Koreyo Senda) for letters by his brother, Michio Ito; Koichi Iwasaki, for letters from his father, Ryozo Iwasaki; Masayoshi Kume, for material of his father, Tamijuro Kume; Yoshinobu Mori, for a letter by his father,
? ACKNOWLEDGEMENT VI
Yasotaro Mori; Masao Noguchi, for letters of Yonijiro Noguchi; and Eiichiro Oshi- ma, for a letter by his father, Shotaro Oshima; Townsman for Katue Kitasono's "Notes" and New Directions for the VOU poems and "Modern Poets of Japan. "
Further acknowledgement and thanks are offered to the following for various permissions: Mary de Rachewiltz, James Laughlin and Fosco Maraini, for their own material; Omar Pound, for letters by Dorothy Pound (copyright (C) 1987 by Omar S. Pound); and Michael Reck, for his own material, and that by Ezra Pound and Katue Kitasono included in his Ezra Pound: A Close-Up (NY: McGraw-Hill, 1967). Ac- knowledgement is also made to Basil Bunting, Collected Poems (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1979, copyright (C) 1978 by Basil Bunting), and to Van Wyck Brooks, FenoJIosa and His Circle (NY: E. P. Dutton, 1962).
Finally,myspecialthanksareduetoJohnWalsh. I shouldliketoexpressmy heartfelt appreciation for the encouragement and assistance I received from him in many forms and over a period of many years. --S. K.
? yiii
NOTE ON TEXT
NOTE ON THE TEXT
In rendering the Pound material in typeset format, certain translations have been utilized: underlined words have been placed in italics; double underlined words are indicated by boldface; and triple underlining appears as italic capitals. Words originally in block letters appear in small capitals. Handwritten inserts have been placed in the text where indicated by Pound and appear in italics within angle brackets. Phrases and words in foreign languages, as well as titles, have been italicized. With few exceptions. Pound's original spelling, punctuation and spacing have been retained, and a line-for-line approximation has been attempted. In only a few cases have the letters from Japanese correspondents been corrected to aid clarification; no attempt has been made to regularize Japanese names and terms, as this forms one of the themes of the correspondence. The following manuscript abbreviations (followed by the number of pages of the original) have been used: tl
= typed letter; TLS = typed letter signed; PC = postcard; AL = handwritten letter; and ALS = handwritten letter signed.
In the Notes, citations to the editions of Pound's works as listed in Donald Gallup's Ezra Pound: A Bibliography, 2nd ed. (Charlottesville: University of Vir- ginia Press, 1983) have been placed within brackets.
Two additional references are to be included: Ezra Pound, Plays Modelled on the Noh (1916), ed. Donald Gallup (Toledo: Friends of the University of Toledo Libraries, 1987); and Octavio Paz, Jacques Roubaud, Eduardo Sanguinetti and Charles Tomlinson, Rengo: A Chain of Poems (NY: Braziller, 1971)--with special reference to letter 73: The modern chain poem is a descendant of the Japanese "kusari-renga" ["linked poems"] developed between the Heian (794-1183) and Muromachi (1336-1573) periods.
? PREFACE
On the walls of the Boston Museum of Fine Arts hangs a painting by the American painter William Paxton entitled The New Necklace. In the paint- ing is depicted a young American woman, wrapped in an oriental jacket placed over her long frilled dress; she is seated by an oriental screen, set in front of the Western painting and tapestry on the wall; an encased oriental statuette is on top of the woman's lacquered writing desk-chest. The date of the painting is 1910.
The intermixing of styles in this painting reflects the extent of the current vogue of /aponisme, in a setting most likely proximate to one of the ports of the Yankee clipper trade which flourished between Yokohama and Salem. "Things Japanese" had most definitely entered American fashion by this time, a good fifty years after the American painters La Farge and Whistler had begun their collections of Japanese Ukiyoe [woodblockl prints. Such artistic transport, facilitated by the speed of the Yankee clipper ships, prompted Van Wyck Brooks to remark that "the Far East seemed closer to Salem than to any other American town when Ernest FenoUosa* was born there in 1853" (FenoJJosa and His Circle).
The Museum of Fine Arts in Boston, and the nearby Peabody Museum in Salem, were the recipients of much of the art and artifacts of traditional Japanese culture that were shored up against time, thanks to a determined effort on the part of a group of Boston-based Americans who had travelled to Japan--fortuitously arriving at precisely the critical moment for their enterprise. Ernest FenoUosa and Edward Morse, followed by William Stur- gis Bigelow and Percival Lowell, and later by Henry Adams, John La Farge, and then Lafcadio Hearn--all arrived in Japan within nearly a decade (1878-90], at a time when the traditional culture of Japan was on the brink of being swept away. "P'or twenty years," remarks Van Wyck Brooks, "the most precious works were treated as rubbish. " Masterpieces were paradox- ically more commonly to be found in trash-heaps than in showrooms. With a broad gesture, the Japanese had turned their backs on their past in favor of Western modernity. A year after FenoUosa had arrived in Japan, he had been able to acquire a masterpiece by the painter Ganku from a dealer who had never even heard of the master's name, and he was still able to find in 1884 a fine ceramic head of the Buddha--one of the earliest relics of Tendai sculpture--in an ash barrel where it had been discarded. Along with FenoUosa and Morse, these Americans eagerly took to the task of attempt-
IX
--
? X PREFACE
ing to preserve what they feared to be the last surviving traces of a vanishing civilization. Fenollosa took sculpture and painting as his specialty, while Morse chose pottery. Morse also took lessons in the traditional tea cere- mony, and studied Japanese singing with the No master, Minoru Umewaka, under whom Fenollosa studied as well.
At a time when the Japanese feudal system was in its death-throes and
noble families found it necessary to sell their great collections to stave off
poverty, excellent examples of traditional art--swords, guards, emblems,
lacquer boxes, along with statues, paintings, scrolls and pottery
abounded in a radically devalued market. And Fenollosa and Morse bought
discerningly and extensively, shipping off vast collections to the Museum
of Fine Arts in Boston.
Along with Okakura Kakuzo (who organized the Imperial Art School in
Tokyo), Fenollosa acted as Imperial Commissioner of Fine Art and scoured the countryside in search of cast-off treasures. Ironically, however, most of this treasure was being shipped to America. Morse, well aware of the contradiction, remarked: "It is like the life-blood of Japan seeping from a hidden wound. " But this wound was soon to be staunched; in 1884, further transport of national Japanese treasures (now recognized to be so) began to be discussed by the Japanese government. By 1885, a rebirth of interest in the traditional culture of Japan had begun.
Certainly, the crucial role played by this small group of American Japanophiles had not been forgotten by the Japanese; in the words of Prof. Yaichi Haga, "An American, Ernest Fenollosa, taught us how to admire the unique beauty of our art. " And upon preparing to return to America in
1886, Fenollosa was told by the Emperor: "You have taught my people to know their own art; in going back to your great country, I charge you, teach them also. "
When Ezra Pound in London received his first letter from a Japanese correspondent in 1911 (a year before the publication of FenoUosa's Epochs of Chinese and Japanese Art], he probably was not as yet familiar with the work of Fenollosa. Perhaps he had not yet at that time thought much directly about Japan, even though he was certainly familiar with the art of Whistler. Were he in London at the time, he most probably would have seen the Japanese Exhibition held at Shepherd's Bush in 1910. Perhaps he had even discussed Fenollosa when he met, in October 1913, the American photographer Alvin Langdon Coburn, who had intensively studied the collection of Chinese and Japanese art set up by Fenollosa in the Boston
? PREFACE xi
Museum of Fine Arts. But when towards the end of 1913 he received from Mary Fenollosa the notebooks containing Fenollosa's notes on oriental literature, draft translations of Chinese poetry and Japanese No dramas, along with his essay "The Chinese Written Character as a Medium for Poetry"--with the stipulation that Fenollosa wanted the material treated as literature, not philology--a world opened. In March 1909, Pound had heard Laurence Binyon lecture on "Oriental and European Art," and in the spring of 1911, he had written his haiku-like poem on the Paris Metro (see Sanehide Kodama, American Poetry and Japanese Culture). He had also written in 1913, prior to the receipt of the bulk of Fenollosa material, the Chinese-inspired poems "After Ch'u Yuan," "Fan-Piece for Her Imperial Lord," and "Liu Ch'e. " Most significantly. Pound's "A Few Don'ts by an Imagiste" had already appeared. But what accompanied China in the Fenollosa notebooks was the near-virgin world of Japan--territory which he set about exploring almost immediately. Pound and W. B. Yeats spent much of the winter of 1913 in Stone Cottage immersed in the study and translation of No drama. By January of 1914 Pound was able to send off to Harriet Monroe of Poetry the finished version of Nishikigi. And so began
his lifetime enthrallment.
Ironically, Pound's discovery of Japanese drama coincided with an-
other phase of modern Japan's turning away from its traditional culture. When the Japanese dancer Michio Ito arrived in London in 1914, he knew next to nothing about classical Japanese drama--but, most fortunately, a fellow expatriate, the painter Tami Koume, did. So it was in London, not Tokyo, that Ito learned about his own cultural tradition. (Perhaps the apocryphal story of Ito's visit with Yeats to the London zoo to watch the movements of a caged hawk justifiedly merits being preserved. ) From these seeds, the study of No drama became an enduring passion for Pound.
The importance of the No drama for Pound echoes throughout this correspondence. Seated in the cinema in Rapallo watching the film Mit- souko, Pound is filled with nostalgia, struck by the sound of the singing, and remembering a No performance enacted in Paris by Tami Koume and other Japanese: "You have a treasure like nothing we have in the Occident. " In a later letter of 1957, Pound most succinctly and poignantly remarks: "Hagoronno is a sacrament. " And Pound seriously and fondly hoped that his own play. Women of Trachis (1954), would be translated into Japanese and be staged by a No troupe: "Am convinced the Noh technique is only way of doing it properly, in whatever language. "
It was to preserve this induplicable treasure of the No that Pound went to the extreme of suggesting that the American-occupied island of Guam be
--
? Xii
PREFACE
negotiated with the Japanese in exchange for a set of films of classic No plays--along with their authentic music, "insist," wrote Pound to the Japanese poet Katue Kitasono, "on having 300 Noh plays done properly and recorded on sound film so as to be able to educate such American students as are capable of being cultured. "
Ironic indeed that this was being said by an American at a time when many modern Japanese were in another phase of turning away from their cultural heritage--the avant-garde poet, Katue Kitasono. most certainly included. When in 1952 Michael Reck--who made a pilgrimage to Fenollo- sa's grave above Lake Biwa [cf. Canto LXXXIX)--upon Pound's urging met Kitasono, he discovered that the Japanese poet evidenced no enthusiasm at all at the prospect of attending a No performance--to such an extent that he sent his wife in his place to accompany the young American. And after a short time, she politely excused herself and left the performance, leaving the American to discover the classical world of Japan on his own. There is a certain humor in the fact that Pound in his letters to Kitasono is continually asking questions about Japan's traditional culture--ironic in that Kitasono was not at all as interested in it as was Pound himself. For Kitasono embodied contemporary Japan.
What Kitasono, in turn, presented to Pound was not the past but the new. He introduced Pound to what the young avant-garde was doing as reflected in poems written by members of the VOU Club and published in its magazine. Pound seized upon the potential offered by this poetry washed clean as if by acid--written in halting English translations by these young Japanese, for he saw that they approached the language with fresh eyes, without preconceptions, and used English freely, idiosyncratically and inventively. "All the moss and fuzz that for twenty years we have been trying to scrape off our language--these young men start without it. " He praised this "vortex of poetic alertness" for its immense clarity and rapid-
ity: "The Japanese eye is like those new camera shutters that catch the bullet leaving the gun. . . . They see the crystal set, the chemical laboratory and the pine tree with untrammeled clearness. . . . The Japanese poet has gone from one peak of [thought] to another faster than our slow wits permit us to follow before we have got used to his pace. "
Rather than condescendingly dismissing these poems for their techni- cal flaws, Pound positively saw in them a new beginning and enthusiasti- cally recommended them to Ronald Duncan of Townsman and lames Laughlin of New Directions for publication. While one need not necessarily agree with Pound's generous evaluation of them as "better work than any save those of E. E. Cummings," by seeing them in the manner that Pound
? PREFACE xiii
saw them and for the qualities that he cited, lessons could be learned. Here Japan was making its contemporary contribution to the West.
This collection of letters and essays documents Pound's lifelong in- volvement with the art, literature and culture of japan. Extending from 1911 to 1968, Pound's correspondence with Japanese artists and poets forms a record of a vital cultural interchange from which both East and West gained through the interaction. Included in this volume are letters from the Japanese painter Tami Koume and the dancer Michio Ito dating from Pound's early years in London--when he was at work with W. B. Yeats on translating Japanese No dramas--and his years in Paris during the early 1920's; the correspondence between Pound and the Japanese mod- ernist poet Katue Kitasono (editor of VOU) while Pound was residing in Rapallo (and later from St. Elizabeths); and articles written by Pound which appeared in the Japan Times just prior to the outbreak of World War II, promoting cross-cultural communication and insisting that "diplomacy alone could not do it. " Letters from Mary Fenollosa and various other
Japanese correspondents, along with the pertinent material included in the appendix, further round out the portrait.
Similar to the influence exerted by a previous generation of Americans who had travelled to Japan (Fenollosa, Bigelow, Morse, La Farge and Hearn), EzraPoundfromafaralsomadehiscontributiontothepreservation of the classic Japanese tradition, drawing attention to its masterworks as an essential component of world culture and a crucial means to increase East-West understanding.
--John WaJsh
'For further on Fenollosa, see note to letter 4 on Mary Fenollosa; see also Van Wyck Brooks, Fenollosa and His Circle (NY: E. P. Dutton, 1962).
? XIV
INTRODUCTION
In this book are collected letters exchanged between Ezra Pound and his Japanese friends, ranging between the years 1911 to 1968. These letters are, in most cases, chronologically arranged so that the reader may have an historical overview of Pound's involvement with the art and culture of Japan. The book also includes Pound's contributions to Japanese per- iodicals written shortly before World War II, at a time when he had little outlet elsewhere. Supplementary letters, such as those between Ezra Pound and Mary Fenollosa, Katue Kitasono to Dorothy Pound and Mary de Rache-
wiltz, etc. , which touch on material regarding Japan have also been in- cluded.
In the summer of 1911 Ezra Pound received a completely unexpected letter postmarked from Japan. "Dear Mr. Pound," the letter opened, "As I believe you may not know my work at all, I send you, under a separate cover, my new book of poems called The Pilgrimage. . . . " It was from Yonejiro Noguchi, a Japanese poet who was ten years older than Pound and had been favorably received in England and America. He had published a few books of verse and prose in English in both countries: Seen and Unseen (1897), The American Diary o/a Japanese GirJ (1902] and From the Eastern Sea (1902), and had returned to Japan after spending thirteen years abroad.
In his polite response to Noguchi Pound wrote, "of your country I know almost nothing. " But he also wrote, "1 had, of course, known of you. " One may wonder how much knowledge Pound actually had of Japan when he said, "I know almost nothing. " It can be assumed that by 1911 Pound already had some knowledge of Japanese haiku, as he had regularly been attending T. E. Hulme's meetings at the Cafe Tour d'Eiffel since 1909, where haiku had by then become common knowledge. Basil Hall Chamber- lain's CJassicaJ Poetry of the Japanese (London, 1880) had long been out. One of the members of the group, Joseph Campbell, had written three-line poems such as "The Dawn Whiteness," and Edward Storer had written "Image. " F. S. Flint had translated some haiku into English from Paul-Louis Couchoud's French translations, including a piece by Arakida Takeari, which Pound was later to quote. Actually Pound might already have read Couchoud's and Chamberlain's translations himself.
But haiku was not the only aspect of Japan that Pound was acquainted with by that time. He surely would have known something of Japan's political and social aspects as well: news of the unexpected victory of Japan
? INTRODUCTION XV
over Imperial Russia in 1905 and reports concerning the Baltic Fleet, the battles at Liishun, and the following negotiations at Portsmouth, New
Hampshire, most certainly.
Moreover, Pound's juvenescence had coincided with the period of
/aponisme. Certainly, Japan had been "opened" to the American market for some time. Even Sears, Roebuck and Co. had listed Japanese fans with illustrations in their catalogue of 1902. Lacquer ware, paper napkins, kimo- no, netsuke, wood-block prints, and other objets d'art had been imported through Yamanaka & Co. for domestic usage. French and American pain- ters had been influenced for some time by Japanese art, and in his early essays Pound had already made frequent mention of the connection be- tween Whistler and Hokusai.
But Pound in 1911 was still looking at Japan through the back end of a pair of opera glasses. Pound viewed Japan as a far-away, beautiful country, inhabited by people with a delicate and subtle sensibility, by women pretty, gentle, obedient, and loveable, and by men courageous enough to defeat Imperial Russia. When he received a businesslike letter from Yone Noguchi, therefore.
The idea of collecting Ezra Pound's letters to his Japanese friends started with her. She introduced me to John Walsh in 1980 and together they provided me with much valuable material for the text and notes. They have read the expanded manuscript, and provided a preface and a postscript for the book. I am also grateful to Mrs. Sakae Hashimoto, widow of Katue Kitasono, and to Yasuo Fujitomi, poet, for their enthusiastic help in Japan.
I wish also to thank the following people for their assistance in many forms: Donald Gallup, Carroll F. Terrell, Jim Generoso, John Solt, Naoki Inagaki, and above all Megumi Nakamura for providing me with information that I needed for the notes; Kenji Aral for his arrangement with the Japan Times, Inc. for permission to reprint Ezra Pound's articles; Michiko Shimizu for typing the greater part of the text; Toru Haga for recommending me to the Suntory Foundation; Akiko Miyake, Motoyuki Yoshida, and the librarians and staff at the Beinecke Library at Yale University for their courteous help and encouragement; and the Trustees of the Suntory Foundation, Osaka, for their generous financial assistance for this publica- tion.
Grateful acknowledgement and thanks are given to the following for permis- sion to include the varied Ezra Pound material: The Ezra Pound Literary Property Trust and New Directions Publishing Corp. ; The Beinecke Rare Book and Manu- script Library, Yale University; Ikuko Atsumi, for a letter from Yone Noguchi's Collected English Letters (Tokyo: Zokei Bijutsu Kyokai, 1975); Koichi Iwasaki, for letters to his father, Ryozo Iwasaki; Yukio Sato, for a letter to the Japanese Ambassa- dor in Rome; Tokutaro Shigehisa, for a letter to Tomoji Okada; Townsman, for the essay "VOU Club"; and Shiro Tsunoda, for his help and for the fragment of the letter addressed to himself. The citations for previously published material by Ezra Pound are as follows: The Cantos (copyright 1934, 1937, 1940, 1948, 1956, 1959, 1962, 1963, 1966, 1968 by Ezra Pound; copyright (C) 1972 by the Estate of Ezra Pound); Selected Letters, 1907-1941, ed. D. D. Paige (copyright 1950 by Ezra Pound; copyright (C) 1971 by New Directions Publishing Corp. ); Ezra Pound Speak- ing, ed. Leonard Doob (copyright (C) 1978 by the Ezra Pound Literary Property Trust). Permission to reprint the articles which first appeared in the papers pub- lished by the Japan Times, Inc. has been granted by Gyo Hani, Chief Editor, The Japan Times, Inc.
Likewise grateful acknowledgement and thanks are extended to the following for permission to include the varied material by Pound's Japanese correspondents. The Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library, Yale University; Lilly Library, Indiana University; Harry Ransom Humanities Research Center, the University of Texas at Austin; Kunio Ito (Koreyo Senda) for letters by his brother, Michio Ito; Koichi Iwasaki, for letters from his father, Ryozo Iwasaki; Masayoshi Kume, for material of his father, Tamijuro Kume; Yoshinobu Mori, for a letter by his father,
? ACKNOWLEDGEMENT VI
Yasotaro Mori; Masao Noguchi, for letters of Yonijiro Noguchi; and Eiichiro Oshi- ma, for a letter by his father, Shotaro Oshima; Townsman for Katue Kitasono's "Notes" and New Directions for the VOU poems and "Modern Poets of Japan. "
Further acknowledgement and thanks are offered to the following for various permissions: Mary de Rachewiltz, James Laughlin and Fosco Maraini, for their own material; Omar Pound, for letters by Dorothy Pound (copyright (C) 1987 by Omar S. Pound); and Michael Reck, for his own material, and that by Ezra Pound and Katue Kitasono included in his Ezra Pound: A Close-Up (NY: McGraw-Hill, 1967). Ac- knowledgement is also made to Basil Bunting, Collected Poems (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1979, copyright (C) 1978 by Basil Bunting), and to Van Wyck Brooks, FenoJIosa and His Circle (NY: E. P. Dutton, 1962).
Finally,myspecialthanksareduetoJohnWalsh. I shouldliketoexpressmy heartfelt appreciation for the encouragement and assistance I received from him in many forms and over a period of many years. --S. K.
? yiii
NOTE ON TEXT
NOTE ON THE TEXT
In rendering the Pound material in typeset format, certain translations have been utilized: underlined words have been placed in italics; double underlined words are indicated by boldface; and triple underlining appears as italic capitals. Words originally in block letters appear in small capitals. Handwritten inserts have been placed in the text where indicated by Pound and appear in italics within angle brackets. Phrases and words in foreign languages, as well as titles, have been italicized. With few exceptions. Pound's original spelling, punctuation and spacing have been retained, and a line-for-line approximation has been attempted. In only a few cases have the letters from Japanese correspondents been corrected to aid clarification; no attempt has been made to regularize Japanese names and terms, as this forms one of the themes of the correspondence. The following manuscript abbreviations (followed by the number of pages of the original) have been used: tl
= typed letter; TLS = typed letter signed; PC = postcard; AL = handwritten letter; and ALS = handwritten letter signed.
In the Notes, citations to the editions of Pound's works as listed in Donald Gallup's Ezra Pound: A Bibliography, 2nd ed. (Charlottesville: University of Vir- ginia Press, 1983) have been placed within brackets.
Two additional references are to be included: Ezra Pound, Plays Modelled on the Noh (1916), ed. Donald Gallup (Toledo: Friends of the University of Toledo Libraries, 1987); and Octavio Paz, Jacques Roubaud, Eduardo Sanguinetti and Charles Tomlinson, Rengo: A Chain of Poems (NY: Braziller, 1971)--with special reference to letter 73: The modern chain poem is a descendant of the Japanese "kusari-renga" ["linked poems"] developed between the Heian (794-1183) and Muromachi (1336-1573) periods.
? PREFACE
On the walls of the Boston Museum of Fine Arts hangs a painting by the American painter William Paxton entitled The New Necklace. In the paint- ing is depicted a young American woman, wrapped in an oriental jacket placed over her long frilled dress; she is seated by an oriental screen, set in front of the Western painting and tapestry on the wall; an encased oriental statuette is on top of the woman's lacquered writing desk-chest. The date of the painting is 1910.
The intermixing of styles in this painting reflects the extent of the current vogue of /aponisme, in a setting most likely proximate to one of the ports of the Yankee clipper trade which flourished between Yokohama and Salem. "Things Japanese" had most definitely entered American fashion by this time, a good fifty years after the American painters La Farge and Whistler had begun their collections of Japanese Ukiyoe [woodblockl prints. Such artistic transport, facilitated by the speed of the Yankee clipper ships, prompted Van Wyck Brooks to remark that "the Far East seemed closer to Salem than to any other American town when Ernest FenoUosa* was born there in 1853" (FenoJJosa and His Circle).
The Museum of Fine Arts in Boston, and the nearby Peabody Museum in Salem, were the recipients of much of the art and artifacts of traditional Japanese culture that were shored up against time, thanks to a determined effort on the part of a group of Boston-based Americans who had travelled to Japan--fortuitously arriving at precisely the critical moment for their enterprise. Ernest FenoUosa and Edward Morse, followed by William Stur- gis Bigelow and Percival Lowell, and later by Henry Adams, John La Farge, and then Lafcadio Hearn--all arrived in Japan within nearly a decade (1878-90], at a time when the traditional culture of Japan was on the brink of being swept away. "P'or twenty years," remarks Van Wyck Brooks, "the most precious works were treated as rubbish. " Masterpieces were paradox- ically more commonly to be found in trash-heaps than in showrooms. With a broad gesture, the Japanese had turned their backs on their past in favor of Western modernity. A year after FenoUosa had arrived in Japan, he had been able to acquire a masterpiece by the painter Ganku from a dealer who had never even heard of the master's name, and he was still able to find in 1884 a fine ceramic head of the Buddha--one of the earliest relics of Tendai sculpture--in an ash barrel where it had been discarded. Along with FenoUosa and Morse, these Americans eagerly took to the task of attempt-
IX
--
? X PREFACE
ing to preserve what they feared to be the last surviving traces of a vanishing civilization. Fenollosa took sculpture and painting as his specialty, while Morse chose pottery. Morse also took lessons in the traditional tea cere- mony, and studied Japanese singing with the No master, Minoru Umewaka, under whom Fenollosa studied as well.
At a time when the Japanese feudal system was in its death-throes and
noble families found it necessary to sell their great collections to stave off
poverty, excellent examples of traditional art--swords, guards, emblems,
lacquer boxes, along with statues, paintings, scrolls and pottery
abounded in a radically devalued market. And Fenollosa and Morse bought
discerningly and extensively, shipping off vast collections to the Museum
of Fine Arts in Boston.
Along with Okakura Kakuzo (who organized the Imperial Art School in
Tokyo), Fenollosa acted as Imperial Commissioner of Fine Art and scoured the countryside in search of cast-off treasures. Ironically, however, most of this treasure was being shipped to America. Morse, well aware of the contradiction, remarked: "It is like the life-blood of Japan seeping from a hidden wound. " But this wound was soon to be staunched; in 1884, further transport of national Japanese treasures (now recognized to be so) began to be discussed by the Japanese government. By 1885, a rebirth of interest in the traditional culture of Japan had begun.
Certainly, the crucial role played by this small group of American Japanophiles had not been forgotten by the Japanese; in the words of Prof. Yaichi Haga, "An American, Ernest Fenollosa, taught us how to admire the unique beauty of our art. " And upon preparing to return to America in
1886, Fenollosa was told by the Emperor: "You have taught my people to know their own art; in going back to your great country, I charge you, teach them also. "
When Ezra Pound in London received his first letter from a Japanese correspondent in 1911 (a year before the publication of FenoUosa's Epochs of Chinese and Japanese Art], he probably was not as yet familiar with the work of Fenollosa. Perhaps he had not yet at that time thought much directly about Japan, even though he was certainly familiar with the art of Whistler. Were he in London at the time, he most probably would have seen the Japanese Exhibition held at Shepherd's Bush in 1910. Perhaps he had even discussed Fenollosa when he met, in October 1913, the American photographer Alvin Langdon Coburn, who had intensively studied the collection of Chinese and Japanese art set up by Fenollosa in the Boston
? PREFACE xi
Museum of Fine Arts. But when towards the end of 1913 he received from Mary Fenollosa the notebooks containing Fenollosa's notes on oriental literature, draft translations of Chinese poetry and Japanese No dramas, along with his essay "The Chinese Written Character as a Medium for Poetry"--with the stipulation that Fenollosa wanted the material treated as literature, not philology--a world opened. In March 1909, Pound had heard Laurence Binyon lecture on "Oriental and European Art," and in the spring of 1911, he had written his haiku-like poem on the Paris Metro (see Sanehide Kodama, American Poetry and Japanese Culture). He had also written in 1913, prior to the receipt of the bulk of Fenollosa material, the Chinese-inspired poems "After Ch'u Yuan," "Fan-Piece for Her Imperial Lord," and "Liu Ch'e. " Most significantly. Pound's "A Few Don'ts by an Imagiste" had already appeared. But what accompanied China in the Fenollosa notebooks was the near-virgin world of Japan--territory which he set about exploring almost immediately. Pound and W. B. Yeats spent much of the winter of 1913 in Stone Cottage immersed in the study and translation of No drama. By January of 1914 Pound was able to send off to Harriet Monroe of Poetry the finished version of Nishikigi. And so began
his lifetime enthrallment.
Ironically, Pound's discovery of Japanese drama coincided with an-
other phase of modern Japan's turning away from its traditional culture. When the Japanese dancer Michio Ito arrived in London in 1914, he knew next to nothing about classical Japanese drama--but, most fortunately, a fellow expatriate, the painter Tami Koume, did. So it was in London, not Tokyo, that Ito learned about his own cultural tradition. (Perhaps the apocryphal story of Ito's visit with Yeats to the London zoo to watch the movements of a caged hawk justifiedly merits being preserved. ) From these seeds, the study of No drama became an enduring passion for Pound.
The importance of the No drama for Pound echoes throughout this correspondence. Seated in the cinema in Rapallo watching the film Mit- souko, Pound is filled with nostalgia, struck by the sound of the singing, and remembering a No performance enacted in Paris by Tami Koume and other Japanese: "You have a treasure like nothing we have in the Occident. " In a later letter of 1957, Pound most succinctly and poignantly remarks: "Hagoronno is a sacrament. " And Pound seriously and fondly hoped that his own play. Women of Trachis (1954), would be translated into Japanese and be staged by a No troupe: "Am convinced the Noh technique is only way of doing it properly, in whatever language. "
It was to preserve this induplicable treasure of the No that Pound went to the extreme of suggesting that the American-occupied island of Guam be
--
? Xii
PREFACE
negotiated with the Japanese in exchange for a set of films of classic No plays--along with their authentic music, "insist," wrote Pound to the Japanese poet Katue Kitasono, "on having 300 Noh plays done properly and recorded on sound film so as to be able to educate such American students as are capable of being cultured. "
Ironic indeed that this was being said by an American at a time when many modern Japanese were in another phase of turning away from their cultural heritage--the avant-garde poet, Katue Kitasono. most certainly included. When in 1952 Michael Reck--who made a pilgrimage to Fenollo- sa's grave above Lake Biwa [cf. Canto LXXXIX)--upon Pound's urging met Kitasono, he discovered that the Japanese poet evidenced no enthusiasm at all at the prospect of attending a No performance--to such an extent that he sent his wife in his place to accompany the young American. And after a short time, she politely excused herself and left the performance, leaving the American to discover the classical world of Japan on his own. There is a certain humor in the fact that Pound in his letters to Kitasono is continually asking questions about Japan's traditional culture--ironic in that Kitasono was not at all as interested in it as was Pound himself. For Kitasono embodied contemporary Japan.
What Kitasono, in turn, presented to Pound was not the past but the new. He introduced Pound to what the young avant-garde was doing as reflected in poems written by members of the VOU Club and published in its magazine. Pound seized upon the potential offered by this poetry washed clean as if by acid--written in halting English translations by these young Japanese, for he saw that they approached the language with fresh eyes, without preconceptions, and used English freely, idiosyncratically and inventively. "All the moss and fuzz that for twenty years we have been trying to scrape off our language--these young men start without it. " He praised this "vortex of poetic alertness" for its immense clarity and rapid-
ity: "The Japanese eye is like those new camera shutters that catch the bullet leaving the gun. . . . They see the crystal set, the chemical laboratory and the pine tree with untrammeled clearness. . . . The Japanese poet has gone from one peak of [thought] to another faster than our slow wits permit us to follow before we have got used to his pace. "
Rather than condescendingly dismissing these poems for their techni- cal flaws, Pound positively saw in them a new beginning and enthusiasti- cally recommended them to Ronald Duncan of Townsman and lames Laughlin of New Directions for publication. While one need not necessarily agree with Pound's generous evaluation of them as "better work than any save those of E. E. Cummings," by seeing them in the manner that Pound
? PREFACE xiii
saw them and for the qualities that he cited, lessons could be learned. Here Japan was making its contemporary contribution to the West.
This collection of letters and essays documents Pound's lifelong in- volvement with the art, literature and culture of japan. Extending from 1911 to 1968, Pound's correspondence with Japanese artists and poets forms a record of a vital cultural interchange from which both East and West gained through the interaction. Included in this volume are letters from the Japanese painter Tami Koume and the dancer Michio Ito dating from Pound's early years in London--when he was at work with W. B. Yeats on translating Japanese No dramas--and his years in Paris during the early 1920's; the correspondence between Pound and the Japanese mod- ernist poet Katue Kitasono (editor of VOU) while Pound was residing in Rapallo (and later from St. Elizabeths); and articles written by Pound which appeared in the Japan Times just prior to the outbreak of World War II, promoting cross-cultural communication and insisting that "diplomacy alone could not do it. " Letters from Mary Fenollosa and various other
Japanese correspondents, along with the pertinent material included in the appendix, further round out the portrait.
Similar to the influence exerted by a previous generation of Americans who had travelled to Japan (Fenollosa, Bigelow, Morse, La Farge and Hearn), EzraPoundfromafaralsomadehiscontributiontothepreservation of the classic Japanese tradition, drawing attention to its masterworks as an essential component of world culture and a crucial means to increase East-West understanding.
--John WaJsh
'For further on Fenollosa, see note to letter 4 on Mary Fenollosa; see also Van Wyck Brooks, Fenollosa and His Circle (NY: E. P. Dutton, 1962).
? XIV
INTRODUCTION
In this book are collected letters exchanged between Ezra Pound and his Japanese friends, ranging between the years 1911 to 1968. These letters are, in most cases, chronologically arranged so that the reader may have an historical overview of Pound's involvement with the art and culture of Japan. The book also includes Pound's contributions to Japanese per- iodicals written shortly before World War II, at a time when he had little outlet elsewhere. Supplementary letters, such as those between Ezra Pound and Mary Fenollosa, Katue Kitasono to Dorothy Pound and Mary de Rache-
wiltz, etc. , which touch on material regarding Japan have also been in- cluded.
In the summer of 1911 Ezra Pound received a completely unexpected letter postmarked from Japan. "Dear Mr. Pound," the letter opened, "As I believe you may not know my work at all, I send you, under a separate cover, my new book of poems called The Pilgrimage. . . . " It was from Yonejiro Noguchi, a Japanese poet who was ten years older than Pound and had been favorably received in England and America. He had published a few books of verse and prose in English in both countries: Seen and Unseen (1897), The American Diary o/a Japanese GirJ (1902] and From the Eastern Sea (1902), and had returned to Japan after spending thirteen years abroad.
In his polite response to Noguchi Pound wrote, "of your country I know almost nothing. " But he also wrote, "1 had, of course, known of you. " One may wonder how much knowledge Pound actually had of Japan when he said, "I know almost nothing. " It can be assumed that by 1911 Pound already had some knowledge of Japanese haiku, as he had regularly been attending T. E. Hulme's meetings at the Cafe Tour d'Eiffel since 1909, where haiku had by then become common knowledge. Basil Hall Chamber- lain's CJassicaJ Poetry of the Japanese (London, 1880) had long been out. One of the members of the group, Joseph Campbell, had written three-line poems such as "The Dawn Whiteness," and Edward Storer had written "Image. " F. S. Flint had translated some haiku into English from Paul-Louis Couchoud's French translations, including a piece by Arakida Takeari, which Pound was later to quote. Actually Pound might already have read Couchoud's and Chamberlain's translations himself.
But haiku was not the only aspect of Japan that Pound was acquainted with by that time. He surely would have known something of Japan's political and social aspects as well: news of the unexpected victory of Japan
? INTRODUCTION XV
over Imperial Russia in 1905 and reports concerning the Baltic Fleet, the battles at Liishun, and the following negotiations at Portsmouth, New
Hampshire, most certainly.
Moreover, Pound's juvenescence had coincided with the period of
/aponisme. Certainly, Japan had been "opened" to the American market for some time. Even Sears, Roebuck and Co. had listed Japanese fans with illustrations in their catalogue of 1902. Lacquer ware, paper napkins, kimo- no, netsuke, wood-block prints, and other objets d'art had been imported through Yamanaka & Co. for domestic usage. French and American pain- ters had been influenced for some time by Japanese art, and in his early essays Pound had already made frequent mention of the connection be- tween Whistler and Hokusai.
But Pound in 1911 was still looking at Japan through the back end of a pair of opera glasses. Pound viewed Japan as a far-away, beautiful country, inhabited by people with a delicate and subtle sensibility, by women pretty, gentle, obedient, and loveable, and by men courageous enough to defeat Imperial Russia. When he received a businesslike letter from Yone Noguchi, therefore. Pound must have been surprised, but he does not seem to have changed his basic view of Japan. The image of a dream-like Japan had been so strongly imprinted on his young mind that it could not easily
be changed or removed.
When he wrote "The Encounter," Pound compared the graceful fingers
of a London woman to the "tissue" of a soft and lissome "Japanese paper napkin. " And when he wrote the "Metro" poem suggested by haiku, Pound presented the image of the glimmering petals scattered upon "the wet, black bough" as if painted on soft Japanese paper, to be "superimposed" upon the image of the beautiful faces of women and children in Paris.
By the time Pound met Mary Fenollosa, in 1913--and soon afterwards received the bundle of her late husband's notebooks on the No plays and Japanese interpretations of Chinese classics--his knowledge of Japan had been substantially enhanced. Yet he does not seem even then to have changed his basic image of Japan. Rather, he became more enthusiastic about "beautifying" Japan. While promoting the production of Yeats' At the Hawk's Well, Pound met Michio Ito, Tamijuro Kume and Jisoichi Kayano, and through them became acquainted with the Japanese language, Japanese customs, the No plays, Zen and various other aspects of Japan. He ex- perienced, as it were, some new phases of the realities of Japan, including the awkward English of many Japanese. But still he rarefied and mytholo- gized Japan by translating the No plays and the Chinese classics into beautiful English poetry. Certainly Pound tried to finish the translations as
? xvi INTRODUCTION
"Ernest Fenollosa would have wanted them done. " But in any event the more Pound learned about Japanese realities, the more he emphasized their beauty and positive value.
The same can be said of Canto 49. That is, Pound read the manuscript poems in Japanese and Chinese on the lakes and hills around the River Hisaio-Hsiang in China, and he used the images to create an unworldly lyrical world of "stillness" suggestive of the paradiso terrestre. And again we find that aspect when he began correspondence with Kitasono in 1936. Pound read the "crystal" poems by the members of the VOU Club, and introduced them as the "vortex of poetic alertness" in the Townsman (see Appendix). He urged the publisher James Laughlin to introduce them also in his yearly New Directions AnthoJogy. In his essay "Orientamenti" in Broletto (1938), Pound also introduced Japan favorably as being in a new "cycle," though he was aware of the Japanese invasion of Manchuria.
In 1939 Pound had begun to subscribe to the Japan Times & Mail, and was thus exposed to much more concerning the political, economic and social realities of contemporary Japan. But in 1940 he mythologized the whole history of Japan by writing that all the emperors "were of heaven descended" in Canto 58. (His source was most probably Heinrich Julius Klaproth's translation of Nippon Odai Ichiran. See Pound's letter to Kitaso- no. 3 March 1939. )
When we trace Pound's view of Japan, we come to realize that even though he continued to further his knowledge of Japan throughout his life, his earlier image of Japan as a far-off, dreamlike country persisted; a treas- ure land for the aesthete, a country entangled with pleasant memories of youth. We cannot neglect the basic fact that Pound grew up in the era of Japonisme, and the image of Japan registered in his mind in his early youth as a land of lotus and butterfly was not to be erased from his mind through- out his life. And we must also remember that FenoUosa's impact was so very strong on him that FenoUosa's admiration for Japanese values could only reinforce Pound's idealized image.
