Several of those who had been invited to confer
with him left his bedchamber carrying with them money received from the
royal hand.
with him left his bedchamber carrying with them money received from the
royal hand.
Macaulay
William had one great end ever before him.
Towards
that end he was impelled by a strong passion which appeared to him under
the guise of a sacred duty. Towards that end he toiled with a patience
resembling, as he once said, the patience with which he had seen a
boatman on a canal, strain against an adverse eddy, often swept back,
but never ceasing to pull, and content if, by the labour of hours, a few
yards could be gained. [225] Exploits which brought the Prince no nearer
to his object, however glorious they might be in the estimation of the
vulgar, were in his judgment boyish vanities, and no part of the real
business of life.
He determined to reject Mordaunt's advice; and there can be no doubt
that the determination was wise. Had William, in 1686, or even in 1687,
attempted to do what he did with such signal success in 1688, it is
probable that many Whigs would have risen in arms at his call. But he
would have found that the nation was not yet prepared to welcome an
armed deliverer from a foreign country, and that the Church had not yet
been provoked and insulted into forgetfulness of the tenet which had
long been her peculiar boast. The old Cavaliers would have flocked to
the royal standard. There would probably have been in all the three
kingdoms a civil war as long and fierce as that of the preceding
generation. While that war was raging in the British Isles, what might
not Lewis attempt on the Continent? And what hope would there be for
Holland, drained of her troops and abandoned by her Stadtholder?
William therefore contented himself for the present with taking measures
to unite and animate that mighty opposition of which he had become
the head. This was not difficult. The fall of the Hydes had excited
throughout England strange alarm and indignation: Men felt that the
question now was, not whether Protestantism should be dominant, but
whether it should be tolerated. The Treasurer had been succeeded by a
board, of which a Papist was the head. The Privy Seal had been entrusted
to a Papist. The Lord Lieutenant of Ireland had been succeeded by a man
who had absolutely no claim to high place except that he was a Papist.
The last person whom a government having in view the general interests
of the empire would have sent to Dublin as Deputy was Tyrconnel. His
brutal manners made him unfit to represent the majesty of the crown. The
feebleness of his understanding and the violence of his temper made him
unfit to conduct grave business of state. The deadly animosity which he
felt towards the possessors of the greater part of the soil of Ireland
made him especially unfit to rule that kingdom. But the intemperance of
his bigotry was thought amply to atone for the intemperance of all his
other passions; and, in consideration of the hatred which he bore to the
reformed faith, he was suffered to indulge without restraint his hatred
of the English name. This, then, was the real meaning of his Majesty's
respect for the rights of conscience. He wished his Parliament to remove
all the disabilities which had been imposed on Papists, merely in
order that he might himself impose disabilities equally galling on
Protestants. It was plain that, under such a prince, apostasy was the
only road to greatness. It was a road, however, which few ventured to
take. For the spirit of the nation was thoroughly roused; and every
renegade had to endure such an amount of public scorn and detestation,
as cannot be altogether unfelt even by the most callous natures.
It is true that several remarkable conversions had recently taken place;
but they were such as did little credit to the Church of Rome. Two
men of high rank had joined her communion; Henry Mordaunt, Earl of
Peterborough, and James Cecil, Earl of Salisbury. But Peterborough, who
had been an active soldier, courtier, and negotiator, was now broken
down by years and infirmities; and those who saw him totter about the
galleries of Whitehall, leaning on a stick and swathed up in flannels
and plasters, comforted themselves for his defection by remarking that
he had not changed his religion till he had outlived his faculties.
[226] Salisbury was foolish to a proverb. His figure was so bloated
by sensual indulgence as to be almost incapable of moving, and this
sluggish body was the abode of an equally sluggish mind. He was
represented in popular lampoons as a man made to be duped, as a man who
had hitherto been the prey of gamesters, and who might as well be the
prey of friars. A pasquinade, which, about the time of Rochester's
retirement, was fixed on the door of Salisbury House in the Strand,
described in coarse terms the horror with which the wise Robert Cecil,
if he could rise from his grave, would see to what a creature his
honours had descended. [227]
These were the highest in station among the proselytes of James. There
were other renegades of a very different kind, needy men of parts who
were destitute of principle and of all sense of personal dignity. There
is reason to believe that among these was William Wycherley, the
most licentious and hardhearted writer of a singularly licentious and
hardhearted school. [228] It is certain that Matthew Tindal, who, at a
later period, acquired great notoriety by writing against Christianity,
was at this time received into the bosom of the infallible Church, a
fact which, as may easily be supposed, the divines with whom he
was subsequently engaged in controversy did not suffer to sink into
oblivion. [229] A still more infamous apostate was Joseph Haines, whose
name is now almost forgotten, but who was well known in his own time as
an adventurer of versatile parts, sharper, coiner, false witness, sham
bail, dancing master, buffoon, poet, comedian. Some of his prologues and
epilogues were much admired by his contemporaries; and his merit as an
actor was universally acknowledged. This man professed himself a Roman
Catholic, and went to Italy in the retinue of Castelmaine, but was soon
dismissed for misconduct. If any credit is due to a tradition which was
long preserved in the green room, Haines had the impudence to affirm
that the Virgin Mary had appeared to him and called him to repentance.
After the Revolution, he attempted to make his peace with the town by a
penance more scandalous than his offence. One night, before he acted in
a farce, he appeared on the stage in a white sheet with a torch in his
hand, and recited some profane and indecent doggerel, which he called
his recantation. [230]
With the name of Haines was joined, in many libels the name of a more
illustrious renegade, John Dryden. Dryden was now approaching the
decline of life. After many successes and many failures, he had at
length attained, by general consent, the first place among living
English poets. His claims on the gratitude of James were superior to
those of any man of letters in the kingdom. But James cared little for
verses and much for money. From the day of his accession he set himself
to make small economical reforms, such as bring on a government the
reproach of meanness without producing any perceptible relief to the
finances. One of the victims of his injudicious parsimony was the Poet
Laureate. Orders were given that, in the new patent which the demise of
the crown made necessary, the annual butt of sack, originally granted to
Jonson, and continued to Jonson's successors, should be omitted. [231]
This was the only notice which the King, during the first year of his
reign, deigned to bestow on the mighty satirist who, in the very crisis
of the great struggle of the Exclusion Bill, had spread terror through
the Whig ranks. Dryden was poor and impatient of poverty. He knew little
and cared little about religion. If any sentiment was deeply fixed
in him, that sentiment was an aversion to priests of all persuasions,
Levites, Augurs, Muftis, Roman Catholic divines, Presbyterian divines,
divines of the Church of England. He was not naturally a man of high
spirit; and his pursuits had been by no means such as were likely to
give elevation or delicacy to his mind. He had, during many years,
earned his daily bread by pandaring to the vicious taste of the pit,
and by grossly flattering rich and noble patrons. Selfrespect and a fine
sense of the becoming were not to be expected from one who had led a
life of mendicancy and adulation. Finding that, if he continued to call
himself a Protestant, his services would be overlooked, he declared
himself a Papist. The King's parsimony instantly relaxed. Dryden was
gratified with a pension of a hundred pounds a year, and was employed to
defend his new religion both in prose and verse.
Two eminent men, Samuel Johnson and Walter Scott, have done their best
to persuade themselves and others that this memorable conversion
was sincere. It was natural that they should be desirous to remove
a disgraceful stain from the memory of one whose genius they justly
admired, and with whose political feelings they strongly sympathized;
but the impartial historian must with regret pronounce a very different
judgment. There will always be a strong presumption against the
sincerity of a conversion by which the convert is directly a gainer. In
the case of Dryden there is nothing to countervail this presumption.
His theological writings abundantly prove that he had never sought with
diligence and anxiety to learn the truth, and that his knowledge both
of the Church which he quitted and of the Church which he entered was of
the most superficial kind. Nor was his subsequent conduct that of a
man whom a strong sense of duty had constrained to take a step of awful
importance. Had he been such a man, the same conviction which had led
him to join the Church of Rome would surely have prevented him from
violating grossly and habitually rules which that Church, in common with
every other Christian society, recognises as binding. There would
have been a marked distinction between his earlier and his later
compositions. He would have looked back with remorse on a literary
life of near thirty years, during which his rare powers of diction
and versification had been systematically employed in spreading moral
corruption. Not a line tending to make virtue contemptible, or to
inflame licentious desire, would thenceforward have proceeded from his
pen. The truth unhappily is that the dramas which he wrote after his
pretended conversion are in no respect less impure or profane than those
of his youth. Even when he professed to translate he constantly wandered
from his originals in search of images which, if he had found them in
his originals, he ought to have shunned. What was bad became worse in
his versions. What was innocent contracted a taint from passing
through his mind. He made the grossest satires of Juvenal more gross,
interpolated loose descriptions in the tales of Boccaccio, and polluted
the sweet and limpid poetry of the Georgics with filth which would have
moved the loathing of Virgil.
The help of Dryden was welcome to those Roman Catholic divines who were
painfully sustaining a conflict against all that was most illustrious in
the Established Church. They could not disguise from themselves the fact
that their style, disfigured with foreign idioms which had been picked
up at Rome and Douay, appeared to little advantage when compared with
the eloquence of Tillotson and Sherlock. It seemed that it was no light
thing to have secured the cooperation of the greatest living master of
the English language. The first service which he was required to perform
in return for his pension was to defend his Church in prose against
Stillingfleet. But the art of saying things well is useless to a man who
has nothing to say; and this was Dryden's case. He soon found himself
unequally paired with an antagonist whose whole life had been one long
training for controversy. The veteran gladiator disarmed the novice,
inflicted a few contemptuous scratches, and turned away to encounter
more formidable combatants. Dryden then betook himself to a weapon at
which he was not likely to find his match. He retired for a time
from the bustle of coffeehouses and theatres to a quiet retreat in
Huntingdonshire, and there composed, with unwonted care and labour, his
celebrated poem on the points in dispute between the Churches of Rome
and England. The Church of Rome he represented under the similitude of a
milkwhite hind, ever in peril of death, yet fated not to die. The beasts
of the field were bent on her destruction. The quaking hare, indeed,
observed a timorous neutrality: but the Socinian fox, the Presbyterian
wolf, the Independent bear, the Anabaptist boar, glared fiercely at
the spotless creature. Yet she could venture to drink with them at the
common watering place under the protection of her friend, the kingly
lion. The Church of England was typified by the panther, spotted indeed,
but beautiful, too beautiful for a beast of prey. The hind and the
panther, equally hated by the ferocious population of the forest,
conferred apart on their common danger. They then proceeded to discuss
the points on which they differed, and, while wagging their tails and
licking their jaws, held a long dialogue touching the real presence, the
authority of Popes and Councils, the penal laws, the Test Act,
Oates's perjuries, Butler's unrequited services to the Cavalier party,
Stillingfleet's pamphlets, and Burnet's broad shoulders and fortunate
matrimonial speculations.
The absurdity of this plan is obvious. In truth the allegory could not
be preserved unbroken through ten lines together. No art of execution
could redeem the faults of such a design. Yet the Fable of the Hind
and Panther is undoubtedly the most valuable addition which was made
to English literature during the short and troubled reign of James the
Second. In none of Dryden's works can be found passages more pathetic
and magnificent, greater ductility and energy of language, or a more
pleasing and various music.
The poem appeared with every advantage which royal patronage could give.
A superb edition was printed for Scotland at the Roman Catholic press
established in Holyrood House. But men were in no humour to be charmed
by the transparent style and melodious numbers of the apostate. The
disgust excited by his venality, the alarm excited by the policy of
which he was the eulogist, were not to be sung to sleep. The just
indignation of the public was inflamed by many who were smarting from
his ridicule, and by many who were envious of his renown. In spite of
all the restraints under which the press lay, attacks on his life and
writings appeared daily. Sometimes he was Bayes, sometimes Poet Squab.
He was reminded that in his youth he had paid to the House of Cromwell
the same servile court which he was now paying to the House of Stuart.
One set of his assailants maliciously reprinted the sarcastic verses
which he had written against Popery in days when he could have got
nothing by being a Papist. Of the many satirical pieces which appeared
on this occasion, the most successful was the joint work of two young
men who had lately completed their studies at Cambridge, and had been
welcomed as promising novices in the literary coffee-houses of London,
Charles Montague and Matthew Prior. Montague was of noble descent: the
origin of Prior was so obscure that no biographer has been able to trace
it: but both the adventurers were poor and aspiring; both had keen
and vigorous minds; both afterwards climbed high; both united in a
remarkable degree the love of letters with skill in those departments of
business for which men of letters generally have a strong distaste. Of
the fifty poets whose lives Johnson has written, Montague and Prior were
the only two who were distinguished by an intimate knowledge of trade
and finance. Soon their paths diverged widely. Their early friendship
was dissolved. One of them became the chief of the Whig party, and was
impeached by the Tories. The other was entrusted with all the mysteries
of Tory diplomacy, and was long kept close prisoner by the Whigs. At
length, after many eventful years, the associates, so long parted, were
reunited in Westminster Abbey.
Whoever has read the tale of the Hind and Panther with attention must
have perceived that, while that work was in progress, a great alteration
took place in the views of those who used Dryden as their interpreter.
At first the Church of England is mentioned with tenderness and respect,
and is exhorted to ally herself with the Roman Catholics against the
Puritan sects: but at the close of the poem, and in the preface, which
was written after the poem had been finished, the Protestant Dissenters
are invited to make common cause with the Roman Catholics against the
Church of England.
This change in the language of the court poet was indicative of a great
change in the policy of the court. The original purpose of James
had been to obtain for the Church of which he was a member, not only
complete immunity from all penalties and from all civil disabilities,
but also an ample share of ecclesiastical and academical endowments,
and at the same time to enforce with rigour the laws against the Puritan
sects. All the special dispensations which he had granted had been
granted to Roman Catholics. All the laws which bore hardest on the
Presbyterians, Independents, and Baptists, had been for a time severely
executed by him. While Hales commanded a regiment, while Powis sate at
the Council board, while Massey held a deanery, while breviaries and
mass books were printed at Oxford under a royal license, while the host
was publicly exposed in London under the protection of the pikes and
muskets of the footguards, while friars and monks walked the streets of
London in their robes, Baxter was in gaol; Howe was in exile; the Five
Mile Act and the Conventicle Act were in full vigour; Puritan writers
were compelled to resort to foreign or to secret presses; Puritan
congregations could meet only by night or in waste places, and Puritan
ministers were forced to preach in the garb of colliers or of sailors.
In Scotland the King, while he spared no exertion to extort from the
Estates full relief for Roman Catholics, had demanded and obtained
new statutes of unprecedented severity against the Presbyterians. His
conduct to the exiled Huguenots had not less clearly indicated his
feelings. We have seen that, when the public munificence had placed
in his hands a large sum for the relief of those unhappy men, he, in
violation of every law of hospitality and good faith, required them to
renounce the Calvinistic ritual to which they were strongly attached,
and to conform to the Church of England, before he would dole out to
them any portion of the alms which had been entrusted to his care.
Such had been his policy as long as he could cherish, any hope that the
Church of England would consent to share ascendency with the Church of
Rome. That hope at one time amounted to confidence. The enthusiasm with
which the Tories had hailed his accession, the elections, the dutiful
language and ample grants of his Parliament, the suppression of the
Western insurrection, the complete prostration of the party which had
attempted to exclude him from the crown, elated him beyond the bounds of
reason. He felt an assurance that every obstacle would give way before
his power and his resolution. His Parliament withstood him. He tried the
effects of frowns and menaces. Frowns and menaces failed. He tried the
effect of prorogation. From the day of the prorogation the opposition
to his designs had been growing stronger and stronger. It seemed clear
that, if he effected his purpose, he must effect it in defiance of
that great party which had given such signal proofs of fidelity to his
office, to his family, and to his person. The whole Anglican priesthood,
the whole Cavalier gentry, were against him. In vain had he, by virtue
of his ecclesiastical supremacy, enjoined the clergy to abstain from
discussing controverted points. Every parish in the nation was warned
every Sunday against the errors of Rome; and these warnings were only
the more effective, because they were accompanied by professions of
reverence for the Sovereign, and of a determination to endure with
patience whatever it might be his pleasure to inflict. The royalist
knights and esquires who, through forty-five years of war and faction,
had stood so manfully by the throne, now expressed, in no measured
phrase, their resolution to stand as manfully by the Church. Dull as was
the intellect of James, despotic as was his temper, he felt that he
must change his course. He could not safely venture to outrage all
his Protestant subjects at once. If he could bring himself to make
concessions to the party which predominated in both Houses, if he could
bring himself to leave to the established religion all its dignities,
emoluments, and privileges unimpaired, he might still break up
Presbyterian meetings, and fill the gaols with Baptist preachers. But if
he was determined to plunder the hierarchy, he must make up his mind to
forego the luxury of persecuting the Dissenters. If he was henceforward
to be at feud with his old friends, he must make a truce with his old
enemies. He could overpower the Anglican Church only by forming against
her an extensive coalition, including sects which, though they differed
in doctrine and government far more widely from each other than from
her, might yet be induced, by their common jealousy of her greatness,
and by their common dread of her intolerance, to suspend their
animosities till she was no longer able to oppress them.
This plan seemed to him to have one strong recommendation. If he could
only succeed in conciliating the Protestant Nonconformists he might
flatter himself that he was secure against all chance of rebellion.
According to the Anglican divines, no subject could by any provocation
be justified in withstanding the Lord's anointed by force. The theory of
the Puritan sectaries was very different. Those sectaries had no scruple
about smiting tyrants with the sword of Gideon. Many of them did not
shrink from using the dagger of Ehud. They were probably even now
meditating another Western insurrection, or another Rye House Plot.
James, therefore, conceived that he might safely persecute the Church if
he could only gain the Dissenters. The party whose principles afforded
him no guarantee would be attached to him by interest. The party
whose interests he attacked would be restrained from insurrection by
principle.
Influenced by such considerations as these, James, from the time at
which he parted in anger with his Parliament, began to meditate a
general league of all Nonconformists, Catholic and Protestant, against
the established religion. So early as Christmas 1685, the agents of the
United Provinces informed the States General that the plan of a general
toleration had been arranged and would soon be disclosed. [232] The
reports which had reached the Dutch embassy proved to be premature.
The separatists appear, however, to have been treated with more lenity
during the year 1686 than during the year 1685. But it was only by slow
degrees and after many struggles that the King could prevail on himself
to form an alliance with all that he most abhorred. He had to overcome
an animosity, not slight or capricious, not of recent origin or hasty
growth, but hereditary in his line, strengthened by great wrongs
inflicted and suffered through a hundred and twenty eventful years, and
intertwined with all his feelings, religious, political, domestic, and
personal. Four generations of Stuarts had waged a war to the death with
four generations of Puritans; and, through that long war, there had been
no Stuart who had hated the Puritans so much, or who had been so much
hated by them, as himself. They had tried to blast his honour and
to exclude him from his birthright; they had called him incendiary,
cutthroat, poisoner; they had driven him from the Admiralty and the
Privy Council; they had repeatedly chased him into banishment; they
had plotted his assassination; they had risen against him in arms by
thousands. He had avenged himself on them by havoc such as England had
never before seen. Their heads and quarters were still rotting on poles
in all the market places of Somersetshire and Dorsetshire. Aged women
held in high honour among the sectaries for piety and charity had, for
offences which no good prince would have thought deserving even of a
severe reprimand, been beheaded and burned alive. Such had been, even
in England, the relations between the King and the Puritans; and in
Scotland the tyranny of the King and the fury of the Puritans had been
such as Englishmen could hardly conceive. To forget an enmity so long
and so deadly was no light task for a nature singularly harsh and
implacable.
The conflict in the royal mind did not escape the eye of Barillon. At
the end of January, 1687, he sent a remarkable letter to Versailles. The
King,--such was the substance of this document,--had almost convinced
himself that he could not obtain entire liberty for Roman Catholics
and yet maintain the laws against Protestant Dissenters. He leaned,
therefore, to the plan of a general indulgence; but at heart he would
be far better pleased if he could, even now, divide his protection and
favour between the Church of Rome and the Church of England, to the
exclusion of all other religious persuasions. [233]
A very few days after this despatch had been written, James made his
first hesitating and ungracious advances towards the Puritans. He had
determined to begin with Scotland, where his power to dispense with
acts of parliament had been admitted by the obsequious Estates. On
the twelfth of February, accordingly, was published at Edinburgh a
proclamation granting relief to scrupulous consciences. [234] This
proclamation fully proves the correctness of Barillon's judgment. Even
in the very act of making concessions to the Presbyterians, James could
not conceal the loathing with which he regarded them. The toleration
given to the Catholics was complete. The Quakers had little reason
to complain. But the indulgence vouchsafed to the Presbyterians, who
constituted the great body of the Scottish people, was clogged by
conditions which made it almost worthless. For the old test, which
excluded Catholics and Presbyterians alike from office, was substituted
a new test, which admitted the Catholics, but excluded most of the
Presbyterians. The Catholics were allowed to build chapels, and even
to carry the host in procession anywhere except in the high streets of
royal burghs: the Quakers were suffered to assemble in public edifices:
but the Presbyterians were interdicted from worshipping God anywhere but
in private dwellings: they were not to presume to build meeting houses:
they were not even to use a barn or an outhouse for religious exercises:
and it was distinctly notified to them that, if they dared to hold
conventicles in the open air, the law, which denounced death against
both preachers and hearers, should be enforced without mercy. Any
Catholic priest might say mass: any Quaker might harangue his brethren:
but the Privy Council was directed to see that no Presbyterian minister
presumed to preach without a special license from the government. Every
line of this instrument, and of the letters by which it was accompanied,
shows how much it cost the King to relax in the smallest degree the
rigour with which he had ever treated the old enemies of his house.
[235]
There is reason, indeed, to believe that, when he published this
proclamation, he had by no means fully made up his mind to a coalition
with the Puritans, and that his object was to grant just so much favour
to them as might suffice to frighten the Churchmen into submission.
He therefore waited a month, in order to see what effect the edict put
forth at Edinburgh would produce in England. That month he employed
assiduously, by Petre's advice, in what was called closeting. London was
very full. It was expected that the Parliament would shortly meet for
the dispatch of business; and many members were in town. The King set
himself to canvass them man by man. He flattered himself that zealous
Tories,--and of such, with few exceptions, the House of Commons
consisted,--would find it difficult to resist his earnest request,
addressed to them, not collectively, but separately, not from the
throne, but in the familiarity of conversation. The members, therefore,
who came to pay their duty at Whitehall were taken aside, and honoured
with long private interviews. The King pressed them, as they were loyal
gentlemen, to gratify him in the one thing on which his heart was fixed.
The question, he said, touched his personal honour. The laws enacted in
the late reign by factious Parliaments against the Roman Catholics had
really been aimed at himself. Those laws had put a stigma on him, had
driven him from the Admiralty, had driven him from the Council Board. He
had a right to expect that in the repeal of those laws all who loved
and reverenced him would concur. When he found his hearers obdurate
to exhortation, he resorted to intimidation and corruption. Those who
refused to pleasure him in this matter were plainly told that they must
not expect any mark of his favour. Penurious as he was, he opened and
distributed his hoards.
Several of those who had been invited to confer
with him left his bedchamber carrying with them money received from the
royal hand. The Judges, who were at this time on their spring circuits,
were directed by the King to see those members who remained in the
country, and to ascertain the intentions of each. The result of this
investigation was, that a great majority of the House of Commons seemed
fully determined to oppose the measures of the court. [236] Among those
whose firmness excited general admiration was Arthur Herbert, brother
of the Chief Justice, member for Dover, Master of the Robes, and Rear
Admiral of England. Arthur Herbert was much loved by the sailors,
and was reputed one of the best of the aristocratical class of naval
officers. It had been generally supposed that he would readily comply
with the royal wishes: for he was heedless of religion; he was fond of
pleasure and expense; he had no private estate; his places brought him
in four thousand pounds a year; and he had long been reckoned among
the most devoted personal adherents of James. When, however, the Rear
Admiral was closeted, and required to promise that he would vote for the
repeal of the Test Act, his answer was, that his honour and conscience
would not permit him to give any such pledge. "Nobody doubts your
honour," said the King; "but a man who lives as you do ought not to talk
about his conscience. " To this reproach, a reproach which came with a
bad grace from the lover of Catharine Sedley, Herbert manfully replied,
"I have my faults, sir: but I could name people who talk much more about
conscience than I am in the habit of doing, and yet lead lives as loose
as mine. " He was dismissed from all his places; and the account of what
he had disbursed and received as Master of the Robes was scrutinised
with great and, as he complained, with unjust severity. [237]
It was now evident that all hope of an alliance between the Churches of
England and of Rome, for the purpose of sharing offices and emoluments,
and of crushing the Puritan sects, must be abandoned. Nothing remained
but to try a coalition between the Church of Rome and the Puritan sects
against the Church of England.
On the eighteenth of March the King informed the Privy Council that he
had determined to prorogue the Parliament till the end of November, and
to grant, by his own authority, entire liberty of conscience to all
his subjects. [238] On the fourth of April appeared the memorable
Declaration of Indulgence.
In this Declaration the King avowed that it was his earnest wish to see
his people members of that Church to which he himself belonged. But,
since that could not be, he announced his intention to protect them
in the free exercise of their religion. He repeated all those phrases
which, eight years before, when he was himself an oppressed man, had
been familiar to his lips, but which he had ceased to use from the day
on which a turn of fortune had put it into his power to be an oppressor.
He had long been convinced, he said, that conscience was not to be
forced, that persecution was unfavourable to population and to trade,
and that it never attained the ends which persecutors had in view. He
repeated his promise, already often repeated and often violated, that
he would protect the Established Church in the enjoyment of her legal
rights. He then proceeded to annul, by his own sole authority, a long
series of statutes. He suspended all penal laws against all classes
of Nonconformists. He authorised both Roman Catholics and Protestant
Dissenters to perform their worship publicly. He forbade his subjects,
on pain of his highest displeasure, to molest any religious assembly.
He also abrogated all those acts which imposed any religious test as a
qualification for any civil or military office. [239]
That the Declaration of Indulgence was unconstitutional is a point on
which both the great English parties have always been entirely agreed.
Every person capable of reasoning on a political question must perceive
that a monarch who is competent to issue such a declaration is nothing
less than an absolute monarch. Nor is it possible to urge in defence
of this act of James those pleas by which many arbitrary acts of the
Stuarts have been vindicated or excused. It cannot be said that
he mistook the bounds of his prerogative because they had not been
accurately ascertained. For the truth is that he trespassed with a
recent landmark full in his view. Fifteen years before that time, a
Declaration of Indulgence had been put forth by his brother with
the advice of the Cabal. That Declaration, when compared with the
Declaration of James, might be called modest and cautious. The
Declaration of Charles dispensed only with penal laws. The Declaration
of James dispensed also with all religious tests. The Declaration of
Charles permitted the Roman Catholics to celebrate their worship in
private dwellings only. Under the Declaration of James they might build
and decorate temples, and even walk in procession along Fleet Street
with crosses, images, and censers. Yet the Declaration of Charles had
been pronounced illegal in the most formal manner. The Commons had
resolved that the King had no power to dispense with statutes in matters
ecclesiastical. Charles had ordered the obnoxious instrument to be
cancelled in his presence, had torn off the seal with his own hand, and
had, both by message under his sign manual, and with his own lips from
his throne in full Parliament, distinctly promised the two Houses that
the step which had given so much offence should never be drawn into
precedent. The two Houses had then, without one dissentient voice,
joined in thanking him for this compliance with their wishes. No
constitutional question had ever been decided more deliberately, more
clearly, or with more harmonious consent.
The defenders of James have frequently pleaded in his excuse the
judgment of the Court of King's Bench, on the information collusively
laid against Sir Edward Hales: but the plea is of no value. That
judgment James had notoriously obtained by solicitation, by threats,
by dismissing scrupulous magistrates, and by placing on the bench
other magistrates more courtly. And yet that judgment, though generally
regarded by the bar and by the nation as unconstitutional, went only
to this extent, that the Sovereign might, for special reasons of state,
grant to individuals by name exemptions from disabling statutes. That he
could by one sweeping edict authorise all his subjects to disobey whole
volumes of laws, no tribunal had ventured, in the face of the solemn
parliamentary decision of 1673, to affirm.
Such, however, was the position of parties that James's Declaration of
Indulgence, though the most audacious of all the attacks made by the
Stuarts on public freedom, was well calculated to please that very
portion of the community by which all the other attacks of the Stuarts
on public freedom had been most strenuously resisted. It could
scarcely be hoped that the Protestant Nonconformist, separated from
his countrymen by a harsh code harshly enforced, would be inclined to
dispute the validity of a decree which relieved him from intolerable
grievances. A cool and philosophical observer would undoubtedly have
pronounced that all the evil arising from all the intolerant laws which
Parliaments had framed was not to be compared to the evil which would be
produced by a transfer of the legislative power from the Parliament to
the Sovereign. But such coolness and philosophy are not to be expected
from men who are smarting under present pain, and who are tempted by the
offer of immediate ease. A Puritan divine, could not indeed deny that
the dispensing power now claimed by the crown was inconsistent with
the fundamental principles of the constitution. But he might perhaps
be excused if he asked, What was the constitution to him? The Act of
Uniformity had ejected him, in spite of royal promises, from a benefice
which was his freehold, and had reduced him to beggary and dependence.
The Five Mile Act had banished him from his dwelling, from his
relations, from his friends, from almost all places of public resort.
Under the Conventicle Act his goods had been distrained; and he had
been flung into one noisome gaol after another among highwaymen and
housebreakers. Out of prison he had constantly had the officers of
justice on his track; he had been forced to pay hushmoney to informers;
he had stolen, in ignominious disguises, through windows and trapdoors,
to meet his flock, and had, while pouring the baptismal water, or
distributing the eucharistic bread, been anxiously listening for the
signal that the tipstaves were approaching. Was it not mockery to
call on a man thus plundered and oppressed to suffer martyrdom for the
property and liberty of his plunderers and oppressors? The Declaration,
despotic as it might seem to his prosperous neighbours, brought
deliverance to him. He was called upon to make his choice, not between
freedom and slavery, but between two yokes; and he might not unnaturally
think the yoke of the King lighter than that of the Church.
While thoughts like these were working in the minds of many Dissenters,
the Anglican party was in amazement and terror. This new turn in affairs
was indeed alarming. The House of Stuart leagued with republican and
regicide sects against the old Cavaliers of England; Popery leagued with
Puritanism against an ecclesiastical system with which the Puritans had
no quarrel, except that it had retained too much that was Popish, these
were portents which confounded all the calculations of statesmen. The
Church was then to be attacked at once on every side and the attack was
to be under the direction of him who, by her constitution, was her head.
She might well be struck with surprise and dismay. And mingled with
surprise and dismay came other bitter feelings; resentment against
the perjured Prince whom she had served too well, and remorse for the
cruelties in which he had been her accomplice, and for which he was now,
as it seemed, about to be her punisher. Her chastisement was just. She
reaped that which she had sown. After the Restoration, when her power
was at the height, she had breathed nothing hut vengeance. She had
encouraged, urged, almost compelled the Stuarts to requite with
perfidious ingratitude the recent services of the Presbyterians. Had
she, in that season of her prosperity, pleaded, as became her, for her
enemies, she might now, in her distress, have found them her friends.
Perhaps it was not yet too late. Perhaps she might still be able to turn
the tactics of her faithless oppressor against himself. There was
among the Anglican clergy a moderate party which had always felt kindly
towards the Protestant Dissenters. That party was not large; but the
abilities, acquirements, and virtues of those who belonged to it made
it respectable. It had been regarded with little favour by the highest
ecclesiastical dignitaries, and had been mercilessly reviled by bigots
of the school of Laud but, from the day on which the Declaration of
Indulgence appeared to the day on which the power of James ceased to
inspire terror, the whole Church seemed to be animated by the spirit,
and guided by the counsels, of the calumniated Latitudinarians.
Then followed an auction, the strangest that history has recorded. On
one side the King, on the other the Church, began to bid eagerly against
each other for the favour of those whom tip to that time King and Church
had combined to oppress. The Protestant Dissenters, who, a few months
before, had been a despised and proscribed class, now held the balance
of power. The harshness with which they had been treated was universally
condemned. The court tried to throw all the blame on the hierarchy.
The hierarchy flung it back on the court. The King declared that he had
unwillingly persecuted the separatists only because his affairs had been
in such a state that he could not venture to disoblige the established
clergy. The established clergy protested that they had borne a part
in severity uncongenial to their feelings only from deference to the
authority of the King. The King got together a collection of stories
about rectors and vicars who had by threats of prosecution wrung
money out of Protestant Dissenters. He talked on this subject much and
publicly, threatened to institute an inquiry which would exhibit the
parsons in their true character to the whole world, and actually issued
several commissions empowering agents on whom he thought that he could
depend to ascertain the amount of the sums extorted in different parts
of the country by professors of the dominant religion from sectaries.
The advocates of the Church, on the other hand, cited instances of
honest parish priests who had been reprimanded and menaced by the court
for recommending toleration in the pulpit, and for refusing to spy out
and hunt down little congregations of Nonconformists. The King asserted
that some of the Churchmen whom he had closeted had offered to make
large concessions to the Catholics, on condition that the persecution
of the Puritans might go on. The accused Churchmen vehemently denied the
truth of this charge; and alleged that, if they would have complied
with what he demanded for his own religion, he would most gladly
have suffered them to indemnify themselves by harassing and pillaging
Protestant Dissenters. [240]
The court had changed its face. The scarf and cassock could hardly
appear there without calling forth sneers and malicious whispers. Maids
of honour forbore to giggle, and Lords of the Bedchamber bowed low, when
the Puritanical visage and the Puritanical garb, so long the favourite
subjects of mockery in fashionable circles, were seen in the galleries.
Taunton, which had been during two generations the stronghold of the
Roundhead party in the West, which had twice resolutely repelled the
armies of Charles the First, which had risen as one man to support
Monmouth, and which had been turned into a shambles by Kirke and
Jeffreys, seemed to have suddenly succeeded to the place which Oxford
had once occupied in the royal favour. [241] The King constrained
himself to show even fawning courtesy to eminent Dissenters. To some
he offered money, to some municipal honours, to some pardons for their
relations and friends who, having been implicated in the Rye House Plot,
or having joined the standard of Monmouth, were now wandering on the
Continent, or toiling among the sugar canes of Barbadoes. He affected
even to sympathize with the kindness which the English Puritans felt for
their foreign brethren. A second and a third proclamation were published
at Edinburgh, which greatly extended the nugatory toleration granted
to the Presbyterians by the edict of February. [242] The banished
Huguenots, on whom the King had frowned during many months, and whom he
had defrauded of the alms contributed by the nation, were now relieved
and caressed. An Order in Council was issued, appealing again in their
behalf to the public liberality. The rule which required them to qualify
themselves for the receipt of charity, by conforming to the Anglican
worship, seems to have been at this time silently abrogated; and the
defenders of the King's policy had the effrontery to affirm that this
rule, which, as we know from the best evidence, was really devised by
himself in concert with Barillon, had been adopted at the instance of
the prelates of the Established Church. [243]
While the King was thus courting his old adversaries, the friends of
the Church were not less active. Of the acrimony and scorn with which
prelates and priests had, since the Restoration, been in the habit of
treating the sectaries scarcely a trace was discernible. Those who had
lately been designated as schismatics and fanatics were now dear fellow
Protestants, weak brethren it might be, but still brethren, whose
scruples were entitled to tender regard. If they would but be true at
this crisis to the cause of the English constitution and of the reformed
religion, their generosity should be speedily and largely rewarded. They
should have, instead of an indulgence which was of no legal validity, a
real indulgence, secured by Act of Parliament. Nay, many Churchmen, who
had hitherto been distinguished by their inflexible attachment to every
gesture and every word prescribed in the Book of Common Prayer, now
declared themselves favourable, not only to toleration, but even to
comprehension. The dispute, they said, about surplices and attitudes,
had too long divided those who were agreed as to the essentials of
religion. When the struggle for life and death against the common enemy
was over, it would be found that the Anglican clergy would be ready to
make every fair concession. If the Dissenters would demand only what was
reasonable, not only civil but ecclesiastical dignities would be open
to them; and Baxter and Howe would be able, without any stain on their
honour or their conscience, to sit on the episcopal bench.
Of the numerous pamphlets in which the cause of the Court and the cause
of the Church were at this time eagerly and anxiously pleaded before the
Puritan, now, by a strange turn of fortune, the arbiter of the fate
of his persecutors, one only is still remembered, the Letter to a
Dissenter. In this masterly little tract, all the arguments which could
convince a Nonconformist that it was his duty and his interest to prefer
an alliance with the Church to an alliance with the Court were condensed
into the smallest compass, arranged in the most perspicuous order,
illustrated with lively wit, and enforced by an eloquence earnest
indeed, yet never in its utmost vehemence transgressing the limits
of exact good sense and good breeding. The effect of this paper was
immense; for, as it was only a single sheet, more than twenty thousand
copies were circulated by the post; and there was no corner of the
kingdom in which the effect was not felt. Twenty-four answers were
published, but the town pronounced that they were all bad, and that
Lestrange's was the worst of the twenty-four. [244] The government was
greatly irritated, and spared no pains to discover the author of the
Letter: but it was found impossible to procure legal evidence against
him. Some imagined that they recognised the sentiments and diction of
Temple. [245] But in truth that amplitude and acuteness of intellect,
that vivacity of fancy, that terse and energetic style, that placid
dignity, half courtly half philosophical, which the utmost excitement
of conflict could not for a moment derange, belonged to Halifax, and to
Halifax alone.
The Dissenters wavered; nor is it any reproach to them that they did so.
They were suffering, and the King had given them relief. Some eminent
pastors had emerged from confinement; others had ventured to return
from exile. Congregations, which had hitherto met only by stealth and in
darkness, now assembled at noonday, and sang psalms aloud in the hearing
of magistrates, churchwardens, and constables. Modest buildings for the
worship of God after the Puritan fashion began to rise all over England.
An observant traveller will still remark the date of 1687 on some of the
oldest meeting houses. Nevertheless the offers of the Church were, to
a prudent Dissenter, far more attractive than those of the King. The
Declaration was, in the eye of the law, a nullity. It suspended the
penal statutes against nonconformity only for so long a time as the
fundamental principles of the constitution and the rightful authority
of the legislature should remain suspended. What was the value of
privileges which must be held by a tenure at once so ignominious and
so insecure? There might soon be a demise of the crown. A sovereign
attached to the established religion might sit on the throne. A
Parliament composed of Churchmen might be assembled. How deplorable
would then be the situation of Dissenters who had been in league with
Jesuits against the constitution. The Church offered an indulgence very
different from that granted by James, an indulgence as valid and as
sacred as the Great Charter. Both the contending parties promised
religious liberty to the separatist: but one party required him to
purchase it by sacrificing civil liberty; the other party invited him to
enjoy civil and religious liberty together.
For these reasons, even if it could be believed that the Court was
sincere, a Dissenter might reasonably have determined to cast in his lot
with the Church. But what guarantee was there for the sincerity of the
Court? All men knew what the conduct of James had been tip to that
very time. It was not impossible, indeed, that a persecutor might be
convinced by argument and by experience of the advantages of toleration.
But James did not pretend to have been recently convinced. On the
contrary, he omitted no opportunity of protesting that he had, during
many years, been, on principle, adverse to all intolerance. Yet, within
a few months, he had persecuted men, women, young girls, to the death
for their religion. Had he been acting against light and against the
convictions of his conscience then? Or was he uttering a deliberate
falsehood now? From this dilemma there was no escape; and either of the
two suppositions was fatal to the King's character for honesty. It was
notorious also that he had been completely subjugated by the Jesuits.
Only a few days before the publication of the Indulgence, that Order had
been honoured, in spite of the well known wishes of the Holy See, with
a new mark of his confidence and approbation. His confessor, Father
Mansuete, a Franciscan, whose mild temper and irreproachable life
commanded general respect, but who had long been hated by Tyrconnel
and Petre, had been discarded. The vacant place had been filled by an
Englishman named Warner, who had apostatized from the religion of his
country and had turned Jesuit. To the moderate Roman Catholics and to
the Nuncio this change was far from agreeable. By every Protestant it
was regarded as a proof that the dominion of the Jesuits over the royal
mind was absolute. [246] Whatever praises those fathers might justly
claim, flattery itself could not ascribe to them either wide liberality
or strict veracity. That they had never scrupled, when the interest of
their Order was at stake, to call in the aid of the civil sword, or to
violate the laws of truth and of good faith, had been proclaimed to
the world, not only by Protestant accusers, but by men whose virtue and
genius were the glory of the Church of Rome. It was incredible that
a devoted disciple of the Jesuits should be on principle zealous for
freedom of conscience: but it was neither incredible nor improbable that
he might think himself justified in disguising his real sentiments, in
order to render a service to his religion. It was certain that the King
at heart preferred the Churchmen to the Puritans. It was certain that,
while he had any hope of gaining the Churchmen, he had never shown the
smallest kindness to the Puritans. Could it then be doubted that, if
the Churchmen would even now comply with his wishes, he would willingly
sacrifice the Puritans? His word, repeatedly pledged, had not restrained
him from invading the legal rights of that clergy which had given such
signal proofs of affection and fidelity to his house. What security then
could his word afford to sects divided from him by the recollection of a
thousand inexpiable wounds inflicted and endured?
When the first agitation produced by the publication of the Indulgence
had subsided, it appeared that a breach had taken place in the Puritan
party. The minority, headed by a few busy men whose judgment was
defective or was biassed by interest, supported the King. Henry Care,
who had long been the bitterest and most active pamphleteer among the
Nonconformists, and who had, in the days of the Popish plot, assailed
James with the utmost fury in a weekly journal entitled the Packet of
Advice from Rome, was now as loud in adulation, as he had formerly been
in calumny and insult. [247] The chief agent who was employed by the
government to manage the Presbyterians was Vincent Alsop, a divine of
some note both as a preacher and as a writer. His son, who had incurred
the penalties of treason, received a pardon; and the whole influence of
the father was thus engaged on the side of the Court. [248] With Alsop
was joined Thomas Rosewell. Rosewell had, during that persecution of
the Dissenters which followed the detection of the Rye House Plot, been
falsely accused of preaching against the government, had been tried for
his life by Jeffreys, and had, in defiance of the clearest evidence,
been convicted by a packed jury. The injustice of the verdict was so
gross that the very courtiers cried shame. One Tory gentleman who had
heard the trial went instantly to Charles, and declared that the neck
of the most loyal subject in England would not be safe if Rosewell
suffered. The jurymen themselves were stung by remorse when they thought
over what they had done, and exerted themselves to save the life of the
prisoner. At length a pardon was granted; but Rosewell remained
bound under heavy recognisances to good behaviour during life, and to
periodical appearance in the Court of King's Bench. His recognisances
were now discharged by the royal command; and in this way his services
were secured. [249]
The business of gaining the Independents was principally intrusted to
one of their ministers named Stephen Lobb. Lobb was a weak, violent, and
ambitious man. He had gone such lengths in opposition to the government,
that he had been by name proscribed in several proclamations. He now
made his peace, and went as far in servility as he had ever done
in faction. He joined the Jesuitical cabal, and eagerly recommended
measures from which the wisest and most honest Roman Catholics recoiled.
It was remarked that he was constantly at the palace and frequently in
the closet, that he lived with a splendour to which the Puritan divines
were little accustomed, and that he was perpetually surrounded by
suitors imploring his interest to procure them offices or pardons. [250]
With Lobb was closely connected William Penn. Penn had never been a
strongheaded man: the life which he had been leading during two years
had not a little impaired his moral sensibility; and, if his conscience
ever reproached him, he comforted himself by repeating that he had a
good and noble end in view, and that he was not paid for his services in
money.
By the influence of these men, and of others less conspicuous, addresses
of thanks to the King were procured from several bodies of Dissenters.
Tory writers have with justice remarked that the language of these
compositions was as fulsomely servile as anything that could be found in
the most florid eulogies pronounced by Bishops on the Stuarts. But, on
close inquiry, it will appear that the disgrace belongs to but a small
part of the Puritan party. There was scarcely a market town in England
without at least a knot of separatists. No exertion was spared to induce
them to express their gratitude for the Indulgence. Circular letters,
imploring them to sign, were sent to every corner of the kingdom in such
numbers that the mail bags, it was sportively said, were too heavy for
the posthorses. Yet all the addresses which could be obtained from all
the Presbyterians, Independents, and Baptists scattered over England did
not in six months amount to sixty; nor is there any reason to believe
that these addresses were numerously signed. [251]
The great body of Protestant Nonconformists, firmly attached to civil
liberty, and distrusting the promises of the King and of the Jesuits,
steadily refused to return thanks for a favour which, it might well
be suspected, concealed a snare. This was the temper of all the most
illustrious chiefs of the party. One of these was Baxter. He had, as we
have seen, been brought to trial soon after the accession of James, had
been brutally insulted by Jeffreys, and had been convicted by a jury,
such as the courtly Sheriffs of those times were in the habit of
selecting. Baxter had been about a year and a half in prison when the
court began to think seriously of gaining the Nonconformists. He was
not only set at liberty, but was informed that, if he chose to reside in
London, he might do so without fearing that the Five Mile Act would
be enforced against him. The government probably hoped that the
recollection of past sufferings and the sense of present ease would
produce the same effect on him as on Rosewell and Lobb. The hope was
disappointed. Baxter was neither to be corrupted nor to be deceived. He
refused to join in an address of thanks for the Indulgence, and exerted
all his influence to promote good feeling between the Church and the
Presbyterians. [252]
If any man stood higher than Baxter in the estimation of the Protestant
Dissenters, that man was John Howe. Howe had, like Baxter, been
personally a gainer by the recent change of policy. The same tyranny
which had flung Baxter into gaol had driven Howe into banishment; and,
soon after Baxter had been let out of the King's Bench prison, Howe
returned from Utrecht to England. It was expected at Whitehall that Howe
would exert in favour of the court all the authority which he possessed
over his brethren. The King himself condescended to ask the help of the
subject whom he had oppressed. Howe appears to have hesitated: but the
influence of the Hampdens, with whom he was on terms of close intimacy,
kept him steady to the cause of the constitution. A meeting of
Presbyterian ministers was held at his house, to consider the state of
affairs, and to determine on the course to be adopted. There was great
anxiety at the palace to know the result. Two royal messengers were in
attendance during the discussion. They carried back the unwelcome news
that Howe had declared himself decidedly adverse to the dispensing
power, and that he had, after long debate, carried with him the majority
of the assembly. [253]
To the names of Baxter and Howe must be added the name of a man far
below them in station and in acquired knowledge, but in virtue their
equal, and in genius their superior, John Bunyan.
that end he was impelled by a strong passion which appeared to him under
the guise of a sacred duty. Towards that end he toiled with a patience
resembling, as he once said, the patience with which he had seen a
boatman on a canal, strain against an adverse eddy, often swept back,
but never ceasing to pull, and content if, by the labour of hours, a few
yards could be gained. [225] Exploits which brought the Prince no nearer
to his object, however glorious they might be in the estimation of the
vulgar, were in his judgment boyish vanities, and no part of the real
business of life.
He determined to reject Mordaunt's advice; and there can be no doubt
that the determination was wise. Had William, in 1686, or even in 1687,
attempted to do what he did with such signal success in 1688, it is
probable that many Whigs would have risen in arms at his call. But he
would have found that the nation was not yet prepared to welcome an
armed deliverer from a foreign country, and that the Church had not yet
been provoked and insulted into forgetfulness of the tenet which had
long been her peculiar boast. The old Cavaliers would have flocked to
the royal standard. There would probably have been in all the three
kingdoms a civil war as long and fierce as that of the preceding
generation. While that war was raging in the British Isles, what might
not Lewis attempt on the Continent? And what hope would there be for
Holland, drained of her troops and abandoned by her Stadtholder?
William therefore contented himself for the present with taking measures
to unite and animate that mighty opposition of which he had become
the head. This was not difficult. The fall of the Hydes had excited
throughout England strange alarm and indignation: Men felt that the
question now was, not whether Protestantism should be dominant, but
whether it should be tolerated. The Treasurer had been succeeded by a
board, of which a Papist was the head. The Privy Seal had been entrusted
to a Papist. The Lord Lieutenant of Ireland had been succeeded by a man
who had absolutely no claim to high place except that he was a Papist.
The last person whom a government having in view the general interests
of the empire would have sent to Dublin as Deputy was Tyrconnel. His
brutal manners made him unfit to represent the majesty of the crown. The
feebleness of his understanding and the violence of his temper made him
unfit to conduct grave business of state. The deadly animosity which he
felt towards the possessors of the greater part of the soil of Ireland
made him especially unfit to rule that kingdom. But the intemperance of
his bigotry was thought amply to atone for the intemperance of all his
other passions; and, in consideration of the hatred which he bore to the
reformed faith, he was suffered to indulge without restraint his hatred
of the English name. This, then, was the real meaning of his Majesty's
respect for the rights of conscience. He wished his Parliament to remove
all the disabilities which had been imposed on Papists, merely in
order that he might himself impose disabilities equally galling on
Protestants. It was plain that, under such a prince, apostasy was the
only road to greatness. It was a road, however, which few ventured to
take. For the spirit of the nation was thoroughly roused; and every
renegade had to endure such an amount of public scorn and detestation,
as cannot be altogether unfelt even by the most callous natures.
It is true that several remarkable conversions had recently taken place;
but they were such as did little credit to the Church of Rome. Two
men of high rank had joined her communion; Henry Mordaunt, Earl of
Peterborough, and James Cecil, Earl of Salisbury. But Peterborough, who
had been an active soldier, courtier, and negotiator, was now broken
down by years and infirmities; and those who saw him totter about the
galleries of Whitehall, leaning on a stick and swathed up in flannels
and plasters, comforted themselves for his defection by remarking that
he had not changed his religion till he had outlived his faculties.
[226] Salisbury was foolish to a proverb. His figure was so bloated
by sensual indulgence as to be almost incapable of moving, and this
sluggish body was the abode of an equally sluggish mind. He was
represented in popular lampoons as a man made to be duped, as a man who
had hitherto been the prey of gamesters, and who might as well be the
prey of friars. A pasquinade, which, about the time of Rochester's
retirement, was fixed on the door of Salisbury House in the Strand,
described in coarse terms the horror with which the wise Robert Cecil,
if he could rise from his grave, would see to what a creature his
honours had descended. [227]
These were the highest in station among the proselytes of James. There
were other renegades of a very different kind, needy men of parts who
were destitute of principle and of all sense of personal dignity. There
is reason to believe that among these was William Wycherley, the
most licentious and hardhearted writer of a singularly licentious and
hardhearted school. [228] It is certain that Matthew Tindal, who, at a
later period, acquired great notoriety by writing against Christianity,
was at this time received into the bosom of the infallible Church, a
fact which, as may easily be supposed, the divines with whom he
was subsequently engaged in controversy did not suffer to sink into
oblivion. [229] A still more infamous apostate was Joseph Haines, whose
name is now almost forgotten, but who was well known in his own time as
an adventurer of versatile parts, sharper, coiner, false witness, sham
bail, dancing master, buffoon, poet, comedian. Some of his prologues and
epilogues were much admired by his contemporaries; and his merit as an
actor was universally acknowledged. This man professed himself a Roman
Catholic, and went to Italy in the retinue of Castelmaine, but was soon
dismissed for misconduct. If any credit is due to a tradition which was
long preserved in the green room, Haines had the impudence to affirm
that the Virgin Mary had appeared to him and called him to repentance.
After the Revolution, he attempted to make his peace with the town by a
penance more scandalous than his offence. One night, before he acted in
a farce, he appeared on the stage in a white sheet with a torch in his
hand, and recited some profane and indecent doggerel, which he called
his recantation. [230]
With the name of Haines was joined, in many libels the name of a more
illustrious renegade, John Dryden. Dryden was now approaching the
decline of life. After many successes and many failures, he had at
length attained, by general consent, the first place among living
English poets. His claims on the gratitude of James were superior to
those of any man of letters in the kingdom. But James cared little for
verses and much for money. From the day of his accession he set himself
to make small economical reforms, such as bring on a government the
reproach of meanness without producing any perceptible relief to the
finances. One of the victims of his injudicious parsimony was the Poet
Laureate. Orders were given that, in the new patent which the demise of
the crown made necessary, the annual butt of sack, originally granted to
Jonson, and continued to Jonson's successors, should be omitted. [231]
This was the only notice which the King, during the first year of his
reign, deigned to bestow on the mighty satirist who, in the very crisis
of the great struggle of the Exclusion Bill, had spread terror through
the Whig ranks. Dryden was poor and impatient of poverty. He knew little
and cared little about religion. If any sentiment was deeply fixed
in him, that sentiment was an aversion to priests of all persuasions,
Levites, Augurs, Muftis, Roman Catholic divines, Presbyterian divines,
divines of the Church of England. He was not naturally a man of high
spirit; and his pursuits had been by no means such as were likely to
give elevation or delicacy to his mind. He had, during many years,
earned his daily bread by pandaring to the vicious taste of the pit,
and by grossly flattering rich and noble patrons. Selfrespect and a fine
sense of the becoming were not to be expected from one who had led a
life of mendicancy and adulation. Finding that, if he continued to call
himself a Protestant, his services would be overlooked, he declared
himself a Papist. The King's parsimony instantly relaxed. Dryden was
gratified with a pension of a hundred pounds a year, and was employed to
defend his new religion both in prose and verse.
Two eminent men, Samuel Johnson and Walter Scott, have done their best
to persuade themselves and others that this memorable conversion
was sincere. It was natural that they should be desirous to remove
a disgraceful stain from the memory of one whose genius they justly
admired, and with whose political feelings they strongly sympathized;
but the impartial historian must with regret pronounce a very different
judgment. There will always be a strong presumption against the
sincerity of a conversion by which the convert is directly a gainer. In
the case of Dryden there is nothing to countervail this presumption.
His theological writings abundantly prove that he had never sought with
diligence and anxiety to learn the truth, and that his knowledge both
of the Church which he quitted and of the Church which he entered was of
the most superficial kind. Nor was his subsequent conduct that of a
man whom a strong sense of duty had constrained to take a step of awful
importance. Had he been such a man, the same conviction which had led
him to join the Church of Rome would surely have prevented him from
violating grossly and habitually rules which that Church, in common with
every other Christian society, recognises as binding. There would
have been a marked distinction between his earlier and his later
compositions. He would have looked back with remorse on a literary
life of near thirty years, during which his rare powers of diction
and versification had been systematically employed in spreading moral
corruption. Not a line tending to make virtue contemptible, or to
inflame licentious desire, would thenceforward have proceeded from his
pen. The truth unhappily is that the dramas which he wrote after his
pretended conversion are in no respect less impure or profane than those
of his youth. Even when he professed to translate he constantly wandered
from his originals in search of images which, if he had found them in
his originals, he ought to have shunned. What was bad became worse in
his versions. What was innocent contracted a taint from passing
through his mind. He made the grossest satires of Juvenal more gross,
interpolated loose descriptions in the tales of Boccaccio, and polluted
the sweet and limpid poetry of the Georgics with filth which would have
moved the loathing of Virgil.
The help of Dryden was welcome to those Roman Catholic divines who were
painfully sustaining a conflict against all that was most illustrious in
the Established Church. They could not disguise from themselves the fact
that their style, disfigured with foreign idioms which had been picked
up at Rome and Douay, appeared to little advantage when compared with
the eloquence of Tillotson and Sherlock. It seemed that it was no light
thing to have secured the cooperation of the greatest living master of
the English language. The first service which he was required to perform
in return for his pension was to defend his Church in prose against
Stillingfleet. But the art of saying things well is useless to a man who
has nothing to say; and this was Dryden's case. He soon found himself
unequally paired with an antagonist whose whole life had been one long
training for controversy. The veteran gladiator disarmed the novice,
inflicted a few contemptuous scratches, and turned away to encounter
more formidable combatants. Dryden then betook himself to a weapon at
which he was not likely to find his match. He retired for a time
from the bustle of coffeehouses and theatres to a quiet retreat in
Huntingdonshire, and there composed, with unwonted care and labour, his
celebrated poem on the points in dispute between the Churches of Rome
and England. The Church of Rome he represented under the similitude of a
milkwhite hind, ever in peril of death, yet fated not to die. The beasts
of the field were bent on her destruction. The quaking hare, indeed,
observed a timorous neutrality: but the Socinian fox, the Presbyterian
wolf, the Independent bear, the Anabaptist boar, glared fiercely at
the spotless creature. Yet she could venture to drink with them at the
common watering place under the protection of her friend, the kingly
lion. The Church of England was typified by the panther, spotted indeed,
but beautiful, too beautiful for a beast of prey. The hind and the
panther, equally hated by the ferocious population of the forest,
conferred apart on their common danger. They then proceeded to discuss
the points on which they differed, and, while wagging their tails and
licking their jaws, held a long dialogue touching the real presence, the
authority of Popes and Councils, the penal laws, the Test Act,
Oates's perjuries, Butler's unrequited services to the Cavalier party,
Stillingfleet's pamphlets, and Burnet's broad shoulders and fortunate
matrimonial speculations.
The absurdity of this plan is obvious. In truth the allegory could not
be preserved unbroken through ten lines together. No art of execution
could redeem the faults of such a design. Yet the Fable of the Hind
and Panther is undoubtedly the most valuable addition which was made
to English literature during the short and troubled reign of James the
Second. In none of Dryden's works can be found passages more pathetic
and magnificent, greater ductility and energy of language, or a more
pleasing and various music.
The poem appeared with every advantage which royal patronage could give.
A superb edition was printed for Scotland at the Roman Catholic press
established in Holyrood House. But men were in no humour to be charmed
by the transparent style and melodious numbers of the apostate. The
disgust excited by his venality, the alarm excited by the policy of
which he was the eulogist, were not to be sung to sleep. The just
indignation of the public was inflamed by many who were smarting from
his ridicule, and by many who were envious of his renown. In spite of
all the restraints under which the press lay, attacks on his life and
writings appeared daily. Sometimes he was Bayes, sometimes Poet Squab.
He was reminded that in his youth he had paid to the House of Cromwell
the same servile court which he was now paying to the House of Stuart.
One set of his assailants maliciously reprinted the sarcastic verses
which he had written against Popery in days when he could have got
nothing by being a Papist. Of the many satirical pieces which appeared
on this occasion, the most successful was the joint work of two young
men who had lately completed their studies at Cambridge, and had been
welcomed as promising novices in the literary coffee-houses of London,
Charles Montague and Matthew Prior. Montague was of noble descent: the
origin of Prior was so obscure that no biographer has been able to trace
it: but both the adventurers were poor and aspiring; both had keen
and vigorous minds; both afterwards climbed high; both united in a
remarkable degree the love of letters with skill in those departments of
business for which men of letters generally have a strong distaste. Of
the fifty poets whose lives Johnson has written, Montague and Prior were
the only two who were distinguished by an intimate knowledge of trade
and finance. Soon their paths diverged widely. Their early friendship
was dissolved. One of them became the chief of the Whig party, and was
impeached by the Tories. The other was entrusted with all the mysteries
of Tory diplomacy, and was long kept close prisoner by the Whigs. At
length, after many eventful years, the associates, so long parted, were
reunited in Westminster Abbey.
Whoever has read the tale of the Hind and Panther with attention must
have perceived that, while that work was in progress, a great alteration
took place in the views of those who used Dryden as their interpreter.
At first the Church of England is mentioned with tenderness and respect,
and is exhorted to ally herself with the Roman Catholics against the
Puritan sects: but at the close of the poem, and in the preface, which
was written after the poem had been finished, the Protestant Dissenters
are invited to make common cause with the Roman Catholics against the
Church of England.
This change in the language of the court poet was indicative of a great
change in the policy of the court. The original purpose of James
had been to obtain for the Church of which he was a member, not only
complete immunity from all penalties and from all civil disabilities,
but also an ample share of ecclesiastical and academical endowments,
and at the same time to enforce with rigour the laws against the Puritan
sects. All the special dispensations which he had granted had been
granted to Roman Catholics. All the laws which bore hardest on the
Presbyterians, Independents, and Baptists, had been for a time severely
executed by him. While Hales commanded a regiment, while Powis sate at
the Council board, while Massey held a deanery, while breviaries and
mass books were printed at Oxford under a royal license, while the host
was publicly exposed in London under the protection of the pikes and
muskets of the footguards, while friars and monks walked the streets of
London in their robes, Baxter was in gaol; Howe was in exile; the Five
Mile Act and the Conventicle Act were in full vigour; Puritan writers
were compelled to resort to foreign or to secret presses; Puritan
congregations could meet only by night or in waste places, and Puritan
ministers were forced to preach in the garb of colliers or of sailors.
In Scotland the King, while he spared no exertion to extort from the
Estates full relief for Roman Catholics, had demanded and obtained
new statutes of unprecedented severity against the Presbyterians. His
conduct to the exiled Huguenots had not less clearly indicated his
feelings. We have seen that, when the public munificence had placed
in his hands a large sum for the relief of those unhappy men, he, in
violation of every law of hospitality and good faith, required them to
renounce the Calvinistic ritual to which they were strongly attached,
and to conform to the Church of England, before he would dole out to
them any portion of the alms which had been entrusted to his care.
Such had been his policy as long as he could cherish, any hope that the
Church of England would consent to share ascendency with the Church of
Rome. That hope at one time amounted to confidence. The enthusiasm with
which the Tories had hailed his accession, the elections, the dutiful
language and ample grants of his Parliament, the suppression of the
Western insurrection, the complete prostration of the party which had
attempted to exclude him from the crown, elated him beyond the bounds of
reason. He felt an assurance that every obstacle would give way before
his power and his resolution. His Parliament withstood him. He tried the
effects of frowns and menaces. Frowns and menaces failed. He tried the
effect of prorogation. From the day of the prorogation the opposition
to his designs had been growing stronger and stronger. It seemed clear
that, if he effected his purpose, he must effect it in defiance of
that great party which had given such signal proofs of fidelity to his
office, to his family, and to his person. The whole Anglican priesthood,
the whole Cavalier gentry, were against him. In vain had he, by virtue
of his ecclesiastical supremacy, enjoined the clergy to abstain from
discussing controverted points. Every parish in the nation was warned
every Sunday against the errors of Rome; and these warnings were only
the more effective, because they were accompanied by professions of
reverence for the Sovereign, and of a determination to endure with
patience whatever it might be his pleasure to inflict. The royalist
knights and esquires who, through forty-five years of war and faction,
had stood so manfully by the throne, now expressed, in no measured
phrase, their resolution to stand as manfully by the Church. Dull as was
the intellect of James, despotic as was his temper, he felt that he
must change his course. He could not safely venture to outrage all
his Protestant subjects at once. If he could bring himself to make
concessions to the party which predominated in both Houses, if he could
bring himself to leave to the established religion all its dignities,
emoluments, and privileges unimpaired, he might still break up
Presbyterian meetings, and fill the gaols with Baptist preachers. But if
he was determined to plunder the hierarchy, he must make up his mind to
forego the luxury of persecuting the Dissenters. If he was henceforward
to be at feud with his old friends, he must make a truce with his old
enemies. He could overpower the Anglican Church only by forming against
her an extensive coalition, including sects which, though they differed
in doctrine and government far more widely from each other than from
her, might yet be induced, by their common jealousy of her greatness,
and by their common dread of her intolerance, to suspend their
animosities till she was no longer able to oppress them.
This plan seemed to him to have one strong recommendation. If he could
only succeed in conciliating the Protestant Nonconformists he might
flatter himself that he was secure against all chance of rebellion.
According to the Anglican divines, no subject could by any provocation
be justified in withstanding the Lord's anointed by force. The theory of
the Puritan sectaries was very different. Those sectaries had no scruple
about smiting tyrants with the sword of Gideon. Many of them did not
shrink from using the dagger of Ehud. They were probably even now
meditating another Western insurrection, or another Rye House Plot.
James, therefore, conceived that he might safely persecute the Church if
he could only gain the Dissenters. The party whose principles afforded
him no guarantee would be attached to him by interest. The party
whose interests he attacked would be restrained from insurrection by
principle.
Influenced by such considerations as these, James, from the time at
which he parted in anger with his Parliament, began to meditate a
general league of all Nonconformists, Catholic and Protestant, against
the established religion. So early as Christmas 1685, the agents of the
United Provinces informed the States General that the plan of a general
toleration had been arranged and would soon be disclosed. [232] The
reports which had reached the Dutch embassy proved to be premature.
The separatists appear, however, to have been treated with more lenity
during the year 1686 than during the year 1685. But it was only by slow
degrees and after many struggles that the King could prevail on himself
to form an alliance with all that he most abhorred. He had to overcome
an animosity, not slight or capricious, not of recent origin or hasty
growth, but hereditary in his line, strengthened by great wrongs
inflicted and suffered through a hundred and twenty eventful years, and
intertwined with all his feelings, religious, political, domestic, and
personal. Four generations of Stuarts had waged a war to the death with
four generations of Puritans; and, through that long war, there had been
no Stuart who had hated the Puritans so much, or who had been so much
hated by them, as himself. They had tried to blast his honour and
to exclude him from his birthright; they had called him incendiary,
cutthroat, poisoner; they had driven him from the Admiralty and the
Privy Council; they had repeatedly chased him into banishment; they
had plotted his assassination; they had risen against him in arms by
thousands. He had avenged himself on them by havoc such as England had
never before seen. Their heads and quarters were still rotting on poles
in all the market places of Somersetshire and Dorsetshire. Aged women
held in high honour among the sectaries for piety and charity had, for
offences which no good prince would have thought deserving even of a
severe reprimand, been beheaded and burned alive. Such had been, even
in England, the relations between the King and the Puritans; and in
Scotland the tyranny of the King and the fury of the Puritans had been
such as Englishmen could hardly conceive. To forget an enmity so long
and so deadly was no light task for a nature singularly harsh and
implacable.
The conflict in the royal mind did not escape the eye of Barillon. At
the end of January, 1687, he sent a remarkable letter to Versailles. The
King,--such was the substance of this document,--had almost convinced
himself that he could not obtain entire liberty for Roman Catholics
and yet maintain the laws against Protestant Dissenters. He leaned,
therefore, to the plan of a general indulgence; but at heart he would
be far better pleased if he could, even now, divide his protection and
favour between the Church of Rome and the Church of England, to the
exclusion of all other religious persuasions. [233]
A very few days after this despatch had been written, James made his
first hesitating and ungracious advances towards the Puritans. He had
determined to begin with Scotland, where his power to dispense with
acts of parliament had been admitted by the obsequious Estates. On
the twelfth of February, accordingly, was published at Edinburgh a
proclamation granting relief to scrupulous consciences. [234] This
proclamation fully proves the correctness of Barillon's judgment. Even
in the very act of making concessions to the Presbyterians, James could
not conceal the loathing with which he regarded them. The toleration
given to the Catholics was complete. The Quakers had little reason
to complain. But the indulgence vouchsafed to the Presbyterians, who
constituted the great body of the Scottish people, was clogged by
conditions which made it almost worthless. For the old test, which
excluded Catholics and Presbyterians alike from office, was substituted
a new test, which admitted the Catholics, but excluded most of the
Presbyterians. The Catholics were allowed to build chapels, and even
to carry the host in procession anywhere except in the high streets of
royal burghs: the Quakers were suffered to assemble in public edifices:
but the Presbyterians were interdicted from worshipping God anywhere but
in private dwellings: they were not to presume to build meeting houses:
they were not even to use a barn or an outhouse for religious exercises:
and it was distinctly notified to them that, if they dared to hold
conventicles in the open air, the law, which denounced death against
both preachers and hearers, should be enforced without mercy. Any
Catholic priest might say mass: any Quaker might harangue his brethren:
but the Privy Council was directed to see that no Presbyterian minister
presumed to preach without a special license from the government. Every
line of this instrument, and of the letters by which it was accompanied,
shows how much it cost the King to relax in the smallest degree the
rigour with which he had ever treated the old enemies of his house.
[235]
There is reason, indeed, to believe that, when he published this
proclamation, he had by no means fully made up his mind to a coalition
with the Puritans, and that his object was to grant just so much favour
to them as might suffice to frighten the Churchmen into submission.
He therefore waited a month, in order to see what effect the edict put
forth at Edinburgh would produce in England. That month he employed
assiduously, by Petre's advice, in what was called closeting. London was
very full. It was expected that the Parliament would shortly meet for
the dispatch of business; and many members were in town. The King set
himself to canvass them man by man. He flattered himself that zealous
Tories,--and of such, with few exceptions, the House of Commons
consisted,--would find it difficult to resist his earnest request,
addressed to them, not collectively, but separately, not from the
throne, but in the familiarity of conversation. The members, therefore,
who came to pay their duty at Whitehall were taken aside, and honoured
with long private interviews. The King pressed them, as they were loyal
gentlemen, to gratify him in the one thing on which his heart was fixed.
The question, he said, touched his personal honour. The laws enacted in
the late reign by factious Parliaments against the Roman Catholics had
really been aimed at himself. Those laws had put a stigma on him, had
driven him from the Admiralty, had driven him from the Council Board. He
had a right to expect that in the repeal of those laws all who loved
and reverenced him would concur. When he found his hearers obdurate
to exhortation, he resorted to intimidation and corruption. Those who
refused to pleasure him in this matter were plainly told that they must
not expect any mark of his favour. Penurious as he was, he opened and
distributed his hoards.
Several of those who had been invited to confer
with him left his bedchamber carrying with them money received from the
royal hand. The Judges, who were at this time on their spring circuits,
were directed by the King to see those members who remained in the
country, and to ascertain the intentions of each. The result of this
investigation was, that a great majority of the House of Commons seemed
fully determined to oppose the measures of the court. [236] Among those
whose firmness excited general admiration was Arthur Herbert, brother
of the Chief Justice, member for Dover, Master of the Robes, and Rear
Admiral of England. Arthur Herbert was much loved by the sailors,
and was reputed one of the best of the aristocratical class of naval
officers. It had been generally supposed that he would readily comply
with the royal wishes: for he was heedless of religion; he was fond of
pleasure and expense; he had no private estate; his places brought him
in four thousand pounds a year; and he had long been reckoned among
the most devoted personal adherents of James. When, however, the Rear
Admiral was closeted, and required to promise that he would vote for the
repeal of the Test Act, his answer was, that his honour and conscience
would not permit him to give any such pledge. "Nobody doubts your
honour," said the King; "but a man who lives as you do ought not to talk
about his conscience. " To this reproach, a reproach which came with a
bad grace from the lover of Catharine Sedley, Herbert manfully replied,
"I have my faults, sir: but I could name people who talk much more about
conscience than I am in the habit of doing, and yet lead lives as loose
as mine. " He was dismissed from all his places; and the account of what
he had disbursed and received as Master of the Robes was scrutinised
with great and, as he complained, with unjust severity. [237]
It was now evident that all hope of an alliance between the Churches of
England and of Rome, for the purpose of sharing offices and emoluments,
and of crushing the Puritan sects, must be abandoned. Nothing remained
but to try a coalition between the Church of Rome and the Puritan sects
against the Church of England.
On the eighteenth of March the King informed the Privy Council that he
had determined to prorogue the Parliament till the end of November, and
to grant, by his own authority, entire liberty of conscience to all
his subjects. [238] On the fourth of April appeared the memorable
Declaration of Indulgence.
In this Declaration the King avowed that it was his earnest wish to see
his people members of that Church to which he himself belonged. But,
since that could not be, he announced his intention to protect them
in the free exercise of their religion. He repeated all those phrases
which, eight years before, when he was himself an oppressed man, had
been familiar to his lips, but which he had ceased to use from the day
on which a turn of fortune had put it into his power to be an oppressor.
He had long been convinced, he said, that conscience was not to be
forced, that persecution was unfavourable to population and to trade,
and that it never attained the ends which persecutors had in view. He
repeated his promise, already often repeated and often violated, that
he would protect the Established Church in the enjoyment of her legal
rights. He then proceeded to annul, by his own sole authority, a long
series of statutes. He suspended all penal laws against all classes
of Nonconformists. He authorised both Roman Catholics and Protestant
Dissenters to perform their worship publicly. He forbade his subjects,
on pain of his highest displeasure, to molest any religious assembly.
He also abrogated all those acts which imposed any religious test as a
qualification for any civil or military office. [239]
That the Declaration of Indulgence was unconstitutional is a point on
which both the great English parties have always been entirely agreed.
Every person capable of reasoning on a political question must perceive
that a monarch who is competent to issue such a declaration is nothing
less than an absolute monarch. Nor is it possible to urge in defence
of this act of James those pleas by which many arbitrary acts of the
Stuarts have been vindicated or excused. It cannot be said that
he mistook the bounds of his prerogative because they had not been
accurately ascertained. For the truth is that he trespassed with a
recent landmark full in his view. Fifteen years before that time, a
Declaration of Indulgence had been put forth by his brother with
the advice of the Cabal. That Declaration, when compared with the
Declaration of James, might be called modest and cautious. The
Declaration of Charles dispensed only with penal laws. The Declaration
of James dispensed also with all religious tests. The Declaration of
Charles permitted the Roman Catholics to celebrate their worship in
private dwellings only. Under the Declaration of James they might build
and decorate temples, and even walk in procession along Fleet Street
with crosses, images, and censers. Yet the Declaration of Charles had
been pronounced illegal in the most formal manner. The Commons had
resolved that the King had no power to dispense with statutes in matters
ecclesiastical. Charles had ordered the obnoxious instrument to be
cancelled in his presence, had torn off the seal with his own hand, and
had, both by message under his sign manual, and with his own lips from
his throne in full Parliament, distinctly promised the two Houses that
the step which had given so much offence should never be drawn into
precedent. The two Houses had then, without one dissentient voice,
joined in thanking him for this compliance with their wishes. No
constitutional question had ever been decided more deliberately, more
clearly, or with more harmonious consent.
The defenders of James have frequently pleaded in his excuse the
judgment of the Court of King's Bench, on the information collusively
laid against Sir Edward Hales: but the plea is of no value. That
judgment James had notoriously obtained by solicitation, by threats,
by dismissing scrupulous magistrates, and by placing on the bench
other magistrates more courtly. And yet that judgment, though generally
regarded by the bar and by the nation as unconstitutional, went only
to this extent, that the Sovereign might, for special reasons of state,
grant to individuals by name exemptions from disabling statutes. That he
could by one sweeping edict authorise all his subjects to disobey whole
volumes of laws, no tribunal had ventured, in the face of the solemn
parliamentary decision of 1673, to affirm.
Such, however, was the position of parties that James's Declaration of
Indulgence, though the most audacious of all the attacks made by the
Stuarts on public freedom, was well calculated to please that very
portion of the community by which all the other attacks of the Stuarts
on public freedom had been most strenuously resisted. It could
scarcely be hoped that the Protestant Nonconformist, separated from
his countrymen by a harsh code harshly enforced, would be inclined to
dispute the validity of a decree which relieved him from intolerable
grievances. A cool and philosophical observer would undoubtedly have
pronounced that all the evil arising from all the intolerant laws which
Parliaments had framed was not to be compared to the evil which would be
produced by a transfer of the legislative power from the Parliament to
the Sovereign. But such coolness and philosophy are not to be expected
from men who are smarting under present pain, and who are tempted by the
offer of immediate ease. A Puritan divine, could not indeed deny that
the dispensing power now claimed by the crown was inconsistent with
the fundamental principles of the constitution. But he might perhaps
be excused if he asked, What was the constitution to him? The Act of
Uniformity had ejected him, in spite of royal promises, from a benefice
which was his freehold, and had reduced him to beggary and dependence.
The Five Mile Act had banished him from his dwelling, from his
relations, from his friends, from almost all places of public resort.
Under the Conventicle Act his goods had been distrained; and he had
been flung into one noisome gaol after another among highwaymen and
housebreakers. Out of prison he had constantly had the officers of
justice on his track; he had been forced to pay hushmoney to informers;
he had stolen, in ignominious disguises, through windows and trapdoors,
to meet his flock, and had, while pouring the baptismal water, or
distributing the eucharistic bread, been anxiously listening for the
signal that the tipstaves were approaching. Was it not mockery to
call on a man thus plundered and oppressed to suffer martyrdom for the
property and liberty of his plunderers and oppressors? The Declaration,
despotic as it might seem to his prosperous neighbours, brought
deliverance to him. He was called upon to make his choice, not between
freedom and slavery, but between two yokes; and he might not unnaturally
think the yoke of the King lighter than that of the Church.
While thoughts like these were working in the minds of many Dissenters,
the Anglican party was in amazement and terror. This new turn in affairs
was indeed alarming. The House of Stuart leagued with republican and
regicide sects against the old Cavaliers of England; Popery leagued with
Puritanism against an ecclesiastical system with which the Puritans had
no quarrel, except that it had retained too much that was Popish, these
were portents which confounded all the calculations of statesmen. The
Church was then to be attacked at once on every side and the attack was
to be under the direction of him who, by her constitution, was her head.
She might well be struck with surprise and dismay. And mingled with
surprise and dismay came other bitter feelings; resentment against
the perjured Prince whom she had served too well, and remorse for the
cruelties in which he had been her accomplice, and for which he was now,
as it seemed, about to be her punisher. Her chastisement was just. She
reaped that which she had sown. After the Restoration, when her power
was at the height, she had breathed nothing hut vengeance. She had
encouraged, urged, almost compelled the Stuarts to requite with
perfidious ingratitude the recent services of the Presbyterians. Had
she, in that season of her prosperity, pleaded, as became her, for her
enemies, she might now, in her distress, have found them her friends.
Perhaps it was not yet too late. Perhaps she might still be able to turn
the tactics of her faithless oppressor against himself. There was
among the Anglican clergy a moderate party which had always felt kindly
towards the Protestant Dissenters. That party was not large; but the
abilities, acquirements, and virtues of those who belonged to it made
it respectable. It had been regarded with little favour by the highest
ecclesiastical dignitaries, and had been mercilessly reviled by bigots
of the school of Laud but, from the day on which the Declaration of
Indulgence appeared to the day on which the power of James ceased to
inspire terror, the whole Church seemed to be animated by the spirit,
and guided by the counsels, of the calumniated Latitudinarians.
Then followed an auction, the strangest that history has recorded. On
one side the King, on the other the Church, began to bid eagerly against
each other for the favour of those whom tip to that time King and Church
had combined to oppress. The Protestant Dissenters, who, a few months
before, had been a despised and proscribed class, now held the balance
of power. The harshness with which they had been treated was universally
condemned. The court tried to throw all the blame on the hierarchy.
The hierarchy flung it back on the court. The King declared that he had
unwillingly persecuted the separatists only because his affairs had been
in such a state that he could not venture to disoblige the established
clergy. The established clergy protested that they had borne a part
in severity uncongenial to their feelings only from deference to the
authority of the King. The King got together a collection of stories
about rectors and vicars who had by threats of prosecution wrung
money out of Protestant Dissenters. He talked on this subject much and
publicly, threatened to institute an inquiry which would exhibit the
parsons in their true character to the whole world, and actually issued
several commissions empowering agents on whom he thought that he could
depend to ascertain the amount of the sums extorted in different parts
of the country by professors of the dominant religion from sectaries.
The advocates of the Church, on the other hand, cited instances of
honest parish priests who had been reprimanded and menaced by the court
for recommending toleration in the pulpit, and for refusing to spy out
and hunt down little congregations of Nonconformists. The King asserted
that some of the Churchmen whom he had closeted had offered to make
large concessions to the Catholics, on condition that the persecution
of the Puritans might go on. The accused Churchmen vehemently denied the
truth of this charge; and alleged that, if they would have complied
with what he demanded for his own religion, he would most gladly
have suffered them to indemnify themselves by harassing and pillaging
Protestant Dissenters. [240]
The court had changed its face. The scarf and cassock could hardly
appear there without calling forth sneers and malicious whispers. Maids
of honour forbore to giggle, and Lords of the Bedchamber bowed low, when
the Puritanical visage and the Puritanical garb, so long the favourite
subjects of mockery in fashionable circles, were seen in the galleries.
Taunton, which had been during two generations the stronghold of the
Roundhead party in the West, which had twice resolutely repelled the
armies of Charles the First, which had risen as one man to support
Monmouth, and which had been turned into a shambles by Kirke and
Jeffreys, seemed to have suddenly succeeded to the place which Oxford
had once occupied in the royal favour. [241] The King constrained
himself to show even fawning courtesy to eminent Dissenters. To some
he offered money, to some municipal honours, to some pardons for their
relations and friends who, having been implicated in the Rye House Plot,
or having joined the standard of Monmouth, were now wandering on the
Continent, or toiling among the sugar canes of Barbadoes. He affected
even to sympathize with the kindness which the English Puritans felt for
their foreign brethren. A second and a third proclamation were published
at Edinburgh, which greatly extended the nugatory toleration granted
to the Presbyterians by the edict of February. [242] The banished
Huguenots, on whom the King had frowned during many months, and whom he
had defrauded of the alms contributed by the nation, were now relieved
and caressed. An Order in Council was issued, appealing again in their
behalf to the public liberality. The rule which required them to qualify
themselves for the receipt of charity, by conforming to the Anglican
worship, seems to have been at this time silently abrogated; and the
defenders of the King's policy had the effrontery to affirm that this
rule, which, as we know from the best evidence, was really devised by
himself in concert with Barillon, had been adopted at the instance of
the prelates of the Established Church. [243]
While the King was thus courting his old adversaries, the friends of
the Church were not less active. Of the acrimony and scorn with which
prelates and priests had, since the Restoration, been in the habit of
treating the sectaries scarcely a trace was discernible. Those who had
lately been designated as schismatics and fanatics were now dear fellow
Protestants, weak brethren it might be, but still brethren, whose
scruples were entitled to tender regard. If they would but be true at
this crisis to the cause of the English constitution and of the reformed
religion, their generosity should be speedily and largely rewarded. They
should have, instead of an indulgence which was of no legal validity, a
real indulgence, secured by Act of Parliament. Nay, many Churchmen, who
had hitherto been distinguished by their inflexible attachment to every
gesture and every word prescribed in the Book of Common Prayer, now
declared themselves favourable, not only to toleration, but even to
comprehension. The dispute, they said, about surplices and attitudes,
had too long divided those who were agreed as to the essentials of
religion. When the struggle for life and death against the common enemy
was over, it would be found that the Anglican clergy would be ready to
make every fair concession. If the Dissenters would demand only what was
reasonable, not only civil but ecclesiastical dignities would be open
to them; and Baxter and Howe would be able, without any stain on their
honour or their conscience, to sit on the episcopal bench.
Of the numerous pamphlets in which the cause of the Court and the cause
of the Church were at this time eagerly and anxiously pleaded before the
Puritan, now, by a strange turn of fortune, the arbiter of the fate
of his persecutors, one only is still remembered, the Letter to a
Dissenter. In this masterly little tract, all the arguments which could
convince a Nonconformist that it was his duty and his interest to prefer
an alliance with the Church to an alliance with the Court were condensed
into the smallest compass, arranged in the most perspicuous order,
illustrated with lively wit, and enforced by an eloquence earnest
indeed, yet never in its utmost vehemence transgressing the limits
of exact good sense and good breeding. The effect of this paper was
immense; for, as it was only a single sheet, more than twenty thousand
copies were circulated by the post; and there was no corner of the
kingdom in which the effect was not felt. Twenty-four answers were
published, but the town pronounced that they were all bad, and that
Lestrange's was the worst of the twenty-four. [244] The government was
greatly irritated, and spared no pains to discover the author of the
Letter: but it was found impossible to procure legal evidence against
him. Some imagined that they recognised the sentiments and diction of
Temple. [245] But in truth that amplitude and acuteness of intellect,
that vivacity of fancy, that terse and energetic style, that placid
dignity, half courtly half philosophical, which the utmost excitement
of conflict could not for a moment derange, belonged to Halifax, and to
Halifax alone.
The Dissenters wavered; nor is it any reproach to them that they did so.
They were suffering, and the King had given them relief. Some eminent
pastors had emerged from confinement; others had ventured to return
from exile. Congregations, which had hitherto met only by stealth and in
darkness, now assembled at noonday, and sang psalms aloud in the hearing
of magistrates, churchwardens, and constables. Modest buildings for the
worship of God after the Puritan fashion began to rise all over England.
An observant traveller will still remark the date of 1687 on some of the
oldest meeting houses. Nevertheless the offers of the Church were, to
a prudent Dissenter, far more attractive than those of the King. The
Declaration was, in the eye of the law, a nullity. It suspended the
penal statutes against nonconformity only for so long a time as the
fundamental principles of the constitution and the rightful authority
of the legislature should remain suspended. What was the value of
privileges which must be held by a tenure at once so ignominious and
so insecure? There might soon be a demise of the crown. A sovereign
attached to the established religion might sit on the throne. A
Parliament composed of Churchmen might be assembled. How deplorable
would then be the situation of Dissenters who had been in league with
Jesuits against the constitution. The Church offered an indulgence very
different from that granted by James, an indulgence as valid and as
sacred as the Great Charter. Both the contending parties promised
religious liberty to the separatist: but one party required him to
purchase it by sacrificing civil liberty; the other party invited him to
enjoy civil and religious liberty together.
For these reasons, even if it could be believed that the Court was
sincere, a Dissenter might reasonably have determined to cast in his lot
with the Church. But what guarantee was there for the sincerity of the
Court? All men knew what the conduct of James had been tip to that
very time. It was not impossible, indeed, that a persecutor might be
convinced by argument and by experience of the advantages of toleration.
But James did not pretend to have been recently convinced. On the
contrary, he omitted no opportunity of protesting that he had, during
many years, been, on principle, adverse to all intolerance. Yet, within
a few months, he had persecuted men, women, young girls, to the death
for their religion. Had he been acting against light and against the
convictions of his conscience then? Or was he uttering a deliberate
falsehood now? From this dilemma there was no escape; and either of the
two suppositions was fatal to the King's character for honesty. It was
notorious also that he had been completely subjugated by the Jesuits.
Only a few days before the publication of the Indulgence, that Order had
been honoured, in spite of the well known wishes of the Holy See, with
a new mark of his confidence and approbation. His confessor, Father
Mansuete, a Franciscan, whose mild temper and irreproachable life
commanded general respect, but who had long been hated by Tyrconnel
and Petre, had been discarded. The vacant place had been filled by an
Englishman named Warner, who had apostatized from the religion of his
country and had turned Jesuit. To the moderate Roman Catholics and to
the Nuncio this change was far from agreeable. By every Protestant it
was regarded as a proof that the dominion of the Jesuits over the royal
mind was absolute. [246] Whatever praises those fathers might justly
claim, flattery itself could not ascribe to them either wide liberality
or strict veracity. That they had never scrupled, when the interest of
their Order was at stake, to call in the aid of the civil sword, or to
violate the laws of truth and of good faith, had been proclaimed to
the world, not only by Protestant accusers, but by men whose virtue and
genius were the glory of the Church of Rome. It was incredible that
a devoted disciple of the Jesuits should be on principle zealous for
freedom of conscience: but it was neither incredible nor improbable that
he might think himself justified in disguising his real sentiments, in
order to render a service to his religion. It was certain that the King
at heart preferred the Churchmen to the Puritans. It was certain that,
while he had any hope of gaining the Churchmen, he had never shown the
smallest kindness to the Puritans. Could it then be doubted that, if
the Churchmen would even now comply with his wishes, he would willingly
sacrifice the Puritans? His word, repeatedly pledged, had not restrained
him from invading the legal rights of that clergy which had given such
signal proofs of affection and fidelity to his house. What security then
could his word afford to sects divided from him by the recollection of a
thousand inexpiable wounds inflicted and endured?
When the first agitation produced by the publication of the Indulgence
had subsided, it appeared that a breach had taken place in the Puritan
party. The minority, headed by a few busy men whose judgment was
defective or was biassed by interest, supported the King. Henry Care,
who had long been the bitterest and most active pamphleteer among the
Nonconformists, and who had, in the days of the Popish plot, assailed
James with the utmost fury in a weekly journal entitled the Packet of
Advice from Rome, was now as loud in adulation, as he had formerly been
in calumny and insult. [247] The chief agent who was employed by the
government to manage the Presbyterians was Vincent Alsop, a divine of
some note both as a preacher and as a writer. His son, who had incurred
the penalties of treason, received a pardon; and the whole influence of
the father was thus engaged on the side of the Court. [248] With Alsop
was joined Thomas Rosewell. Rosewell had, during that persecution of
the Dissenters which followed the detection of the Rye House Plot, been
falsely accused of preaching against the government, had been tried for
his life by Jeffreys, and had, in defiance of the clearest evidence,
been convicted by a packed jury. The injustice of the verdict was so
gross that the very courtiers cried shame. One Tory gentleman who had
heard the trial went instantly to Charles, and declared that the neck
of the most loyal subject in England would not be safe if Rosewell
suffered. The jurymen themselves were stung by remorse when they thought
over what they had done, and exerted themselves to save the life of the
prisoner. At length a pardon was granted; but Rosewell remained
bound under heavy recognisances to good behaviour during life, and to
periodical appearance in the Court of King's Bench. His recognisances
were now discharged by the royal command; and in this way his services
were secured. [249]
The business of gaining the Independents was principally intrusted to
one of their ministers named Stephen Lobb. Lobb was a weak, violent, and
ambitious man. He had gone such lengths in opposition to the government,
that he had been by name proscribed in several proclamations. He now
made his peace, and went as far in servility as he had ever done
in faction. He joined the Jesuitical cabal, and eagerly recommended
measures from which the wisest and most honest Roman Catholics recoiled.
It was remarked that he was constantly at the palace and frequently in
the closet, that he lived with a splendour to which the Puritan divines
were little accustomed, and that he was perpetually surrounded by
suitors imploring his interest to procure them offices or pardons. [250]
With Lobb was closely connected William Penn. Penn had never been a
strongheaded man: the life which he had been leading during two years
had not a little impaired his moral sensibility; and, if his conscience
ever reproached him, he comforted himself by repeating that he had a
good and noble end in view, and that he was not paid for his services in
money.
By the influence of these men, and of others less conspicuous, addresses
of thanks to the King were procured from several bodies of Dissenters.
Tory writers have with justice remarked that the language of these
compositions was as fulsomely servile as anything that could be found in
the most florid eulogies pronounced by Bishops on the Stuarts. But, on
close inquiry, it will appear that the disgrace belongs to but a small
part of the Puritan party. There was scarcely a market town in England
without at least a knot of separatists. No exertion was spared to induce
them to express their gratitude for the Indulgence. Circular letters,
imploring them to sign, were sent to every corner of the kingdom in such
numbers that the mail bags, it was sportively said, were too heavy for
the posthorses. Yet all the addresses which could be obtained from all
the Presbyterians, Independents, and Baptists scattered over England did
not in six months amount to sixty; nor is there any reason to believe
that these addresses were numerously signed. [251]
The great body of Protestant Nonconformists, firmly attached to civil
liberty, and distrusting the promises of the King and of the Jesuits,
steadily refused to return thanks for a favour which, it might well
be suspected, concealed a snare. This was the temper of all the most
illustrious chiefs of the party. One of these was Baxter. He had, as we
have seen, been brought to trial soon after the accession of James, had
been brutally insulted by Jeffreys, and had been convicted by a jury,
such as the courtly Sheriffs of those times were in the habit of
selecting. Baxter had been about a year and a half in prison when the
court began to think seriously of gaining the Nonconformists. He was
not only set at liberty, but was informed that, if he chose to reside in
London, he might do so without fearing that the Five Mile Act would
be enforced against him. The government probably hoped that the
recollection of past sufferings and the sense of present ease would
produce the same effect on him as on Rosewell and Lobb. The hope was
disappointed. Baxter was neither to be corrupted nor to be deceived. He
refused to join in an address of thanks for the Indulgence, and exerted
all his influence to promote good feeling between the Church and the
Presbyterians. [252]
If any man stood higher than Baxter in the estimation of the Protestant
Dissenters, that man was John Howe. Howe had, like Baxter, been
personally a gainer by the recent change of policy. The same tyranny
which had flung Baxter into gaol had driven Howe into banishment; and,
soon after Baxter had been let out of the King's Bench prison, Howe
returned from Utrecht to England. It was expected at Whitehall that Howe
would exert in favour of the court all the authority which he possessed
over his brethren. The King himself condescended to ask the help of the
subject whom he had oppressed. Howe appears to have hesitated: but the
influence of the Hampdens, with whom he was on terms of close intimacy,
kept him steady to the cause of the constitution. A meeting of
Presbyterian ministers was held at his house, to consider the state of
affairs, and to determine on the course to be adopted. There was great
anxiety at the palace to know the result. Two royal messengers were in
attendance during the discussion. They carried back the unwelcome news
that Howe had declared himself decidedly adverse to the dispensing
power, and that he had, after long debate, carried with him the majority
of the assembly. [253]
To the names of Baxter and Howe must be added the name of a man far
below them in station and in acquired knowledge, but in virtue their
equal, and in genius their superior, John Bunyan.