Our complexion is such, that we are palled
with enjoyment, and stimulated with hope, - that we
become less sensible to a long-possessed benefit from
the very circumstance that it is become habitual.
with enjoyment, and stimulated with hope, - that we
become less sensible to a long-possessed benefit from
the very circumstance that it is become habitual.
Edmund Burke
Burke that there are impartial men in the world.
To them
I address myself, pending the appeal which on his
part is made from the living to the dead, from the
modern Whigs to the ancient.
The gentlemen, who, in the name of the party,
have passed sentence on Mir. Burke's book, in the
light of literary criticism, are judges above all challenge. He did not, indeed, flatter himself that as a
writer he could claim the approbation of men whose
talents, in his judgment and in the public judgment,
approach to prodigies, if ever such persons should be
disposed to estimate the merit of a composition upon
the standard of their own ability.
In their critical censure, though Mr. Burke may find
himself humbled by it as a writer, as a man, and as
an Englishman, he finds matter not only of consolation, hbut of pride. He proposed to convey to a foreign people, not his own ideas, but the prevalent opinions and sentiments of a nation, renowned for
? ? ? ? 64 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
wisdom, and celebrated in all ages for a well-under.
stood and well-regulated love of freedom. This was
the avowed purpose of the far greater part of his
work. As that work has not been ill received, and
as his critics will not only admit, but contend, that
this reception could not be owing to any excellence
in the composition capable of perverting the public
judgment, it is clear that he is not disavowed by the
nation whose sentiments he had undertaken to describe. His representation is authenticated by the verdict of his country. Had his piece, as a work of
skill, been thought worthy of commendation, some
doubt might have been entertained of the cause of
his success. But the matter stands exactly as he
wishes it. He is more happy to have his fidelity in
representation recognized by the body of the people
than if he were to be ranked in point of ability (and
higher he could not be ranked) with those whose critical censure he has had the misfortune to incur.
It is not from this part of their decision which the
author wishes an appeal. There are things which
touch him more nearly. To abandon them would
argue, not diffidence in his abilities, but treachery
to his cause. Had his work been recognized as a
pattern for dexterous argument and powerful eloquence, yet, if it tended to establish maxims or to inspire sentiments adverse to the wise and free Constitution of this kingdom, he would only have cause to lament that it possessed qualities fitted to perpetuate the memory of his offence. Oblivion would be the only means of his escaping the reproaches of posterity. But, after receiving the common allowance due to the common weakness of man, he wishes to
owe no part of the indulgence of the world to its for
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 65
getfulness. He is at issue with the party before the
present, and, if ever he can reach it, before the coming generation.
The author, several months previous to his publication, well knew that two gentlemen, both of them
possessed of the most distinguished abilities, and of
a most decisive authority in the party, had differed
with him in one of the most material points relative
to the French Revolution: that is, in their opinion
of the behavior of the French soldiery, and its revolt
from its officers. At the time of their public declaration on this subject, he did not imagine the opinion of
these two gentlemen had extended a great way be --
yond themselves. He was, however, well aware ofthe probability that persons of their just credit and!
influence would at length dispose the greater number
to an agreement with their sentiments, and perhaps
might induce the whole body to a tacit acquiescence,
in their declarations, under a natural and not always
an improper dislike of showing a difference with those
who lead their party. I will not deny that in general this conduct in parties is defensible; but within
what limits the practice is to be circumscribed, and!
with what exceptions the doctrine which supports
it is to be received, it is not my present purpose to,
define. The present question has nothing to do with
their motives; it only regards the public expression
of their sentiments.
The author is compelled, however reluctantly, to
receive the sentence pronounced upon him in the
House of Commons as that of the party. It proceeded from the mouth of him who must be regarded as its authentic organ. In a discussion which continued for two days, no one gentleman of the
VOL. IV. 5
? ? ? ? 66 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
opposition interposed a negative, or even a doubt,
in favor of him or his opinions. If an idea consonant
to the doctrine of his book, or favorable to his conduct, lurks in the minds of any persons in that description, it is to be considered only as a peculiarity which they indulge to their own private liberty of
thinking. The author cannot reckon upon it. It
has nothing to do with them as members of a party.
In their public capacity, in everything that meets the
public ear or public eye, the body must be considered as unanimous.
They must have been animated with a very warm
zeal against those opinions, because they were under
no necessity of acting as they did, from any just cause
of apprehension that the errors of this writer should
be taken for theirs. They might disapprove; it was
not necessary they should disavow him, as they have
done in the whole and in all the parts of his book;
because neither in the whole nor in any of the parts
were they directly, or by any implication, involved.
The author was known, indeed, to have been warm-,ly, strenuously, and affectionately, against all allurements of ambition, and all possibility of alienation from pride or personal pique or peevish jealousy,
attached to the Whig party. (With one of them he
has had a long friendship, which he must ever remember with a melancholy pleasure. To the great,
real, and amiable virtues, and to the unequalled abilities of that gentleman, he shall always join with his
country in paying a just tribute of applause. There
are others in that party for whom, without any shade
of sorrow, he bears as high a degree of love as can
enter into the human heart, and as much veneration
as ought to be paid to human creatures] because he
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 67
firmly believes that they are endowed with as many
and as great virtues as the nature of man is capable
of producing, joined to great clearness of intellect, to
a just judgment, to a wonderful temper, and to true
wisdom. His sentiments with regard to them can
never vary, without subjecting him to the just indignation of mankind, who are bound, and are generally
disposed, to look up with reverence to the best patterns of their species, and such as give a dignity to
the nature of which we all participate. For the whole
of the party he has high respect. Upon a view, indeed, of the composition of all parties, he finds great
satisfaction. It is, that, in leaving the service of his
country, he leaves Parliament without all comparison richer in abilities than he found it. Very solid
and very brilliant talents distinguish the ministerial
benches. The opposite rows are a sort of seminary
of genius, and have brought forth such and so great
talents as never before (amongst us at least) have appeared together. If their owners are disposed to serve
their country, (he trusts they are,) they are in a condition to render it services of the highest importance.
If, through mistake or passion, they are led to contribute to its ruin, we shall at least have a consolation denied to the ruined country that adjoins us: we shall not be destroyed by men of mean or secondary
capacities.
~ All these considerations of party attachment, of
personal regard, and of personal admiration rendered the author of the Reflections extremely cautious, lest the slightest suspicion should arise of his having undertaken to express the sentiments even
of a single man of that description. His words at
the outset of his Reflections are these:
? ? ? ? 68 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
"In the first letter I had the honor to write to you,
and which at length I send, I wrote neither for nor
from any desr o a f men; nor shall I in this. My
errors, if any, are my own. My reputation alone is to
answer for them. " In another place he says, (p.
126,*) " I have no man's proxy. I speak only from
myself, when I disclaim, as I do with all possible
earnestness, all communion with the actors in that
triumph, or with the admirers of it. When I assert
anything else, as concerning the people of England,
I speak from observation, notfrom authority. "
To say, then, that the book did not conia-ii-the sentiments of their party is not to contradict the author
or to clear themselves. If the party had denied his
doctrines to be the current opinions of the majority
in the nation, they would have put the question on
its true issue. There, I hope and believe, his censurers will find, on the trial, that the author is as
faithful a representative of the general sentiment of
the people of England, as any person amongst them
can be of the ideas of his own party.
The French Revolution can have no connection
with the objects of any parties in England formed
before the period of that event, unless they choose
to imitate any of its acts, or to consolidate any principles of that Revolution with their own opinions. The
French Revolution is no part of their original contract.
The matter, standing by itself, is an open subject of
political discussion, like all the other revolutions (and
there are many) which have been attempted or accomplished in our age. But if any considerable number of British subjects, taking a factious interest in * Reflections, &c. , 1st ed. , London, J. Dodsley, 1790. --Works,
Vol. III. p. 343, in the present edition.
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 69
the proceedings of France, begin publicly to incorporate themselves for the subversion of nothing short
of the whole Constitution of this kingdom, -to incorporate themselves for the utter overthrow of the
body of its laws, civil and ecclesiastical, and with
them of the whole system of its manners, in favor of
the new Constitution and of the modern usages of
the French nation, -I think no party principle could
bind the author not to express his sentiments strongly
against such a faction. On the contrary, he was perhaps bound to mark his dissent, when the leaders of
the party were daily going out of their way to make
public declarations in Parliament, which, notwithstanding the purity of their intentions, had a tendency to encourage ill-designing men in their practices against our Constitution. The members of this faction leave no doubt of the
nature and the extent of the mischief they mean to
produce. They declare it openly and decisively.
Their intentions are not left equivocal. They are
put out of all dispute by the thanks which, formally
and as it were officially, they issue, in order to recommend and to promote the circulation of the most atrocious and treasonable libels against all the hitherto
cherished objects of the love and veneration of this
people. Is it contrary to the duty of a good subject
to reprobate such proceedings? Is it alien to the
office of a good member of Parliament, when such
practices increase, and when the audacity of the conspirators grows with their impunity, to point out in
his place their evil tendency to the happy Constitution which he is chosen to guard? Is it wrong, in
any sense, to render the people of England sensible
how much they must suffer, if, unfortunately, such
? ? ? ? 70 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
a wicked faction should become possessed in this
country of the same power which their allies in the
very next to us have so perfidiously usurped and so
outrageously abused? Is it inhuman to prevent, if
possible, the spilling their blood, or imprudent to
guard against the effusion of our own? Is it contrary
to any of the honest principles of party, or repugnant
to any of the known duties of friendship, for any senator respectfully and amicably to caution his brother members against countenancing, by inconsiderate expressions, a sort of proceeding which it is impossible they should deliberately approve?
He had undertaken to demonstrate, by arguments
which he thought could not be refuted, and by documents which he was sure could not be denied, that
no comparison was to be made between the British
government and the French usurpation. - That they
who endeavored madly to compare them were by no
means making the comparison of one good system
with another good system, which varied only in local and circumstantial differences; much less that
they were holding out to us a superior pattern of legal liberty, which we might substitute in the place of our old, and, as they describe it, superannuated Constitution. He meant to demonstrate that the French scheme was not a comparative good, but a positive
evil. -That the question did not at all turn, as it
had been stated, on a parallel between a monarchy
and a republic. He denied that the present scheme
of' things in France did at all deserve the respectable
name of a republic: he had therefore no comparison
between monarchies and republics to make. - That
what was done in France was a wild attempt to
methodize anarchy, to perpetuate and fix disorder.
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 71
That it was a foul, impious, monstrous thing, wholly
out of the course of moral Nature. He undertook
to prove that it was generated in treachery, fraud,
falsehood, hypocrisy, and unprovoked murder. - He
offered to make out that those who have led in that
business had conducted themselves with the utmost
perfidy to their colleagues in function, and with the
most flagrant perjury both towards their king and
their constituents: to the one of whom the Assembly
had sworn fealty; and to the other, when under no
sort of violence or constraint, they had sworn a full
obedience to instructions. -- That, by the terror of
assassination, they had driven away a very great
number of the members, so as to produce a false ap
pearance of a majority. - That this fictitious majority
had fabricated a Constitution, which, as now it stands,
is a tyranny far beyond any example that can be
found in the civilized European world of our age;
that therefore the lovers of it must be lovers, not
ofiliberty, but, if they really understand its nature,
of the lowest and basest of all servitude.
He proposed to prove that the present state of
things in France is not a transient evil, productive,
as some have too favorably represented it, of a lasting good; but that the present evil is only the means of producing future and (if that were possible) worse
evils. -That it is not an undigested, imperfect, and
crude scheme of liberty, which may gradually be
mellowed and ripened into an orderly and social freedom; but that it is so fundamentally wrong as to be utterly incapable of correcting itself by any length of
time, or of being formed into any mode of polity of
which a member of the House of Commons could
publicly declare his approbation.
? ? ? ? 72 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
If it had been permitted to Mr. Burke, he would
have shown distinctly, and in detail, that what the
Assembly calling itself National had held out as a
large and liberal toleration is in reality a cruel and
insidious religious persecution, infinitely more bitter than any which had been heard of within this
century. - That it had a feature in it worse than the
old persecutions. -- That the old persecutors acted,
or pretended to act, from zeal towards some system
of piety and virtue: they gave strong preferences to
their own; and if they drove people from one religion, they provided for them another, in which men
might take refuge and expect consolation. - That
their new persecution is not against a variety in conscience, but against all conscience. That it professes
contempt towards its object; and whilst it treats all
religion with scorn, is not so much as neutral about
the modes: it unites the opposite evils of intolerance
and of indifference.
He could have proved that it is so far from rejecting tests, (as unaccountably had been assserted,) that
the Assembly had imposed tests of a peculiar hardship, arising from a cruel and premeditated pecuniary fraud: tests against old principles, sanctioned by the laws, and binding upon the conscience. -- That
these tests were not imposed as titles to some new
honor or some new benefit, but to enable men to hold
a poor compensation for their legal estates, of which
they had been unjustly deprived; and as they had
before been reduced from affluence to indigence, so,
on refusal to swear against their conscience, they are
now driven from indigence to famine, and treated
with every possible degree of outrage, insult, and
inhumanity. -That these tests, which their impos
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 73
ers well knew would not be taken, were intended for
the very purpose of cheating their miserable victims
out of the compensation which the tyrannic impostors of the Assembly had previously and purposely
rendered the public unable to pay. That thus their
ultimate violence arose from their original fraud. 'He would have shown that the universal peace and
concord amongst nations, which these common enemies to mankind had held out with the same fraudulent ends and pretences with which they had uniformly conducted every part of their proceeding, was a coarse and clumsy deception, unworthy to be proposed as an example, by an informed and sagacious
British senator, to any other country. --That, far
from peace and good-will to men, they meditated
war against all other governments, and proposed
systematically to excite in them all the very worst
kind of seditions, in order to lead to their common
destruction. -- That they had discovered, in the few
instances in which they have hitherto had the power
of discovering it, (as at Avignon and in the Comtat,
at Cavaillon and at Carpentras,) in what a savage
manner they mean to conduct the seditions and wars
they have planned against their neighbors, for the
sake of putting themselves at the head of a confederation of republics as wild and as mischievous as their
own. He would have shown in what manner that
wicked scheme was carried on in those places, without being directly either owned or disclaimed, in
hopes that the undone people should at length be
obliged to fly to their tyrannic protection, as some
sort of ref e from their barbarous and treacherous
hostility. \ie would have shown from those examples that neither this nor any other society could be
? ? ? ? 74 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
in safety as long as such a public enemy was in a
condition to continue directly or indirectly such practices against its peace. --That Great Britain was a
principal object of their machinations; and that they
had begun by establishing correspondences, communications, and a sort of federal union with the factious here. - That no practical enjoyment of a thing so imperfect and precarious as human happiness must
be, even under the very best of governments, could
be a security for the existence of these governments,
during the prevalence of the principles of France,
propagated from that grand school of every disorder
and every vice.
He was prered to show the madness of their declaration of the pretended rights of man, -the childish
futility of some of their maxims, the gross and stupid absurdity and the palpable falsity of others, and'
the mischievous tendency of all such declarations to
the well-being of men and of citizens and to the safety and prosperity of every just commonwealth. He
was prepared to show, that, in their conduct, the
Assembly had directly violated not only every sound
principle of government, but every one, without exception, of their own false or futile maxims, and
indeed every rule they had pretended to lay down
for their own direction.
In a word, he was ready to show that those who
could, after such a full and fair exposure, continue
to countenance the French insanity were not mistaken politicians, but bad men; but he thought that in
this case, as in many others, ignorance had been the
cause of admiration.
These are strong assertions. They required strong
proofs. The member who laid down these positions
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 75
was and is ready to give, in his place, to each position decisive evidence, correspondent to the nature
and quality of the several allegations.
In order to judge on the propriety of the interruption given to Mr. Burke, in his speech in the committee of the Quebec Bill, it is necessary to inquire,
First, whether, on general principles, he ought to
have been suffered to prove his allegations? Secondly, whether the time he had chosen was so very unseasonable as to make his exercise of a parliamentary right productive of ill effects on his friends or his
country? Thirdly, whether the opinions delivered in
his book, and which he had begun to expatiate upon
that day, were in contradiction to his former principles, and inconsistent with the general tenor of his
public conduct?
They who have made eloquent panegyrics on the
French Revolution, and who think a free discussion
so very advantageous in every case and under every
circumstance, ought not, in my opinion, to have prevented their eulogies from being tried on the test
of facts. If their panegyric had been answered with
an invective, (bating the difference in point of eloquence,) the one would have been as good as the
other: that is, they would both of them have been
good for nothing. The panegyric and the satire
ought to be suffered to go to trial; and that which
shrinks from it must be contented to stand, at best,
as a mere declamation.
I do not think Mr. Burke was wrong in the course
he took. That which seemed to be recommended to
him by Mr. Pitt was rather to extol the English
Constitution than to attack the French. I do not determine what would be best for Mr. Pitt to do in his
? ? ? ? 76 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
situation. I do not deny that he may have good reasons for his reserve. Perhaps they might have been
as good for a similar reserve on the part of Mr. Fox,
if his zeal had suffered him to listen to them. But
there were no motives of ministerial prudence, or of
that prudence which ought to guide a man perhaps
on the eve of being minister, to restrain the author
of the Reflections. He is in no office under the
crown; he is not the organ of any party.
The excellencies of the British Constitution had already exercised and exhausted the talents of the best
thinkers and the most eloquent writers and speakers
that the world ever saw. But in the present case a
system declared to be far better, and which certainly
is much newer, (to restless and unstable minds no
small recommendation,) was held out to the admiration of the good people of England. In that case
it was surely proper for those who had far other
thoughts of the French Constitution to scrutinize
that plan which has been recommended to our imitation by active and zealous factions at home and
abroad.
Our complexion is such, that we are palled
with enjoyment, and stimulated with hope, - that we
become less sensible to a long-possessed benefit from
the very circumstance that it is become habitual.
Specious, untried, ambiguous prospects of new advantage recommend themselves to the spirit of adventure which more or less prevails in every mind. From this temper, men and factions, and nations too,
have sacrificed the good of which they had been in
assured possession, in favor of wild and irrational
expectations. What should hinder Mr. Burke, if he
thought this temper likely at one time or other to
prevail in our country, from exposing to a multitude
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 77
eager to game the false calculations of this lottery of
fraud?
I allow, as I ought to do, for the effusions which
come from a general zeal for liberty. This is to be
indulged, and even to be encouraged, as long as the
question is general. An orator, above all men, ought
to be allowed a full and free use of the praise of liberty. A commonplace in favor of slavery and tyranny, delivered to a popular assembly, would indeed be a bold defiance to all the principles of rhetoric.
But in a question whether any particular Constitution is or is not a plan of rational liberty, this kind of
rhetorical flourish in favor of freedom in general is
surely a little out of its place. It is virtually a beg
ging of the question. It is a song of triumph before
the battle.
"But Mr. Fox does not make the panegyric of
the new Constitution; it is the destruction only of
the absolute monarchy he commends. " When that
nameless thing which has been. lately set up in
France was described as " the most stupendous and
glorious edifice of liberty which had been erected
on the foundation of human integrity in any time or
country," it might at first have led the hearer into
an opinion that the construction of the new fabric
was an object of admiration, as well as the demolition of the old. Mr. Fox, however, has explained
himself; and it would be too like that captious and
cavilling spirit which I so perfectly detest, if I were
to pin down the language of an eloquent and' ardent mind to the punctilious exactness of a pleader.
Then Mr. Fox did not mean to applaud that monstrous thing which, by the courtesy of France, they
call a Constitution. I easily believe it. Far from
? ? ? ? 78 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
meriting the praises of a great genius like Mr. Fox, it
cannot be approved by any man of common sense or
common information. He cannot admire the change
of one piece of barbarism for another, and a worse.
He cannot rejoice at the destruction of a monarchy,
mitigated by manners, respectful to laws and usages,
and attentive, perhaps but too attentive, to public
opinion, in favor of the tyranny of a licentious, ferocious, and savage multitude, without laws, manners,
or morals, and which, so far from respecting the general sense of mankind, insolently endeavors to alter
all the principles and opinions which have hitherto
guided and contained the world, and to force them
into a conformity to their views and actions. His
mind is made to better things.
That a man should rejoice and triumph in the destruction of an absolute monarchy, - that in such an
event he should overlook the captivity, disgrace, and
degradation of an unfortunate prince, and the continual danger to a life which exists only to be endangered, -that he should overlook the utter ruin of whole orders and classes of men, extending itself directly,
or in its nearest consequences, to at least a million
of our kind, and to at least the temporary wretchedness of a whole community, -I do not deny to be in
some sort natural; because, when people see a political object which they ardently desire but in one
point of view, they are apt extremely to palliate or
underrate the evils which may arise in obtaining it.
This is no reflection on the humanity of those persons. Their good-nature I am the last man in the
world to dispute. It only shows that they are
not sufficiently informed or sufficiently considerate.
When they come to reflect seriously on the trans
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 79
action, they will think themselves bound to examine
what the object is that has been acquired by all this
havoc. They will hardly assert that the destruction
of an absolute monarchy is a thing good in itself,
without any sort of reference to the antecedent state
of things, or to consequences which result from the
change, -- without any consideration whether under its
ancient rule a country was to a considerable degree
flourishing and populous, highly cultivated and highly commercial, and whether, under thlat domination,
though personal liberty had been precarious and insecure, property at least was ever violated. They cannot take the moral sympathies of the human mind
along with them, in abstractions separated from the
good or evil condition of the state, from the quality
of actions, and the character of the actors. None of
us love absolute and uncontrolled monarchy; but
we could not rejoice at the sufferings of a Marcus
Aurelius or a Trajan, who were absolute monarchs,
as we do when Nero is condemned by the Senate to
be punished more majorum; nor, when that monster
was obliged to fly with his wife Sporus, and to drink
puddle, were men affected in the same manner as
when the venerable Galba, with all his faults and
errors, was murdered by a revolted mercenary soldiery. With such things before our eyes, our feelings contradict our theories; and when this is the
case, the feelings are true, and the theory is false.
What I contend for is, that, in commending the destruction of an absolute monarchy, all the circumstances ought not to be wholly overlooked, as "'considerations fit only for shallow and superficial minds. " (The words of Mr. Fox, or to that effect. )
The subversion of a government, to deserve any
? ? ? ? 80 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
praise, must be considered but as a step preparatory
to the formation of something better, either in the
scheme of the government itself, or in the persons
who administer it, or in both. These events cannot
in reason be separated. For instance, when we praise
our Revolution of 1688, though the nation in that act
was on the defensive, and was justified in incurring
all the evils of a defensive war, we do not rest there.
We always combine with the subversion of the old
government the happy settlement which followed.
When we estimate that Revolution, we mean to comprehend in our calculation both the value of the thing parted with and the value of the thing received
in exchange.
The burden of proof lies heavily on those who tear
to pieces the whole frame and contexture of their
country, that they could find no other way of settling
a government fit to obtain its rational ends, except
that which they have pursued by means unfavorable
to all the present happiness of millions of people, and
to the utter ruin of several hundreds of thousands.
In their political arrangements, men have no right to
put the well-being of the present generation wholly
out of the question. Perhaps the only moral trust
with any certainty in our hands is the care of our
own time. With regard to futurity, we are to treat
it like a ward. We are not so to attempt an improvement of his fortune as to put the capital of his estate to any hazard.
It is not worth our while to discuss, like sophisters, whether in no case some etil for the sake of
some benefit is to be tolerated. Nothing universal
can be rationally affirmed on any moral or any political subject. Pure metaphysical abstraction does not
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 81
belong to these matters. The lines of morality are not
like the ideal lines of mathematics. They are broad
and deep as well as long. They admit of exceptions;
they demand modifications. These exceptions and
modifications are not made by the process of logic,
but by the rules of prudence. Prudence is not only
the first in rank of the virtues political and moral,
but she is the director, the regulator, the standard
of them all. Metaphysics cannot live without definition; but Prudence is cautious how she defines.
Our courts cannot be more fearful in suffering fictitious cases to be brought before them for elicit --
ing their determination on a point of law than pru --
dent moralists are in putting extreme and hazardous cases of conscience upon emergencies not exists ing. Without attempting, therefore, to define, what
never can be defined, the case of a revolution in government, this, I think, may be safely affirmed, - that a sore and pressing evil is to be removed, and that a
good, great in its amount and unequivocal in its
nature, must be probable almost to certainty, before
the inestimable price of our own morals and the wellbeing of a number of our fellow-citizens is paid for a revolution. If ever we ought to be economists even
to parsimony, it is in the voluntary production of evil.
Every revolution contains in it something of evil.
It must always be, to those who are the greatest
amateurs, or even professors, of revolutions, a matter
very hard to prove, that the late French government
was so bad that nothing worse in the infinite devices
of men could come in its place. They who have
brought France to its present condition ought to
prove also, by something better than prattling about
the Bastile, that their subverted government was as
VOL. IV. 6
? ? ? ? 82 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
incapable as tile present certainly is of all improvement and correction. How dare they to say so who have never made that experiment? They are experimpnters by their trade. They have made an hundred others, infinitely more hazardous.
The English admirers of the forty-eight thousand
republics which form the French federation praise
them not for what they are, but for what they are to
become. They do not talk as politicians, but as
prophets. But in whatever character they choose
to found panegyric on prediction, it will be thought
a little singular to praise any work, not for its own
merits, but for the merits of something else which
may succeed to it. When any political institution
is praised, in spite of great and prominent faults of
every kind, and in all its parts, it must be supposed
to have something excellent in its fundamental principles. It must be shown that it is right, though imperfect, -that it is not only by possibility susceptible of improvement, but that it contains in it a principle tending to its melioration.
Before they attempt to show this progression of
their favorite work from absolute pravity to finished
perfection, they will find themselves engaged in a
civil war with those whose cause they maintain.
What! alter our sublime Constitution, the glory of
France, the envy of the world, the pattern for man~ kind, the masterpiece of legislation, the collected and concentrated glory of this enlightened age? Have
we not produced it ready-made and ready-armed,
mature in its birth, a perfect goddess of wisdom and
of war, hammered by our blacksmith midwives out
of the brain of Jupiter himself? Have we not sworn
-our devout, profane, believing, infidel people to an
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 83
allegiance to this goddess, even before she had burst
the dura mater, and as yet existed only in embryo?
Have we not solemnly declared this Constitution unalterable by any future legislature? Have we not bound it on posterity forever, though our abettors
have declared that no one generation is competent
to bind another? Have we not obliged the members
of every future Assembly to qualifiy themselves for
their seats by swearing to its conservation?
Indeed, the French Constitution always must be
(if a change is not made in all their principles ancl
fundamental arrangements) a government wholly by
popular representation. It must be this or nothing.
The French faction considers as an usurpation, as
an atrocious violation of the indefeasible rights of
man, every other description of government. Take
it, or leave it: there is no medium. Let the irrefragabl6 doctors fight out their own controversy in their own way and with their own weapons; and when
they are tired, let them commence a treaty of peace.
Let the plenipotentiary sophisters of England settle
with the diplomatic sophisters of France in what
manner right is to be corrected by an infusion of
wrong, and how truth may be rendered more true
by a due intermixture of falsehood.
Having sufficiently proved that nothing could make
it generally improper for Mr. Burke to prove what
he had alleged concerning the object of this dispute,
I pass to the second question, that is, Whether he was
justified in choosing the committee on the Quebec
Bill as the field for this discussion? If it were necessary, it might be shown that he was not the first to bring these discussions into Parliament, nor the first
? ? ? ? 84 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
to renew them in this session. The fact is notorious.
As to the Quebec Bill, they were introduced into the
debate upon that subject for two plain reasons: First,
that, as he thought it then not advisable to make the
proceedings of the factious societies the subject of a
direct motion, he had no other way open to him.
Nobody has attempted to show that it was at all
admissible into any other business before the House.
Here everything was favorable. Here was a bill to
form a new Constitution for a French province under English dominion. The question naturally arose,
whether we should settle that constitution upon English ideas, or upon French. This furnished an opportunity for examining into the value of the French Constitution, either considered as applicable to colonial government, or in its own nature. The bill, too,
was in a committee. By the privilege of speaking
as often as he pleased, he hoped in some measure to
supply the want of support, which he had but too
much reason to apprehend. In a committee it was
always in his power to bring the questions from generalities to facts, from declamation to discussion.
Some benefit he actually received from this privilege.
These are plain, obvious, natural reasons for his conduct. I believe they are the true, and the only true
ones.
They who justify the frequent interruptions, which
at length wholly disabled him from proceeding, attribute their conduct to a very different interpretation of
his motives. They say, that, through corruption, or
malice, or folly, he was acting his part in a plot to
make his friend Mr. Fox pass for a republican, and
thereby to prevent the gracious intentions of his sovereign from taking effect, which at that time had
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 85
begun to disclose themselves in his favor. * This is
a pretty serious charge. This, on Mr. Burke's part,,
would be something more than mistake, something
worse than formal irregularity. Any contumely, any,
outrage, is readily passed over, by the indulgence:
which we all owe to sudden passion. These thillgs
are soon forgot upon occasions in which all men are
so apt to forget themselves. Deliberate injuries, to a
degree, must be remembered, because they require
deliberate precautions to be secured against their return.
I am authorized to say for Mr. Burke, that he
* To explain this, it will be necessary to advert to a paragraph
which appeared in a paper in the minority interest some time before:
this debate. " A very dark intrigue has lately been discovered, the,
authors of which are well known to us; but until the glorious day:
shall come when it will not be a LIBEL to tell the TRUTH, We must
not be so regardless of our own safety as to publish their names. .
We will, however, state the fact, leaving it to the ingenuity of our
readers to discover what we dare not publish.
"Since the business of the armament against Russia has been
under discussion, a great personage has been heard to say,' that he,
was not so wedded to Mr. PITT as not to be very willing to give his
confidence to Mr. Fox, if the latter should be able, in a crisis like the,
present, to conduct the government of the country with greater advan-,
tage to the public. '
"This patriotic declaration immediately alarmed the swarm of'
courtly insects that live only in the sunshine of ministerial favor. It
was thought to be the forerunner of the dismission of Mr. Pitt, and
every engine was set at work for the purpose of preventing such an
event. The principal engine employed on this occasion was CALUISNY. It was whispered in the ear'of a great personage, that Mr. Fox was the last man in England to be trusted by a KING, because he was
by PRINCIPLE a REPUBLICAN, and consequently an enemy to MONARCHY.
"In the discussion of the Quebec Bill which stood for yesterday, it
was the intention of some persons to connect with this subject the
? ? ? ? 86 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
considers that cause assigned for the outrage offered
to him as telln times worse than the outrage itself.
There is such a strange confusion of ideas on this
subject, that it is far more difficult to understand
the nature of the charge than to refute it when understood. Mr. Fox's friends were, it seems, seized
with a sudden panic terror lest he should pass for a
republican. I do not think they had any ground
for this apprehension. But let us admit they had.
What was there in the Quebec Bill, rather than in
ally other, which could subject him or them to that
imputationl? Nothing in a discussion of the French
Constitution, which might arise on the Quebec Bill,
French Revolution, in hopes that Mr. Fox would be warmed by a collision with Mr. Burke, and induced to defend that Revolution, in which so much power was taken from, and so little left in the crown.
Had Mr. Fox fallen into the snare, his speech on the occasion
would have been laid before a great personage, as a proof that a man
who could defend such a revolution might be a very good republican,
but could not possibly be a friend to monarchy.
" But those who laid the snare were disappointed; for Mr. Fox, in
the short conversation which took place yesterday in the House of
Commons, said, that he confessedly had thought favorably of the
French Revolution, but that most certainly he never had, either in
Parliament or out of Parliament, professed or defended republican
principles. " -Argus, April 22d, 1791.
Mr. Burke cannot answer for the truth nor prove the falsehood of
the story given by the friends of the party in this paper. He only
knows that an opinion of its being well or ill authenticated had no
influence on his conduct. He meant only, to the best of his power,
to guard the public against the ill designs of factions out of doors.
What Mr. Burke did in Parliament could hardly have been intended
to draw Mr. Fox into any declarations unfavorable to his principles,
since (by the account of those who are his friends) he had long before effectually prevented the success of any such scandalous designs. Mr. Fox's friends have themselves done away that imputation on Mr.
Burke.
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS.
I address myself, pending the appeal which on his
part is made from the living to the dead, from the
modern Whigs to the ancient.
The gentlemen, who, in the name of the party,
have passed sentence on Mir. Burke's book, in the
light of literary criticism, are judges above all challenge. He did not, indeed, flatter himself that as a
writer he could claim the approbation of men whose
talents, in his judgment and in the public judgment,
approach to prodigies, if ever such persons should be
disposed to estimate the merit of a composition upon
the standard of their own ability.
In their critical censure, though Mr. Burke may find
himself humbled by it as a writer, as a man, and as
an Englishman, he finds matter not only of consolation, hbut of pride. He proposed to convey to a foreign people, not his own ideas, but the prevalent opinions and sentiments of a nation, renowned for
? ? ? ? 64 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
wisdom, and celebrated in all ages for a well-under.
stood and well-regulated love of freedom. This was
the avowed purpose of the far greater part of his
work. As that work has not been ill received, and
as his critics will not only admit, but contend, that
this reception could not be owing to any excellence
in the composition capable of perverting the public
judgment, it is clear that he is not disavowed by the
nation whose sentiments he had undertaken to describe. His representation is authenticated by the verdict of his country. Had his piece, as a work of
skill, been thought worthy of commendation, some
doubt might have been entertained of the cause of
his success. But the matter stands exactly as he
wishes it. He is more happy to have his fidelity in
representation recognized by the body of the people
than if he were to be ranked in point of ability (and
higher he could not be ranked) with those whose critical censure he has had the misfortune to incur.
It is not from this part of their decision which the
author wishes an appeal. There are things which
touch him more nearly. To abandon them would
argue, not diffidence in his abilities, but treachery
to his cause. Had his work been recognized as a
pattern for dexterous argument and powerful eloquence, yet, if it tended to establish maxims or to inspire sentiments adverse to the wise and free Constitution of this kingdom, he would only have cause to lament that it possessed qualities fitted to perpetuate the memory of his offence. Oblivion would be the only means of his escaping the reproaches of posterity. But, after receiving the common allowance due to the common weakness of man, he wishes to
owe no part of the indulgence of the world to its for
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 65
getfulness. He is at issue with the party before the
present, and, if ever he can reach it, before the coming generation.
The author, several months previous to his publication, well knew that two gentlemen, both of them
possessed of the most distinguished abilities, and of
a most decisive authority in the party, had differed
with him in one of the most material points relative
to the French Revolution: that is, in their opinion
of the behavior of the French soldiery, and its revolt
from its officers. At the time of their public declaration on this subject, he did not imagine the opinion of
these two gentlemen had extended a great way be --
yond themselves. He was, however, well aware ofthe probability that persons of their just credit and!
influence would at length dispose the greater number
to an agreement with their sentiments, and perhaps
might induce the whole body to a tacit acquiescence,
in their declarations, under a natural and not always
an improper dislike of showing a difference with those
who lead their party. I will not deny that in general this conduct in parties is defensible; but within
what limits the practice is to be circumscribed, and!
with what exceptions the doctrine which supports
it is to be received, it is not my present purpose to,
define. The present question has nothing to do with
their motives; it only regards the public expression
of their sentiments.
The author is compelled, however reluctantly, to
receive the sentence pronounced upon him in the
House of Commons as that of the party. It proceeded from the mouth of him who must be regarded as its authentic organ. In a discussion which continued for two days, no one gentleman of the
VOL. IV. 5
? ? ? ? 66 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
opposition interposed a negative, or even a doubt,
in favor of him or his opinions. If an idea consonant
to the doctrine of his book, or favorable to his conduct, lurks in the minds of any persons in that description, it is to be considered only as a peculiarity which they indulge to their own private liberty of
thinking. The author cannot reckon upon it. It
has nothing to do with them as members of a party.
In their public capacity, in everything that meets the
public ear or public eye, the body must be considered as unanimous.
They must have been animated with a very warm
zeal against those opinions, because they were under
no necessity of acting as they did, from any just cause
of apprehension that the errors of this writer should
be taken for theirs. They might disapprove; it was
not necessary they should disavow him, as they have
done in the whole and in all the parts of his book;
because neither in the whole nor in any of the parts
were they directly, or by any implication, involved.
The author was known, indeed, to have been warm-,ly, strenuously, and affectionately, against all allurements of ambition, and all possibility of alienation from pride or personal pique or peevish jealousy,
attached to the Whig party. (With one of them he
has had a long friendship, which he must ever remember with a melancholy pleasure. To the great,
real, and amiable virtues, and to the unequalled abilities of that gentleman, he shall always join with his
country in paying a just tribute of applause. There
are others in that party for whom, without any shade
of sorrow, he bears as high a degree of love as can
enter into the human heart, and as much veneration
as ought to be paid to human creatures] because he
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 67
firmly believes that they are endowed with as many
and as great virtues as the nature of man is capable
of producing, joined to great clearness of intellect, to
a just judgment, to a wonderful temper, and to true
wisdom. His sentiments with regard to them can
never vary, without subjecting him to the just indignation of mankind, who are bound, and are generally
disposed, to look up with reverence to the best patterns of their species, and such as give a dignity to
the nature of which we all participate. For the whole
of the party he has high respect. Upon a view, indeed, of the composition of all parties, he finds great
satisfaction. It is, that, in leaving the service of his
country, he leaves Parliament without all comparison richer in abilities than he found it. Very solid
and very brilliant talents distinguish the ministerial
benches. The opposite rows are a sort of seminary
of genius, and have brought forth such and so great
talents as never before (amongst us at least) have appeared together. If their owners are disposed to serve
their country, (he trusts they are,) they are in a condition to render it services of the highest importance.
If, through mistake or passion, they are led to contribute to its ruin, we shall at least have a consolation denied to the ruined country that adjoins us: we shall not be destroyed by men of mean or secondary
capacities.
~ All these considerations of party attachment, of
personal regard, and of personal admiration rendered the author of the Reflections extremely cautious, lest the slightest suspicion should arise of his having undertaken to express the sentiments even
of a single man of that description. His words at
the outset of his Reflections are these:
? ? ? ? 68 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
"In the first letter I had the honor to write to you,
and which at length I send, I wrote neither for nor
from any desr o a f men; nor shall I in this. My
errors, if any, are my own. My reputation alone is to
answer for them. " In another place he says, (p.
126,*) " I have no man's proxy. I speak only from
myself, when I disclaim, as I do with all possible
earnestness, all communion with the actors in that
triumph, or with the admirers of it. When I assert
anything else, as concerning the people of England,
I speak from observation, notfrom authority. "
To say, then, that the book did not conia-ii-the sentiments of their party is not to contradict the author
or to clear themselves. If the party had denied his
doctrines to be the current opinions of the majority
in the nation, they would have put the question on
its true issue. There, I hope and believe, his censurers will find, on the trial, that the author is as
faithful a representative of the general sentiment of
the people of England, as any person amongst them
can be of the ideas of his own party.
The French Revolution can have no connection
with the objects of any parties in England formed
before the period of that event, unless they choose
to imitate any of its acts, or to consolidate any principles of that Revolution with their own opinions. The
French Revolution is no part of their original contract.
The matter, standing by itself, is an open subject of
political discussion, like all the other revolutions (and
there are many) which have been attempted or accomplished in our age. But if any considerable number of British subjects, taking a factious interest in * Reflections, &c. , 1st ed. , London, J. Dodsley, 1790. --Works,
Vol. III. p. 343, in the present edition.
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 69
the proceedings of France, begin publicly to incorporate themselves for the subversion of nothing short
of the whole Constitution of this kingdom, -to incorporate themselves for the utter overthrow of the
body of its laws, civil and ecclesiastical, and with
them of the whole system of its manners, in favor of
the new Constitution and of the modern usages of
the French nation, -I think no party principle could
bind the author not to express his sentiments strongly
against such a faction. On the contrary, he was perhaps bound to mark his dissent, when the leaders of
the party were daily going out of their way to make
public declarations in Parliament, which, notwithstanding the purity of their intentions, had a tendency to encourage ill-designing men in their practices against our Constitution. The members of this faction leave no doubt of the
nature and the extent of the mischief they mean to
produce. They declare it openly and decisively.
Their intentions are not left equivocal. They are
put out of all dispute by the thanks which, formally
and as it were officially, they issue, in order to recommend and to promote the circulation of the most atrocious and treasonable libels against all the hitherto
cherished objects of the love and veneration of this
people. Is it contrary to the duty of a good subject
to reprobate such proceedings? Is it alien to the
office of a good member of Parliament, when such
practices increase, and when the audacity of the conspirators grows with their impunity, to point out in
his place their evil tendency to the happy Constitution which he is chosen to guard? Is it wrong, in
any sense, to render the people of England sensible
how much they must suffer, if, unfortunately, such
? ? ? ? 70 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
a wicked faction should become possessed in this
country of the same power which their allies in the
very next to us have so perfidiously usurped and so
outrageously abused? Is it inhuman to prevent, if
possible, the spilling their blood, or imprudent to
guard against the effusion of our own? Is it contrary
to any of the honest principles of party, or repugnant
to any of the known duties of friendship, for any senator respectfully and amicably to caution his brother members against countenancing, by inconsiderate expressions, a sort of proceeding which it is impossible they should deliberately approve?
He had undertaken to demonstrate, by arguments
which he thought could not be refuted, and by documents which he was sure could not be denied, that
no comparison was to be made between the British
government and the French usurpation. - That they
who endeavored madly to compare them were by no
means making the comparison of one good system
with another good system, which varied only in local and circumstantial differences; much less that
they were holding out to us a superior pattern of legal liberty, which we might substitute in the place of our old, and, as they describe it, superannuated Constitution. He meant to demonstrate that the French scheme was not a comparative good, but a positive
evil. -That the question did not at all turn, as it
had been stated, on a parallel between a monarchy
and a republic. He denied that the present scheme
of' things in France did at all deserve the respectable
name of a republic: he had therefore no comparison
between monarchies and republics to make. - That
what was done in France was a wild attempt to
methodize anarchy, to perpetuate and fix disorder.
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 71
That it was a foul, impious, monstrous thing, wholly
out of the course of moral Nature. He undertook
to prove that it was generated in treachery, fraud,
falsehood, hypocrisy, and unprovoked murder. - He
offered to make out that those who have led in that
business had conducted themselves with the utmost
perfidy to their colleagues in function, and with the
most flagrant perjury both towards their king and
their constituents: to the one of whom the Assembly
had sworn fealty; and to the other, when under no
sort of violence or constraint, they had sworn a full
obedience to instructions. -- That, by the terror of
assassination, they had driven away a very great
number of the members, so as to produce a false ap
pearance of a majority. - That this fictitious majority
had fabricated a Constitution, which, as now it stands,
is a tyranny far beyond any example that can be
found in the civilized European world of our age;
that therefore the lovers of it must be lovers, not
ofiliberty, but, if they really understand its nature,
of the lowest and basest of all servitude.
He proposed to prove that the present state of
things in France is not a transient evil, productive,
as some have too favorably represented it, of a lasting good; but that the present evil is only the means of producing future and (if that were possible) worse
evils. -That it is not an undigested, imperfect, and
crude scheme of liberty, which may gradually be
mellowed and ripened into an orderly and social freedom; but that it is so fundamentally wrong as to be utterly incapable of correcting itself by any length of
time, or of being formed into any mode of polity of
which a member of the House of Commons could
publicly declare his approbation.
? ? ? ? 72 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
If it had been permitted to Mr. Burke, he would
have shown distinctly, and in detail, that what the
Assembly calling itself National had held out as a
large and liberal toleration is in reality a cruel and
insidious religious persecution, infinitely more bitter than any which had been heard of within this
century. - That it had a feature in it worse than the
old persecutions. -- That the old persecutors acted,
or pretended to act, from zeal towards some system
of piety and virtue: they gave strong preferences to
their own; and if they drove people from one religion, they provided for them another, in which men
might take refuge and expect consolation. - That
their new persecution is not against a variety in conscience, but against all conscience. That it professes
contempt towards its object; and whilst it treats all
religion with scorn, is not so much as neutral about
the modes: it unites the opposite evils of intolerance
and of indifference.
He could have proved that it is so far from rejecting tests, (as unaccountably had been assserted,) that
the Assembly had imposed tests of a peculiar hardship, arising from a cruel and premeditated pecuniary fraud: tests against old principles, sanctioned by the laws, and binding upon the conscience. -- That
these tests were not imposed as titles to some new
honor or some new benefit, but to enable men to hold
a poor compensation for their legal estates, of which
they had been unjustly deprived; and as they had
before been reduced from affluence to indigence, so,
on refusal to swear against their conscience, they are
now driven from indigence to famine, and treated
with every possible degree of outrage, insult, and
inhumanity. -That these tests, which their impos
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 73
ers well knew would not be taken, were intended for
the very purpose of cheating their miserable victims
out of the compensation which the tyrannic impostors of the Assembly had previously and purposely
rendered the public unable to pay. That thus their
ultimate violence arose from their original fraud. 'He would have shown that the universal peace and
concord amongst nations, which these common enemies to mankind had held out with the same fraudulent ends and pretences with which they had uniformly conducted every part of their proceeding, was a coarse and clumsy deception, unworthy to be proposed as an example, by an informed and sagacious
British senator, to any other country. --That, far
from peace and good-will to men, they meditated
war against all other governments, and proposed
systematically to excite in them all the very worst
kind of seditions, in order to lead to their common
destruction. -- That they had discovered, in the few
instances in which they have hitherto had the power
of discovering it, (as at Avignon and in the Comtat,
at Cavaillon and at Carpentras,) in what a savage
manner they mean to conduct the seditions and wars
they have planned against their neighbors, for the
sake of putting themselves at the head of a confederation of republics as wild and as mischievous as their
own. He would have shown in what manner that
wicked scheme was carried on in those places, without being directly either owned or disclaimed, in
hopes that the undone people should at length be
obliged to fly to their tyrannic protection, as some
sort of ref e from their barbarous and treacherous
hostility. \ie would have shown from those examples that neither this nor any other society could be
? ? ? ? 74 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
in safety as long as such a public enemy was in a
condition to continue directly or indirectly such practices against its peace. --That Great Britain was a
principal object of their machinations; and that they
had begun by establishing correspondences, communications, and a sort of federal union with the factious here. - That no practical enjoyment of a thing so imperfect and precarious as human happiness must
be, even under the very best of governments, could
be a security for the existence of these governments,
during the prevalence of the principles of France,
propagated from that grand school of every disorder
and every vice.
He was prered to show the madness of their declaration of the pretended rights of man, -the childish
futility of some of their maxims, the gross and stupid absurdity and the palpable falsity of others, and'
the mischievous tendency of all such declarations to
the well-being of men and of citizens and to the safety and prosperity of every just commonwealth. He
was prepared to show, that, in their conduct, the
Assembly had directly violated not only every sound
principle of government, but every one, without exception, of their own false or futile maxims, and
indeed every rule they had pretended to lay down
for their own direction.
In a word, he was ready to show that those who
could, after such a full and fair exposure, continue
to countenance the French insanity were not mistaken politicians, but bad men; but he thought that in
this case, as in many others, ignorance had been the
cause of admiration.
These are strong assertions. They required strong
proofs. The member who laid down these positions
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 75
was and is ready to give, in his place, to each position decisive evidence, correspondent to the nature
and quality of the several allegations.
In order to judge on the propriety of the interruption given to Mr. Burke, in his speech in the committee of the Quebec Bill, it is necessary to inquire,
First, whether, on general principles, he ought to
have been suffered to prove his allegations? Secondly, whether the time he had chosen was so very unseasonable as to make his exercise of a parliamentary right productive of ill effects on his friends or his
country? Thirdly, whether the opinions delivered in
his book, and which he had begun to expatiate upon
that day, were in contradiction to his former principles, and inconsistent with the general tenor of his
public conduct?
They who have made eloquent panegyrics on the
French Revolution, and who think a free discussion
so very advantageous in every case and under every
circumstance, ought not, in my opinion, to have prevented their eulogies from being tried on the test
of facts. If their panegyric had been answered with
an invective, (bating the difference in point of eloquence,) the one would have been as good as the
other: that is, they would both of them have been
good for nothing. The panegyric and the satire
ought to be suffered to go to trial; and that which
shrinks from it must be contented to stand, at best,
as a mere declamation.
I do not think Mr. Burke was wrong in the course
he took. That which seemed to be recommended to
him by Mr. Pitt was rather to extol the English
Constitution than to attack the French. I do not determine what would be best for Mr. Pitt to do in his
? ? ? ? 76 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
situation. I do not deny that he may have good reasons for his reserve. Perhaps they might have been
as good for a similar reserve on the part of Mr. Fox,
if his zeal had suffered him to listen to them. But
there were no motives of ministerial prudence, or of
that prudence which ought to guide a man perhaps
on the eve of being minister, to restrain the author
of the Reflections. He is in no office under the
crown; he is not the organ of any party.
The excellencies of the British Constitution had already exercised and exhausted the talents of the best
thinkers and the most eloquent writers and speakers
that the world ever saw. But in the present case a
system declared to be far better, and which certainly
is much newer, (to restless and unstable minds no
small recommendation,) was held out to the admiration of the good people of England. In that case
it was surely proper for those who had far other
thoughts of the French Constitution to scrutinize
that plan which has been recommended to our imitation by active and zealous factions at home and
abroad.
Our complexion is such, that we are palled
with enjoyment, and stimulated with hope, - that we
become less sensible to a long-possessed benefit from
the very circumstance that it is become habitual.
Specious, untried, ambiguous prospects of new advantage recommend themselves to the spirit of adventure which more or less prevails in every mind. From this temper, men and factions, and nations too,
have sacrificed the good of which they had been in
assured possession, in favor of wild and irrational
expectations. What should hinder Mr. Burke, if he
thought this temper likely at one time or other to
prevail in our country, from exposing to a multitude
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 77
eager to game the false calculations of this lottery of
fraud?
I allow, as I ought to do, for the effusions which
come from a general zeal for liberty. This is to be
indulged, and even to be encouraged, as long as the
question is general. An orator, above all men, ought
to be allowed a full and free use of the praise of liberty. A commonplace in favor of slavery and tyranny, delivered to a popular assembly, would indeed be a bold defiance to all the principles of rhetoric.
But in a question whether any particular Constitution is or is not a plan of rational liberty, this kind of
rhetorical flourish in favor of freedom in general is
surely a little out of its place. It is virtually a beg
ging of the question. It is a song of triumph before
the battle.
"But Mr. Fox does not make the panegyric of
the new Constitution; it is the destruction only of
the absolute monarchy he commends. " When that
nameless thing which has been. lately set up in
France was described as " the most stupendous and
glorious edifice of liberty which had been erected
on the foundation of human integrity in any time or
country," it might at first have led the hearer into
an opinion that the construction of the new fabric
was an object of admiration, as well as the demolition of the old. Mr. Fox, however, has explained
himself; and it would be too like that captious and
cavilling spirit which I so perfectly detest, if I were
to pin down the language of an eloquent and' ardent mind to the punctilious exactness of a pleader.
Then Mr. Fox did not mean to applaud that monstrous thing which, by the courtesy of France, they
call a Constitution. I easily believe it. Far from
? ? ? ? 78 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
meriting the praises of a great genius like Mr. Fox, it
cannot be approved by any man of common sense or
common information. He cannot admire the change
of one piece of barbarism for another, and a worse.
He cannot rejoice at the destruction of a monarchy,
mitigated by manners, respectful to laws and usages,
and attentive, perhaps but too attentive, to public
opinion, in favor of the tyranny of a licentious, ferocious, and savage multitude, without laws, manners,
or morals, and which, so far from respecting the general sense of mankind, insolently endeavors to alter
all the principles and opinions which have hitherto
guided and contained the world, and to force them
into a conformity to their views and actions. His
mind is made to better things.
That a man should rejoice and triumph in the destruction of an absolute monarchy, - that in such an
event he should overlook the captivity, disgrace, and
degradation of an unfortunate prince, and the continual danger to a life which exists only to be endangered, -that he should overlook the utter ruin of whole orders and classes of men, extending itself directly,
or in its nearest consequences, to at least a million
of our kind, and to at least the temporary wretchedness of a whole community, -I do not deny to be in
some sort natural; because, when people see a political object which they ardently desire but in one
point of view, they are apt extremely to palliate or
underrate the evils which may arise in obtaining it.
This is no reflection on the humanity of those persons. Their good-nature I am the last man in the
world to dispute. It only shows that they are
not sufficiently informed or sufficiently considerate.
When they come to reflect seriously on the trans
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 79
action, they will think themselves bound to examine
what the object is that has been acquired by all this
havoc. They will hardly assert that the destruction
of an absolute monarchy is a thing good in itself,
without any sort of reference to the antecedent state
of things, or to consequences which result from the
change, -- without any consideration whether under its
ancient rule a country was to a considerable degree
flourishing and populous, highly cultivated and highly commercial, and whether, under thlat domination,
though personal liberty had been precarious and insecure, property at least was ever violated. They cannot take the moral sympathies of the human mind
along with them, in abstractions separated from the
good or evil condition of the state, from the quality
of actions, and the character of the actors. None of
us love absolute and uncontrolled monarchy; but
we could not rejoice at the sufferings of a Marcus
Aurelius or a Trajan, who were absolute monarchs,
as we do when Nero is condemned by the Senate to
be punished more majorum; nor, when that monster
was obliged to fly with his wife Sporus, and to drink
puddle, were men affected in the same manner as
when the venerable Galba, with all his faults and
errors, was murdered by a revolted mercenary soldiery. With such things before our eyes, our feelings contradict our theories; and when this is the
case, the feelings are true, and the theory is false.
What I contend for is, that, in commending the destruction of an absolute monarchy, all the circumstances ought not to be wholly overlooked, as "'considerations fit only for shallow and superficial minds. " (The words of Mr. Fox, or to that effect. )
The subversion of a government, to deserve any
? ? ? ? 80 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
praise, must be considered but as a step preparatory
to the formation of something better, either in the
scheme of the government itself, or in the persons
who administer it, or in both. These events cannot
in reason be separated. For instance, when we praise
our Revolution of 1688, though the nation in that act
was on the defensive, and was justified in incurring
all the evils of a defensive war, we do not rest there.
We always combine with the subversion of the old
government the happy settlement which followed.
When we estimate that Revolution, we mean to comprehend in our calculation both the value of the thing parted with and the value of the thing received
in exchange.
The burden of proof lies heavily on those who tear
to pieces the whole frame and contexture of their
country, that they could find no other way of settling
a government fit to obtain its rational ends, except
that which they have pursued by means unfavorable
to all the present happiness of millions of people, and
to the utter ruin of several hundreds of thousands.
In their political arrangements, men have no right to
put the well-being of the present generation wholly
out of the question. Perhaps the only moral trust
with any certainty in our hands is the care of our
own time. With regard to futurity, we are to treat
it like a ward. We are not so to attempt an improvement of his fortune as to put the capital of his estate to any hazard.
It is not worth our while to discuss, like sophisters, whether in no case some etil for the sake of
some benefit is to be tolerated. Nothing universal
can be rationally affirmed on any moral or any political subject. Pure metaphysical abstraction does not
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 81
belong to these matters. The lines of morality are not
like the ideal lines of mathematics. They are broad
and deep as well as long. They admit of exceptions;
they demand modifications. These exceptions and
modifications are not made by the process of logic,
but by the rules of prudence. Prudence is not only
the first in rank of the virtues political and moral,
but she is the director, the regulator, the standard
of them all. Metaphysics cannot live without definition; but Prudence is cautious how she defines.
Our courts cannot be more fearful in suffering fictitious cases to be brought before them for elicit --
ing their determination on a point of law than pru --
dent moralists are in putting extreme and hazardous cases of conscience upon emergencies not exists ing. Without attempting, therefore, to define, what
never can be defined, the case of a revolution in government, this, I think, may be safely affirmed, - that a sore and pressing evil is to be removed, and that a
good, great in its amount and unequivocal in its
nature, must be probable almost to certainty, before
the inestimable price of our own morals and the wellbeing of a number of our fellow-citizens is paid for a revolution. If ever we ought to be economists even
to parsimony, it is in the voluntary production of evil.
Every revolution contains in it something of evil.
It must always be, to those who are the greatest
amateurs, or even professors, of revolutions, a matter
very hard to prove, that the late French government
was so bad that nothing worse in the infinite devices
of men could come in its place. They who have
brought France to its present condition ought to
prove also, by something better than prattling about
the Bastile, that their subverted government was as
VOL. IV. 6
? ? ? ? 82 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
incapable as tile present certainly is of all improvement and correction. How dare they to say so who have never made that experiment? They are experimpnters by their trade. They have made an hundred others, infinitely more hazardous.
The English admirers of the forty-eight thousand
republics which form the French federation praise
them not for what they are, but for what they are to
become. They do not talk as politicians, but as
prophets. But in whatever character they choose
to found panegyric on prediction, it will be thought
a little singular to praise any work, not for its own
merits, but for the merits of something else which
may succeed to it. When any political institution
is praised, in spite of great and prominent faults of
every kind, and in all its parts, it must be supposed
to have something excellent in its fundamental principles. It must be shown that it is right, though imperfect, -that it is not only by possibility susceptible of improvement, but that it contains in it a principle tending to its melioration.
Before they attempt to show this progression of
their favorite work from absolute pravity to finished
perfection, they will find themselves engaged in a
civil war with those whose cause they maintain.
What! alter our sublime Constitution, the glory of
France, the envy of the world, the pattern for man~ kind, the masterpiece of legislation, the collected and concentrated glory of this enlightened age? Have
we not produced it ready-made and ready-armed,
mature in its birth, a perfect goddess of wisdom and
of war, hammered by our blacksmith midwives out
of the brain of Jupiter himself? Have we not sworn
-our devout, profane, believing, infidel people to an
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 83
allegiance to this goddess, even before she had burst
the dura mater, and as yet existed only in embryo?
Have we not solemnly declared this Constitution unalterable by any future legislature? Have we not bound it on posterity forever, though our abettors
have declared that no one generation is competent
to bind another? Have we not obliged the members
of every future Assembly to qualifiy themselves for
their seats by swearing to its conservation?
Indeed, the French Constitution always must be
(if a change is not made in all their principles ancl
fundamental arrangements) a government wholly by
popular representation. It must be this or nothing.
The French faction considers as an usurpation, as
an atrocious violation of the indefeasible rights of
man, every other description of government. Take
it, or leave it: there is no medium. Let the irrefragabl6 doctors fight out their own controversy in their own way and with their own weapons; and when
they are tired, let them commence a treaty of peace.
Let the plenipotentiary sophisters of England settle
with the diplomatic sophisters of France in what
manner right is to be corrected by an infusion of
wrong, and how truth may be rendered more true
by a due intermixture of falsehood.
Having sufficiently proved that nothing could make
it generally improper for Mr. Burke to prove what
he had alleged concerning the object of this dispute,
I pass to the second question, that is, Whether he was
justified in choosing the committee on the Quebec
Bill as the field for this discussion? If it were necessary, it might be shown that he was not the first to bring these discussions into Parliament, nor the first
? ? ? ? 84 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
to renew them in this session. The fact is notorious.
As to the Quebec Bill, they were introduced into the
debate upon that subject for two plain reasons: First,
that, as he thought it then not advisable to make the
proceedings of the factious societies the subject of a
direct motion, he had no other way open to him.
Nobody has attempted to show that it was at all
admissible into any other business before the House.
Here everything was favorable. Here was a bill to
form a new Constitution for a French province under English dominion. The question naturally arose,
whether we should settle that constitution upon English ideas, or upon French. This furnished an opportunity for examining into the value of the French Constitution, either considered as applicable to colonial government, or in its own nature. The bill, too,
was in a committee. By the privilege of speaking
as often as he pleased, he hoped in some measure to
supply the want of support, which he had but too
much reason to apprehend. In a committee it was
always in his power to bring the questions from generalities to facts, from declamation to discussion.
Some benefit he actually received from this privilege.
These are plain, obvious, natural reasons for his conduct. I believe they are the true, and the only true
ones.
They who justify the frequent interruptions, which
at length wholly disabled him from proceeding, attribute their conduct to a very different interpretation of
his motives. They say, that, through corruption, or
malice, or folly, he was acting his part in a plot to
make his friend Mr. Fox pass for a republican, and
thereby to prevent the gracious intentions of his sovereign from taking effect, which at that time had
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 85
begun to disclose themselves in his favor. * This is
a pretty serious charge. This, on Mr. Burke's part,,
would be something more than mistake, something
worse than formal irregularity. Any contumely, any,
outrage, is readily passed over, by the indulgence:
which we all owe to sudden passion. These thillgs
are soon forgot upon occasions in which all men are
so apt to forget themselves. Deliberate injuries, to a
degree, must be remembered, because they require
deliberate precautions to be secured against their return.
I am authorized to say for Mr. Burke, that he
* To explain this, it will be necessary to advert to a paragraph
which appeared in a paper in the minority interest some time before:
this debate. " A very dark intrigue has lately been discovered, the,
authors of which are well known to us; but until the glorious day:
shall come when it will not be a LIBEL to tell the TRUTH, We must
not be so regardless of our own safety as to publish their names. .
We will, however, state the fact, leaving it to the ingenuity of our
readers to discover what we dare not publish.
"Since the business of the armament against Russia has been
under discussion, a great personage has been heard to say,' that he,
was not so wedded to Mr. PITT as not to be very willing to give his
confidence to Mr. Fox, if the latter should be able, in a crisis like the,
present, to conduct the government of the country with greater advan-,
tage to the public. '
"This patriotic declaration immediately alarmed the swarm of'
courtly insects that live only in the sunshine of ministerial favor. It
was thought to be the forerunner of the dismission of Mr. Pitt, and
every engine was set at work for the purpose of preventing such an
event. The principal engine employed on this occasion was CALUISNY. It was whispered in the ear'of a great personage, that Mr. Fox was the last man in England to be trusted by a KING, because he was
by PRINCIPLE a REPUBLICAN, and consequently an enemy to MONARCHY.
"In the discussion of the Quebec Bill which stood for yesterday, it
was the intention of some persons to connect with this subject the
? ? ? ? 86 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
considers that cause assigned for the outrage offered
to him as telln times worse than the outrage itself.
There is such a strange confusion of ideas on this
subject, that it is far more difficult to understand
the nature of the charge than to refute it when understood. Mr. Fox's friends were, it seems, seized
with a sudden panic terror lest he should pass for a
republican. I do not think they had any ground
for this apprehension. But let us admit they had.
What was there in the Quebec Bill, rather than in
ally other, which could subject him or them to that
imputationl? Nothing in a discussion of the French
Constitution, which might arise on the Quebec Bill,
French Revolution, in hopes that Mr. Fox would be warmed by a collision with Mr. Burke, and induced to defend that Revolution, in which so much power was taken from, and so little left in the crown.
Had Mr. Fox fallen into the snare, his speech on the occasion
would have been laid before a great personage, as a proof that a man
who could defend such a revolution might be a very good republican,
but could not possibly be a friend to monarchy.
" But those who laid the snare were disappointed; for Mr. Fox, in
the short conversation which took place yesterday in the House of
Commons, said, that he confessedly had thought favorably of the
French Revolution, but that most certainly he never had, either in
Parliament or out of Parliament, professed or defended republican
principles. " -Argus, April 22d, 1791.
Mr. Burke cannot answer for the truth nor prove the falsehood of
the story given by the friends of the party in this paper. He only
knows that an opinion of its being well or ill authenticated had no
influence on his conduct. He meant only, to the best of his power,
to guard the public against the ill designs of factions out of doors.
What Mr. Burke did in Parliament could hardly have been intended
to draw Mr. Fox into any declarations unfavorable to his principles,
since (by the account of those who are his friends) he had long before effectually prevented the success of any such scandalous designs. Mr. Fox's friends have themselves done away that imputation on Mr.
Burke.
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS.