"
cognition generally, and then how this general ob-
In giving a sketch or of Aristotle's ject branches out into separate species, and first
philosophy, we must be satisfied with a mere out- really manifests itself in these.
cognition generally, and then how this general ob-
In giving a sketch or of Aristotle's ject branches out into separate species, and first
philosophy, we must be satisfied with a mere out- really manifests itself in these.
William Smith - 1844 - Dictionary of Greek and Roman Antiquities - a
ing would be the original order of the books : i. ii. 9. 'Απορήματα Ομηρικά. (See Nitzsch, de Arist.
iii. vii. viii. iv. vi. v. On the other hand, Biese adv. Wolfunos, Kilae, 1831. )
(Phil. des Arist. ii. p. 400) has acutely defended 10. Περί Αλεξάνδρου, a work of doubtful au-
the old order.
thenticity.
The best editions of the Politics are by Schnei- We now turn to those writings of Aristotle
der, Francof. ad Viadr. 1809, 2 vols. ; Corais, Paris which, as belonging to the emothUN TONTT), have
1821 ; Göttling, Jenae, 1824; Stahr, with a Ger- for their subject the exercise of the creative faculty,
man translation, Lips. 1837; Barthélemy St. Hi- or Art. To these belong the Poetics and Rhetoric.
laire, with a French translation, and a very good 1. The Poetics (Tiepl Tointikńs). Aristotle pe-
introduction, Paris, 1837.
netrated deeper than any of the ancients, either
Of the work extant under Aristotle's name, the before or after him, into the essence of Hellenic
Oeconomics (oikovojird), in two books, only the art, and with the most comprehensive mind tra-
first book is genuine; the second is spurious. versed the region in which the intellectual life of
(Niebuhr, Kleine Schr. i. p. 412. ) The first book the Hellenes unfolded itself, and brought it under
is ascribed to Theophrastus in a fragment of Philo- the dominion of science. He is the father of the
demus. (Herculanens. vol. iii. pp. vii. xxvii. ) The aesthetics of poetry, as he is the completer of Greek
rhetoric as a science. The treatise itself is un-
* For this section Aristotle had made preparation doubtedly genuine; but the explanation of its pre-
by his collection of 158 Hellenic constitutions; of sent form is still a problem of criticism. Some
which hercafter.
(as Gottf. llermann and Bernhardy) look upon it
## p. 332 (#352) ############################################
332
ARISTOTELES.
ARISTOTELES.
a
not
1
as the first sketch of an uncompleted work; others, inasmuch as earlier rhetoricians, as he says, had
as an extract from a larger work; others again, as treated this most important subject in an exceed-
the notes, taken by some hearer, of lectures deli- ingly superficial manner. The second main divi-
vered by Aristotle. Thus much, however, is clear, sion of the work treats of the production of that
that the treatise, as we have it at present, is an favourable disposition in the hearer, in consequence
independent whole, and, with the exception of a , of which the orator appears to him to be worthy of
few interpolations, the work of one author. Farther, credit. Yet it is not sufficient merely to know
that the lost work nepl Tointwv, a history of the what must be said, ---one must also say this in a
literature of poetry, must not be confounded with proper manner, if the speech is to produce the in-
the Poetics, to which it stands in the same relation tended effect. Therefore in the third part be
as the Polities do to the Politics. As regards the treats of oratorical expression and arrangement.
contents of the Poetics, Aristotle, like Plato, starts The best edition with a commentary is the one
from the principle of the imitation, or imitative re published at Oxford, 1820, 8vo. ; but a good critical
presentation (uiumous), either of a real object exist- and explanatory edition is still a desideratum.
ing in the external world, or of one produced by Among the writings of Aristotle we also find
the internal power of imagination. It is in accord- 3. A work on Rhetoric addressed to Alexander
ance with this view that the different species of (*PnTopino, após 'Anéfavopov); but it is spurious,
art generally, and of poetry in particular, assume and should probably be ascribed to Anaximenes
their definite forms. The activity of art is distin- of Lampsacus. Others consider its author to have
guished from practical activity in this respect : been Theodectes or Corax.
that in the case of the former the exercise of the
C. MISCELLANEOUS Works.
creative faculty, the production of a work, is the
main thing; and that the internal condition, the Among the writings which Aristotle left behind
disposition, of the person who exercises this crea- him, there was undoubtedly a large number of
tive faculty, is a matter of indifference. The Collectanea, which had grown up under the hand
greatest part of the treatise (cc. 6—22) contains a of the philosopher in the course of his extended
theory of tragedy; nothing else is treated of, with studies. To these writings, which were
the exception of the epos; comedy is merely al originally destined for publication, belong
luded to. The best editions of the work are by 1. The Problems (i pobanuara), in 36 sections,
Gottf. Hermann, Lips. 1802, with philological and questions on individual points in all the depart-
philosophical (Kantian) explanations ; Gräfenban, ments of knowledge, a treasure of the deepest and
Lips. 1821, an ill-arranged compilation; Bekker, most acute remarks, which has been far from being
Berol. 1832, 8vo. ; and Ritter, Colon. 1839, properly used and sifted. A good edition is a
8vo.
Ritter considers two-thirds of the Poetics desideratum. (Compare Chabanon, Trois Mémoires
to consist of the interpolations of a later and sur les Problèmes d'Arist, in the Mém. de l'Acad.
extremely silly editor; but his opinion has been des Inscript. vol. xlvi. p. 285, &c. , p. 326, &c.
almost universally rejected in Germany.
2. Θαυμάσια Ακούσματα, short notices and ac-
explanatory writings, besides Lessing's Ham- counts of various phaenomena, chietly connected
burgische Dramaturgie, we need mention only with natural history, of very unequal value, and
Miller, Gesch, der Theorie der Kunst bei den Alten, in part manifestly not of Aristotelian origin. The
pt. ii. pp. 1–181, and the German translation by best edition is by Westermann, in his Rerum
Knebel, Stuttgart, 1840.
Mirabil. script. Graeci, Bruns. 1839.
2. The Rhetoric (Téxin OnTopik), in three
books. Aristotle, in accordance with his method,
D. LETTERS.
as we have already observed in the case of the All those which are extant are spurious: the
Physics, Politics, and Poetics, before proceeding to genuine and copious collection of Aristotle's letters,
lay down a theory of rhetoric, prepared a safe which antiquity possessed, is lost. Those which
foundation by means of extensive studies. These were arranged by Andronicus of Rhodes filled 20
studies gave rise to a separate historical work books. (Pseudo-Demetrius, de Elocut. § 231. )
(entitled 7exvæv ouvaywyn), in which he collected A later collection by Artemon, a learned Christian
all the earlier theories of the rhetoricians from of the third century, consisted of 8 books. (See
Tisias and Corax onwards. From the latter work David, Categ. p. 24, a. 1. 27, ed. Berol. ) David
the Aristotelian rhetoric developed itself, a work of (p. 22, a. 21, Berol. ) praises the clear, simple,
which, as regards its leading features, the first noble style of Aristotle's letters, a description
sketch was drawn at an early period;-it has been which is quite at variance with the character of
already mentioned that the first lectures and those that are extant. Respecting Aristotle's will,
written works of Aristotle treated of rhetoric;--it which Diog. Laërt. (v. ll--16) has preserved,
was then carefully enlarged from time to time, we have spoken before. (p. 321, a. ]
and enriched with remarks drawn from the olm
servation of human life and knowledge through
E. POEMS AND SPEECHES.
many years.
The period of its composition is There are preserved
treated of by Max. Schmidt, De tempore quo al 1. The Scolion addressed to Hermias, which we
Arist. libri de Arte Rhetor. conscripti et editi sint, have already mentioned. (In Ilgen, Scolia, Jenae,
Halle, 1837.
1798, p. 137 ; Gräfenhan, Aristot. poeta, Mul-
Rhetoric, as a science, according to Aristotle, stands husae, 1831, 4to. ; Bergk, Poëtae Lyrici Graeci. )
side by side (áutiotpoqov) with Dialectics. That 2. Two epigrams, the one on a statue erected to
which alone makes a scientific treatment of rheto his friend Hermias, and one on an altar dedicated
ric possible is the argumentation which awakens to Plato.
conviction (αι γαρ πίστεις έντεχνόν έστι μόνον). The speeches of Aristotle which are lost, were
He therefore directs his chief attention to the | Απολογία ευσεβείας προς Ευρυμέδοντα, of which
theory of oratorical argumentation; and the more, we have already spoken ; an 'Eyku ulov TAOÚTou,
As
## p. 333 (#353) ############################################
ARISTOTELES.
333
ARISTOTELES.
and an 'Eykóklov asyov. Among the writings / which had been formed of Aristotle's philosophy
which were foisted upon Aristotle in the middle up to the time of Hegel, was, that Aristotle had
ages, there were the treatises (in Latin): 1. Mys- made what is called experience the principle of
licuc Aegyptiorum philosophiac libr. xiv. , a compila- knowledge and cognition. Accordingly the Aris
tion from Plotinus. (Clussical Journal, vol. xv. p. totelian philosophy, as realism in the most ordinary
279. ) 4. De Pomo (translated from the Hebrew sense of the word, was placed in direct opposition
by Manfred, son of the emperor Frederick 11. ), a to the Platonic idealism. This complete misap-
treatise on the immortality of the soul. 3. Secreta prehension of the Aristotelian philosophy proceed-
secretorum (doctrines on prudence and the art of ed from various causes. Firstly and chiefly, from
government), and others.
want of acquaintance with the writings of Aris-
totle. Little more than twenty years ago Aristotle
IV. LEADING FEATURES OF ARISTOTLE'S
was still very little read. We have seen how
PhiloSOPHY.
even the philological study of his writings was
All that the Hellenes had as yet attained in the neglected for centuries ; and the philosophical
whole compass of science and art, was embraced by study of them fared no better. The properly
the gigantic mind of Aristotle, which, so to say, speculative writings, the logical and metaphysical
traversed in thought all that the Hellenic world i works, were scarcely read by any one. Nay, even
had up to that time struggled and lived through, on certain aesthetical propositions (e. g. on the three
and transmitted to posterity in his writings and unities of the drama) false traditions prevailed,
philosophy the result, as reflected in his mind, of which were utterly unsubstantiated by the Poctics.
this earlier age.
Aristotle stands at the turning And yet the Poetics was one of the most read and
point of Hellenic life, when, after the original forms most easily accessible of his writings. To this
of political existence and art were completed, after were added other causes. Very many derived
the close of the age of production, the period of their acquaintance with Aristotelian philosophy
reflection stept in, and endeavoured by the exercise from Cicero, in whose works Aristotle appears only
of thought to possess itself of the immense mass of as a moral philosopher and natural historian.
materials that had been gained. And we cannot Others confounded the so-called scholastic Aristo-
but admire the Divine Providence, which sum-telism with the genuine Aristotelian philosophy,
moned to this task a mind like Aristotle's, at the which, however, in the schoolmen appears as mere
very time when the contemplation of the past was empty formalism. Others, lastly, overlooked in
still fresh and lively, and tradition still recent; and the consideration of the method in which Aristotle
which called forth all his powers by placing him in pbilosophized the essential character of the philo-
the midst of the new impetus which the Hellenic sophy itself. This last circumstance in particular
mind had received through the Macedonian con- introduced that false conception, according to which
quest of the world
Thus did the genius of the common empeiria experience, was looked upon as
age find in Aristotle its first and wonderful in the principle of Aristotelian philosophy. We must
strument. We have already, in enumerating his therefore first endeavour to make clear Aristotle's
works, had occasion to admire the universality of method.
the philosopher, for whom a mythical legend of the The peculiar method of Aristotle stands in close
foundation of a city was not less attractive than connexion with the universal direction which he
speculations on first causes and highest ends, or gave to his intellectual exertions, striving to pene-
observations on animal life and poetry. Quot trate into the whole compass of knowledge. In
saeculis," exclaims Quintilian (Or. Inst. xii. 11. this endeavour he certainly sets out from experi-
$ 22) in astonishment, “ Aristoteles didicit, ut non ence, in order first to arrive at the consciousness of
solum quae ad philosophos et oratores pertinerent that which really exists, and so to grasp in thought
scientia complecteretur, sed animalium satorumque the multiplicity and breadth of the sensible and
naturas omnes perquireret. " Aristotle," says spiritual world. Thus he always first lays hold of
Hegel (Gesch. der Philosophie, ii. p. 298), “ pene- his subject externally, separates that in it which is
trated into the whole mass and into every depart- merely accidental, renders prominent the contra-
ment of the universe of things, and subjected to dictions which result, seeks to solve them and to
the comprehension its scattered wealth ; and the refer them to a higher idea, and so at last arrives
greater number of the philosophical sciences owe to at the cognition of the ideal intrinsic nature, which
him their separation and commencement. While manifests itself in every separate object of reality.
in this manner science separates itself into a series in this manner he consecutively develops the ob-
of definitions, the Aristotelian philosophy at the jects as well of the natural as of the spiritual world,
same time contains the most profound speculative proceeding genetically from the lower to the higher,
ideas. He is more comprehensive and speculative from the more known to the less known, and
than any one else. And although his system does translates the world of experience into the ldca.
not appear developed in its several parts, but the Accordingly he usually first points out how, when
parts stand side by side, they yet form a totality an object is produced, it first presents itself to our
of essentially speculative philosophy.
"
cognition generally, and then how this general ob-
In giving a sketch or of Aristotle's ject branches out into separate species, and first
philosophy, we must be satisfied with a mere out- really manifests itself in these. In this way he
line, to which an accurate study of Aristotle's also develops the origin of science itself geneti-
works alone can give completeness. * The true and
correct apprehension of the nature of Aristotle's a Hegel's Vorlesungen über Gesch. der Philoso-
philosophy is due to the revolution which philosophie, ii. pp. 298–422.
phy itself has undergone in Germany through Biese, Die Philosophie des Aristoteles in ihrem
the influence of Hegel. The universal conception Zusammenhange, mit besonderer Berücksichtigung des
philosophischen Sprachgebrauchs, vol. i. , Berlin,
* The best works upon his philosophy are- 1835, and vol. ii. , 1842.
66
a
sum
## p. 334 (#354) ############################################
334
ARISTOTELES.
ARISTOTELES.
or not.
|
cally; hc seizes upon the individual steps of con. bined by the vigorous self-development of the idea
sciousness, from the impression on the senses to the into one whole, the several members of which are
highest exercise of reason, and exhibits the internal mutually connected and dependent. This, the de-
wealth of intellectual life. He sets out, therefore, monstration of the unity of idea in the entire uni-
from the individual, the concrete individual exist- verse of natural and spiritual life, was a problem
ence of the apparent world; and this is the empir which was reserved for after ages.
icul side of his philosophy. The beginning of his The composition of Aristotle's writings stands
philosophical investigations is external. But the in close connexion with the method of his philoso-
end in view manifests itself in the course of them. phizing. Here the object of investigation is always
For, while in this way he begins with the external, first laid down and distinctly defined, in order to
he steadily endeavours to bring into prominent obviate any misunderstanding. Thereupon he
and distinct relief the intrinsic nature of each sepa- gives an historical review of the way in which the
rate thing according to the internal formative subject has been hitherto treated by earlier philo-
principles which are inherent in it, and essentially sophers (Phys. i. 2, &c. , de Anima, i. 2, Metaph.
belong to it.
i. 3, &c. , Eth. Nic. i. 3, Magn. Mor. i. 1, Polit. ii. );
Next to this starting-point, an essential part of and indeed it may be remarked generally, that
his method is the exhibition and removal of the Aristotle is the father of the history of philosophy.
difficulties which come in the way in the course of the The investigation itself then begins with the exhi-
investigation (droplai, duoxépeian, Comp. Metaph. bition of the difficulties, doubts, and contradictions
iii. 1, p. 40, 20). “For," says Aristotle, " those which present themselves (atropiai, dropruara).
who investigate without removing the difficulties. These are sifted, and discussed and explained on
are like persons who do not know whither they all sides (daropeiv), and the solution and recon.
ought to go, and at the same time never perceive ciliation of them (arois, europeîv, in opposition to
whether they have found what they were seeking atopeiv) is given in the course of the investigation.
For the end in view is not clear to such a (Metaph. i. init
. p. 40, Brandis, Phys. iv. 4, p. 211,
person, but is clear to one who has previously ac- 1. 7, ed. Berol. ) In this enumeration of the various
quired a consciousness of the difficulties. Lastly, views and apories, Aristotle is not unfrequently
that person must necessarily be in a better condi- explicit to a degree which wearies the reader, as it
tion for judging, who has, as it were, heard all the is continued without any internal necessity.
opposing doctrines as though they were antagonist
parties pleading before a tribunal. ” Hence he v. RELATION OF THE ARISTOTELIN Pulila
everywhere has regard to his predecessors, and
SOPHY TO THE PLATONIC.
endeavours carefully to develop the foundation In the Platonic philosophy the opposition be-
and relative truth of their doctrines. (Metaph. l. 3, tween the real and the ideal had completely de
Top. i. 2. ) In this manner Aristotle proceeds with veloped itself. For while the opposition and con-
an impartiality which reminds one of the epic re- tradiction in the ideal--in the world of thought-
pose in Homer, and which may easily give him a was conquered by Plato's dialectics, the external
tinge of scepticisin and indefiniteness, where the and sensible world was looked upon as a world of
solution does not immediately follow the aporia, appearance, in which the ideas cannot attain to
but occurs in the progress of the development. true and proper reality. Between these two, the
Intimately connected with his endeavour to set world of ideas and the visible world of appenr-
out with that which is empirically known, is his ances, there exists, according to Plato, only a
practice of everywhere making conceptions of the passing relation of participation (mébefus) and
ordinary understanding of men, manners, and cus- imitation, in so far namely as the ideas, as the
toms, proverbs, religious conceptions (comp. Metaph. prototypes, can only to a certain extent rule the
xii. 8, xiv. 8, de Caelo, ii. 1, de Generat. Anim. i. 2), formless and resisting matter, and fashion it into a
and above all, language, the points on which to visible existence. Plato accordingly made the ex-
hang his speculative investigations. The Ethics in ternal world the region of the incomplete and bad,
particular give abundant proofs of the last. Thus, of the contradictory and false, and recognized ab-
advancing from the lower to the higher, from the solute truth only in the eternal immutable ideas.
more imperfect to the more perfect, he constantly Now this opposition, which set fixed limits to cog-
brings into notice the entelecheia (éYTENÉXeba), or nition, was surmounted by Aristotle. He laid
that to which everything, according to its pecu- down the proposition, that the idea, which cannot
liarity, is capable of attaining ; whereupon, again of itself fashion itself into reality, is powerless, and
he also points out in this entelecheia the higher has only a potential existence, and that it becomes
principle through which the entelecheia itself be a living reality only by realizing itself in a crealive
comes a potentiality (Súvayıs). In this manner he manner by means of its own energy. (Metaph.
exhibits the different steps of development in na- xii. 6, p. 246. 8. , Brandis. ) The transition
tural existence in their internal relation to each of the ideal into the real, however, Aristotle ex-
other, and so at last arrives at the highest unity, plains by means of the pure idea of negation
consisting in the purpose and cause, which, in its (otépnois). That is to say, ideality and reality
creative, organizing activity, makes of the manifold are not opposed to each other, as existence and
and different forms of the universe one internally non-existence, according to Plato's view; but the
connected whole.
material itself contains in itself the opposition, the
With all this, however, we must bear in mind, negation, through which it comes to have a kind of
that this method did not lead Aristotle to a perfect feeling of want, and strives after the ideal forn, as
and compact system. The philosophy of Aristotle the ugly strives after the beautiful. The giving it
is not such. in every single science he always, so a definite form does awav not with the matter,
to say, starts afresh from the commencement. The but with the negation which is inherent in the
individual parts of his philosophy, therefore, sub- matter, and by that means the material is fashioned
sist independently side by side, and are not com. so as to assume a definite existence. Thus matter
## p. 335 (#355) ############################################
ARISTOTELES.
335
ARISTOTELES.
is that which is eternal, fundamental, whilst the After substance (ovo ía) Aristotle first treats
single object, fashioned so as to assume an indivi- of quantity, which with that which is relative
dual existence is produced, and perishes. The ma- attaches to the material of the substance, then
terial in which the negation is inherent, is the passes to what is qualitative, which has reference
potentiality (súvauis), out of which the formative especially to the determination of the form of the
principle, as an entelecheia, fashions itself into ex object. (In the Metaphysics on the other hand
istence. This, as the full reality (évépzena), is the (v. 15), where the categories are defined more in
higher step in opposition to the mere potentiality. accordance with our conceptions of them, the in-
According to these definitions, the Aristotelian vestigation on the qualitative precedes that on the
philosophy progresses genetically from the lower to relative. ) The six remaining categories are treated
the higher, from the dúvapıs to the evTché xela of of only in short outlines.
that, of which the potential, according to its pecu- The object of the categories is, to render possi-
liarity, is capable. Thus by nieans of the cron* ble the cognition of the enormous multiplicity of
the universe becomes a whole consisting of mu- phaenomena ; since by means of them those modes of
tually connected members, in which these eron viewing things which constantly recur in connexion
attain to full existence. In inorganic nature the with existence arc fixed, and thus the necessity for
purpose is still identical with the necessity of the advancing step by step ad infinitum is removed.
maiter ; but in organic nature it comes into exist- But in Aristotle's view they are not the ultimatum
ence as the soul of the enlivened object (yuxý). for cognition. They rather denote only the differ-
The energy (évépyela) of the soul is, as an entele- ent modes in which anything is inherent in the
cheia, thought, both voûs mantikos, since, as the substance, and are truly and properly determined
temporary activity of the mind, it is necessarily only by means of that which is substantial. This
dependent on the co-operation of the senses, and again is determined by the eldos, which is what is
volls TointiKÓS, i. e. cognoscent, self-acting reason, essential in the material, and owes its existence to
in so far as, in the pure element of thought freed the purpose of the thing. This purpose, and
from what is sensuous, it elevates the finite world nothing short of this, is an ultimatum for cognition.
into cognoscible truth. From this exalted point of The highest opposition in which the purpose
view Aristotle regarded and subjected to inquiry realises itself is that of dúvauis and {vtené Xela.
the entire empire of reality and life, as it had (Arist. de Anima, ii. c. 1. )
developed itself up to his time in science, arts, and The categories are single words (τα άνευ συμ-
politics.
alorñs deyóueva). As such, they are in them-
VI. ARISTOTELIAN Logic.
selves neither true nor false. They become both
Aristotle is the creator of the science of logic. only in the union of ideas by means of mutual
The two deepest thinkers of Germany, Kant and reference in a proposition (td kard ouut horriv
Hegel, acknowledge that from the time of Aris. Aeyoueva). A proposition is the expression
totle to their own age logic had made no progress. (dpuúvera) of reflecting thonght, which separates
Aristotle has described the pure forms and opera- and combines (dialpeois, ouundunh). This opera-
tions of abstract reason, of finite thought, with the tion of thought manifests itself first of all in judg-
accuracy of an investigator of nature, and his logic ment. In this way Aristotle succeeds in advan-
is, as it were, a natural history of this “finite cing from the categories to the doctrine of the ex-
thought. "
pression of thought (éputvera). Here he treats
Aristotle obtains the categories, the fundamen- first of all of the component elements of the pro-
tal conceptions of thought, from language, in which position, then of simple propositions, together with
these universal forms of thought appear as parts of the mode of their opposition with reference to the
speech. These categories (κατηγορίαι, also κατηγ-
true and the false; lastly, of compound propositions
ορήματα, τα κατηγορούμενα) give all the possible | (αι συμπλεκόμενοι αποφάνσεις), or modal forms of
definitions for the different modes in which every- judgment (ai atopávo eis uetá pórov), out of
thing that exists may be viewed; they are the which the category of modality was afterwards
most universal expressions for the relations which formed.
constantly recur in things ; fundamental definitions, In the second part of the treatise nepi épunveias
which cannot be comprehended under any higher the different modes of opposition of both kinds of
generic conception, and are, therefore, called wévn. propositions are discussed. The essence of judg-
Yet they are not themselves generic conceptions, ment, which presents itself in a visible form in the
which gire what is essential in an object, but the proposition, consists in this, that the idea, which
most universal modes of expressing it. An inde in itself is neither true nor false, separates itself
pendent existence belongs to ovolan substance, into the momenta peculiar to it, the universal, the
alone of all the categories ; the rest denote particular, the individual, and that the relation be-
only the different modes of what is inherent. The tween these momenta is either established by
categories themselves, therefore, are not an ultima means of affirmation, or abolished by means of
tum, by means of which the true cognition of an negation.
object can be attained. The most important pro- Judgment, however, stands in essential relation
position in Aristotle's doctrine of substances + is, to conclusion. In judgment, Universal and Parti-
that “the universal attains to reality only in the cular are referred to each other; these two mo-
individual” (uni ovow oùy twv apurwv ovoiwv menta of our conceptions separate themselves, with
αδύνατον των άλλων τι είναι).
reference to the conclusion, into two premises
(a por does), of which the one asserts the universal,
eldos is the internal formative principle; ubpon the other the particular. (Anal. pr. i. 25; to mer
is the external form itself.
ως όλον, το δε ως μέρος. ) The conclusion itself,
+ The apuéto ouoia expresses the essential qua- however, is that expression, in which, from certain
lities only, the dettepai ovolai are substances, in- premises, something else beyond the premises is
cluding both essential and accidental qualities. necessarily deduced. But the conclusion is still
## p. 336 (#356) ############################################
336
ARISTOTELES.
ARISTOTELES.
considered apart from its particular contents; it is means of induction. (Anal. post. ii. 7. ) We find
treated quite as a form, and the remark is at the out the essence of a thing only when we know the
same time made, that for that very reason it as yet essential attributes of the thing, and its existence
supplies us with no knowledge (étuotuun). But itself. Aristotle analyses the different kinds of
because this abstract universal possesses greater definition (Anal. post. ii. 10), then treats of the
facilities for subjective cognition, Aristotle makes individual causes (for the definition declares the
the doctrine of the syllogism precede that of why of a thing with reference to its essence), and
proof, for according to him, proof is a particular Instly lays down the method of finding a correct
kind of conclusion. (Anal. pr. i. 4. ) Accordingly, definition. (Anal. post. ii. 11, &c. ii. 13. ) The ob-
together with the mode of its formation, he treats ject of definition is to comprehend the whole ac-
of the figures of the syllogism, and the different cording to its essential differences, and to refer
forms of conclusion in them. (cc. 1-27. ) Then he these again to the genus, in order by these means
gives directions for finding with ease the syllogistic to bring under contemplation the whole as a unity
figures for each problem that is proposed (Europe), consisting of mutually connected and dependent
and lastly shews how to refer given conclusions to members. One aid in definition is suiniivision
their principles, and to arrange them according to (olalpecus). The definition must be clear and dis-
preinises. Thereupon, in the second book of the rinct. This distinctness is attained by endeavour-
Analytics, he treats of the complete conclusion ing first to define the particular, in order to become
according to its peculiar determining principles acquainted with the import of it in every species.
(Anal. ii
. 1—15), points out errors and deficiencies The use of definition is especially important in
in concluding (cc. 16–21), and teaches how to proposing problenis. (Anal. post. ii.