of the statement of the grammarian, that Aristo- From what has been said in the early part of this
phanes assigned to him the plays against Socrates article, a strong presumption may be gathered that
and Euripides, coupled with the known fact that the persons in whose names the dramas of others
the Froys were exhibited in the name of Philo- were exhibited were themselves poets, who had
nides ; but, however this may be, we find that, in already gained a certain degree of reputation, but
the following year, B.
phanes assigned to him the plays against Socrates article, a strong presumption may be gathered that
and Euripides, coupled with the known fact that the persons in whose names the dramas of others
the Froys were exhibited in the name of Philo- were exhibited were themselves poets, who had
nides ; but, however this may be, we find that, in already gained a certain degree of reputation, but
the following year, B.
William Smith - 1844 - Dictionary of Greek and Roman Antiquities - c
ii.
p.
482.
)
(armamentarium) in the Peiraeeus, containing arms The other question respecting Philonides is one
for 1000 ships (Plin. H. N. vii. 37. s. 38). This of very great importance in connection with the
work, which excited the greatest admiration (Cic. literary history of the Old Comedy in general, and
de Orut. i. 14 ; Strab. ix. p. 395, d. ; Val. Max. of Aristophanes in particular. It is generally
viii. 12. ext. 2), was destroyed in the taking of believed that Philonides was an actor of Ariston
Athens by Sulla. (Plut. Sulla, 14). He wrote phanes, who is said to have committed to him
works on the architecture of temples, and on the and to Callistratus his chief characters. But the
naval basin which he constructed in the Peiraeeus. evidence on which this statement rests is regarded
(Vitruv. vii. Praef. § 12. )
S
by some of the best modern critics as leading to
3. A sculptor (1. Bouprós), whose name appears a very different conclusion, namely, that several of
on an inscription recently discovered at Delphi. the plays of Aristophanes were brought out in
(Ross, Inscr. Graec. Ined. Fasc. i. n. 73. p. 30 ; the names of Callistratus and Philonides. This
R. Rochette, Lettre à M. Schorn, p. 384, 2nd ed. ) question has been treated of by such scholars as
4. An engraver of medals, whose name is seen Ranke, C. F. Hermann, Fritzsch, Hanorius, W.
on the front of the helmet of the head of Minerva, Dindorf, and Droysen ; bit by for the most elabo-
which is the type of several coins of Heracleia in rate and satisfactory discussion of it is that by
Lucania. The letters are extremely minute, and the Theodor Bergk, prefixed to his edition of the fraga
inscription is sometimes in the form PIA, sometimes ments of Aristophanes, in Meineke's Fragmenia
pian. (R. Rochette, Lettre à M. Schorn, p. 94, Comicorum Graecorum, vol. ii. pp. 902—939.
2nd ed. )
[P. S. ] It must be remeinbered that, when a poet
PHILONI'CUS, artists. 1. C. Cornelius, a wished to exhibit a drama, he had first to apply to
Roman artist in silver, whose name occurs in an either the first or second archon for a chorus, his
inscription found at Narbonne, FABER ARGENT. obtaining which depended on the opinion of the
(Gruter, p. dcxxxix. 5). This inscription is one archon as to the merits of his play, and also in no
of several proofs that this branch of the arts was small degree on personal and political influence.
diligently cultivated in (aul under the early em- We even find choruses refused to such poets as
perors. "In other inscriptions we find mention Sophocles and Cratinus. Even when he succeeded
made of Vasclarii Argentari, specimens of whose in obtaining a chorus, he had to encounter the
work are furnished by beautiful silver vases, which proverbial capriciousness of an Athenian audience,
have been found in Gaul. (R. Rochette, Lettre à whose treatment even of old favourites was, as
M. Schorn, p. 385, 2nd ed. )
Aristophanes complains, no small discouragement
2. M. Canuleius, an artist, whose name occurs to a young candidate for their favour. In order to
in an inscription (Gruter, p. xxv. l), where he is reduce the obstacles which a young poet found
designated as Geniarius, that is, a maker of little thus placed in his way upon the very threshold,
figures of genii. (R. Rochette, l. c. ) [P. S. ] two courses were customary: the candidate for
PHILO'NIDES ($! Awvions), an Athenian dramatic honours either brought out in his own
comic poet of the Old Comedy, who is, however, name the play of some popular poet, the intrinsic
better known as one of the two persons in whose merit of which was sure to obtain a chorus, or else
names Aristophanes brought out some of his plays, he availed himself of the reputation of a well-
than by his own dramas. The information we have known poet by applying for a chorus in his name.
of him as a poet can be stated in a very few words ; The result was that by the former plan, which we
but the question of his connection with Aristo know to have been adopted by the sons of Aeschy-
phanes demands a careful examination.
lus, Sophocles, and Aristophanes, the young poet's
Before becoming a poet, Philonides was either a name became known, and he could more easily
fuller or a painter, according to the different texts hope to obtain a chorus for one of his own plass;
of Suidas and Eudocia, the former giving yvapeús, and, in the latter case, the reception of his works
the latter ypapeús. Three of his plays are men- would encourage him to appear again under his
tioned, 'Atvn, Kódopvoi, and Diétaipos (Suid. own name, or the contrary. There is, in fact, a
8. . ). The title of Kódopvoi would of itself lead passage of Aristophanes, which, if the figure be
us to suppose that it was an attack upon Thera- interpreted closely, would suggest the notion that
menes, whose party fickleness had gained him the it was customary for a young poet to pass through
well-known epithet Kóbopvos, and this conjecture the following three stages : the first, assisting
is fully confirmed by the following passage of a another poet in the composition of the less im-
grammarian (Bekker, Anecd. p. 100. 1): Onpa- portant passages of his plays (like the pupils of a
μένης της κλητικήν· Φιλιππίδης Κοθόρνοις, where great artist), as we know Eupolis to have worked
we ought no doubt to read ! Awvidrs, for no such under Aristophanes in the Knights ; then putting
play of Philippides is ever mentioned, but the out his own dramas under the name of another
Kódopvol of Philonides, besides being mentioned poet, in order to see how the popular favour in-
by Suidas, is several times quoted by Athenaeus clined ; and lastly, producing them in his own
and other writers. The plural number of the title, name. These several stages are perhaps intimated
Κόθορνοι, is no doubt because the chorus consisted by the phrases, Ερέτην γένεσθαι, πρωρατεύσαι και
of persons of the character of Theramenes. We τους ανέμους διαθρησαι, and κυβερνάν αυτόν εαυτό
have another example of that confusion between in the passage alluded to (Eq. 511--543, see
names beginning with Phil. , which has been no- Bergk, l. c. pp. 916, 917). In addition to the
ticed under Philemon, in the fact that many frag- reasons just stated, there is a very common opinion,
## p. 315 (#331) ############################################
PHILONIDES.
315
PHILONIDES.
founded on the statement of a grammarian (Schol. / at first exceedingly cautious and otherwise clever,
in Aristoph. Nub. 530), that an express law for- he brought out (kalier, the regular word for bringing
bade a poet to exhibit a drama in his own name into a contest) his first dramas in the names of
while he was under thirty years of age ; but (Sid) Callistratus and Philonides ; wherefore he
Bergk has shown (l. c. pp. 906, 907) that this law was ridiculed . . . . on the ground that he labouret
is probably one of those innumerable fictions of the for others : but afterwards he contended in his own
commentators, who state as facts things which are nume (autós nywvioato):” here again the plırase
simply the expression of their own notion of their “ that he laboured for others" must imply that
author's meaning; for Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Callistratus and Philonides were poets.
Euripides are all known to have brought out Thus far all is clear and consistent. Aristo-
plays in their own names while they were under phanes, from motives of modesty and caution,
thirty.
but not from any legal necessity, began to exhibit,
Now, in every case, the name enrolled in the not in his own name, but in that of Callistratus,
public records was that of the person in whose and afterwards of Pbilonides. The success of
name the chorus was applied for, whether he were these first efforts encouraged him to come forward
the real author or not, and this is the name which as the avowed author of his plays ; and again,
appears in the Didasculiu prefixed to a play under towards the close of his life, he aided his son
the form εδιδάχθη δια Καλλιστράτου (Acharn. ), or Araros, by allowing him to bring out some of his
di autoŮ TOÛ Apotopávous (Equit. ). In fact, dramas (the Cocalus for example) in his own name.
according to the original spirit of the institution, the But at the close of this very same Life of Aris-
chorus was the only essential part of a play, tophanes (p. xxxix. ) we find the error which we
and the public functionaries knew nothing of the have to expose, but yet combined with truth as to
author as such, but only of the teacher of the chorus. the main fact, in the statement that “ the actors of
Now we can easily understand how, when a poet Aristophanes were Callistratus and Philonides, in
was wealthy and fond of enjoyment, he might whose names (8ův) he exhibited his own dramas,
choose to assign the laborious duty of training the the public (or political) ones (td Snuotiká) in the
chorus and actors to another person ; and thus, name of Philonides, and the private (or personal)
besides the reasons already stated for a poet's using ones (rd lowtiká) in that of Callistratus. ” It seems
another's name at the commencement of his career, that the grammarian, though himself understand-
we see another ground on which he might continue ing the meaning of diá, copied the error into which
that practice, after his reputation was established. some former writer had been led, by supposing
Now we learn from Aristophanes himself, to say
that it referred to the actors : for, that it cannot
nothing of other evidence, not only the fact that he have that sense in the passage before us, is obvious
brought out his early plays in the names of other from the tautology which would arise from so
poets, but also his reasons for so doing. In the translating it, and from the force of the faut où ;
Parabasis of the Knights (v. 514), he states that namely, “ the actors of Aristophanes were Callis-
he had pursued this course, not from want of tratus and Philonides, by whom as actors he exhi-
thought, but from a sense of the difficulty of his bited his own dramas. " We may, however, with
profession, and from a fear that he might suffer great probability regard the passage as a later in-
from that fickleness of taste which the Athenians terpolation: how little credit is due to it is plain
had shown towards other poets, as Magnes, Crates, from the fact that the distribution of subjects in the
and Cratinus. Again, in the Parabusis of the last clause agrees neither with the testimony al-
Clouds (v. 530), he expresses the same thing in ready cited, nor with the information which we
the following significant language :-
derive from the Didascalive, as to the plays which
Kaya', rapbévos gap čr' i1, koủk nu Tu MOL TEKEîv listratus. From the Didascaliae and other testi-
were assigned respectively to Philonides and Cal-
εξέθηκα, παις δ' ετέρα τις λαβούσ' ανείλετο,
monies, we find that the Bubylonians (B. C. 426)
where the last words evidently imply, if the figure and the Acharnians (B. C. 425) were also brought
is to be interpreted consistently, that the person in out in the name of Callistratus ; and that the first
whose name he brought out the play referred to play which Aristophanes exhibited in his own
(the Daetuleis) was unother poet. It was evidently name was the Knights, B. c. 424 (68. 8áyon. . . . 81
the word oliv in this passage that misled the autoù toù 'Aplotopavous, Didasc. ). And hence
scholiast into his fancy of a legal prohibition. the notion has been hastily adopted, that he hence-
We must now inquire what light the ancient forth continued to exhibit in his own name, until
grammarians throw upon the subject. The author towards the close of his life, when he allowed
of the anonymous work, ſlepi kwupdías, who is de- Araros to bring out his plays. But, on the con-
cidedly one of the best of these writers, states (p. trary, we find from the Diduscaliae that he brought
xxix. ) that “ Aristophanes first exhibited (ebidae) out the Birds (B. C. 414) and the Lysistrata (B. C.
in the archonship of Diotimus (B. C, 427), in the 411) in the name of Callistratus (8. a Kallio.
name of Callistratus (8. d Kalliotpátov); for his Tpátou).
political comedies (Tds Tolitikas) they say that he Thus far the testimonies quoted have only re-
gave to him, but those against Euripides and Socrates ferred to Philonides in generul terms: it remains
to Philonides ; and on account of this (tirst drama) to be seen what particular plays Aristophanes
being esteemed a good poet, he conquered on sub-brought out in his name. From the above state-
sequent occasions (τους λοιπούς, sc. χρόνους), en- ments of the grammarians it might be inferred that
rolling his own name as the author (errypapóuevos). Aristophanes used the name of Philonides in this
Afterwards he gave his dramas to his son" (Araros). manner before the composition of the l’nights ; but
The play which he exhibited on this occasion was this is probably only a part of the error by which
the Aaitancis (Vub. l. c. and Schol. ). To the same it was assumed that, from the time of his exhibiting
effect another respectable grammarian, the author of the Knights, it was his constant custom to bring
the life of Aristophanes, tells us(p. xxxv. ) that “ being out his comedies in his own name. It is true that
## p. 316 (#332) ############################################
316
PHILONIDES.
PHILONIDES
the scholiast on the passage from the Clouds, above nians, the Acharnians, the Birds, and the Lyris
quoted, in which the Daetaleis is referred to, ex- trata, were brought out, as we have seen, in the
plains the phrase παις ετέρα as meaning Φιλωνίδης | name of Callistratus Of the extant plays of Arie-
kai Kanilotpatos, and Dindorf
, by putting toge- tophanes, the only ones which he is known to
ther this passage and the above inference, imagines have brought out in his own name are the Knights,
that the Ductulcis was brought out in the name of the Peace, and the Plutus. His two last plays
Philonides (Fraq. Arist. Daet. ) ; but the scholiast the Cocalus and Acolosicon, he gave to his son
is evidently referring, not so much to the bringing Araros. The Thesmophoriazusae and the Ecclesia-
out of this particular play (for mais étépa cannot zusae have no name attached to them in the Di-
mean two persons, nor were dramas ever brought dascaliae.
out in more than one name) as to the practice of These views are further supported by Bergk, in
Aristophanes with respect to several of his plays an elaborate discussion of all the passages in Aris-
There is, therefore, no reason for the violent and tophanes and his scholiasts, which bear upon the
arbitrary alteration of the words of the grammarian, matter; which must be read by all who wish to
who, as above quoted, expressly says that the play master this important question in the literary
was exhibited bid Katriotpátou. There is, there history of Aristophanes.
fore, no evidence that Aristophanes exhibited under There still remain, however, one or two questions
the name of Philonides previous to the date of the which must not be passed over. Supposing it
k'nughts ; but that he did so afterwards we know established, that Aristophanes brought out many
on the clearest evidence. His next play, the of his plays in the names of Callistratus and Philo-
Clouds (B. C. 423), we might suppose to have been nides, might they not also be the chief actors in
brought out in the name of Philonides, on account those plars, and, if not, who and what were ther?
of the statement of the grammarian, that Aristo- From what has been said in the early part of this
phanes assigned to him the plays against Socrates article, a strong presumption may be gathered that
and Euripides, coupled with the known fact that the persons in whose names the dramas of others
the Froys were exhibited in the name of Philo- were exhibited were themselves poets, who had
nides ; but, however this may be, we find that, in already gained a certain degree of reputation, but
the following year, B. C. 42. 2, Aristophanes brought who, from advancing years, or for other reasons,
out two plays, the Proagon and the Wasps, both might prefer this sort of literary partnership to the
in the name of Philonides, and gained with them risk and trouble of original composition. Indeed,
the first and second prize. This statement rests it would appear, on the face of the thing, an absurd.
on the authority of the difficult and certainly cor-ity for a person, who did not profess to be a poet,
rupted passage in the Didascalia of the Wasps, to enrol his name with the archon as the author of
into the critical discussion of which we cannot here a drama, and to undertake the all important office
enter, further than to give, as the result, the fol- of training the performers. But we have the evi-
lowing amended reading, which is founded on the dence of Aristophanes himself, that those in whose
Ravenna MS. , adopted both by Dindorf and Bergk, names he exhibited his dramas, were poets, like
and of the correctness of which there can now himself, ét épouoi hointais (resp. 1016; comp.
hardly be a doubt :-'E018á xonér ápxortos 'Aur Schol. ): we have already seen that Philonides was
viov oid iawvidov ev TỈ TỐ SA uuribdi: B' (i. e. a poet of the Old Comedy ; and with reference to
δεύτερος) ήν. είς Λήναια: και ενίκα πρωτος Φιλω- Callistratus, we have no other information to throw
νίδης Προαγώνι, Λεύκων Πρέσβεσι γ (i. e. τρίτος); doubt on that contained in the above and other
from which we learn that the Wasps was exhibited passages of Aristophanes and the grammarians.
at the Lenaea, in the 89th Olympiad, in the year The fact, that we have only three titles of plays by
of the Archon Amynias, under the name of Philo Philonides, and none by Callistratus, accords with
nides, and that it gained the second place, the first the view that they were chiefly employed as 8. 8áv.
being assigned to the Ipodywy, which was also ex- kaloi of the plays of Aristophanes. We have
hibited in the name of Philonides, and which we seen, indeed, that one or two of the grammarians
know from other sources to have been a play of state that they were actors; but, with all the evi-
Aristophanes (see the Fragments), and the third to dence on the other side, there can be little doubt
the Iperbers of Leucon. *
that this statement has merely arisen from a mis-
In the year B. C. 414 we again find Aristophanes take as to the meaning of the word Sia in the Die
exhibiting two plays (though at different festivals), dascaliae. That word has its recognized meaning
the Amphiaraus, in the name of Philonides, and in this connection, and no one hesitates to give it
the Birds, in that of Callistratus (Arg. in Ar. ); that meaning in the Dulascaliae of the earlier plays:
and, lastly, we learn from the Didascalia to the there is no good authority for supposing it to desig-
Frogs, that that play also was brought out in the nate the actor : the Didascalige were not designed
name of Philonides. We thus see that Aristo- to record the name of the actor, but that of the
phanes used the name of Philonides, probably, for poet, whether real or professed ; the terms didáo.
the Clouds (see Bergk, l. c. pp. 913, 914), and cer- καλος, χοροδιδάσκαλος, κωμοδοδιδάσκαλος, are used
tainly for the Wasps, the Proagon, the Amphia- as precisely equivalent to Tointhis and Kwuwdo-
raus, and the Frogs. The Daetaleis, the Babylo 10117s : and the notion that the xopoñidéokalos
and the chief actor could be the same person involves
Clinton (F. 11. vol. ii. p. xxxviii. n. i. ) gives a the almost absurd idea of the chief actor's training
very good account of the extraordinary errors which himself. The common story about Aristophanes
have been founded on this passage ; to which must taking upon himself the part of the chief actor in
be added his own, for, on the strength of a reading the Knights is shown by Bergk to be, in all proba-
which cannot be sustained, he makes the passage bility, a mere fabrication of some grammarian, who
mean that Aristophanes gained the first prize with mistook the meaning of taxon di' autoll Toll
the Wasps, and some poet, whose name is not men- | 'Aplotopávovs in the Didascalia ; and there is no
tioned, the second with the Proagon.
clear case, after the regular establishment of the
:
## p. 317 (#333) ############################################
PHILONOE.
317
PHILOPHRON.
a
drama, in which a poet was at the same time the PHILO'NOME (1Novóun). 1. A danghter
actor, either of his own plays, or of those of another of Nyctimus and Arcadia, and a companion of
poet. There is a curious confirmation of one of Artemis, became by Ares the mother of Lycastus
the arguments just urged in one of the Scholia on and Parrhasius ; but from fear of her father she
that passage of the Clouds which has so misled the threw her twin babes into the river Erymanthus.
commentators (v. 531),—Andovóti o Diawvidns kal They were carried by the river-god into a hollow
ο Καλλίστρατος, οι “ΥΣΤΕΡΟΝ γενόμενοι υποκριται oak tree, where they were suckled by a she-wolf,
TOû 'Aplotopávous, the author of which passage until the shepherd Tyliphus found them and took
evidently inserted Cotepov in order to gloss over them home. *(Plut. Paral. min. 36. )
the absurdity of giving dià different meanings 2. [TENES. ]
[L. S. )
the Didascaliae of the earlier and the later plays. PHILONOMUS (bvouos), a son of Elec-
One more question of interest still remains, re- tryon and Anaxo. (Apollod. ii. 4. 85; Strab. viii.
specting the knowledge which the Athenian public pp. 364, 384 ; comp. ELECTRYON. ) [L. S. ]
had of the real author of those plays which appeared PHILOPATOR (AOTátwp). This name,
under other names, especially in the case of Aris- which we find applied as an epithet or distinctive
tophanes ; concerning which the reader is referred appellation to several of the kings of Syria and
to Bergk (l. c. pp. 930, &c. ), who sums up the Egypt, appears to have been borne as a proper
whole discussion in words to the following effect :- name by two kings of Cilicia ; at least no other
that Aristophanes, through youthful timidity, when is mentioned either by historians or on their
he began to write plays, entrusted them to Callis-coins.
tratus ; but afterwards also, even when he had PHILOPATOR I. was a son of TARCONDIMO-
made the experiment of exhibiting in his own Tus I. In common with his father he had
name, he still retained his former custom, and ge- espoused the cause of Antony during the civil war
nerally devolved the task of bringing out the play between the latter and Octavian, but on learning
on Callistratus or Philonides ; that both these the tidings of the battle of Actium, and the death
were poets, and not actors ; nor did even Aristo- of Tarcondimotus B. c. 31, he declared in favour of
phanes himself act the part of Cleon in the Knights; the conqueror. He was nevertheless deprived of
that the fame of Aristophanes, though under the his kingdom by Octavian, and we do not learn
name of another, quickly spread abroad ; and that that he was subsequently reinstated, though in
it was he himself, and not Callistratus, whom B. C. 20 we find his paternal dominions restored to
Cleon thrice attacked in the courts of law (p. 939). his brother, Tarcondimotus. (Dion Cass. li. 2, 7,
Philonides, the comic poet, must not be con- liv. 9. )
founded with a certain Philonides who is attacked PhiloPATOR II. is known only from the
as a profligate voluptuary by Aristophanes (Plut. mention by Tacitus of his death in a. D. 17. (Tac.
179, 303 ; comp. Schol. ), and other comic poets, Ann. ii. 42. ) Eckhel supposes him to have been
such as Nicochares, Theopompus, and Philyllius. a son of Tarcondimotus II. , but it does not seem
(Bergk, Frag. Com. Att. Antiq. p. 400. ), ĮP. S. ] quite clear that he is distinct from the preceding,
PHILO'NIDES (Piawions). 1. A physician of who may have been allowed to resume the sove-
Catana in Sicily, the tutor of Paccius Antiochus reignty after his brother's death. (See, concerning
(Scribon. Larg. De Compos. Medicam. c. 23. § 97. these obscure princes of Cilicia, Eckhel, vol. iji.
p. 209; Marcell
. Empir. De Medicam. c. 20, p. 83 ; Walther, ad Tac. l. c. ) [E. H. B. ]
p. 324), who lived about the beginning of the
Christian era. He is probably the physician who
is quoted by Dioscorides, and said by him to have
been a native of Enna in Sicily (De Mat. Med. iv.
148, vol. i. p. 629); by Erotianus (Lex. Hippocr.
p. 144); and also by Galen, who refers to his
eighteenth book, lepi 'latpiris, De Medicina.
(De Differ. Puls. iv. 10, vol. viii. p. 748. )
2. A physician of Dyrrachium in Illyricum,
who was a pupil of Asclepiades of Bithynia in the
COIN OF PHILOPATOR.
first century B. C. , practised in his own country
with some reputation, and wrote as many as five PHILOPHRON (1Móopwv), a Rhodian, who
and forty books. (Steph. Byz. s. v. Auppáxtov. ) was sent ambassador together with Theaetetus to
One of these physicians (for, though they were the ten Roman deputies appointed to settle the
probably contemporaries, there is no reason for affairs of Asia after the defeat of Antiochus, B. C.
supposing them to have been the same individual) 189. They succeeded in obtaining the assignment
wrote a work, Tepi Múpwr kad Stepávwv, De of Lycia to the Rhodians as a reward for their
Unguentis et Coronis, which is quoted by Athen- services in the late contest (Polyb. xxiii. 3). At
aeus (xv. 17, 18, 45, pp. 675, 676, 691), and the commencement of the war between Rome and
one on Pharmacy quoted by Andromachus (ap. Perseus, the Rhodians were divided into two par-
Gal. De Compos. Medican. sec. Gen. viii. 7, ties, the one disposed to favour the Macedonian
vol. xiii. p. 978), and by Marcellus Empiricus (De king, the other to adhere closely to the Roman
Medicam. c. 29, p. 380). [W. A. G. ] alliance. Philophron was one of the principal
PHILONIS. [Chione and Ceyx. )
leaders of the latter ; and we find him (together
PHILO'NOE (VIAovón), the name of two my with Theaetetus) taking a prominent part in op-
thical personages, one a daughter of Tyndareos, posing all concessions to Perseus. But though in
who was rendered immortal by Artemis (Apollod. B. c. 169 they were still able to carry a decree
iii. 10. & 6), and the other a daughter of Jobates, for sending ambassadors to the senate at Rome, as
and wife of Bellerophontes (ii. 3.
(armamentarium) in the Peiraeeus, containing arms The other question respecting Philonides is one
for 1000 ships (Plin. H. N. vii. 37. s. 38). This of very great importance in connection with the
work, which excited the greatest admiration (Cic. literary history of the Old Comedy in general, and
de Orut. i. 14 ; Strab. ix. p. 395, d. ; Val. Max. of Aristophanes in particular. It is generally
viii. 12. ext. 2), was destroyed in the taking of believed that Philonides was an actor of Ariston
Athens by Sulla. (Plut. Sulla, 14). He wrote phanes, who is said to have committed to him
works on the architecture of temples, and on the and to Callistratus his chief characters. But the
naval basin which he constructed in the Peiraeeus. evidence on which this statement rests is regarded
(Vitruv. vii. Praef. § 12. )
S
by some of the best modern critics as leading to
3. A sculptor (1. Bouprós), whose name appears a very different conclusion, namely, that several of
on an inscription recently discovered at Delphi. the plays of Aristophanes were brought out in
(Ross, Inscr. Graec. Ined. Fasc. i. n. 73. p. 30 ; the names of Callistratus and Philonides. This
R. Rochette, Lettre à M. Schorn, p. 384, 2nd ed. ) question has been treated of by such scholars as
4. An engraver of medals, whose name is seen Ranke, C. F. Hermann, Fritzsch, Hanorius, W.
on the front of the helmet of the head of Minerva, Dindorf, and Droysen ; bit by for the most elabo-
which is the type of several coins of Heracleia in rate and satisfactory discussion of it is that by
Lucania. The letters are extremely minute, and the Theodor Bergk, prefixed to his edition of the fraga
inscription is sometimes in the form PIA, sometimes ments of Aristophanes, in Meineke's Fragmenia
pian. (R. Rochette, Lettre à M. Schorn, p. 94, Comicorum Graecorum, vol. ii. pp. 902—939.
2nd ed. )
[P. S. ] It must be remeinbered that, when a poet
PHILONI'CUS, artists. 1. C. Cornelius, a wished to exhibit a drama, he had first to apply to
Roman artist in silver, whose name occurs in an either the first or second archon for a chorus, his
inscription found at Narbonne, FABER ARGENT. obtaining which depended on the opinion of the
(Gruter, p. dcxxxix. 5). This inscription is one archon as to the merits of his play, and also in no
of several proofs that this branch of the arts was small degree on personal and political influence.
diligently cultivated in (aul under the early em- We even find choruses refused to such poets as
perors. "In other inscriptions we find mention Sophocles and Cratinus. Even when he succeeded
made of Vasclarii Argentari, specimens of whose in obtaining a chorus, he had to encounter the
work are furnished by beautiful silver vases, which proverbial capriciousness of an Athenian audience,
have been found in Gaul. (R. Rochette, Lettre à whose treatment even of old favourites was, as
M. Schorn, p. 385, 2nd ed. )
Aristophanes complains, no small discouragement
2. M. Canuleius, an artist, whose name occurs to a young candidate for their favour. In order to
in an inscription (Gruter, p. xxv. l), where he is reduce the obstacles which a young poet found
designated as Geniarius, that is, a maker of little thus placed in his way upon the very threshold,
figures of genii. (R. Rochette, l. c. ) [P. S. ] two courses were customary: the candidate for
PHILO'NIDES ($! Awvions), an Athenian dramatic honours either brought out in his own
comic poet of the Old Comedy, who is, however, name the play of some popular poet, the intrinsic
better known as one of the two persons in whose merit of which was sure to obtain a chorus, or else
names Aristophanes brought out some of his plays, he availed himself of the reputation of a well-
than by his own dramas. The information we have known poet by applying for a chorus in his name.
of him as a poet can be stated in a very few words ; The result was that by the former plan, which we
but the question of his connection with Aristo know to have been adopted by the sons of Aeschy-
phanes demands a careful examination.
lus, Sophocles, and Aristophanes, the young poet's
Before becoming a poet, Philonides was either a name became known, and he could more easily
fuller or a painter, according to the different texts hope to obtain a chorus for one of his own plass;
of Suidas and Eudocia, the former giving yvapeús, and, in the latter case, the reception of his works
the latter ypapeús. Three of his plays are men- would encourage him to appear again under his
tioned, 'Atvn, Kódopvoi, and Diétaipos (Suid. own name, or the contrary. There is, in fact, a
8. . ). The title of Kódopvoi would of itself lead passage of Aristophanes, which, if the figure be
us to suppose that it was an attack upon Thera- interpreted closely, would suggest the notion that
menes, whose party fickleness had gained him the it was customary for a young poet to pass through
well-known epithet Kóbopvos, and this conjecture the following three stages : the first, assisting
is fully confirmed by the following passage of a another poet in the composition of the less im-
grammarian (Bekker, Anecd. p. 100. 1): Onpa- portant passages of his plays (like the pupils of a
μένης της κλητικήν· Φιλιππίδης Κοθόρνοις, where great artist), as we know Eupolis to have worked
we ought no doubt to read ! Awvidrs, for no such under Aristophanes in the Knights ; then putting
play of Philippides is ever mentioned, but the out his own dramas under the name of another
Kódopvol of Philonides, besides being mentioned poet, in order to see how the popular favour in-
by Suidas, is several times quoted by Athenaeus clined ; and lastly, producing them in his own
and other writers. The plural number of the title, name. These several stages are perhaps intimated
Κόθορνοι, is no doubt because the chorus consisted by the phrases, Ερέτην γένεσθαι, πρωρατεύσαι και
of persons of the character of Theramenes. We τους ανέμους διαθρησαι, and κυβερνάν αυτόν εαυτό
have another example of that confusion between in the passage alluded to (Eq. 511--543, see
names beginning with Phil. , which has been no- Bergk, l. c. pp. 916, 917). In addition to the
ticed under Philemon, in the fact that many frag- reasons just stated, there is a very common opinion,
## p. 315 (#331) ############################################
PHILONIDES.
315
PHILONIDES.
founded on the statement of a grammarian (Schol. / at first exceedingly cautious and otherwise clever,
in Aristoph. Nub. 530), that an express law for- he brought out (kalier, the regular word for bringing
bade a poet to exhibit a drama in his own name into a contest) his first dramas in the names of
while he was under thirty years of age ; but (Sid) Callistratus and Philonides ; wherefore he
Bergk has shown (l. c. pp. 906, 907) that this law was ridiculed . . . . on the ground that he labouret
is probably one of those innumerable fictions of the for others : but afterwards he contended in his own
commentators, who state as facts things which are nume (autós nywvioato):” here again the plırase
simply the expression of their own notion of their “ that he laboured for others" must imply that
author's meaning; for Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Callistratus and Philonides were poets.
Euripides are all known to have brought out Thus far all is clear and consistent. Aristo-
plays in their own names while they were under phanes, from motives of modesty and caution,
thirty.
but not from any legal necessity, began to exhibit,
Now, in every case, the name enrolled in the not in his own name, but in that of Callistratus,
public records was that of the person in whose and afterwards of Pbilonides. The success of
name the chorus was applied for, whether he were these first efforts encouraged him to come forward
the real author or not, and this is the name which as the avowed author of his plays ; and again,
appears in the Didasculiu prefixed to a play under towards the close of his life, he aided his son
the form εδιδάχθη δια Καλλιστράτου (Acharn. ), or Araros, by allowing him to bring out some of his
di autoŮ TOÛ Apotopávous (Equit. ). In fact, dramas (the Cocalus for example) in his own name.
according to the original spirit of the institution, the But at the close of this very same Life of Aris-
chorus was the only essential part of a play, tophanes (p. xxxix. ) we find the error which we
and the public functionaries knew nothing of the have to expose, but yet combined with truth as to
author as such, but only of the teacher of the chorus. the main fact, in the statement that “ the actors of
Now we can easily understand how, when a poet Aristophanes were Callistratus and Philonides, in
was wealthy and fond of enjoyment, he might whose names (8ův) he exhibited his own dramas,
choose to assign the laborious duty of training the the public (or political) ones (td Snuotiká) in the
chorus and actors to another person ; and thus, name of Philonides, and the private (or personal)
besides the reasons already stated for a poet's using ones (rd lowtiká) in that of Callistratus. ” It seems
another's name at the commencement of his career, that the grammarian, though himself understand-
we see another ground on which he might continue ing the meaning of diá, copied the error into which
that practice, after his reputation was established. some former writer had been led, by supposing
Now we learn from Aristophanes himself, to say
that it referred to the actors : for, that it cannot
nothing of other evidence, not only the fact that he have that sense in the passage before us, is obvious
brought out his early plays in the names of other from the tautology which would arise from so
poets, but also his reasons for so doing. In the translating it, and from the force of the faut où ;
Parabasis of the Knights (v. 514), he states that namely, “ the actors of Aristophanes were Callis-
he had pursued this course, not from want of tratus and Philonides, by whom as actors he exhi-
thought, but from a sense of the difficulty of his bited his own dramas. " We may, however, with
profession, and from a fear that he might suffer great probability regard the passage as a later in-
from that fickleness of taste which the Athenians terpolation: how little credit is due to it is plain
had shown towards other poets, as Magnes, Crates, from the fact that the distribution of subjects in the
and Cratinus. Again, in the Parabusis of the last clause agrees neither with the testimony al-
Clouds (v. 530), he expresses the same thing in ready cited, nor with the information which we
the following significant language :-
derive from the Didascalive, as to the plays which
Kaya', rapbévos gap čr' i1, koủk nu Tu MOL TEKEîv listratus. From the Didascaliae and other testi-
were assigned respectively to Philonides and Cal-
εξέθηκα, παις δ' ετέρα τις λαβούσ' ανείλετο,
monies, we find that the Bubylonians (B. C. 426)
where the last words evidently imply, if the figure and the Acharnians (B. C. 425) were also brought
is to be interpreted consistently, that the person in out in the name of Callistratus ; and that the first
whose name he brought out the play referred to play which Aristophanes exhibited in his own
(the Daetuleis) was unother poet. It was evidently name was the Knights, B. c. 424 (68. 8áyon. . . . 81
the word oliv in this passage that misled the autoù toù 'Aplotopavous, Didasc. ). And hence
scholiast into his fancy of a legal prohibition. the notion has been hastily adopted, that he hence-
We must now inquire what light the ancient forth continued to exhibit in his own name, until
grammarians throw upon the subject. The author towards the close of his life, when he allowed
of the anonymous work, ſlepi kwupdías, who is de- Araros to bring out his plays. But, on the con-
cidedly one of the best of these writers, states (p. trary, we find from the Diduscaliae that he brought
xxix. ) that “ Aristophanes first exhibited (ebidae) out the Birds (B. C. 414) and the Lysistrata (B. C.
in the archonship of Diotimus (B. C, 427), in the 411) in the name of Callistratus (8. a Kallio.
name of Callistratus (8. d Kalliotpátov); for his Tpátou).
political comedies (Tds Tolitikas) they say that he Thus far the testimonies quoted have only re-
gave to him, but those against Euripides and Socrates ferred to Philonides in generul terms: it remains
to Philonides ; and on account of this (tirst drama) to be seen what particular plays Aristophanes
being esteemed a good poet, he conquered on sub-brought out in his name. From the above state-
sequent occasions (τους λοιπούς, sc. χρόνους), en- ments of the grammarians it might be inferred that
rolling his own name as the author (errypapóuevos). Aristophanes used the name of Philonides in this
Afterwards he gave his dramas to his son" (Araros). manner before the composition of the l’nights ; but
The play which he exhibited on this occasion was this is probably only a part of the error by which
the Aaitancis (Vub. l. c. and Schol. ). To the same it was assumed that, from the time of his exhibiting
effect another respectable grammarian, the author of the Knights, it was his constant custom to bring
the life of Aristophanes, tells us(p. xxxv. ) that “ being out his comedies in his own name. It is true that
## p. 316 (#332) ############################################
316
PHILONIDES.
PHILONIDES
the scholiast on the passage from the Clouds, above nians, the Acharnians, the Birds, and the Lyris
quoted, in which the Daetaleis is referred to, ex- trata, were brought out, as we have seen, in the
plains the phrase παις ετέρα as meaning Φιλωνίδης | name of Callistratus Of the extant plays of Arie-
kai Kanilotpatos, and Dindorf
, by putting toge- tophanes, the only ones which he is known to
ther this passage and the above inference, imagines have brought out in his own name are the Knights,
that the Ductulcis was brought out in the name of the Peace, and the Plutus. His two last plays
Philonides (Fraq. Arist. Daet. ) ; but the scholiast the Cocalus and Acolosicon, he gave to his son
is evidently referring, not so much to the bringing Araros. The Thesmophoriazusae and the Ecclesia-
out of this particular play (for mais étépa cannot zusae have no name attached to them in the Di-
mean two persons, nor were dramas ever brought dascaliae.
out in more than one name) as to the practice of These views are further supported by Bergk, in
Aristophanes with respect to several of his plays an elaborate discussion of all the passages in Aris-
There is, therefore, no reason for the violent and tophanes and his scholiasts, which bear upon the
arbitrary alteration of the words of the grammarian, matter; which must be read by all who wish to
who, as above quoted, expressly says that the play master this important question in the literary
was exhibited bid Katriotpátou. There is, there history of Aristophanes.
fore, no evidence that Aristophanes exhibited under There still remain, however, one or two questions
the name of Philonides previous to the date of the which must not be passed over. Supposing it
k'nughts ; but that he did so afterwards we know established, that Aristophanes brought out many
on the clearest evidence. His next play, the of his plays in the names of Callistratus and Philo-
Clouds (B. C. 423), we might suppose to have been nides, might they not also be the chief actors in
brought out in the name of Philonides, on account those plars, and, if not, who and what were ther?
of the statement of the grammarian, that Aristo- From what has been said in the early part of this
phanes assigned to him the plays against Socrates article, a strong presumption may be gathered that
and Euripides, coupled with the known fact that the persons in whose names the dramas of others
the Froys were exhibited in the name of Philo- were exhibited were themselves poets, who had
nides ; but, however this may be, we find that, in already gained a certain degree of reputation, but
the following year, B. C. 42. 2, Aristophanes brought who, from advancing years, or for other reasons,
out two plays, the Proagon and the Wasps, both might prefer this sort of literary partnership to the
in the name of Philonides, and gained with them risk and trouble of original composition. Indeed,
the first and second prize. This statement rests it would appear, on the face of the thing, an absurd.
on the authority of the difficult and certainly cor-ity for a person, who did not profess to be a poet,
rupted passage in the Didascalia of the Wasps, to enrol his name with the archon as the author of
into the critical discussion of which we cannot here a drama, and to undertake the all important office
enter, further than to give, as the result, the fol- of training the performers. But we have the evi-
lowing amended reading, which is founded on the dence of Aristophanes himself, that those in whose
Ravenna MS. , adopted both by Dindorf and Bergk, names he exhibited his dramas, were poets, like
and of the correctness of which there can now himself, ét épouoi hointais (resp. 1016; comp.
hardly be a doubt :-'E018á xonér ápxortos 'Aur Schol. ): we have already seen that Philonides was
viov oid iawvidov ev TỈ TỐ SA uuribdi: B' (i. e. a poet of the Old Comedy ; and with reference to
δεύτερος) ήν. είς Λήναια: και ενίκα πρωτος Φιλω- Callistratus, we have no other information to throw
νίδης Προαγώνι, Λεύκων Πρέσβεσι γ (i. e. τρίτος); doubt on that contained in the above and other
from which we learn that the Wasps was exhibited passages of Aristophanes and the grammarians.
at the Lenaea, in the 89th Olympiad, in the year The fact, that we have only three titles of plays by
of the Archon Amynias, under the name of Philo Philonides, and none by Callistratus, accords with
nides, and that it gained the second place, the first the view that they were chiefly employed as 8. 8áv.
being assigned to the Ipodywy, which was also ex- kaloi of the plays of Aristophanes. We have
hibited in the name of Philonides, and which we seen, indeed, that one or two of the grammarians
know from other sources to have been a play of state that they were actors; but, with all the evi-
Aristophanes (see the Fragments), and the third to dence on the other side, there can be little doubt
the Iperbers of Leucon. *
that this statement has merely arisen from a mis-
In the year B. C. 414 we again find Aristophanes take as to the meaning of the word Sia in the Die
exhibiting two plays (though at different festivals), dascaliae. That word has its recognized meaning
the Amphiaraus, in the name of Philonides, and in this connection, and no one hesitates to give it
the Birds, in that of Callistratus (Arg. in Ar. ); that meaning in the Dulascaliae of the earlier plays:
and, lastly, we learn from the Didascalia to the there is no good authority for supposing it to desig-
Frogs, that that play also was brought out in the nate the actor : the Didascalige were not designed
name of Philonides. We thus see that Aristo- to record the name of the actor, but that of the
phanes used the name of Philonides, probably, for poet, whether real or professed ; the terms didáo.
the Clouds (see Bergk, l. c. pp. 913, 914), and cer- καλος, χοροδιδάσκαλος, κωμοδοδιδάσκαλος, are used
tainly for the Wasps, the Proagon, the Amphia- as precisely equivalent to Tointhis and Kwuwdo-
raus, and the Frogs. The Daetaleis, the Babylo 10117s : and the notion that the xopoñidéokalos
and the chief actor could be the same person involves
Clinton (F. 11. vol. ii. p. xxxviii. n. i. ) gives a the almost absurd idea of the chief actor's training
very good account of the extraordinary errors which himself. The common story about Aristophanes
have been founded on this passage ; to which must taking upon himself the part of the chief actor in
be added his own, for, on the strength of a reading the Knights is shown by Bergk to be, in all proba-
which cannot be sustained, he makes the passage bility, a mere fabrication of some grammarian, who
mean that Aristophanes gained the first prize with mistook the meaning of taxon di' autoll Toll
the Wasps, and some poet, whose name is not men- | 'Aplotopávovs in the Didascalia ; and there is no
tioned, the second with the Proagon.
clear case, after the regular establishment of the
:
## p. 317 (#333) ############################################
PHILONOE.
317
PHILOPHRON.
a
drama, in which a poet was at the same time the PHILO'NOME (1Novóun). 1. A danghter
actor, either of his own plays, or of those of another of Nyctimus and Arcadia, and a companion of
poet. There is a curious confirmation of one of Artemis, became by Ares the mother of Lycastus
the arguments just urged in one of the Scholia on and Parrhasius ; but from fear of her father she
that passage of the Clouds which has so misled the threw her twin babes into the river Erymanthus.
commentators (v. 531),—Andovóti o Diawvidns kal They were carried by the river-god into a hollow
ο Καλλίστρατος, οι “ΥΣΤΕΡΟΝ γενόμενοι υποκριται oak tree, where they were suckled by a she-wolf,
TOû 'Aplotopávous, the author of which passage until the shepherd Tyliphus found them and took
evidently inserted Cotepov in order to gloss over them home. *(Plut. Paral. min. 36. )
the absurdity of giving dià different meanings 2. [TENES. ]
[L. S. )
the Didascaliae of the earlier and the later plays. PHILONOMUS (bvouos), a son of Elec-
One more question of interest still remains, re- tryon and Anaxo. (Apollod. ii. 4. 85; Strab. viii.
specting the knowledge which the Athenian public pp. 364, 384 ; comp. ELECTRYON. ) [L. S. ]
had of the real author of those plays which appeared PHILOPATOR (AOTátwp). This name,
under other names, especially in the case of Aris- which we find applied as an epithet or distinctive
tophanes ; concerning which the reader is referred appellation to several of the kings of Syria and
to Bergk (l. c. pp. 930, &c. ), who sums up the Egypt, appears to have been borne as a proper
whole discussion in words to the following effect :- name by two kings of Cilicia ; at least no other
that Aristophanes, through youthful timidity, when is mentioned either by historians or on their
he began to write plays, entrusted them to Callis-coins.
tratus ; but afterwards also, even when he had PHILOPATOR I. was a son of TARCONDIMO-
made the experiment of exhibiting in his own Tus I. In common with his father he had
name, he still retained his former custom, and ge- espoused the cause of Antony during the civil war
nerally devolved the task of bringing out the play between the latter and Octavian, but on learning
on Callistratus or Philonides ; that both these the tidings of the battle of Actium, and the death
were poets, and not actors ; nor did even Aristo- of Tarcondimotus B. c. 31, he declared in favour of
phanes himself act the part of Cleon in the Knights; the conqueror. He was nevertheless deprived of
that the fame of Aristophanes, though under the his kingdom by Octavian, and we do not learn
name of another, quickly spread abroad ; and that that he was subsequently reinstated, though in
it was he himself, and not Callistratus, whom B. C. 20 we find his paternal dominions restored to
Cleon thrice attacked in the courts of law (p. 939). his brother, Tarcondimotus. (Dion Cass. li. 2, 7,
Philonides, the comic poet, must not be con- liv. 9. )
founded with a certain Philonides who is attacked PhiloPATOR II. is known only from the
as a profligate voluptuary by Aristophanes (Plut. mention by Tacitus of his death in a. D. 17. (Tac.
179, 303 ; comp. Schol. ), and other comic poets, Ann. ii. 42. ) Eckhel supposes him to have been
such as Nicochares, Theopompus, and Philyllius. a son of Tarcondimotus II. , but it does not seem
(Bergk, Frag. Com. Att. Antiq. p. 400. ), ĮP. S. ] quite clear that he is distinct from the preceding,
PHILO'NIDES (Piawions). 1. A physician of who may have been allowed to resume the sove-
Catana in Sicily, the tutor of Paccius Antiochus reignty after his brother's death. (See, concerning
(Scribon. Larg. De Compos. Medicam. c. 23. § 97. these obscure princes of Cilicia, Eckhel, vol. iji.
p. 209; Marcell
. Empir. De Medicam. c. 20, p. 83 ; Walther, ad Tac. l. c. ) [E. H. B. ]
p. 324), who lived about the beginning of the
Christian era. He is probably the physician who
is quoted by Dioscorides, and said by him to have
been a native of Enna in Sicily (De Mat. Med. iv.
148, vol. i. p. 629); by Erotianus (Lex. Hippocr.
p. 144); and also by Galen, who refers to his
eighteenth book, lepi 'latpiris, De Medicina.
(De Differ. Puls. iv. 10, vol. viii. p. 748. )
2. A physician of Dyrrachium in Illyricum,
who was a pupil of Asclepiades of Bithynia in the
COIN OF PHILOPATOR.
first century B. C. , practised in his own country
with some reputation, and wrote as many as five PHILOPHRON (1Móopwv), a Rhodian, who
and forty books. (Steph. Byz. s. v. Auppáxtov. ) was sent ambassador together with Theaetetus to
One of these physicians (for, though they were the ten Roman deputies appointed to settle the
probably contemporaries, there is no reason for affairs of Asia after the defeat of Antiochus, B. C.
supposing them to have been the same individual) 189. They succeeded in obtaining the assignment
wrote a work, Tepi Múpwr kad Stepávwv, De of Lycia to the Rhodians as a reward for their
Unguentis et Coronis, which is quoted by Athen- services in the late contest (Polyb. xxiii. 3). At
aeus (xv. 17, 18, 45, pp. 675, 676, 691), and the commencement of the war between Rome and
one on Pharmacy quoted by Andromachus (ap. Perseus, the Rhodians were divided into two par-
Gal. De Compos. Medican. sec. Gen. viii. 7, ties, the one disposed to favour the Macedonian
vol. xiii. p. 978), and by Marcellus Empiricus (De king, the other to adhere closely to the Roman
Medicam. c. 29, p. 380). [W. A. G. ] alliance. Philophron was one of the principal
PHILONIS. [Chione and Ceyx. )
leaders of the latter ; and we find him (together
PHILO'NOE (VIAovón), the name of two my with Theaetetus) taking a prominent part in op-
thical personages, one a daughter of Tyndareos, posing all concessions to Perseus. But though in
who was rendered immortal by Artemis (Apollod. B. c. 169 they were still able to carry a decree
iii. 10. & 6), and the other a daughter of Jobates, for sending ambassadors to the senate at Rome, as
and wife of Bellerophontes (ii. 3.