Francis a
while longer under the baneful influence of the commendation of the Court of Directors.
while longer under the baneful influence of the commendation of the Court of Directors.
Edmund Burke
?
502 SPEECH ON MR.
FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL.
justice, and for the collection of revenue, was planned
and executed by the President and Council of Bengal,
subject to the pleasure of the Directors, in the year
1772. According to this plan, the country was divided into six districts, or provinces. In each of
these was established a provincial council, which
administered the revenue; and of that council, one
member, by monthly rotation, presided in the courts
of civil resort, with an appeal to the council of the
province, and thence to Calcutta. In this system
(whether in other respects good or evil) there were
some'capital advantages. There was, in the very
number of persons in each provincial council, authority, communication, mutual check, and control.
They were obliged, on their minutes of consultation,
to enter their reasons and dissents; so that a man of
diligence, of research, and tolerable sagacity, sitting
in London, might, from these materials, be enabled
to form some judgment of the spirit of what was
going on on the furthest banks of the Ganges and
Burrampooter.
The Court of Directors so far ratified this establishment, (which was consonant enough to their general
plan of government,) that they gave precise orders
that no alteration should be made in it without their
consent. So far from being apprised of any design
against this constitution, they had reason to conceive
that on trial it had been more and more approved by
their Council-General, at least by the Governor-General, who had planned it. At the time of the revolution, the Council-General was nominally in two persons, virtually in one. At that time measures of
an arduous and critical nature ought to have been
forborne, even if, to the fullest council, this specific
? ? ? ? SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL. 503
measure had not been prohibited by the superior
authority. It was in this very situation that one
man had the hardiness to conceive and the temerity
to execute a total revolution in the form and the
persons composing the government of a great kingdom. Without any previous step, at one stroke, the whole constitution of Bengal, civil and criminal, was
swept away. The counsellors were recalled from
their provinces; upwards of fifty of the principal
officers of government were turned out of employ,
and rendered dependent on Mr. Hastings for their
immediate subsistence, and for all hope of future
provision. The chief of each council, and one European collector of revenue, was left in each province.
But here, Sir, you may imagine a new government, of some permanent description, was established
in the place of that which had been thus suddenlyoverturned. No such thing. Lest these chiefs, without councils, should be conceived to form the groundplan of some future government, it was publicly declared that their continuance was. only temporary
and permissive. The whole subordinate British administration of revenue was then vested in a committee in Calcutta, all creatures of the' GovernorGeneral; and the provincial management, under the permissive chief, was delivered over to native officers.
But that the revolution and the purposes of the
revolution might be complete, to this committee were
delegated, not only the functions of all the inferior,
but, what will surprise the House, those of the supreme administration of revenue also. Hitherto the Governor-General and Council had, in their revenue
department, administered the finances of those king
? ? ? ? 504 SPEECH -ON MR. . FOX'S:EAST INDIA BILL.
doms. . By the. new scheme they are delegated to this
committee, who are only. :to report their proceedings
for approbation,.
The key to the whole transaction is given in one of
the: instructions to the committee, --" that it is not
necessary that they should enter dissents. ". By this
means the. ancient plan of the Company's administration was destroyed; but the plan of concealment was perfected. To that moment the accounts of the revenues. were tolerably clear, --or at least means were furnished for inquiries, by which they might be rendered satisfactory. In the obscure and silent gulf of
this committee everything is now buried. The thickest shades of night surround all their transactions.
No effectual means of detecting fraud, mismanagement, or misrepresentation exist. The Directors,
who have dared to talk with such confidence on their
revenues, know nothing about them. What used to
fill volumes is now comprised under a few dry heads
on a sheet of paper. The natives, a people habitually
made to concealment, are the chief managers of the
revenue throughout -the provinces. I mean by natives such wretches as your rulers select out of them
as most fitted for, their purposes. As a proper keystone to bind the arch, a native, one Gunga Govind
Sing, a man turned out of his employment by Sir
John Clavering for malversation in office, is made
the corresponding secretary, and, indeed, the great
moving principle of their new board.
As the whole revenue and civil administration was
thus subverted, and a clandestine government substituted in the place of it, the judicial institution underwent a like revolution. :In 1772 there had
been six courts, formed out of the six provincial
? ? ? ? SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL. . 506
councils. . Eighteen new ones are appointed in their
place, with each a judge, taken from the junior servants of the Company. To maintain these eighteen
courts, a. tax is levied on the sums in litigation, of
two and one half per cent on the great, and of five
per cent on the less. This money is all drawn from
the provinces to Calcutta. The. chief justice (the
same who stays in defiance of a vote of this House,
and of his Majesty's recall) is appointed at once the
treasurer: and disposer of these taxes, levied without
any sort:of authority from the Company, from the
Crown, or from Parliament.
In effect, Sir, every legal, regular authority, in
matters of revenue,. of political administration, of
criminal law, of civil law, in many of the most essential parts, of military discipline, is laid level with the
ground; and an oppressive, irregular, capricious, unsteady, rapacious, and peculating despotism, with a. direct disavowal. of obedience to, any authority at home, and without! any fixed maxim, principle, or
rule. of proceeding to guide them in India, is at present the state of your charter-government over great
kingdoms.
As the Company has made this use of their trust, I
should ill discharge mine, if I refused to give my most
cheerful vote for the redress of these abuses, by putting the affairs of so large and valuable a part of the
interests of this nation and of'mankind into some
steady hands, possessing the confidence and assured
of the. support of this House, until they can be restored
to regularity, order, and consistency.
I have touched the heads of some of the grievances
of the people and the abuses of government. But I
hope. and trust you will give me credit, when I faith
? ? ? ? 506 SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL.
fully assure you that I have not mentioned one
fourth part of what has come to my knowledge in
your committee; and further, I have full reason to
believe that not one fourth part of the abuses are
come to my knowledge, by that or by any other
means. Pray consider what I have said only as an
index to direct you in your inquiries.
If this, then, Sir, has been the use made of the trust
of political powers, internal and external, given by
you in the charter, the next thing to be seen is the
conduct of the Company with regard to the commercial trust. And here I will make a fair offer:- If it
can be proved that they have acted wisely, prudently,
and frugally, as merchants, I shall pass by the whole
mass of their enormities as statesmen. That they
have not done this their present condition is proof
sufficient. Their distresses are said to be owing to
their wars. This is not wholly true. But if it were,
is not that readiness to engage in wars, which distinguishes them, and for which the Committee of Secrecy has so branded their politics, founded on the falsest
principles of mercantile speculation?
The principle of buying cheap and selling dear is
the first, the great foundation of mercantile dealing.
Have they ever attended to this principle? Nay, for
years have they not actually authorized in their servants a total indifference as to the prices they were
to pay?
A great deal of strictness in driving bargains for
whatever we contract is another of the principles of
mercantile policy. Try the Company by that test.
Look at the contracts that are made for them. Is
the Company so much as a good commissary to their
own armies? I engage to select for you, out of the
? ? ? ? SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL. 507 innumerable mass of their dealings, all conducted very nearly alike, one contract only the excessive profits on which during a short term would pay the whole of their year's dividend. I shall undertake
to show that upon two others the inordinate profits
given, with the losses incurred in order to secure
those profits, would pay a year's dividend more.
It is a third property of trading-men to see that
their clerks do not divert the dealings of the master
to their own benefit. It was the other day only,
when their Governor and Council taxed the Company's investment with a sum of fifty thousand pounds, as an inducement to persuade only seven
members of their Board of Trade to give their honor that they would abstain from such profits upon that investment, as they must have violated their oaths, if they had made at all.
It is a fourth quality of a merchant to be exact in
his accounts. What will be thought, when you have
fully before you the mode of accounting made use of
in the Treasury of Bengal? I hope you will have it
soon. With regard to one of their agencies, when it
came to the material part, the prime cost of the goods
on which a commission of fifteen per cent was allowed, to the astonishment of the factory to whom the commodities were sent, the Accountant-General reports that he did not think himself authorized to call for vouchers relative to this and other particulars, -
because the agent was upon his honor with regard to
them. A new principle of account upon honor seems
to be regularly established in their dealings and their
treasury, which in reality amounts to an entire annihilation of the principle of all accounts.
It is a fifth property of a merchant, who does not
? ? ? ? 508 SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA. BILL.
meditate a fraudulent bankruptcy, to calculate his
probable profits. upon the. money he takes up to vest
in business. Did the Company,:when they bought
goods on bonds bearing eight per cent interest, at
ten and even twenty per cent discount, even ask
themselves a question concerning the possibility of
advantage from dealing on these terms?
The last quality of a merchant I shall advert to is
the taking care. to be properly prepared, in cash or
goods in the ordinary course of sale, for the. bills
which are drawn on them. Now I ask, whether they
have ever calculated the clear produce of any given
sales, to make them tally with the four million of
bills which are come and coming upon them, so as
at the proper periods to enable the one to liquidate
the other. No, they have not. They are now obliged
to borrow money of their own servants to purchase
their investment. The servants stipulate five per
cent on the capital they advance, if their bills. should
not be paid at. the time when they become due; and
the value of the rupee on which they charge this interest is taken, at two shillings and. a penny. Has the
Company ever troubled themselves to inquire whether
their sales can bear the payment of that interest, and
at that rate of exchange? Have they once considered
the dilemma in which they are placed, - the ruin of
their credit in the East Indies, if they refuse the bills,
- the ruin. of their credit and existence in England,
if they accept them?
Indeed, no trace of equitable government is found
in their politics,not one trace of commercial principle
in their mercantile dealing: and hence is the deepest and maturest, -wisdom of Parliament demanded, and the best resources of this kingdom must be
? ? ? ? SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL. 509
strained, to' restore them,- that is, to restore -the
countries destroyed by the misconduct of the Company, and to restore the. Company itself, ruined by the consequences of their plans for destroying what
they were bound to preserve.
I required, if you: remember, at my outset, a proof
that these abuses were habitual. 'But surely this is
not: necessary for me to consider as:a separate head';
because I trust: I have madeit evident beyond a doubt,
in considering the abuses themselves, that they are
regular,:permanent, and systematical.
J:I am,now come:to my last condition, without
which, for one, I will never readily-lend:my hand to
the. destruction of any established government, which
is,. :that, in its present. state, the government of the
East India Company is absolutely incorrigible.
Of this great truth. I think there can be little' doubt,
after all that has appeared in this Eouse. It is so
very. clear,'that I'. must consider the leaving any
power in. their; hands, and the determined resolution
to. . . :continue and countenance every mode and every
degree of peculation, oppression, and tyranny, to be
one and the same'thing. I look, upon that body incorrigible, from the fullest consideration both of their uniform conduct and their present real and'virtual
constitution.
If. they had not constantly been apprised of all the
enormities -committed in India under their authority,
if this state of things had been as much a discovery to
them as,'it was. to many of us, we might flatter ourselves that the detection of the abuses would lead to their reformation. I will go further. If the Court
of Directors had not uniformly condemned every
act which this House or any of its committees had
? ? ? ? 510 SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL.
condemned, if the language in which they expret;sed
their disapprobation against enormities and their authors had not been much more vehement and indignant than any ever used in this House, I should entertain some hopes. If they had not, on the other
hand, as uniformly commended all their servants who
had done their duty and obeyed their orders as they
had heavily censured those who rebelled, I might
say, These people have been in an error, and when
they are sensible of it they will mend. But when I
reflect on' the uniformity of their- support to the objects of their uniform censure, and the state of insignificance and disgrace to which all of those have been reduced whom they approved, and that even utter
ruin and premature death have been among the fruits
of their favor, I must be convinced, that in this case,
as in all others, hypocrisy is the only vice that never
can be cured.
Attend, I pray you, to the situation and prosperity
of Benfield, Hastings, and others of that sort. The
last of these has been treated by the Company with an
asperity of reprehension that has no parallel. They
lament "' that the power of disposing of their property
for perpetuity should fall into such hands. " Yet for
fourteen years, with little interruption, he has governed all their affairs, of every description, with an
absolute sway. He has had himself the means of
heaping up immense wealth; and duiring that whole
period, the fortunes of hundreds have depended on
his smiles and frowns. He himself tells you he is
incumbered with two hundred and fifty young gentlemen, some of them of the best families in England,
all of whom aim at returning with vast fortunes to
Europe in the prime of life. He has, then, two hun
? ? ? ? SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL. 511
dred and fifty of your children as his hostages for
your good behavior; and loaded for years, as he
has been, with the execrations of the natives, with
the censures of the. Court of Directors, and struck
and blasted with resolutions of this House, he still
maintains the most despotic. power ever known in
India. He domineers with an overbearing sway in
the assemblies of his pretended masters; and it is
thought in a degree rash to venture to name his
offences in this House, even as grounds of a legislative remedy.
On the other hand, consider the fate of those who
have met with the applauses of the Directors. Colonel Monson, one of the best of men, had his days
shortened by the applauses, destitute of the support,
of the Company. General Clavering, whose panegyric was made in every dispatch from England,
whose hearse was bedewed with the tears and hung
round with the eulogies of the Court of Directors,
burst an honest and indignant heart at the treachery
of those who ruined him by their praises. Uncommon patience. and temper supported Mr.
Francis a
while longer under the baneful influence of the commendation of the Court of Directors. His health,
however, gave way at length; and in utter despair,
he returned to Europe. At his return, the doors of
the. India House were shut to this man who had been
the object of their, constant admiration. He has, indeed, escaped with life; but he has forfeited all expectation of credit, consequence, party, and following. He may well say, "Me nemo ministro fur erit, atque
ideo nulli comes exeo. " This man, whose deep reach
of thought, whose large legislative conceptions, and
whose grand plans of policy make the most shining
? ? ? ? 512 SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL.
part of our Reports, from whence we have all learned
our lessons, if we have learned any good ones, - this
man, from whose materials those gentlemen who
have least acknowledged it have yet spoken as from
a brief, -this man, driven from his employment, discountenanced by the Directors, has had no other reward, and no other distinction, but that inward
" sunshine of the soul " which a good conscience can
always bestow upon itself. He has not yet had so
much as a good word, but from a person too insignificant to make any other return for the means with which he has been furnished for performing his share
of a duty which is equally urgent on us all.
Add to this, that, from the highest in place to the
lowest, every British subject; who, in obedience to
the Company's orders, has been active in the discovery of peculations, has been ruined. They have been driven from India. When they made their appeal at
home, they were not heard; when they attempted to
return, they were stopped. No artifice of fraud, no
violence of. power, has been omitted to destroy them
in character as well as in fortune.
Worse, far worse, has been the fate of the poor
creatures, the natives of India, whom the hypocrisy
of the Company has betrayed into complaint of oppression and discovery of peculation. The first women
in Bengal, the Ranny of Rajeshahi, the Ranny of
Burdwan, the Ranny of Ambooah, by their weak and
thoughtless trust in. the Company's honor and protection, are utterly ruined: the first of these women,
a person of princely rank, and once of correspondent
fortune, who -paid above two hundred thousand a year
quit-rentto the state, is, according to very credible information, so completely beggared as to stand in need
? ? ? ? SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL. 513
of the relief of allns. - Mahomed Reza Khan, the second Mussulman in Bengal, for having been distinguished by the ill-omened honor of the countenance and protection of the Court of Directors, was, without
the pretence of any inquiry whatsoever into his conduct, stripped of all his employments, and reduced to
the lowest condition. His ancient rival for power,
the Rajah Nundcomar, was, by an insult on everything which India holds respectable and sacred,
hanged in the face of all his nation by the judges
you sent to protect that people: hanged for a pretended crime, upon an ex post facto British act of
Parliament, in the midst of his evidence against Mr.
Hastings. The accuser they saw hanged. The culprit,
without acquittal or inquiry, triumphs on the ground
of. that murder: a murder, not of Nundcomar only, but
of all living testimony, and even of evidence yet unborn. From that time not a complaint has been heard
from the natives against their governors. All the.
grievances of India have found a complete remedy.
Men will not look to acts of Parliament, to regulations, to declarations, to votes, and resolutions. No,
they are not such fools. They will ask, What is the
road to power, credit, wealth, and honors? They
will ask, What conduct ends in neglect, disgrace, poverty, exile, prison, and gibbet? These will teach
them the course which they are to follow. It is your
distribution of these that will give the character and
tone to your government. All the rest is miserable
grimace.
When I accuse the Court of Directors of this habitual treachery in the use of reward and punishment,
I do not mean to include all the individuals in that
court. . There have been, Sir, very frequently men
VOL. II 33
? ? ? ? 514 SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL.
of the greatest integrity and virtue amongst them;
and the contrariety in the declarations and conduct
of that court has arisen, I take it, from this, -- that
the honest Directors have, by the force of matter of
fact on the records, carried the reprobation of the evil
measures of the servants in India. This could not
be prevented, whilst these records stared them in the
face; nor were the delinquents, either here or there,
very solicitous about their reputation, as long as they
were able to secure their power. The agreement of
their partisans to censure them blunted for a while
the edge of a severe proceeding. It obtained for
them a character of impartiality, which enabled them
to recommend with some sort of grace, what will
always carry a plausible appearance, those treacherous expedients called moderate measures. Whilst
these were under discussion, new matter of complaint
came over, which seemed to antiquate the first. The
same circle was here trod round once more; and
thus through years they proceeded in a compromise
of censure for punishment, until, by shame and despair, one after another, almost every man who preferred his duty to the Company to the interest of their servants has been driven from that court.
This, Sir, has been their conduct: and it has been
the result of the alteration which was insensibly made
in their constitution. The change was made insensibly; but it is now strong and adult, and as public
and declared as it is fixed beyond all power of reformation: so that there is none who hears me that is
not as certain as I am, that the Company, in the
sense in which it was formerly understood, has no
existence.
The question is not, what injury. you may do to the
? ? ? ? SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL. 515
proprietors of India stock;. for there are no such men
to be injured. If the active, ruling part of the Company, who form the General Court, who fill the offices
and direct the measures, (the rest tell for nothing,)
were persons~ who held their stock as a means of
their subsistence, who in the part they took were only concerned in the government of India for the rise
or fall of their dividend, it would be indeed a defective plan of policy. The interest of the people who
are governed by them would not be their primary object, - perhaps a very small part of their consideration at all. But then they might well-be depended on, and
perhaps more than persons in other respects preferable, for preventing the peculations of their servants to their own prejudice. Such a body would not easily
have left their trade as a spoil to the avarice of those
who received their wages. But now things are totally reversed. The stock is of no value, whether it
be the qualification of a Director or Proprietor; and
it is impossible that it should. A Director's qualification may be worth about two thousand five hundred pounds, -- and the interest, at eight per cent, is about
one hundred and sixty pounds a year. Of,what value is that, whether it rise to ten, or fall to six, or to nothing, to him whose son, before he is in Bengal two
months, and before he descends the steps of the Council-Chamber, sells the grant of a single contract for forty thousand pounds'? Accordingly, the stock is
bought up in qualifications. The vote is not to protect the stock, but the stock' is bought to acquire the vote; and the end of the vote is to cover and support,
against justice, some man of power who has made an
obnoxious fortune in India, or to maintain in power
those who are actually employing it in the acquisition
? ? ? ? 516 SPEECHE ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL.
Of such a fortune, - and to avail themselves, in return,
of his patronage, that he may shower the spoils of the
East, "barbaric pearl and gold," on them, their families, and dependants. : So that all the relations of the
Cbmpany are not only changed, but inverted. The servants in India are not appointed by the Directors, but
the Directors are chosen by them. The trade is carried on with their capitals. To them the revenues of
the country are mortgaged. The seat of the supreme
power is in Calcutta. The house in Leadenhall Street
is nothing more than a'change for their agents, factors, and deputies to meet in, to take care of their
affairs and support their interests, - and this so avowedly, that we see the known agents of the delinquent
servants marshalling and disciplining their forces, and
the prime spokesmen in all their assemblies.
Everything has followed in this order, and according to the natural train of events. I will close what
I have to say on the incorrigible condition of the
Company, by stating to you a few facts that will leave
no doubt of the obstinacy of that corporation, and of
their strength too, in resisting the reformation of
their servants. By these facts'you will be enabled to
discover the sole grounds upon which they are tenar
cious of their charter.
It is now more than two years, that upon account
of the gross abuses and ruinous situation of the Company's affairs,'(which occasioned the cry of the whole
world long before it was taken up here,) that we instituted two committees to inquire into the mismanagements by which the Company's affairs had been brought to the brink of ruin. These inquiries had been pursued
with unremitting diligence, and a great body of facts
was collected and printed for general information.
? ? ? ? SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL. 517
In the result of those inquiries, although the committees consisted of very different descriptions, they were
unanimous. They joined in censuring the conduct
of the. Indian admiinistration', and enforcing the responsibility upon two men, whom this House, in consequence of these reports, declared it to be the duty of the Directors to. remove from their stations, and
recall to Great Britain, --" because they had acted in
a manner repugnant to the honor and policy of this nation, and thereby brought great calamities on India and
enormous expenses on the East India Company. ".
Here was no attempt on the charter. Here was
no question of their privileges. To. vindicate their
own honor, to support their own interests, to enforce
obedience to their own orders,- these were the sole
object of the monitory resolution of this House. But
as soon as the General Court could. assemble, they
assembled to demonstrate who they really were.
Regardless of the proceedings of this House, they
ordered the Directors not to carry into effect any
resolution they might: come to for the removal df
Mr. - Hastings and Mr. Hornby. The Directors, still
retaining some shadow of respect to this House, instituted an inquiry themselves, which continued from
June to October, and, after an attentive perusal and
full consideration of papers, resolved to take:steps for
removing the persons who had been the objects of
our resolution, but not. without a violent struggle
against evidence. Seve4 Directors went so far as to
enter a protest against the vote of their court. Upon
this the General Court takes the alarm: it reassem*bles; it orders the Directors to rescind their resolution, that is, not to recall Mr. Hastings and Mr.
Hornby, and to despise the resolution of the House
? ? ? ? 518 SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL.
of Commons. Without so much as the pretence of
looking into a single paper, without the formality
of instituting any committee of inquiry, they superseded all the labors of their own Directors and of
this House.
It will naturally occur to ask, how it was possible
that they should not attempt some sort of examination into facts, as a color for their resistance to a
public authority proceeding so very deliberately, and
exerted, apparently at least, in favor of their own.
The answer, and the only answer which can be
given, is, that they were afraid that their true relation should be mistaken. They were afraid that
their patrons and masters in India should attribute
their support of them to an opinion of their cause,
and not to an attachment to their power. They
were afraid it should be suspected that they did not
mean blindly to support them in the use they made
of that power. They determined to show that they
at least were set against reformation: that they were
firmly resolved to bring the territories, the trade, and
the stock of the Company to ruin, rather than be wanting in fidelity to their nominal servants and real masters, in the ways they took to their private fortunes. Even since the beginning of this session, the same
act of audacity was repeated, with the same circumstances of contempt of all the decorum of inquiry on
their part, and of all the proceedings of this House.
They again made it a request to their favorite, and
your culprit, to keep his post, -and thanked and
applauded him, without calling for a paper which,could afford light into the merit or demerit of the
transaction, and without giving themselves a moment's time to consider, or even to understand, the
? ? ? ? SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL. 519
articles of the Mahratta peace. The fact is, that for a
long time there was a struggle, a faint one indeed,
between the Company and their servants. But it is
a struggle no longer. For some time the superiority
has been decided. The interests abroad are become
the settled preponderating weight both in the Court
of Proprietors and the Court of Directors. Even the
attempt you have made to inquire into their practices and to reform abuses has raised and piqued them to a far more regular and steady support.
The Company has made a common cause and identified themselves with the destroyers of India. They have taken on themselves all that mass of enormity;
they are supporting what you have reprobated;
those you condemn they applaud, those you order
home to answer for their conduct they request to
stay, and thereby encourage to proceed in their practices. Thus the servants of the East India Company triumph, and the representatives of the people of
Great Britain are defeated.
I therefore conclude, what you all conclude, that
this body, being totally perverted from the purposes
of its institution, is utterly incorrigible; and because
they are incorrigible, both in conduct and constitution, power ought to be taken out of their hands, - just on the same principles on which have been made
all the just changes and revolutions of government
that have taken place since the beginning of the
world.
I will now say a few words to the general principle
of the plan which is set up against that of my right
honorable friend. It is to recommit the government
of India to the Court of Directors. Those who would
commit the reformation of India to the destroyers of
? ? ? ? 520 SPEECH;ON BMR. FOX'S. EAST INDIA BILL.
it are the enemies to that reformation. They would
make a distinction between Directors and Proprietors,
which, inl the present state of things, does not, cannot exist. But. a right honorable gentleman says, he would keep the present government of India in the
Court of Directors, and would, to curb them, provide salutary: regulations. Wonderful! That is, he would appoint the old offenders to correct the old
offences; and he would render the vicious and the
foolish wise and virtuous by salutary regulations.
He would appoint the wolf as guardian of the sheep;
but he has invented a curious muzzle, by which this
protecting wolf shall not be able to open his jaws
above an inch or two at the utmost. Thus his work
is finished. But I tell the right honorable gentleman, that controlled depravity is not innocence, and that it is not the labor of delinquency in chains that
will correct abuses. Will these gentlemen of the
direction animadvert on the partners of their own
guilt? Never did a serious plan of amending of any
old tyrannical establishment propose the authors and
abettors of the abuses as the reformers of them. If
the undone people of India see their old oppressors in
confirmed power, even by the reformation, they will
expect nothing but what they will certainly feel,a continuance, or rather an aggravation, of all their former sufferings. They look to the seat of power,
and to the persons who fill it; and they despise
those gentlemen's regulations as much as the gentlemen do who talk of them.
But there is a cure for everything. Take away,
say they, the Court of Proprietors, and the Court. of
Directors will do their duty. Yes, - as they have
done it hitherto. That the evils in India have solely
? ? ? ? SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL. 521
arisen from the Court of Proprietors is grossly false.
In many of them the Directors were heartily concurring; in most of them they were encouraging, and
sometimes commanding; in all they were conniving.
But who are to choose this well-regulated and reforming Court of Directors? - Why, the very Proprietors who are excluded from all management, for the abuse of their power. They will choose, undoubtedly, out of themselves, men like themselves; and
those who are most forward in resisting your authority, those who are most engaged in faction or interest
with the delinquents abroad, will be the objects of
their selection. But gentlemen say, that, when this
choice is rade, the Proprietors are not to interfere in
the measures of the Directors, whilst those Directors
are busy in the control of their common patrons and
masters in India. No, indeed, I believe they will not
desire to interfere. They will choose those whom
they know may be trusted, safely trusted, to act in
strict conformity to their common principles, manners, measures, interests, and connections. -They will
want neither monitor nor control. It is not easy to
choose men to act in conformity to a public interest
against their private; but a sure dependence may be
had on those who are chosen to forward their private
interest at the expense of the public. But if the
-Directors should slip, and deviate into rectitude, the
punishment is in the hands of the General Court, and
it will surely be remembered to them at their next
election.
If the government of India wants no reformation,
but gentlemen are amusing themselves with a theory, conceiving a more democratic or aristocratic
mode of government for these dependencies, or if
? ? ? ? 522 SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL.
justice, and for the collection of revenue, was planned
and executed by the President and Council of Bengal,
subject to the pleasure of the Directors, in the year
1772. According to this plan, the country was divided into six districts, or provinces. In each of
these was established a provincial council, which
administered the revenue; and of that council, one
member, by monthly rotation, presided in the courts
of civil resort, with an appeal to the council of the
province, and thence to Calcutta. In this system
(whether in other respects good or evil) there were
some'capital advantages. There was, in the very
number of persons in each provincial council, authority, communication, mutual check, and control.
They were obliged, on their minutes of consultation,
to enter their reasons and dissents; so that a man of
diligence, of research, and tolerable sagacity, sitting
in London, might, from these materials, be enabled
to form some judgment of the spirit of what was
going on on the furthest banks of the Ganges and
Burrampooter.
The Court of Directors so far ratified this establishment, (which was consonant enough to their general
plan of government,) that they gave precise orders
that no alteration should be made in it without their
consent. So far from being apprised of any design
against this constitution, they had reason to conceive
that on trial it had been more and more approved by
their Council-General, at least by the Governor-General, who had planned it. At the time of the revolution, the Council-General was nominally in two persons, virtually in one. At that time measures of
an arduous and critical nature ought to have been
forborne, even if, to the fullest council, this specific
? ? ? ? SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL. 503
measure had not been prohibited by the superior
authority. It was in this very situation that one
man had the hardiness to conceive and the temerity
to execute a total revolution in the form and the
persons composing the government of a great kingdom. Without any previous step, at one stroke, the whole constitution of Bengal, civil and criminal, was
swept away. The counsellors were recalled from
their provinces; upwards of fifty of the principal
officers of government were turned out of employ,
and rendered dependent on Mr. Hastings for their
immediate subsistence, and for all hope of future
provision. The chief of each council, and one European collector of revenue, was left in each province.
But here, Sir, you may imagine a new government, of some permanent description, was established
in the place of that which had been thus suddenlyoverturned. No such thing. Lest these chiefs, without councils, should be conceived to form the groundplan of some future government, it was publicly declared that their continuance was. only temporary
and permissive. The whole subordinate British administration of revenue was then vested in a committee in Calcutta, all creatures of the' GovernorGeneral; and the provincial management, under the permissive chief, was delivered over to native officers.
But that the revolution and the purposes of the
revolution might be complete, to this committee were
delegated, not only the functions of all the inferior,
but, what will surprise the House, those of the supreme administration of revenue also. Hitherto the Governor-General and Council had, in their revenue
department, administered the finances of those king
? ? ? ? 504 SPEECH -ON MR. . FOX'S:EAST INDIA BILL.
doms. . By the. new scheme they are delegated to this
committee, who are only. :to report their proceedings
for approbation,.
The key to the whole transaction is given in one of
the: instructions to the committee, --" that it is not
necessary that they should enter dissents. ". By this
means the. ancient plan of the Company's administration was destroyed; but the plan of concealment was perfected. To that moment the accounts of the revenues. were tolerably clear, --or at least means were furnished for inquiries, by which they might be rendered satisfactory. In the obscure and silent gulf of
this committee everything is now buried. The thickest shades of night surround all their transactions.
No effectual means of detecting fraud, mismanagement, or misrepresentation exist. The Directors,
who have dared to talk with such confidence on their
revenues, know nothing about them. What used to
fill volumes is now comprised under a few dry heads
on a sheet of paper. The natives, a people habitually
made to concealment, are the chief managers of the
revenue throughout -the provinces. I mean by natives such wretches as your rulers select out of them
as most fitted for, their purposes. As a proper keystone to bind the arch, a native, one Gunga Govind
Sing, a man turned out of his employment by Sir
John Clavering for malversation in office, is made
the corresponding secretary, and, indeed, the great
moving principle of their new board.
As the whole revenue and civil administration was
thus subverted, and a clandestine government substituted in the place of it, the judicial institution underwent a like revolution. :In 1772 there had
been six courts, formed out of the six provincial
? ? ? ? SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL. . 506
councils. . Eighteen new ones are appointed in their
place, with each a judge, taken from the junior servants of the Company. To maintain these eighteen
courts, a. tax is levied on the sums in litigation, of
two and one half per cent on the great, and of five
per cent on the less. This money is all drawn from
the provinces to Calcutta. The. chief justice (the
same who stays in defiance of a vote of this House,
and of his Majesty's recall) is appointed at once the
treasurer: and disposer of these taxes, levied without
any sort:of authority from the Company, from the
Crown, or from Parliament.
In effect, Sir, every legal, regular authority, in
matters of revenue,. of political administration, of
criminal law, of civil law, in many of the most essential parts, of military discipline, is laid level with the
ground; and an oppressive, irregular, capricious, unsteady, rapacious, and peculating despotism, with a. direct disavowal. of obedience to, any authority at home, and without! any fixed maxim, principle, or
rule. of proceeding to guide them in India, is at present the state of your charter-government over great
kingdoms.
As the Company has made this use of their trust, I
should ill discharge mine, if I refused to give my most
cheerful vote for the redress of these abuses, by putting the affairs of so large and valuable a part of the
interests of this nation and of'mankind into some
steady hands, possessing the confidence and assured
of the. support of this House, until they can be restored
to regularity, order, and consistency.
I have touched the heads of some of the grievances
of the people and the abuses of government. But I
hope. and trust you will give me credit, when I faith
? ? ? ? 506 SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL.
fully assure you that I have not mentioned one
fourth part of what has come to my knowledge in
your committee; and further, I have full reason to
believe that not one fourth part of the abuses are
come to my knowledge, by that or by any other
means. Pray consider what I have said only as an
index to direct you in your inquiries.
If this, then, Sir, has been the use made of the trust
of political powers, internal and external, given by
you in the charter, the next thing to be seen is the
conduct of the Company with regard to the commercial trust. And here I will make a fair offer:- If it
can be proved that they have acted wisely, prudently,
and frugally, as merchants, I shall pass by the whole
mass of their enormities as statesmen. That they
have not done this their present condition is proof
sufficient. Their distresses are said to be owing to
their wars. This is not wholly true. But if it were,
is not that readiness to engage in wars, which distinguishes them, and for which the Committee of Secrecy has so branded their politics, founded on the falsest
principles of mercantile speculation?
The principle of buying cheap and selling dear is
the first, the great foundation of mercantile dealing.
Have they ever attended to this principle? Nay, for
years have they not actually authorized in their servants a total indifference as to the prices they were
to pay?
A great deal of strictness in driving bargains for
whatever we contract is another of the principles of
mercantile policy. Try the Company by that test.
Look at the contracts that are made for them. Is
the Company so much as a good commissary to their
own armies? I engage to select for you, out of the
? ? ? ? SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL. 507 innumerable mass of their dealings, all conducted very nearly alike, one contract only the excessive profits on which during a short term would pay the whole of their year's dividend. I shall undertake
to show that upon two others the inordinate profits
given, with the losses incurred in order to secure
those profits, would pay a year's dividend more.
It is a third property of trading-men to see that
their clerks do not divert the dealings of the master
to their own benefit. It was the other day only,
when their Governor and Council taxed the Company's investment with a sum of fifty thousand pounds, as an inducement to persuade only seven
members of their Board of Trade to give their honor that they would abstain from such profits upon that investment, as they must have violated their oaths, if they had made at all.
It is a fourth quality of a merchant to be exact in
his accounts. What will be thought, when you have
fully before you the mode of accounting made use of
in the Treasury of Bengal? I hope you will have it
soon. With regard to one of their agencies, when it
came to the material part, the prime cost of the goods
on which a commission of fifteen per cent was allowed, to the astonishment of the factory to whom the commodities were sent, the Accountant-General reports that he did not think himself authorized to call for vouchers relative to this and other particulars, -
because the agent was upon his honor with regard to
them. A new principle of account upon honor seems
to be regularly established in their dealings and their
treasury, which in reality amounts to an entire annihilation of the principle of all accounts.
It is a fifth property of a merchant, who does not
? ? ? ? 508 SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA. BILL.
meditate a fraudulent bankruptcy, to calculate his
probable profits. upon the. money he takes up to vest
in business. Did the Company,:when they bought
goods on bonds bearing eight per cent interest, at
ten and even twenty per cent discount, even ask
themselves a question concerning the possibility of
advantage from dealing on these terms?
The last quality of a merchant I shall advert to is
the taking care. to be properly prepared, in cash or
goods in the ordinary course of sale, for the. bills
which are drawn on them. Now I ask, whether they
have ever calculated the clear produce of any given
sales, to make them tally with the four million of
bills which are come and coming upon them, so as
at the proper periods to enable the one to liquidate
the other. No, they have not. They are now obliged
to borrow money of their own servants to purchase
their investment. The servants stipulate five per
cent on the capital they advance, if their bills. should
not be paid at. the time when they become due; and
the value of the rupee on which they charge this interest is taken, at two shillings and. a penny. Has the
Company ever troubled themselves to inquire whether
their sales can bear the payment of that interest, and
at that rate of exchange? Have they once considered
the dilemma in which they are placed, - the ruin of
their credit in the East Indies, if they refuse the bills,
- the ruin. of their credit and existence in England,
if they accept them?
Indeed, no trace of equitable government is found
in their politics,not one trace of commercial principle
in their mercantile dealing: and hence is the deepest and maturest, -wisdom of Parliament demanded, and the best resources of this kingdom must be
? ? ? ? SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL. 509
strained, to' restore them,- that is, to restore -the
countries destroyed by the misconduct of the Company, and to restore the. Company itself, ruined by the consequences of their plans for destroying what
they were bound to preserve.
I required, if you: remember, at my outset, a proof
that these abuses were habitual. 'But surely this is
not: necessary for me to consider as:a separate head';
because I trust: I have madeit evident beyond a doubt,
in considering the abuses themselves, that they are
regular,:permanent, and systematical.
J:I am,now come:to my last condition, without
which, for one, I will never readily-lend:my hand to
the. destruction of any established government, which
is,. :that, in its present. state, the government of the
East India Company is absolutely incorrigible.
Of this great truth. I think there can be little' doubt,
after all that has appeared in this Eouse. It is so
very. clear,'that I'. must consider the leaving any
power in. their; hands, and the determined resolution
to. . . :continue and countenance every mode and every
degree of peculation, oppression, and tyranny, to be
one and the same'thing. I look, upon that body incorrigible, from the fullest consideration both of their uniform conduct and their present real and'virtual
constitution.
If. they had not constantly been apprised of all the
enormities -committed in India under their authority,
if this state of things had been as much a discovery to
them as,'it was. to many of us, we might flatter ourselves that the detection of the abuses would lead to their reformation. I will go further. If the Court
of Directors had not uniformly condemned every
act which this House or any of its committees had
? ? ? ? 510 SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL.
condemned, if the language in which they expret;sed
their disapprobation against enormities and their authors had not been much more vehement and indignant than any ever used in this House, I should entertain some hopes. If they had not, on the other
hand, as uniformly commended all their servants who
had done their duty and obeyed their orders as they
had heavily censured those who rebelled, I might
say, These people have been in an error, and when
they are sensible of it they will mend. But when I
reflect on' the uniformity of their- support to the objects of their uniform censure, and the state of insignificance and disgrace to which all of those have been reduced whom they approved, and that even utter
ruin and premature death have been among the fruits
of their favor, I must be convinced, that in this case,
as in all others, hypocrisy is the only vice that never
can be cured.
Attend, I pray you, to the situation and prosperity
of Benfield, Hastings, and others of that sort. The
last of these has been treated by the Company with an
asperity of reprehension that has no parallel. They
lament "' that the power of disposing of their property
for perpetuity should fall into such hands. " Yet for
fourteen years, with little interruption, he has governed all their affairs, of every description, with an
absolute sway. He has had himself the means of
heaping up immense wealth; and duiring that whole
period, the fortunes of hundreds have depended on
his smiles and frowns. He himself tells you he is
incumbered with two hundred and fifty young gentlemen, some of them of the best families in England,
all of whom aim at returning with vast fortunes to
Europe in the prime of life. He has, then, two hun
? ? ? ? SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL. 511
dred and fifty of your children as his hostages for
your good behavior; and loaded for years, as he
has been, with the execrations of the natives, with
the censures of the. Court of Directors, and struck
and blasted with resolutions of this House, he still
maintains the most despotic. power ever known in
India. He domineers with an overbearing sway in
the assemblies of his pretended masters; and it is
thought in a degree rash to venture to name his
offences in this House, even as grounds of a legislative remedy.
On the other hand, consider the fate of those who
have met with the applauses of the Directors. Colonel Monson, one of the best of men, had his days
shortened by the applauses, destitute of the support,
of the Company. General Clavering, whose panegyric was made in every dispatch from England,
whose hearse was bedewed with the tears and hung
round with the eulogies of the Court of Directors,
burst an honest and indignant heart at the treachery
of those who ruined him by their praises. Uncommon patience. and temper supported Mr.
Francis a
while longer under the baneful influence of the commendation of the Court of Directors. His health,
however, gave way at length; and in utter despair,
he returned to Europe. At his return, the doors of
the. India House were shut to this man who had been
the object of their, constant admiration. He has, indeed, escaped with life; but he has forfeited all expectation of credit, consequence, party, and following. He may well say, "Me nemo ministro fur erit, atque
ideo nulli comes exeo. " This man, whose deep reach
of thought, whose large legislative conceptions, and
whose grand plans of policy make the most shining
? ? ? ? 512 SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL.
part of our Reports, from whence we have all learned
our lessons, if we have learned any good ones, - this
man, from whose materials those gentlemen who
have least acknowledged it have yet spoken as from
a brief, -this man, driven from his employment, discountenanced by the Directors, has had no other reward, and no other distinction, but that inward
" sunshine of the soul " which a good conscience can
always bestow upon itself. He has not yet had so
much as a good word, but from a person too insignificant to make any other return for the means with which he has been furnished for performing his share
of a duty which is equally urgent on us all.
Add to this, that, from the highest in place to the
lowest, every British subject; who, in obedience to
the Company's orders, has been active in the discovery of peculations, has been ruined. They have been driven from India. When they made their appeal at
home, they were not heard; when they attempted to
return, they were stopped. No artifice of fraud, no
violence of. power, has been omitted to destroy them
in character as well as in fortune.
Worse, far worse, has been the fate of the poor
creatures, the natives of India, whom the hypocrisy
of the Company has betrayed into complaint of oppression and discovery of peculation. The first women
in Bengal, the Ranny of Rajeshahi, the Ranny of
Burdwan, the Ranny of Ambooah, by their weak and
thoughtless trust in. the Company's honor and protection, are utterly ruined: the first of these women,
a person of princely rank, and once of correspondent
fortune, who -paid above two hundred thousand a year
quit-rentto the state, is, according to very credible information, so completely beggared as to stand in need
? ? ? ? SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL. 513
of the relief of allns. - Mahomed Reza Khan, the second Mussulman in Bengal, for having been distinguished by the ill-omened honor of the countenance and protection of the Court of Directors, was, without
the pretence of any inquiry whatsoever into his conduct, stripped of all his employments, and reduced to
the lowest condition. His ancient rival for power,
the Rajah Nundcomar, was, by an insult on everything which India holds respectable and sacred,
hanged in the face of all his nation by the judges
you sent to protect that people: hanged for a pretended crime, upon an ex post facto British act of
Parliament, in the midst of his evidence against Mr.
Hastings. The accuser they saw hanged. The culprit,
without acquittal or inquiry, triumphs on the ground
of. that murder: a murder, not of Nundcomar only, but
of all living testimony, and even of evidence yet unborn. From that time not a complaint has been heard
from the natives against their governors. All the.
grievances of India have found a complete remedy.
Men will not look to acts of Parliament, to regulations, to declarations, to votes, and resolutions. No,
they are not such fools. They will ask, What is the
road to power, credit, wealth, and honors? They
will ask, What conduct ends in neglect, disgrace, poverty, exile, prison, and gibbet? These will teach
them the course which they are to follow. It is your
distribution of these that will give the character and
tone to your government. All the rest is miserable
grimace.
When I accuse the Court of Directors of this habitual treachery in the use of reward and punishment,
I do not mean to include all the individuals in that
court. . There have been, Sir, very frequently men
VOL. II 33
? ? ? ? 514 SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL.
of the greatest integrity and virtue amongst them;
and the contrariety in the declarations and conduct
of that court has arisen, I take it, from this, -- that
the honest Directors have, by the force of matter of
fact on the records, carried the reprobation of the evil
measures of the servants in India. This could not
be prevented, whilst these records stared them in the
face; nor were the delinquents, either here or there,
very solicitous about their reputation, as long as they
were able to secure their power. The agreement of
their partisans to censure them blunted for a while
the edge of a severe proceeding. It obtained for
them a character of impartiality, which enabled them
to recommend with some sort of grace, what will
always carry a plausible appearance, those treacherous expedients called moderate measures. Whilst
these were under discussion, new matter of complaint
came over, which seemed to antiquate the first. The
same circle was here trod round once more; and
thus through years they proceeded in a compromise
of censure for punishment, until, by shame and despair, one after another, almost every man who preferred his duty to the Company to the interest of their servants has been driven from that court.
This, Sir, has been their conduct: and it has been
the result of the alteration which was insensibly made
in their constitution. The change was made insensibly; but it is now strong and adult, and as public
and declared as it is fixed beyond all power of reformation: so that there is none who hears me that is
not as certain as I am, that the Company, in the
sense in which it was formerly understood, has no
existence.
The question is not, what injury. you may do to the
? ? ? ? SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL. 515
proprietors of India stock;. for there are no such men
to be injured. If the active, ruling part of the Company, who form the General Court, who fill the offices
and direct the measures, (the rest tell for nothing,)
were persons~ who held their stock as a means of
their subsistence, who in the part they took were only concerned in the government of India for the rise
or fall of their dividend, it would be indeed a defective plan of policy. The interest of the people who
are governed by them would not be their primary object, - perhaps a very small part of their consideration at all. But then they might well-be depended on, and
perhaps more than persons in other respects preferable, for preventing the peculations of their servants to their own prejudice. Such a body would not easily
have left their trade as a spoil to the avarice of those
who received their wages. But now things are totally reversed. The stock is of no value, whether it
be the qualification of a Director or Proprietor; and
it is impossible that it should. A Director's qualification may be worth about two thousand five hundred pounds, -- and the interest, at eight per cent, is about
one hundred and sixty pounds a year. Of,what value is that, whether it rise to ten, or fall to six, or to nothing, to him whose son, before he is in Bengal two
months, and before he descends the steps of the Council-Chamber, sells the grant of a single contract for forty thousand pounds'? Accordingly, the stock is
bought up in qualifications. The vote is not to protect the stock, but the stock' is bought to acquire the vote; and the end of the vote is to cover and support,
against justice, some man of power who has made an
obnoxious fortune in India, or to maintain in power
those who are actually employing it in the acquisition
? ? ? ? 516 SPEECHE ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL.
Of such a fortune, - and to avail themselves, in return,
of his patronage, that he may shower the spoils of the
East, "barbaric pearl and gold," on them, their families, and dependants. : So that all the relations of the
Cbmpany are not only changed, but inverted. The servants in India are not appointed by the Directors, but
the Directors are chosen by them. The trade is carried on with their capitals. To them the revenues of
the country are mortgaged. The seat of the supreme
power is in Calcutta. The house in Leadenhall Street
is nothing more than a'change for their agents, factors, and deputies to meet in, to take care of their
affairs and support their interests, - and this so avowedly, that we see the known agents of the delinquent
servants marshalling and disciplining their forces, and
the prime spokesmen in all their assemblies.
Everything has followed in this order, and according to the natural train of events. I will close what
I have to say on the incorrigible condition of the
Company, by stating to you a few facts that will leave
no doubt of the obstinacy of that corporation, and of
their strength too, in resisting the reformation of
their servants. By these facts'you will be enabled to
discover the sole grounds upon which they are tenar
cious of their charter.
It is now more than two years, that upon account
of the gross abuses and ruinous situation of the Company's affairs,'(which occasioned the cry of the whole
world long before it was taken up here,) that we instituted two committees to inquire into the mismanagements by which the Company's affairs had been brought to the brink of ruin. These inquiries had been pursued
with unremitting diligence, and a great body of facts
was collected and printed for general information.
? ? ? ? SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL. 517
In the result of those inquiries, although the committees consisted of very different descriptions, they were
unanimous. They joined in censuring the conduct
of the. Indian admiinistration', and enforcing the responsibility upon two men, whom this House, in consequence of these reports, declared it to be the duty of the Directors to. remove from their stations, and
recall to Great Britain, --" because they had acted in
a manner repugnant to the honor and policy of this nation, and thereby brought great calamities on India and
enormous expenses on the East India Company. ".
Here was no attempt on the charter. Here was
no question of their privileges. To. vindicate their
own honor, to support their own interests, to enforce
obedience to their own orders,- these were the sole
object of the monitory resolution of this House. But
as soon as the General Court could. assemble, they
assembled to demonstrate who they really were.
Regardless of the proceedings of this House, they
ordered the Directors not to carry into effect any
resolution they might: come to for the removal df
Mr. - Hastings and Mr. Hornby. The Directors, still
retaining some shadow of respect to this House, instituted an inquiry themselves, which continued from
June to October, and, after an attentive perusal and
full consideration of papers, resolved to take:steps for
removing the persons who had been the objects of
our resolution, but not. without a violent struggle
against evidence. Seve4 Directors went so far as to
enter a protest against the vote of their court. Upon
this the General Court takes the alarm: it reassem*bles; it orders the Directors to rescind their resolution, that is, not to recall Mr. Hastings and Mr.
Hornby, and to despise the resolution of the House
? ? ? ? 518 SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL.
of Commons. Without so much as the pretence of
looking into a single paper, without the formality
of instituting any committee of inquiry, they superseded all the labors of their own Directors and of
this House.
It will naturally occur to ask, how it was possible
that they should not attempt some sort of examination into facts, as a color for their resistance to a
public authority proceeding so very deliberately, and
exerted, apparently at least, in favor of their own.
The answer, and the only answer which can be
given, is, that they were afraid that their true relation should be mistaken. They were afraid that
their patrons and masters in India should attribute
their support of them to an opinion of their cause,
and not to an attachment to their power. They
were afraid it should be suspected that they did not
mean blindly to support them in the use they made
of that power. They determined to show that they
at least were set against reformation: that they were
firmly resolved to bring the territories, the trade, and
the stock of the Company to ruin, rather than be wanting in fidelity to their nominal servants and real masters, in the ways they took to their private fortunes. Even since the beginning of this session, the same
act of audacity was repeated, with the same circumstances of contempt of all the decorum of inquiry on
their part, and of all the proceedings of this House.
They again made it a request to their favorite, and
your culprit, to keep his post, -and thanked and
applauded him, without calling for a paper which,could afford light into the merit or demerit of the
transaction, and without giving themselves a moment's time to consider, or even to understand, the
? ? ? ? SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL. 519
articles of the Mahratta peace. The fact is, that for a
long time there was a struggle, a faint one indeed,
between the Company and their servants. But it is
a struggle no longer. For some time the superiority
has been decided. The interests abroad are become
the settled preponderating weight both in the Court
of Proprietors and the Court of Directors. Even the
attempt you have made to inquire into their practices and to reform abuses has raised and piqued them to a far more regular and steady support.
The Company has made a common cause and identified themselves with the destroyers of India. They have taken on themselves all that mass of enormity;
they are supporting what you have reprobated;
those you condemn they applaud, those you order
home to answer for their conduct they request to
stay, and thereby encourage to proceed in their practices. Thus the servants of the East India Company triumph, and the representatives of the people of
Great Britain are defeated.
I therefore conclude, what you all conclude, that
this body, being totally perverted from the purposes
of its institution, is utterly incorrigible; and because
they are incorrigible, both in conduct and constitution, power ought to be taken out of their hands, - just on the same principles on which have been made
all the just changes and revolutions of government
that have taken place since the beginning of the
world.
I will now say a few words to the general principle
of the plan which is set up against that of my right
honorable friend. It is to recommit the government
of India to the Court of Directors. Those who would
commit the reformation of India to the destroyers of
? ? ? ? 520 SPEECH;ON BMR. FOX'S. EAST INDIA BILL.
it are the enemies to that reformation. They would
make a distinction between Directors and Proprietors,
which, inl the present state of things, does not, cannot exist. But. a right honorable gentleman says, he would keep the present government of India in the
Court of Directors, and would, to curb them, provide salutary: regulations. Wonderful! That is, he would appoint the old offenders to correct the old
offences; and he would render the vicious and the
foolish wise and virtuous by salutary regulations.
He would appoint the wolf as guardian of the sheep;
but he has invented a curious muzzle, by which this
protecting wolf shall not be able to open his jaws
above an inch or two at the utmost. Thus his work
is finished. But I tell the right honorable gentleman, that controlled depravity is not innocence, and that it is not the labor of delinquency in chains that
will correct abuses. Will these gentlemen of the
direction animadvert on the partners of their own
guilt? Never did a serious plan of amending of any
old tyrannical establishment propose the authors and
abettors of the abuses as the reformers of them. If
the undone people of India see their old oppressors in
confirmed power, even by the reformation, they will
expect nothing but what they will certainly feel,a continuance, or rather an aggravation, of all their former sufferings. They look to the seat of power,
and to the persons who fill it; and they despise
those gentlemen's regulations as much as the gentlemen do who talk of them.
But there is a cure for everything. Take away,
say they, the Court of Proprietors, and the Court. of
Directors will do their duty. Yes, - as they have
done it hitherto. That the evils in India have solely
? ? ? ? SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL. 521
arisen from the Court of Proprietors is grossly false.
In many of them the Directors were heartily concurring; in most of them they were encouraging, and
sometimes commanding; in all they were conniving.
But who are to choose this well-regulated and reforming Court of Directors? - Why, the very Proprietors who are excluded from all management, for the abuse of their power. They will choose, undoubtedly, out of themselves, men like themselves; and
those who are most forward in resisting your authority, those who are most engaged in faction or interest
with the delinquents abroad, will be the objects of
their selection. But gentlemen say, that, when this
choice is rade, the Proprietors are not to interfere in
the measures of the Directors, whilst those Directors
are busy in the control of their common patrons and
masters in India. No, indeed, I believe they will not
desire to interfere. They will choose those whom
they know may be trusted, safely trusted, to act in
strict conformity to their common principles, manners, measures, interests, and connections. -They will
want neither monitor nor control. It is not easy to
choose men to act in conformity to a public interest
against their private; but a sure dependence may be
had on those who are chosen to forward their private
interest at the expense of the public. But if the
-Directors should slip, and deviate into rectitude, the
punishment is in the hands of the General Court, and
it will surely be remembered to them at their next
election.
If the government of India wants no reformation,
but gentlemen are amusing themselves with a theory, conceiving a more democratic or aristocratic
mode of government for these dependencies, or if
? ? ? ? 522 SPEECH ON MR. FOX'S EAST INDIA BILL.