Any number of individuals, who can
agree upon it, have an undoubted right to form themselves into a state apart and wholly independent.
agree upon it, have an undoubted right to form themselves into a state apart and wholly independent.
Edmund Burke
struct a nation, some reason might be offered for
-monarchy; but when we cast our eyes about a coun
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 161
try, and observe how every part understands its own
affairs, and when we look around the world, and see.
that, of all men in it, the race of kings are the most
insignificant in capacity, our reason cannot fail to ask
us, What are those men kept for? " *
These are the notions which, under the idea of
Whig principles, several persons, and among them
persons of no mean mark, have associated themselves
to propagate. I will not attempt in the smallest
degree to refute them. This will probably be done
(if such writings shall be thought to deserve any
other than the refutation of criminal justice) by others, who may think with Mr. Burke. He has performed his part. I do not wish to enter very much at large into
the discussions which diverge and ramify in all ways
from this productive subject. But there is one topic upon which I hope I shall be excused in going a
little beyond my design. The factions now so busy
amongst us, in order to djyov men of all love for
their country, and to remove from their minds all
duty with regard to the state, endeavor to propagate
an opinion, that the people, in forming their commonwealth, have by no means parted with their power
over it. This is an impregnable citadel, to which
these gentlemen retreat, whenever they are pushed by
the battery of laws and usages and positive conventions. Indeed, it is such, and of so great force, that
all they have done in defending their outworks is so
much time and labor thrown away. Discuss any of
their schemes, their answer is, It is the act of te'd
* Vindication of the Rights of Man, recommended by the sevcral
societies.
VOL. IV. 11
? ? ? ? 162 APPEAL FROMI THE NEW
people, and that is sufficient. Are we to deny to a
majority of the people the right of altering even the
whole frame of their society, if such should be their
pleasure? They may change it, say they, from a
monarchy to a republic to-day, and to-morrow back
again from a republic to a monarchy; and so backward and forward as often as they like. They are
masters of the commonwealth, because in substance
they are themselves the commonwealth. The French
Revolution, say they, was the act of the majority of
the people; and if the majority of any other people,
the people of England, for instance, wish to make the
same change, they have the same right.
Just the same, undoubtedly. That is, none at all.
Neither the few nor the many have a right to act
merely by their will, in any matter connected with
duty, trust, engagement, or obligation. The Constitution of a country being once settled upon some
compact, tacit or expressed, there is no power existing of force to alter it, without the breach of the covenant, or the consent of all the parties. Such is the nature of a contract. And the votes of a majority
of the people, whatever their infamous flatterers may
teach in order to corrupt their minds, cannot alter
the moral any more than they can alter the physical
essence of things. The people are not to be taught
to think lightly of their engagements to their governors; else they teach governors to think lightly
of their engagements' towards them. In that kind
of game, in the end, the people are sure to be losers.
To flatter them into a contempt of faith, truth, and
justice is to ruin them; for in these virtues consists
their whole safety. To flatter any man, or any part
of mankind, in any description, by asserting that in
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 163
engagements he or they are free, whilst any other human creature is bound, is ultimately to vest the rule
of morality in the pleasure of those who ought to be
rigidly submitted to it, -- to subject the sovereign
reason of the world to the caprices of weak and giddy
men.
But, as no one of us men can dispense with public
or private faith, or with any other tie of moral obligation, so neither can any number of us. The number
engaged in crimes, instead of turning them into laudable acts, only augments the quantity and intensity
of the guilt. I am well aware that men love to hear
of their power, but have an extreme disrelish to be
told of their duty. This is of course; because every
duty is a limitation of some power. Indeed, arbitrary power is so much to the depraved taste of the vulgar, of the vulgar of every description, that almost all the dissensions which lacerate the commonwealth are
not concerning the manner in which it is to be exercised, but concerning the hands in which it is to be
placed. Somewhere they are resolved to have it.
Whether they desire it to be vested in the many or
the few depends with most men upon the chance
which they imagine they themselves may have of partaking in the exercise of that arbitrary sway, in the
one mode or in the other.
It is not necessary to teach men to thirst after
power. But it is very expedient that by moral instruction they should be taught, and by their civil
constitutions they should be compelled, to put many
restrictions upon the immoderate exercise of it, and
the inordinate desire. The best method of obtaining
these two great points forms the important, but at
the same time the difficult problem to the true states
? ? ? ? 164 APPEAL FROM THE NEW.
man. He thinks of the place in which political power is to be lodged with no other attention than as it
may render the more or the less practicable its salutary restraint and its prudent direction. For this
reason, no legislator, at any period of the world, has
willingly placed the seat of active power in the hands
of the multitude; because there it admits of no control, no regulation, no steady direction whatsoever.
The people are the natural control on authority; but
to exercise and to control together is contradictory
and impossible.
As the exorbitant exercise of power cannot, under popular sway, be effectually restrained, the other
great object of political arrangement, the means of
abating an excessive desire of it, is in such a state
still worse provided for. The democratic commonwealth is the foodful nurse of ambition. Under the
other forms it meets with many restraints. Whenever, in states which have had a democratic basis, the
legislators have endeavored to put restraints upon
ambition, their methods were as violent as in the
end they were ineffectual, -- as violent, indeed, as any
the most jealous despotism could invent. The ostracism could not very long save itself, and much less
the state which it was meant to guard, from the attempts of ambition, - one of the natural, inbred, incurable distempers of a powerful democracy. But to return from this short digression, - which,
however, is not wholly foreign to the question of the
effect of the will of the majority upon the form or the
existence of their society. I cannot too often recommend ii to the serious consideration of all men who
think civil society to be within the province of moral
jurisdiction, that, if we owe to it any duty, it is not
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 165
subject to our will. Duties are not voluntary. Duty
and will are even contradictory terms. Now, though
civil society might be at first a voluntary act, (wrhich
in many cases it undoubtedly was,) its continuance
is under a permanent standing covenant, coexisting
with the society; and it attaches upon every individual of that society, without any formal act of his own.
This is warranted by the general practice, arising
out of the general sense of mankind. Men without
their choice derive benefits from that association;
without their choice they are subjected to duties
in consequence of these benefits; and without their
choice they enter into a virtual obligation as bindinlg
as any'that is actual. Look through the whole of life
and the whole system of duties. Much the strongest
moral obligations are such as were never the results
of our option. I allow, that, if no Supreme Ruler
exists, wise to form, and potent to enforce, the moral
law, there is no sanctionl to any contract, virtual or
even actual, against the will of prevalent power. On
that hypothesis, let any set of men be strong enough
to set their duties at defiance, and they cease to
be duties any longer. We have but this one appeal against irresistible power,Si genus humanum et mortalia temnitis arma, At sperate Deos memores fandi atque nefandi.
Taking it for granted that I do not write to the disciples of the Parisian philosophy, I may assume that
the awful Author of our being is the Author of our
place ill the order of existence, - and that, having
disposed and marshalled us by a divine tactic, not
according to our will, but according to His, He has
in and by that disposition virtually subjected us
to act the part which belongs to the place assigned
? ? ? ? 166 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
us. We have obligations to mankind at large, which
are not in consequence of any special voluntary pact.
They arise from the relation of man to man, and the
relation of man to God, which relations are not matters of choice. On the contrary, the force of all the
pacts which we enter into with any particular person or number of persons amongst mankind depends upon those prior obligations. In some cases the subordinate relations are voluntary, in others they are necessary, --but the duties are all compulsive. When
we marry, the choice is voluntary, but the duties are
not matter of choice: they are dictated by the nature of the situation. Dark and inscrutable are the
ways by which we come into the world. The instincts which give rise to this mysterious process of
Nature are not of our making. But out of physical
causes, unknown to us, perhaps unknowable, arise
moral duties, which, as we are able perfectly to comprehend, we are bound indispensably to perform. Parents may not be consenting to their moral relation; but, consenting or not, they are bound to a
long train of burdensome duties towards those with
whom they have never made a convention of any
sort. Children are not consenting to their relation;
but their relation, without their actual consent, binds
them to its duties, -or rather it implies their consent,
because the presumed consent of every rational creature is in unison with the predisposed order of things. Men come in that manner into a community with the
social state of their parents, endowed with all the
benefits, loaded with all the duties of their situation.
If the social ties and ligaments, spun out of those
physical relations which are the elements of the commonwealth, in most cases begin, and always continue,
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 167
Independently of our will, so, without any stipulation
on our own part, are we bound by that relation called
our country, which comprehends (as it has been well
said) " all the charities of all. " * Nor are we left
without powerful instincts to make this duty as dear
and grateful to us as it is awful and coercive. Our
country is not a thing of mere physical locality. It
consists, in a great measure, in the ancient order
into which we are born. We may have the same
geographical situation, but another country; as we
may have the same country in another soil. The
place that determines our duty to our country is a
social, civil relation.
These are the opinions of the author whose cause I
defend. I lay them down, not to enforce them upon
others by disputation, but as an account of his proceedings. On them he acts; and from them he is
convinced that neither he, nor any man, or number
of men, have a right (except what necessity, which
is out of and above all rule, rather imposes than bestows) to free themselves from that primary engagement into which every mall born into a community as much contracts by his being born into it as he
contracts an obligation to certain parents by his having been derived from their bodies. The place of
every man determines his duty. If you ask, Quem
te Deus esse jussit? you will be answered when
you resolve this other question, Humana qua parte
locatus es in re? *
I admit, indeed, that in morals, as in all things
else, difficulties will sometimes occur. Duties will
sometimes cross one another. Then questions will
* Omnes omnium charitates patria una complectitur. " - CIc.
t A few lines in Persius contain a good summary of all the objects
? ? ? ? 168 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
arise, which of them is to be placed in subordination?
which of them may be entirely superseded? These
doubts give rise to that part of moral science called
csastry, which though necessary to be well studied
by those who would become expert in that learning,
who aim at becoming what I think Cicero somewhere calls artifices officiorum, it requires a very
solid and discriminating judgment, great modesty
and caution, and much sobriety of mind in the
handling; else there is a danger that it may totally
subvert those offices which it is its object only to
methodize and reconcile. Duties, at their extreme
bounds, are drawn very fine, so as to become almost
evanescent. In that state some shade of doubt will
always rest on these questions, when they are pursued with great subtilty. But the very habit of stating these extreme cases is not very laudable or safe; because, in general, it is not right to turn our duties
into doubts. They are imposed to govern our conduct, not to exercise our ingenuity; and therefore
our opinions about them ought not to be in a state
of fluctuation, but steady, sure, and resolved.
Amongst these nice, and therefore dangerous points
of casuistry, may be reckoned the question so much
agitated in the present hour, --Whether, after the
people have discharged themselves of their original
power by an habitual delegation, no occasion call
of moral investigation, and hint the result of our inquiry: There human will has no place.
Quid sumus? et quidnam victuri gignimur? ordo
Quis datus? et metwe quis mollis flexus, et unde?
Quis modus argento? Quidfas optarte? Quid asper
Utile nummus habet? Patrice charisquepropinquis
Quantum elargiri debet? Quem te Deus esse
Jussit? et humana qua parte locatus es in re?
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 169
possibly occur which may justify the resumption of
it? This question, in this latitude, is very hard to
affirm or deny: but I am satisfied that no occasion
can justify such a resumption, which would not
equally authorize a dispensation with any other moral duty, perhaps with all of them together. However, if in general it be not easy to determine concerning the lawfulness of such devious proceedings, which must be ever on the edge of crimes, it is far
from difficult to foresee the perilous consequences of
the resuscitation of such a power in the people. The
practical consequences of any political tenet go a
great way in deciding upon its value. Political problems do not primarily concern truth or falsehood.
They relate to good or evil. What in the result is
likely to produce evil is politically false; that which
is productive of good, politically true.
Believing it, therefore, a question at least arduous
in the theory, and in the practice very critical, it
would become us to ascertain as well as we can
what form it is that our incantations are about to
call up from darkness and the sleep of ages. WhenI
the supreme authority of the people is in question,
before we attempt to extend or to confine it, we
ought to fix in our minds, with some degree of distinctness, an idea of what it is we mean, when we
say, the PEOPLE.
In a state of rude Nature there is no such thing as
a people. A number of men in themselves have no
collective capacity. The idea of a people is the idea
of a corporation. It is wholly artificial, and made,
like all other legal fictions, by common agreement.
What the particular nature of that agreement was
is collected from the form into which the particular
? ? ? ? 170 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
society has been cast. Any other is not their covenant. When men, therefore, break up the original compact or agreement which gives its corporate form
and capacity to a state, they are no longer a people, -
they have no longer a corporate existence - they have
no longer a legal coactive force to bind within, nor
a claim to be recognized abroad. They are a number of vague, loose individuals, and nothing more.
With them all is to begin again. Alas! they little
know how many a weary step is to be taken before
they can form themselves into a mass which has a
true politic personality.
We hear much, from men who have not acquired
their hardiness of assertion from the profundity of
their thinking, about the omnipotence of a majority,
in such a dissolution of an ancient society as hath taken place in France. But amongst men so disbanded there can be no such thing as majority or minority,
or power in any one person to bind another. The
power of acting by a majority, which the gentlemen
theorists seem to assume so readily, after they have
violated the contract out of which it has arisen, (if at
all it existed,) must be grounded on two assumptions: first, that of an incorporation produced by unanimity; and secondly, an unanimous agreement
that the act of a mere majority (say of one) shall pass
with them and with others as the act of the whole.
We are so little affected by things which are habitual, that we consider this idea of the decision of a majority as if it were a law of our original nature.
But such constructive whole, residing in a part only,
is one of the most violent fictions of positive law that
ever has been or can be made on the principles of
artificial incorporation. Out of civil society Nature
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 171
knows nothing of it; nor are. men, even when arranged according to civil order, otherwise than by
very long training, brought at all to submit to it.
The mind is brought far more easily to acquiesce in
the proceedings of one man, or a few, who act under
a general procuration for the state, than in the vote
of a victorious majority in councils in which every
man has his share in the deliberation. For there the
beaten party are exasperated and soured by the previous contention, and mortified by the conclusive defeat. This mode of decision, where wills may be so nearly equal, where, according to circumstances, the
smaller number may be the stronger force, and where
apparent reason may be all upon one side, and on the
other little else than impetuous appetite, - all this
must be the result of a very particular and special
convention, confirmed afterwards by long habits of
obedience, by a sort of discipline in society, and by a
strong hand, vested with stationary, permanent power to enforce this sort of constructive general will.
What organ it is that shall declare the corporate
mind is so much a matter of positive arrangement,
that several states, for the validity of several of their
acts, have required a proportion of voices much
greater than that of a mere majority. These proportions are so entirely governed by convention that
in some cases the minority decides. The laws in
many countries to condemn require more than a mere
majority; less than an equal number to acquit. In
our judicial trials we require unanimity either to condemn or to absolve. In some incorporations one man
speaks for the whole; in others, a few. Until the
other day, in the Constitution of Poland unanimity
was required to give validity to any act of their great
? ? ? ? 172 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
national council or diet. This approaches much more
nearly to rude Nature than the institutions of any
other country. Such, indeed, every commonwealth
must be, without a positive law to recognize in a certain number the will of the entire body.
If men dissolve their ancient incorporation in order to regenerate their community, in that state of things each man has a right, if he pleases, to remain
all individual.
Any number of individuals, who can
agree upon it, have an undoubted right to form themselves into a state apart and wholly independent. If any of these is forced into the fellowship of another,
this is conquest and not compact. On every principle which supposes society to be in virtue of a free covenant, this compulsive incorporation must be null
and void.
As a people can have no right to a corporate capacity without universal consent, so neither have they a right to hold' exclusively any lands in the name and
title of a corporation. On the scheme of the present
rulers in our neighboring country, regenerated as
they are, they have no more right to the territory
called France than I have. I have a right to pitch
my tent in any unoccupied place I can find for it;
and I may apply to my own maintenance any part
of their unoccupied soil. I may purchase the house
or vineyard of any individual proprietor who refuses
his consent (and most proprietors have, as far as they
dared, refused it) to the new incorporation. I stand
in his independent place. Who are these insolent
men, calling themselves the French nation, that would
monopolize this fair domain of Nature? Is it because
they speak a certain jargon? Is it Trei mode of chattelilg, to me unintelligible, that forms their title to
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 1]73
my land? Who are they who claim by prescription
and descent from certain gangs of banditti called
Franks, and Burgundians, and Visigoths, of whom I
may have never heard, and ninety-nine out of an hundred of themselves certainly never have heard, whilst
at the very time they tell me that prescription and
long possession form no title to property? Who are
they that presume to assert that the land which I
purchased of the individual, a natural person, and not
a fiction of state, belongs to them, who in the very
capacity in which they make their claim can exist
only as an imaginary being, and in virtue of the very
prescription which they reject and disown? This
mode of arguing might be pushed into all the detail,
so as to leave no sort of doubt, that, on their principles, and on the sort of footing on which they have
thought proper to place themselves, the crowd of
men, on the other side of the Channel, who have the
impudence to call themselves a people, can never be
the lawful, exclusive possessors of the soil. By what
they call reasoning without prejudice, they leave not
one stone upon another in the fabric of human society. They subvert all the authority which they hold,
as well as all that which they have destroyed.
As in the abstract it is perfectly clear, that, out
of a state of civil society, majority and minority are
relations which can have no existence, and that, in
civil society, its own specific conventions in each corporation determine what it is that constitutes the people, so as to make their act the signification of the general will, - to come to particulars, it is equally
clear that neither in France nor in England has the
original or any subsequent compact of the state, expressed or implied, constituted a majority of men, told
? ? ? ? 174 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
by the head, to be the acting people of their several
communities. And I see as little of policy or utility
as there is of right, in laying down a principle that
a majority of men told by the head are to be considered as the people, and that as such their will is
to be law. What policy can there be found in arrangements made in defiance of every political principle? To enable men to act with the weight and character of a people, and to answer the ends for
which they are incorporated into that capacity, we
must suppose them (by means immediate or consequential) to be in that state of habitual social discipline in which the wiser, the more expert, and the more opulent conduct, and by conducting enlighten
and protect, the weaker, the less knowing, and the
less provided with the goods of fortune. When the
multitude are not under this discipline, they can
scarcely be said to be in civil society. Give once
a certain constitution of things which produces a
variety of conditions and circumstances in a state,
and there is in Nature and reason a principle which,
for their own benefit, postpones, not the interest, but
the judgment, of those who are numero plures, to those
who are virtute et honore majores. Numbers in a state
(supposing, which is not the case in France, that a
state does exist) are always of consideration, - but
they are not the whole consideration. It is in things
more serious than a play, that it may be truly said,
Satis est equitem mihi plaudere.
A true natural aristocracy is not a separate interest in the state, or separable from it. It is an essential
integrant part of any large body rightly constituted.
It is forlmed out of a class of legitimate presumptions,
whicll, taken as generalities, must be admitted for
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 175
actual truths. To be bred in a place of estimation;
to see nothing low and sordid from one's infancy; to
be taught to respect one's self; to be habituated to
the censorial inspection of the public eye; to look
early to public opinion; to stand upon such elevated
ground as to be enabled to take a large view of the
wide-spread and infinitely diversified combinations of
men and affairs in a large society; to have leisure to
read, to reflect, to converse; to be enabled to draw
the court and attention of the wise and learned, wherever they are to be found; to be habituated in armies to command and to obey; to be taught to despise danger in the pursuit of honor and duty; to be formed to the greatest degree of vigilance, foresight,
and circumspection, in a state of things in which no
fault is committed with impunity and the slightest
mistakes draw on the most ruinous consequences;
to be led to a guarded and regulated conduct, from
a sense that you are considered as an instructor of
your fellow-citizens in their highest concerns, and
that you act as a reconciler between God and man;
to be employed as an administrator of law and justice, and to be thereby amongst the first benefactors
to mankind; to be a professor of high science, or
of liberal and ingenuous art; to be amongst rich
traders, who from their success are presumed to have
sharp and vigorous understandings, and to possess the
virtues of diligence, order, constancy, and regularity,
and to have cultivated an habitual regard to commutative justice: these are the circumstances of men
that form what I should call a natural aristocracy,
without which there is no nation.
The state of civil society which necessarily generates this aristocracy is a state of Nature, --and much
? ? ? ? 176 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
more truly so than a savage and incoherent mode of
life. For man is by nature reasonable; and he is
never perfectly in his natural state, but when he is
placed where reason may be best cultivated and most
predominates. Art is man's nature. We are as much,
at least, in a state of Nature in formed manhood as
in immature and helpless infancy. Men, qualified ill
the manner I have just described, form in Nature, as
she operates in the common modification of society,
the leading, guiding, and governing part. It is the
soul to the body, without which the man does not
exist. To give, therefore, no more importance, in
the social order, to such descriptions of men than
that of so many units is a horrible usurpation.
When great multitudes act together, under that
discipline of Nature, I recognize the PEOPLE. I
acknowledge something that perhaps equals, and
ought always to guide, the sovereignty of convention. In all things the voice of this grand chorus
of national harmony ought to have a mighty and
decisive influence. But when you disturb this harmony,-when you break up this beautiful order, this
array of truth and Nature, as well as of habit and prejudice, - when you separate the common sort of men from their proper chieftains, so as to form them into
an adverse army, -- I no longer know that venerable object called the people in such a disbanded race
of deserters and vagabonds. For a while they may
be terrible, indeed, -but in such a manner as wild
beasts are terrible. The mind owes to them no sort
of submission. They are, as they have always been
reputed, rebels. They may lawfully be fought with,
and brought under, whenever an advantage offers.
Those who attempt by outrage and violence to de
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 177
prive men of any advantage which they hold under
the laws, and to destroy the natural order of life, proclaim war against them.
We have read in history of that furious insurrection of the common people in France called the Jacquerie: for this is not the first time that the people
have been enlightened into treason, murder, and rapine. Its object was to extirpate the gentry. The
Captal de Buch, a famous soldier of those days, dis.
honored the name of a gentleman and of a man by
taking, for their cruelties, a cruel vengeance on these
deluded wretches: it was, however, his right and his
duty to make war upon them, and afterwards, in
moderation, to bring them to punishment for their
rebellion; though in the sense of the French Revolution, and of some of our clubs, they were the people, - and were truly so, if you will call by that appellation any majority of men told by the head. At a time not very remote from the same period
(for these humors never have'affected one of the
nations without some influence on the other) happened several risings of the lower commons in England. These insurgents were certainly the majority
of the inhabitants of the counties in which they resided; and Cade, Ket, and Straw, at the head of
their national guards, and fomented by certain traitors of high rank, did no more than exert, according
to the doctrines of ours and the Parisian societies,
the sovereign power inherent in the majority.
We call the time of those events a dark- age. Indeed, we are too indulgent to our own proficiency.
The Abb6 John Ball understood the rights of manl
as well as the Abbe Gr6goire. That reverend patriarch of sedition, and prototype of our modern preachVOL. IV. 12
? ? ? ? 178 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
ers, was of opinion, with the National Assembly, that
all the evils which have fallen upon men had been
caused by an ignorance of their " having been born
and continued equal as to their rights. " Had the
populace been able to repeat that profound maxim,
all would have gone perfectly well with them. No
tyranny, no vexation, no oppression, no care, no sorrow, could have existed in the world. This would
hlave cured them like a charm for the tooth-ache.
But the lowest wretches, in their most ignorant state,
were able at all times to talk such stuff; and yet at
all timnes have they suffered many evils and many
oppressions, both before and since the republication
by the National Assembly of this spell of healing potency and virtue. The enlightened Dr. Ball, when
he wished to rekindle the lights and fires of his audience on this point, chose for the text the following
couplet: -
When Adam delved and Eve span,
Who was then the gentleman?
Of this sapien. t maxim, however, I do not give him
for the inventor. It seems to have been handed
down by tradition, and had certainly become proverbial; but whether then composed or only applied,
thus much must be admitted, that in learning, sense,
energy, and comprehensiveness, it is fully equal to
all the modern dissertations oil the equality of mankind: and it has one advantage over them, -that it
is in rhyme. *
* It is no small loss to the world, that the whole of this enlightened and philosophic sermon, preached to two hundred thousand national guards assembled at Blackheath (a number probably equal to the sublime and majestic Federation of the 14th of July, 1790, in the
Champ de Mars) is n-t preserved. A short abstract is, however, to
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 179
There is no doubt but that this great teacher of the
rights of man decorated his discourse on this valuable
text with lemmas, theorems, scholia, corollaries, and
all the apparatus of science, which was furnished in
be found in Walsingham. I have added it here for the edification of
the modern Whigs, who may possibly except this precious little fragment from their general contempt of ancient learning.
"Ut sua doctrin' plures inficeret, ad le Blackheth (ubi ducenta millia hominum communium fuere simul congregata) hujuscemodi sermonem est exorsus.
"Whan Adam dalfe and Eve span,
Who was than a gentleman?
Continuansque sermonem inceptum, nitebatur per verba proverbii,
quod pro themate sumpserat, introducere et probare, ab initio omnes
pares creatos a naturd, servitutem per injustam oppressionern nequam
hominum introductam contra Dei voluntatem, quia si Deo placuisset
servos cre'asse, utique in principio mundi constituisset, quis servus,
quisve dominus futurus fuisset. Considerarent igitur jam tempus a
Deo datum eis, in quo (deposito servitutis jugo diutius) possent, si
vellent, libertate diu concupitf gaudere. Quapropter monuit ut essent viri cordati, et amore boni patrisfamilias excolentis agrum suum,
et extirpantis ac resecantis noxia gramina quae fruges solent opprimere, et ipsi in prsesenti facere festinarent. Primb majores regni dolinos occidendo. Deinde juridicos, justiciarios, et juratores patrice perilendo.
Postremb quoscunque scirent in posterurn commnunitati nocivos tollerent
de terra sua, sic demum et pacem sibimet parerent et securitatent in futurum. Si sublatis majoribus esset inter eos oequa libertas, eadem nobilitas,
par dignitas, similisque potestas. "
Here is displayed at once the whole of the grand arcanuma pretended to be found out by the National Assembly, for securing future happiness, peace, and tranquillity. There seems, however, to be some
doubt whether this venerable protomartyr of philosophy was inclined
to carry his own declaration of the rights of men more rigidly into
practice than the National Assembly themselves. He was, like them,
only preaching licentiousness to the populace to obtain power for himself, if we may believe what is subjoined by the historian. ,' Cumque hwec et plura alia deliramenta " (think of this old fool's calling all the wise maxims of the French Academy deliramenta! ) "prredicasset, commune vulgus eum tant
? ? ? ? 180 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
as great plenty and perfection out of the dogmatic
and polemic magazines, the old horse-armory of the
Schoolmen, among whom the Rev. Dr. Ball was bred,
as they can be supplied from the new arsenal at Hack(,rent ern archiepiscopum futurum, et regni cancellarium. " Whether
ho would have taken these situations under these names, or would
have chanled the whole nomenclature of the State and Church, to
be understood in the sense of the Revolution, is not so certain. It is
)robable that he would have changed the names and kept the substance of power.
We find, too, that they had in those days their society for constitutional inlformation, of which the Reverend John Ball was a conspicuous
member, sometimes under his own name, sometimes under the feigned
name of John Schep. Besides him it consisted (as Knyghton tells
us) of persons who went by the real or fictitious names of Jack Mylner, Tom Baker, Jack Straw, Jack Trewman, Jack Carter, and probably of many more. Some of the choicest flowers of the publications charitably written and circulated by them gratis are upon record in
Walsingham and Knyghton: and I am inclined to prefer the pithy
and sententious brevity of these bulletins of ancient rebellion before
the loose and confused prolixity of the modern advertisements of constitutional information. They contain more good morality and less
bad politics, they had much more foundation in real oppression, and
they have the recommendation of being much better adapted to the
capacities of those for whose instruction they were intended. Whatever laudable pains the teachers of the present day appear to take, I
cannot compliment them so far as to allow that they have succeeded
in writing down to the level of their pupils, the members of the sovereign,
with half the ability of Jack Carter and the Reverend John Ball.
That my readers may judge for themselves, I shall give them one or
two specimens.
The first is an address from the Reverend John Ball, under his
aonm de guerre of John Schep. I know not against what particular
", guyle in borough" the writer means to caution the people; it may
have been only a general cry against, rotten boroughs," which it was
thought convenient, then as now, to make the first pretext, and place
at the head of the list of grievances.
JOHN SCHEP.
" Iohn Schep sometime seint Mary priest of Yorke, and now of Col
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 181
ney. It was, no doubt, disposed with all the adjutancy of definition and division, in which (I speak it
with submission) the old marshals were as able as the
modern martinets. Neither can we deny that the
chester, greeteth well Iohn Namelesse, and Iohn the Miller, and Iohn
Carter, and biddeth then that they beware of guyle in borough, and stand
together in Gods name, and biddeth Piers Ploweman goe to his
werke, and chastise well Hob the robber, [probably the king,] and take
with you Iohn Trewman, and all his fellows, and no moe.
" Iohn the Miller hath yground smal, small, small:
The kings sonne of heauen shal pay for all.
Beware or ye be woe,
Know your frende fro your foe,
IHaue ynough, and say hoe:
And do wel and better, & flee sinne,
And seeke peace and holde you therin,
& so biddeth Iohn Trewman & all his fellowes. "
The reader has perceived, from the last lines of this curious statepaper, how well the National Assembly has copied its union of the
profession of universal peace with the practice of murder and confusion, and the blast of the trumpet of sedition in all nations. He will
in the following constitutional paper observe how well, in their enigmatical style, like the Assembly and their abettors, the old philosopliers proscribe all hereditary distinction, and bestow it only on virtue and wisdom, according to their estimation of both. Yet these people are supposed never to have heard of "the rights of man" I
JACK MYLNER.
"' Jakke Mylner asket help to turne his mylne aright.
"'He hath grounden smal smal,
The Kings sone of heven he schal pay for alle.
Loke thy mylne go a rygt, with the foure sayles, and the post stande
in steadfastnesse.
" With rygt and with mygt,
With skyl and with wylle,
Lat mygt helpe rygt,
And skyl go before wille,
And rygt before mygt:
Than goth oure mvlne aryght.
And if mygt go before ryght,
? ? ? ? 182 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
philosophic auditory, when they had once obtained
this knowledge, could never return to their former
ignorance, or after so instructive a lecture be in the
same state of mind as if they had never heard it. *
But these poor people, who were not to be envied for
their knowledge, but pitied for their delusion, were
not reasoned, (that was impossible,) but beaten, out of
their lights. With their teacher they were delivered
over to the lawyers, who wrote in their blood the
statutes of the land, as harshly, and in the same sort
of ink, as they and their teachers had written the
rights of man.
Our doctors of the day are not so fond of quoting
the opinions of this ancient sage as they are of imitating his conduct: first, because it might appear that they are not as great inventors as they would
be thought; and next, because, unfortunately for his
fame, he was not successful. It is a remark liable
to as few exceptions as any generality can be, that
they who applaud prosperous folly and adore triumAnd. wylle before skylle;
Than is oure mylne mys a dygt. "
JACK CARTER understood perfectly the doctrine of looking to the
end, with an indifference to the means, and the probability of much
good arising from great evil.
- Jakke Carter pryes yowe alle that ye make a gode ende of that
ye hane begunnen, and doth wele and ay bettur and bettur: for at
the even men heryth the day. For if the ende be wele, than is alle
Awele. Lat Peres the Plowman my brother duelle at home and dygt
us corne, and I will go with yowe and helpe that y may to dygte
youre mete and youre drynke, that ye none fayle: lokke that Hobbe
robbyoure be wele chastysed for lesyng of youre grace: for ye have
gret nede to take God with yowe in alle youre dedes. For nowe is
tyme to be war. "
* See the wise remark on this subject in the Defence of Rights
of Man, circulated by the societies.
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 183
phant guilt have never been known to succor or even
to pity human weakness or offence, when they become
subject to human vicissitude, and meet with punishment instead of obtaining power. Abating for their
want of sensibility to the sufferings of their associates, they are not so much in the wrong; for madness and wickedness are things foul and deformed in themselves, and stand in need of all the coverings
and trappings of fortune to recommend them to the
multitude. Nothing can be more loathsome in their
naked nature.
Aberrations like these, whether ancient or modern,
unsuccessful or prosperous, are things of passage.
They furnish no argument for supposing a multitude
told by the head to be the people. Such a multitude
can have no sort of title to alter the seat of power in
the society, in which it ever ought to be the obedient,
and not the ruling or presiding part. What power
may belong to the whole mass, in which mass the
natural aristocracy, or what by convention is appointed to represent and strengthen it, acts in its proper
place, with its proper weight, and without being subjected to violence, is a deeper question. But in that
case, and with' that concurrence, I should have much
doubt whether any rash or de~perate changes in the
state, such as we have seen in France, could ever be
effected.
I have said that in all political questions the consequences of any assumed rights are of great, moment in deciding upon their validity. In this point
of view let us a little scrutinize the effects of a right
in the mere majority of the inhabitants of any country of superseding and altering their government at
pleasure.
? ? ? ? 184 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
The sum total of every people is composed of its
units. Every individual must have a right to originate what afterwards is to become the act of the ma.
jority. Whatever he may lawfully originate lie may
lawfully endeavor to accomplish. He has a right,
therefore, in his own particular, to break the ties and
engagements which bind him to the country in which
he lives; and he has a right to make as many converts to his opinions, and to obtain as many associates in his designs, as he can procure: for how can you know the dispositions of the majority to destroy
their government, but by tampering with some part
of the body? You must begin by a secret conspiracy, that you may end with a national confederation.
The mere pleasure of the beginner must be the sole
guide; since the mere pleasure of others must be the
sole ultimate sanction, as well as the sole actuating
principle in every part of the progress. Thus, arbitrary will (the last corruption of ruling power) step
by step poisons the heart of every citizen. If the
undertaker fails, he has the misfortune of a rebel,
but not the guilt. By such doctrines, all love to our
country, all pious veneration and attachment to its
laws and customs, are obliterated from our minds;
and nothing can result from this opinion, when
grown into a principle, and animated by discontent,
ambition, or enthusiasm, but a series of conspiracies
and seditions, sometimes ruinous to their authors,
always noxious to the state. No sense of duty can
prevent any man from being a leader or a follower
in such enterprises. Nothing restrains the tempter;
nothing guards the tempted. Nor is the new state,
fabricated by such arts, safer than the old. What
can prevent the mere will of any person, who hopes
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS.
-monarchy; but when we cast our eyes about a coun
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 161
try, and observe how every part understands its own
affairs, and when we look around the world, and see.
that, of all men in it, the race of kings are the most
insignificant in capacity, our reason cannot fail to ask
us, What are those men kept for? " *
These are the notions which, under the idea of
Whig principles, several persons, and among them
persons of no mean mark, have associated themselves
to propagate. I will not attempt in the smallest
degree to refute them. This will probably be done
(if such writings shall be thought to deserve any
other than the refutation of criminal justice) by others, who may think with Mr. Burke. He has performed his part. I do not wish to enter very much at large into
the discussions which diverge and ramify in all ways
from this productive subject. But there is one topic upon which I hope I shall be excused in going a
little beyond my design. The factions now so busy
amongst us, in order to djyov men of all love for
their country, and to remove from their minds all
duty with regard to the state, endeavor to propagate
an opinion, that the people, in forming their commonwealth, have by no means parted with their power
over it. This is an impregnable citadel, to which
these gentlemen retreat, whenever they are pushed by
the battery of laws and usages and positive conventions. Indeed, it is such, and of so great force, that
all they have done in defending their outworks is so
much time and labor thrown away. Discuss any of
their schemes, their answer is, It is the act of te'd
* Vindication of the Rights of Man, recommended by the sevcral
societies.
VOL. IV. 11
? ? ? ? 162 APPEAL FROMI THE NEW
people, and that is sufficient. Are we to deny to a
majority of the people the right of altering even the
whole frame of their society, if such should be their
pleasure? They may change it, say they, from a
monarchy to a republic to-day, and to-morrow back
again from a republic to a monarchy; and so backward and forward as often as they like. They are
masters of the commonwealth, because in substance
they are themselves the commonwealth. The French
Revolution, say they, was the act of the majority of
the people; and if the majority of any other people,
the people of England, for instance, wish to make the
same change, they have the same right.
Just the same, undoubtedly. That is, none at all.
Neither the few nor the many have a right to act
merely by their will, in any matter connected with
duty, trust, engagement, or obligation. The Constitution of a country being once settled upon some
compact, tacit or expressed, there is no power existing of force to alter it, without the breach of the covenant, or the consent of all the parties. Such is the nature of a contract. And the votes of a majority
of the people, whatever their infamous flatterers may
teach in order to corrupt their minds, cannot alter
the moral any more than they can alter the physical
essence of things. The people are not to be taught
to think lightly of their engagements to their governors; else they teach governors to think lightly
of their engagements' towards them. In that kind
of game, in the end, the people are sure to be losers.
To flatter them into a contempt of faith, truth, and
justice is to ruin them; for in these virtues consists
their whole safety. To flatter any man, or any part
of mankind, in any description, by asserting that in
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 163
engagements he or they are free, whilst any other human creature is bound, is ultimately to vest the rule
of morality in the pleasure of those who ought to be
rigidly submitted to it, -- to subject the sovereign
reason of the world to the caprices of weak and giddy
men.
But, as no one of us men can dispense with public
or private faith, or with any other tie of moral obligation, so neither can any number of us. The number
engaged in crimes, instead of turning them into laudable acts, only augments the quantity and intensity
of the guilt. I am well aware that men love to hear
of their power, but have an extreme disrelish to be
told of their duty. This is of course; because every
duty is a limitation of some power. Indeed, arbitrary power is so much to the depraved taste of the vulgar, of the vulgar of every description, that almost all the dissensions which lacerate the commonwealth are
not concerning the manner in which it is to be exercised, but concerning the hands in which it is to be
placed. Somewhere they are resolved to have it.
Whether they desire it to be vested in the many or
the few depends with most men upon the chance
which they imagine they themselves may have of partaking in the exercise of that arbitrary sway, in the
one mode or in the other.
It is not necessary to teach men to thirst after
power. But it is very expedient that by moral instruction they should be taught, and by their civil
constitutions they should be compelled, to put many
restrictions upon the immoderate exercise of it, and
the inordinate desire. The best method of obtaining
these two great points forms the important, but at
the same time the difficult problem to the true states
? ? ? ? 164 APPEAL FROM THE NEW.
man. He thinks of the place in which political power is to be lodged with no other attention than as it
may render the more or the less practicable its salutary restraint and its prudent direction. For this
reason, no legislator, at any period of the world, has
willingly placed the seat of active power in the hands
of the multitude; because there it admits of no control, no regulation, no steady direction whatsoever.
The people are the natural control on authority; but
to exercise and to control together is contradictory
and impossible.
As the exorbitant exercise of power cannot, under popular sway, be effectually restrained, the other
great object of political arrangement, the means of
abating an excessive desire of it, is in such a state
still worse provided for. The democratic commonwealth is the foodful nurse of ambition. Under the
other forms it meets with many restraints. Whenever, in states which have had a democratic basis, the
legislators have endeavored to put restraints upon
ambition, their methods were as violent as in the
end they were ineffectual, -- as violent, indeed, as any
the most jealous despotism could invent. The ostracism could not very long save itself, and much less
the state which it was meant to guard, from the attempts of ambition, - one of the natural, inbred, incurable distempers of a powerful democracy. But to return from this short digression, - which,
however, is not wholly foreign to the question of the
effect of the will of the majority upon the form or the
existence of their society. I cannot too often recommend ii to the serious consideration of all men who
think civil society to be within the province of moral
jurisdiction, that, if we owe to it any duty, it is not
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 165
subject to our will. Duties are not voluntary. Duty
and will are even contradictory terms. Now, though
civil society might be at first a voluntary act, (wrhich
in many cases it undoubtedly was,) its continuance
is under a permanent standing covenant, coexisting
with the society; and it attaches upon every individual of that society, without any formal act of his own.
This is warranted by the general practice, arising
out of the general sense of mankind. Men without
their choice derive benefits from that association;
without their choice they are subjected to duties
in consequence of these benefits; and without their
choice they enter into a virtual obligation as bindinlg
as any'that is actual. Look through the whole of life
and the whole system of duties. Much the strongest
moral obligations are such as were never the results
of our option. I allow, that, if no Supreme Ruler
exists, wise to form, and potent to enforce, the moral
law, there is no sanctionl to any contract, virtual or
even actual, against the will of prevalent power. On
that hypothesis, let any set of men be strong enough
to set their duties at defiance, and they cease to
be duties any longer. We have but this one appeal against irresistible power,Si genus humanum et mortalia temnitis arma, At sperate Deos memores fandi atque nefandi.
Taking it for granted that I do not write to the disciples of the Parisian philosophy, I may assume that
the awful Author of our being is the Author of our
place ill the order of existence, - and that, having
disposed and marshalled us by a divine tactic, not
according to our will, but according to His, He has
in and by that disposition virtually subjected us
to act the part which belongs to the place assigned
? ? ? ? 166 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
us. We have obligations to mankind at large, which
are not in consequence of any special voluntary pact.
They arise from the relation of man to man, and the
relation of man to God, which relations are not matters of choice. On the contrary, the force of all the
pacts which we enter into with any particular person or number of persons amongst mankind depends upon those prior obligations. In some cases the subordinate relations are voluntary, in others they are necessary, --but the duties are all compulsive. When
we marry, the choice is voluntary, but the duties are
not matter of choice: they are dictated by the nature of the situation. Dark and inscrutable are the
ways by which we come into the world. The instincts which give rise to this mysterious process of
Nature are not of our making. But out of physical
causes, unknown to us, perhaps unknowable, arise
moral duties, which, as we are able perfectly to comprehend, we are bound indispensably to perform. Parents may not be consenting to their moral relation; but, consenting or not, they are bound to a
long train of burdensome duties towards those with
whom they have never made a convention of any
sort. Children are not consenting to their relation;
but their relation, without their actual consent, binds
them to its duties, -or rather it implies their consent,
because the presumed consent of every rational creature is in unison with the predisposed order of things. Men come in that manner into a community with the
social state of their parents, endowed with all the
benefits, loaded with all the duties of their situation.
If the social ties and ligaments, spun out of those
physical relations which are the elements of the commonwealth, in most cases begin, and always continue,
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 167
Independently of our will, so, without any stipulation
on our own part, are we bound by that relation called
our country, which comprehends (as it has been well
said) " all the charities of all. " * Nor are we left
without powerful instincts to make this duty as dear
and grateful to us as it is awful and coercive. Our
country is not a thing of mere physical locality. It
consists, in a great measure, in the ancient order
into which we are born. We may have the same
geographical situation, but another country; as we
may have the same country in another soil. The
place that determines our duty to our country is a
social, civil relation.
These are the opinions of the author whose cause I
defend. I lay them down, not to enforce them upon
others by disputation, but as an account of his proceedings. On them he acts; and from them he is
convinced that neither he, nor any man, or number
of men, have a right (except what necessity, which
is out of and above all rule, rather imposes than bestows) to free themselves from that primary engagement into which every mall born into a community as much contracts by his being born into it as he
contracts an obligation to certain parents by his having been derived from their bodies. The place of
every man determines his duty. If you ask, Quem
te Deus esse jussit? you will be answered when
you resolve this other question, Humana qua parte
locatus es in re? *
I admit, indeed, that in morals, as in all things
else, difficulties will sometimes occur. Duties will
sometimes cross one another. Then questions will
* Omnes omnium charitates patria una complectitur. " - CIc.
t A few lines in Persius contain a good summary of all the objects
? ? ? ? 168 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
arise, which of them is to be placed in subordination?
which of them may be entirely superseded? These
doubts give rise to that part of moral science called
csastry, which though necessary to be well studied
by those who would become expert in that learning,
who aim at becoming what I think Cicero somewhere calls artifices officiorum, it requires a very
solid and discriminating judgment, great modesty
and caution, and much sobriety of mind in the
handling; else there is a danger that it may totally
subvert those offices which it is its object only to
methodize and reconcile. Duties, at their extreme
bounds, are drawn very fine, so as to become almost
evanescent. In that state some shade of doubt will
always rest on these questions, when they are pursued with great subtilty. But the very habit of stating these extreme cases is not very laudable or safe; because, in general, it is not right to turn our duties
into doubts. They are imposed to govern our conduct, not to exercise our ingenuity; and therefore
our opinions about them ought not to be in a state
of fluctuation, but steady, sure, and resolved.
Amongst these nice, and therefore dangerous points
of casuistry, may be reckoned the question so much
agitated in the present hour, --Whether, after the
people have discharged themselves of their original
power by an habitual delegation, no occasion call
of moral investigation, and hint the result of our inquiry: There human will has no place.
Quid sumus? et quidnam victuri gignimur? ordo
Quis datus? et metwe quis mollis flexus, et unde?
Quis modus argento? Quidfas optarte? Quid asper
Utile nummus habet? Patrice charisquepropinquis
Quantum elargiri debet? Quem te Deus esse
Jussit? et humana qua parte locatus es in re?
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 169
possibly occur which may justify the resumption of
it? This question, in this latitude, is very hard to
affirm or deny: but I am satisfied that no occasion
can justify such a resumption, which would not
equally authorize a dispensation with any other moral duty, perhaps with all of them together. However, if in general it be not easy to determine concerning the lawfulness of such devious proceedings, which must be ever on the edge of crimes, it is far
from difficult to foresee the perilous consequences of
the resuscitation of such a power in the people. The
practical consequences of any political tenet go a
great way in deciding upon its value. Political problems do not primarily concern truth or falsehood.
They relate to good or evil. What in the result is
likely to produce evil is politically false; that which
is productive of good, politically true.
Believing it, therefore, a question at least arduous
in the theory, and in the practice very critical, it
would become us to ascertain as well as we can
what form it is that our incantations are about to
call up from darkness and the sleep of ages. WhenI
the supreme authority of the people is in question,
before we attempt to extend or to confine it, we
ought to fix in our minds, with some degree of distinctness, an idea of what it is we mean, when we
say, the PEOPLE.
In a state of rude Nature there is no such thing as
a people. A number of men in themselves have no
collective capacity. The idea of a people is the idea
of a corporation. It is wholly artificial, and made,
like all other legal fictions, by common agreement.
What the particular nature of that agreement was
is collected from the form into which the particular
? ? ? ? 170 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
society has been cast. Any other is not their covenant. When men, therefore, break up the original compact or agreement which gives its corporate form
and capacity to a state, they are no longer a people, -
they have no longer a corporate existence - they have
no longer a legal coactive force to bind within, nor
a claim to be recognized abroad. They are a number of vague, loose individuals, and nothing more.
With them all is to begin again. Alas! they little
know how many a weary step is to be taken before
they can form themselves into a mass which has a
true politic personality.
We hear much, from men who have not acquired
their hardiness of assertion from the profundity of
their thinking, about the omnipotence of a majority,
in such a dissolution of an ancient society as hath taken place in France. But amongst men so disbanded there can be no such thing as majority or minority,
or power in any one person to bind another. The
power of acting by a majority, which the gentlemen
theorists seem to assume so readily, after they have
violated the contract out of which it has arisen, (if at
all it existed,) must be grounded on two assumptions: first, that of an incorporation produced by unanimity; and secondly, an unanimous agreement
that the act of a mere majority (say of one) shall pass
with them and with others as the act of the whole.
We are so little affected by things which are habitual, that we consider this idea of the decision of a majority as if it were a law of our original nature.
But such constructive whole, residing in a part only,
is one of the most violent fictions of positive law that
ever has been or can be made on the principles of
artificial incorporation. Out of civil society Nature
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 171
knows nothing of it; nor are. men, even when arranged according to civil order, otherwise than by
very long training, brought at all to submit to it.
The mind is brought far more easily to acquiesce in
the proceedings of one man, or a few, who act under
a general procuration for the state, than in the vote
of a victorious majority in councils in which every
man has his share in the deliberation. For there the
beaten party are exasperated and soured by the previous contention, and mortified by the conclusive defeat. This mode of decision, where wills may be so nearly equal, where, according to circumstances, the
smaller number may be the stronger force, and where
apparent reason may be all upon one side, and on the
other little else than impetuous appetite, - all this
must be the result of a very particular and special
convention, confirmed afterwards by long habits of
obedience, by a sort of discipline in society, and by a
strong hand, vested with stationary, permanent power to enforce this sort of constructive general will.
What organ it is that shall declare the corporate
mind is so much a matter of positive arrangement,
that several states, for the validity of several of their
acts, have required a proportion of voices much
greater than that of a mere majority. These proportions are so entirely governed by convention that
in some cases the minority decides. The laws in
many countries to condemn require more than a mere
majority; less than an equal number to acquit. In
our judicial trials we require unanimity either to condemn or to absolve. In some incorporations one man
speaks for the whole; in others, a few. Until the
other day, in the Constitution of Poland unanimity
was required to give validity to any act of their great
? ? ? ? 172 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
national council or diet. This approaches much more
nearly to rude Nature than the institutions of any
other country. Such, indeed, every commonwealth
must be, without a positive law to recognize in a certain number the will of the entire body.
If men dissolve their ancient incorporation in order to regenerate their community, in that state of things each man has a right, if he pleases, to remain
all individual.
Any number of individuals, who can
agree upon it, have an undoubted right to form themselves into a state apart and wholly independent. If any of these is forced into the fellowship of another,
this is conquest and not compact. On every principle which supposes society to be in virtue of a free covenant, this compulsive incorporation must be null
and void.
As a people can have no right to a corporate capacity without universal consent, so neither have they a right to hold' exclusively any lands in the name and
title of a corporation. On the scheme of the present
rulers in our neighboring country, regenerated as
they are, they have no more right to the territory
called France than I have. I have a right to pitch
my tent in any unoccupied place I can find for it;
and I may apply to my own maintenance any part
of their unoccupied soil. I may purchase the house
or vineyard of any individual proprietor who refuses
his consent (and most proprietors have, as far as they
dared, refused it) to the new incorporation. I stand
in his independent place. Who are these insolent
men, calling themselves the French nation, that would
monopolize this fair domain of Nature? Is it because
they speak a certain jargon? Is it Trei mode of chattelilg, to me unintelligible, that forms their title to
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 1]73
my land? Who are they who claim by prescription
and descent from certain gangs of banditti called
Franks, and Burgundians, and Visigoths, of whom I
may have never heard, and ninety-nine out of an hundred of themselves certainly never have heard, whilst
at the very time they tell me that prescription and
long possession form no title to property? Who are
they that presume to assert that the land which I
purchased of the individual, a natural person, and not
a fiction of state, belongs to them, who in the very
capacity in which they make their claim can exist
only as an imaginary being, and in virtue of the very
prescription which they reject and disown? This
mode of arguing might be pushed into all the detail,
so as to leave no sort of doubt, that, on their principles, and on the sort of footing on which they have
thought proper to place themselves, the crowd of
men, on the other side of the Channel, who have the
impudence to call themselves a people, can never be
the lawful, exclusive possessors of the soil. By what
they call reasoning without prejudice, they leave not
one stone upon another in the fabric of human society. They subvert all the authority which they hold,
as well as all that which they have destroyed.
As in the abstract it is perfectly clear, that, out
of a state of civil society, majority and minority are
relations which can have no existence, and that, in
civil society, its own specific conventions in each corporation determine what it is that constitutes the people, so as to make their act the signification of the general will, - to come to particulars, it is equally
clear that neither in France nor in England has the
original or any subsequent compact of the state, expressed or implied, constituted a majority of men, told
? ? ? ? 174 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
by the head, to be the acting people of their several
communities. And I see as little of policy or utility
as there is of right, in laying down a principle that
a majority of men told by the head are to be considered as the people, and that as such their will is
to be law. What policy can there be found in arrangements made in defiance of every political principle? To enable men to act with the weight and character of a people, and to answer the ends for
which they are incorporated into that capacity, we
must suppose them (by means immediate or consequential) to be in that state of habitual social discipline in which the wiser, the more expert, and the more opulent conduct, and by conducting enlighten
and protect, the weaker, the less knowing, and the
less provided with the goods of fortune. When the
multitude are not under this discipline, they can
scarcely be said to be in civil society. Give once
a certain constitution of things which produces a
variety of conditions and circumstances in a state,
and there is in Nature and reason a principle which,
for their own benefit, postpones, not the interest, but
the judgment, of those who are numero plures, to those
who are virtute et honore majores. Numbers in a state
(supposing, which is not the case in France, that a
state does exist) are always of consideration, - but
they are not the whole consideration. It is in things
more serious than a play, that it may be truly said,
Satis est equitem mihi plaudere.
A true natural aristocracy is not a separate interest in the state, or separable from it. It is an essential
integrant part of any large body rightly constituted.
It is forlmed out of a class of legitimate presumptions,
whicll, taken as generalities, must be admitted for
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 175
actual truths. To be bred in a place of estimation;
to see nothing low and sordid from one's infancy; to
be taught to respect one's self; to be habituated to
the censorial inspection of the public eye; to look
early to public opinion; to stand upon such elevated
ground as to be enabled to take a large view of the
wide-spread and infinitely diversified combinations of
men and affairs in a large society; to have leisure to
read, to reflect, to converse; to be enabled to draw
the court and attention of the wise and learned, wherever they are to be found; to be habituated in armies to command and to obey; to be taught to despise danger in the pursuit of honor and duty; to be formed to the greatest degree of vigilance, foresight,
and circumspection, in a state of things in which no
fault is committed with impunity and the slightest
mistakes draw on the most ruinous consequences;
to be led to a guarded and regulated conduct, from
a sense that you are considered as an instructor of
your fellow-citizens in their highest concerns, and
that you act as a reconciler between God and man;
to be employed as an administrator of law and justice, and to be thereby amongst the first benefactors
to mankind; to be a professor of high science, or
of liberal and ingenuous art; to be amongst rich
traders, who from their success are presumed to have
sharp and vigorous understandings, and to possess the
virtues of diligence, order, constancy, and regularity,
and to have cultivated an habitual regard to commutative justice: these are the circumstances of men
that form what I should call a natural aristocracy,
without which there is no nation.
The state of civil society which necessarily generates this aristocracy is a state of Nature, --and much
? ? ? ? 176 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
more truly so than a savage and incoherent mode of
life. For man is by nature reasonable; and he is
never perfectly in his natural state, but when he is
placed where reason may be best cultivated and most
predominates. Art is man's nature. We are as much,
at least, in a state of Nature in formed manhood as
in immature and helpless infancy. Men, qualified ill
the manner I have just described, form in Nature, as
she operates in the common modification of society,
the leading, guiding, and governing part. It is the
soul to the body, without which the man does not
exist. To give, therefore, no more importance, in
the social order, to such descriptions of men than
that of so many units is a horrible usurpation.
When great multitudes act together, under that
discipline of Nature, I recognize the PEOPLE. I
acknowledge something that perhaps equals, and
ought always to guide, the sovereignty of convention. In all things the voice of this grand chorus
of national harmony ought to have a mighty and
decisive influence. But when you disturb this harmony,-when you break up this beautiful order, this
array of truth and Nature, as well as of habit and prejudice, - when you separate the common sort of men from their proper chieftains, so as to form them into
an adverse army, -- I no longer know that venerable object called the people in such a disbanded race
of deserters and vagabonds. For a while they may
be terrible, indeed, -but in such a manner as wild
beasts are terrible. The mind owes to them no sort
of submission. They are, as they have always been
reputed, rebels. They may lawfully be fought with,
and brought under, whenever an advantage offers.
Those who attempt by outrage and violence to de
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 177
prive men of any advantage which they hold under
the laws, and to destroy the natural order of life, proclaim war against them.
We have read in history of that furious insurrection of the common people in France called the Jacquerie: for this is not the first time that the people
have been enlightened into treason, murder, and rapine. Its object was to extirpate the gentry. The
Captal de Buch, a famous soldier of those days, dis.
honored the name of a gentleman and of a man by
taking, for their cruelties, a cruel vengeance on these
deluded wretches: it was, however, his right and his
duty to make war upon them, and afterwards, in
moderation, to bring them to punishment for their
rebellion; though in the sense of the French Revolution, and of some of our clubs, they were the people, - and were truly so, if you will call by that appellation any majority of men told by the head. At a time not very remote from the same period
(for these humors never have'affected one of the
nations without some influence on the other) happened several risings of the lower commons in England. These insurgents were certainly the majority
of the inhabitants of the counties in which they resided; and Cade, Ket, and Straw, at the head of
their national guards, and fomented by certain traitors of high rank, did no more than exert, according
to the doctrines of ours and the Parisian societies,
the sovereign power inherent in the majority.
We call the time of those events a dark- age. Indeed, we are too indulgent to our own proficiency.
The Abb6 John Ball understood the rights of manl
as well as the Abbe Gr6goire. That reverend patriarch of sedition, and prototype of our modern preachVOL. IV. 12
? ? ? ? 178 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
ers, was of opinion, with the National Assembly, that
all the evils which have fallen upon men had been
caused by an ignorance of their " having been born
and continued equal as to their rights. " Had the
populace been able to repeat that profound maxim,
all would have gone perfectly well with them. No
tyranny, no vexation, no oppression, no care, no sorrow, could have existed in the world. This would
hlave cured them like a charm for the tooth-ache.
But the lowest wretches, in their most ignorant state,
were able at all times to talk such stuff; and yet at
all timnes have they suffered many evils and many
oppressions, both before and since the republication
by the National Assembly of this spell of healing potency and virtue. The enlightened Dr. Ball, when
he wished to rekindle the lights and fires of his audience on this point, chose for the text the following
couplet: -
When Adam delved and Eve span,
Who was then the gentleman?
Of this sapien. t maxim, however, I do not give him
for the inventor. It seems to have been handed
down by tradition, and had certainly become proverbial; but whether then composed or only applied,
thus much must be admitted, that in learning, sense,
energy, and comprehensiveness, it is fully equal to
all the modern dissertations oil the equality of mankind: and it has one advantage over them, -that it
is in rhyme. *
* It is no small loss to the world, that the whole of this enlightened and philosophic sermon, preached to two hundred thousand national guards assembled at Blackheath (a number probably equal to the sublime and majestic Federation of the 14th of July, 1790, in the
Champ de Mars) is n-t preserved. A short abstract is, however, to
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 179
There is no doubt but that this great teacher of the
rights of man decorated his discourse on this valuable
text with lemmas, theorems, scholia, corollaries, and
all the apparatus of science, which was furnished in
be found in Walsingham. I have added it here for the edification of
the modern Whigs, who may possibly except this precious little fragment from their general contempt of ancient learning.
"Ut sua doctrin' plures inficeret, ad le Blackheth (ubi ducenta millia hominum communium fuere simul congregata) hujuscemodi sermonem est exorsus.
"Whan Adam dalfe and Eve span,
Who was than a gentleman?
Continuansque sermonem inceptum, nitebatur per verba proverbii,
quod pro themate sumpserat, introducere et probare, ab initio omnes
pares creatos a naturd, servitutem per injustam oppressionern nequam
hominum introductam contra Dei voluntatem, quia si Deo placuisset
servos cre'asse, utique in principio mundi constituisset, quis servus,
quisve dominus futurus fuisset. Considerarent igitur jam tempus a
Deo datum eis, in quo (deposito servitutis jugo diutius) possent, si
vellent, libertate diu concupitf gaudere. Quapropter monuit ut essent viri cordati, et amore boni patrisfamilias excolentis agrum suum,
et extirpantis ac resecantis noxia gramina quae fruges solent opprimere, et ipsi in prsesenti facere festinarent. Primb majores regni dolinos occidendo. Deinde juridicos, justiciarios, et juratores patrice perilendo.
Postremb quoscunque scirent in posterurn commnunitati nocivos tollerent
de terra sua, sic demum et pacem sibimet parerent et securitatent in futurum. Si sublatis majoribus esset inter eos oequa libertas, eadem nobilitas,
par dignitas, similisque potestas. "
Here is displayed at once the whole of the grand arcanuma pretended to be found out by the National Assembly, for securing future happiness, peace, and tranquillity. There seems, however, to be some
doubt whether this venerable protomartyr of philosophy was inclined
to carry his own declaration of the rights of men more rigidly into
practice than the National Assembly themselves. He was, like them,
only preaching licentiousness to the populace to obtain power for himself, if we may believe what is subjoined by the historian. ,' Cumque hwec et plura alia deliramenta " (think of this old fool's calling all the wise maxims of the French Academy deliramenta! ) "prredicasset, commune vulgus eum tant
? ? ? ? 180 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
as great plenty and perfection out of the dogmatic
and polemic magazines, the old horse-armory of the
Schoolmen, among whom the Rev. Dr. Ball was bred,
as they can be supplied from the new arsenal at Hack(,rent ern archiepiscopum futurum, et regni cancellarium. " Whether
ho would have taken these situations under these names, or would
have chanled the whole nomenclature of the State and Church, to
be understood in the sense of the Revolution, is not so certain. It is
)robable that he would have changed the names and kept the substance of power.
We find, too, that they had in those days their society for constitutional inlformation, of which the Reverend John Ball was a conspicuous
member, sometimes under his own name, sometimes under the feigned
name of John Schep. Besides him it consisted (as Knyghton tells
us) of persons who went by the real or fictitious names of Jack Mylner, Tom Baker, Jack Straw, Jack Trewman, Jack Carter, and probably of many more. Some of the choicest flowers of the publications charitably written and circulated by them gratis are upon record in
Walsingham and Knyghton: and I am inclined to prefer the pithy
and sententious brevity of these bulletins of ancient rebellion before
the loose and confused prolixity of the modern advertisements of constitutional information. They contain more good morality and less
bad politics, they had much more foundation in real oppression, and
they have the recommendation of being much better adapted to the
capacities of those for whose instruction they were intended. Whatever laudable pains the teachers of the present day appear to take, I
cannot compliment them so far as to allow that they have succeeded
in writing down to the level of their pupils, the members of the sovereign,
with half the ability of Jack Carter and the Reverend John Ball.
That my readers may judge for themselves, I shall give them one or
two specimens.
The first is an address from the Reverend John Ball, under his
aonm de guerre of John Schep. I know not against what particular
", guyle in borough" the writer means to caution the people; it may
have been only a general cry against, rotten boroughs," which it was
thought convenient, then as now, to make the first pretext, and place
at the head of the list of grievances.
JOHN SCHEP.
" Iohn Schep sometime seint Mary priest of Yorke, and now of Col
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 181
ney. It was, no doubt, disposed with all the adjutancy of definition and division, in which (I speak it
with submission) the old marshals were as able as the
modern martinets. Neither can we deny that the
chester, greeteth well Iohn Namelesse, and Iohn the Miller, and Iohn
Carter, and biddeth then that they beware of guyle in borough, and stand
together in Gods name, and biddeth Piers Ploweman goe to his
werke, and chastise well Hob the robber, [probably the king,] and take
with you Iohn Trewman, and all his fellows, and no moe.
" Iohn the Miller hath yground smal, small, small:
The kings sonne of heauen shal pay for all.
Beware or ye be woe,
Know your frende fro your foe,
IHaue ynough, and say hoe:
And do wel and better, & flee sinne,
And seeke peace and holde you therin,
& so biddeth Iohn Trewman & all his fellowes. "
The reader has perceived, from the last lines of this curious statepaper, how well the National Assembly has copied its union of the
profession of universal peace with the practice of murder and confusion, and the blast of the trumpet of sedition in all nations. He will
in the following constitutional paper observe how well, in their enigmatical style, like the Assembly and their abettors, the old philosopliers proscribe all hereditary distinction, and bestow it only on virtue and wisdom, according to their estimation of both. Yet these people are supposed never to have heard of "the rights of man" I
JACK MYLNER.
"' Jakke Mylner asket help to turne his mylne aright.
"'He hath grounden smal smal,
The Kings sone of heven he schal pay for alle.
Loke thy mylne go a rygt, with the foure sayles, and the post stande
in steadfastnesse.
" With rygt and with mygt,
With skyl and with wylle,
Lat mygt helpe rygt,
And skyl go before wille,
And rygt before mygt:
Than goth oure mvlne aryght.
And if mygt go before ryght,
? ? ? ? 182 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
philosophic auditory, when they had once obtained
this knowledge, could never return to their former
ignorance, or after so instructive a lecture be in the
same state of mind as if they had never heard it. *
But these poor people, who were not to be envied for
their knowledge, but pitied for their delusion, were
not reasoned, (that was impossible,) but beaten, out of
their lights. With their teacher they were delivered
over to the lawyers, who wrote in their blood the
statutes of the land, as harshly, and in the same sort
of ink, as they and their teachers had written the
rights of man.
Our doctors of the day are not so fond of quoting
the opinions of this ancient sage as they are of imitating his conduct: first, because it might appear that they are not as great inventors as they would
be thought; and next, because, unfortunately for his
fame, he was not successful. It is a remark liable
to as few exceptions as any generality can be, that
they who applaud prosperous folly and adore triumAnd. wylle before skylle;
Than is oure mylne mys a dygt. "
JACK CARTER understood perfectly the doctrine of looking to the
end, with an indifference to the means, and the probability of much
good arising from great evil.
- Jakke Carter pryes yowe alle that ye make a gode ende of that
ye hane begunnen, and doth wele and ay bettur and bettur: for at
the even men heryth the day. For if the ende be wele, than is alle
Awele. Lat Peres the Plowman my brother duelle at home and dygt
us corne, and I will go with yowe and helpe that y may to dygte
youre mete and youre drynke, that ye none fayle: lokke that Hobbe
robbyoure be wele chastysed for lesyng of youre grace: for ye have
gret nede to take God with yowe in alle youre dedes. For nowe is
tyme to be war. "
* See the wise remark on this subject in the Defence of Rights
of Man, circulated by the societies.
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS. 183
phant guilt have never been known to succor or even
to pity human weakness or offence, when they become
subject to human vicissitude, and meet with punishment instead of obtaining power. Abating for their
want of sensibility to the sufferings of their associates, they are not so much in the wrong; for madness and wickedness are things foul and deformed in themselves, and stand in need of all the coverings
and trappings of fortune to recommend them to the
multitude. Nothing can be more loathsome in their
naked nature.
Aberrations like these, whether ancient or modern,
unsuccessful or prosperous, are things of passage.
They furnish no argument for supposing a multitude
told by the head to be the people. Such a multitude
can have no sort of title to alter the seat of power in
the society, in which it ever ought to be the obedient,
and not the ruling or presiding part. What power
may belong to the whole mass, in which mass the
natural aristocracy, or what by convention is appointed to represent and strengthen it, acts in its proper
place, with its proper weight, and without being subjected to violence, is a deeper question. But in that
case, and with' that concurrence, I should have much
doubt whether any rash or de~perate changes in the
state, such as we have seen in France, could ever be
effected.
I have said that in all political questions the consequences of any assumed rights are of great, moment in deciding upon their validity. In this point
of view let us a little scrutinize the effects of a right
in the mere majority of the inhabitants of any country of superseding and altering their government at
pleasure.
? ? ? ? 184 APPEAL FROM THE NEW
The sum total of every people is composed of its
units. Every individual must have a right to originate what afterwards is to become the act of the ma.
jority. Whatever he may lawfully originate lie may
lawfully endeavor to accomplish. He has a right,
therefore, in his own particular, to break the ties and
engagements which bind him to the country in which
he lives; and he has a right to make as many converts to his opinions, and to obtain as many associates in his designs, as he can procure: for how can you know the dispositions of the majority to destroy
their government, but by tampering with some part
of the body? You must begin by a secret conspiracy, that you may end with a national confederation.
The mere pleasure of the beginner must be the sole
guide; since the mere pleasure of others must be the
sole ultimate sanction, as well as the sole actuating
principle in every part of the progress. Thus, arbitrary will (the last corruption of ruling power) step
by step poisons the heart of every citizen. If the
undertaker fails, he has the misfortune of a rebel,
but not the guilt. By such doctrines, all love to our
country, all pious veneration and attachment to its
laws and customs, are obliterated from our minds;
and nothing can result from this opinion, when
grown into a principle, and animated by discontent,
ambition, or enthusiasm, but a series of conspiracies
and seditions, sometimes ruinous to their authors,
always noxious to the state. No sense of duty can
prevent any man from being a leader or a follower
in such enterprises. Nothing restrains the tempter;
nothing guards the tempted. Nor is the new state,
fabricated by such arts, safer than the old. What
can prevent the mere will of any person, who hopes
? ? ? ? TO THE OLD WHIGS.